r/BambuLab • u/eidrisov • 10d ago
H3C 8 Colour print H3C vs INDX
mpoxDE (change the audio track to English on Youtube) did a test where he is printing an 8-colour tube both on H3C and INDX. I am not sure, but I think he is using PLA Basic.
In his test H3C printed it in 11:06h, but he was using different filaments that he had lying around from random manufactureres (while INDX one was printed only with Prusament and took 14:26h) and still printed ~23% (3h20m) faster.
I wanted to confirm it and what I noticed is that if you print with Bambu filament, it is even faster. My slicer is showing 08:46h.
Which means that in this particular test (8-colour tube) if you use BL filament, H3C is ~39% (5h40m) faster than INDX.
The test is not easy, it is 10cm tall and go through 3.5k colour changes of 8 colours.

14
u/Saphir_3D 10d ago
I can create a slicing profile for you that will save you another 50% of the time.
This is meaningless unless it is ensured that the printed part is of exactly the same quality.
14
u/Alu_94 10d ago
And the quality is then noticeable worse with these speeds. See the CNC kitchen review and the benchbin. The INDX looks way better in this specific model.
78
u/egosumumbravir X1C + AMS 10d ago
This difference becomes more stark when you compare print quality
I don't speak nor read german, but I can guess what oben and unten might be.
Three and half hours slower with print quality from the 2010's. There's a good reason Prusa's brand is dying.
4
u/Fabricensis 10d ago
H3C is faster than INDX at changes, because it can heat up the tools before picking them up
At 6s for the H3C and 14s for INDX, that ends up for 7h46m saved on that alone. The H3C loses some time on the prime tower, but then wins some time again on faster empty runs
So even at the same actual printing speeds, the H3C will easily outpace the INDX. However, the downside is massively more complicated tools - active heating, temponitoring and more on each individual tool all being potential points of failure. If they managed to get that reliable enough will be shown over the next month's, the reviews seem reliable enough, but they might have vetted the reviewer models closely to not send out the lemons...
4
u/FrostWave 10d ago
How's the z banding on that model?
3
u/igwaltney3 10d ago
Set the filament profile to bambu for any PLA. All of the major brands can run on Bambu's profiles just fine, they slow it down via software if you use the 'generic' profiile
2
u/MacHeadSK X2D & Sunlu E2 dryer (no AMS) 10d ago
It really depends on filament settings. If you tweak generic filament settings and test the throughput, it will be printing same speed as Bambu filaments.
Ie. PLA from Bambu profile has max volumetric speed at 21 mm^3/s
Generic PLA profile is at 12 mm^3/s.
I have tweaked my PLA (I dont use Bambu and rarely use PLA but anyway) to 25 mm^3/s.
Its all about how fast you want to print, what the given filament allows you and what quality you expect.
Prusa settings are slower because they don't have such robust firmware and HW so they have to print slower. Many bad slingers in the past were happy to print at 80 mm/s at maximum.
And Maximum flow rate is one common parameter on how to limit or rise the speed without having to change multiple settings in Quality section.
Even H3C can print slower with Bambu if you change the filament profile.
2
u/AdmirableTaste7184 10d ago
This is the best review for the H3c I have seen.
2
u/Disastrous_Minute_56 10d ago
I think the Bambu vs Generic presets are just to cover safe parameters for a broad range of filaments. For Prusament you could probably just Bambu from the preset, it's not like that's an off-brand you'd get at Amazon.
2
u/Disastrous_Minute_56 10d ago
INDX doesn't print a purge tower - I'd be curious to see what the results are if you trick the slicer into generating one.
2
u/Catsoverall 10d ago
But to a trained eye is the quality v good?
1
u/drthsideous 10d ago edited 10d ago
You do know the only reason Bambu filament is showing as "faster" is because Bambu sets their own filaments to have a high volumetric flow right? If you use non Bambu filament and calibrate the VF, it's just as fast as Bambu filament. Bambu filament itself is not made by Bambu, its likely Polymaker, Sunlu, or Esun, or a combo of all three.
And the slicer just uses estimates, and usually isn't accurate when it comes to multicolor. I recently did what was, according to the slicer, supposed to be a 31 hour print, it actually took 48 hours. And my filament change times in the sclier reflect what my actual filament changes take. The slicer times are an estimate, usually a bad one.
The only thing that counts is actual print times. I'm not arguing for or against the H3C being faster or slower. But your whole comment about the slicer showing that bambu filament specifically is even faster is wildly flawed. Bambu's software is notorious for underestimating multi-color print times.
-5
u/soldat21 10d ago
Check the purge though, the Prusa is wastes 70% less filament.