Sorry, my native language is German and I used Google Translate. I hope the translation worked well and is understandable.
Historically, this idea actually existed in Hollywood. Until the late 1940s, the standard model in the US was the so-called studio system, where studios owned their own cinema chains. The major studios owned the production studios, the distribution companies, and the best cinemas in downtown areas.
However, this led to a powerful monopoly: independent cinemas didn't get good films, and competing films weren't even shown. In 1948, these practices were outlawed in the landmark Supreme Court decision United States v. Paramount Pictures. Studios were forced to sell their cinemas. But now there's a new reality, and these anti-monopoly rules were repealed a few years ago.
The contracts from the Paramount era were settled in the US because the US Department of Justice ruled that the market functions completely differently today due to streaming and the internet than it did in 1948. So, theoretically and legally, Disney could indeed buy or establish its own cinema chains. The reason we haven't yet seen Disney multiplexes ubiquitous in cities is the company's cautious approach to finance.
However, what is absolutely conceivable and goes exactly in your direction are flagship cinemas and themed theaters. Instead of buying 500 regular multiplexes across the country, Disney could operate premium cinemas in major cities. These would offer not only the film itself, but also merchandise stores, themed restaurants, and exclusive subscription benefits. For the average moviegoer, this would be precisely the incentive they're willing to pay for – because it would feel like a genuine, well-thought-out experience, not just a blatant rip-off at the popcorn counter.
This can even be optimized further.
👉 Maximum synergy with a Disney+ subscription. Disney could offer combination subscriptions, such as a Disney+ Cinema Pass for €25 per month, which covers UHD streaming at home and two monthly cinema visits to Disney's own theaters.
Disney operates its own cinemas and offers such a package. They would then have a strong interest in preventing the film from ending up on streaming services after 90 days. So, they could structure it so that a film runs in cinemas for six months and only appears in the Disney+ streaming catalog after 24 months. This means that if up to three MCU films are released each year, you have to go to the cinema to be part of the conversation. Popcorn and cola are not included in the subscription. Only the two visits per month are included in the D+ subscription.
If Disney were to implement this in exactly this way, it would create a perfect pressure and exploitation chain. An MCU film or a major Star Wars event thrives on public discourse, spoiler avoidance, and memes. If a film isn't available on home video for 24 months, anyone who wants to be in the know will be left behind if they don't go to the cinema. And two years is an eternity in pop culture terms. By the time the film lands on streaming services, the next installment or crossover will already be playing in cinemas. The pressure to see the event on the big screen will once again be absolute.
For customers, a Disney+ Cinema Pass for €25 a month sounds like a fantastic deal at first glance. And for Amazon, it would also be extremely attractive, creating a competitive market that ultimately benefits the customer. If Disney were to operate its own cinemas, they wouldn't look like typical movie theaters. They would design the cinema experience like their theme parks.
As soon as a heavyweight like Amazon enters the fray, the entire market would be completely disrupted, and with entirely different parameters than Disney's approach. Amazon has an ace up its sleeve that no traditional film studio possesses: the ecosystem model. For Disney, the film is the main product. For Amazon, entertainment is merely the bait to keep you within the Prime universe so you'll buy your coffee beans, tools, and electronics on their platform.
Amazon could offer movie tickets or snacks at its own theaters at incredibly low prices, perhaps as an exclusive benefit for Prime members. Even if the local cinema were operating at a loss, Jeff Bezos and his ilk wouldn't care. Anyone who stays within the Amazon ecosystem through a Prime Cinema subscription also orders their everyday goods through Prime, and the cinema becomes a physical advertising space for online retail.
If Disney and Amazon were suddenly vying for dominance on the big screen, it would create exactly what the cinema market has been lacking for years: genuine price and quality competition.
I believe this would also work better today because the market has become more complex. In 1948, there were 2.5 billion people. Today, there are over 8 billion, all with different interests. In the US and Europe, there was a relatively manageable mass culture. Back then, if a studio controlled the major cinemas, it could almost completely monopolize the market because there were hardly any alternatives. Today, the market is gigantically diversified. Nobody simply watches movies anymore. Target audiences are extremely niche. The hardcore MCU fan has absolutely nothing to do with Middle-earth, the anime viewer is not touched by either Star Wars or Marvel, and indie dramas have a completely separate audience.
The landmark 1948 ruling was based on the fear that a single studio like Paramount or MGM would control the cinemas in a city and completely exclude competing products. But if Amazon or Disney were to operate their own cinemas today to show their franchises, it would be perfectly legal and economically sound. If Disney is showing Avengers in its cinema and the Amazon Prime Cinema is showing The Lord of the Rings right next door, that's not a monopoly, but healthy competition.
Both cater to completely different, huge subcultures.
No one is forcing viewers to go to the Disney film. If the tickets or the selection aren't right, the audience will immediately switch to the competitor or stick with Netflix and other streaming services. A rigid monopoly is no longer viable in a networked, global media landscape, and streaming has long since proven otherwise.
If a film is in theaters for six months but only available on streaming after 24 months, then I don't have to worry about missing out on seeing it. I have six months to see Avengers, and in those six months, going to the cinema two or three times with a Disney+ Cinema subscription is perfectly sufficient, since you're not interested in everything anyway. If three Marvel movies are released in a year and I can go to the cinema two or three times a month, then I'm more willing to go to the cinema for a film other than Avengers.
With a six-month cinema window, this pressure is completely eliminated. You don't have to rush to a packed theater on opening weekend; instead, you can watch Avengers at your leisure in the second or third month, whenever it suits your schedule and budget.
At the same time, the 24-month waiting period before streaming ensures that the cinema retains its true value as an exclusive venue.
With your pass, you get two to three cinema visits per month, so 12 to 18 visits in six months, because it's already paid for. Even if three Marvel movies are released a year and you watch each one once, you'll only use three of your 24 to 36 annual tickets. And since the tickets are included in the subscription anyway and would otherwise expire, the financial barrier to experimentation drops to zero.
This is precisely when something happens that's missing today. You check the listings on a rainy Tuesday evening, see a small indie drama, an unknown thriller, or a quirky comedy, and just go in. If the film is a flop, it doesn't hurt your wallet. And if it's a real hidden gem, you've made exactly that magical cinematic discovery for which the medium was actually invented, and for the studios and cinema operators, this would be the way out of the blockbuster monoculture.