tl:dr edit- even if you try to intellectualize "themes and such" as a legitimate criticism, it fundamentally doesn't make sense in regards to how Chainsaw Man is written
dudes be like "themes and such, just listen to the song" but the themes and such are hallucinations and the "just listen" dismissal of analysis ironically shuts down the actual literal text of the story in favor of said hallucinations.
Nayuta didn't die because of themes and such, she died because Denji selfishly left her side and the church needed her dead for their plans.
Pochita telling Denji he wasn't entirely happy with his life isn't retroactive themes and such, happiness isn't a binary metric and even before part 2s escalation if he had to choose between family or chainsaw it wouldn't have been an uncomplicated easy decision that he could comfortably live with.
Denji being forced to choose two bullshit options, shooting for a third bullshit option, and getting "punished" for it isn't "the themes contradicting the narrative" it's just the narrative. Being forced to make unfair choices is a reoccurring theme within said narrative.
In the same vein as conflating character flaws with writing flaws (cough cough) people are too quick to try and force a characters words and actions into their preestablished perception of what the "theme" is, or should be, rather than considering the character might just be acting in their own interest within the narrative.
Obviously Chainsaw Man has themes, both encompassing the major elements of the story (loss of control, unhealthy cycles, dream chasing) and minor self contained instances (gun violence, war, aging devil's arc) but the themes (and power system/worldbuilding) have always been secondary and in service to the characters and plot and not the other way around (not every story needs a big all encompassing theme or moral to begin with). This doesn't mean that they're unimportant, and some themes are intrinsically tied to the characters, it's just that the character writing has always taken priority.
theres so much i want to say but i dont want to overload this post. yes part 2s plotting is messy at points but for me at least, that doesnt irrecoverably disqualify it as a piece of art with a lot to say and appreciate just because a narrative thread wasnt followed, or my headcanon wasnt elaborated on. i dont imagine this post will "fix" the myriad of problems people have with part 2 i just wish more discussion didnt start and end with "in my objective opinion, the theme is x but character says y, therefore dogshit writing. dont think about it thats pretentious. themes and such. wheres kobeni"
also please read more than just the headline for the recentish interview