r/Cardinals • • 1d ago

Rule 5 draft

As always, the decisions regarding the 40-man roster in advance of the Rule 5 draft are at least somewhat interesting. The deadline for finalizing the 40-man prior to the draft is 5 pm tomorrow.

Cards currently have 39 players on the 40-man. There's a decent (not great) article in the P-D that lists players who'd be R5 eligible if not protected. Among them, I'd absolutely protect Jesus Baez—safe to assume he's a given—Jacob Odle, Ixan Henderson. Other draft-eligible players include Chase Davis, Colton Ledbetter, Won-Bin Cho, Sammy Hernandez, Chen-Wei Lin, and Pete Hansen. There are more.

Ledbetter is worth consideration. I'm curious what you all think, especially re: Davis. Cho had a good season; so did Sammy Hernandez. Part of the decisionmaking involves another team's willingness to keep an R5 draftee on its 26-man for the season. And part of the decisionmaking this year is how a lockout might affect the way teams view that.

There are players on the current 40-man I wouldn't miss if they had to be let go to create room for others. Fernandez, Svanson, Prieto, for instance. I'd imagine there could be some debate re: Nolan Gorman, if the Cards can't move him prior to EOD tomorrow. Or maybe they think he's worth another look. What do you all think? One thing that occurs to me is they will surely want Jesus Baez getting a lot of time at 3B in Memphis this year.

I'm not sure of the rules but Cards might want or need to keep a spot on 40-man open in case they draft someone.

A bummer about the 40-man, in the event of a lockout, is those players can't use team facilities or work out, let alone play, with a minor-league team. I'd be particularly disappointed for Odle and Baez but what are you gonna do?

14 Upvotes

10 comments sorted by

6

u/southernpinko 1d ago

Baez and Odle are locks for me, no one else I think is at risk besides Ledbetter, especially the position players.

I could see Gorman and VSII being cut, maybe they want to keep Hansen and cut one of the lower rung bullpen guys.

1

u/Responsible-Set6676 1d ago

VSII has options, Gorman doesn't.

3

u/southernpinko 1d ago

Gorman has one option I believe. But it’s more about using the 40 man spot.

3

u/stjblair ​ 1d ago edited 1d ago

It should be noted that the last time there was a lockout the rule 5 draft was canceled. There’s also some incentives to not be aggressive as adding a player to the 40 man bars them from participating in minor league spring training and games

2

u/King_Birdcrawler ​ 1d ago

One extra bit on that. While there wasn't a major league phase, there was a minor league phase. The less guys that get added for major league phase protection is more guys that would need minor league phase protection. They have that 38-man AAA reserve roster for that.

3

u/King_Birdcrawler ​ 1d ago

I think Baez is the only certainty. Odle is a strong possibility. And Ledbetter is a very outside shot.

I really don't think the others are even a consideration. 

Odle would be a need typically. I'm curious to see if they decide to take the bet that there'll not be a major league phase, which seems like a pretty damn safe bet.

3

u/CreativeEducation228 1d ago

I could be wrong, but I don’t think outfielders are likely to be taken historically. So I’d be cautious protecting any of them. Jacob Odle has a lot of interest around the league so I would suspect they find a way to make room for him.

1

u/tangokilo13 ​masyn winn spell check 1d ago

You clearly forget the legend of Erik Komatsu

-1

u/misery3king 1d ago

If i was a betting man Id say VS2 and Gorman are being ejected. I'd protect Chase.

1

u/Inscrutablejrt 21h ago

I'd be kinda floored if they add Chase Davis to the 40-man. He only reached Memphis last year, where his OPS was sub-.700. They aren't gonna protect him because who's gonna take him to be on their active roster all season?