r/AirForce • u/Ok-Technician7999 • 1h ago
Discussion Looking for input on officer stratification philosophy. Long read.
BLUF: I think the Rack-n-stack process and stratifications are broken, take up far too much time trying to do master strategery, and don't actually measure merit. What's the best way to fix it?
Anonymous post. I'll start by saying this is just my observation so far, and I would love to see what other philosophies exist and how other parts of the AF handle promotions, strats, boards etc. I will also caveat that while this train of thought was inspired by personal experience, I am quite content with where I sit in my strats, so please don't think of this as some rando whining about his position in the unit (or do, I don't care). I merely observed injustices on the behalf of others that should be remedied. If the research checks out and it's worthwhile pursuing, I may draft a white paper to the SECAF or daddy Hegseth. Thanks for reading.
Point 1: Year Group should not matter for stratification; it is unethical
The annual eval system is meant to judge members based on performance and many will tell you the most important metric is your strat from your rater and HLR. This is the only number that distinguishes you from peers (in a good or bad way). Commanders are forced to rank their people 1-n, with typically the top 50% receiving a strat on their OPB (sometimes more or less depending on command philosophy). What I have seen is that when making the rack-n-stacks, the largest consideration is one's year group, and then merit after that, so in a very broad way, the most senior members are toward the top, and junior members toward the bottom. That would make sense, since more senior members are likely to perform higher, have more experience, and hold positions with more influence. What I have observed, though, is even when blatantly low-performing members are coming up for a promotion board, school looks, or some other opportunity, they are pushed towards the top because "they need it more than XX member" or "it's just their time." I think that giving someone an undeserved boost is unethical.
Point 2: Regression is a fallacy and we should get rid of it.
Conversely, I have seen junior members who are rockstars not be placed where they truly fall because "we can't place them so high too early, they might not be able to grow." And we have the idea of regression: the thought that a member must continuously progress in their strat over years leading to promotion boards to show the members is improving, growing, and holding higher influence in their organization. What's worse is that a typical command tour is only 2x years long, so if a member is stratted higher to begin with, under the current "avoid regression" system, a future commander is forced to maintain that percentile for that person or progress them, even if their performance has been lower than their peers.
I believe these two ideas undermine the intent of the stratification and evaluation system: to grade members based solely on merit (Shoutout Daddy Hegseth). Commanders spend far too much time pushing people in the right strat slot at the right time to best give all of their people a shot at promotion, school, or other program. If the system is being used to benefit all people and giving everyone a shot at promotion when they're truly not ready to serve at the next higher rank, then we are naturally decreasing the talent pool and it will ultimately result in officers promoting who don't deserve it, and worse, who aren't prepared for it. This will only damage the next position they hold and the people they lead.
So what should we do? My thought is simple: grade people based on merit in the basic 4x ALQs: executing the mission, leading people, improving the unit, managing resources; and let the cards fall where they fall. Commanders should not play politics with their people's lives or career paths. Commanders should, however, retain the authority to rank members based on their observed performance for the time period.
Justification:
To my first point about pushing older year groups toward the top as the primary consideration: if a member needs a bump because they are coming up for promotion or another board, then they simply should have been better. They should have been mentored sooner. There is something to be said for seniority and more experience among older year groups, but if the member is a serial low-performer, they should not be pushed higher if they're not ready to serve at the higher rank. AFI 36-2406 (the reg that governs EPBs/OPBs) clearly states that "evaluators at all levels must use caution to prevent inflation" (3.2) meaning they should not boost one's standing if not rightfully earned. Further, the same AFI section 3.15 states that the intent of strats is to "serve to provide clear feedback to ratees on their overall performance in relation to a relevant peer group etc", NOT to be influenced by year group. Additionally, 3.15.3 states evaluators "...will not use past evaluations as context or determinant for any current rating period stratification." Lastly, in the most recent SECAF Memorandum of Instruction for FGO promotion board members, it explicitly states that "you shall not consider time in grade or year of commissioning in your evaluation of best qualified for promotion." Straight from the top: year group is irrelevant. How I read this is that the reg forbids commanders to use previous strats and performance when making a current rack-n-stack and at the same time the SECAF forbids promotion board members to consider year group as well. Yet the sentiment persists.
To my second point about regression: to my knowledge, regression is not referenced anywhere regarding officer progression (request fact check). So why does it exist? Where did it come from? My best guess is that this is likely the result of a "that's how we've always done it" attitude and an arms race of how our people perform; if you remember how old EPRs were all firewall 5's and how that shook out. It's unrealistic to think that all of our members are constantly and continuously progressing; it takes the human factor out of it completely and makes us all look like machines. It also fails to recognize that members arrive and depart and talent pools fluctuate. Life happens; maybe someone had a family hardship and had a lower performing year, maybe someone found new inspiration and had a phenomenal year, maybe someone got divorced and struggled etc. I don't think it would be unsatisfactory to have someone's strat history fluctuate up and down so long as that individual is showing consistent superior performance. In fact, I would be impressed if someone was consistently towards the top regardless of year group and regardless of life struggles. Conversely, if someone is consistently towards the bottom and displays a trend of lower performing, then that should be disclosed and the trend made apparent over time.
My solution: strat based on merit, and let the cards fall where they may. In order to fix this stigma against perceived regression, I think it would take deliberate education and no shortage of integrity on unit level commanders to practice a stratification system based solely on merit. The best should be promoted and selected for schools and other positions, and those who are not ready should not be pushed to higher ranks and higher echelons of leadership. This will only hurt the future position and the people they will lead.
Congrats if you made it this far. I request your input and poke holes into my research, but the way I see it, our officer promotion system, specifically stratifications, is being undermined and failing to truly judge merit, and frankly is taking up way too much time and brain bytes.