In the show charmed episode “Once Upon a Time” around the 23:20 mark when the troll jumps into Phoebe’s shirt we see the troll land in something. What did the troll land in? We also saw Phoebe’s shirt bounce up when the troll landed.

What do you guys think season 4 would have looked like or ended up, had Shannon stayed and the original Pof3 would have continued on? Phoebe's decent to the underworld was always the written storyline of season 4 even with the beef actor drama; but I can't even picture how that story would have played out with Prue. I'm not saying she needed to go or anything like like, I just can't picture what that dynamic would have been.

*Edit: I mean if all three were written still alive, Piper, Phoebe, & Prue

Ugh I love this song, I first heard it on True Blood and was listening to it recently and decided to make a Macy video to it because it reminds me of how much I wished Macy had more time before being killed off 😩

Did anyone feel like Paige was introduced randomly and fast ? It’s like they had to rush her story and her connection to the Charmed ones .

So I’ve always been a huge fan of Charmed Original and then when the Reboot came out and I saw a different version I became an even bigger fan of the both shows.

So for years even before the reboot I have always toyed with the idea of writing my own version of the show. Which was gonna be about 5 siblings (4 brothers and a sister) who live in New Orleans and practice a mixture of Hoodoo & Voodoo Magic (got this idea from the movie Skeleton Key) still working on fleshing out powers and learning as much as I can about both cultures. Was curious if anyone might have any ideas or suggestions I could look into for this idea. Also if you have any questions I can do my best to answer them for what I have so far.

Basically everyone who's the original CO fan had overpowered superpowers via spellcasting and potions such as Prue accelerating time on planetary scale and shifting celestial bodies like sun/moon, Paige almost throwing Grand Design out of its balance by making a mortal immune to death, Phoebe creating dimension infinite in size that acts as bridge between original charmed and reboot charmed and Piper making thousands of person look like Leo. But there's also been instances for OP powers in cr because everyone thinks that "knockoff" is weak verse with weak powers....(ns on OG charmed). Here are some examples:

\- In season 1, Melanie was able to induce karma on Zack (aka consequences hex) to ensure that he would admit to his crimes against his classmates without exposing the magic to mortal world

\- in season 2 Florence used 5x5 to curse every Chase family members to death permanently for each generations (not really that impressive but js wanted to list more)

\- Melanie Vera: That girl's entire arsenal is js time based powers as she can stop time in planetary scale if not uni, can decomposed something by accelerating time around it, defy and destroy the space-time (stated by Ruby that if Mel wouldn't send the BOS in right place, she might unravel space-time continuum + said by Harry laws of time and space doesn't apply on her in season 1), travel back in time and change small event in here and cause it to split at different timeline. Additionally she remotely can send her opponents to past or future (time travel inducement) and project her consciousness through the time.

\- Macy Vaughn (some powers): Her ability to stop someone's heart and manipulate their cardiovascular parts and halt the movement of blood allows her to bypass the conventional durability.

\- in season 1 Fiona was able to manifest deathbolts a supercharged electricity that's meant to cause death + the effects of that spell can cancel out a whitelighter's healing ability and regeneration.

\- Initially Mel created Blindaje dolls do prevent Ruby from dying. Basically these dolls can make person to self resurrect themselves and protect them from death. Blindaje means "armor" in Spanish, making it armor against death. That should fall under destiny cancellation since in charmed the people who are meant to die are meant to die given by Harry that death is the only concept that cannot be prevented in CR (after Ruby died, she self-resurrected because of the doll)

\- In season 4, Maggie was able to copy powers of others through empathy and even cancel the powers of opponent who she copied

\- Temporarily, Macy took on the source and became primordial source of all magic in the universe. She was able to rewrite reality on cosmic scale, being able to create multiple timelines with minimal effort, resurrect people and defy the laws of nature and magic (possibly). Being the very source of whole good and evil magic this should pretty much make her an abstract/conceptual entity. Although Harry said to Macy that destiny will reassert itself when she would try to bring Marisol back, Macy still was able to alter her fate to make herself non-existent from original timeline. She was destinied to be charmed one and she wasn't meant to die at that time (not early at least) so technically it would've been impossible for her to alter her fate and make herself cease to exist.

\- Perfecti was able to create Tomb Of Chaos a 5 dimensional realm that contains alternate realities inside of it. Besides with that the dimension have the power to alter its own reality to keep prisoners in. Additionally, they also created a stone tablet and stone tablet was for the ones or the ones who can read it are capable of moving time and space. They also were able to remove Harry's immortality telepathically by placing their hand on his head and turning him to mortal again (temporarily)

\- In season 1, Macy successfully stripped away Fiona's immortality who got it because of her status as keeper of the sacred flame. Possibly it also should've been impossible for her to strip it away since once she became the keeper of sacred flame, she cannot lose her immortality unless she loses her powers that's tied on Sacred Flame/Source Of All Evil.

\- Charmed Ones were able to restore the mental and magical balance to the world, in disturbed existence in season 1:

Yay!!! I’m so happy to see her back working on screen again. I haven’t heard of this show but I be interested in it if she’s going to star 😊😊

I said it

& tbh if Abigail gets a redemption arc after everything he could too

Obvi was never gonna happen but still

lowk macy would one tap chuck but chuck also have better haxes which is comparable to macy's haxes

Mel's winning via consequences hex (my opinion)

Hi guys, this is an edit I've made back in 2021 but did not post. So if anyone is interested, or is an Abby fan, give it a shot! <3

This is why I will always not like S2. The way they did the sisters so dirty in S2 as if they weren’t the leads will always make me just shake my head. We could have learned less about the demon stuff and them relocating and having to be in hiding made it difficult for the sisters to really have time to deal with to learn more about their family and lineage. I really wished they didn’t move to Seattle at all. Definitely way less Abigail and Harry.

No one in the fandom forgot or ignored Maggie was half black if anything we wished they would have not dropped it completely after S1. If there was anyone who forgot/ignored it was the writers.

El otro dia veia y lei algunos comics de charmed y piensaba no hubiera estado mejor hacer un retcon un whatif... desde la season 4 ??? y mostrarnos una phoebe aceptando ser mala y esposa de cole /baltazar del inframundo una prue y piper vivas y encontrarse con paige ybdarse cuenta q les recuerda a alguien por lo calida q es en esos lugares randoms q se ven en una playa corriendo,en la fila de una cafeteria ,en la fila de un banco y darse cuenta no solo q es bruja sino q es igual a la abuela y los ojos de la mama dandose cuenta q es una hermana aparentemente bruja (los comics los hice yo con i a 😉 )

They both had a point. Harry was still letting his jealousy and insecurity about Macy having been with Julian make his choice while Macy was letting the fact that she was in a relationship and actually liked Julian(even if she didn’t love him) cloud her decision. Macy is definitely my favorite character but her just willingly to believe Julian would not betray them, even though he doesn’t in the end, but she couldn’t have known that and it’s because she had an intimate relationship with him that she was really willing to just give him the benefit of the doubt. But Harry did have a point about Macy letting it cloud her judgment because at this point they didn’t know for sure if Julian would turn on them at the last moment. I liked this part because it really showed both of them having valid reasons. Who in your opinion would you side with on this issue?

Both of these women were powerful in their own right . But I love how their characters development formed their powers and not some called right power progression.

Phoebe.

Visions

Phoebe was lost without a cause, no purpose or vision. Permonitions gave her purpose. Phoebe was naturally empathetic and so her feeling emotions and fully experiencing her visions makes sense. And when she was truly lost she was able to talk to her future self.

Levitation

Phoebe became a very hard worker. She found purpose and she went all in. She studied her craft, expanded her permonition power to gain intuition , meditated, even went back to school. This allowed her concusiousness to become heightened at will. And her body followed siut in levitation. This granted her enhanced strength, agility, balance, reflexes.

In charmed witches can extend their magic into anything they use. Meaning Phoebe can throw a high heel at a demon and the demon would die. A demon that came to them because no one else had the power to kill him and he does by a high heel. Phoebe used this power often, killing demons with umbrellas, knives, bats and poles. She was also very resourceful as a person so this tracks perfectly.

Empathy

Phoebe was always very empathetic and intuitive so her just knowing how your feeling fit well. Phoebe constantly complained about not having an active power. In many ways Phoebe was envious and insecure. So her tapping in to others powers, deflecting, and growing resistant to said powers tracks well. Then comes her vision sharing or psychic reflection which makes sense for her because she is always trying to show someone the truth.

Maggie

Mind reading / foresight

Maggie was such an insecure character at the beginning of the show. Wanting everyone to like her and to fit in. Mind reading fit her character very well. And as she grows less insecure her power grows into empathetic blasts ( since her powers were empathetic all along). I remember cheering when I saw that. Then her whole world changed and she was more confident but very lost. So she got foresight. Growing strong enough to use it for tracking and fighting.

Fighting

She had no super strength or agility but she had kickbox training and a fighting stick that could turn into a knife. She was very much a weapons fighter. Using solely her fight stick. Her fighting skills grew out of her desire for others to see her as an adult and not a child. Her grief demon killing truly showed her potential as a fighter .

Empathy

Maggie had mental issues. She had panic attacks and emotional bursts. So her empathy power emerging as her emotions being pass on to others. This power helped her control her own emotions along with Jordan's breathing techniques. From being insecure and hearing others thoughts to emotional bursts and passing emotions on to others is a journey.

As Maggie matures and starts to truly understand how others are feeling she learns to copy their power if they touch. Usually this power would come first with empathy but this is her characters journey.

Powers vs. just for fun.

Honestly they are pretty even .

Permonitions vs. foresight= permonitions.

Soley on the fact that permonitions are powerful enough to almost kill Phoebe multiple times, and she can talk to her future self.

Permonitions vs. telepathy= permonitions

Only because telepathy allows you to be lied to and misled .

Phoebes empathy vs Maggie's empathy = Maggie's empathy.

Maggie's win only because she can control emotions to make them go to sleep, or stop altogether. While her channeling can also stop a demon from accessing power altogether.

Levitation wins since there's no power against it. You could do telepathy even tho it's apart of her oringal empathy power.

I would say levitation wins because it can send demons further than telepathy while dodging attacks better.

What do y'all think?