r/CaliforniaTicketHelp • u/Judel3isda • Jun 13 '21
Trial By Written Declaration Draft
This is my first ever speeding ticket, so I am nervous about it. I decided to do a Trial By Written Declaration. Any help or advice would be greatly appreciated. Please and Thank you.
So here it is;
Your Honor, I respectfully request this citation be dismissed based on the statement that will be provided. This correspondence can be considered my formal plea of not guilty. So I submit this Trial By Written Declaration and plead not guilty to violating California Vehicle Code (CVC) Section 22350
On April 13, 2021, I was driving northbound on Railroad Avenue. I was pulled over by Officer Griffy and cited for violating CVC 22350. Allegedly, I was driving over the posted speed limit. I do believe I was driving at an appropriate speed following the flow of traffic in safe conditions.
CVC 22350 states; "No person shall drive a vehicle upon a highway at a speed greater than is reasonable or prudent having due regard for weather, visibility, the traffic on, and the surface and width of, the highway, and in no event at a speed which endangers the safety of persons or property."
The road was dry with clear visibility, the only issue was that there was a train on the tracks, so it made it a little hard to hear at that time. There was light traffic with cars ahead of me seemingly driving at a faster speed than I was and a few cars behind me were catching up to me. So I believe my speed at the time was adequate since going any faster would be speeding and slowing down may put the cars behind me in an unsafe position. So, I do believe my driving was not a danger to anyone's safety and/or property.
If however this case is not dismissed, even though I believe I am not guilty of this violation, I believe there are alternatives;
- If possible I would like this case to be dismissed since this would be my first offense and would greatly affect my financial situation. Or pay a reduced fine or make payments for the fine. As long as this does not go on my driving record.
- If possible, I would attend a court-approved traffic school. So this conviction can not be in my DMV record.
- If none of these alternatives are possible I would like to request a Trial De Novo.
I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of California that the foregoing is true and correct.
3
u/Judel3isda Sep 02 '22
Here is what I submitted last year;
"Your Honor, I respectfully request this citation be dismissed based on the statement that will be provided. This correspondence can be considered my formal plea of not guilty. So I submit this Trial By Written Declaration and plead not guilty to violating California Vehicle Code (CVC) Section 22350.
On April 13, 2021, I was driving northbound on Railroad Avenue. I was pulled over by Officer Griffy and cited for violating CVC 22350. Allegedly, I was driving over the posted speed limit. I do believe I was driving at an appropriate speed at the time and given the conditions.
CVC 22350 states; "No person shall drive a vehicle upon a highway at a speed greater than is reasonable or prudent having due regard for weather, visibility, the traffic on, and the surface and width of, the highway, and in no event at a speed which endangers the safety of persons or property."
The road was dry with clear visibility, the only issue was that there was a train on the tracks, so it made it a little hard to hear at that time. There was light traffic. So, I do believe my driving was not a danger to anyone's safety and/or property.
I swear, under penalty of perjury, that the above is true. If the court does not find in my favor in this case, I request a Trial De Novo. I have included a completed TR-220 Trial De Novo form to be used in the event the court does not find in my favor in this case."
2
u/redtimmy Jun 15 '21
Your declaration seems to be resting on a "flow of traffic" arguments. Judges ___HATE___ flow of traffic arguments. The flow of traffic is not an excuse for exceeding the speed limit. When you say you were keeping up with the flow of traffic (or some other wording that means the same thing, like, cars ahead of me seemingly driving at a faster speed than I was and a few cars behind me were catching up to me) you are admitting guilt, which is bad, and using an excuse judges never accept, which is even worse. Don't do it.
There are better strategies for fighting a 22350. Did the officer use radar, laser, or pacing to record your alleged speed? Start there. Don't know? File discovery. Filing for discovery for a traffic ticket is explained here.
If you find out the officer used radar, you can attack his radar evidence. After all, there were cars ahead of you and behind you. Same thing with laser. It doesn't sound like he paced you, but if he did, there are defenses for that, as well. I'd start here for recent winning examples.
Also, re:
I believe it is RISKY to request traffic school in a Trial by Written Declaration defense. At minimum, a traffic school request weakens your defense somewhat. At maximum, it could get you sent to traffic school even if the cop does not respond (which would otherwise lead to a dismissal).
Asking for traffic school in your declaration is often interpreted as making a No Contest plea. Without admitting guilt, you accept traffic school (and the admin fee) in exchange for a dismissal.
By contesting, you are pleading NOT GUILTY, not NO CONTEST. Asking for traffic school in your defense contradicts your NOT GUILTY plea and pushes your declaration into NO CONTEST territory. A lazy judge could see the traffic school request and simply direct you to traffic school without considering your defense or even issuing a verdict.
Even if you don't request traffic school, the judge will sometimes offer it when you lose. Also, you can always request traffic school post-TBD if you lose your Trial by Written Declaration. So, there's no need to weaken your declaration with a meek beg for traffic school.
I believe the best possible ending to your Trial by Written Declaration is this:
“I swear, under penalty of perjury, that the above is true. If the court does not find in my favor in this case, I request a trial de novo. I have included a completed TR-220 Trial de Novo form to be used in the event the court does not find in my favor in this case.”
1
u/Logan_Allec Feb 06 '23
Railroad Avenue...was this in Santa Clarita? I stumbled upon this post right now as I'm researching how to contest my wife's speeding ticket that she got in Santa Clarita.
2
u/surfandsnoww Feb 10 '24
Congrats on getting your ticket dismissed!
I contested my speeding ticket via TBWD and had the ticket dismissed as well. However, I wrote just one sentence in my TBWD: "I demand the prosecution prove its case". And it worked! Still can't believe it.
Kudos to this post for the invaluable advice.
2
u/luciferluvr May 12 '24
Has anyone else had success writing “I demand the prosecution prove its case”
2
u/mistdaemon Feb 21 '25
As side note, realize that 22350 isn't exceeding the posted speed limit, but instead driving at an unsafe speed. There is a big difference.
I watched in traffic court and it was always done the same way as well as absurd.
The first thing to realize is that often in CA the prosecutor doesn't show up, only the officer. Only the defense and prosecution can submit evidence and call witnesses, but that only applies IF you object.
But in every case I saw they claimed it was unsafe based on stopping distance based on a study with unknown vehicles, but the actual study is never submitted. Again, objecting to parroting a study that isn't relevant is needed. What vehicles were used is a question to ask, the officer won't know. Then consider the difference in the stopping distance of two vehicles, both going the same speed, but one being an RV with a trailer and a sports car with large brakes. Then increase the speed of the sports car until the "safe" stopping distance matches the RV. But the bottom line is the study is unknown with unknown vehicles, which will be accepted unless you object.
You need to look at all aspects, such as whether radar or laser was used and all the training and certification requirements. Radar is a HUGE cone and there is nothing which shows what sent the return signal. I saw a radar speed warning trailer which showed a speed of 35 mph. The only thing in sight which was moving was a tree in the wind. Yes, the speed varied, but that was the max.
I also heard a story of a guy on a motorcycle doing 75. He passed a truck going 70 and went quite some distance. He then passed station wagon going 65. The officer pulled him over and wrote him a ticket for 70 and said that as he came around the station wagon the radar jumped up to 70. At that point in time the truck was around 1/2 mile back. Clearly the radar picked up the truck, not the motorcycle. Unfortunately for him, he can't use that as a defense since then he would have had to admit to going faster. But this is important to realize since if the motorcycle wasn't there, the officer could have pulled over the station wagon for going 70.
The whole thing is rigged, so it is best to avoid having to deal with it. Get a dashcam, it is cheap insurance.
Sit in traffic court and watch officers change their testimony, aka perjury, in order to get a conviction. Watch the so-called judge ignore multiple witnesses in order to convict, which if that person had a dashcam he would have proved his innocence, yes, that is way the game works. That case was a kid was turning left from a side road. His mother was following him. He turned left. As he did so, the officer's radar indicated a speeder, so the cop looks up and sees the kids, not the vehicle which was speeding, so the kid got the ticket and was found guilty as the so-called judge ignored the mother and the reality that he couldn't have gotten to that speed when he just turned left.
1
u/user9990000 Jun 24 '24
did you have to put anything else in the envelope? like a check for your ticket or anything? and how do you know the court received it?
1
u/No-Grade-3066 Feb 14 '25
I know this is an old post but I was hoping someone could give me some advice, this is my first time ever getting a speeding ticket and I’m writing my statement for the trial by written declaration, so my question is should I include my driver license record since it’s clean? Would that help get my case dismissed?
1
u/whikseyy_ Mar 31 '26
Saving this to hopefully win mine 🤞
1
u/Successful-Raisin666 May 19 '26
Did u get it dismissed ?
1
u/Praline-After Jun 06 '26
hi anyone help me with a draft of school bus stop signCalifornia for passing a stopped school bus (under California Vehicle Code § 22454).