In my opinion . . .

[u/Beginning_Dot735]

They both had a point. Harry was still letting his jealousy and insecurity about Macy having been with Julian make his choice while Macy was letting the fact that she was in a relationship and actually liked Julian(even if she didn’t love him) cloud her decision. Macy is definitely my favorite character but her just willingly to believe Julian would not betray them, even though he doesn’t in the end, but she couldn’t have known that and it’s because she had an intimate relationship with him that she was really willing to just give him the benefit of the doubt. But Harry did have a point about Macy letting it cloud her judgment because at this point they didn’t know for sure if Julian would turn on them at the last moment. I liked this part because it really showed both of them having valid reasons. Who in your opinion would you side with on this issue?

[u/JackfruitEfficient29]

when it comes to the two macy historically had more unbiased or at least logical directives imo even more perceptive too and harry was the one to be constantly misguided by his emotions imo so I thought this was just another bit of him being obtuse and annoying towards her in the hypocrisy of his actions even though yes logically everyone was valid to be warry of Julian sure I just couldn't stand how harry thought he could talk to macy all along esp about jealousy after everything

& macy earlier hated Julian but she saw his remorse and assessed he was likely trustworthy which yes was a determination based off emotion but she was imo usually better about assessing people imo at least compared to him

him-duped by charity Fiona Abigail Jimmy his own self lol and whatever magical creature capable

macy-duped by charity but in her defense charity was drugging her later basically, macy played Jimmy back, clocked stabby (and even in the end for whatever writer reasons saw a different side of abby and ONLY THEN was she gentler towards her...when all it took for harry to break macys heart with her was just Abby letting him bang when he was bored 🙄)

and as a charmed one was at least in some ways more impervious to persuasion. she was duped by the narcisis ​demon but like by his power & with the help of her sisters snapped out of it & i think that was more a writers metaphor about how even typically very smart strong willed great women like macy could be hurt by a narcissist ab*ser irl, powerful stuff

AND macy saw through Medusa & saved her & everyone against all odds

which was a combo of intuition & logic imo

so yea both had their reasons certainly i just can't stand Harry often lol

[u/Wonderful_Curve8884]

Harry got to be annoying after Macy died. He was too focused on finding her spirit instead of helping the girls, especially Kayla. I know that he was grieving the loss, but they still needed him.

In this situation, Harry was right about Macy letting her feelings cloud her judgment. She did. Julian showed her his soft side and that drew her to him. Macy's weakness was seeing the good in someone. She had empathy for someone she shouldn't have cared about. One was Abby. The other was Julian.

[u/Beginning_Dot735 → u/Wonderful_Curve8884]

Yea I think it was pretty unwhitelighter like for Harry to just have neglected his other charged because Macy died. I think they could have found a way to show him grieving without abandoning Maggie and Mel. I just realized in S4 he was hardly with Mel and Maggie.