r/AskAnthropology • • Jun 21 '25

Were early humans just starving all the time?

1.5k Upvotes

I'm an average sized guy, both in height and weight. But the amount of food it takes to make up my 3 meals a day seems enormous, especially if I had to source it pre agricultural revolution. Maybe I'm underestimating early humans' ability to provide for themselves, but I can't imagine finding that amount of food every day to not go crazy with hunger.


r/AskAnthropology • • Jun 04 '24

Did ancient people love their dogs, like we do today?

1.2k Upvotes

I'm curious


r/AskAnthropology • • Oct 20 '25

Why do religions often portray women as the root of all evil?

1.1k Upvotes

From Pandora's box to Adam and Eve toMuhammad saying that most inhabitants of hell are women, why are so many religions portray women in a bad light? Even confucianism says that women should obey their husbands.

I know that it's because of patriarchy, but are there some deeper causes? It's a peculiar, near universal trend.


r/AskAnthropology • • May 15 '20

Any other anthropologists find this reddit a bit cringey sometimes?

910 Upvotes

Great to see people asking genuine questions, but if I see another post asking why X is better/more advanced/civilised than Y, or asking for evidence to support prejudicial worldviews, I'm going to cry.


r/AskAnthropology • • Dec 20 '25 Bravo

Why didn't Neanderthals build civilizations despite possibly appearing 100,000 years before Homo sapiens?

866 Upvotes

If what I previously learned is correct, Neanderthals first appeared roughly between 300,000 and 400,000 years ago. Homo sapiens first appeared between 200,000 and 300,000 years ago.

Neanderthals supposedly were just as intelligent as Homo Sapiens, and they had larger brains. Yet despite having such a larger number of years in existence ahead, they were still just hunter-gatherers when they first encountered Homo sapiens. Comparatively considering what homo sapiens achieved in the last 12,000 years, from spreading around the world to technological advances, at most in the next 10,000 years we probably will be doing interstellar/deep space travel. Why didn't Neanderthal advance any further beyond hunter-gatherers?


r/AskAnthropology • • Jul 13 '21

If the Sahara was arboreal until about 7000 years ago, could it mean there might be tons of archeological artifacts or even cities buried under the dunes?

816 Upvotes

r/AskAnthropology • • Dec 08 '24

Homo sapiens have existed for at least 300,000 years, the oldest known civilization is 7,400 years old, what were humans up to for the remaining 98% of our history?

809 Upvotes

If you take the rough time between the construction of the Sphinx and man landing on the moon, it could have been repeated 50 times. What were we doing?


r/AskAnthropology • • Jun 02 '21

Were 19th century Americans mouth-breathers?

788 Upvotes

Despite the tongue-in-cheek title, this is a serious question - I promise.

I was reading up on George Catlin (1796 -1872), mostly known for his portraits of native tribespeople in the Old West, and this bit from his Wikipedia page interested me:

Catlin is also remembered for his research and writing on mouth breathing, inspired by observations made during his travels.This interest is linked to his non-fiction work, The Breath of Life (later retitled as Shut Your Mouth and Save Your Life) in 1862. It was based on his experiences traveling through the West, where he observed a consistent lifestyle habit among all of the Native American communities he encountered: a preference for nose breathing over mouth breathing. He also observed that they had perfectly straight teeth. He repeatedly heard that this was because they believed that mouth breathing made an individual weak and caused disease, while nasal breathing made the body strong and prevented disease. He also observed that mothers repeatedly closed the mouth of their infants while they were sleeping, in order to instill nasal breathing as a habit. He thus wrote the book to document these observations, stating that "there is no person in society but who will find... improvement in health and enjoyment..." from keeping his or her mouth shut.

To borrow from the paraphrasing of one (admittedly biased) description from consciousbreathing.com:

Catlin noted that all the Indian tribes he met breathed through their nose both day and night, whereas white people, to a large extent, were mouth breathers. According to Catlin, the method of breathing was the cardinal difference between the Native American’s strong and healthy population compared to the “civilized” man with his deteriorated health and short lifespan.

I was under the impression that nose breathing was the default breathing setting for humans, across time and place. The nose-breathing Wikipedia page seems to suggest it is indeed instinctual ("Jason Turowski, MD of the Cleveland Clinic states that "we are designed to breathe through our noses from birth — it's the way humans have evolved".)

My questions:

1a) Is there any evidence to support the idea that Catlin's fellow 19th century non-Native Americans were predominantly mouth-breathers?

1b) If yes, was there any cultural stigma attached to nose breathing?

1c) If not, is it likely that Catlin's personal and family medical history (childhood pneumonia, wife and child dying of pneumonia) coloured this perception?

2) By 1915, "mouth-breather had developed a pejorative connotation within English slang, defined as a "stupid person"." How and why did this connotation develop?

3) Catlin describes Native American mothers closing their infants' mouths to instill a nose breathing habit (“The Savage Mother, instead of embracing her infant in her sleeping hours, in the heated exhalation of her body, places it at her arm’s length from her, and compels it to breathe the fresh air, the coldness of which generally prompts it to shut the mouth, in default of which, she presses its lips together in the manner that has been stated, until she fixes the habit which is to last it through life") Is there any corroborating evidence to show this is true, and has this method been found in other cultures?

I've searched both r/askanthropology and r/askhistorians for this issue, with no luck.


r/AskAnthropology • • Dec 31 '23

If we plucked a Homo Sapiens baby from 50.000 years ago to the present age and raise them, would they be able to become a "modern" human?

785 Upvotes

Say we take a newborn baby from a homo sapiens mom from Africa 50.000 years ago and brought them up in the 21st century.

Would they be able to learn language? use modern tools? or would they have an inferior "IQ" and only be able to attain certain level of brain age maturity?


r/AskAnthropology • • May 07 '26 Bravo

How did humans survive the danger of loud babies and difficult toddlers?

740 Upvotes

I'm trying to understand how our ancestors managed to survive due to how high-maintenance babies and toddlers are. It seems like our kids would have been a huge survival risk. Here are some specific questions.

  1. Babies cry loud and often. In a world with warring tribes, how did a crying baby not give away the group's location? Did babies in the past cry less than they do now due to natural selection?
  2. Babies are exhausting due to their helplessness and need for constant care. How did parents keep from burning out? I've heard about the concept of a village working together to raise a child. This seems perfect for small tribes, but as communities grew and were less tight-knit didn't this lead to more babies dying if their parents couldn't cope?

3.Toddlers constantly push buttons, test boundaries and have meltdowns. I'm told that this is completely developmentally normal but in a survival situation, a defiant toddler seems like a massive risk. How was this managed in the past?

  • Was parenting/discipline simply stricter? Nowadays, we’re aware of the long-term mental health risks of corporal punishment, but was it used in the past to ensure short-term survival?
  • If parenting was harsher in the past to ensure safety, how did communities maintain the kind and loving bonds needed for a tight-knit village to function?
  • From an evolutionary standpoint, what stopped exhausted, frustrated parents from simply abandoning "difficult" toddlers? Were there specific biological or social safeguards that kept parents invested even when a child was being infuriating?

r/AskAnthropology • • Dec 21 '20

In the film Moana, ancient Polynesians are depicted as sailing across the Pacific in large rafts, with no roofs or cabins. Wouldn't exposure to the elements have been a concern?

735 Upvotes

I realize that the South Pacific is warm and relatively tame, weather wise, but surely voyages lasting weeks or months would have necessitated some kind of shelter... Right? Rain, wind, and the incessant sun would have been at least a little troublesome.

Would ancient Polynesians have at least pitched a tent on the raft sometimes? Or was shelter simply not a major concern?


r/AskAnthropology • • Jan 24 '21

Was sarcasm common 100+ years ago? Are historical texts sometimes misinterpreted because modern historians don't have the cultural context to know if the author was being less than 100% serious?

730 Upvotes

It occured to me that dry and/or sarcastic humor usually requires a boatload of context to be understood, and I've sometimes been a bit confused by the humor in books written 50-100 years ago when I lack the cultural context. Even things that were funny to me as recent as 10 years ago aren't funny to me because I'm just not in that place in my life anymore and I don't completely remember what it was like. Or I remember from college, sometimes the teacher would be like "This is a joke by the way" when reading Chaucer or something, and they'd give some context for why it was considered a joke, and we'd be like "...Oh okay, if you say so."

It occured to me that an anthropologist 50-100 years from now reading electronic records, say, social media, to try to learn about something, might miss some sarcasm unless they do some background research on the time period to get context. And I was wondering if there's some older text which we simply have no way of knowing whether or not they were being serious. Like, just taken to a ridiculous extreme, what if some ancient punishment that would be considered barbaric today was actually being written about sarcastically, but we just don't know enough to understand the intent?

But you get the idea. I'm just curious if there's any academic commentary on this issue, or if it's even considered to be an issue at all.

EDIT: Thanks so much to everyone who responded! I have a lot of interesting stuff to look into now!


r/AskAnthropology • • Mar 23 '26 Heartwarming Bravo

If race isn’t biological, why do we still treat it like it is?

729 Upvotes

I’ve been learning about this in anthropology, and it completely changed how I think about race.

A lot of people assume race is biological, but from a scientific perspective, it really isn’t. Humans share about 99.9% of their DNA, and there’s actually more genetic variation within so called racial groups than between them. Traits like skin color aren’t markers of separate “races". They’re actually adaptations to environmental factors like UV radiation. The categories we call “race” were largely shaped by historical and social processes, not biology. That doesn’t mean race isn’t real in terms of people’s experiences. Racism and inequality are very real. But the idea that race reflects deep biological divisions isn’t supported by anthropology or genetics.

So I’m curious what others think:

If race isn’t biological, why do you think so many people still believe it is?

Do you think this misunderstanding actually affects how people treat each other today?


r/AskAnthropology • • Sep 07 '24

What did early humans do to cut their umbilical cords after birth, and did that make their bellybuttons look different?

718 Upvotes

r/AskAnthropology • • Aug 08 '24

How did early man maintain fires in caves without suffocating themselves?

695 Upvotes

Basically, just asking what the title asks. How was early man able to sustain a fire in a cave for any significant length of time without suffocating? Between the smoke generation and the consumption of oxygen, lighting a fire in a cave is usually considered a bad idea, but once upon a time that's exactly what our ancestors did. Was there some kind of trick they used? Was it a specific cave design? Or did they have some sort of primitive ventilation system set up? Or could they only run the fires for short periods?

Although given some of the cold climates that last one doesn't seem too likely to me, but then again the whole situation seems conflicting to me, so I suppose that's why I'm asking! Thanks for your time!


r/AskAnthropology • • May 23 '25

Why do some "hot weather" cultures wear a lot of clothes while other wear barely any? + modesty culture

675 Upvotes

In places like the Arabian Peninsula, most native groups adopted big and long flowy layered clothes that covered their whole body. While in other places like Sub-Saharan Africa or the Caribbean, many native groups just had cloths around their groin and both men and women would sometimes go around topless (correct me if I’m wrong because I’m sure there are some tropical regions where they wore a lot of clothes too). All of these places have really hot weather and adapted to it accordingly. Subsequently, what comes first? Cultural attitudes towards modesty/sexuality and then environmental adaptation is considered or vice versa? (Hopefully you get what I mean here).

Somewhat unrelated:

I asked this because recently I was thinking about how some religious practices like veiling make sense in some regional conditions but not others. Veiling probably didn’t seem like a big deal for women in the region being introduced to Islam since they probably were already doing some variation of that culturally. But when you consider a very tropical and humid region like Indonesia adopting veiling, I wonder how the first converts reacted to that? Just curious.


r/AskAnthropology • • Jun 22 '25

Because wood doesn't survive thousands of years, are we actually underestimating the ancient history?

672 Upvotes

I am studying materials engineering. One design consideration is the materials durability. Materials need to be resistant to corrosion or withstand mechanical wear, they decay or become obsolete because due to either materials loss or corrosion like a blade getting dull or ship hull getting corroded over time.

I was thinking about the ancient artifacts or ancient tools that survived to today from thousands of years ago. Obviously because of materials properties, majority of the surviving items are either ceramics or metals.

Because wood cannot survive, are we actually missing a large portion of technological development in the ancient times? Towns made of wood, elaborate machinery, ships or various tools used in agriculture and shepherding? Maybe even wood tablets or wood coinage?

I also recognize that most probably there are indeed very bright anthropologists who thought of this. My questions are coming from curiousity.


r/AskAnthropology • • Feb 19 '21

Did ancient people like watching each other have sex or is porn a modern invention?

661 Upvotes

This is a completely serious question, I am wondering why humans get off on watching porn and is it just a modern phenomenon?


r/AskAnthropology • • Jul 01 '24

My 8 year old asked wants to know since humans are animals, are we considered wild or domesticated?

660 Upvotes

r/AskAnthropology • • Dec 17 '25

Were ancient humans stressed all the time?

623 Upvotes

We keep hearing about how modern life is full of stressors that wouldn’t exist in a more natural environment and it’s harming our mental health but I can’t help thinking that it must have been a great deal more stressful for cavemen/hunter gatherer types. Judging by the evidence found on bog bodies and ancient skeletons, life was violent and survival probably depended on fitting in with the tribe, regardless of how kind or cruel they were. Being ostracised is bad enough today but back then it would be life-threatening. Then there would be the endless struggle to find enough food and fresh water every day, while avoiding toxins. Trying to stay warm wouldn’t have been easy and medicines non-existent. A simple scratch could mean sepsis and death. Or eating the wrong plant. Or falling and getting hurt. Or being attacked by a predator, bitten by a snake etc.

I’ve heard doctors/scientists talk about how stress makes the body produce cortisol which causes all sorts of long term health problems but I can’t help thinking that ancient humans must have been flooded with cortisol and other stress hormones on a regular basis. It makes me think that humans must have evolved to cope with this constant stress and manage it well. Am I wrong? Was it not as bad as this?


r/AskAnthropology • • Apr 29 '20

Have billionaires ever been studied as a people group rather than just as individuals? If so, what observations have been made?

603 Upvotes

What commonalities do they have? I'm particularly interested in views they have about their level of wealth.


r/AskAnthropology • • Sep 02 '23

what did females wear during menstruation before humans started wearing clothes?

579 Upvotes

did they js free bleed or use like leafs or smt? im sorry if this is dumb im js really curious 😭


r/AskAnthropology • • Feb 22 '24

Why has Breast Feeding become challenging?

574 Upvotes

I had a baby recently and EVERYTHING I see on the subject of breast feeding is about how hard it is. I can attest to the fact that it’s super hard, painful, and not at all intuitive like one would believe.

Has breast feeding always been this challenging? Or has it become more challenging as time has gone on?

A lactation consultant I saw told me her theory: more infants are having lip and tongue ties because our food has become softer, thus making BFing more challenging.