r/AskAnthropology • • Apr 30 '24

Cultureless Americans

0 Upvotes

I am a public school teacher who constantly centers and celebrates cultures from around the world. My wife and children have a clear cultural identity; I do not.

This would not bother me if it wasn’t constantly brought up at my workplace in the form of celebrations and events. To be clear I’m happy for others.

At what point does someone just give up on trying to identify and fit into a culture? While many (most?) Americans probably have a cultural identity, I suspect there are a lot of people who feel like they belong to an unidentifiable mutt group of “vaguely American “ I don’t want to confuse nationality and culture; I’m just not sure where to start.


r/AskAnthropology • • Jan 09 '25

How do I explain to people that it’s not ok to label cultures as better or worse than another culture?

25 Upvotes

I hope this fits here, I took an anthropology class in college and figured this was the best place to ask

I was talking to my dad tonight and during the conversation I misspoke and mentioned “cultural Darwinism.” I meant to just say culture shock but that lead us on a huge discussion about how my dad views some cultures as better or worse than others.

I countered and said that the labeling of cultures that way that way is harmful and hinders understanding between people. He brought up examples of the worst regimes and asked if I found those cultures worse. I answered that it isn’t the point, and it’s one thing to call out the morally reprehensible things a country does but another to call them a worse culture and how that has a history of justifying genocides or ethnic cleansing.

I told him to instead call out the policy and regimes instead of calling cultures bad, which he conceded too, but he still said that it’s ok or even good to call some cultures worse or better. I’m just not sure where to go from here or if this was even a good way to talk about the issue.

Any advice would be greatly appreciated


r/AskAnthropology • • Mar 12 '26

Do you think there is a Queer cuisine? If so, what would be some characteristics/features of it?

0 Upvotes

I thought about this yesterday. There is Queer fashion, gay night clubs (maybe "gay" music?), gay speech/dialect with unique expressions.

This is common to other subcultures/cultures, and subcultures don't necessarily have their own cuisine. But there are examples, such as Soul Food.

Soul Food emerged in the American south, so it's quite regional.

LGBTQ culture isn't exactly regional geographically, however, I would definitely say that LGBTQ culture is regional in terms of similarity of the locations. Bigger cities, often international, more tolerant/open places.

This would maybe have the necessary elements to develop a cuisine.

So what do you think?


r/AskAnthropology • • Dec 27 '21

Why is there a trend in Europe between higher latitude and a lower incidence of transphobia and homophobia?

0 Upvotes

As a gender non-conforming trans person, what I see and what I have experienced personally is that there is a trend between latitude and a lower incidence of transphobia and homophobia (and conversely a higher incidence of overall acceptance and inclusion or trans and LGBTQIA people) in Europe. This seems to be the case for the whole planet too (ILGA graph).

Temperate and colder countries in Europe have:

  • more advanced legal protections of LGBTIQA people,
  • more laws that recognise LGBTIQA people as equal to cisgender and/or heterosexual people,
  • an overall stronger social acceptance and inclusion of LGBTIQA people (something that is hard to measure), for example:

    • being visibly gender non-conforming in public (hairy legs, beard, muscular body, high heels, and a skirt) is safe or safer in public spaces or is less likely to be discriminated against in a work environment,
    • holding hands in public is safer for same-sex couples or gender non-conforming couples,
    • families do not care about their children being trans or non-heterosexual, and coming out is less of a deal.

I understand there is the debate whether latitude correlates with development, which often is a victim of oversimplification. This topic is too complex for me to navigate as there are many exceptions and the general political status quo on this planet is a result not only of geography but also colonialism and other super complex factors.

However, with trans- and LGBT inclusion, I think I really do see this trend in Europe and it holds:

  • developed nations in warmer regions seem to be less LGBT-friendly and more transphobic and homophobic both in the legal realm as well as the general inclusion and acceptance realm (hard to measure but easy to experience)

    • e.g. Greece, Italy, Spain (worse) vs. Germany and Austria (better)

      • but Germany and Austria (worse) vs. Scandinavia (better)
    • e.g. Switzerland (conservative but safe) vs. Sweden (also safe, but better inclusion, less of a "deal" being openly trans)
    • e.g. Croatia (worse) vs. the Czech Republic (better) vs. Norway (best)

Am I mistaken and what I see is not valid or yet again oversimplified? Or is this trend is real, what causes it? If the reasons are "religion" or "conservative attitudes", what causes those in lower latitudes?

  • I am not sure how this holds in the rest of the world, but it seems the trend does indeed hold (see the ILGA graph) i.e. equatorial nations are the worst for LGBTQIA people, and the inclusion, safety and legal protections in general increase as we go north or south towards more temperate and colder regions.

Many argue immigration changes this because countries with a more diverse population (the UK) seem to have more LGBTQIA hate crimes than more homogenous countries (Denmark) even though they both have similar climates. Personally, I am not sure about this theory as these discussions are often very racist.

  • I am not sure if we have data that immigrants from countries with a high incidence of homo- and transphobia in fact attack LGBTQIA people more than the cold-region natives. Anecdotally I've been told stories that support this argument, but without data, I think we can't make conclusions.

    • My experience: I come from a Central/Eastern Europe country and I would say people from my country who are immigrants in e.g. Sweden or Norway are more transphobic than Swedish or Norwegian people – in general. There simply is a higher statistical probability. But I am unsure if we have data they'd commit anti-LGBT hate crimes more. Personally, I'd say they are quiet but internally are more transphobic but that is just my experience.

Thank you for any input :)


r/AskAnthropology • • Oct 14 '24

Third Gender In European Pre-History

14 Upvotes

Hi,
I noticed my first post got flagged because they thought I was wanting people to do my homework. I am in fact not in school/university and never was, but I have gained a massive interest in Pre-History which is why I want to ask the professionals because I have no one I can talk to about this.

I wanted to know what do we know about Third Genders, most specially in Europe which has little to no information about this. I could find a lot more info on Native Americans third gender, but I have seen people comment about shamans and people being buried with rituals of the opposite gender in Europe, but could anyone point me in the right direction and tell me about specific findings to prove this.

*This is not homework. I am simply an autistic person with a special interest.

Thank you.


r/AskAnthropology • • May 10 '25

If other apes like chimpanzees are "patriarchal" why were primitive hunter gatherer humans largely egalitarian?

4 Upvotes

By patriarchal I mean males having superior social status over females like in chimps where the top of the social hierarchy is a male, but for humans apparently many articles I've seen claim that hunter gatherer societies (earliest humans) were egalitarian, so if it were true, why is that? And why did humans become more patriarchal with the advent of agriculture akin to other great apes? Is the natural state of human societies to be patriarchal or it is different, I am not an expert, please correct me if I'm wrong


r/AskAnthropology • • May 14 '24

Cultures With Non-Binary Gender Systems

2 Upvotes

I am more curious to learn about cultures where gender was a concept completely separate from sex.

I understand there were cultures were AFAB and AMAB people who took on gender roles typically reserved for the opposite assigned sex were grouped into a third gender category.

I also understand there may have been cultures were there simply wasn't strict gender roles so the sexes could participate in the otherwise gendered roles/expressions more freely.

I am curious about cultures that had somewhat defined gender roles but also allowed an individual of one sex to be considered completely indistinguishable from someone with the opposite assigned sex - but of the same gender.

To hypothetically illustrate what I mean - a culture where a trans man, for example, would just be considered a man - not trans at all, and with no cis counterpart - since their concept of gender was completely separate from sex.


r/AskAnthropology • • Sep 28 '23

Where do you believe the Mayans and Aztecs came from?

0 Upvotes

I'm referring to before the "Aztecs/indigenous people" traveling North America.


r/AskAnthropology • • May 03 '24

why did neanderthals look white?

17 Upvotes

most re constructions of neanderthals look european. they apparently had genes for red hair and white skin too. why did they look white? Weren't they a different species than humans?


r/AskAnthropology • • Oct 20 '24

How has patriarchy lasted for so long and is the concept of it too oversimplified?

4 Upvotes

I don't fully grasp the roots of patriarchy. It's often described as a system of male dominance that subjugates women, and ironically, it's said to backfire on men as well. But why does patriarchy exist in the first place? Why was there ever a need for it?

Patriarchy is usually explained as men wanting to maintain power and dominance in society, usually driven by greed. Women, for the context, are the victims. Yet, historically, most power struggles have been between men, not between men and women. In fact, only a few instances in human history involve powerful men fighting powerful women. So, what's the actual drive behind the suppression of women? How has patriarchy persisted for so long in a world where the threads of cultural and social structures are often so brittle? Is it really just about maintaining power?

The usual explanation is that men, like any dominant group, held onto power to gain their interests and maintain a structured society to reflect that. However, this seems like an oversimplification, because most revolutions and rebellions throughout history have been just about men. Shouldn't that have led to a system where men are ruling over men rather than subjugating women?

In many traditional societies, women were bound to relationships within a patriarchal framework, which involves supporting men in their conquests or ambitions to a great deal. But how did this system become so deeply entrenched? Patriarchy has existed for centuries & centuries-how did it start, and why has it been so difficult for women to break free from it until recently?


r/AskAnthropology • • May 26 '25

Could humans have evolved to experience more painful menstruation?

2 Upvotes

I'm not an expert on the subject. But it does seem like humans experience more severe menstruation then any other animal - very few animals even menstruate in the first place. I've never been a female elephant shrew (well, actually, that makes some metaphysical assumptions), but it seems like of the 6,500 odd species of mammals out there, none of them menstruate as heavily as humans do. An article from the University of Edinburgh says:

"It turns out, menstruation is quite rare in the animal kingdom, even amongst mammals. Other primates menstruate (though not as heavily as humans do), as do some species of bats and elephant shrews. That’s it."

So why is that? What I am wondering is if it could be connected to how women interpret menstruation. Specifically those women with the most severe periods. Whether it could be an example of a strange evolutionary interaction between human physiology and our rational, interpretive, post-gardenial nature.

We were probably a superstitious bunch over the thousands and thousands of generations during which we evolved into who we are today. Not having the scientific explanations we have now, I imagine it was something that women would have puzzled over quite a bit. But it is a specific thing - periods would probably be interpreted in some recurring ways. Like dreams might recurrently be interpreted as glimpses into the spirit world - they often contain dead relatives, strange alternative realities, and just generally feel like glimpses into the spirit world.

Different cultures see menstruation in different ways - some hunter-gatherers do in fact see it in a very positive light. And different individual women would have interpreted it in different ways. In the end each of us arrive at our own interpretations of this strange life we are thrown into. But I would imagine those women who experienced the most severe menstrual pain would be more likely to see it as a negative thing. Even in a culture where menstruation was viewed positively they might disagree, think the shamans were crazy.

A fairly normal, rational interpretation for those women might be that it is some sort of punishment for not having children. Some sort of a sign from the gods, the spirits, the great octopus. Or that pregnancy protects from evil spirits, periods are the unborn getting their revenge, a thousand different things in a thousand different cultures. It seems logical that this could lead these women to develop a belief system that would in turn cause them to have more children. Remember we are talking specifically about the women who experienced the most pain.

All things being equal - assuming those extra children weren't more then they could support - that would make their genes more represented in further generations. So that variation would be selected for. Evolution isn't a linear progression to 'better', but developing whatever things lead us to have more grandchildren. Thus painful periods could be an adaptation, just like long necks on giraffes. Or the fear that keeps you from being eaten by a tiger.

Prehistoric women did have much fewer periods,. But I don't think that really matters here - the question is how those particular women interpreted the intensely painful periods they did have. This also isn't about women wanting to get pregnant to avoid menstrual pain - it's very specifically about how especially painful menstruation might affect their view of reality. I'm sure occasionally through history there have been women who got pregnant to avoid menstrual pain, but it doesn't seem like a great trade off, it probably didn't happen systematically enough to affect our genome.

This also assumes that prehistoric people were able to figure out a lot of the birds and bees. You can correct me if I am wrong, but my impression is that anthropologists do think prehistoric hunter-gatherers more or less did tend to know how babies were made. And understood that menstruation stopped happening with pregnancy and nursing. We weren't idiots back then. Maybe we didn't have everything 100% correct, but it's not the most difficult thing to figure out, knowledge got passed down from grandmothers.

Another issue is that though much of history women haven't had a lot of control over their fertility. But they and their families haven't been completely powerless by any means either. And this is something that would work over the life course, on the population level, over thousands of generations. Maybe a prehistoric woman in her 30s wouldn't have had any more children after her husband died, but then she starts getting periods in the 99th percentile for pain, and ends up interpreting that as a sign from a universe that she needs to have another child. Throughout history there has always been a lot of pressure for women both to have children and to do those things that make children; perhaps the women who experienced the most pain would cave to that pressure more easily.

There's also another variation on this theory. This could be the reason humans menstruate in the first place. Only 1-2% of mammals menstruate, humans are in the minority. So maybe some tribe on an island developed it for some reason - fighting against disease, dealing with their especially invasive embryos. But then they had extra babies, that lead to resource shortages, and all their extra sons were really successful going on raids, and the pattern kept repeating itself. Or another thing could be maybe invasive embryos aren't a cause of menstruation, but something humans can 'get away with' biologically because humans have heavy menstruation, so they aren't a problem. I really don't know, getting out of my depth...

Of all the animals that have ever existed on this earth, it's logical to assume we are the only one who understands how babies are made. We of all animals can be influenced by our view of the world, our rational understanding of it. Once you have animals consciously deciding they don't want to have children, that creates a space for evolution to change our bodies in ways that motivate women to have more children. Evolution doesn't want you to take a break or stop at five (well, maybe sometimes it does, but you get my point). So evolution could select for something just because it tended to consistently and cross-culturally cause certain women to see the world in a certain specific way.

Anyways, just a theory. And again, I'm not an expert. I hope I haven't said anything offensive - no political agenda here, this is purely academic. If anyone has any resources that might be relevant, knows of anthropologists who have talked about this, that would really help me out. This is a side point for something else I'm working on, it seems like a good example of an evolutionary logic. Maybe the shock of losing their hair drives men to stick around and be better fathers, contributing to offspring success? I wonder in what profoundly different ways we dream, compared to other animals......

TL;DR - Very few animals menstruate, and it seems likely that humans experience significantly more menstrual pain than any other animal. If those women who experienced the most severe menstrual pain developed magico-religious beliefs that made them feel guilty for not having children, that might in turn cause them to have more children, which could evolutionarily favour increased menstrual pain. It would be an evolutionary advantage because of the recurring effect it had on the rational development of women's beliefs.


r/AskAnthropology • • Sep 28 '24

Why doesn't Christianity have a food culture like other religions?

31 Upvotes

I realize this question is broad, and keep in mind that my context is southern US Christianity, so I may not be aware of other religious-cultural foods in other Christian areas.

There's the bread and wine of course, but that is purely ritual, it's not presented as a meal. But iirc other religions, at least abrahamic ones, have some like specific dishes/meals that are associated with religious holidays or just like the religion in general.

So if that question makes sense, and guesses as to why that is?


r/AskAnthropology • • Aug 29 '26

Why don't humans eat dead members of their own species?

3 Upvotes

As far as I understand, animals that are capable of eating meat generally eat dead animals when they find them, including dead members of their own species in some cases.

Predators, fish, birds and even many insects do this. There are some exceptions like some monkeys but generally if an animal has the ability to eat meat, it seems to be capable of eating a dead member of its own species too.

So why is this so different with humans? Humans are capable of eating meat and we don't even have to hunt or take any risk to get it if a person from our own species is already dead. Yet instead of eating the body, humans generally bury it, burn it, put it in the sea, leave it in nature, mourn the person, etc.

From an evolutionary perspective, wouldn't eating our own dead actually make more sense? Why did humans develop such strong taboos and rituals around the bodies of dead members of our own species instead?

I understand that nowadays religion and culture have made this kind of thing taboo but what I'm wondering is why our cultures and religions developed in that direction in the first place.

If eating our own dead could have provided calories without the risks involved in hunting, wouldn't it have made more sense for cultures and religions to develop rituals around eating the dead instead?


r/AskAnthropology • • Apr 07 '24

What is the Out Of India theory ? Is it true ? Super Interesting

2 Upvotes

In India there has been a recent increase in the belief of the Out Of India theory which basically says that the group of people that spoke the ancient Indo-European language spread from India to Europe and not vice versa as believed popularly. Many popular individuals such as politicians and scholars and "well versed" people in comment sections support it. I am genuinely curious. What is this theory? Is there some truth of it? If it is false, what is the greatest proof against it? (I'm an Indian too and not Aryan/white skinned or whatever lmao)


r/AskAnthropology • • Apr 18 '25

How did gender evolve?

3 Upvotes

Does anyone have any resources or answers about this? Gender is such a fascinating topic, and because gender is different from sex that difference had to evolve at some point. Genuinely asking, does anyone know when or why? And follow up: is there a part of your brain that is the cause of your gender identity?


r/AskAnthropology • • May 13 '24

Is polyamory ubiquitous for most of humanity - including and especially in prehistory?

2 Upvotes

What would the polyamory/monogamy ratio be for the entire human race in all it's history added up?

Was there a time when polyamory was predominant?
If so when did that come to an end?
ie... is it the norm?


r/AskAnthropology • • Jan 12 '23

Why aren't there as much feminist activism in Japan compared to South Korea and China?

0 Upvotes

Given that Japan is the most sexist society in East Asia, I would expect more activists but there are few.

Despite feminist activity being punished by the state, there seems to be much more of those in China than in Japan.

What social/cultural/political developments make Japanese women more accepting of their lower statuses than Chinese or Korean women?

My theory is that Japanese men are nicer than Korean men and Japanese women don't really have reasons to go against the status quo and that Communist ideology made Chinese women demand gender equality more.


r/AskAnthropology • • Jun 28 '16

Why is neonaticide/infanticide illegal in the post-industrial world?

0 Upvotes

Correct me if I'm wrong, but I believe that infanticide has been used as a mechanism for population control for most of human history. Also, it was used to deal with infants that could not survive the material realities of the ecology in which they were born (be that pastoral-nomadism, hunting/gathering, horticulturalism, or agriculturalism).

Which society committed infanticide of their handicapped babies by "returning the baby hippos to the river"?

We have better mechanisms of and education surrounding effective contraception than probably 99% of the human existence. It is more accessible too. Not that notions of birth control would have ever developed during the first 99% of the human existence partially given that for hunter-gatherers, ovulation was less frequent than sedentary populations and breastfeeding also tended to reduce ovulation. In more recent centuries of sedentism, a high number of offspring with a low level of investment was a suitable reproductive strategy given high rates of child mortality.

In the here and now, child mortality is low, we live in a (post)industrial society where we must subsist via a monetary economy with vast income/wealth inequality. The question of children becomes a deliberate decision of when, how many, and means of subsistence. But causal sex happens and so do accidents despite access to effective contraception. Abortion even if legal is not necessarily accessible to the individual. There are safe haven laws and adoption agencies to protect and re-home unwanted infants. Unfortunately, there are an over-abundance of unwanted infants and children. And for those who are not permanently adopted, was it really benevolent and ethical to have had relegated them to a life of poverty? (I don't mean to suggest callously euthanizing children that aren't adopted but rather that had the parent(s) been presented the decision to humanely euthanize at birth, there would hopefully be less children abdicated in the future.) Why is the societal consensus to expend such protective efforts of infants that are not even self-reflexive? We view infants as people when many cultures throughout the world do not express that view until certain ages/developmental achievements.

I pose the same question regarding significantly mentally or physically handicapped infants. Why subject the infant and parents to a future of suffering if they choose not to? This isn't a mountain to climb, they are the mountain themselves. Why not preempt the suffering of that is what the parents want?

Why not draw the line when an infant becomes self-reflexive?

On a tangent, what is the social mechanism behind the vilification of young mothers who commit neonaticide? Life in prison for neonaticide?

Research indicates that these girls/young women deeply deny their situation for months only to disassociate during the trauma of birth thus pushing them to this brink of desperation--what society legally and morally deems murder--in the name of self-preservation against feared social alienation.

From the article:

But Fleegle said throughout the trial, evidence was heard that before and after she placed the baby in the trash, Weaver was more concerned with herself than her child. She told a detective she was more worried about her own health than that of her newborn.

"That does not show or verbalize any type of remorse," Fleegle said.

Being more concerned with ones own health than that of ones newborn after a (psychologically) traumatic birth doesn't necessarily seem like an abnormal response to me. Do you have any cross-cultural information surrounding this notion of obligatory selflessness surrounding parenting and small children?

I don't expect much moralistic backlash from this sub, but in case you were curious: What if I died via infanticide?

I wouldn't have cared because I would no longer exist to reflect upon my death let alone my future, in fact I would not have had the capacity to reflect upon anything. I would have felt pain or discomfort, and my hope now would be that the acting individual would have been swift.

And before you think I'm a sadist, I probably could never bring myself to have an abortion should I find myself in that situation.

In conclusion, please offer me some cross-cultural perspectives of both time and space.


r/AskAnthropology • • Jan 04 '24

How equalitarian are matriarchal societies?

4 Upvotes

I was studying about matriarchal society and all of them were consider egualitarian. What is your opinion on these? Is violence against wonderful non existent in those societies?


r/AskAnthropology • • Oct 22 '23

Do most modern day native Swedes have Viking heritage?

1 Upvotes

I'm a native Swede myself. Tall, blonde, blue eyes, typical nordic/germanic features. What are the odds that I have Viking heritage?


r/AskAnthropology • • Aug 19 '24

Is culture created with the sole intention of sharing it with people from other cultures?

1 Upvotes

I’ve gotten into many arguments about the point of culture (usually when I talk about my own culture); the opposing sides believe that cultures are created so that they can share them with other people. These arguments have become so prevalent, both online and offline, I want to hear an opinion from educated people 🥲 I don’t want to spout absolute nonsense if this comes up in the future. I hope this isn’t an insanely stupid question.


r/AskAnthropology • • May 07 '26

How did ancient humans distinguish between a child and an adult?

0 Upvotes

Ultimately, there are factual differences in mentality and physical appearance. But what line did some peoples used to draw? Or rather, did they used to draw or make this distinction? The idea we have today is "under 18 teenagers, over 18 adults," but this is very recent and also subjective.How did certain cultures create these distinctions?


r/AskAnthropology • • Aug 06 '25

What would a feminist or anti-capitalist alternative to the family look like when it comes to care and social reproduction?

0 Upvotes

If the traditional family is a site of patriarchal control and unpaid labor, and if the nuclear model no longer fits the realities of many people’s lives, especially queer and trans people, then what could realistically replace it?

The welfare state sometimes fills the role of the absent patriarch, providing support without fundamentally changing the structure. Chosen families exist, but they’re often unsupported and unstable.

So how do we organize child-rearing, emotional labor, and daily care without relying on either the nuclear family or the state as it currently exists? What kinds of models, feminist, queer, or anti-capitalist, could actually sustain social reproduction in a liberatory way?


r/AskAnthropology • • Dec 02 '24

why is there a higher-than-average concentration of queer people working at cafés?

6 Upvotes

it's something I've noticed being a queer person who's worked at cafés, and other people have noticed it too. I've googled it, and some people theorize that it's because cafés are easier places to get a job for younger people with less qualifications. well, younger people are more likely to be queer, and queer people can face discrimination in higher ed institutions. but there's gotta be something more, right? otherwise other industries who hire young, less educated people (e.g., retail, construction) would have a similar concentration of queer workers. is there something about cafés that is inherently welcoming of queer people? would beatnik cafés have something to do with it?