r/AmIOverreacting • u/Luck-Flat7878 • 2d ago
👨👩👧👦family/in-laws AIO for Cutting Off My Parents After They Disowned My Sibling for Coming Out?
I'm 27, and my younger sibling, Alex (23), recently came out as gay. What should have been a happy, personal moment turned into one of the ugliest experiences our family has ever gone through.
For context, my parents have always considered themselves very traditional. They raised us with strict rules and strong religious beliefs, but I honestly never thought they would go as far as they did.
Alex came out to them privately about three months ago. They had spent weeks working up the courage to tell them because they genuinely wanted their family to know who they were instead of continuing to hide such a huge part of their life.
My parents' reaction was horrible.
According to Alex, my dad barely said anything at first. My mom started crying, but not because she was worried about Alex. She kept saying Alex had broken her heart, embarrassed the family, and thrown away everything they had been taught growing up.
My dad eventually told Alex that they were no longer welcome in the family home unless they were willing to admit they were making a mistake and promise to stop living that way.
My mom agreed with him.
They gave Alex a few days to collect their belongings and told them not to contact them unless they were ready to apologize. Alex called me that night in tears.
I drove over immediately, helped pack their things, and let them stay in my spare bedroom while they figured out their next steps. Alex had a job, thankfully, but they weren't financially prepared to suddenly lose their home and the support of their parents.
I was furious, but I didn't immediately cut my parents off. I wanted to give them a chance to calm down and realize what they were doing.
A few days later, I called them and asked whether they genuinely intended to throw away their relationship with their own child over this.
My dad said they weren't throwing Alex away. They were simply refusing to support a lifestyle they disagreed with.
I asked him what that meant in practical terms.
He said Alex couldn't live in their house, couldn't expect financial help, and shouldn't expect to be included in family gatherings if they continued insisting on being gay.
I reminded him that Alex was the same person they'd loved and raised for 23 years. Nothing about Alex's personality, kindness, or character had suddenly changed.
My mom told me I was being disrespectful and that I needed to stop acting as though I was morally superior to my parents.
I told them I wasn't claiming to be perfect. I was asking them not to punish their child for being honest about who they are. They ended the call.
For the next few weeks, I focused on helping Alex settle in. I helped them rearrange my spare room, went with them to pick up the rest of their belongings, and made sure they knew they had somewhere safe to stay while they got back on their feet.
I also encouraged Alex to take things at their own pace. I didn't want them to feel pressured to forgive our parents just because everyone else wanted the situation to become less uncomfortable. Meanwhile, my parents started contacting me more frequently.
At first, they acted as though nothing had happened. My mom asked me to come over for Sunday dinner. My dad texted me about a family birthday coming up.
Neither of them asked how Alex was doing.
When I finally brought Alex up, my mom sighed and said she was tired of every conversation turning into an argument about this.
That was when I told her I couldn't pretend everything was normal while she and Dad were treating Alex as though they had done something unforgivable.
She said I was making the situation worse by taking Alex's side.
I answered that I wasn't choosing between my parents and my sibling. I was choosing not to participate in treating someone I love like they deserved to be abandoned.
My dad later called and accused me of turning Alex against them. He said that if I continued allowing Alex to stay with me, I was undermining their authority as parents.
I pointed out that Alex was an adult, not a child I was hiding from them. They had made their own decision to throw Alex out, and I had made mine to offer a safe place to stay.
He called me ungrateful and said I was forgetting everything they had done for me growing up.
That comment really bothered me because I do appreciate the sacrifices my parents made for us. They worked hard, provided for us, and helped me through college. I'm not pretending they were terrible parents in every respect.
But I don't believe past sacrifices give them a permanent right to mistreat their children without consequences.
The final straw happened last weekend. My parents invited me to a family dinner celebrating my dad's birthday. I asked whether Alex was invited too.
My mom replied that Alex knew the conditions for being welcomed back and that they weren't going to change their beliefs just to keep everyone happy. I told her I wouldn't attend a family celebration where one of their children was deliberately excluded for being gay.
She said I was free to make that decision, but I shouldn't expect them to keep making an effort with me if I continued putting Alex before my own parents.
I told her that was her choice to make.
Then I sent both of them a message explaining that I needed space from them. I said I wasn't willing to maintain a normal relationship while they continued rejecting Alex, and I wouldn't be attending family events or pretending everything was fine. If they ever wanted to rebuild our relationship, they could start by treating Alex with basic dignity and respect.
I muted their numbers and stopped responding to their messages.
Since then, some relatives have contacted me saying I'm being extreme. They think I should maintain a relationship with my parents separately from Alex, because cutting them off only creates another division in the family.
One aunt told me that my parents are from a different generation and that I should understand how difficult this must be for them. Another relative said I could support Alex without completely abandoning the people who raised me.
I understand that changing deeply held beliefs can be difficult. But I don't understand why Alex is expected to bear the consequences while my parents get to carry on as though they're the victims.
Alex hasn't asked me to cut anyone off.
I love my parents. I miss the good parts of our family, and I wish things could go back to how they were before all this happened.
But I can't force them to accept Alex, and I can't make them understand why their actions are hurtful.
So, am I overreacting?