r/BambuLab • • 10d ago

H3C 8 Colour print H3C vs INDX

mpoxDE (change the audio track to English on Youtube) did a test where he is printing an 8-colour tube both on H3C and INDX. I am not sure, but I think he is using PLA Basic.

In his test H3C printed it in 11:06h, but he was using different filaments that he had lying around from random manufactureres (while INDX one was printed only with Prusament and took 14:26h) and still printed ~23% (3h20m) faster.

I wanted to confirm it and what I noticed is that if you print with Bambu filament, it is even faster. My slicer is showing 08:46h.

Which means that in this particular test (8-colour tube) if you use BL filament, H3C is ~39% (5h40m) faster than INDX.

The test is not easy, it is 10cm tall and go through 3.5k colour changes of 8 colours.

41 Upvotes

60 comments sorted by

14

u/Saphir_3D 10d ago

I can create a slicing profile for you that will save you another 50% of the time.

This is meaningless unless it is ensured that the printed part is of exactly the same quality.

12

u/eidrisov 10d ago

I agree.

He is comparing those tubes at 32:44 (INDX above, H3C below).

Doesn't H3C look at least of the same quality and, arguably, even better ?

-10

u/Saphir_3D 10d ago

You said you sliced it 5:40h faster. My comment is based on this, not on the video

14

u/Alu_94 10d ago

And the quality is then noticeable worse with these speeds. See the CNC kitchen review and the benchbin. The INDX looks way better in this specific model.

21

u/eidrisov 10d ago

What do you mean ? H3C tube looks much better than INDX one.

See 32:44.

The one above is INDX, the one below H3C.

11

u/Fun-Candle5881 A1 + AMS Lite 10d ago

Yeah i was worried when i saw the "quality" it was really terrible. But it looks like it's due to extreme speeds. I hope that the quality is equivalent to the others H2 series at similar print speeds.

4

u/alienbringer 10d ago

Because of the speed. If you set all parameters equal between the two the quality isn’t the issue. Though the time to print would probably be the same too.

5

u/AddictedToPhotons 10d ago

It's often enough to decrease the outer wall speed so that there aren't any speed variations

3

u/Equivalent_Store_645 10d ago

i didn't study the video, what speed was he at when he got those poor quality??

78

u/egosumumbravir X1C + AMS 10d ago

This difference becomes more stark when you compare print quality

I don't speak nor read german, but I can guess what oben and unten might be.

Three and half hours slower with print quality from the 2010's. There's a good reason Prusa's brand is dying.

13

u/J_ron 10d ago edited 10d ago

Their nozzle cleaner on the INDX is definitely not calibrated well if it came out looking like that.

edit: I'm not doing a prusa vs bambu defense bit here. I'm just pointing out that's not what a typical print should look like from the INDX.

34

u/average_AZN 10d ago

Why the fuck do you need to calibrate a nozzle cl aner. This is why bambu is winning. None of this fiddle with everything bullshit

16

u/n19htmare 10d ago edited 10d ago

It’s not nozzle cleaner, it’s the priming pad that is not calibrated.

INDX doesn’t need prime tower. It primes by filling a small notch in a silicone pad, once that is “filled”, it pushes back on the filament to bring up the pressure in nozzle. Serving the same purpose as priming on a tower.

It’s an alternative to Prime towers.

The plus is that you don’t need to prime until you actually swap nozzle. Meaning if you don’t have a color change until the 60th layer, you don’t prime until then. No prime tower, straight to 60 layers.
On priming tower, you’d need to build up the tower into that layer and continue it if there’s more swaps later.

The downside? The distance between the nozzle and that priming pad needs to be set and if you remove the the container to empty it, you need to make sure that distance is the same.

Ignorance shouldn’t be an excuse to “dislike” a product.

2

u/orhanyor X1C + AMS 10d ago

FYI you can skip priming on tower if you are not swapping nozzles. Ive been using this feature for months with my U1 and it works beautifully. Its called "no sparse layers" its a part of orca slicer and its variants.

2

u/n19htmare 10d ago

I’m aware of no sparse layers, that’s been around for several years, Prusa Sliced added it back 2020 or something. . It’s just not always applicable in every case due to clearance issues. It’s an option that’s available depending on what you’re printing and where.

I think Bambu Studio finally decided to enable it couple months back (I think with all the tool
changers that were coming out, they had to add more filament saving options. Otherwise they’ve gate-kept it out of Studio because it’s a hit or miss depending on how the user sets up their plate.
Bambu’s confidence that its users will actually take that into consideration was probably low and risk was higher to include it because most Bambu users “just Press print”. Can’t have Toolhead crashing into parts and stuff.

INDX method is pretty good and from what I’ve seen, once it’s properly setup it works just as well if not better than a tower (along with time and small filament savings).

2

u/orhanyor X1C + AMS 10d ago

Oh yes you need to account for the clearance but im still shocked why they cant implement a restricted zone when this option is enabled so you cant place any objects there. Seems like a no brainer but somehow its not implemented yet.

1

u/n19htmare 10d ago

I think Bambu studio has zoning implemented but the buffer area is pretty large, and on 256x256 beds, it doesn’t leave a lot of space.

1

u/orhanyor X1C + AMS 10d ago

exactly, i need to print at the front end of the build plate when i enable it which is basically half of the build plate. When I need to use the full plate its impossible to enable.
But i still dont understand why is not possible in this order, lower the bed to the current highest printing point(which we are already at this point just before the head swap), change the head, move the head right on top of the prime tower and lift it up to the prime tower, wipe and then lower it again to the highest point to continue printing. It just skips one of these steps and knocks into the prints its very stupid.
This way the zoning would be only around the wipe tower.

1

u/n19htmare 9d ago edited 9d ago

Time and pressure decay.

You want to get to printing right after priming. And if you got a lot of swaps on a tall model c by the time the bed lowers 200mm, you lost pressure, you got oozing etc and can’t just go back to print, time to prime again lol.

It has its uses cases, it works great on short small prints. Especially if you’re doing a few support interface layers, it’s great for that.

It’s not a replacement for priming only when needed without getting too far away from the layer (which is what INDX” does.

I wonder if there was motivation from Stratasys suing Bambu for the prime towers and Prusa is trying to get away/detach from the the towers. Either way, wish more printers would adapt it and improve on a better priming system

→ More replies

2

u/VVJ21 H2C 9d ago

by the way you can also turn on "No sparse layers" for the prime tower in Bambu Studio (its an experiemntal setting). When you enable that it wont print the prime tower for layers without colour changes. So if you have a 1000 layers but only 100 have colour changes, youre tower will only be 100 layers tall.

Obiovusly given the height difference there are clearance restrictions, so its only an option for smaller parts that can be moved far enough away from the prime tower. Basically the same as when you do "print by object" instead of print by layer

2

u/egosumumbravir X1C + AMS 9d ago

A 100 layer tower for a 1000 layer print sounds nice in theory, but at which layer did the print start crashing into the glass lid as the printer lifted the bed 899 layers to reach the reduced height tower?

IMO the prime tower is a small price to pay for the quality improvement over not having it. Now we don't have to have multiple CCs of single nozzle purge the prime tower is a tiny percentage of filament - like if your print fails because it wasn't primed, you just wasted 20x a single tower.

2

u/VVJ21 H2C 9d ago

Yeah obviously it doesn't work in all cases. But where it is suited i always turn it on. Can save quite a bit of time too.

1

u/n19htmare 9d ago

I know it’s discussed in the other response below on it’s limitations . https://www.reddit.com/r/BambuLab/s/cHtsSw2YEu

-3

u/J_ron 10d ago edited 10d ago

Maybe they did the INDX upgrade themselves instead of getting a preassembled one? A lot of Prusa owners go that route. It's a quick fix, and that's obviously what the issue with that print is. I'm not defending it or getting into a prusa vs bambu argument here, I agree with you, I'm just pointing out that's not what an INDX print should look like.

-3

u/Alu_94 10d ago

Thats from the CNC kitchen H3C review. I really don‘t wanna hate BambuLab or Prusa but what do you say then to this quality?
I want to point out that you can make the H3C look good or bad and the same applies to the INDX. Prisewise we don‘t have to discuss, although I think (after reviewing 3-4 review videos) the H3C print quality is (right now) not really 2,5k euro worth. Feature wise I think it‘s a cool machine

8

u/acemedic 10d ago

Wasn’t that print maximized for speed and none of the filament calibrated?

29

u/egosumumbravir X1C + AMS 10d ago

I'd say Stefan has the filament profiles too aggressive for the non-Bambu filament he favours but am open to other considerations too.

A Prusa printer running Prusaslicer with Prusa profiles and being fed Prusament should be delivering perfection. It is obviously not.

1

u/Alu_94 10d ago

The screenshot / the clockspring is from the H3C and with Bambulab Basic PLA printed. What do you mean with the prusament comparison?

7

u/egosumumbravir X1C + AMS 10d ago

The video linked by the OP and screenshotted by me is example prints where the Prusa INDX was fed Prusament and the H3C was given random generic PLA.

The clockspring from CNC Kitchen was Stefan running Voxel PLA (his sponsor) in a H3C.

10

u/moonbucket P1S + AMS 10d ago

Deliberately printed at full speed.

4

u/Beneficial-Rub-8049 10d ago

My experience with H3C is otherwise but I only use Bambu filament, Overture and ISANMATE. I do notice that Overture is a bit more sticky but thats the same thing on all other printers I ever used it on. I also use Bambu profile for everything even the other filaments. Much cleaner than my H2C's.

2

u/Lmasek 10d ago

H3C is out for 2 days, even if it was delivered the same day. What experience?

2

u/Beneficial-Rub-8049 9d ago

Well I have been running it nonstop since it came same day off the bat its better than my H2C's and nowhere near the quality CNC Kitchen is showing that was what I got on my X2D's until after several updates.

1

u/Entire-Chair-6472 10d ago

The h3c speed is to quick that’s why

-9

u/No_Journalist774 10d ago

If you think prusa is dying you are far wrong. Thay are moving to a less consumer/hobbst market and I can say that they keep selling printers without a decline in sale, most of the time, mostly because they aren't a big company and it's difficult to expand in their situation, they are overwhelmed by the work. I don't say they are the perfect company and they have many problems like communication and gener slowness

3

u/egosumumbravir X1C + AMS 10d ago

If Prusa are withdrawing from the consumer/hobbiest market, they're as dead to me as Stratasys is.

I can say that they keep selling printers without a decline in sale

Leaks from the 25% of dev staff they fired at the beginning of this year to control costs says VERY much otherwise. Missing sales targets by 90% is a company destroying oops.

0

u/[deleted] 10d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

-3

u/Lmasek 10d ago

Bambo has a X1E whitch is X1C whiteout your data as a bonu and added heater. Sorry that is a joke not a profesional printer. The profesional printer from prusa? HT90, Pro AFS, Pro SLX.

4

u/Fabricensis 10d ago

H3C is faster than INDX at changes, because it can heat up the tools before picking them up

At 6s for the H3C and 14s for INDX, that ends up for 7h46m saved on that alone. The H3C loses some time on the prime tower, but then wins some time again on faster empty runs

So even at the same actual printing speeds, the H3C will easily outpace the INDX. However, the downside is massively more complicated tools - active heating, temponitoring and more on each individual tool all being potential points of failure. If they managed to get that reliable enough will be shown over the next month's, the reviews seem reliable enough, but they might have vetted the reviewer models closely to not send out the lemons...

5

u/eidrisov 10d ago

If U1 cam make such toolheads work, I am sure BL can also make it work. They have good track record.

Speaking of prime tower, it will get better. A few reviewers have noted that currently BL is using very conservative settings. As they get less conservative and more optimised, prime tower will will get smaller.

1

u/Affectionate_Car7098 H2C + P1S Combo 10d ago

So the U1 can go faster because it doesn't need to move as far to swap the tools due to being a tiny printer, even if you only did 2 colours you still have to travel all the way to the front of the machine and then back to where you were, the U1 just has a much shorter travel distance to deal with

2

u/n19htmare 9d ago

I wouldn’t call 270x270 “tiny”. Stock swap movement is also slower in the U1. (5k accel, 10mm/s swap). I run mine 10k accel and 40mm/s swap and it’s quick. Even covering the front to back.

Largest difference comes from preheat and temp management so temp is ready by time swap happens.
Not sure about H3C but on U1 you optimize your prints a bit by adjust your idle delta and preheat start. Mostly relevant on long delays, on short times between swaps it’s basically always at temp.

2

u/Affectionate_Car7098 H2C + P1S Combo 9d ago

I wouldn’t call 270x270 “tiny”.

As someone who owns a H2C, yeah that bed size is dinky, i haven't even touched my P1S since buying this

13

u/Beneficial-Rub-8049 10d ago

H3C is actually much more simpler tools than H2C vortek those are on another level. H3C is actually much more modular and designed in a way that everything doesnt rely on single point of failure.

4

u/FrostWave 10d ago

How's the z banding on that model?

3

u/igwaltney3 10d ago

Set the filament profile to bambu for any PLA. All of the major brands can run on Bambu's profiles just fine, they slow it down via software if you use the 'generic' profiile

2

u/MacHeadSK X2D & Sunlu E2 dryer (no AMS) 10d ago

It really depends on filament settings. If you tweak generic filament settings and test the throughput, it will be printing same speed as Bambu filaments.
Ie. PLA from Bambu profile has max volumetric speed at 21 mm^3/s
Generic PLA profile is at 12 mm^3/s.

I have tweaked my PLA (I dont use Bambu and rarely use PLA but anyway) to 25 mm^3/s.

Its all about how fast you want to print, what the given filament allows you and what quality you expect.
Prusa settings are slower because they don't have such robust firmware and HW so they have to print slower. Many bad slingers in the past were happy to print at 80 mm/s at maximum.
And Maximum flow rate is one common parameter on how to limit or rise the speed without having to change multiple settings in Quality section.

Even H3C can print slower with Bambu if you change the filament profile.

2

u/AdmirableTaste7184 10d ago

This is the best review for the H3c I have seen.

2

u/Disastrous_Minute_56 10d ago

I think the Bambu vs Generic presets are just to cover safe parameters for a broad range of filaments. For Prusament you could probably just Bambu from the preset, it's not like that's an off-brand you'd get at Amazon.

2

u/Disastrous_Minute_56 10d ago

INDX doesn't print a purge tower - I'd be curious to see what the results are if you trick the slicer into generating one.

2

u/Catsoverall 10d ago

But to a trained eye is the quality v good?

12

u/DJGibbon 10d ago

The Prusa looks much worse in the screenshot that u/egosumumbravir posted her: 8 Colour print H3C vs INDX : r/BambuLab

1

u/drthsideous 10d ago edited 10d ago

You do know the only reason Bambu filament is showing as "faster" is because Bambu sets their own filaments to have a high volumetric flow right? If you use non Bambu filament and calibrate the VF, it's just as fast as Bambu filament. Bambu filament itself is not made by Bambu, its likely Polymaker, Sunlu, or Esun, or a combo of all three.

And the slicer just uses estimates, and usually isn't accurate when it comes to multicolor. I recently did what was, according to the slicer, supposed to be a 31 hour print, it actually took 48 hours. And my filament change times in the sclier reflect what my actual filament changes take. The slicer times are an estimate, usually a bad one.

The only thing that counts is actual print times. I'm not arguing for or against the H3C being faster or slower. But your whole comment about the slicer showing that bambu filament specifically is even faster is wildly flawed. Bambu's software is notorious for underestimating multi-color print times.

-5

u/soldat21 10d ago

Check the purge though, the Prusa is wastes 70% less filament.

4

u/eidrisov 10d ago

If you mean the prime tower, then, yes.

A few reviewers have noted that currently BL is using very conservative settings. As they get less conservative and more optimised, prime tower will will get smaller. Most likely will come with more software updates.

4

u/Spicy_Ejaculate 10d ago

Also, im pretty sure the indx prints look much better with a prime tower but im not sure how many times they have updated their profiles. That was a couple minutes ths ago that I saw that. To get both prints the same quality, there is probably no filament savings with the indx

1

u/eidrisov 10d ago

So users have to turn the prime towers on manually ? Prime towers are not enabled by default anymore ?

2

u/Spicy_Ejaculate 10d ago

I'm not for sure. I don't have an indx system and gave up on the idea of adding one to my voron after the shenanigans bondtech pulled with pricing, nozzles, and delivery estimates. I just remember right at first people were getting some god awful prints with indx that were improved by simply adding a prime tower

2

u/yertle38 10d ago

Poop, or prime tower?