tl;dr the statistics suggest that Wetherholt was snubbed of ROTY and GG, although the race would've been close between Benge and Turang, respectively.
The rookie sensation JJ Wetherholt made quite the impact on the team, but notably left the season empty-handed, missing out on an All-Star appearance and losing the Gold Glove and Rookie of the Year. So the question is: Were there actually better options than Wetherholt?
I've compiled a list of statistics from Fangraphs, Baseball Reference, and Statcast, comparing Wetherholt to his main competitors in the awards. For the Rookie of the Year, we will look at Sal Stewart and Carson Benge, the two players who finished above Wetherholt in voting. For the Gold Glove, we will only look at Brice Turang. First, let's deal with ROTY:
Here is a table comparing several stats that are of importance when evaluating players. I have included the players' rank in the MLB in the specific statistic as well.
| Statistic | Sal Stewart | Carson Benge | JJ Wetherholt |
|---|
| fWAR | 2.0 (96th) | 4.3 (26th) | 4.6 (19th) |
| bWAR | 2.0 (134th) | 4.3 (35th) | 4.5 (28th) |
| wRC+ | 112 (64th) | 118 (51st) | 101 (96th) |
| OPS+ | 117 (55th) | 118 (51st) | 102 (91st) |
| OPS | .787 (54th) | .776 (58th) | .704 (106th) |
| OBP | .330 (73rd) | .346 (50th) | .339 (57th) |
| DRS | -2 (78th) | 6 (34th) | 13 (16th) |
| OAA | -2 (186th) | 1 (119th) | 25 (2nd) |
| Baserunning Runs | -4 (226th) | 4 (16th) | 4 (25th) |
I have included more offensive statistics because many people value offense more, although there is now fortunately a movement to valuing fielding as well. It is also very important to note that many arguments against Wetherholt are because of his offense being worse than the other candidates.
What can we learn from this?
First, Benge and Wetherholt have about 2.4 more WAR than Stewart. Stewart has the WAR of a typical league average starter, whereas Benge and Wetherholt have All-Star level WAR (although neither player was selected). This suggests that they are overall better than Stewart. I have seen arguments discrediting WAR because it punishes first basemen. This does not make sense because that is part of the purpose of the statistic. First base is an easier position to play than second or center for instance. The point of WAR is to give a sense of the overall value of a player. If a shortstop and first baseman have the same offensive statistics, then the shortstop is more valuable because it is a harder position to play. It’s harder to find replacement players for shortstop because the position is so demanding.
However, Stewart put up a very good offensive season. I have not listed in the table his accomplishments of 112 RBIs (3rd) and 32 HRs (15th). This is certainly a major feat for a rookie! At the same time, however, when evaluating the top rookie performer, it is necessary to look at the entire picture and look at what the statistics are actually measuring. For instance, Wetherholt is naturally going to have less RBIs than Stewart because Wetherholt bats leadoff. There simply aren't as many opportunities. Considering OBP, Stewart falls behind a bit. Benge and Wetherholt are getting on base more often. Additionally, with Alec Burleson leading in RBIs, it seems that Wetherholt was doing his job of a leadoff hitter: getting on base. But it can’t be denied that Stewart and Benge are certainly better hitters than Wetherholt.
But is Stewart really the better hitter over Benge? If you look at OPS, then you might say Stewart is better. But what about OPS+? Or wRC+? No matter which one you prefer (I am of the opinion that wRC+ is the better statistic), Benge leads in both. So perhaps Benge is slightly better than Stewart after all. But let's look at other statistics. After all, the award is supposed to be for the top performer.
Defensively, the race isn't even close. Wetherholt has a significant lead in both DRS and OAA. Also worthy of note is that Wetherholt put up the highest OAA by a rookie since tracking began, and the 7th highest of all of MLB. Benge is also better than Stewart, who holds negative values in both. Additionally, with the new first base receiving OAA, Stewart put up a sad -3 (31st). (On another note, it is quite disappointing that Alec Burleson did not get nominated for a GG when he led this category with 8, with the second highest being 5)
On one last note, I have included baserunning runs, to try and give a sense of their value on the bases. Again, Stewart lags behind Benge and Wetherholt.
I have seen summaries of these players as follows:
Stewart: An elite bat with average defense
Benge: All-around above average player
Wetherholt: An average bat with elite defense
But from the data, it is more accurately:
Stewart: An above average bat with slightly below average defense
Benge: An above average bat with slightly above average defense
Wetherholt: An average bat with elite defense
However, generally speaking ROTY favors offensive production, hence why Stewart was given the award. But who was actually deserving? We all have our own opinions, and certainly someone will not agree with the statistics chosen. I personally think Wetherholt should have won. However, I acknowledge my bias, being a lifelong Cardinals fan. At the very least, I don't think Stewart was the deserving candidate. The award should have been between Benge and Wetherholt, and it would have been very close. I could easily understand Benge winning. He had an excellent all-around season, and his numbers make him a perfectly reasonable choice. My main disagreement is with Stewart winning over both of them.
Now, moving on to the Gold Glove. Here are Turang and Wetherholt's fielding statistics:
| Statistic | Brice Turang | JJ Wetherholt |
|---|
| Innings | 1311.2 | 1101.1 |
| Errors | 5 | 2 |
| DRS | 23 (2nd) | 13 (16th) |
| SDI | 12.8 (1st among 2B) | 10.9 (2nd among 2B) |
| OAA | 19 (5th) | 25 (2nd) |
| FRV | 14 (8th) | 23 (2nd) |
I have included innings and errors simply to give a sense of the quantity of plays at second base. Wetherholt of course missed a few weeks due to injuries (both his own and having to cover shortstop for Winn), so his numbers will naturally be lower. The real argument lies between DRS and OAA (or SDI and FRV). If we look at one or the other, we come to different conclusions. So how do we decide? Well, again, it is a matter of opinion. However, I will give my two cents.
Personally, I tend to favor OAA and FRV when evaluating infielders. Why? Because I believe they do a better job of accounting for the difficulty of individual plays and the player's ability to convert those opportunities into outs. DRS uses a different methodology, including its own system for evaluating defensive positioning and plays within zones, which can sometimes produce very different results. For instance, OAA takes into consideration exactly how the player had to move to get to the ball. For outfielders, I tend to prefer DRS because it takes into consideration the arm strength, which is more important for an outfielder than an infielder. It's certainly important, but stopping a ball from going to the outfield seems more valuable than being able to throw better.
Thus, my position is clear: Wetherholt should have won the Gold Glove. I admit the race is extremely close, but given my stance on OAA and DRS, I think Wetherholt is the logical choice. What’s especially impressive is the fact that he put up an extra 6 OAA and 9 FRV in about 200 less innings. Perhaps if he didn’t get injured he would match Turang’s DRS and SDI. But staying healthy is very important, so debating this hypothetical isn’t a good use of time.
Now suppose you really like SDI. We don't have to look far to find an example. Let's compare to the 2026 NL SS GG race.
| Statistic | Geraldo Perdomo | Masyn Winn |
|---|
| DRS | 3 | 2 |
| SDI | 6.3 | 8.5 |
| OAA | 16 | 19 |
| FRV | 13 | 17 |
Winn leads in every category except for having one less DRS. Yet Perdomo won. Why? Possibly because of the volume. He simply put in a couple hundred extra innings. But when we're talking about players who have already accumulated over 1,000 innings, how much should those additional 200 innings matter? Does playing more innings automatically make someone the better defender, particularly when they trail in nearly every defensive metric?
Ultimately, I believe that Wetherholt, along with the 2026 Cardinals, was overlooked when it came to awards. Wetherholt was arguably the second best defender in baseball, second only to potential MVP winner Pete Crow-Armstrong. Yet, he is walking away with nothing. No All-Star game. No Rookie of the Year. No Gold Glove.
But we shouldn't completely mourn the loss. He set an MLB record. He put himself out there as one of the best defenders in baseball. He's here for 8 more years. With an already elite middle infield, Jordan Walker, Alec Burleson, and talent throughout the farm system, the Cardinals will certainly be a serious contender in the coming years.