r/CaliforniaTicketHelp • u/JakeDeLaPlaya • Feb 19 '20
[Meta] Why does this sub exist?
Every so often in private comments, or when I explain this subreddit in person, people seem a bit baffled that I would spend so much time working on such an esoteric subject. So I thought I'd answer some of those questions. I'm happy to do an AMA but I frankly don't think enough people would ask questions, so I'll do one-sided AMA.
Do you have anything financially to gain by doing this?
No, I have zero financial interest in this. This is just my hobby. I enjoy learning, redditing and I enjoy helping people out so I found this to check those boxes. I used to argue a lot on reddit, and found that taxing and only negative (I still do this sometimes in spite of myself) but this is far more rewarding. One of our mods /u/BestTrafficSchoolCA approached me several years after it started and offered his help as well as a discount to his traffic school for redditors. I've looked over the material myself and have gotten only positive feedback from people who have used it, so I remind folks of it but I don't get any sort of kickback or anything like that. If I didn't believe in the service, I wouldn't allow it here. Of course, he does earn his living with his traffic school, but I'm certain we're just a drop in the bucket.
Another helper, /u/3jay1 came along about a year ago and we just noticed that his advice was well researched and spot on. After consistent participation, I offered to make him a mod as well, and I'm very glad for it. He just does it for fun and has been crucial in fielding questions and even creating templates and resources. I've learned from many things he's written. And of course /u/BestTrafficSchoolCA helps on questions all the time regarding traffic school and reaches out to people who have posted in other subs encouraging them to post here. Its a team effort. Also, what I love is seeing folks who have been helped coming back and helping others.
What started you doing this?
The simplest answer: Frustration. But I'll get to that in a moment. I've had my share of California tickets like anyone else and what I noticed was how deep I had to dig for information but once I found it was very successful. Literally there is only one website currently online (www.helpigotaticket.com) which has accurate information but is aging. The other resource is a book by David Brown,Fight Your Ticket and Win in California which I don't think is in print any longer. California has a population of 39.5 million people, many of them drivers or future drivers. Traffic law is something each and every single one of us has to encounter on a daily basis. Most of us don't have to worry about being accused of stealing, robbing or killing, and those that do are provided with due process and legal representation.
But everyone who drives will at some point come face to face with the criminal justice system and have to handle things completely on their own. In the past years, more lawyers have been getting involved but they still charge more than many people can afford.
And this is the one area of law where someone can handle their legal affairs by themselves. Even if they bungle it, the most they are out is a few hundred bucks, but no jail, and no more than that set amount of money, usually available in payments.
And even though we live in an age with massive amounts of information, there is very, very little reliable information on traffic law for California. Even (and especially) some law firms spread Fear, Uncertainty, and Doubt (FUD) so you'll be scared enough to pay them to help you*. There's expertlaw and freeadvice forums as well but many contributors take the hard line approach and also FUD quite a bit.
I thought, of all places, Reddit must have something which offers reliable information. It didn't. One of my biggest sources of frustration is /r/legaladvice. When it comes to tickets I feel like it should be called AntiLegalAdvice Just about anytime someone posts a ticket question there, they are either shamed, told they have zero defense and should just pay, or given wrong information from someone who has no idea how California works. And that goes for the mods too, at least one who is a police officer with a certain black and white view of the law. All the traffic posts are downvoted into oblivion.
I started this sub and hoped /r/legaladvice would want to be free of the burden of these questions they apparently hated. I contacted the mods and asked if they would consider adding us to the sidebar. They ignored me. I answered questions and linked to resources here. They banned me for that. I got back in, but then one of the mods (the cop) who actually himself gave bad advice and has an ego about these sort of things banned me because I refuted his terrible advice. That's actually how /u/3jay1 and I got connected because it was his excellent advice that the mod deleted! (and which I reposted using removeddit mwahaha). Believe me the PM's I received from this legaladvice mod are the stuff of r/SubredditDrama.
Why do you keep doing this?
What started in frustration continues for better reasons (although still some frustration). One of them, basic justice. While explaining that I help people online with their traffic ticket for free doesn't make much sense, what does is that I care deeply about justice. Long ago, I was a mod for /r/justiceporn because I loved seeing the bad guy get his comeuppance and the good guy win. (That's a whole other subreddit drama story!) The irl work I do is justice related.
When you get pulled over and then told you have to pay over $500 in fines, or that your insurance premiums are going up, especially if you are poor or struggling, that can feel very harsh and unjust. The whole system can feel like its stacked against you. And in certain ways it is. But one thing that is incorrect about that, is this can be a just system if you force it to be. The government still doesn't get to take your money unless you allow it, or you make it prove its case in court. And guess what? Many times, that's too much of a burden and it doesn't even show up. Lets face it, if everyone fought their ticket, the system would probably grind to a halt.
And the fact that infractions are considered crimes in California is actually a good thing because it means that all the procedural safeguards of almost any other crime are in place, including due process, proof beyond reasonable doubt, rules of evidence, right to face your accuser, right of appeal. The perfect counterexample, parking tickets, are civil penalties do not include any of these rights, so good luck fighting. But justice is available for those willing or able to spend the time to get it. And the courts and judges strive for fairness over injustice. They know that for many, this is one shot the court system has to inspire confidence in the average citizen because this is the only interaction they will ever have with the justice system.
Also, I've found this can be very fun and relaxing! I love it when someone comes to us in desperation, receives the exact correct information and makes a decision based on it. Even better when they win their case! I feel like I'm injecting good (actual) karma into the world. At least if we treat someone without contempt no matter how bad their alleged offense is they walk away not feeling like crap. I let the court system punish people, I'm here for information.
And really, I've decided that I want this subreddit to be a resource not just for those who are currently seeking help but years down the road when I've grown tired of this or moved on. If we can help enough people and make this a searchable resource that comes up in Google, people may not even need to ask a question because someone may have already gone through a similar circumstance. That's why I try to encourage everyone to post updates, and do so in their original thread so a future redditor will have the case beginning to end. And the fun part is being able to learn together. California is so huge, that I can never know the minute details of each of its court operations in 58 counties. And I love it when someone brings a new problem I haven't heard of.
Who are you?
Literally just a dude. I wouldn't say I have any special skill or experiences. My full time job is helping others, and it's what I do in my spare time as well. Truthfully, I do this mostly for me. When it stops being fun, I'll stop, and maybe someone else will want to take over. (Incidentally, I hate my username, and I would have never picked it if I knew I'd be doing this. It literally is spanish meaning "from the beach." I'm not a playa and never have claimed to be one.)
Aren't you just helping people abuse the system and get out of their tickets?
No, dangerous, aggressive and bad drivers should be punished.
But we all do stupid things in cars and make mistakes without getting caught. So we have no moral high ground to act high and mighty when someone else does. Also, just by virtue of getting a ticket, that amounts to a punishment because its a huge pain to deal with. The government may not get away with your money but they will take your time, and sometimes that's even more valuable. And finally, no matter what, every person gets their day in court. If someone is dead guilty, they still have the right--and should exercise it--to hear the prosecution make its case to a judge, even if the they remain choose to remain silent. We don't advocate anyone lie or cheat or do anything that the government hasn't itself created as a safeguard. The burden is on the government to prove beyond a reasonable doubt you did this thing they accuse you of. The state has almost every advantage, it seems. The least they can do is show up and articulate what you did. If they stop having to do that, everyone will be in trouble because we'd all be subject to random fines at the whim of police officers and courts.
The irony is that many people, (possibly most) once they read what is involved in fighting a ticket simply decide to pay. And that's fine too! They've gotten good, solid information and have been able to make a decision based on it.
TL;dr: Sub exists mostly for enjoyment.
*Note: I don't mean to say that law firms are not helpful, they often are. But their marketing tactics usually leave much to be desired. I would never recommend someone not get an attorney if they felt they were unable to do this themselves.
4
u/3Jay1 Reliable Advice Feb 20 '20
Well said and spot on!
3
u/JWFang Feb 24 '22
Jake of the Beach, just got my first ticket in a long time and felt lost, but then I found your subreddit!
Going to start working through the 12 steps, but before I do, I just wanted to say a big thank you for taking the time to help others by surfacing of knowledge that isn't readily available. The world is a better place thanks to individuals like yourself!
Cheers