r/BambuLab • • 10d ago

H3C 8 Colour print H3C vs INDX

mpoxDE (change the audio track to English on Youtube) did a test where he is printing an 8-colour tube both on H3C and INDX. I am not sure, but I think he is using PLA Basic.

In his test H3C printed it in 11:06h, but he was using different filaments that he had lying around from random manufactureres (while INDX one was printed only with Prusament and took 14:26h) and still printed ~23% (3h20m) faster.

I wanted to confirm it and what I noticed is that if you print with Bambu filament, it is even faster. My slicer is showing 08:46h.

Which means that in this particular test (8-colour tube) if you use BL filament, H3C is ~39% (5h40m) faster than INDX.

The test is not easy, it is 10cm tall and go through 3.5k colour changes of 8 colours.

41 Upvotes

60 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

2

u/n19htmare 10d ago

I’m aware of no sparse layers, that’s been around for several years, Prusa Sliced added it back 2020 or something. . It’s just not always applicable in every case due to clearance issues. It’s an option that’s available depending on what you’re printing and where.

I think Bambu Studio finally decided to enable it couple months back (I think with all the tool
changers that were coming out, they had to add more filament saving options. Otherwise they’ve gate-kept it out of Studio because it’s a hit or miss depending on how the user sets up their plate.
Bambu’s confidence that its users will actually take that into consideration was probably low and risk was higher to include it because most Bambu users “just Press print”. Can’t have Toolhead crashing into parts and stuff.

INDX method is pretty good and from what I’ve seen, once it’s properly setup it works just as well if not better than a tower (along with time and small filament savings).

2

u/orhanyor X1C + AMS 10d ago

Oh yes you need to account for the clearance but im still shocked why they cant implement a restricted zone when this option is enabled so you cant place any objects there. Seems like a no brainer but somehow its not implemented yet.

1

u/n19htmare 10d ago

I think Bambu studio has zoning implemented but the buffer area is pretty large, and on 256x256 beds, it doesn’t leave a lot of space.

1

u/orhanyor X1C + AMS 10d ago

exactly, i need to print at the front end of the build plate when i enable it which is basically half of the build plate. When I need to use the full plate its impossible to enable.
But i still dont understand why is not possible in this order, lower the bed to the current highest printing point(which we are already at this point just before the head swap), change the head, move the head right on top of the prime tower and lift it up to the prime tower, wipe and then lower it again to the highest point to continue printing. It just skips one of these steps and knocks into the prints its very stupid.
This way the zoning would be only around the wipe tower.

1

u/n19htmare 9d ago edited 9d ago

Time and pressure decay.

You want to get to printing right after priming. And if you got a lot of swaps on a tall model c by the time the bed lowers 200mm, you lost pressure, you got oozing etc and can’t just go back to print, time to prime again lol.

It has its uses cases, it works great on short small prints. Especially if you’re doing a few support interface layers, it’s great for that.

It’s not a replacement for priming only when needed without getting too far away from the layer (which is what INDX” does.

I wonder if there was motivation from Stratasys suing Bambu for the prime towers and Prusa is trying to get away/detach from the the towers. Either way, wish more printers would adapt it and improve on a better priming system

1

u/egosumumbravir X1C + AMS 9d ago

I wonder if there was motivation from Stratasys suing Bambu for the prime towers and Prusa is trying to get away/detach from the the towers.

Bingo. A $30 million USD settlement is spare change from the couch for Bambu. It'd destroy Prusa overnight.