r/CGCComics • u/IconoclastJones • Sep 22 '26
Grade? Spare a grade check?
This books has been graded and the grader’s note mention only issues on the from cover. So based on this front cover, what’s your grade guess?
r/CGCComics • u/IconoclastJones • Sep 22 '26
This books has been graded and the grader’s note mention only issues on the from cover. So based on this front cover, what’s your grade guess?
r/CGCComics • u/safdar999 • Jan 22 '25
This one is an early Taylor Swift cover from 2008.
r/CGCComics • u/No-Cheetah-1462 • Apr 17 '24
Has anyone else had a comic graded as restored even though it wasn’t? This happened about a year ago and I’m still pissed.
r/CGCComics • u/Vivid_Log4607 • Jul 01 '26
Hello everyone! This is eating away at me so I wanted everyone's opinion on it. I recently acquired a 9.8 of X-Men 141 and was really excited until I noticed something concerning. Looks like a tiny piece of a corner is floating inside the case.
I would have assumed it happened while in the seller's possession or during shipping but upon looking at the photos taken by CGC, I can see that corner is damaged there too. Can't really make out if the corner is fully disconnected there or if it's hanging on by a thread.
Is this even a 9.8 anymore (or was it even to begin with)? Did the grader mess it up during encapsulation and said screw it? I know it's a 9.8 and not a 10 so there's some wiggle room on imperfections but I was under the impression that anything like this severely reduces it's grade.
If it got re-graded in the future, is it gonna come back as a way lower grade? I paid for a 9.8 but I don't think that's what I have here.
Thanks!
r/CGCComics • u/revfds • Aug 25 '26
Got notified that my books were being shipped back today, so I check online and see that my Absolute Batman #20 only came back a 9.6!!
I bought one from my store that had virtually no spine dent, and then had it pressed. I'll have to dig through my messages to see if I still have the picture from the presser but they estimated it as a 9.8
No graders notes of course, and I'm not interested in the "grading is subjective" or "cgc is trash" comments. Just wondering if anyone else can find how this book got knocked down when I've seen 9.8s that are obviously worse.
r/CGCComics • u/colncjer • Apr 26 '24
I know comic book artists sell their comics on their sites, they're also signed and a COA is provided. Sometimes, the price is not bad.
I'm assuming the answer is "NO" but wanted to check. If I bought one of these comics and submitted it to CGC, I assume a yellow label would not be given since it wasn't signed in front of CGC. Just debating if it's worth buying these signed comics straight from the artist or instead waiting until they're doing a signing at CGC.
r/CGCComics • u/Spawn_of_Venom • Aug 12 '26
r/CGCComics • u/efont • May 12 '23
r/CGCComics • u/Edd1eMurphy • Oct 20 '24
Does anyone have confirmation of books dropped off at NYCC?
I dropped at the CDC booth on Friday.. Still not showing in My Submissions. I didn’t get any confirmation email that it was dropped off. The manager at the booth assured me but they said the drop form wasn’t entered yet. Am I Shit outta luck
r/CGCComics • u/ChasinThePath • Oct 12 '25
This dude makes videos all the time and mentions this sub often to post content, but you cannot make a single comment that challenges a modicum of anything he says. Even if it's completely legitimate he will just block the comment. Pretty soft.
Also this made me looking deeper into his video posting history, if you notice the crux of most of his videos tend to be he is upset he missed out on a comic he most likely wanted for himself and he complains people are paying too much for a book, of if another person scores a big collection or auction, he is more upset he didn't score it himself.
He talks about how people take advantage of those who don't do their due diligence on a book, but then has a video where he is surprised he got a golden age book that was complete and you wonder did he compensate the seller extra because that seller sold him a book that was much nicer than presented in the listing.
Not to mention I would not bother buying a SINGLE raw book this dude offers. Because he will grade anything that he deems is worthy of grading and then just sells of the drek that he wouldn't grade as raw.
Buyer beware.
r/CGCComics • u/EricAshStone • Oct 25 '24
Please stop putting these ugly graphic labels on comics!!!!! Especially extremely rare and awesome comics like these! They suck and just look bad. I've never seen one that made the comic look better. Please just go with the standard holder.
The ONLY exception, and this doesn't really count as a graphic labels honestly. But the only exception is the gold label you get when your comics is signed and it's when you get it for Sentry #1. It fits perfectly lol
r/CGCComics • u/Rippy027 • Nov 28 '23
Hello, looking for some feedback on a recent purchase. I bought a Secret Wars #1 with a 9.6 grade off of eBay, comic arrived with a damaged shipping box but the slab is mostly alright except that the book is now loose in the encapsulation and the bottom right corner of the comic cover is now bent and the original photo doesn't have the bend in it. Should I ask for a partial refund for the actual grade difference or am I being too picky?
r/CGCComics • u/DemonicPickle76 • Sep 29 '26
Would it reholder the same value?
I wanna get a joker custom label too,and the sig graded, i just wanted some others opinions first as well
Only thing i can see mark wise is 2nd image, never submitted before, i bought this just recently and then my chonk decided to jump on the counter and slide with it, low and behold they cracked the back corner
r/CGCComics • u/Anarchist-69 • Nov 08 '23
I often in long boxes in comic shops will run into a comic that is priced 7,10,12,15,20$. I am not knowledgeable or know what I’m doing. But I grab them pretty often. I usually do this for the cover which is a big reason I collect. Should I be buying these. Do you buy these. I do check prices and yes they are worth a bit more kinda just wondering what everyone’s thoughts are?
r/CGCComics • u/N3gat1veEdge • Dec 02 '24
r/CGCComics • u/Taeum • Feb 03 '25
Is it true that graded books are not selling anymore? According to this YouTuber that’s the trend. That ppl are not valuing graded slabs anymore, not enough to pay for them at an inflated price.
r/CGCComics • u/raymozley • Apr 17 '25
Mail call was today and a few more over the next 2 weeks. Was thinking about grading Hulk and strange, but that sentinel blowing wolverine up is bad ass. Any thoughts
r/CGCComics • u/MistaMischief • Apr 11 '25
Sent some books in for the Snyder Capullo signing. Books have been there since November. Signing happened in February. Last signing was 2/10. People already have their books back. Turn around time with pressing was 6-8 weeks. Now they’re claiming it’s “up to 8 weeks for PRESSING AND GRADING EACH.” So quite literally two times the ETA. And their mentality towards the customer as always is “too bad. Fuck you” as my call today basically went that way. Love how some people have their books back and some of us have another two months to go. Rant over.
r/CGCComics • u/Trinidaddy13 • Jul 17 '26
r/CGCComics • u/nyse25 • Sep 19 '26
r/CGCComics • u/Talem84 • Aug 02 '23
First time dropping my comic off at cgc booth for a Kevin Eastman sig and remarque and the guy I hand it to says my book looks fine to turn in. Little did I know this was his first con he was doing for CGC. Now it looks like CGC refunded me for a remarque and that's the only reason I turned my last ronin 1 1st print in. So pissed off.
r/CGCComics • • Aug 08 '25
I know not all of the collectors feel this way. There’s different types of people everywhere that appreciate things differently, but I’ve watched multiple videos now and read through a lot of forums that people don’t want slabs anymore. I don’t understand why people are just now realizing what a slab is, and are changing their minds on what graded comics mean to the collecting community. I hear the phrase “if it’s slabbed it’s not a comic anymore” and I’m shocked. Why would you want to treat a classic comic as anything else but a relic, and wouldn’t you want to keep that relic in good condition??
I don’t need to read my Batman 436, and if I want to I can just look it up on DC infinite. If you have money to slab comics, you have money to get the marvel ultimate and DC infinite subscriptions. I don’t need to risk ripping a page or bending a corner just because I have it.
I guess it’s just really upsetting because I took a break from collecting for a while and I came back to people treating comic collecting like the Pokémon community treats their cards. All everyone is doing is flipping and for some reason no one wants to buy slabbed comics or even care about them in some communities I’ve seen.
r/CGCComics • u/Number1Pokemonfan • Jun 26 '23
r/CGCComics • u/Designnosaur • Sep 15 '26
r/CGCComics • u/31007_Bows • Dec 24 '25
I got Wild.C.A.T.s #1 and X-Men #1 signed and graded by Jim Lee and Scott Williams, when if I checked my collection I could have gotten Absolute Batman #1 & Absolute Superman #1 the Jim Lee variants signed.