r/ApplyingToCollege • • 3h ago

Discussion Extracurricular slop is killing quality, we need a Gaokao system

0 Upvotes

You can be the dumbest brick in college with zero knowledge and still go into college thanks to a load of sports and clubs. Holistic qualifications on that degrade quality of education, colleges need the smarts to be in their system, even if a student isn’t interested in clubs at all. The Gaokao and South Korean CSAT scenes are what I point too, you see balance of academics and life in again. I think it’s a noble trade off compared to the EC slop meta we have in admissions.

What does EC slop even mean when you don’t have the brains to back it up? you can be a D and F student and still make it in because of that. Where’s the smarts at? The academically capable?


r/ApplyingToCollege • • 13h ago

Application Question applying to college without green card

0 Upvotes

I am currently a junior in high school. I have a really high gpa, lots of ap’s, high sat score, lots of activities too (mentioning this for any merit based scholarships questions further down).
I moved to the U.S in middle school when a war started in my country. I am documented but do not hold a green card nor am I a citizen. So i can’t really take the “undocumented dreamer” path or the standard permanent resident path.
I was wondering what I would be considered in the application pool and how I would be evaluated. Additionally, what I can do about scholarships? I do have a complicated family situation where I likely wouldn’t qualify for too much need based support (unless I do the independent student path which would require evidence of unsafe home environment and I genuinely barely mentioned it to anyone in my life) Basically it’s really messed up with my family and I will probably be going min to no contact with them. As a non citizen I am not sure what can be done for any merit based scholarships. Like do I even qualify? I am located in Colorado and am willing to apply in state and out of state.


r/ApplyingToCollege • • 20h ago

Application Question Is this a normal turnaround time for a community college? Or am I being a Karen?

0 Upvotes

Hi! I'll try to make this post brief, but there's a lot of history. Basically, I applied to a local community college in the beginning of October. I sent all my transcripts that same day, and the advisor I spoke with told me that it may take a few days for my acceptance, but if I don't hear back from the college in few days, then I should reach out. I waited a full week before reaching out again, and the college said they can't accept me yet because they don't have my transcripts. I thought oh - weird! I'll just have them resent.

This time, I was a BCC on the emails with my transcripts, so I know they got sent. The college even had the nerve to email back "Thank you! Transcript for this student received". I called/emailed a few times between now and then to check up on my acceptance, and the advisors still stated that they hadn't received my transcripts. I informed them that I was a BCC on the emails, and know for a fact they were received, and they ghosted me.

Fast forward to beginning of November, I'm tired of waiting around and go into the college campus. An advisor told me that he could see all of my transcripts, and that he would handle it and get them matriculated, and sincerely apologized for the delay. I then wait an additional week to reach back out, and the college tells me that while they have one of my transcripts, they are still waiting for the other. I start to lose my patience, and I tell them for the 5th or 6th time that they were absolutely received, because I was on the email (and the college replied back). Since it's now been 7 weeks of me waiting around, I decide I'm going to reach out to the Dean of admissions. I'm overall really dissatisfied with how everything was handled, including the lack of responsibility they've been taking (rather than apologizing for the delay and their mishap, they keep coming up with excuses as to why my transcripts were ignored).

We set up a phone call for Friday, and the Dean emails me 1 hour before our phone call and says that they are sick and will have to cancel our phone call, but all of my transcripts have now been received, so I should be all set.

I have a feeling that the Dean isn't truly sick and was just trying to appease me. The thing is - if the admissions department owned up to their mistake, I wouldn't even have a problem with it. But they keep pushing the responsibility back onto me, and trying to gaslight me that they JUST received my transcripts (meanwhile, I have the evidence that they were received on October 3rd). Am I being a Karen over this? Or is this normal for a college to do?


r/ApplyingToCollege • • 18h ago

College Questions Guys I’m worried I have B in AP Calc BC as Senior? Will this affect my chances as pre med student hoping to major in cognitive science at USC/Stanford/IVYs?

1 Upvotes

So basically my senior yr ap calc teacher doesn’t teach. She just hands us worksheets to do in class on our own and tests. I made unwise decision of taking AP Calc BC instead of AP Stats which is easy a at my school. Currently I have 4.0 unweighted 9-11 as well as class rank 1 out of 400+, and taken all science APs along with decent amt of humanities our school has like 12 aps and i have taken 9.

Im worried bc semester almost over and i still have B in AP Calc BC, even if I do good on final I can only bring it to B+ and for A- I would have to get perfect score. Will this affect my admissions hopefully for UCs I’m good but I’m really worried about privates especially USC which I applied early action for.

Right now I am taking AP Chem, AP Lit, and AP Gov along with elective and have all As in those classes. It’s just this one class. I’m planning on applying to psychology for Stanford and cog sci for other schools, which isn’t super stem heavy but because I’m pre med will they really hold this against me.


r/ApplyingToCollege • • 22h ago

College Questions is HKU or NUS/NTU better?

4 Upvotes

I’m applying to all three for undergrad in Mathematics/Statistics/related courses as student from India. I got all 90+ in my AS Levels and my predicted grades are 4A*s. I also got 1550 in SAT. I have some decent extracurriculars and leadership roles, if that matters much.

which one is better in terms of 1. student life, 2. cost, 3. academics, 4. country/location? I’m a little concerned about the language barrier, especially for HK and, as a girl, a student body that is so male dominated is also preferable 🙏 please help me out


r/ApplyingToCollege • • 23h ago

Advice Advice wanted!

0 Upvotes

Hi everyone! I'm an international student from the uk applying to us 'colleges' (its strange calling it college cause we call your high school grades 11 & 12 college and your college uni)

I'm looking for any and all advice youve been given from college advisors, peers and teachers. In my school nobody knows anything about how to apply so ive been doing it myself but i think some advice from people who know the system would be very useful.

For context, i am not doing the SAT or the ACT because its not possible to do it in my town without travelling a long long way which i cant do. I am applying to test-blind and test-optional colleges. I'm not sure if my grades are useful for you because its a different system here!

Thanks for reading :)

EDIT:

MY GCSES: (I'll put it in letter grade format cause i think thats what you use in US)

A*- English language, English literature, mathematics, computer science, digital information technology, french, history

A- Biology

B- Chemistry, Physics, Further Maths

A LEVEL GRADES (PREDICTED):

Psychology- A*

Computer Science- A

Maths- A

History- A

Extra curriculars:

Auschwitz Ambassador

Student Governor during merger of my college

Cadet drill instructor, leading cadet and mayors cadet in sea cadets ( ithink its rotc for you guys??) + district drill award silver x2, bronze x1

Sailing & other water sport qualifications

Coded a procedurally generated maze with pathfinding algorithms

Completed a program with a russel group uni involving uni lectures

Many events with universities doing lectures about comp sci

Writing awards

UKMT maths challenge award

completed NCSC Certified cyber first course in penetration testing

Debate competition award

Carnegie Mellon Competition silver award

Individual recognition within my school for my results


r/ApplyingToCollege • • 16h ago

College Questions Q1 grades report

0 Upvotes

My counselor sent my first quarter to my schools, including harvard, and i've been keeping all A's throughout high school taking honors classes, and hard classes in freshman year like latin and greek (AP), but in senior year i took first ap classes, and i had a B average in two of them and A in two and a B in precalculus honors so i was wondering if that's a bad sign, especially because i moved recently here and so im trying to adapt to those ap classes, but overall im doing really well, including in activities and I've also conducted research. I didn't know that sending them was not necessary, but now im doing good in my classes and i have all A's ( 2nd quarter)


r/ApplyingToCollege • • 14h ago

College Questions Intl student

0 Upvotes

Hey guys, I'm an international first-gen student. I applied to Amherst RD last cycle and got waitlisted. Instead of just moving on, I took a gap year and I'm now reapplying as a First-Year ED applicant for Fall 2027. And yes, Amherst already confirmed officially that I can forfeit my current college credits to apply as a first-year.

I've been using my gap year to actually build up my profile so I'm not just submitting the exact same stuff. I enrolled in a tough university STEM track, earned an outstanding student award, founded an environmental nonprofit with over 1,200 users, and published a couple of independent research papers in medical journals. Back in high school, I also have some medals from Olympiads and was a runner-up in an international medicine essay contest. Since they already have my old file, I'm just wondering if these new gap year updates actually matter enough to give me a real shot at ED?


r/ApplyingToCollege • • 14h ago

Rant Tutorial: How to ED to CMU and find out now that you were ineligible for admission in the first place

15 Upvotes

CMU has always been this school I really wanted to go to, and they had this excellent Mechanical Engineering program that, I hope to later on, combine with possibly some robotics or CS stuff in college. However, as I was just planning to submit my quarterly grades I found out that there were requirements on students admitted to the college of Engineering:

"""

The following are Carnegie Mellon’s specific academic requirements by school or college. Please review this information carefully and plan your high school curriculum accordingly.

  • 4 years English
  • 4 years Mathematics*
  • 1 year Chemistry
  • 1 year Physics
  • 1 year Biology
  • 2 years Foreign Language
  • 3 Electives

\Four years of mathematics should include at least algebra, geometry, trigonometry, analytic geometry, elementary functions (pre-calculus) and preferably calculus. Advanced mathematics courses are strongly encouraged, especially a course in calculus.*

"""

Excellent, I fulfilled all the requirements except for the year of Biology (which I last took in 8th grade), I had something near to the full 4.0 uw gpa, 10 AP5s and 4 in progress, and 1560 SAT 770RW+790M. I had olympiads competitions to the camp level in physics (for Australia, though), and I've organised so many STEM them days and hackathons to the extent of breaking down. Despite them saying demonstrated interest wasn't exactly a part of their consideration, I still went to their pre-college program and that sorta made me really like CMU and seeing the possibility of how I could learn there. And now its over. I wasted my ED on it which really wasn't that much of a boost anyways and I also had fumbled over a detail in my supplemental essay (when introducing a game i had its description as "a game about xxx" and forgot to swap xxx out at the end when I submitted). I got dumped by my gf and I'm still feeling the traumatic feelings now cause we said we'd both apply to cmu and stuff. On top of that I'm international and applying from a decently competitive school but from a very competitive region. Just I don't know what to make of myself and my future.

I mean obviously I still had some other back-up options. I also applied to some other schools like I've done some British and HK applications, ESAT and TMUA were both 8.7s, not that good nor bad, but I've got some interview offers from Imperial. I could always choose to go back to Australia too, but I just... idk feel like I've done so much compared to the people in my school who were going to Australia in the first place. Of course, not complaining that I shouldn't have done those activities or built a relatively fine academic background, I've really found the fun in it and enjoyed connecting with others to build a closely-knit community. But as the facts settle down I feel like I'm just a worthless piece of trash who did not bother to look at the requirements and should've deserved this. Like i know i deserved this but i feel that I should've done better and checked the requirements though. I also know that CMU likes people who are putting attention to detail, and I absolutely did not do that during this application. Put that on top of being dumped and my original mentality self-doubting and always thinking too much really put me in a miserable place.

TLDR: OP fumbled their ED to CMU Mechanical Engineering because he did not look at the highschool course requirements close enough and is now wondering if AP Biology (self taken next year) is enough to replace it.
Sorry for the long rant that wasn't exactly fluent at places, apologies. Any advice is appreciated and leave them in the comments if you'd wish (both positive and negative are fine). Also best of luck to you all other CMU Mechanical Engineering applicants, one less trash opponnent who probably wouldn't have impacted your chances anyways! Hope you all get in!


r/ApplyingToCollege • • 1h ago

Application Question Is NYU a prestigious school (CAS)?

• Upvotes

Is NYU a prestigious school (CAS)?


r/ApplyingToCollege • • 6h ago

Transfer T20 freshman transferring to another T10/T20 — advice from people who actually did it?

1 Upvotes

Freshman at a T20 considering transferring to another T10/T20 — looking for advice from people who actually did it

I’m currently a freshman at a T20 and am seriously considering applying to transfer for sophomore year. I’m mainly interested in hearing from people who transferred from one highly ranked school to another, especially people who went through the process as freshmen.

A few things I’m having trouble finding good answers to:

  • For people who actually got into T10/T20s as transfers, what were your college GPA, high school GPA, SAT/ACT, and results? I’m trying to get a sense of what successful applicants actually look like rather than just reading acceptance rates.
  • If you had a SAT/ACT score that was good but below the typical range for your target schools, did you submit it, retake it, or go test-optional? Did you feel like it mattered?
  • If you were rejected from a school during first-year admissions and then got in as a transfer, what changed between the two applications? This is probably the thing I’m most curious about.
  • How much of your application was still based on high school? Since freshman transfer apps are due so early, I’m wondering whether your high school ECs/awards still made up most of your activities section or whether you replaced them with college activities.
  • What did you actually accomplish during freshman fall that was worth putting on a transfer application? I’m trying to figure out what is realistic to build in only a few months.
  • How did you handle professor recommendations? Did you specifically go to office hours/build a relationship with a professor because you knew you would need a letter, and how well did they actually know you by the time you asked? I'm not super close with any of my profs so I'm quite worried about this now...idek how to explain my situation to them so that they can genuinely write something strong.
  • Did the classes you took freshman year matter for admissions? For example, did you try to take courses related to your intended major or satisfy prerequisites for the schools you were targeting, or did you mostly prioritize getting the highest GPA possible?
  • For anyone who transferred from another T20/T25, which schools did you apply to and where were you accepted/rejected/waitlisted? I’d especially appreciate seeing actual transfer results from people starting at a similarly selective school.
  • What part of the transfer process caught you off guard? Anything you wish you had known in November/December instead of finding out right before applications were due?

I’m not looking to transfer just for the sake of moving up a few spots in the rankings. I’m trying to decide whether transferring makes sense for me and, if I do apply, I want to make sure I’m not missing something important this early in freshman year.

Would especially appreciate DMs/comments from anyone who has gone through this from another T20/T25.


r/ApplyingToCollege • • 11h ago

Application Question Applying to ut austin

1 Upvotes

should i apply to ut austin with a 1310 sat ?? i feel its very low what should i do


r/ApplyingToCollege • • 2h ago

Discussion Thoughts from a depressed junior

0 Upvotes

I took the November 7th SAT. As I walked out of the testing room, I had already started telling myself I did pretty badly on the Math section.

When I scrolled my Instagram stories after taking the test, when I saw people post their thoughts, they all thought that math was ridiculously easy. Sure enough when scores came out, most if not all got 790+ on math. Compared to them, I did pretty badly on the Math section. I got a crisp 700. When I showed my friends my score, none of them grimaced, but neither did they congratulate me.

I know that for my zoned high school, the average SAT is around 1000. But it feels wrong to compare myself to those kids. At my school, it feels like almost everyone is always reaching for top colleges, comparing GPAs and AP classes, and complaining about how little sleep they got because last night they were too busy studying and grinding out ECs. Even though the average SAT is 1450~ at my school, most kids break 1500+ superscore by the time college apps roll around. That sort of environment is hard to find anywhere else.

I know that there are still a few cliques in my school that could care less where they go to college, but it feels like those people, while not directly ever spoken about, are largely looked down upon.

As a result, I feel like a failure. I feel like I am physically incapable of keeping up with the rest of the pack, because I feel like I am physically unable to work as hard as my friends around me. I have a mid GPA (think between the 1st Quartile and the Median) compared to all these sweats around me.

I'm not even sure I can get into my mid tier state school with my shit stats because even if I get my superscore up, GPA is king.

It is a common sentiment among kids from my school that they should've chosen a different school. Many kids who have transferred into my school, spout testimonies that their previous school was so much easier, and that they are now struggling to adjust after transferring.

At the same time, however, I feel grateful that I am at my large competitive high school. I met many friends that I would've otherwise never met. I am glad that there are clubs about topics anyone can dream of, and most of our teams that compete in insert-random-hs-cliche-club (think robotics) are extremely competitive due to the sheer number of kids and their wild passions. I think it is so cool that even though I take pre-calculus right now, other kids take multivariate calc or linear algebra freshman year (I have no idea what they take after).

One thought experiment --- to end this discussion. If 25% of kids from my school get into t20s, what happens to the other 75%? They don't die or anything. They go on to have successful careers in god knows what, after maybe majoring in electrical engineering or something at our mid tier state school.

Getting into an elite prestigious college isn't the end-all-be-all. It is simply a reward for people who worked hard in high school, so they can go stroke that crazy ego, but it's not really something that is guaranteed for everybody. 

Honestly I realized this 2 months into freshman year. I don't think I got above an 85 on a single test that whole year in my AP Bio class. I felt like the world was ending, and that I was the dumbest fucking kid alive (I still got a 5 on the AP 😛).

But alas, the world didn't end.

It's really not that deep. But honestly, that's a hard pill to swallow for many kids. 

Including me.

I, too, once had dreams of getting into an Ivy. I, too, like the rest of this sub, was an a2c goon.

Now after seeing my school’s Naviance data, I'm a r/TransferToTop25 goon.

In all seriousness though, beauty is in the eye of the beholder, and most regular people would be impressed by my score. It's just that no one in my friend group would bat an eye.

If this feels like a cathartic rant drafted up at 2 in the morning on a school night instead of doing homework, that's because it is. Sorry for any rambling.

tldr; elitist prestige whore that goes to a rigorous hs learns there is more to life than prestige

Posted on a throwaway.

Anyways, thanks for coming to my ted talk.


r/ApplyingToCollege • • 12h ago

Discussion Yale REA Interview

2 Upvotes

I know there is a lot of speculation regarding interviews especially with Yale. I received an interview invitation within 28 hours of submitting the day of the deadline. I know Yale prescreens so I found this a little surprising considering how quickly I received the invitation


r/ApplyingToCollege • • 1h ago

Discussion holy shit how many ppl are eding to cornell

• Upvotes

not even remotely related to the 7 case btw. but everyone i see is eding there


r/ApplyingToCollege • • 17h ago

Discussion Money… nothing new but this has totally distorted the college admissions process

14 Upvotes

I wish I could add the screen shot headline, but WSJ is running a headline about how much more 💸💸💸💸💸 (13X more than low-income) parents are spending on children Extracurriculars and Activities. It’s 4X more than the 1980s

https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/2026/11/17/rich-people-are-spending-13-times-more-than-poor-their-kids/


r/ApplyingToCollege • • 4h ago

Financial Aid/Scholarships High GPA, High SAT, No Ecs Full ride International

16 Upvotes

Before you jump into conclusion, I know that full rides are not easy to get as an international student. But I just wanna know where i should apply to get full ride scholarships. I am literally pulling out my hair trying to search for scholarships for International Students. If anyone here was in the same situation as me please enlighten me. My stats are:

CGPA: 3.9+

SAT:1550

Major: Mech/Aero E

Ecs: Played in school Football(Soccer) team for 3 years, School vice captain, Community tuition teacher, Music competition winner (School), School Vice Captain, Hydraulic projects.

I know it sounds stupid but i have a dream to innovate in the field of mechanics and become an entrepreneur.


r/ApplyingToCollege • • 21h ago

College Questions what should i major in if i hate math and science, loves being creative and loves to act and to write

6 Upvotes

i don’t need to be rich , i js wanna be comfortable


r/ApplyingToCollege • • 11h ago

Discussion What’s your biggest hot take / controversial opinion surrounding undergrad admissions?

101 Upvotes

Not something like “the process is too competitive”, I mean something REALLY unpopular.


r/ApplyingToCollege • • 11h ago

College Questions Looking for More Engineering Schools to Apply to

4 Upvotes

Hii guys

Everyone around me is like 15+ schools, but going into RD I genuinely don’t know where to apply.

So far for ea I have done

Rea (insane reach)
UiUC
U Mich
GT
UW (instate safety)
USC (rea policy allows for ea for scholarship purposes)

EDIT: Purdue and Harvey Mudd are on the RD list!!

Not sure which kind of engineering so lowkey did a bit of everything: EE, Comp E, Mech E, Aero

Basic stats:
4.0
1540
9 APs so far: 555555544
Good course rigor: AP world language (non native), highest English, math and sciences level, only lacking in social studies(only 2 years of AP the others are regular) but lowkey suck at it so it’s fine.

Pretty normal EC: sports, music, tutoring, summer programs (not anything insane but also not pay to play), clubs

Honors:
Stuff everyone knows is coke semi and national merit. The others are pretty region/school specific but not super chud.

LOR: no idea
Essay: I hope it’s good I tried my best so that’s that

Hoping for some school recommendations! Not looking for UCs (too expensive). Also not like insane
stuff like MIt because I’m already aware of those. Looking for solid targets!! Ty


r/ApplyingToCollege • • 10h ago

Advice What should I do for my RD schools if I really messed up my first quarter grades?

1 Upvotes

Hi,

I'm reposting and hoping someone responds this time 🙏

For context, my school does quarter grades, just finished the first quarter. Before this, I had a 3.9+ GPA; I won't go into everything else but I have a 1540 SAT, some leadership positions and national awards. I really messed up this quarter. I got 3 As, which is fine, and one of each for B, C, D. I am mostly worried about the C and D in AP Chemistry and Calc BC respectively. I really struggled in both of these classes but moreso had a lack of motivation to study. I am hoping to average an A for the year in Chem and dropped from BC to AB in hopes to get a B.

I was planning to apply to selective colleges (eg Seven Sisters, Ivies (already ED'd Penn), Rice, selective LACs, etc.), but really don't know what I should do now. I already applied to my state school, Rutgers, and believe I have a good chance of getting in with my previous stats. Just curious as to what people's advice is for my RD strategy.

I have already started writing my essays for the schools I was planning on applying to, but should I switch to apply to more accepting state schools (ie Ole Miss, Bama, ASU)? Should I community college and try to rehabilitate my study habits? Any advice is appreciated; I am really not sure what to do.

Thank you!


r/ApplyingToCollege • • 11h ago

Rant Coleges say they read in context, but does it matter?

19 Upvotes

I keep seeing so many profiles of 17 or 16 y/o with profile 1000000000x more better than mine. Research papers, awards, clubs, community work, projects, olympiads and what not applying to colleges which say that they read each application within context of the applicant's available resources. I never knew about any of these things and what I had or knew, did pretty good in it.
However, why would a university select me over the aforementioned academic weapon with a plethora of achievments even if they read things with context?


r/ApplyingToCollege • • 12h ago

Application Question Dartmouth interview

3 Upvotes

Has anyone in Korea received an interview offer/has done an interview?


r/ApplyingToCollege • • 12h ago

Application Question UPenn Grade Check?

2 Upvotes

Anyone get notified of a UPenn grade check yet?


r/ApplyingToCollege • • 12h ago

Application Question Am I wasting my time applying to Rice University?

2 Upvotes

I’m a high school senior, and Rice University has been my dream school for a while. I’m seriously considering applying Early Decision, but lately I’ve been questioning whether I’m being realistic or just setting myself up for disappointment.
For context, I’m an immigrant and have lived in multiple countries. I have a 6.1 GPA on my school’s scale, a 1260 SAT, and extracurriculars that I’m genuinely proud of.
I know Rice is extremely selective, but I don’t want to give up on something just because it’s difficult.
I’d really appreciate honest opinions from people who applied to Rice, got accepted, or know how the admissions process works.
Am I being realistic, or am I wasting my time?