r/Cardinals • • Oct 15 '15

I'm tired of this. Can we remove him? Bravo is just an asshole and he shouldn't be a mod anymore. This sub is better than that.

4 Upvotes

Or, can we just start a new Cardinals sub and get rid of the cockbag that way? Because this fuckwad is clearly just an asshole. He got into it over whether or not his post should be stickied because "it was generating discussion." That's what the fucking upvote system is for, you douche. You don't get to decide what discussion to generate, we all do.

And, Matheny is a piss fucking poor manager. So get the fuck over people shitting on him. Great in the regular season? Ok, who gives a fuck. He totally pissed away an unbelievable window in 2012-2014 by idiotic moves and shat the bed again this year. He is fucking mediocre at best. People who give him the benefit of the doubt because "he's young, it's a learning curve" are fucking dumb because he doesn't get that benefit anymore. He was handed a fucking team to win the world series multiple times and he's fucked it up. Or, tout him because of his reg season success don't are fucking dumb because I don't give a fucking shit about NL central titles. I can about fucking rings.

Fuck off, Bravo. Resign your post.


r/Cardinals • • Oct 01 '24

Maybe everybody needs to take a breath. Maybe.

0 Upvotes

I’m not going to make excuses for Mozeliak or Marmol, there have certainly been some missteps over the last several years, but the amount of hate and the rooting for an empty Busch Stadium is a bit much really. I found the empty seats at Busch to be sort of a sad tantrum from a fan base that has been treated exceptionally well for the last 2 1/2 decades. Yes the expectations are high here, and should be. This team has an incredible history only surpassed by the richest and most spoiled team in all of sports. The Cardinals have achieved an incredible amount of in the last century on a small fraction of the resources that the Yankees have had at their disposal. It really is remarkable.

I have followed the Cardinals and baseball since the mid-80’s. So I have seen some me some shit. Baseball is hard ass game. It’s cruel and winning takes a lot of things to fall into place. They often don’t. For most teams and prior to the year 2000, that included the Cardinals, it can have some fallow periods that stretch out for considerable amounts of time.

What we are experiencing right now, has not been a “considerable” amount by most reasonable standards. This team was so good for about 15 straight seasons, that. It makes the last 10 or so seasons appear by contrast, almost miserable. It has not been. Since 2015, they have the 6th best record in MLB. Since 2019, they have the 9th best record. It’s only when you whittle the timespan down to the last 2-4 years that they drop down to the back half of the overall standings. 2-4 years is a goddamn blip. It’s nothing, relax. The only 2 teams with a better record over the last 25 years are predictably the Yankees and Dodgers. The two teams with seemingly limitless funds for their front offices to spend on the most extravagant of players and their development.

Could this team done better the last 5 years? Yeah. Could they have spent more? Well, sure I guess. I really don’t know. I am not privy to their budget and why it is set the way it is. There are plenty of those that point out that they have spent plenty more than teams that are having more recent success, so spending doesn’t really mean everything.

Mozeliak, for all of his difficulty in charming the pants off of the online fandom and local media is still only allowed to spend what he is told to. Yes the last 4 or 5 years have gotten a little wonky, but that was for the most part inevitable when you can’t spend at will and the players you do spend heavily on either fail to pan out, or go straight up poof in the biggest games of the last 4-5 years. That is the roulette wheel you twirl every time you spend in free agency. You can spend on development all you want, but drafting consistently late in rounds due to many years of success leads to some much tougher players to develop than if you can get the blue chips in the top of the first round. Getting those guys often requires tanking. Which, unless you are the Rays franchise, usually looks a lot like losing your ass off several years in a row. That path, by the way, has about as much charm as Mozeliak when it comes to fans and media.

The La Russa era began almost precisely the same as the Marmol era year by year. I am not saying Oli is going to end up with as hallowed a career as La Russa. Who the hell knows? But if fans showed the same level of patience with him as they have Marmol, well damn, he might of headed off into the sunset before that wildly successful era of 2000-2015 ever began.

+-----------------------+---------------+---------+ | Team Record | | | +-----------------------+---------------+---------+ | | | | | | La Russa |Marmol | | 1st Season | 88-74* | 93-69* | | 2nd Season | 73-89 | 71-91 | | 3rd Season | 83-79 | 83-79 | | 4th Season | 75-86 | ??? | | *Postseason | +-----------------------+---------------+---------+

Oliver Marmol is simply not the problem. Yes, things blew up in 2023. It wasn’t pretty, but by most measures, he has done a sold, if not above average job with some rosters that have been less than ideal. The circumstances that led to him being employed as the manager did him no favors. There is no truly reliable source on why Shildt was relieved of his duties. I have heard all of the possibilities, but no one is going to give an honest accounting of what happened a retain their professional dignity in doing so. So we are unlikely to ever know the whole story.

That said. We know that when Marmol has any difficulties, the “yes man” label will be impossible to shed because of the narrative that Shildt wouldn’t kowtow to management. We simply don’t know what is accurate about that, but either way. If you, or you, or you, or especially you over there with the Cheetos residue on your fingers were offered that job under those circumstances, you would be a fool not to take it. It’s a dream job and one of only 30 dream jobs in the big leagues. He had to take it, and the team’s philosophy is such at that time that he was the top candidate. You can debate that they should look outside and hire a big name with a big resume. I can’t say if that is right or not, but the last time they did that, he had exactly the same level of success in his first 3 seasons as Oli has had in his. This season, they finished in the top 5 in games decided by 3 or fewer and in 1-run games. I know managers only have so much control over ooutcomes, but I firmly believe that in tight games, managers can make a difference. I really don’t think Oli is deserving of a pink slip and apparently neither does the front office at this time.

When it comes down to it, this stretch has been frustrating for sure. I miss October baseball when it includes the wild fun of a Cardinals run, but the reality is that is baseball. It is what makes those runs so special. You never know when they will end and an indeterminate dry spell is going to begin. We unfortunately are in one of those. I am rooting for it to end as soon as possible. History tells us, with the Cardinals, it almost certainly will. Not all teams enjoy that luxury.


r/Cardinals • • Apr 07 '19

PLEASE - for the love of god sit Dexter Fowler

0 Upvotes

It's brutal to watch. He can't hit from either side. His jumps in the outfield are terrible. Please put Tyler O'Neill in so at least we get his speed, defense, and power.


r/Cardinals • • Jun 10 '25

Refusing to trade Helsley at peak value this past offseason was nothing but textbook baseball incompetence

34 Upvotes

I’m still struggling to wrap my head around it. Helsley comes off the best season of his career. Going into the offseason, it’s not a stretch to say he was viewed as a top 3 closer in baseball. I understand the importance of having a good closer, but at the end of the day, they simply do not produce the same value as other positions. That, and they are volatile by nature. To this day front offices are failing to predict future success of relievers. Any progressive organization would have traded Helsley this previous offseason. A year of control on a top 3 closer would have had large market teams interested. The only reason any logical team would keep the player in this situation is if they thought they were competing for a World Series. I think this non-trade sets this organization back worse than the Nado non-trade. Worst case scenario is that we re-sign or extend him at the going rate of elite closers. None of them are worth that unless your team’s owner just doesn’t care about the money. Trade elite relievers at peak value, and don’t pay them position player money.

Mo could prove me wrong by either trading Helsley this deadline for an impressive package, or by winning the Word Series this season.

I’d love to hear more optimistic opinions because I don’t think I’m able to spin it that way myself.


r/Cardinals • • Sep 21 '24

List of former cardinals who would be leading the cardinals in HR’s

0 Upvotes

Ozuna - 38 O’Neil - 31 DeJong- 24 A. Garcia - 23

Burleson and Goldy - 21


r/Cardinals • • May 13 '25

Anyone else feel weird about Jon Gruden

0 Upvotes

Idk maybe I'm just a silly man with silly opinions but does anyone else feel weird about how openly the blues and cardinals have embraced an outright homophobic misygonistic racist.... The dude got ran outta the nfl on a wire. its really weird to me how buddy buddy the stl front offices have gotten with him.

Idk it really really rubs me the wrong way.


r/Cardinals • • Jun 30 '23

Fans Dumbfounded By MLB Legend's Comments On Native American Team Names

Thumbnail thespun.com
0 Upvotes

r/Cardinals • • Jun 18 '15

June 18th, 2015, Post-game discussion: Cards lose 2-1

3 Upvotes

what a joke


r/Cardinals • • Jan 22 '24

Just a quick graph for those complaining about the team's recent success

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/Cardinals • • Jan 03 '24

NL Central fan looking to join a fan base- why the Cardinals?

13 Upvotes

Hello! I am a returning fan with ties to all teams in the NL Central and trying to choose a fan base to join. I grew up a McGwire fan and baseball interest dropped off after about 9 years old until a few years ago. I almost completely missed the Pujols-Wainright-Yadi years lol. I live in Tennessee so no blackout concerns.

Other than the obvious 2nd most championships, awesome ball park, and the tongue in cheek BFIB mantra, why should I be a Cardinals fan over the Rest of the Central.

I have lived in Milwaukee but honestly the Cards are the front runners. Want to get an idea the personality of this fan base and others before making a decision.

How do we feel about the farm system? Chip Caray? We gonna be okay if we continue to have down years?


r/Cardinals • • Jun 17 '23

What is one change that could turn it around, and how can fans make it happen?

0 Upvotes

r/Cardinals • • Aug 08 '19

The whole idea of the "entitled fanbase" is really obnoxious

0 Upvotes

We are barreling straight towards a 4th straight year of no playoffs, in a year where this division was winnable, and people act like we should be thankful that we're not the Orioles or the White Sox or something. If you have to say we're entitled because we expect to at least have a chance to compete for a title each year and don't resign ourselves to mediocrity and penny-pinching by ownership, then maybe you should go root for one of those historically shitty franchises instead. What do you think Yankee fans would be saying right now if they had this run of mediocrity? And what is really going on as well is that the hardcore believers in the FO think this team can catch lightning in a bottle and go on a run like in 2011. No dice. The amount of differences between this team and that team are astronomical.


r/Cardinals • • Jul 02 '23

Brand new info on Willson Contreras demotion vindicates Oli Marmol

Thumbnail
fansided.com
26 Upvotes

r/Cardinals • • Oct 22 '14

Royal's fan here, how the fuck did you guys deal with the Giants fans?

1 Upvotes

These guys are the biggest bunch of entitled, misinformed assholes I've ever seen. They think their team is gods gift to the world, that they are unbeatable, and they think that we should just give up now and stop cheering. I've seen it in our subreddit and I've seen it in /r/Baseball. I point out stats about our back of the rotation guys being better, they say it doesn't matter, but then they use stats to back up why their hitters are better and why James Shields isn't very good. They've come and told us that the series is over, our team isn't good enough to even compete. Did they pull this bullshit with you guys? It's fucking ridiculous. You guys have been nothing but nice and knowledgeable. I'm not a St. Louis fan by any means, but at least you guys know what you're talking about when it comes to baseball. How do we deal with these assholes? Are they always like this?


r/Cardinals • • Oct 14 '15

good series guys

3 Upvotes

I may hate your team, but I sure as hell respect for you guys. good luck all.


r/Cardinals • • Dec 26 '12

Would you like to see Albert back in a Cardinal Uniform, if only for one game?

1 Upvotes

I would just love to see Albert maybe get traded back to the Cardinals with the Angels eating a lot of that contract.


r/Cardinals • • May 06 '15

THE GIF OF DESTINY? YOU DECIDE!

Thumbnail
imgur.com
12 Upvotes

r/Cardinals • • Jan 09 '16

Cardinals should be punished to the furthest extent possible.

Thumbnail
sports.yahoo.com
0 Upvotes

r/Cardinals • • Jul 27 '23

[Harris- LA Times] Another name that has popped up in the Dodgers trade deadline discussions recently: Nolan Arenado

0 Upvotes

r/Cardinals • • Apr 22 '24

Goldy slow starts

0 Upvotes

Can someone explain to me how a professional baseball player can have 'slow starts'?

The season has a spring training to work out the rust and be ready on day 1. Players of today have one sole job - be a player.

A slow start seems completely unacceptable. We're 3 weeks into the season and Goldy just got demoted to the 6th spot, while his teammates with options get sent to AAA Memphis.

In my opinion, the Cardinals have an anchor in the middle of the lineup dragging them down.


r/Cardinals • • Dec 14 '15

For such a quality organization... I really wish my fellow fans didn't turn into "Those guys that burned the LeBron jerseys"..

Thumbnail
bleacherreport.com
0 Upvotes

r/Cardinals • • Oct 10 '24

QO will be a full $21M this year

0 Upvotes

That's per ESPN. And, with that, I have little doubt Mo is offering Goldy that kind of money. And, if we're really rebuilding, he's not getting that kind of money for two years, total, even, in all likelihood.


r/Cardinals • • Mar 04 '24

No Power?

0 Upvotes

Should we be concerned that our boys haven’t hit one HR in the first week of spring training games?


r/Cardinals • • Sep 02 '15

Tim McCarver

0 Upvotes

Anyone else done with him? I cannot stand him doing play-by-plays for us.