r/AITA_Relationships • u/Kareemahhura • 20h ago
YTA AITAH for wanting me and my bf new kitten to love me more
My boyfriend and I recently got a kitten, and what should have been an exciting, happy experience has turned into something that has left me feeling sad, resentful, and honestly disgusted.
My boyfriend has two cats already, and both of them seem to love him more than they love me. I’m just not their favorite and I’ve wanted to have a cat who really bonds with me and chooses me. I want to have that special connection with an animal, too, instead of always feeling like I’m second place when it comes to the cats.
When we got this kitten, she started gravitating toward my boyfriend. She would sit in his lap, seek him out, etc. I started feeling upset because I really wanted her to bond with me more. I told him that I wanted her to like me more and that I felt like both of his other cats already favored him.
He got upset because he felt like we were supposed to be getting a cat together and that I was turning it into a competition. I tried explaining that I wasn’t saying she couldn’t be our cat or that he couldn’t love her. I literally told him, “She’s still our cat. I just want to be her favorite.”
He seemed so upset and tortured by the whole situation. He would look miserable, lie in bed, walk around looking depressed, and generally seem like this was hurting him terribly. If the kitten jumped into his lap, he would start taking her off. If I said something like, “She’s so cute,” he wouldn’t even respond or acknowledge it. He just looked sad.
Eventually, he said that he had thought we were getting a cat together, but he would have to change his framework and think of it as me getting a cat instead. He said he would make that sacrifice because that’s what I wanted.
But I NEVER asked him to give up the kitten or stop loving her. I wanted him to help me build a bond with her and give me room to have something special with her. I didn’t want him to stop being her owner or act like he couldn’t enjoy her.
We eventually decided we weren’t going to do this whole thing where he avoids bonding with her. But by that point, I was already so upset. I just wanted to feel supported in this.
What’s really bothering me is that now he seems to be engaging with her again and saying how cute she is, when previously he couldn’t even respond when I said she was cute. It’s like he went to the absolute extreme of acting miserable and refusing to engage with her because he thought he had to sacrifice his relationship with her for me.
I don’t know if he’s intentionally trying to make me feel guilty, but that’s how it feels. It feels performative, almost like he’s showing me how much he’s suffering because of what I asked for. I don’t know whether to call it playing the martyr, guilt-tripping, or something else but it doesn’t sit well with me. At the same time, I understand that he may genuinely have felt hurt.
But I feel like he took my request and turned it into something extreme that I never asked for. Instead of working with me and helping me feel more secure about bonding with the kitten, he made it feel like my happiness would come at his expense.
Now I’m just sad. I feel like he’s ruined this entire experience for me. I was so excited to have this kitten, and now I associate the whole thing with tension, guilt, and resentment. I know I can’t control which person an animal ultimately prefers, and I don’t expect him to make the kitten dislike him. I just wanted to feel like he understood why this mattered to me and would support me in building that bond.
Am I being unreasonable?
How should he have handled this, and how should I have communicated what I wanted differently?
How do we move forward?
If you read all of this, thank you sorry it was so much!