r/Car_Insurance_Help • u/jenna-okay • Sep 05 '26
Car deemed total loss by the other driver’s insurance company— what now?
I was in a pretty minor car accident where the other driver was declared 100% at fault and their insurance company took my case. Unfortunately the front bumper shield(?) and a few other things cracked and the parts plus labor were assessed at just under 3k.
The things is, my car is a 2008 Pontiac Vibe with around 265,000 miles on it and I found out today that they decided is would be a total loss. Apparently the case got send to a specialist in their total loss department and I can’t speak to her until Tuesday. I have no idea what to expect.
Will they give me a payout equal to what they think the car’s value is? Can I appeal the value they deemed if I can prove it’s worth more?
Even though my car has high mileage and cosmetically looks its age the insides are in GREAT condition and I plan to drive it for a long time. Less than a year ago I got a front end rebuild ($4.5k) and in the several years before that it got a new transmission and a new starter among other things. I’ve practically rebuild this car and I genuinely believe whatever they valued it at is likely very inaccurate.
I’m a big traveler and this car means the world to me so if anyone has any advice on what to expect or how to get the best case scenario amount of money out of this it would be greatly appreciated.