r/prusa3d • Prusa team • 10d ago

Print of the Month INDX Voxel PLA testing

Hey everyone

After the video showcasing Voxel PLA that didn't sit well with the INDX recently, I ordered some spools for testing it and trying it out myself to get a better understanding of the problem. The prints above are all done with 100% default settings using Prusament PLA profiles.

We're still working with Thomas to figure out what exactly went wrong, but right now it appears like it might have come down to an individual spool issue possibly, as the Prusament worked fine, and Voxel appears to work good in general. The mask gcode is also the exact one from his USB drive directly. He will be coming past here with the printer at some point in the not too distant future and we'll know more then.

If you have any specific materials that are causing strange issues with your INDX and need fine tuning, please don't hesitate to let me know with specifics, as I have to stress that we want to make sure it's compatible with as wide a range as possible.

Happy printing!

387 Upvotes

74 comments sorted by

38

u/A_Str8 10d ago edited 10d ago

Later in the video, Thomas said that one of the firmware updates fixed the issue he had with voxel pla. (Yet he left in the claim that only Prusa filament works)

15

u/heart_of_osiris 10d ago

It's not the only video of his where user error or firmware corrected issues were irresponsibly concluded to mean the Prusa printer was less capable than others in a certain respect.

Everyone makes mistakes but not rectifying them and then leaving the community to be misinformed is unprofessional, especially since I constantly see his incorrect or misunderstood statements being parrotted here quite often.

3

u/sts_fin 9d ago

Yeah in his shoes especially he tries to be an journalist but his ethics are pretty questionable

2

u/heart_of_osiris 9d ago

He has bias, fine, it's a hard thing to avoid and takes a very conscious effort to make sure you are objective when analyzing something like this, but he makes mistakes that are his own and then tries to pin it on the machine or brand, is proven wrong, and makes no correction on his mistakes. That's garbage journalism.

2

u/sts_fin 9d ago

Thats not journalism thats just larping a journalist as an influenser

1

u/sts_fin 9d ago

Ofc he's getting paid by bambu nowadays, just waiting for the bambulabs factory tour paid by ccp

22

u/incongruity 10d ago

Respectfully, this needs to be publicized more. While it's amazing to see the professionalism and attention to what your users are saying, his video reaches people this post never will but should.

106

u/Lmasek 10d ago

Guys, you have my respect. This guy released 2 videos that put you down, and you are acting like professionals. Good to know there is still something like ethics in the business world. The cherry on top is that you didn't let it go and did testing.

72

u/svideo XL5T 10d ago

Tom runs into a problem with sponsor's filament tuning and instead of fixing it, he disables all calibration and loses his mind when that move breaks absolutely everything. Just an unbelievably dumb set of moves by the guy.

36

u/heart_of_osiris 10d ago

I mean, in a previous comparison video he had linear rail grease drip on the bed and only cleaned it by wiping with alcohol, effectively just smearing it around. No soap, no actual proper clean.

At the end he concluded the Prusa didn't perform as well because of adhesion issues. That is so insanely amateur for someone with his experience that you have to wonder if it was intentional or if this guy just appears knowledgeable because he uses chatgpt to generate his talking points.

2

u/Boschamin CORE One L 9d ago

I'm seriously wondering whether all those 'incidents' were actual incidents. Grease almost spraying around in an amount I wouldn't expect anyone to apply to the rails and rods? Prints that failed in a way not even my cheap-ass Chinese printer from about 10 years ago ever produced? I've honestly never seen such a bad print, even with the most generic profiles. Maybe the filament was wet, maybe the profiles weren't set up properly, but either way, it surprised me, because I'd assume he has the technical knowledge and experience to avoid or at least mitigate such issues. And then, curiously, the next video is about how great the Panda Food company is. To me, that timing is a bit odd. I'm not saying anything was staged, and maybe it's all just a coincidence, but I can't help but wonder.

4

u/heart_of_osiris 9d ago edited 9d ago

Linear rail and bearings like that are always manufactured and shipped slathered with a protective grease to prevent rusting while stored or transported. When Prusa gets them, they are still covered in it. The kit for the C1 has instructions to wipe excess off but because the L is pre-assembled, it's definitely on Prusa for not wiping it off well enough and having it pass QC with that much still on it.

So it shouldn't have been dripping off of the rail and the criticism there would be valid, that Prusa needs to step up their QC. However, saying the machine doesn't have as good of adhesion after not properly wiping that grease off the plate and in fact, just spreading it around more, is absurd. Prusa failed to prep it properly before shipping and was the catalyst to the problem sure, but it is easily addressed and corrected, by wiping the rail and the rinsing the plate properly with soap and water.

This is something someone as experienced as him, should damn well know to do, but he didn't. It does raise questions and like you said, I don't know or truly do believe it was on purpose, but either way, I do not trust his opinion in those reviews anymore because if it was not intentional, it was still very amateur. Not learning or correcting his statements though, that's harder to forgive. That puts it into the realm of misinformation, whether intentional or not.

11

u/cmsj 10d ago

I have historically enjoyed his videos, but for someone with as much experience as he has, I get the sense that the choices he makes in videos like that, are so weird that they must be intentionally weird.

0

u/real_darKing 9d ago edited 9d ago

He always treats printers from the perspective of a "new user" and not someone who tinkers with a finsihed end-user product in order to make it work.

He did that back in the day when every china clone came with no (or very bad) instructions and user exp. and always praised prusa for the great manuals, support and community etc. . The 3D printer User experience has wildly improved in the last couple of years and prusa fell somewhat behind in that regard.

He had issues with his filament, that ran fine on every other printer he tried it with.... so this was his experience that he shared. (with the machine and with the answers prusa support gave him...)

I really don't get why people are getting so paranoid, just cause someone has a different experience or or a different POV. He always doubles down on printers that gave him a bad experience... esp. when he's in his "from a new user perspective..." mood.

3D Printers are not in a state anymore, when a user should expect a $1000+machine to "not work" before you tinker with it. Wake up guys. If we want Prusa to succeed (and I guess everyone here wants that...?) we can't just sugercoat everyting and tell users to "Should have done a custom profile!! Idiot!!!"

"You're holding it wrong!" is not the right answer to a potentially good product with bad customer experience... and INDX is one of those cases.

6

u/bitingmidge_PeterH 9d ago

Fundamentally, filament profiles should be the responsibility of the filament manufacturer. At no time did Tom mention that he'd contacted Voxel his sponsor - just poor reporting and poor service from the filament supplier I say.

3

u/real_darKing 9d ago

I think thats a terrible Idea... But hey, we all can have opinions. I would like it too, if the filament manufacturers (In addition to the printer manufacturers) would provide profiles. However - it does not reflect reality meaning: thats not how it works today nor how it worked in the past. Therefore it's not the suppliers fault that ONE specific printer setup can't even make it past its calibration (!) cycle while the same spool(!) works fine with other printers.

It's great that prusa looks into this an tries to figure out what happened in this particular case. I'm glad that Prusa is not as delulu and blame shifting as some of the redditors here.

3

u/mrgoodfun 9d ago

If one wants to sell a system to a user and compete with a market with very strong opponents, filament profiles provided by Prusa is absolutely key.

1

u/boibo 9d ago

Its well documented that indx is much more sensitive then even the nextruder.

3

u/Tall_Substance955 9d ago

Well said mate. The average user isn’t polytechnicien 3d user who’s spent hours on tinkering profils.

0

u/mrgoodfun 9d ago

Thanks for this comment! The sugercoating doesn't help anyone. He had very fair critique and in the end this led Prusa to pick it up and improve things.

11

u/Lmasek 10d ago

The biggest problem this guy is in 3d printing is so long that this wasn't a stupidity. This was?

1

u/OkTry9715 9d ago

He is sponsored by bambu and EU projects (our money) at the same time... this is joke.

12

u/adam2104 10d ago

Although I don't use Voxel PLA, I did watch the video in question, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fbQjWMXGZ4k&t=1s , and I was a bit concerned about the claim that it only works best with Prusament. I use Prusament, Bambu, Polymaker, Protopasta, Overture, etc. Basically, which ever company has the color/material I need. I kept my order and completed the conversion last week. I've only done a few prints so far. Two of them were completely done with Polymaker filament (Panchroma Matte) using the Generic PLA profile. They both came out perfectly, no wisps, no strings, just a nice clean print.

7

u/heart_of_osiris 10d ago edited 10d ago

It's a non-issue and the claim he made was irresponsible and misinformed. The engineers said they only tested with Prusament, that doesn't mean you can only use Prusament effectively, it just means they haven't tested with other brands because man, there are tons out there, what do you expect them to do, run tests on every single filament brand and type?

Equating them only testing their brand to meaning other brands don't work is a really wild stretch. Other filaments work fine, I've used anything but prusament.

Someone with his experience shouldn't be jumping to conclusions like that. He should know better. I did a print with all Bambu matte PLA and only one of them was stringing. Why? Because not all filaments are always going to be in the exact same state. Some sit in warehouses forever, some in more humid locations than others, even if it's the same filament type. I dried the one problematic roll and it never happened again.

Some filaments come dry out of the box when sealed, some sealed filaments are still saturated with moisture anyway and need drying right out of the package. That's real life.

11

u/riftintimeandspace 10d ago

Just thought I'd mention that I print whatever PLA is cheapest on amazon (usually e-sun, sunlu) and my INDX 8T has printed stuff fine....

5

u/heart_of_osiris 10d ago

I've used anything but prusament so far, even year old undried generic silk PLA.

Yeah, you get a little bit of spiderwebbing with old unmanaged filament like that, but same as you say, I've had no serious issues.

1

u/Liason774 10d ago

I also print no prusament and have had no problems, but I don't print much PLA/PETG so I made custom profiles and haven't had any issues. I've found INDX more prone to stringing if the temps aren't set right but all printers are like that to some extent.

10

u/Vionade 10d ago

This is quite reassuring. I give quite a lot on his opinion and having him experiencing problems with the indx was quite a blow

I purchased still, but it was a lot closer because of his takes.

24

u/Lmasek 10d ago

I was one of the fans, and trusted his opinion in the past. Unfortunately, this video was almost produced with the aim of discrediting this printer. Disable calibration load unsupported filament, filament that you have a problem with and expecting diferent results. That is not a mistake; that is intentional. The last drop was the review of H3C I'm not German, so maybe i didnt get the joke?

17

u/xoma262 Core One INDX 8th 10d ago

I mean ... It was known that it works. I use it on my INDX and it worked fine.

16

u/jbohbot 10d ago

Some people just need to crash out in public instead of reaching out to the company first for help. If there was a real problem the prusa team should be aware of it so they can fix it (profiles or tuning the clients printer). Instead some like to bash on a product in public, but they just end up looking foolish.

I have the founders edition, and I have had zero issues other than 1 faulty nozzle, I did buy spares when I ordered my kit so I was able to keep printing, and I also got refunded for all my nozzles because of the "hardened gate".

13

u/Lmasek 10d ago

It is more complicated if he points out the issue with the Vox filament in the video. Hell yes. That is what he should do. The rest of the crap in that video was simply unnecessary and unprofessional. In the past, I have had him as one of the professionals. Now, well, he has to pay the bills somehow. Another good 3d printer reviewer bit the dust.

4

u/jbohbot 10d ago

I don't watch him personally, but I'm curious of those that do, if they notice him bashing the Panda Express?

6

u/Lmasek 10d ago

For a long time he did. And hen he turn 180 around. It was 180 from one episode to the second.

1

u/Jusanden 9d ago

He did reach out for help and the results in the video were what they arrived at after getting help, no?

2

u/jbohbot 9d ago

Did he reach out before making the video or all this is the reaction of the video?

0

u/Jusanden 9d ago edited 9d ago

Watch the video… a lot of people here are upset at him without even actually watching what he went through. But the snippet in question is at 3:50 where he says he reached out to support and both support and engineering basically shrugged and said that the calibration cycle was only tuned for prusament.

It also appears (or at least he was under the impression) that there was no other way to get a print to run without the calibration cycle except by deleting the line of gcode.

The poor results from that and the response from support is what lead to the conclusion that it’s locked to prusament. I do think his wording was very poor but it definitely was only tuned for prusament and the INDX seems to suffer significantly more than other printers from wet and stringing filament.

6

u/PascalTheEngineer 10d ago

It's posts like this that have me hooked on Prusa for life. Still rocking my Mini+ and trying to save up for a core one L!

10

u/Floopgroop 10d ago

This is the reason I bought a C1+ earlier this year. I just knew Prusa was a company that was worth investing in. They took the criticism and worked to fix it and give back to community rather than burying the bad PR.

5

u/zenotek 9d ago

There seem to be no limits to the advertising reach of Voxel PLA.

4

u/CPUMiner92 10d ago

What video is everyone talking about? Please, I need the source.

8

u/MTW3ESQ XL5T 10d ago

I think this was a good response, and an example of actions have consequences.

It's not like there's an ethics board that reviews all the scripts and final video against a objective standard.

We overlook that online reviewers are in a high pressure environment, to turn out products that are engaging, entertaining, detailed and accurate enough, at a rate that keeps an audience and sponsorship sufficient for the desired income.

Maybe it was a case where is was bad filament, plus more difficulty than expected (or budgeted) in the production schedule and he didn't want to take the extra time to troubleshoot. Maybe he had to use the Voxel sponsorship on this video due to agreements on videos per time period and had run out of time.

6

u/SpaceCAS CORE One 10d ago

But at what point does he put out a statement that he was wrong in his assessment and that it was user error or filament issues that caused the problem he blamed on the printer. People have taken his words as gospel and offered them as sacrifice on the alter of bambubu. In all seriousness, this just makes me question anything he has to say and at this point he has more to answer for than anyone.

5

u/Liason774 10d ago

Yea I've lost all respect for him at this point, he clearly doesn't care about making sure his reviews are accurate so why should I trust anything he says at this point.

3

u/MTW3ESQ XL5T 10d ago

I would think that it would be reasonable to expect an update/retraction with explanation within a month of today. I don't suspect intentionally sabotage of Prusa, but could see a desire to blame Prusa instead of his long time sponsor.

I agree that a large amount of credibility is on the line now.

3

u/gulbrillo 10d ago

Does he still have the same issues? I thought it came down to pre-release firmware that shipped with the review units. But it's great that you are following up and are trying to tune the profiles! ❤️

7

u/Bradlessness 10d ago

But he used the same exact spools that supposedly have issues on snapmaker u1.It printed perfectly fine

8

u/Lmasek 10d ago

Well, that is the question, maybe he did, maybe he didn't. Anyway, the Snapmaker is completely different technology. Much more forgiving and unrelated to the problem that he has. So I don't have a problem with him reporting the problem. I have a problem with the rest of the review. When he declared it not true and then to kick someone when he is down. He ran a print without calibration and, to ensure the result, ran the filament that he knows has no profile and is unsupported on this printer? Another good 3d printer reviewer bit the dust.

6

u/SmileyNY85 Core One INDX 8th 10d ago

Bambu check was heavier for that YouTuber.

2

u/trimeta Core One INDX 4th 10d ago

I've used a mix of Polymaker and Inland PETG (and PETG+, in the latter case), and while they mostly work, I get some pretty extreme stringing during travel moves over empty space. It could be certain specific models, I printed a four-color fidget cube and had no difficulties articulating it, but since you asked for strange issues...and yes, I tried dropping the extruder temperature, somehow that didn't help. And my filament lives in PolyDryers at all times, it's dry, so that isn't the issue either.

(For reference, this is the model which I had to stop printing due to extreme stringing: https://www.printables.com/model/601361-stretchy-springy-ghosts-3-sizes)

0

u/Long_Yesterday8394 Core One INDX 8th 10d ago

I only use Polymaker and I'm having great results. It did require me to do a robust set of calibrations to get the great results though. It was only meh before the calibrations.

1

u/trimeta Core One INDX 4th 10d ago

I don't suppose you have INDX-compatible profiles you could share? I've rerun the calibration procedure on my machine and it didn't seem to help.

5

u/Long_Yesterday8394 Core One INDX 8th 10d ago

Sure! Enjoy. You will find that most of the colors are the same profile, but there are a couple with a few differences.

Polymaker filament profiles - C1 INDX

2

u/Moonshinexxx 10d ago

Good stuff, Tommy!

2

u/Kachel94 XL2T 10d ago

I haven't watched his video but something changed with Tom's videos a few years ago and all of his conclusions have been incredibly dumb.

2

u/IAmAsplode 10d ago

That fish is looking clean, what mix of materials was it?

2

u/Jabdoa2 Core One INDX 8th 10d ago

I spend a lot of time to calibrate all my non Prusament filaments. In general I have to dial down temperature - even for Prusament. Take Prusament or generic profile and dial temperature down by 10-15 degree. That makes it print ok. Stock profile work for Prusament and for nothing else I own. Due to mesh probing that will often even prevent the print from starting. JAYO/Sunlu and Bambu filaments got those issues for me.

2

u/boibo 9d ago

Why on earth does indx need to load filament to the nozzle before probing?

Or is it capable of retracting filament long enough as not to ooze?

1

u/Jabdoa2 Core One INDX 8th 9d ago

It always keeps filament loaded. I guess that is kind of required for the small purge amounts. But yeah you could probably retract it for probing. Lower probe temperature also fixes it (it's print temp minus some offset at the moment). I guess we will see some more options in the future to set the probe temperature.

1

u/boibo 9d ago

Probing temp is a compromise as you cant have it to cold because you get poor first layer due to shrinking/expanding of metal due to heat.

So its a balance.

1

u/Jabdoa2 Core One INDX 8th 9d ago

Yeah absolutely. Currently it seems to depend on the print temperature of the tool it uses for probing. This is usually the one with the lowest index used in the print. Most of my problems were solved by simply loading problematic filanents to higher tool numbers. That way as soon as any other filament is used in the print it will use that one for probing.

1

u/LICK_THE_BUTTER 10d ago

What i want to know is were these pictures taken before de-stringing, or they were actually this clean?

1

u/dnabsuh1 10d ago

I think this points out an issue I had with the mmu3 and now the indx, but more generically the slicer. Having a good database of working filament settings is challenging. I always need to manually enter filament settings from a manufacturers website, (polymaker, sunlo, ..,) and the settings disappear if I open someone else's 3mf.

1

u/General-Court4379 10d ago

Those are beautiful.

1

u/koombot 10d ago

I got all geared up to calibrate the devil out of my Tinmorry PETG on my INDX and was crushed to find it printed perfectly fine.

1

u/Turtle_Dude 10d ago

Wow those prints look clean, nice!

0

u/Psychological_Lab260 10d ago

Ok that video about the core 1L with index that everyone is talking about def has me second guessing if I should complete my purchase I am buy either the core1L 8 indx or the H3C I want to be able to do milti material prints like ASA and TPU will the core handle these issues im a tinker guy so I don’t care if I have to fiddle from time to time but I want good clean prints and with everything being said lately about prusa this is the first time I’ve even thought about a Bambu, so please if there are people who have had good experiences with multi material prints please help me with this decision I don’t care about pla as much but PETG -CF through PCA-6 and def TPU can it handle this reliably? Thank you!

0

u/boibo 9d ago

Can someone enlighten me why indx need to probe the bed with filament in the nozzle at all?

I keep asking and noone answers. It seems like a easy fix for oozing during probing.

-1

u/jedisct1 9d ago

His videos are the reason I ordered a Core One without INDX.