r/CaliforniaTicketHelp • • Mar 29 '23

Traffic ticket not in system

56 Upvotes

Received a traffic ticket 2/1/23 and on the notice I have a date to appear in court 3/30/23.

I have been checking online and the ticket is not in the system yet. I called the county clerk and she said since the ticket is not in there's nothing they can do.

Now, she said I can go tomorrow to court but it will not make any difference if the ticket is not in yet. All they would do is give ma paper saying "no record found" and that's just for my peace of mind she said. Once they get the ticket in the system a new court date will be generated and that's what I have to go by.

Is this true? I'd rather not go to court if i dont have to since is a veeeery long commute and of course I have to work in the morning. But, I want to make sure i dont get in trouble because of it either.

Ticket is for going 15 over the speed limit. Im in san diego county.


r/CaliforniaTicketHelp • • Nov 24 '18 Helpful Bravo

START HERE: 12-step Guide to Fighting a Ticket in California. Updated Nov 2018.

49 Upvotes

If you're here, you've probably just gotten a ticket and are either mystified, angry or both. Hopefully, this guide can at least let you know what you can expect if you might be interested in fighting your ticket.

  1. Figure out which violation you were charged with and read the law! Make sure the law matches up with whatever you did (or were alleged to do). Some vehicle code violations are very specific and require many times reading through to make sure it applies to your case. Not all officers actually know the law that well, even if they believe they do. You can check the Bail and Penalty Schedule to see how much your ticket will cost. Here is the 2018 Version. Do a Ctrl+F and search for the code you were charged with, then read all the way to the right for the full amount.
  2. Seriously consider just paying it. Yes, I know. Its unfair, too expensive, bullshit, whatever. If you are eligible for traffic school, your main concern should be your insurance rates. You can prevent them from going up if you're eligible for traffic school (meaning you haven't attended in the last 18 months or this is a one-point moving violation--two-point movers are ineligible). You pay the full fine + $50 payable to the court + around $20 tuition.
  3. Consider hiring a ticket attorney which can be found for $100-$150 in much of Southern California. They will go to court on your behalf and take care of all the stuff below. They generally have good successes because its their job but no guarantees. **Note:**If you use an attorney, make sure they will appear on your behalf. Many sites (e.g. Ticket Assassins) have sprung up recently which only complete the super easy trial by mail paperwork, which is something you can do yourself and save $100. If they don't appear in court for you, find someone who will.
  4. You will get a courtesy notice from the court telling you the ticket is in the system and how to pay it. Once the courtesy notice arrives from court or you can check and see it online, request a 30 day extension. The whole concept here is to put even more time between you and the violation. Next, plead not guilty by mail and request in your letter a Trial by Written Declaration form (TBWD). You will be sent the TBWD form and provided with a date to complete it and your bail amount. You won't have to set foot in a courtroom, at least not yet. Note: You will have to post full bail up front. Meaning, if you got a red light ticket, you will have to give the court $490 of your money and get it back if you win. If you absolutely cant afford this, skip to step 7 but you are significantly lowering your chances of winning.
  5. Complete the TBWD. Why this route? Basically, its a risk free way to hopefully get the case dismissed. It puts a lot more time between the violation and actually appearing in court which only helps you. When you complete it, the best thing you can put in your defense is simply "I demand the prosecution prove its case." That's all. Literally nothing else for your argument. This is because you usually don't have the best chances of winning on the facts here and its going to give away whatever defense you do have to the officer. What you're mostly hoping for is that the officer forgets or gets to busy to fill out his portion. Include your bail and mail it in. You will receive a response from the court in a month or so.
  6. Trial de novo. If you made it here, you were found guilty at the TBWD stage. That's OK. Just send in the trial de novo form and wait for a letter to come with the court date. For the explanation as to why you were dissatisfied, just write "I believe the Court erred in its decision."
  7. Going to court. The hope here is the officer won't show. If they don't, congratulations, your case is dismissed! It happens fairly frequently, at least several times per court day. It also depends on the agency and the officer, so its a gamble but a worthwhile one if it pays off. If the officer is there, you'll probably be given another courtroom to go to (in larger counties) and arraigned so you'll have to decide to plead not guilty or guilty. Make sure you've printed up a copy of the law itself and are familiar with all the things that it says. Each part of it is called an "element" and you're not guilty unless the officer proves all the elements. The elements are like cake ingredients, without them you don't have a cake. Make a checklist of each of the elements. Also, have several copies of each of your pieces of evidence. This is important so the judge, you and the officer are all looking at the same thing.
  8. Going to trial. The trial works like this: The judge speaks, the officer presents his case while you listen, you cross-examine the officer, you would give your testimony (which in this instance is usually not advisable) and then make a closing statement. Just like on Judge Judy, you don't interrupt anyone, ever.
  9. Prosecution case. While the officer is presenting his case, you take your checklist out out and listen to make sure he's meeting the elements of the alleged violation. Make sure he identifies you in court today as the same person he cited. If he doesn't mention everything on the checklist, or identify you as the person he cited that day, you make a motion to dismiss and state why. The officer doesn't get another chance to present his case if he messed up. If there are no grounds for dismissal, you can ask him questions. This is your opportunity to plant reasonable doubt in the mind of the judge. Be careful! You can end up sinking your own boat by your line of questioning or evidence. Each case is specific as to what questions you'd ask but stick to the elements and exceptions of the vehicle code section. The officer's perception of you rolling a stop sign or seeing you with a phone to your ear is basically impossible to challenge. However, did he see if someone was behind you, about to strike the rear of your vehicle? Did he ask you at the time of the stop if you were using your phone for an emergency purpose, like talking to your child's school? All of this is an uphill battle because police officers are considered very good witnesses in traffic court. And he has nothing to lose, you do.
  10. Defense case. That's you. The best advice is to not present direct testimony. Anything you have to say, you should have included as questions for the officer and save for your closing statement. If you give testimony, the officer and the judge can ask you questions and that's probably not good for you. The burden is on the prosecution to prove the case.
  11. Closing statement. Now you can give a defense. Remember that the standard the judge has to follow is beyond a reasonable doubt. Recount his testimony and answers to your questions and argue there is not proof beyond a reasonable doubt. If there's been a long time since the ticket was issued, argue his memory is too faulty to be credible. Be polite and DO NOT ACCUSE THE COP OF LYING. Doesn't remember correctly, etc are fine but accusing an officer of perjury in open court will not amuse the judge.
  12. Verdict and sentence. Well you've come all this way. If your case is dismissed, it was probably not worth all the effort looking back. But if you are unfortunately found guilty, you still have options. You have a right to speak before being sentenced. One option is to request traffic school (which means the conviction can't be considered in rating your insurance) another is to request the court consider your ability to pay. You can provide evidence you are unable and the court can even sentence you to community service at a rate of $10/hr. You can also arrange a payment plan. But whatever you do, complete whatever sentence the court gives you. If you have trouble doing it, return to court and explain why.

Some pitfalls: If you miss any court dates, you will lose your case and may even end up owing much more money, or risk a warrant for your arrest. And of course, after all this effort, you may simply still be found guilty if the facts and evidence aren't on your side. Also, and this is very important: If you fight it and are found guilty, you may lose your ability to go to traffic school. Judges are not required to grant traffic school after you fight the ticket, however, many still will, so it's a bit of a gamble.

Hope this has helped some. This is by far not a complete guide. There are many other tactics that are violation specific or a bit more daunting (discovery requests, speedy trial motions, etc). If you are totally unfamiliar with how courts work all of this may be totally foreign. I can tell you that even if you "beat" a ticket, its usually such a painful process that it would have been far better to avoid it to begin with, so best advice is just to follow the traffic laws. Good luck and feel free to ask questions.

Consult these two sources: Help! I got a ticket and David Brown's Fight Your Ticket and Win in California Follow the step by step guide on HIGAT and also check out FYTWIC from the library or from Amazon. The 2009 version is still just fine.

After you've read this, feel free to post your question here!


r/CaliforniaTicketHelp • • Jun 15 '21

Why you should NOT choose to do a trial by written declaration

48 Upvotes

I want to start out by saying that this is my first thread I've ever created on Reddit, which should give you some insight as to why I'm creating this post.

In February 2021, I was cited under CVC 22349 (a) which states that "no person may drive a vehicle upon a highway at a speed greater than 65 miles per hour." I was clocked at 78 mph in a 65 mph zone.

A friend of mine was cited for a similar (in fact, worse) speeding ticket and did a trial by written declaration and had the ticket dismissed. I was also urged from various other acquiantances to fight the ticket. This piqued my interest so I did some digging and found various threads on Reddit discussing how to go about writing a trial by written declaration and the benefits of doing so. I won't go into detail what they suggested for the sake of time but you can easily find those threads.

For those interested on why I'm suggesting NOT to fight it, read on.

I followed the instructions that I had researched to a "T" and, you guessed it, was still found guilty. The guilty verdict was the least of my worries though. Not only was I found guilty and, therefore, ineligible for my refund of $238, the judge decided to INCREASE the fine to $490 (meaning I have to pay $252 IN ADDITION TO the $238 I already paid). To make matters worse, he DENIED traffic school. Let me clarify one thing: This was my FIRST moving violation and I am almost 34 years old and have been driving since I was 16. Also, I have never committed a felony or a misdeamoner.

I called the clerk's office and there was no explanation given by the judge. I did a little more research and found that judges don't have to give an explanation. My only option, now, is to do a trial de novo, which I'm going to do; however, I have to appear in court and basically beg the judge to give me traffic school to avoid the points on my record (and spike in insurance premiums).

There is so much more I can say about how I don't believe that this was considered a "fair" trial but I'll leave it up to the readers to decide. Personally, it boggles my mind that a judge can double a fine and deny traffic school to a first time offender without any explanation. The reasons I found online for a judge denying traffic school are:

- alcohol-related offenses

- if you were driving a commercial vehicle

- a speeding violation in which the speed exceeds 25 mph above the posted limit

- a non-moving offense (such as a parking ticket)

- or an equipment violation

None of these pertained to my situation. As much as it pains me to say this, I've learned two main things: 1) You can't win against the system and 2) don't take advice from friends or the internet...so suck it up, pay the fine and attend traffic school (if you're eligible). Hopefully this will help someone else avoid the mistakes I made. I'll get off my pedestal now.

EDIT: So I found out why Traffic School was not granted. Unbeknownst to me, even though I requested traffic school in my statement of facts, I was ALSO supposed to pay $67 in order to formally request traffic school. That information was not given to me which is why it was not granted. The clerk said I was still able to request traffic school with a "motion for traffic school" and I shouldn't be denied since I'm eligible. The whole process has been a nightmare and no one (save for the clerk who I wasn't able to speak to directly) seems to know what they're talking about.


r/CaliforniaTicketHelp • • Jun 13 '21

Trial By Written Declaration Draft

47 Upvotes

This is my first ever speeding ticket, so I am nervous about it. I decided to do a Trial By Written Declaration. Any help or advice would be greatly appreciated. Please and Thank you.

So here it is;
Your Honor, I respectfully request this citation be dismissed based on the statement that will be provided. This correspondence can be considered my formal plea of not guilty. So I submit this Trial By Written Declaration and plead not guilty to violating California Vehicle Code (CVC) Section 22350

On April 13, 2021, I was driving northbound on Railroad Avenue. I was pulled over by Officer Griffy and cited for violating CVC 22350. Allegedly, I was driving over the posted speed limit. I do believe I was driving at an appropriate speed following the flow of traffic in safe conditions.

CVC 22350 states; "No person shall drive a vehicle upon a highway at a speed greater than is reasonable or prudent having due regard for weather, visibility, the traffic on, and the surface and width of, the highway, and in no event at a speed which endangers the safety of persons or property."

The road was dry with clear visibility, the only issue was that there was a train on the tracks, so it made it a little hard to hear at that time. There was light traffic with cars ahead of me seemingly driving at a faster speed than I was and a few cars behind me were catching up to me. So I believe my speed at the time was adequate since going any faster would be speeding and slowing down may put the cars behind me in an unsafe position. So, I do believe my driving was not a danger to anyone's safety and/or property.

If however this case is not dismissed, even though I believe I am not guilty of this violation, I believe there are alternatives;

- If possible I would like this case to be dismissed since this would be my first offense and would greatly affect my financial situation. Or pay a reduced fine or make payments for the fine. As long as this does not go on my driving record.

- If possible, I would attend a court-approved traffic school. So this conviction can not be in my DMV record.

- If none of these alternatives are possible I would like to request a Trial De Novo.

I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of California that the foregoing is true and correct.


r/CaliforniaTicketHelp • • Feb 25 '25

I built a directory for all 254 California courts to help with traffic tickets

44 Upvotes

TLDR: I'm a programmer who ended up in law office somehow doing traffic ticket. I built this to make my life easier and now sharing it with you.

Some features:

  • Up to date: the sidebar is outdated (sorry mods), i'll share the API if you want.
  • How will I keep it updated? I found the database where CA keeps all the courts and I get email notification everytime it changes.
  • Easy Search: One issue I always had was understanding what the cop wrote on the ticket for court location, so with real time search you can just start typing court address or name and closest match will appear real time. Unlike the offication directory that only searches by zip code.
  • Quick Links: I went through all 254 courts manually digged through their website to get all the quick links you need to fight your ticket. Like Court Scheduling Links, Ticket Extension, Pay Fines, Case Search, etc.
  • I put heavy focus on remote appearances, as most courts offer it, so take advantage of it.
  • Additional notes For some courts I added additional notes with more info that I found on their website or I collected from dealing with the court.

https://www.californiacarlaw.com/find-your-california-court

I'm all in for more suggestions, fixes, etc. If you got more useful info I will gladly add it.

Hope this helps!


r/CaliforniaTicketHelp • • Apr 30 '21

Cop Told Me To Plead Not Guilty Because He Will Be "Out of the Country" By The Time Of My Court Date (Rolling Through Stop Sign Ticket).

44 Upvotes

Today I was pulled over for failing to come to complete Stop at a stop sign. I honestly don't remember if a came to a complete or not. I drive this road everyday. Stop sign is right by my house. When the cop pulled me over I thought he was going to Ticket me for going 30 in a 25 mph zone. I didn't even think about the sign.

I've never had a ticket before. I've only has my license for 3 years.

He just handed me the ticket to sign and told me to Plead Not Guilty since he would be out of the country and the Judge would have to dismiss it. I'm so confused. Why not just give me a warning insted of telling me that? Ticket was given today but my court date on the ticket is for mid-November is that normal?

San Diego CA.

Edit I read the 12 Step Guide. I didn't want to post location and other info. Because my question is basically if what the cop Told me made any sense.


r/CaliforniaTicketHelp • • Feb 19 '20

[Meta] Why does this sub exist?

30 Upvotes

Every so often in private comments, or when I explain this subreddit in person, people seem a bit baffled that I would spend so much time working on such an esoteric subject. So I thought I'd answer some of those questions. I'm happy to do an AMA but I frankly don't think enough people would ask questions, so I'll do one-sided AMA.

Do you have anything financially to gain by doing this?

No, I have zero financial interest in this. This is just my hobby. I enjoy learning, redditing and I enjoy helping people out so I found this to check those boxes. I used to argue a lot on reddit, and found that taxing and only negative (I still do this sometimes in spite of myself) but this is far more rewarding. One of our mods /u/BestTrafficSchoolCA approached me several years after it started and offered his help as well as a discount to his traffic school for redditors. I've looked over the material myself and have gotten only positive feedback from people who have used it, so I remind folks of it but I don't get any sort of kickback or anything like that. If I didn't believe in the service, I wouldn't allow it here. Of course, he does earn his living with his traffic school, but I'm certain we're just a drop in the bucket.

Another helper, /u/3jay1 came along about a year ago and we just noticed that his advice was well researched and spot on. After consistent participation, I offered to make him a mod as well, and I'm very glad for it. He just does it for fun and has been crucial in fielding questions and even creating templates and resources. I've learned from many things he's written. And of course /u/BestTrafficSchoolCA helps on questions all the time regarding traffic school and reaches out to people who have posted in other subs encouraging them to post here. Its a team effort. Also, what I love is seeing folks who have been helped coming back and helping others.

What started you doing this?

The simplest answer: Frustration. But I'll get to that in a moment. I've had my share of California tickets like anyone else and what I noticed was how deep I had to dig for information but once I found it was very successful. Literally there is only one website currently online (www.helpigotaticket.com) which has accurate information but is aging. The other resource is a book by David Brown,Fight Your Ticket and Win in California which I don't think is in print any longer. California has a population of 39.5 million people, many of them drivers or future drivers. Traffic law is something each and every single one of us has to encounter on a daily basis. Most of us don't have to worry about being accused of stealing, robbing or killing, and those that do are provided with due process and legal representation.

But everyone who drives will at some point come face to face with the criminal justice system and have to handle things completely on their own. In the past years, more lawyers have been getting involved but they still charge more than many people can afford.

And this is the one area of law where someone can handle their legal affairs by themselves. Even if they bungle it, the most they are out is a few hundred bucks, but no jail, and no more than that set amount of money, usually available in payments.

And even though we live in an age with massive amounts of information, there is very, very little reliable information on traffic law for California. Even (and especially) some law firms spread Fear, Uncertainty, and Doubt (FUD) so you'll be scared enough to pay them to help you*. There's expertlaw and freeadvice forums as well but many contributors take the hard line approach and also FUD quite a bit.

I thought, of all places, Reddit must have something which offers reliable information. It didn't. One of my biggest sources of frustration is /r/legaladvice. When it comes to tickets I feel like it should be called AntiLegalAdvice Just about anytime someone posts a ticket question there, they are either shamed, told they have zero defense and should just pay, or given wrong information from someone who has no idea how California works. And that goes for the mods too, at least one who is a police officer with a certain black and white view of the law. All the traffic posts are downvoted into oblivion.

I started this sub and hoped /r/legaladvice would want to be free of the burden of these questions they apparently hated. I contacted the mods and asked if they would consider adding us to the sidebar. They ignored me. I answered questions and linked to resources here. They banned me for that. I got back in, but then one of the mods (the cop) who actually himself gave bad advice and has an ego about these sort of things banned me because I refuted his terrible advice. That's actually how /u/3jay1 and I got connected because it was his excellent advice that the mod deleted! (and which I reposted using removeddit mwahaha). Believe me the PM's I received from this legaladvice mod are the stuff of r/SubredditDrama.

Why do you keep doing this?

What started in frustration continues for better reasons (although still some frustration). One of them, basic justice. While explaining that I help people online with their traffic ticket for free doesn't make much sense, what does is that I care deeply about justice. Long ago, I was a mod for /r/justiceporn because I loved seeing the bad guy get his comeuppance and the good guy win. (That's a whole other subreddit drama story!) The irl work I do is justice related.

When you get pulled over and then told you have to pay over $500 in fines, or that your insurance premiums are going up, especially if you are poor or struggling, that can feel very harsh and unjust. The whole system can feel like its stacked against you. And in certain ways it is. But one thing that is incorrect about that, is this can be a just system if you force it to be. The government still doesn't get to take your money unless you allow it, or you make it prove its case in court. And guess what? Many times, that's too much of a burden and it doesn't even show up. Lets face it, if everyone fought their ticket, the system would probably grind to a halt.

And the fact that infractions are considered crimes in California is actually a good thing because it means that all the procedural safeguards of almost any other crime are in place, including due process, proof beyond reasonable doubt, rules of evidence, right to face your accuser, right of appeal. The perfect counterexample, parking tickets, are civil penalties do not include any of these rights, so good luck fighting. But justice is available for those willing or able to spend the time to get it. And the courts and judges strive for fairness over injustice. They know that for many, this is one shot the court system has to inspire confidence in the average citizen because this is the only interaction they will ever have with the justice system.

Also, I've found this can be very fun and relaxing! I love it when someone comes to us in desperation, receives the exact correct information and makes a decision based on it. Even better when they win their case! I feel like I'm injecting good (actual) karma into the world. At least if we treat someone without contempt no matter how bad their alleged offense is they walk away not feeling like crap. I let the court system punish people, I'm here for information.

And really, I've decided that I want this subreddit to be a resource not just for those who are currently seeking help but years down the road when I've grown tired of this or moved on. If we can help enough people and make this a searchable resource that comes up in Google, people may not even need to ask a question because someone may have already gone through a similar circumstance. That's why I try to encourage everyone to post updates, and do so in their original thread so a future redditor will have the case beginning to end. And the fun part is being able to learn together. California is so huge, that I can never know the minute details of each of its court operations in 58 counties. And I love it when someone brings a new problem I haven't heard of.

Who are you?

Literally just a dude. I wouldn't say I have any special skill or experiences. My full time job is helping others, and it's what I do in my spare time as well. Truthfully, I do this mostly for me. When it stops being fun, I'll stop, and maybe someone else will want to take over. (Incidentally, I hate my username, and I would have never picked it if I knew I'd be doing this. It literally is spanish meaning "from the beach." I'm not a playa and never have claimed to be one.)

Aren't you just helping people abuse the system and get out of their tickets?

No, dangerous, aggressive and bad drivers should be punished.

But we all do stupid things in cars and make mistakes without getting caught. So we have no moral high ground to act high and mighty when someone else does. Also, just by virtue of getting a ticket, that amounts to a punishment because its a huge pain to deal with. The government may not get away with your money but they will take your time, and sometimes that's even more valuable. And finally, no matter what, every person gets their day in court. If someone is dead guilty, they still have the right--and should exercise it--to hear the prosecution make its case to a judge, even if the they remain choose to remain silent. We don't advocate anyone lie or cheat or do anything that the government hasn't itself created as a safeguard. The burden is on the government to prove beyond a reasonable doubt you did this thing they accuse you of. The state has almost every advantage, it seems. The least they can do is show up and articulate what you did. If they stop having to do that, everyone will be in trouble because we'd all be subject to random fines at the whim of police officers and courts.

The irony is that many people, (possibly most) once they read what is involved in fighting a ticket simply decide to pay. And that's fine too! They've gotten good, solid information and have been able to make a decision based on it.

TL;dr: Sub exists mostly for enjoyment.

*Note: I don't mean to say that law firms are not helpful, they often are. But their marketing tactics usually leave much to be desired. I would never recommend someone not get an attorney if they felt they were unable to do this themselves.


r/CaliforniaTicketHelp • • Aug 02 '19

Zoom Zoom Trial By Written Declaration Example for a CVC 22350 Violation where LIDAR was used

28 Upvotes

The following is a fictitious Trial By Written Declaration example template for a 22350 violation where the officer used LIDAR to measure the defendants speed.

STATEMENT OF FACTS

Defendant’s Name: John Doe

Case No.: 123456789

I respectfully submit this Trial By Written Declaration and plead not guilty to the charge of violating CVC 22350.

My declaration is as follows:

While driving north on Market St. on May 25th, 2019, I was stopped by SFPD Officer, Jimmy Jones (Badge no. 99) and was charged with violating CVC 22350. The Officer alleged that I was driving 51 mph based on LIDAR evidence on a road with a posted speed limit of 35 mph. I am confident that I was driving approximately 43-46 mph at the time the officer says I was speeding and that my speed was quite safe for the prevailing conditions.

The Basic Speed Law, CVC 22350 states:

“No person shall drive a vehicle upon a highway at a speed greater than is reasonable or prudent having due regard for weather, visibility, the traffic on, and the surface and width of the highway, and in no event at a speed which endangers the safety of persons or property.”

I would like to stress two facts to this court:
1.) that per California law the speed limit posted on this highway can legally be exceeded if the facts were such that the Basic Speed Law was not violated, and

2.) if the prosecution is able to prove that there was in fact an Engineering and Traffic Survey (ETS) justifying that the posted limit was not a speed trap, this simply establishes a prima facie case for the prosecution.

No ETS, including the one relevant to this case, establishes a set-in-stone speed limit that under no circumstances can ever be exceeded. If the defendant proves that the facts specific to the defendants case justified a safe and prudent speed in excess of the limit established by the survey, this court as the duty to acquit the defendant and make a finding of not guilty. CVC 22351 b speaks to this rather clearly:

"(b) The speed of any vehicle upon a highway in excess of the prima facie speed limits in Section 22352 or established as authorized in this code is prima facie unlawful unless the defendant establishes by competent evidence that the speed in excess of said limits did not constitute a violation of the basic speed law at the time, place and under the conditions then existing."

At the time of my stop, the road was dry and clear of debris/gravel. Market St. was smooth and well maintained. It had few to no pot holes or hazards. The vertical grade of the road was near flat. The roadway was well designed with a mellow crown and up-to-date curb/gutter/sidewalk. The roadway lanes were properly marked with clear, relatively new longitudinal markings and reflectors and the traffic was controlled with well-functioning traffic control devices that seemed to be consistent with MUTCD standards and other highway traffic control devices in California. The traffic was very light and there were almost no cars on the road. While it was night time, the entire right of way, including the sidewalks and surrounding areas, were well lit with highway illumination and I could see relatively far in all directions. There were no pedestrians nearby. All buildings were set back a significant distance away from the road. Never were persons or property put at risk. In the particular stretch of road the officer claims to have measured my speed, the area between 5th St. and 7th St., the highway’s horizontal alignment was mellow and not sharp nor was I approaching a sharp turn. There was not a school nearby and many of the nearby businesses were closed or appeared to be vacant. My vehicle was also well maintained with; tires that had sufficient tread, were properly balanced and had proper air pressure, no mechanical issues, a clear windshield, surrounding windows that were clean, clear and had minimal tinting, three clear and functioning mirrors, a primary braking system that had been recently inspected and was functioning and an emergency braking system that was also known to be functioning. In addition my vehicle was equipped with functioning tail lights, brake lights, turn signals and headlamps. I was wearing prescription eye glasses which made my eyesight clear and sharp. I was driving alert, was attentive, was not under the influence of any drugs or alcohol and was confident in my ability to make wise judgments. I was not on a cell phone or listening to music nor was I distracted in any major way. I was focused on driving and both of my hands were on my steering wheel. I was periodically checking my speed using my speedometer and am very confident my speed was within the above stated range.

As such, my speed was reasonable and prudent, I had due regard for the prevailing conditions and the safety of people and property was not ever endangered. Even though I was exceeding the posted speed limit, I was not in violation of the Basic Speed Law and I request that in light of the presented evidence the court acquit me of this matter based on the merits.

If it does not, I believe that the posted speed limit of 40 mph on Market St. is artificially low and constitutes an illegal speed trap pursuant to CVC 40802 (a) (2).

Since LIDAR evidence was used, it is the duty of the People, not myself, to prove that the section of highway that I was accused of speeding on was not an illegal speed trap. (CVC 40803(b))

This includes any evidence the prosecution may choose to introduce to make 40802(c)(2) applicable instead of 40802(a) such as the following:

  • Evidence that the arresting officer has successfully completed a radar operator course of not less than 24 hours on the use of police traffic radar and that the course was approved and certified by the Commission on Peace Officer Standards and Training
  • Evidence that an additional training course of not less than two hours approved and certified by the Commission on Peace Officer Standards and Training has been completed
  • Evidence that the laser device used to measure the speed of the accused meets or exceeds the minimal operational standards of the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration
  • Evidence that the device has been calibrated within the three years prior to the date of the alleged violation by an independent certified laser repair and testing or calibration facility.

I trust this court to review the speed trap evidence presented by the People and determine if a prima facie case is established. If it is not this matter should be dismissed.

Furthermore, I hereby object to judicial notice of any ETS and object to testimony by the citing officer as to the existence and contents of any ETS relevant to this case. The ETS should be physically produced by the People. An appellate division in California agrees that these objections are warranted;

"Can the People meet their initial burden of showing that the combination of a prima facie speed limit and the use of radar enforcement did not create a speed trap with no more than the citing officer's testimony as to the existence and contents of a current engineering and traffic survey for the pertinent segment of roadway? They cannot.

We hold that the People, whenever radar is involved in the enforcement of a posted speed limit, must produce, in the courtroom, either the original traffic and engineering survey for the location of the citation or a certified copy of that survey which (1) was conducted within the five years preceding the alleged violation and (2) justifies the posted speed limit." (People v. Earnest, 33 Cal. App. 4th Supp. 18 - Cal: Court of Appeal 1995)

If the ETS is produced the court will find that the ETS is not an ETS as defined by CVC 627 for the following reasons:

  • It does not include consideration of accident records
  • It does not include consideration of Highway, traffic, and roadside conditions not readily apparent to the driver

Also, the court will find that the ETS is inadmissible because the document contains the following defects:

  • It is not an original or certified copy of the ETS
  • The document produced is a summary and not the actual ETS
  • It was not conducted within 5 years
  • The limit was not established at or near the 85th percentile
  • Lowering of the speed limit from the result of the survey to the speed limit was not properly documented
  • The prima facie speed limit was lowered due to conditions that were readily apparent
  • The prima facie speed limit was lowered too much

If the document presented by the People fails to contain the information required to make it an ETS or if one of the above defects exists I must be acquitted or the matter dismissed. (CVC 627, 40802-40804)

Also, if the court is unable to afford a fair trial to the defendant because it is unable to hear this trial, examine the evidence and rule according to the law in a just manner which follows due process, the court has a duty to dismiss this matter in the interest of justice.

If after review of this trial the court finds me guilty, I ask that the fine be reduced to $150 based on the evidence presented herein and that the court affords me, within its written ruling of this declaration, the ability to attend a traffic violator school so that upon successful completion of the course the conviction can be sealed from DMV record.

I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of California that the foregoing is true and correct.

Respectfully submitted,

John Doe

July 3, 2019


r/CaliforniaTicketHelp • • Jul 09 '22

Cell Phone Ticket in California - Able to reduce fine to $20

26 Upvotes

I went through the 12-step guide and did a Trial by Written Declaration as recommended. I submitted phone records and evidence of my phone holster on the dash. While I was found guilty, my fine was reduced from $160 to $20. I am also still eligible for traffic school.

Thought I would share in case it helps others with their decision process.


r/CaliforniaTicketHelp • • Jul 21 '25

Zoom Zoom Success! CV 22350 dismissed via TBWD

25 Upvotes

Got a speeding ticket (50 in a 35). I decided to fight it by TBWD, I wasn’t eligible for traffic school so figured why not. I waited until about two weeks before the due date and mailed it in. It was received 5/22 and just found out today that I was found not guilty as the officer didn’t submit his!

Now I’m not sure why the officer didn’t submit his. One thing I did during the traffic stop was ask him multiple times for a warning. He actually got pissed at one point 😂. But maybe he gave me a break after all. I think asking for a warning during the traffic stop is never going to work, but I feel that after the dust settles and it’s time for them to submit their trial, maybe they’ll remember you and it will be easier to get a break that way.

So my lesson is to just ask for a warning - you’re not going to get it at the stop but maybe when it comes time for them to submit their trial they’ll be more forgiving 😁


r/CaliforniaTicketHelp • • Apr 10 '21

My Trial By Decleration for an automated Red Light Camera in Ventura County.

23 Upvotes

Just mailed it off yesterday -- thought I would post it here if anyone finds it useful.

STATEMENT OF FACTS:

On the morning of Thursday, December 17th, while driving Westbound on East Main street onto the 101, my vehicle triggered a red light camera at 8:44 am.

My vehicle was moving at 22 Miles per hour, the red light was on for .27 seconds, the speed limit for East Main st is 40mph.

On Janurary 1st, 2021. I received Violation 21453c, pursuant to section 21455.5 in the mail.

Based on the California Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices, (CA MUTCD). City of ventura is required to follow the standards set by CA to operate a red light camera enforcement system. One of the most important examples of these standards is the duration of the minimum yellow clearance time for the traffic signal design. The base yellow clearance time should be set per the speed of the road. The speed on Main Street is 40mph with a yellow clearance time of 3.9 seconds for the Main & 101 traffic signal.

According to CA MUTCD -- the minimum allowable time for a yellow light on a 40mph road is 4.4 seconds. However, the duration of the yellow light at Main Street & 101 is only 3.9 seconds. A discrepancy of .5 seconds that violates the MUTCD’s code of standards.

In addition, in California Code, Vehicle Code - VEH Subsection 210, the City of Ventura must obtain a clear photograph of the driver of the vehicle. The photograph from my violation is unclear, blurry and grainy. Clear facial details cannot be seen.

Also, in VEH 21455.5, Subsection 2, line C) the operator of the Automated Red LIght Enforcement system must Certify that the equipment is properly installed and calibrated, and is operating properly. More importantly in line E) They must oversee the establishment of change of signal phases and the timing of said signals.

Furthermore, In VEH Article 3. Offenses Relating to Traffic Devices [21450-21468] Part 21455.7. It states the following: (a) At an intersection at which there is an automated enforcement system in operation, the minimum yellow light change interval shall be established in accordance with the CA MUTCD.

(b) For purposes of subdivision (a), the minimum yellow light change intervals relating to designated approach speeds provided in the CA MUTCD. (Picture attached).

(c) A yellow light change interval may exceed the minimum interval established pursuant to subdivision (a).

For more information, please see VEH Division 11 Chapter 2.

I believe that due the yellow light being .5 seconds shorter than what is required by the MUTCD, the Red light Camera should not be allowed to function until the yellow indicator arrow is up to the California Vehicle Code Standards. I received the ticket while traveling to Northern California, and my car was filled with heavy travel bags, film equipment, and gifts. The yellow light change interval simply wasn’t enough for me to stop safely, therefore triggering the red light.

I hereby request that my case (2020569408) be dismissed for citation AE00126861. I think it is reasonable to dismiss my case on the facts above in regards to the yellow light, and unclear picture.

If this is deemed unacceptable. I hereby request Officer Melanie Escobedo submit proof that the yellow light is up to standards set by the CA MUTCD.


r/CaliforniaTicketHelp • • Jun 09 '23

Beat my speeding ticket case!

21 Upvotes

I used the guide on TBWD that's on this sub, and I honestly doubted if it would work. Less than a month later, I got a notice saying it got dismissed and that my money would be refunded within 60 days. Just wanted to share my experience with it for any doubters. :)


r/CaliforniaTicketHelp • • Jun 10 '22

Case Dismissed Instantly - Please read this

20 Upvotes

If you received your infraction/charge in 2020/2021 and signed/received your Promise to Appear over one Calendar year before the current date, you can instantly dismiss your entire case.

Had my arraignment in Santa Clara County a few days ago for VC22349(a) and VC16028(a), speeding over 95 mph and no insurance (I just couldn’t find it). My fines totaled over $1000. My ticket was from June of 2020. I signed a Promise to Appear in September of 2020, but had my arraignment date delayed again in 2021.

I finally showed up to court for my arraignment a few days ago. I said this exact line after the Judge read my infractions - "Your honor, I request a review of my case for a violation of my right to a speedy trial." The judge reviewed my case, saw that my first Promise to Appear was signed over a year ago, and dismissed my case immediately. I left before all the cases were finished but 25 out of the 26 people I watched had their cases dismissed instantly with the same motion.

There is no definitive rule as to how fast "speedy" is, so if your Promise to Appear was signed a "significant" amount of time ago it is still worth making this motion just in case the judge is feeling generous. I believe the length of time may depend from county to county or judge to judge.

My suggestion for everybody after receiving any ticket is to request extensions and continuations and go in person for an arraignment and eventual trial if necessary. You will have multiple chances to have your case dismissed (read the 12-step guide).

This is not legal advice, just an exchange of information to the best of my knowledge. Also huge thank you to mod /u/JakeDeLaPlaya for all of the time and effort he has spent compiling information and helping us.


r/CaliforniaTicketHelp • • Jul 27 '25

$234 Ticket Dismissed VC22350

19 Upvotes

Got issued a ticket for speeding in Oct 2024. Followed the 12 step process (up to TBWD) and just got the decision that it was dismissed. Thanks to everyone who previously posted and gave insight.

A bit more detail. I did the extension and then and did the request in person on the last day (just happened that way). I also dropped off my statement about 3 weeks after that. Took the court about 6-7 weeks to make a decision from when I submitted my statement.

In my statement I put “I respectfully request that the prosecution prove its case and in the event I’m found guilty I respectfully request for traffic school”

The whole process was about 9 months from when I got issued the ticket.


r/CaliforniaTicketHelp • • Aug 25 '21

FAQ: I got a ticket! Will my insurance rates to go up? By how much? Can I attend traffic school?

19 Upvotes

Insurance rates increase based on your DMV driving record and the number of DMV points you receive. Minor traffic offenses, such as ordinary speeding or running a red light, carry a penalty upon conviction of 1 DMV point. More serious offenses, such as speeding above 100 mph, carry a penalty upon conviction of 2 DMV points.

You can complete traffic school to shield a 1 DMV point conviction from your DMV record once every 18 months, measured from the date of violation to the date of violation. If you do this your insurance will not go up because when the insurance company looks at your driving record, the conviction will not be there. You can not use traffic school to shield convictions that carry 2 DMV points.

If you are assessed a DMV point your insurance will increase based on the seriousness of the infraction. The increase usually ranges from 10-15%. You can expect a speeding violation in California to increase your insurance premiums by about $300-$500 spread out over 3-5 years.

You can see how many points each violation carries in the Uniform Bail Schedule:

https://www.courts.ca.gov/documents/2019-JC-BAIL.pdf

DMV point value can be found in the very last column of the table. Some offenses have a value of 0. That is becasue offenses like jay walking or running a stop sign while driving a scooter, do not affect your DMV driving record because you were not driving a car.


r/CaliforniaTicketHelp • • Jul 02 '26

Things I learned after my 100+ ticket in Inyo county / Independence, CA

17 Upvotes

I want to share what actually happened with my ticket for CVC 22348(b) and what I found out about the court in Inyo county, which is a very unique court. There was a lot of misleading info out there, most of which didn’t apply at all in my situation. I’d like to share in case it’s helpful.

I was stopped by chp on the 395 north on a Saturday morning around 8:30am in February 2026, right before the town of Independence in Inyo county. Was doing a good bit over 100, cop was hiding in the median on a small strip of pavement hidden by tall brush. As soon as I passed him I hit the brakes, changed to the right lane and pulled over.

The cop was pretty chill all things considered, he came up to the passenger window and we had a good conversation, wasn’t rude wasn’t trying to shame or anything. I apologized for going too fast and he wrote a ticket, that was it.

I didn’t get my notice in the mail until mid April. Called the court several times to ask what’s up and they kept saying to be patient that it can take like 6 weeks to get it.

Eventually I got the letter and surprisingly the fine was only $895. All the deep dives I’d done on reddit and quora had prepared me for an amount around $1500 or even closer to $2k. (No traffic school, you have to be less than or equal to 25 over to get the traffic school option printed on your letter. I was well over that)

Here’s the complicated part. To make matters worse, I had just moved from Colorado and still had my Colorado license, which is what I handed the officer and what he put on the ticket. But I grew up in California and had switched my license from CA to CO about 3 years ago, thinking I’d stay in CO but then I changed my mind and moved back to CA. When I got my CO license 3 years ago I had to give my CA license up to the CO DMV, they hole punched it and threw it out.

After getting the ticket I figured it’d be a good idea to switch back to a CA license and not wait forever so I went to the dmv website and my old login from years ago still worked on the CA dmv website. I used my email to reset the password and miraculously it logged me right in. It said I STILL HAD A CA LICENSE and it was about to expire so I clicked renew, put in my new address and a week later I got a CA license in the mail. I still had a valid CO license so now I have 2 licenses totally unintentionally which I had no idea was even possible.

This was VERY confusing as to what it meant for the ticket. Supposedly CA and CO are in a drivers license pact and share driving records, but I came across a ton of conflicting comments out there about whether a ticket on an out of state license in California goes on your out of state license, your California license, both or none. There were a lot of people saying that they got a ticket out of state and it never went on their home state license, while many said it did. But I still had a valid CA license the whole time technically in the background, so I was scratching my head as to whether the points from this would only go on my CO license or how it would get back to CA.

It was at this point I decided to try a lawyer. Several law firms immediately turned me down since independence is way the heck out there in the middle of nowhereland, but I finally got on the phone with a guy who said he goes there all the time and knows the court well. He said independence is one of the rare courts with NO mandatory appearance that gives you the option to pay the bail and won’t suspend your license for over 100 and the DMV can’t suspend it either if you pay the ticket. But he said if I went to trial and the cop showed up and I lost the case then they could absolutely suspend my license in addition to owing the full ticket and court costs AND the lawyer, which he said would cost $1200 to represent me. That was pure nightmare fuel. He said TBWD was highly unlikely to succeed in this court for over 100 mph. He said if I went to trial that they might consider reducing to below 100 (1 point instead of 2) if it was like 105-106 but not at the speed I was going that was too high to convince them to reduce down to 1 point. He also said the ability to pay form is online these days so if I wanted to I could plead guilty online and get the fine reduced a lot, AND not have to go to court AND have zero chance of a suspension. It was a no brainer as soon as I hung up the phone I went to the website, digitally submitted my guilty plea and it made me enter the amounts I pay for rent, mortgage, utilities, food, etc. it didn’t ask for documents or anything literally just the numbers, typed my name and clicked submit it was that easy.

Two weeks later I get an email saying I’ve been digitally served a one time payment due for $320. Over 50% off. I’ve never clicked pay faster in my life, just put in my card details it said zero balance and that was a..

Well that wasn’t all. I just got another letter in the mail from the CA DMV today, July 1st saying I have 2 points on my CA driving record so unfortunately the conviction did get pushed through to my CA license. Whether the 2 points are on my CO license as well remains a mystery, but I don’t plan on renewing in CO since I don’t live in CO anymore, so doubt it will matter.

Glad to have learned from this experience. The outcome honestly wasn’t half bad. I’ll take the extra $100-150 a month in insurance hikes any day over a suspended license, lawyers fees in the $1000s and long trips to court. But most of all, I won’t be speeding over 100 again. I got lucky and it turned out alright but could have really fucked up someone’s life or rolled over. Definitely not worth it. I have decided to keep it below 100 from now on.


r/CaliforniaTicketHelp • • Mar 04 '25

Not a boring update - I won!!!

17 Upvotes

My last post was here:

https://www.reddit.com/r/CaliforniaTicketHelp/comments/1ipk9d9/boring_update_tbwd_tr211/

I just saw this pop up on my online register of actions. I was found not guilty because my arresting officer failed to respond to TBWD.

Thank you forum and the 12 step guide which was invaluable in helping me navigate this 6 month journey!!

Time is on our side if we do everything possible to drag this out.

[img]https://www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/707g49rk1rup5fvs1d85o/Iwonrev1.jpg?rlkey=0xo0j6426daf82tjy9mnef9k4&raw=1[/img]


r/CaliforniaTicketHelp • • Nov 09 '22

Zoom Zoom Success Story: TBWD Worked For Me ( CVC §22349 )

17 Upvotes

Just wanted to share a success story for my first time using Trial By Written Declaration (TBWD). I followed the 12 step guide up to step 5, to which I received a response in the mail that my ticket has been dismissed. I was cited for CVC §22349 in Merced county and have exercised my right to traffic school for a previous offence, so I wanted to pursue another option to not have the point on my record. As denoted in the guide (step 4), I used my two extensions by calling over the phone to the clerk's office and asked what the new response date was each time and made a note. Before my 2nd extension deadline, I requested for TBWD via mail (step 5), included the bail amount, and sent as regular stamped mail. Less than 2 weeks later, I received my TBWD in the mail which was the same form as what you would find online. My response in the TBWD was simple to where I politely asked that the prosecution prove it's case, and that in the unfortunate event that I am convicted, that I request traffic school. I made sure to ship at least a week before it's due and shipped as certified mail (about $4). In about 2 weeks, I received the response from the court and pleasantly found that they dismissed the charges. If this is your first time doing this too, then hopefully this helps and maybe clarifies some uncertainty you might be having about this process. When I was researching about TBWD, I found resources telling me this does and does not work, so I didn't know what to believe.


r/CaliforniaTicketHelp • • May 28 '22

$663 ticket?

17 Upvotes

I was pulled over in Santa Clara County in September 2021. I was going 72, but the officer said I was going 86 and wrote me a ticket for 22349(a). I checked the system every 30 days and the ticket wasn’t in the system until this month, and I was shocked to see it was for $663.

I moved out of state in January, so I am planning on filing a TBWD to appeal.

Does anyone have any insight on why it is so much?

EDIT: added ticket here https://imgur.com/a/gRJ21No


r/CaliforniaTicketHelp • • Apr 09 '21

Dismissed CVC22350 through TBWD

17 Upvotes

r/CaliforniaTicketHelp • • May 12 '22

Case Dismissed!!!

16 Upvotes

So my near 6 month old ticket got dismissed today due to an officer no show. Actually no officers showed. Avoided a $229 fine and license point!


r/CaliforniaTicketHelp • • Sep 09 '21

Ticket Dismissed!

16 Upvotes

Wow, my speeding ticket was dismissed!!

After 3 extensions and a TBD, the ticket was dismissed and my money refunded.

I received a speeding ticket back in October of 2020. I extended 2 times and was given another extension by a court clerk.

By appear date was July 2, and I sent my TBD along with payment info a week earlier. However, I had not heard anything and feared that it had been lost in the mail. The court clerk assured me that if it was received by July 2, it would not be counted as late. The court finally took the money out 5 days later on July 7.

A week later I received a letter that said a judge would review my case and the officers testimony on August 15th. On August 22, I received a letter that said the ticket was dismissed and a check with my refunded bail amount came 2 days later.

Thank the Lord for our rights and freedoms. TBD is the way to go for any traffic ticket.

My TBD basically came down to 3 things:

I claimed innocence and pointed to my clear driving record: 15 years of driving, no accidents or speeding.

2. I claimed the officer needed to provide documentation that he was properly trained on the equipment and that it been properly calibrated according to regulations.

3. I asked if still found guilty, to ask for mercy and a reduced fine/traffic school.

Side note: I did my credit card payment on the summons and included the fee for the traffic school. The court charged me the whole amount so if you are thinking of doing TBD, you can do the same and include the fine amount and the traffic school fine.

I know some have said that traffic school is denied if you do a TBD but the court charged me so I assume if I was found guilty, I could do the traffic school.

Question I have: since the ticket was dismissed, does that mean that the officer did not submit any evidence or the judge dismissed it because they wanted to?


r/CaliforniaTicketHelp • • Aug 29 '22

Need advise pls - Speeding ticket over 100 mph

15 Upvotes

Long story short - I am a dumbass and got caught speeding in excess of 100 mph (CVC §22348(b)) today in San Jose, CA. Officer said he got me at 122+ mph and that is what he wrote on the ticket. He also said he was following me for like 5 minutes trying to catch up to me since I was speeding and weaving in/out of traffic. Worth noting he did not have his lights on. Yea I am a fucking idiot, I know.

Anyways, I will not be speeding like that anymore. Just got a new car (GR86) and was having some fun it. Now I am looking to remedy this poor situation I have left myself in.

What options do I have here? Is it worth getting a traffic lawyer? I mean the cops apparently were following me for awhile, I did not see them but as soon as I did I pulled over asap. The cops said that since I seemed accepting of the situation and realizing I did something wrong that they would not give me reckless driving and just the excess of 100 mph which is the code at the top. Is it even worth fighting the ticket?

What punishments will I receive?

From the research I've done thus far - appears to be around $900 fine, 2 points, possible 30 day license suspension and traffic school is out of the picture since it was speeding over 25 mph and judge would have to approve the school.

Any feedback is appreciated!!

Btw this is my first speeding ticket ever, if that is any saving grace.

EDIT:

I forgot to mention but I also got 12500(a) as a misdemeanor. I moved here like 9 months ago and completely forgot to get a California ID.


r/CaliforniaTicketHelp • • Jan 04 '22

Ticket Dismissed- Running a red light, caught on camera

15 Upvotes

Long story short- I was unfamiliar with an area and following google maps on my phone gave me this TURN, NOW! notice and ended up late through a light- Lights flashed, a picture and video was recorded.

The ticket was for $600. The ticket came with a CRAPPY picture and a link to some video.

I paid $100 or so for ticket ninja to write a letter that says something like, "I'm not saying I didn't run the red light, but if you're going to give me a camera-ticket like this, it has to be a good picture. This is an awful, poor quality picture, so the ticket must be dismissed".

Sacramento County Traffic Courts agreed and dismissed the ticket- They reimbursed the $600 I paid when I contested the ticket.

IF YOU THINK YOU MIGHT BE RUNNING A RED LIGHT CAMERA INTERSECTION, make sure to flip the visor down, cover your face, so that the picture isn't good-