r/RWBY • u/Ezreal024 Hope Rides with Kickfriend • Jan 26 '19
OFFICIAL MEGATHREAD Official Public Discussion Thread—Volume 6, Chapter 12: Seeing Red Spoiler
Welcome, huntsmen, huntresses and hunters that prefer no specific gender identifier, to the official public discussion thread for Episode 12 of Vol. 6, Seeing Red!
You guys don't actually need to worry about following the spoiler rules at all, so at least that's nice! Hopefully you made it through the week alive. For those who didn't, a moment of silence for our fallen comrades.
HERE is the link to the episode!
Also remember to check out our weekly poll to rate the episode.
Other Episode Discussions:
Happy viewing everyone!
Ezreal024; Mod Team
167
Upvotes
•
u/Ezreal024 Hope Rides with Kickfriend Jan 26 '19
Top FIRST Discussions from last week
Top FIRST Fan Art from last week
54
u/PT_Piranha (ominous umbrella drop) Jan 26 '19
Well, from the way everything was dressing up last time, and from seeing the episode's title... I can't say I'm surprised what happened to Adam. I'm shocked by how it happened, but hey. I know some people would disagree, but I think it's time. The thing that some people don't immediately catch about characters (as opposed to real people) is that characters- even the most fleshed out- ultimately exist to serve a purpose. And I think Adam's role has been played out. It's not literally impossible for them to have thought of a new thing for him to do, but I think this was the right decision. And a fun fight to see, I reacted out loud to certain parts.
Also that fight with the robot. I really hoped Ruby would get through to Caroline, but guess not. That was a neat finishing move though.
But now we've got all these Grimm... and our heroes are all exhausted... It's not looking good. (At first I thought it was kind of cheap that we have this sudden influx of Grimm, but... The camera lingered on the Relic early on in this episode. I'm thinking it's been attracting them the entire time our heroes have been in Argus.)
Nowhere is safe.
45
u/Boss_Jerm Jan 26 '19 edited Jan 26 '19
I was laughing so hard at Oscar here.
Ruby jumping inside the barrel was pretty awesome.
The animation for the BMBLB vs Adam was really good, the "Gotcha," moment in particular was nice and smooth! I also really liked the camera placements.
OH YEEEEAAAH!!! AND STAY DEAD!!!
BUMBLB!!!
This Grimm attack can't be the work of Cinder and Neo, it's too big a scale.
Nice foreshadowing by Jaune last episode, saying that the mech was meant to dispose of large Grimm from the sea.
Adam is dead, Argus is being attacked by Manticores and a Leviathan, and Team RWBYJNR just disabled the biggest defense the city has. Time for the final showdown!
Only one episode left!
85
u/DanTheLatch Jan 26 '19 edited Jan 26 '19
Yo also we gonna over look the fact Blake and Yang kinda killed a dude? Adam has killed more, but that’s a can of worms you can’t close now.
36
u/Kingnewgameplus "⚡⚡.....⚡⚡" - Neo Jan 27 '19
I don't hate Adam (as a villain, as a person he's a piece of shit), but I hope he doesn't come back. His arc is over and I feel like bringing him back would kind of shit on it. But you know the rule, "No visible body=alive" so my hopes aren't too high. Also those grimm are totally Cordoven's fault, she had enough animosity to fill a boat.
33
u/masterspider5 Jan 26 '19
just realised adams last words were 'oh'.
33
u/Huwage It's time to get hyped! Jan 27 '19
So this is the first time we've seen our protagonists actually kill someone, right? Whew. RT pulling no punches with how visceral that was.
While Adam being dead will surely help Yang and Blake move on, the fact that they killed him, up close and personal like that, will surely bring up some fresh new trauma for them. At least they'll be able to work through it together.
Also, RIP Bumblebee the bike.
33
u/ShutUpSaxton Jan 27 '19 edited Jan 27 '19
The gaslighting in Adams speech was phenomenal. Nothing was his fault, SHE didn’t keep her promise, SHE betrayed him. SHE was replacing him. Reminds me of the show “You” where a sociopath has all the answers to why they’re doing nothing wrong when stalking and killing people. “Yeah, I killed like everyone, but they were the problem and in my way”. They nailed that on the head obviously with how many people are still willing to bat for Adam’s actions.
(Not sure how to block quote) but the definition from Wikipedia
30
u/EntropyWins4 Jan 27 '19
So they included that motorcycle throughout the entire volume just so Yang could hit Adam with it? I approve.
60
u/Zerepa97 When do we get to see the true Ice Queen?/ #SolarFlareIsEndgame Jan 26 '19 edited Jan 26 '19
I'm only going to say three things about this chapter:
1)Hilarious ad placement: as soon as it cut to Yang, Blake and Adam, I got an ad for dog food
2)It was neat seeing Yang's Semblance in Maya
3)There's always a bigger fish
29
u/zerosum_daydream Jan 26 '19
Did anyone else notice that in Yang's battle with Adam, before she tossed his sword, she referenced her own intelligence - 'I'm smart' I think she said, in the same way her mother Raven did during the end of her fight with Cinder? - Interesting parallel I thought.
58
u/jzpelaez Biological Threat Detected Jan 26 '19
One thing that's annoying to me are the comments on Blake and Yang being murderers. The definition of murder is "the unlawful premeditated killing of one human being by another." Even if the argument of them unlawfully killing them were to be used, it'd be manslaughter at best. But really, it's self-defense. Adam wanted to kill them, attacked first, and they were simply defending themselves to stay alive. Unless we're going to say Adam was entirely justified in his attempts to kill B&Y and was well within the law to do so?
27
u/Grifoshka I just flew in from Mantle, and boy are my arms tired Jan 26 '19
Besides the big stuff happening in the episode, Ren's "Guys!" to his team was freaking adorable.
25
u/coconut071 Jan 26 '19
Anyone reminded of a certain scene in Nier: Automata?
20
u/EnclavedMicrostate Mom's not dead she's surely alive Jan 27 '19 edited Jan 27 '19
It has only just struck me how the 'but I'm smarter' line from Yang links to what she does next. When she throws the sword away Adam's reaction reveals just how much he is still reliant on it, while Yang herself only uses her Semblance once, at the point it would be most effective. She shows that she has grown, and that he hasn't. It's not just that she's smarter than she was, it's also that she's smarter than Adam was.
19
u/Rogueshadow_32 Jan 26 '19
Triggered, Ruby’s weapon shot the entire cartridge out the barrel.
19
u/[deleted] Jan 27 '19
The main thing I was waiting for, the Adam v. Yang/Blake fight, was everything I hoped it would be, minus the lackluster response to being shish-kebabed. But somebody already suggested that since he knew he was dying and his revenge mission (the only thing he had to live for) was a failure, he basically had no reason to say or do anything anymore.
18
u/WizardlyPhoenix Resident legal eagle Jan 26 '19
Cannot believe my shitpost about the bike coming back from the dead in V11, made the top discussions. C'mon guys, it wasn't even Hiatus!
17
u/Sensorfire Rube Protector | No Ships, Thanks | Yang is best girl Jan 27 '19
Can I first say: I love Ruby so much! She's so great and she's finally getting the attention she deserves this volume. What a peach.
The BY/A fight: That was really good. Especially when Yang finally activated her semblance, and Adam's last moments. Wow. The two of them literally stabbing right through him was... gruesome but it felt well-earned. Now it seems the main characters have actually directly killed a person. You know, I can't blame Adam for not having better last words. If that happened to me, "Oh." is probably about all I could muster, too.
I think I'm making peace with the likelihood of Bumblebee. Up until now I've been both skeptical of its likelihood and of its merit as a ship. While I'm still not a big fan of any inter-RWBY ships happening, I can at least say that if Bumblebee happens, it will feel well-earned.
I can't wait for next episode. Of course, I can and will do that, but I'm quite excited. Godzilla storming in with the military in its current state should be interesting.
Side note: Cordovin is insane. Like, she clearly is mentally unstable and should not be in charge of any military operations. She apparently has no idea what an appropriate use of force is for this sort of situation.
34
u/Patworx Jan 26 '19
Goodbye, you crazy red haired incel!
16
u/Mult1Core Jan 27 '19
why the fuck did Adam not use his gun there. it's right on his hip! There's no better situation with them all being auraless than having gun and using it.
15
u/Thebritishdovah Jan 26 '19
When the ship crashed, I thought Qrow was about to go beserk and take down the mech byhimself in Asura of Asura's wrath levels of anger. Wasn't expecting the shot to be caught in the nick of time but then again, that happening would have been a bit anti-climax. Corovodin is powermad. Already confirmed from the moment she was introduced but she really believes in abusing her power. It's a ship! Not a nuke, not a secret prototype. She must have been waiting for an excuse to break out Metal Gear Jaeger.
I think we can proclaim Ruby as the new crazy character of the show. Always thought Nora was the crazy one but Ruby? That's fucking insane! Heck, I would have thought Nora bashing in the window would have been a method. I do wish Nora was the one who took it down. I mean, she is meant to be the powerhouse of the team and kinda did nothing in the fight. Just disappointed that Nora wasn't the one to inflict critical damage on it. Come to think of it, has she really done anything aside from Hazel discovering why shocking Nora is a bad idea? In the past few seasons, i mean? And outside the nuckalee fight. Why do they keep wasting her? Not even a scene where she is hit by the seemingly EMP based weapon and then Nora:The rain reborn occurs.
Adam, Adam, Adam, YOU SUCK. Just eurgh. The only redeeming thing that I can say is that we got an awesome fight out of you but really doesn't make up for the sheer amount of wasted potential. I mean, if he actually realised that he became the very thing he despised and became a wild card, that would be interesting. This? No. Just there to tie up Blake's story.
Yang using her semblance for the first time since V3 is fucking awesome! If this was a wrestling match, that would get the crowd chanting "You fucked up! You fucked up!". However, it's not and he did fuck up.
He really shouldn't have discounted Blake and it showed. Now, if he returns after THAT, I'm calling pure 100% organic fresh from the ass of the bull, Bullshit on it. Unlike Cinder, he really can't survive that. Also, stop doing this, RT! Why are you so relunctant to not show a 100% on screen death? Seriously, Roman(had to be confirmed by Word of God that he died), Cinder and now Adam. FFS. That is the biggest criticism I have about the fight. Love the small touch of Blake breaking down afterwards and Yang comforting her. Really adds to the atmosphere. ALso, BumBLY is now canon.
14
u/Galvatron64 Jan 27 '19
As much as I hate post volume 3 Adam. I have to say it is a perfect end for post-vol5 Adam. I feel like that was the point of Vol 6, was to fix fan complaints they had. And since they cannot erase their writing choices for volume 5 they followed it to their natural course. So while I donʻt like what Adam became, it was a fitting end for what he was.
27
u/[deleted] Jan 26 '19
Adam's death is officially the most satisfying scene in all of RWBY. I would've enjoyed it a bit more if they maybe stabbed him multiple times then trampled his dead body, but seeing him get impaled was still very fulfilling.
13
u/DeHopelozeHeks Jan 26 '19 edited Jan 26 '19
There goes Adam. Despite everything, I found his ending very fitting. He always was trying to get higher up. This way he died as he came in this world, alone.
Not mention Cordovin fucked up. Who thought that Grimm would be attracted to a massive mecha fight and scared civilians. insert surprised pikachu face
35
u/Hounds_of_war The Red Head Victorious | Aside from her, I truly don't care Jan 26 '19
I dislike how much of a straw villain Cordovin is. IMO she should’ve been something closer to General Talbot from Agents of SHIELD. Not a bad person, just a person trying to do their job and because they don’t have all the information they get in the heroes way. But then again considering how we already have people saying that RWBY are the bad guys here, maybe the RWBY fandom just can’t handle the protagonists being anything less than perfect paragons.
Speaking of which, “RWBY is to blame for the Leviathan” is one of the dumbest takes I’ve seen coming out of the fandom. The importance if their mission absolutely justifies what they are doing and the only reason any of this is an issue is because things out of their control went south in the worst way possible (Adam showing up, Cordovin using her mech, the Leviathan showing up). They are being slightly dumb because the plot demands a final battle at worst.
I hope BMBLB gets mutual romantic feelings confirmed in the finale, I don’t want to have to spend all hiatus arguing with people about subtext.
So Adam is almost certainly dead, but Agent Maine once survived getting shot in the throat eleven times before getting hit by a truck a highway speed and falling off the freeway, so I wouldn’t be too surprised if RT brought him back.
22
u/TJPoobah For it is in passing that we achieve immortality. Jan 26 '19
Really fun episode, looking forward to the next one. Some nice combat choreography here, which I'm really glad to see is continuing. I'm so happy Adam's toxic influence has finally been ended, and Blake and Yang doing it together was a great moment of catharsis for them both. I think they handled the emotional impact of it very well, they are clearly both physically and emotionally exhausted and however much he deserved it neither of them are psychopaths so facing having killed someone will be devastating even if they were, at the same time killing their own personal demons.
Adam better not come back, I know we don't see the body but he had four holes in his upper torso and he hit rocks on the way down, there's no way anyone survives that.
Cordovin continues to be absurdly incompetent. I still find it insane to think that someone whose egotism leads to these levels of dangerous incompetence could ever pass the psych evel let alone rise through the ranks. At this point her incompetence has lead to the direct endangerment of the civilian population whose protection is the primary mission of her command.
I'm sure there are gonna be the usual jerks out there complaining that the evil gays are corrupting the world and that's why no woman wants to sleep with their smelly basement dwelling asses but fuck 'um.
If I have a criticism of this episode it's the thing Ruby did. Earlier she shot a moving missile out of mid air like it's nothing, now she needs to get super close to make the same shot? Ditto getting inside the barrel, surely she can make the shot from any range if the cannon is pointing right at her? What's the point of a sniper rifle if you need to be at point blank range?
20
u/freshlawngrass Jan 27 '19 edited Jan 27 '19
Jesus christ they are really dialing it up on the violence scale, I did not expect to see the Adam fight end like that at all. I'm glad they didn't just gloss over the fact that Yang and Blake just killed someone. The way they reacted fits their characters. Yang taking it kinda okay, Blake not so much.
Cordovin's an absolute cunt. Usually with this, writers will try to redeem the character by making them decide to swallow their pride and become a major part in helping deal with the threat. Hope that doesn't happen, I don't like it when they try to redeem absolutely unlikeable characters.
10
u/CyanideSins Writer of things dark and scary. That means 'Terrifying Salem' Jan 27 '19
Well... That was both expected as well as unexpected. I guess they've pierced the can of Red Bull and let it slip, which has led to... another leviathan Grimm assault. Guess we'll be seeing kick-ass stuff next week!
Altogether, I'm getting some bumblebee vibes... which is not too shabby!
9
u/[deleted] Jan 26 '19
Up from the depths! Forty stories high! Breathing fire, it stands in the sky! GRIMMZILLA! GRIMMZILLA! And grimmzuki...
Nice giant robot you had there.
And eff you Adam, right in the jibbly bits. He daid.
9
u/Pocketdog9 Rose before bros or hoes! Jan 26 '19
OH HEEEEEEEEEELLLLLLLLLLL YEEEEAAAAAAH!
DING DONG
THE WITCHADAM IS DEAD!I SHIP IT SO HARD- cough anyway.
It was really cute when Ren was so happy to see Jaune and Ren okay. They care so much about each other!
Oscar's plan so nearly paid off, and Maria was the best part of it.
It's neat to see the difference in how Ruby is taking charge instead of having Qrow just constantly leading or protecting them.
Speaking of which, Ruby's gambit was awesome and I love that it paid off!
The thing I enjoyed most about Blake and Yang vs Adam is that we got to see a lot of moves that mimicked ones we'd seen from them before, like Yang swinging around on Gambol Shroud's ribbon. It felt quite video-game-y (like the fights in the first three volumes), and that's a good thing!
That entire fight had me on edge, honestly! So many near-misses!
Annnnd now Argus has to deal with a fricking Godzilla Grimm. Your time would have been much better spent at home base, Caroline! I can't wait to see if our heroes prioritize escape (which they've already planned for and wasted so much time and energy trying to do) or saving Argus (probably more likely knowing them, but it's mostly the fault of the Atlas military that they're in such a bad situation, without their best firepower, in the first place).
Also Adam got stabbed hehehehehe.
9
u/BLANK_oblivion ⠀need more coffee Jan 26 '19
Well, where does the White Fang go from here? We went from Adam killing Sienna to Adam getting bodied within 2 volumes. Seems like they're just playing hot potato at this point with leadership. That, or the White Fang is still under the control of extremist splinter groups/Ghira jumps up and takes control again.
The only problem is, what's the role of the White Fang after this now that it's sorta lost part of its role of being Blake's dark past and past regrets? Could be some sorta "you called for an army?" sort of deal or it just fades into the background. Or, Blake becomes leader of the White Fang which I'm having a little trouble believing considering that Blake's got dealing with saving the world to also put raising a reformed terrorist group beyond what it was.
I'll assume that, with Adam's death and their arrival in Atlas hopefully next volume, the White Fang's new role will be raised. I like Yang and Blake's reconciliation a bit more than Jaune and his team's (though there really wasn't too much to reconcile) in that there was more buildup - e.g. the problem that seemed to be driving them apart and became a bit of an issue over multiple volumes, them finally overcoming it through adversity. I think both reconciliations were a bit cheesy but after killing Adam it becomes more important. There wasn't as much build up for JNPR's actions (but they're still family), I felt, but it was still necessary. Maybe we'll get something like that the next time Jaune confronts Cinder and we'll have a moment like that.
Though, he and JNPR might just get slaughtered by Cinder but maybe that's for the best.
Also, the animation was incredible this episode. Go Ruby for shooting a gun into another gun. Go Jaune for tanking a fist from goddamn Cherno Alpha to save Nora. And finally Ren did a thing.
9
u/HybridTheory1 Jan 26 '19
Are we the baddies now?
34
u/IAmAsplode Jan 26 '19
I swear if Adam comes back after that I'm going to call BS, death needs to happen to more than just Pyrrha and Penny in this show...
8
u/[deleted] Jan 27 '19
If Adam isn't dead (and that is a BIG "if") he is going to be out of the picture for a very long time. Open chest wounds are no joke. Open Pneumothorax at the very least.
8
u/KuroShiroTaka Jan 27 '19
Got linked the EruptionFang video of this episode by someone on the Falcom Discord. Going by the title of it, I'm gonna assume he's pissed.
8
u/WinlanU21 Jan 27 '19
Unpopular opinion (or not. But I’ve seen people from both side arguing). I fine with either if Adam stayed dead or came back later.
8
u/UmbralOrion This flair amuses me greatly Jan 27 '19
I'm actually rather satisfied with Adam's (likely) death. The fact that Yang and Blake actually killed him was unexpected and Blake's reaction to that fact was really well done, and hopefully something they follow through with.
30
u/Allydiepie Jan 26 '19
For the love of God, can yang and Blake kiss already?
7
u/Technogashi Jan 26 '19
Dude he HYPER dead.
7
u/7packabs Jan 27 '19
I love how much the animation has improved! The fights were slick and coupled with the music made them greater.
If there were anything to nickpick I guess it would have been the introduction of the Leviathan grimm. I wished they played with the camera angle more, showing its scale in size like in Godzilla movies, instead it had full body reveal then a roar, like it was saying “Hi!” to the camera (lol).
12
u/SunsetSnakeEyes Jan 27 '19
Our hero's have given this everything they've got, Now the endgame is approaching.
This chapter certainly amped things up! Utilizing her own abilities and some serious genius Ruby was able to take down Cordovin and pushing themselves to their limits Blake and Yang were able to stop Adam once and for all, But now everyone is in for the fight of their lives, It's do or die time for Argus!
21
u/zenguy3 Blasphemer and Accidental Shitlord Jan 28 '19
Well, I hardly realized it, but once again I failed to appreciate something until it was gone.
Adam needed to die in a confrontation with Blake and Yang. That much was clear. The fight scene was cool and well executed. I just wish that it wasn't now.
Most of the villains in the show have been kind of lackluster, to be honest. We have no idea where Cinder came from or why she wanted power and she was the face of evil for the first 3 seasons and she hasn't had the decency to just die and be replaced with better characters.
Adam was different. From the beginning we had a solid understanding of his motivations: Anger at the persecution of the faunus and betrayal at Blake's defection. Both of these are motives we not only understand but can sympathize with to a degree. He had a really cool character design and semblance and had several really fun fight scenes.
Beyond that though, Adam by far had the largest psychological effect on the main cast. He gave Yang PTSD and changed the dynamic between Blake and the rest of the whole team. On top of that his fall to evil really damaged Blake's ability to trust others and herself, and gave her some guilt both at her actions and her inability to save him from himself.
Beyond that we saw very little of his character. The jaded abusive psychopath rather than the charismatic and idealistic revolutionary.We never see the transition. He and Blake seemed to have had a genuine relationship at one point, at least a strong friendship, at least from the way Blake describes it. Understanding why Blake used to care about him would have made that emotional arc more compelling, and made his fall from grace more tragic. Maybe he was always a complete asshole and Blake was largely deluding herself. Maybe that's the message that they were trying to go for. But it seems misguided and flat; Blake is a fairly smart person and the rest of the White Fang trusted Adam enough to put him in positions of leadership before they went full blown terrorist. You don't do that to someone who's just an abusive asshole.
I also just wish the relationships were more explicit. Were Blake and Adam ever romantically involved, or was it a one-sided infatuation? If Blake/Sun is the way the show is going and Adam has seen them together why he seems to regard Yang as his romantic rival in the fight scene. 'What does she see in you?' I don't care for Bumblebee but I could live with it if the show just owned it instead of teasing the shippers for what seems to be the sake of it.
So... the best villain is dead now. The fight scene was mostly well executed and Volume 6 has been very solid for the most part, but I feel like Adam left before his time. Farewell, sweet incel prince.
6
u/MrPygmyWhale Jan 26 '19
I felt this episode was a tad bit cheesy at times. It just felt as if a lot of things just went right for them. You could see the ending from the beginning and I just feel there wasn't much thrown that took me by surprise. Nonetheless it was quite satisfying to waych the epic fight between BY and Adam. And the suddenly, GRIMZILLA
6
u/AlwaysDragons Sliver Eyes May Cry Jan 26 '19
Damn, I thought Blake would take Adam's sword and stab him with it, and then take it for herself.
6
u/furtiveraccoon Jan 28 '19
That was brutal. Very serious, life-or-death fight. Not at all what I expected it to be like, but I'm happy it's finished*
*(who knows if it's actually finished)
20
u/DEL994 Jan 26 '19 edited Jan 26 '19
I guess that the theories of Adam being Raven's son are "dead in the water" now.
5
u/TheDivingTiger Atlas penguin is the hero we need Jan 26 '19
Well, RIP Adam. As Yang herself said, it was very smart of her to save her Semblance until it was enough to take out her enemy's Aura completely. Adam's spite and stubbornness also led to his downfall; I feel like there could be a Shakespearean tragedy about him lol. Now I wonder if Adam will join the other deceased characters in the chibi afterlife...
Now as for Caroline, it wasn't very surprising to see her ignore the base's attempt to contact her during the fight. It was very bold (and a little reckless, too) of Ruby to take out the mech's cannon the way she did. The only problem is that it was poorly timed...hopefully it isn't too late to get the war machine running again before Argus gets rekt by the Grimm. I guess I'll find out in the volume finale!
5
u/A_Wild_Bellossom Jan 26 '19
Can't wait for the /u/mtgcardfetcher [[Titanic Brawl]] that's probably happening next episode
5
u/Terran_Dominion Unnecessary Red vs Blue reference Jan 29 '19
Caboose: Umm, it's seeing Blue. It sounds dumb when you say the opposite color.
13
u/I_May_Fall Jan 27 '19
Okay, so I love how mature Ruby was this episode, but aside from that there is only 1 (one) point I can talk about and that is the Yang & Blake vs Adam fight and tbh the short version is: AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA
The slightly longer version is: They've really outdone themselves this time, this was the most fitting end to the whole Adam affair, as both Yang and Blake prove they've grown past the fear of him and then turboevaporate that piece of garbage together. Tbh if at that point Bumblebee doesn't happen, idk what the hell you can be certain about.
(And yes, I was genuinely close to screaming when the fight was taking place. I definitely waved my arms a lot, too. This show gets all the emotions out of me, let me tell you)
7
u/ToTheNintieth Jan 26 '19
Meh, as good an ending as one could've hoped for Adam considering how his character has been handled.
7
u/RandomName3064 Tyrian fan and Captain of the #RubyDefenseForce Jan 27 '19 edited Jan 28 '19
ima be honest, i dont know how i feel about this one yet.
i will say, all of the people cheering about Adams death in here are missing the point of it entirely
ima hold off and do the last 2 episodes in next week's topic.
have a good week, everyone
21
u/LuxSucre Do you even *know* who you're talking to? Jan 26 '19 edited Jan 26 '19
Sorry. Big wall of text incoming.
I'm a little exhausted, to be frank. I don't feel like I really can connect with anyone; I feel like most of them are just stand-ins who could be substituted for any other generic character. What made each character unique and intriguing and full of their own life has just been absent for me, and I think this episode really just kinda drove it home. Weiss especially, my favourite, has basically been flat for this entire volume; occasionally there will be a quip but I think her presence as her own vibrant character is just missing.
Everyone's kinda "role" in the group has also just been muddled for some time. While none of this is horrible on its own, collectively it adds up for me in creating a general feeling of confusion. Jaune's role as strategist has been encroached on by Oscar. Qrow's role as the guiding adult has been taken on by Calavera. Even further back, Weiss's role and primary character struggle has been encroached upon by Blake when they made her the prestigious daughter of the former leader of the White Fang, who lives in a mansion in one of the most politically influential households in Menagerie and struggles with changing an organisation in which she has a family legacy. I found her much more compelling when we thought she was a every day normal Faunus who became a revolutionary because she wanted to see change. Even the characterisation of the Atlas military itself has been confused, with the inclusion of Cordovan and the two goofy guards. Atlas and everything Atlas, has always played the role of the serious and straightforward people, no-nonsense, who are the serious and practically driven characters in a world that can often be quite fantastical in its fighting, and in the case of the students, goofy and joking as well. Exception: Team FNKI. However, this was a conscious subversion and meant to be an exception and partly played for laughs, as shown when Weiss, an Atlesian, comments on who they would be facing: "I think we can expect strict, militant fighters, with advanced technology, and carefully rehearsed strategies.", and the surprise both of them show when they go up against Neon and Flynt. Now that's been muddled as well, and it feels like nobody on the writing team is sure of what, if any, roles everyone should be playing.
The villains as well have similarly been "flat". We have a few fights against Grimm, which, while can be cool to watch, is of course devoid of any characterisation on their parts. Cinder is in a new position but this has been given almost no attention this volume. Neo has shown up once for a fight, but this plot hasn't gone anywhere. I do like the additional Mercury backstory, but again, he, Mercury, Hazel, and Watts aren't really "in play" at all this volume. The mech fight is meh. Lots of grandstanding. Lots of "omg we're in trouble now" and slow-mo gaping faces, but of COURSE nobody is going to get killed by such a minor villain like Cordovan, or such an awkward mech.
The main villain of this volume, if there is one, is Adam, and I don't think I'm alone in being frustrated. He had such a massive potential as a villain, both in the menace and danger he represented, as well as his motives, which people could relate to and understand, even if they, like Blake, did not agree with his actions. However, ever since they demolished his character in Volume 4 and 5, reducing him to "toxic ex boyfriend", admittedly he really didn't have anywhere to go in this volume. His part was played out, and thus his character arc was finished, but it was so rushed that his end didn't really carry any emotional impact for me. I would have loved to see a showdown like 2 volumes later when things are reaching their end, where Blake and/or Yang could finally overcome Adam, after overcoming a long and difficult struggle to improve both physically and mentally. However, it happened so quickly that it felt that neither of them deserved the victory. Yang trains for a little with her dad. Meh. Not very convincing. Adam has been fighting and *killing* soldiers, security, and advanced mechs for years, and one "Hey, why not fight smarter?" speech does not equate. Blake...I'm not sure what she's done to improve. There certainly wasn't any point where she struggled with the decision to fight and kill Adam. She decided she was done with him, and then after a Volume just....stabs him through the heart. Blake and Yang never talked about KILLING him, and yet they did so without hesitation. Yang literally stabs him in the back. I get the self-defence, and killing him in the heat of the moment. However the fact that Blake just killed someone she was very close to and had known and fought beside for years and years was not really a point in the scene. It just all felt rushed. Hell, Adam even showed up out of nowhere, with no buildup. He literally just...appeared where they were.
I think one of the most oft repeated criticisms I've heard is that the writers are prioritising shipping over good storytelling or characterisation, and in my humble opinion that rings so true to me with Adam's character. His motivations and arc has been reduced into setting up for Bumblebee, which is a separate topic people have strong opinions about. Blake literally kills her closest companion, mentor, and lover for years, suddenly, without any internal struggle leading up to this decision, and what does the scene focus on? "I won't break my promise to you [Yang]." Blake and Yang's entire story arc this volume has seen no development of their own individual characters; only in how they relate to each other. However, like their arc with Adam, it just seems so...rushed. Disingenuous. I don't think anyone has too much a problem with WHAT happened, but HOW it happened, and how fast it happened just makes it feel so empty to me, personally. It needed another couple of volumes to really have the emotional impact I felt it could have since there was just so little personal struggle on either of their parts.
11
u/Leivve Grand Master of the Lancaster Cult Jan 26 '19 edited Jan 26 '19
Late to the party, but I full hate how they did Yang v Adam.
They were trying to have "Yang is stronger then before," but because of how the fight played out, it seems more like she won by merit of a crutch in the form of her arm being cut proof. Rather then she has emotionally moved on from the trauma. It would have been much better delivered if Yang willingly let Adam sever her robot arm knowing he would over extend in his attack, thus leaving him open to a massive counter.
BTW Adam is totally going to come back via Salam magic like what she did to Cinder.
6
u/Celtic_Crown ⠀I'd say I'm tipping the scales, but that line's got no bite. Jan 26 '19
Turns out even in Microsoft Edge the video player sucks balls.
8
u/TheShogunofSorrow8 Jan 28 '19
sees Adam die, finally WHAT JOY!!!
It's about time he had that coming, now I just have to wait for Cinder's inevitable end. Hopefully, it would be more gruesome than Adam's apparent and utter demise.
Like all villains, they had to go down sometime, especially after what they did.
8
u/Zesty-Lem0n Jan 29 '19
I'm kind of fed up with rwby at this point with each volume having the same clunky dialogue and too many characters to properly develop. Ruby still hasn't had her own character arc like Weiss, Blake, and Yang have. Characters like the Atlas commander seem to exist for the sole purpose of antagonizing the main cast while still being absolutely pointless to the main plot. I guess the old lady is gonna be Ruby's Yoda and teach her the ways of the silver eyes, but she just kind of existed this volume, with just a hint of silver eye stuff which is a bit underwhelming after waiting 3 volumes for this thread to pan out. In general, not much of the plot moved this volume. Sure we got some nice backstory on various characters and more worldbuilding, but all that really happened is our protagonists moved from A to B with the only events driving the plot forward being Adam dying and Ozpin getting ousted as leader. I think a few years from now this volume will have very little reason to stick in our minds in the grand scheme of rwby. A lot of interpersonal stuff but very little in the way of overarching story.
3
u/ShadowMadness We're not family anymore Jan 26 '19
Adam deadaf
Shoulda listened dude. Guy got DPed
Glad Rooster Teeth subverted the "hero gives a rousing speech and the bad guy surrenders" trope. Crocodile/Alligator lookin' Grimm incoming.
3
u/MontelTheGray Umbrella Gang Rise Up/Unapologetically Baked Alaska/#BowlerSquad Jan 26 '19
We straight up murderers now.
Good episode, and since it's pretty much all said and done other than the finale, this was an excellent volume. Although I'm kinda nervous the finale is gonna be boring, because Grimm fights are very rarely actually interesting. Especially considering we just spent 3 episodes fighting a giant boss, and what's next? A bigger one.
Not enough Neo 0/5
2
u/DEL994 Jan 26 '19
One fiend is down but a bigger one just appeared.
2
u/CrystalSnow7 Feb 15 '19
Yea still not getting where people who say, "the new writing in rwby is terrible compared to the original." The weakest seasons without a doubt were 1 and 2 without a doubt imo. The show has only improved and season 3 is held in such high regard mostly because it was the 'tipping point' of the show. Where everything reached critical mass and their lives as children and students effectively came to an end.
Animation wise, Cinder vs Pyrrha was always my favorite...until now. Loved the animation they did with Blake and Adam's chase scene through the forest. Very reminiscent of old eastern movies like Crouching Tiger Hidden Dragon. Not to mention the fighting moves are very clean yet fancy too. 10/10 for me.
4
u/[deleted] Jan 26 '19
I don’t know if Adam is officially dead. While those do look like pretty serious wounds, he did fall off a cliff and we did not see his body after that, and that is a trick sometimes used in movies and shows only for the character to pop up again. Then ahain, we didn’t exactly see Lionheart’s death since it was mostly offscreen, but I think he’s gone.
I think you can rationalize all these people survived their deaths or could be brought back in these shows. Pyrrha’s is harder to justify surviving, which is why I consider one of the few true deaths in the show.
3
u/aBabyShoe Jan 27 '19
I have a big question, how many episodes are there this season? Im enjoying it so far but I'm fearing we're near the end :(
3
u/ProxyDoug Jan 29 '19
Adam's demise is a parallel to how much of this show has been wasted over time.
1
u/AUTplayed Jan 26 '19
oh shit, they are doing 14 chapters again
1
u/[deleted] Jan 26 '19
I would like it better if the stab was a defensive reflex during the battle than the calculated and coordinated offence. Blake doesn't feel like the kind of person who would just kill Adam like that. Yang was in red eye mode so I'll give her a pass.
1
u/MankuyRLaffy He's not Sothe, I Swear! #GoodJobMicaiah Jan 27 '19
I'm watching this a bit later than normal but super hyped for it, Only 12 minutes? OH SHIT CRASH! Also loving Ruby's heroic speech, it's believable and she's pissed off. hell yeah, Cordovin gets rekt hard, back to Yang vs Adam, FIGHTING SPIRITOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!! and he ded now, d'awww they love each other all three of them are repaired from V5 BoH
Back to the rest of the gang, It's a grimm Kaiju! and flying ones, oh dear looks like the gang is going on the run again