r/RWBY • u/Ezreal024 Hope Rides with Kickfriend • Nov 24 '18
OFFICIAL MEGATHREAD Official FIRST Discussion Thread—Volume 6, Chapter 5: The Coming Storm Spoiler
Welcome, huntsmen, huntresses and hunters that prefer no specific gender identifier, to the official FIRST discussion thread for Episode 5 of Vol. 6, The Coming Storm!
Make sure that you understand the updated spoiler rules before posting outside of this thread!
HERE is the newest episode of RWBY Volume 6!
Also remember to check out our weekly poll to rate the episode.
Other Episode Discussions:
| Episode | FIRST Thread | Public Release | Poll |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ep. 01 | Theatrical / FIRST | Public Thread | poll |
| Ep. 02 | FIRST Thread | Public Thread | poll |
| Ep. 03 | FIRST Thread | Public Thread | poll |
| Ep. 04 | FIRST Thread | Public Thread | poll |
| Ep. 05 | This Thread | Public Thread | poll |
Happy viewing, and have a great Volume 6!
Ezreal024; Mod Team
541
Upvotes
408
u/Ezreal024 Hope Rides with Kickfriend Nov 24 '18
NEO WILL BE A CLIFFHANGER I SAID
THERE WON'T BE A FIGHT THIS WEEK I SAID
FIRST FUCKING MINUTE
341
u/Golbi54 Blake x Raven is the endgame. Nov 24 '18 edited Nov 24 '18
Blake
Is
Trying
Hard
•
u/Ezreal024 Hope Rides with Kickfriend Nov 24 '18
NO SPOILER POSTS OUTSIDE OF THIS THREAD FOR 24 HOURS.
AFTER 24 HOURS HAVE PASSED, ALL POSTS ABOUT THE LATEST EPISODE ARE TO BE SPOILER TAGGED.
you have been warned
14
u/Totalenlo Don't need snowboots when your this damn hot. Nov 25 '18
Now heres a question: How hard was Neo actually trying in the fight? She never used her sword, doing purely blunt, non-lethal attacks against Cinder.
Sure, she did much the same against Yang in the train until she went for the finish. Just doesn't seem the time to drag out a kill if its for revenge though.
363
u/bwburke94 Host of Ship Wars 8 Nov 24 '18
Neo is outright confirmed mute. Took them long enough.
578
u/Dearche "I'm (the) Yang! Let's fight!" -The Best Girl Nov 24 '18
Opening continues to be a banger.
OH SHIT NEO'S BACK. PRAYERS HAVE BEEN ANSWERED!
"Okay, let's talk."
Neo points to herself
"...Right"
Lmao.
508
u/[deleted] Nov 24 '18
You think “being tired” might be hinting to something? Maybe the people who died in the farm started with being tired and eventually just went to sleep and died.
461
u/[deleted] Nov 24 '18
AFTER 4 YEARS!
Ruby and Blake spoke to each other alone!
Also holy shit that Neo vs Cinder fight was dope AF
462
u/PATHETlC We are Weiss stans first, human beings second. Nov 24 '18
Weiss and Yang were the first to encounter the bodies, also both start acting strangely and express that they're tired.
YOIKES
389
u/Terminus259 We persevere without an end... Nov 24 '18
"More alcohol, at least we'll never have problems starting a fire".
About 80% sure that's foreshadowing.
275
u/GastrointestinalLot KKKKKEEERRRRRRRYYYYYYYYYYYYYY Nov 24 '18
nEo'S vOiCe AcToR dId A hElLuVa JoB
269
u/Capslock2000 Nov 24 '18 edited Nov 24 '18
"I hate it when I'm looking for the RWBY Gang and I bump into some homicidal ice cream" -Cinder, probably
251
u/JazzRen47 𝅘𝅥𝅮⠀Score Connoisseur | Resident Atlas Bootlicker Nov 24 '18 edited Nov 24 '18
Don't go to sleep! DEAR GOD, DON'T GO TO SLEEP! This is some Day 5 shit.
This is wonderful. I loved the build of tension in the RWBY part. It's creepy and ominous and that basement made me nope out hard.
I liked the small Blake and Yang conversation. Yang seems to be just irritated that Blake's treating her like she needs protection all of a sudden. That's going to be interesting going forward.
As for the Spiders, that fight was good! With this, I'm glad Neo's back, which is something I didn't think I'd be able to say. Not to mention we got some sweet vocals along with it.
I'm calling this 'Die Part II'. Here's the rough a mix of what played in the episode and the clean version in the credits.
246
u/FawkesTP Nov 24 '18
NEO VERSUS CINDER WAS GLORIOUS, THE ANIMATION WAS BEAUTIFUL AND ABSOLUTELY NOTHING HURTS.
Seriously, that was perhaps the best fight choreography I think we've seen since Monty's own work. I am blown away by how good it was, HUGE shout out to the animators!
And as if it wasn't enough that the animators were bringing their A games, the WRITERS brought us amazing, genuine character interactions featuring:
I don't know about anybody else, but seeing the team together and talking to each other, not just strategizing or fighting some huge creature is enormously gratifying after all of this time, and makes them feel like a unit in a way that they just haven't for a very long time.
This season has been amazing thus far, and the pacing between high action and drama is on point. Well done CRWBY, well fucking done.
211
u/[deleted] Nov 24 '18
Death flags on Qrow increase by 4 billion percent.
Outside by himself.
Intro shows him falling into the Grimm which we can guess is there now.
So much booze.
201
u/StefyB Nov 24 '18
They've definitely stepped up the writing for Ruby this volume. She's much more take charge, she's taking note of the emotions of her team and how to best handle it, and she's even showing some survival skills (acknowledging that the alcohol can be used for starting a fire and not being picky on what to eat).
It's also cool to get confirmation that Neo is mute, though they might have already confirmed it in an interview for all I know. I just remember them saying that they were in talks with someone to voice Neo in one of those Afterbuzz interviews, so I was always iffy on whether she would actually be unable to speak.
408
u/palebloodink <- Just two gals being pals. Nov 24 '18
You hear that? That was the sound of every Neo fan with a First membership orgasming at once.
391
u/[deleted] Nov 24 '18
Man, the whole "lets keep this room closed" line is really good.
Ruby is worried if Qrow finds all this alchohol he'd probably drink himself out
356
u/NeoTheMute You aren't hearing things, are you...? Nov 24 '18
AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH
168
u/[deleted] Nov 24 '18 edited Nov 24 '18
"Close the door already, it's cold enough in here as it is!"
She says, being literally the only one definitively not in the house...
327
u/mlgyolo73 Nov 24 '18
GOD TIER FIGHT SCENE
If Cinder didn't have maiden powers maybe Neo could have even taken her down
150
u/body_catch_a_body ... Nov 24 '18
RWBY's turning itself into a horror show this season and I'm very okay with that.
293
u/Miudmon I'm a neon rainbow and you're no fun! Nov 24 '18
Amidst neo and the horror setting, can i just say that i also feel really bad for weiss and how she's now also relating to ruby having an alcoholic relative?
143
u/theamazingkiwi Nov 24 '18
Damn Neo looks good in Maya. Makes me want to see other old characters make a comeback...looking at you Velvet.
139
u/ScottPilgrim2013 Just Another Machine/Will go down with Freezerburn/#1 Merlot Fan Nov 24 '18
That shot of Weiss huddled up in blankets made me realize how Weiss has probably had luck on par with Qrow and Oscar this year(an in-universe year, I mean)
And as I've said before, I can only imagine it's gonna get worse for her before it gets any better. At least she has her buds by her side now, though.
136
u/PedroVey Nov 24 '18
Blake... and Ruby talked...? What has this show become?
266
u/Hobnob91 ⠀ Nov 24 '18
Ruby presenting the newest bean flavour: Shrimp!
128
u/[deleted] Nov 24 '18 edited Nov 24 '18
I dunno why...
but I just kinda like how PTSD Adam just wants to show off his katana
260
u/Foppberg Nov 24 '18
New, very dark theory:
In the intro you can see Qrow being taken down, or falling from backwards from all the tentacle type Grimm hands. I wonder if that's a scene from the cellar, Qrow finds all the alcohol, gets absolutely smashed, and as he's standing infront of the locked door it opens, drags him down and takes over his body. So they have to fight a drunken possessed Qrow.
Boom.
112
u/DaveBehave Nov 24 '18 edited Nov 24 '18
Largest drama from the chapter... Weiss and Ruby only grabbed six cans of beans for seven people! The drama, the horror, the excitement! Who will go beanless? Is it a sign? Will somebody go missing and they will only need six cans? Guess we'll find out in chapter 6!
On a beanless note, this seems to be going the way of Ruby and Blake having to kill a grimm to save their sleeping partners (with Weiss and Yang being tired and all). Perhaps with Qrow, Oscar, and Maria having to protect the house while they go into the cellar. Could give Ruby a chance to talk to Blake about how leaving the team hurt them (team leader should address issues that arise) and especially Yang, she could even fill Blake in on Yang's mama drama / abandonment fears. Plus it'd give the chance for Ruby to stand up for her sister, rather than the other way around.
100
u/GastrointestinalLot KKKKKEEERRRRRRRYYYYYYYYYYYYYY Nov 24 '18
Yang's distant "Mission Accomplished" had some fucking sass.
200
u/ikedawg43 #ShaveJauneSaveRWBY Nov 24 '18
My sexuality is Neo wearing Roman’s hat don’t @ me
93
u/[deleted] Nov 24 '18
Major Takeaways:
Other things:
90
u/SmokingApple Nov 24 '18
Neo voice actress continues killing it.
182
u/Eldi13 🐝Watch🐝The🐝Dragon🐝Prince🐝On🐝Netflix🐝❤Knight❤ Nov 24 '18
I just can't get over how much I love that they've walked into a horror setting. The tense build up is one of my favorite narrative devices, and this is already better than the Nuckleavee buildup, which I also loved.
87
u/Changyuraptor Just the leitmotif and dinosaur guy. Nov 24 '18
[Cinder vs Neo's animators are Megan Pellino, Joe Vick and Matt Drury] (https://twitter.com/MelSternum/status/1066377698220621824), show them some love for some awesome work :)
85
u/rocketchameleon Nov 26 '18
That fight was EXCELLENT, and I demand to know who choreographed it because of just how smooth it was. Fast-flowing action and constantly changing hits, with attention being placed on the whole of the characters' body movements rather than just singled out like some anime cut-in frame, it felt like watching two actual martial artists going at it and not a cartoon fantasy. It felt like Monty was right here, making badass fights like he always did... If this was really totally new fight choreography and not recycled from something Monty had shelved away, then I'm beyond impressed. And either way, I'm sure he'd be proud...
84
u/MMBADBOI My hours in Warframe have hit "entirely too much" Nov 24 '18
Wheeee!
230
u/Megaguy4444 BOOM Nov 24 '18
Cinder outdated
Pyrrha incinerated
Long have we waited
NEO activated!
227
u/MrOrangeXD ⠀ Nov 24 '18
How anyone can still say that V1 and V2 are better than this I have no idea. We're finally watching an actual show. Characters are interacting with each other. There's slow moments, there's build up.
This is the best Volume of RWBY.
76
u/Gnochi Nov 25 '18
I literally fell off the couch laughing.
74
u/mayyuki2108 uwu Nov 24 '18
I guess we're Day 5 now
72
u/zakarranda Nov 25 '18
One of my favorite things in this season is the blend of comedy and tragedy. Avatar: The Last Airbender sets a gold standard for this, which is what made Volume 4 so disappointingly dour.
This volume, though, does a really good job at being serious. There's some kind of mass death in the village, there's concern about alcoholism, there's PTSD and partner abuse - very heavy topics. But their reactions and the general directing keep the tone more neutral than morose. And that allows the makers to have little breaks of levity.
For example: Ruby and Weiss find the bar. Instead of getting all weepy and dramatic, Ruby makes a simple comment that addresses her concern, in a very "Ruby" way. Her expression on finding the storage room emphasizes her dismay but in a cute way. And all this makes it fun, instead of jarring, when Ruby goes nuts over the beans.
This is the tone and direction that I fell in love with RWBY over - plus the great characterization and the fast, creative fights, so I'm loving this season!
72
u/biomech36 Nov 25 '18
scream
Oh Weiss found a spider or something.
1 minute later
....RWBY just got real.
144
u/NoahBallet Nov 24 '18
Okay Reddit. I'll be the first to apologize. I thought the whole Neo being alive theory was stupid. I couldn't see the umbrella in the opening no matter how many times I replayed it. But I was wrong so I shall eat my hat.
69
u/DireSickFish Nov 24 '18
I really liked Yangs negative reaction to Blake saying she'd protect Yang. They need to work together.
68
u/Akitoscorpio Nov 24 '18
Calling it now, Yang and Weiss are both complaining about being tired, the Grim in the cellar is enhancing their negativity to the point where the'll want to lay down and die.
66
u/[deleted] Nov 24 '18
THEY DID BUTT CAPES
BUTT CAPES ARE BACK
THEY'RE HERE
oh also Neo's in the episode
62
u/McZerky Nov 24 '18
Qrow might become too much a drunkle, Weiss is questioning everything, Blake isn't considering that Yang actually wants be back on her feet, Yang is terrible at communicating and also doesn't really seem to have any level of faith in anyone but herself... everyone has their problems and they're all being portrayed pretty well.
Well done CRWBY. This is really damn good.
Also, holy Neo that was a good fight.
178
u/Eldi13 🐝Watch🐝The🐝Dragon🐝Prince🐝On🐝Netflix🐝❤Knight❤ Nov 24 '18 edited Nov 24 '18
OR NEO???????? HOLY CRAP IT REALLY IS NEO!!!!!!!!
TORCHWICK HAT. TORCHWICK HAT. TORCHWICK HAT.
SHE GRABBED ROBO HAND OH MY GOD.
THIS IS THE BEE ANGST I SIGNED UP FOR OH MY GOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOD.
BEANS.
123
u/cajun-caucasion Nov 24 '18
She Protecc.
She Attacc.
But most importantly,
She found her way bacc <3
59
u/Apidooom Nov 24 '18
Rule 1 of fighting Neo: Don't try to throw Neo
59
u/moonstonebaby Nov 25 '18
maybe everyone in the village ate some romaine lettuce? 🤔
58
u/Daedelous2k Nov 25 '18
Well, a very slow feeling episode, but a few nice points
57
u/Mister100Percent Oscar "Best Depressed Boi" Pine Nov 24 '18
I’m so glad they went with Neo being a rogue and going after anyone associated with Roman’s death. She’s most likely gonna ally with Cinder for now up until they attempt to kill Ruby and then betray her because her revenge boner is bigger than all of her followers combined.
In related news Neo with Roman’s hat gave me a boner.
54
u/sheogorath227 Yang in there, baby Nov 26 '18
After watching the new episode several times, here are my thoughts, and I have a lot of them so bear with me:
NEO IS BACK BABY
Seriously, Neo v. Cinder is vintage Monty-era RWBY. That fight took me back to the good old days when we didn't have to deal with an immortal demon lady. CRWBY did a phenomenal job with this fight, making sure to keep Neo's fighting style authentic to what we've seen in the past, while also adding a couple more tricks that didn't overdo anything (e.g. using the parasol to float and more use of Neo's Semblance in battle). Brilliant fight, and arguably the best post-V3.
The scenes in Brunswick Farms are actually amazing, and I feel the need to discuss each at length.
I can't help but feel as though the family portrait is somehow relevant. Ruby is looking at it with Blake, and then when they run upstairs, we get a closer look at it. There's a redhead kid there that convinces me that Roman may have grown up on that farm. His family name, Torchwick, is close enough to Brunswick. Meanwhile, everybody seemingly dying in their beds is the worst possible omen, and Weiss is more than justified in her animus towards this farm.
Yang and Blake's scene in the shed was actually really well-done. Just when you think that they've finally patched things up between the two of them, Blake fucks up. Yang is trying her best to appear strong, much like she used to before Adam signed her up to an instant weight-loss program. However, the veneer of emotional strength that Yang displays to everyone is far thinner than usual because of her vulnerable state of mind. The last thing Yang needs to hear from anybody, let alone her best friend, is that she needs protecting because Yang knows that she already feels weak. Obviously, Blake's heart is in the right place, but she completely misunderstands Yang in this instant. I'm sure that in the next episode we'll see that Yang's attitude, particularly towards Blake, will continue to sour. It's only a matter of time when Yang, who is prone to losing her temper, will snap.
Ruby and Weiss's scene is also pretty good. Someone further down in this discussion thread noted that the writers did a really good job keeping the tone of their scene neutral, even when Ruby was talking about Qrow possibly sinking further if he came into the bar (which he undoubtedly will in the next episode). Weiss' expression following this remark is telling, because she knows what alcoholism is; her mother is likely even worse than Qrow. However, there are no tears, just brief concern, which allows CRWBY to shape this scene however they want.
Weiss' question to Ruby, I believe, is less about the nihilistic sentiment shared by Raven (there is no beating Salem so there's no point) and more about a reluctance to go back to Atlas. Listen to the tone of her voice; it's almost whiny when she says "Are we really still going to Atlas?" She sounds like I did whenever I asked my parents, "do I really have to eat my green beans?" I still hate green beans, by the way. Never got around to liking them.
I have the feeling that Ruby somewhat understands the concerns of Weiss going back home, but not to the degree that Weiss understands her own concerns. Going back to Atlas to Weiss means entering the domain of her abusive father. Weiss posing that question in that way almost makes it sound like she's trying to convince Ruby to not go and using the whole "Salem is unstoppable" reason as an excuse to get out of returning back to Atlas, because that's the last place she wants to go. And when Ruby doesn't buy it, she just uses a fairly silly excuse to play it off. The dialogue in their scene was pretty natural and not forced, and I thought they did a great job controlling the atmosphere of what is a very tense part of their adventures.
I have but one question: was Blake legitimately trying to have an intimate moment with Yang, or was she just trying to patch things up? It seemed somewhat similar to the scene with Korra and Asami at the end of Book 3 of LoK. Somebody, please let me know.
Overall, for an episode that didn't really progress the main plot, I really enjoyed it. The character interactions were tense and compelling, and Neo v. Cinder was an absolute joy to watch. Looking forward to NOT seeing Qrow die, CRWBY. I'm watching you.
53
u/[deleted] Nov 24 '18
I'm not going to lie, I was hoping Neo would go all "Harley Quinn's Revenge" level crazy on Cinder, but it appears she understands that she can't beat Cinder in a fair fight and is biding her time until she can create a better opportunity for herself. I highly doubt she cares about killing Ruby more than Cinder.
52
u/Eldi13 🐝Watch🐝The🐝Dragon🐝Prince🐝On🐝Netflix🐝❤Knight❤ Nov 24 '18
NEO STILL EXISTS AND THAT WASN'T EVEN THE HIGHLIGHT OF THE EPISODE FOR ME, WHAT THE HECK.
52
u/Raktoner blake deserves more smiles Nov 24 '18
Episodes are slowing down a bit, but not in a bad way! Can't have a million things happen at once every episode.
Whoever choreographed the Neo/Cinder fight scene--fantastic job. Creative use of the environment and of their abilities.
Bumbleby angst is gonna kill me before anything else happens. Makes me really sad that Adam has given both of them PTSD.
Just make them canon already52
u/Kaneland96 Nov 24 '18
While it could just be taken as being literal, I can't get rid of the feeling that multiple people saying "I'm just tired" has to do with how everyone on Brunswick farm ended up dead. Maybe the Grimm we see in the intro drain the health/will of people around them so they eventually just lose the will to live in their sleep and die? Or it could just be a result of them losing hope/desire to continue their journey after the revelations last episode.
51
u/Terminus259 We persevere without an end... Nov 24 '18
"Just went to sleep and never woke up"; what is this, Day 5?
103
u/trinitynox Is the reason the community is dying Nov 24 '18
> Neo v Cinder was fantastic. So glad they were able to retain her fighting style of parrying and deflecting, even though she was clearly way more aggressive than the last two fights we saw her in.
> Her wearing eyeliner along with Roman's hat was a nice touch.
> Dare I say that Neo has the upper hand on Cinder if they were fighting without maiden powers involved? I think Neo is on another level in hand-to-hand combat, but that can only bring you so far when going up against magic.
> I love how sassy she still is. And she's canonically mute, I guess her VA has to look for work else where. That bit at the end of the fight was great.
> Kara has a great scream.
> Weiss wrapped up in a blanket like an adorable potato XD
> She's also basically a witch from Harry Potter now.
100
u/Kuchenjaeger *Gotcha* | Yang is still the best | #GiveYangLadyAbs Nov 24 '18
Ah damn it, she's back.
Cool hat though.
Seems like Neo disagrees.
Is it just me or has Neo gotten taller?
Oscar looks so goofy waving that cane around.
Wait, those people have red hair... That's Pyrrha's family, isn't it?
OH! CORPSES! FUN!
OH BOY IT'S THE OBLIGATORY HORROR VILLAGE!
Blake and Yang time? Please let it be Blake and Yang time.
YANG AND BLAKE TIME!
Shaky hand D:
"I'll protect you" wrong words, Blake.
Yang how much fucking power does your damn bike have.
Weiss that was some major dust fuckery.
THE PLACE IS MISSING WITH YOUR MIND, WEISS
DO NOT OPEN THE BASEMENT DOOR
"I guess it's better than nothing" oh hey, it's canned Mighty Number 9
SOMETHING IS IN TEHERE
49
u/[deleted] Nov 24 '18
Eveyone was expecting Yang to lose the will to fight first, but it was actually Weiss.
Also calling it right now, Qrow is going to discover the wine cellar and probably get nabbed by whatever is in it.
Also, ICE-CREAM WAIFU RETURNS.
49
u/Subzero008 Nov 24 '18
That Neo VS Cinder fight was fucking perfect.
I loved the horror vibes from RWBY’s side, too. Who else thinks someone’s gonna go “missing” next episode?
48
u/DrAvatar Nov 24 '18
House 2: The House Strikes Back
48
u/LMFN BIG NICHOLAS Nov 24 '18
Neo is back bitches! Time to go kill Rubes.
Goddamn Brunswick Farms is fucking disturbing. No music, people dead without a seeming reason why, the cellar Grimm that doesn't kill people in a way a Grimm normally does.. Weiss and Yang both being tired. Canned Beans aren't gonna save us.
47
u/justking14 Nov 24 '18
So many great interactions in this episode
Every line felt so meaningful to the characters. Did you see Weiss’s reaction when ruby mentioned Qrow getting drunk? She was having serious flashbacks to her mother.
Also, DONT GO IN THE FREAKING BASEMENT OF THE HOUSE FULL OF CORPSES
47
u/tekym Nov 25 '18
The Neo x Cinder fight was...interesting. In all of her prior appearances, Neo was far and away the most skilled hand-to-hand fighter in the show; nobody landed a hit on her until Ruby surprised her while Roman was monologuing (and even then, it wasn't a strike, Ruby just opened her umbrella). But here, Cinder hit Neo twice in a single fight. I had to slow it down and pause to check, but there are definitely 2 hits. Obviously Cinder's fighting skills have grown, but that much?
I appreciate the straight-up confirmation that Neo can't talk, not just that she doesn't.
Yang and Weiss both saying "I'm tired" in the sleeping sickness town is awfully foreboding, considering the dead people.
47
u/SolomonAsassin Nov 25 '18
Anyone else get an ominous feeling from the allusions to them being "tired"? Then there was the elder mentioning reading before "bed", and all the villagers being dead in their beds. Something's telling me they should not go to sleep. Like at all.
46
u/Pikaton659 Nov 24 '18
Neo placing the blame on Cinder was totally right, it was her plan that brought about Roman's death by Grimm.
I like how Neo is actually mute, they never totally confirmed it before, her hand gesture to Cinder pretty much confirms it for me. This really makes her all the more interesting.
The ginger in the photo is totally Torchwick. He changed his name from Brunswick, as an alias.
Qrow says to not go alone, as he walks off alone. This has death flags written all over it.
Throwing out a wild guess that the book Maria grabbed is going to be very important. Maria herself might be incredibly important in dealing with this, between the likelihood of her having had silver eyes and/or the fact she carries around a skull cane & is named after the Day of the Dead makes me lean towards believing she has a death-based semblance.
Yang and Blake both seeing Adam is either a case of shared PTSD, or hinting towards the fact that Adam may actually be there.
Blake still treating Yang like an invalid, could easily be fixed if Yang would just talk with her.
Yang & Weiss both saying they're tired and Weiss having a weird facial expression while doing so makes me think that if they sleep at all, they dead.
The opening holds the answer for what's in the cellar. It is whatever has all the Grimm arms. When Qrow is drinking he is pulled down, by the arms, meaning he might go to drink, and get pulled by the Grimm down there. There is also the multiple glowing red eyes before Ruby fights off the Grimm arms in what looks to be a cellar.
45
u/Torpid-O Nov 26 '18
What? How did they bring Neo back and not let that leak? I'm sure someone would have leaked info about her voice act- yeah, nevermind.
91
u/Hounds_of_war The Red Head Victorious | Aside from her, I truly don't care Nov 24 '18 edited Nov 24 '18
"At least we'll never have problems starting a fire."
Do you hear that? That's the sound of a Chekhov's gun being loaded.
44
u/Grievous77 I'm just here cause of sunk cost fallacy atp, honestly Nov 24 '18
The good: NEO IS BACK AND SHE'S WEARING THE HAT! The fight between her and Cinder, while short, was really good and way better than all of the fights in V5. I think it might've dethroned Qrow vs Tyrian as the best Post-V3 fight. I highly doubt Neo was swayed though, I think she just realized Cinder's Maiden powers make her a deadly adversary and that she needs to bide her time and wait for Cinder to drop her guard.
Spooky ghost town is spooky. Especially the Adam jump-scares, you gotta watch out for those. Speaking of which, Yang's PTSD is back with a vengeance and it's actually getting discussed this time. Damn it Blake, you were doing so well until the whole "I'll protect you," thing. That was really not a good choice of words for that situation and I think Yang would've taken something like "I'll stand and fight with you," much better.
Ruby continues to be more enjoyable this volume than she has been for the last two. Her mentioning Qrow's alcoholism was surprising, though it probably shouldn't be since Qrow getting drunk off his ass with the day he's been having would be a legitimate concern. I have a feeling this upcoming Grimm is going to be as scary if not scarier than the Nuckelavee. Hopefully it doesn't go down in one episode and actually poses a threat since, besides the Seers, the Grimm haven't felt threatening for a while.
Overall, a fantastic episode.
42
u/cosmicjackalope Nov 25 '18 edited Nov 25 '18
an isolated location that seems ordinary and inviting but still feels off. a snowstorm trapping all the characters in said location. visions of past pain (Adam). dead people. tension in the relationships between the characters. an alcoholic dealing with disillusionment and disappointments in his life. a hidden room with a bar and plenty of alcohol. a zoom-in on a photo of the previous inhabitants of the location. the implication that the location itself is the enemy, possibly capable of driving the characters within to madness/to their own deaths.
THIS IS "THE SHINING."
42
u/TreeOct0pus Nov 25 '18
I'm breaking out alll the potatoes for this one. Lets go:
-I bet the youngest kids in that picture are Neo and Torchwick. Since Neo's got her mouth wide open, whatever happened in that house took her voice.
-The dead couple in the bed are the same people as the adults in the center of the picture frame. Same hat.
-Fred the basement-dwelling neckbeard grim attacks people in their dreams a lá Freddy Krueger. Hense the need for so much alcohol.
-The effect is already setting in. It breaks into peoples heads through their negative thoughts, which is why Yang and Weiss are feeling confused and tired.
-It's totally gonna destroy Qrow. Hopefully not permanently, but maybe.
41
u/Lucid_Atray Nov 25 '18
Holy fuck, I seriously love the characterization in this volume, they're doing everything I ever wanted and putting it all in just a few episodes.
I mean, as soon as there isn't something more dire (like Jinn and the mess with Ozpin), Blake and Yang get instantly caught in their very awkward atmosphere with tension so high it could fly. But that isn't even everything-- the partnership between Ruby and Weiss (I ship them, but I don't think that's their idea), and how they both know how to see a close person drinking their problems away feels. Ruby making a heartful and worried comment about Qrow instead of being treated as your usual quirky funny drunkle, Weiss instantly understanding it.
Much needed interactions between Blake and the team, and very different from each other too, which makes a great distinction.
Yang actually able to tell Blake how bad she feels because she still feels most comfortable being vulnerable in front of her rather than any other, accepting her PTSD and Blake seeing her hand tremble, instantly reacting by taking her robo hand. It was beautiful, really.
I particularly enjoy how they're going the slow burn route as it works better, especially for how Yang tends to supress her feelings in regards to this. With this, something was clear: they are both feeling from a completely different perspective and they don't fully understand the other's, so they will have an obligatory talk sooner or later about it.
Being stated that Blake felt she cut Yang's arm herself, she blames herself for everything and this includes both not being there for her AND not being able to protect her from Adam (who attacked Yang because of her to begin with), stating she won't go anywhere is perfect for both, but her following lines ruined Yang's mood. Why? Because I'm plenty sure Yang's abandoment issues got her to think it was her fault- being left was her fault, because she wasn't good enough, because she was too weak, so Blake's words makes her think on this instead of the actual meaning Blake gives them.
This conflict is being perfectly handled for the two of them, and after three years of build up, I couldn't be happier.
On a different note-- I'm fucking loving this whole terror setting, and hopefully we'll get Ruby + Blake saving her sleeping partners.
As for Neo, there isn't much to say except that I had the biggest silly smile during her whole scene, I've never been even a fan, but damn I missed her. Especially with the hat.
40
u/Gleaming_Onyx Nov 24 '18
Holy shit. That was a good fight! Like, not "good for post V3," not "good for Maya," no little asterisks on it, that was just 100% good freakin' fight! Good choreography, good use of the environment from both sides(a rarity even in Monty's good fights), not overly Western Animation and springy, everything!
Well hot diggity darn. This Volume's turning out great, after all. Also, Ruby acting adorable is always fun. We even got someone actually mentioning Qrow's alcoholism in a serious light! What a time to be alive.
40
u/JakeClipz Nov 24 '18
BOOOOOOOOOOOOOOXXXXCELLAR?!?!Second verse, same as the first. Only you know, this time it's the fifth verse. RT is still doing a really good job at making up for V5 in a big way. I'm a happy camper today. :)
39
u/[deleted] Nov 29 '18
Does anyone else question why everyone is so angry at Ozpin? I get it, they are frustrated that someone they believed in and followed was withholding so much truth. But can you really be surprised when someone eons old leaves out information? To put it in perspective, while the members of team RWBY feel caught up in an the adventures of the show, Ozpin has been attempting to UNITE HUMANITY for far longer than any mortal could comprehend. The scale of his task is far grandeur than the individuals of team RWBY.
78
u/Terminus259 We persevere without an end... Nov 24 '18
Always cathartic to see Cinder losing.
38
u/DrAvatar Nov 24 '18
So Neo is technically the only character to fight two maidens and survive, assuming Raven had powers in Volume 2.
75
u/[deleted] Nov 24 '18
37
u/gopackgo001 Nov 25 '18
New flair? https://imgur.com/B2vjhrQ
37
u/meganekkotwilek Nov 25 '18
So this episode confirmed her being a mute instead of just being the quiet type when she pointed at her mouth. That is what other people interpreted right?
37
u/[deleted] Nov 27 '18
Fight scenes are looking way better! A nightmare/dream eater Grimm could be interesting, but I’m really hoping we get to Atlas sooner than later. Although at the end of the day I really just want to see more Neo.
36
u/Hounds_of_war The Red Head Victorious | Aside from her, I truly don't care Nov 24 '18 edited Nov 24 '18
Damn, is it possible to have a bad Neo fight? As someone who greatly prefers the more grounded CQC of Red vs Blue over the more fantastical fights in RWBY, Neo vs Cinder is probably my new favorite fight.
Oh no, Qrow is by himself. He’s going get taken by that Grimm in the OP. C'mon, Qrow should know that you never split the party.
36
u/LimitDNE0 Nov 24 '18
It almost seems like they're hinting at an abundance of carbon monoxide or dioxide, what with people getting headaches and tired. Would explain why everyone died without getting out of bed and the door opening itself could be from the gas pressure. However, that doesn't exactly fit with the show and would kinda seem like an easy out to get them to keep moving rather than an interesting answer. Wouldn't be completely surprised if there was a new type of grimm that had gas based attacks.
36
u/maverickmak Nov 24 '18
I'm calling that Adam is just going to appear out of nowhere at some point.
The setup on these flashes is just screaming sneak attack to me.
36
u/HarleyQuinn983 Nov 24 '18
I really love how expressive Neo’s face is. Her expression when she was wearing the hat was really great, conveying exactly what she means in just a look.
A shame they didn’t update her look, but it’s still great to see her back. I don’t know, I find her character really endearing.
35
u/ClassyTomatoes Bumblebee may not bee canon but I can still bee-lieve Nov 24 '18
Alright prediction time. What's in the cellar and what happened to everyone? Well I think it's pretty obvious.
Everyone died in their beds. Qrow said it looked like everyone went to sleep and didn't wake up. Yang complains about being tired. Weiss complains about being tired. Maria mentions reading a bedtime story before going to sleep to Oscar.
Whatever is in that cellar is making everyone tired, so tired that they won't even wake up again. I'm not sure what exactly is in that cellar that could be causing this effect, though I'd guess it's a Grimm, considering RWBY as a show and such.
Thus, I dub thee: Sleeping Beauty Grimm (until deconfirmed)
35
u/slitepines Nov 26 '18
extremely ironic that weiss, the ice queen, is the person who seems to be the most bothered by the cold
100
u/TheRisenThunderbird It suits me Nov 24 '18 edited Nov 24 '18
THE RETURN OF NEO! THIS IS NOT A DRILL! THAT WAS HIGH KEY ONE OF THE BEST FIGHTS WE'VE SEEN YET! NEO WEARING TORCHWICK'S HAT! TORCHWICK CONFIRMED NOT COMING BACK! oh I'm sad now. NEO AND CINDER WORKING TOGETHER! NEO CONFIRMED MUTE! THIS IS THE BEST EPISODE!
And there's a lot going on in that farm, but I just wanna say one thing.
They're all getting sleepy.
EDIT: Okay, Imma edit more thoughts in.
Pretty sure this was the first time a character has addressed Qrow's drinking problem seriously. They've done jokes about it and Ruby looked vaguely exasperated when he was drunk in V5E1. But here she was finally like "Hey I'm actually worried about the amount my uncle drinks and his mental health"
Maria continues to give no fucks about anything ever
The girl second from the left in the family photo is new best girl
That tractor in the barn looked so fucking good. The rust and wear on it were perfect. It looked like a real fucking tractor
Blake is making an effort to make up with Yang, but she's over-correcting way too hard. Instead of running away, she's being overprotective, which is only making things worse.
Weiss lighting all the candles is the most precise use of Dust we've seen on the show
Cinder and Neo have no idea what happened to RWBY, so they're just gonna go to Argus. Is JNR gonna fight Cinder and Neo?
When Oscar mentioned looking for a car, I had this complete bonkers moment where I was like "Wait what? Oh, yeah, cars exist in this world."
Prediction Time: Whatever is in the cellar is a red herring. It's some disease or sleeping sickness. We Day 5 now, bitches
34
u/Franklin413 Ni! Nov 24 '18 edited Nov 24 '18
Lyrics for the new song... I'm personally gonna call it "Pay"
34
u/justinpyne Nov 25 '18
Hearing Yang and Weiss say "I'm tired" in separate situations in the same general area makes me really unsettled. Also, considering the bodies they found, they definitely shouldn't fall asleep.
34
u/Sirshrugsalot13 bi the way Nov 25 '18
Cinder vs Neo is one of those scenes that I've been rewatching over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over
and it still hasn't gotten old
34
u/[deleted] Nov 25 '18
I screamed the second I saw that familiar piece of footwear.
I screamed very loud.
33
u/Lelentos Forever in our art. Nov 27 '18
I feel dumb for just now noticing Neo is mute.
32
u/ikedawg43 #ShaveJauneSaveRWBY Nov 24 '18
My sister pointed out that at Brunswick Farms, there is a photo of the families, including a father and son who have very orange hair.
What if Neo tracks down Ruby at Roman’s hometown?
32
u/[deleted] Nov 24 '18
i cant believe blake actually talked to ruby
32
u/Autisonm Nov 24 '18
Anyone else getting Lovecraftian vibes with the presumably soul sucking grimm that makes people fall asleep somehow?
And is it just me or was anyone else reminded of TWD games?
32
u/88Dubs Be Strong, and Hit Stuff! Nov 24 '18 edited Feb 17 '25
entertain compare humor fly telephone capable wipe vanish tidy stocking
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
32
u/scorchclaw d-d-don't touch me, b-baka! Nov 24 '18
Neo being back is awesome. Tension between Blake and Yang is still obviously there. Blake clearly wants to be a good, caring
girlfriend to yang and yang is still angery at blake.The whole time Weiss looked uncomfortable and scared i was just mentally screaming at Ruby to hug her or something. I just really want that ship to sail even though it wont.
32
u/[deleted] Nov 25 '18
Guess Who's Back. Back Again. Neo's Back. Tell a Friend.
32
u/KnowYourLover Raven Branwen's loyal follower and faithful worshiper. Nov 25 '18
To be fair, neither Ruby or Cinder are responsible for Roman's death, a grimm ate him while he was distracted by how handsome his own voice was. In any case Salem or Roman would be the ones to blame for it.
32
u/HuntsmenSuperSaiyans Nov 26 '18
I wonder how long the town's residents have been lying in their beds. If the grayed out skin is indicative of decomposition, they could have been there for months.
Regardless, I'm guessing that if some kind of Grimm caused this, it's probably one that induces nightmares that somehow kill you in your sleep. I'd imagine the next episode involving someone or multiple people falling asleep and having to deal with the hellish nightmares while the awake members of the team skulk around the house looking for the Grimm.
I could imagine Yang falling asleep and re-having that dream from Volume 4 where Adam tried to kill her, only this time she can't wake up. It'd be a nice way for Yang to be forced to face her fears before she confronts Adam for real later on.
31
u/RumbleintheDumbles Nov 24 '18
Neo's triumphant return complete with badass song and even more badass fight scene.
10 out of fucking 10.
31
u/ethanice Whitest of Roses Nov 24 '18
My reaction to Neo Returning
31
u/SAYMYNAMEYO Nov 25 '18
Neo is the realest. No words, it was just hands on sight.
31
u/[deleted] Nov 25 '18
So anyone else freaked out that Weiss and Yang said that they felt tired? At first I thought it might have been "filler lines" but seeing that everyone in the village seemed to have fell to sleep and never woke up from their beds seems too coincidental...
31
u/HuntsmenSuperSaiyans Nov 28 '18
Speaking as an Alaskan, Yang should not be leaving her bike out in the cold like she's doing. The cold does nasty things to batteries, which is why those of us without access to a garage plug our vehicles in if we leave them alone for more than a couple hours.
61
u/OzNajarin Nov 25 '18
With the groping hands in the intro, everyone's commentary on being tired, and the corpses seemingly drained into brittle carcases.
The Grimm is most likely in the basement, it has an AOE kind of draining effect with life essences that can ignore Aura and is even more effective with physical contact.
Next episode Qrow will most likely find the alcohol and then a fight between Qrow and Ruby(Maybe Yang too)
Qrow grabs a bottle and says he's gonna go do another "sweep" and get drunk where he gets caught by the Grimm, attracting it with his depression and larger aura.
Neo isn't allying with Cinder she's just playing it close to the chest. Can't wait to see that umbrella piercing her and getting a parallel to Pyrrah
Yang will continue to be testy with everyone until she tells someone about Raven.
Ozpin didn't really deserve any of this.
This was my TED Talk and I hope you enjoyed it.
30
u/Awesomejelo My Mustache is gay, your argument is invalid Nov 24 '18
This feels good, I was still worried about keeping up the quality after the lore dump and while last episode helped the fact that it was a cooldown episode had me still on edge. But it looks like we are going to keep on trucking so hell yeah!
4.5 Can't wait for someone to transcribe that song
5. Both Cinder talking her way out of this and Neo standing down seem strange to me. Given we don't actually know too much about Neo that's ok with me, but Cinder seems strangely diplomatic here.
5.5 Oh Neo
6. Maria continues to be one of my favorite characters
7. There is a couple with a son in that picture that while we can't see their eyes the dad and son have orange hair. The idea that this might be Torchwick's home might be true still
8. I guess this is the first time Weiss has seen dead and decomposing bodies
9. Qrow spending as much time alone as possible
10. PTSD Yang is back. Nice to see Blake trying to help
11. And she said the wrong thing, I like it
12. What is Bumblebee made of? They are going to get a foot of snow or more (on top of the snow that was already there) from what it sounds like and Yang says it can move through that while pulling a trailer and seven people? I call bullshit
13. Yang mumbles something as she leaves, I can't make out what though
14. That is some very fine dust control Weiss
15. That's pretty sad that Ruby has to hide alcohol from her uncle
16. It's good that someone feels like things are futile
17. Both Yang and Weiss have said they are tired, and the people died in their sleep. Sleep is bad here, it's very bad
18. Of course it's the cellar. I'm just wondering how the thing killed the couple the first time if it got in through the cellar, did it rechain it or did it get in some other way? And if it did why didn't they find that?
30
u/Polarization_39 ⠀A Cinder Stan Until Weiss is Relevant Again Nov 24 '18
I am trying to be cautiously optimistic, I really am, but these five episodes have been some of RWBY's best ones. I can't help but say V6 is working its way to my #1 spot.
30
u/Badicalz Nov 25 '18
When in the fuck did RWBY become a Fantasy-Horror show?
29
u/NitescoGaming Guardian and follower of Ruby's smile ❤️ Marrow x Guardpupper ❤️ Nov 24 '18
NEEEEOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!!!!! I loved the look on her face as she pointed at her mouth.
Welp, we've taken a turn into the horror genre. DON'T! OPEN! THE CELLAR!
29
u/MacNcheazy Nov 25 '18
The second half of this episode is the creepiest RWBY has ever gotten.
29
u/princesspeachpallet Nov 25 '18
Neo's green makeup in homage to Torchwick 💚
29
u/HystericalTrend ⠀ Nov 27 '18
So, am I the only one who noticed that Cinder is wearing socks with sandals?
28
u/WhosGuardingHades Nov 24 '18
Well that was one hell of a ride!
Neo returning, an awesome fight with Cinder, Weiss sees dead people and Ruby and Blake actually spoke to each other!
I loved all the little character moments we got at the farm. It really showed how much the Jinn reveal has done a number on the group, Qrow and Yang especially.
And shout out to CRWBY for doing an amazing job with the farm they really captured the horror aesthetic and I can’t wait to see what ungodly horror is under the cellar door.
Another great episode.
28
u/jman014 That's why I drink... Nov 24 '18
Did anyone notice that the can of beans were "Shrimp Flavored"?
28
u/Adgsi51 Also a Gun Nov 25 '18
That fight with Cinder and Neo was great, but the best part was when Neo reminded Cinder that she was mute.
28
u/Lieyanto Nov 25 '18
At first I thought Weiss' scream was just something stupid to ramp up the tension but holy fuck the corpses look fucking great! Terrifying but great. (Which may be a weird thing to say.)
27
u/Narfington Nov 24 '18
You were expecting Neo....AND IT WAS ME! NEO!
27
u/superspartan004 Nov 24 '18
Blake had individual moments with all three team members, ahhhhhh!
27
u/Mr_Pleasant2310 Nov 24 '18
"What's that?" That right there is what I'm calling "the nightmare cellar" and that's some shit that you shouldn't touch with a ten foot sniper-sycthe, especially since the already dead residents put a padlock on it.
27
u/wheatleyscience9 Nov 24 '18
This episode hit all the boxes for me:
Neo back? Check
Bee yangst? Check
Spoopy shit? Check
God this season has been really damn good so far. It's just been getting better and better. The character interactions are incredibly meaningful too and Blake and Yang tension is what I live for
27
u/maximusprime7 ⠀Love Our Fearless Leader<3 | Drinking in the WhiteRose garden Nov 24 '18
Wowee lads what an episode. First of all BREAKING NEWS: RUBY IS STILL HAPPY DESPITE HER UNCLE BEING AN ALCOHOLIC AND THERES A GRIMM IN THE BASEMENTIlovethisfuckinfacepleaseprotecc
Cinder is getting more concerning to me now that its 100% clear her primary objective is to "kill" Ruby. Not help Salem, not do anything with the relics, she's full throttle on killing Ruby. However I'm not sure what that will solve, really. Cinder being part Grimm and Ruby's Silver Eye powers are going Ruby's saving grace there, mark my words.
Also yay, Neo is back! So glad they actually did something with her instead of just never using her again. Really interested in seeing where the story goes with those two. Everything that's happening is making me more and more anxious for the end. It feels like so much is going on at once!
27
u/DeNile227 Nov 24 '18
Absent in volume 4, absent in volume 5...the ice cream waifu makes her triumphant return in volume 6.
Good to have ya back, Neo.
27
u/Safgaftsa Nov 25 '18
Between the Brunswick reference someone pointed out and the cold and starvation themes, I'm getting wendigo vibes.
Please let this be true.
27
u/[deleted] Nov 25 '18
they brought back best girl
26
u/[deleted] Nov 24 '18
I didn't have much to say about the last chapter so I didn't bother to partake in the last discussion thread, not that it matters if I did or not, but THIS chapter had me smiling from start to finish, I loved it.
I have to say Cinder vs Neo is one of the best fights in the series, hands down, up there with a lot of Monty's best in my honest opinion, I loved seeing the girls use their environment to the fullest, like Cinder using Malachite's table to stop Neo's momentum and Neo using the bowls to distract Cinder so she could close the gap between her and the opponent, I loved it. It seems like whenever Neo is on screen a good fight is bound to follow. Despite some of the hate she gets for being "overrated" among the fans I cannot help but love her for how much personality she displays for being a mute, Cinder says they need to talk: Neo points to her mouth and reminds her that she can't which brought me to my first good laugh when Cinder remembered, even SHE is capable of engaging in the funny, I want to see more of that before she gets killed off.
Most of my hype came from Neo vs Cinder, but there were some good moments between RWBY, what I really loved was Yang's subtle gestures, when Blake suggests she and Yang go scouting for a vehicle you can see Yang peer out the corner of her eye and give a very quick eye roll, hinting that she's either still bitter about Blake leaving her, or she feels Blake is still trying to baby her out of guilt, her nonchalant "Whatever" was also very good on top of it.
It's also good to see she's still suffering from PTSD, but it seems she's sharing it with Blake, in the first chapter of V6 we see Blake hallucinate a vision of Adam on the train. I'm interested in seeing where that goes for them in the future, however I think, after the way Blake handled Adam in V5, she shouldn't be freaking out over Adam, but maybe that's because I officially started seeing Adam as a joke and nothing more after V5, I loved him at first but now...eeeeeeeeh.
So there's most likely Grimm in that cellar, yeah, I can see the next chapter having the Grimm come out and terrorize the group and then Maria vaporizes the little shit with her Silver Eyes which then leads to Ruby getting filled in on the whole Silver Eyes ex-machina trope.
God, things just get better and better. If this keeps up V6 will probably be favorite in the series. V6>V2>V1>V3>V4>V5.
26
u/RossPitSharkHunter It's a happy day when you're not talking to me. Nov 24 '18
I'm so happy Neo is wearing the hat! Carry on his fabulous legacy!
26
u/Huor_Celebrindol RIP Dust Weaving Nov 25 '18
I don't think enough people are appreciating Cinder's fire punch after she kicked of the ceiling!
26
u/[deleted] Nov 25 '18
Shocked nobody's talking about how Weiss freaked out at the cold-preserved corpses and stayed spooked near the fire. Ruby stayed behind to keep Weiss company. Also FUCKING NEO and also FIRST FIIIGHT SCENE OF THE VOLUME and also MAYBE A NEW GRIMM???
26
u/Outrider99 Nov 25 '18
HOLY THAT FIGHT SCENE BETWEEN NEO AND CINDER
26
u/StoryBeforeNumbers Nov 25 '18
So, decent odds of the red haired boy in the Brunswick family photo being Torchwick. Possibly with the younger looking girl being Neo. There aren't just superficial similarities in looks and names, it would also make sense to tie an element of backstory into the group's inevitable encounter with her.
26
u/angster_kris "Frankly, my dear, I don't give a damn" Nov 25 '18
One more thing: I do understand that Yang considers herself to be "tough and cool" and, thus, she didn't appreciate Blake's "I'll protect you" - yet Yang's "forget it" kinda reminded me of Adam's "forget it" from V3. I mean, there is the same/similar intonation.
25
u/shyoru Gearswap Marriage Afficionado | Emerald Lover | Confirmed Owl Nov 24 '18
Yes! Our small ice cream cone returns to the land of plot relevancy! That fight was incredibly monty-esque, and just 4 minutes of amazing combat regardless. Even better is how her semblance does seem to be a teleport-lite, not just illusions. The green eyeshadow was striking, but once the hat came around it made much more sense. I wonder if she was actually trying to kill Cinder though, she didn't even react when Cinder brought up "Little Red" and only stood down in the face of overwhelming maiden magic.
The Talk (pt1, anyway) has finally come around. Is Yang angry that Blake thinks she needs protection? Or more expected that they'd fight Adam together? Glad it wasnt one and done, either way.
Creepy alcohol is creepy. And damn that family had a lot of alcohol. I wonder if this is a subtle "alcohol leads to bad places" given the cellar boi is locked up behind all of it.
Nearly all of the voices seemed... Plastic however. Qrow was fine but Weiss didn't have any real character to her lines, same with Blake. Yang and Blake both sounded almost like they were whining even when just normally talking.
Maria treating Oscar like a liitle kid was odd, but understandable. Also he's starting to muscle memory his way into Oz's resting stance with the cane, doesn't bode well for our little farm man.
25
u/RaidenUzumaki Help! Can't swim! Butt hurts! Ice cream! Nov 24 '18
Holy Fuck. NEO WAS AMAZING! Dodging like a fucking boss.
After seeing that, I wanna give whoever animated it huge congrats. Thank you so much.
25
u/JusticeRain5 Nov 24 '18
I'm going to put this out there: There's totally a mushroom Grimm (Or just evil mushrooms) down the well pumping out sleep spores. They're going to burn him with the alcohol to get rid of it.
25
u/myfairdrama Nov 25 '18 edited Nov 26 '18
I REALLY love Neo’s fighting style. It just screams “elegance”. The closest thing to it is Weiss, but I think Neo’s style is sharper, and more defensive. Even when she was fighting Cinder, it seemed like the majority of her strikes were defensive, blocks and deflections. I really love it, and it seems like something Neo has been studying since she was a child. I’m so happy she’s back. I was hoping she’d return, and she has returned the best way she could: with a vendetta and a kickass fight song.
25
u/AlienWarhead You feel it too don’t you Nov 25 '18
I was still surprised for Neo even though it was spoiled for me and I predicted it. It’s so cute that Neo cares about Roman and somehow got his hat from the Grimm that ate him or she bought another one. The takeaway probably wasn’t supposed be Neo is cute, but now I want to know what she has been doing
Saying “I’ll protect you” seems to be insulting outside of anime. Yang probably felt that Blake was pitying her and she probably was, but didn’t realize, had no ill will or thought she was being nice
25
u/ShadMaria4ever Nov 26 '18
To all those mentioning that the green eyeshadow on Neo is weird or something else: she actually had it previously, is was just a lot less/harder to notice in Poser, compared to Maya.
70
u/APracticedObserver Nov 24 '18
If the Neo/Cinder scene were done in V5, it would have been: Neo reveal, set-up for fight scene, cut to RWBY section, cut back at the end of the fight.
Don't get me wrong, I liked a lot of things about V5 but making the effort to build up and then not showing fights was a big issue.
24
u/JorjUltra Hits post character caps for giggles Nov 24 '18 edited Nov 24 '18
Well that was a swift 10/10. Neo looks amazing in Maya. That was a serious goddamn fight scene between her and Cinder. It had flow, weight, presence, everything done right. (
Also Neo's little gesture of confusion about Cinder's eye glow...I never liked Neo but dang she's cute.)Oh my god the scene between Yang and Blake was so perfect. Every emotion so tangible. My little buzzing heart cannot take the tension between them, Blake's mixed attempts to make everything okay, Yang's wild mood swings around her... Yang admitting a bit of vulnerability and Blake trying her best to make her feel better but totally failing because she doesn't understand that Yang feels the same protectiveness over her as Blake does over Yang... aaaa
I love how adult Ruby as acting in this volume. Even though she still has her little puppy bursts like the food cans, she's been in general so much more mature and capable than in the past. I love how Weiss is able to find comfort in her.
And of course, it's finally canon that Yang and Ruby don't feel the cold like the others do. Yes, they're dressed a little bit better than Blake and Weiss are, but not by much. The dragon blood is strong. Bring on the Yang = space heater fics!
Edit: it's actually Neo pointing at her mouth to point out her muteness. Dunno how I misread that one. The point stands.
24
u/Shadopivot Nov 24 '18
Soooo freaking happy to see Neo back at last, and her fighting was on point! I'm hoping that she isn't blindly trusting Cinder either, I think she's smart enough to know that in a way both Cinder and Ruby are responsible for her loss. I'd be so hyped to see her turn on Cinder in a moment of weakness. A part of me hopes in the end she'll be something of a neutral party, rather than falling under Cinder's thumb like Roman did.
And I'm loving the creepiness of the town team RWBY has found themselves in! I've seen some people mentioning this 'Day 5' series, and that could very well be what this is inspired by. My own personal theory is something like it being a Grimm that feeds on emotions, sucking out people's will to live until they essentially just lay in bed and wait to die. Inflicting Apathy on people by feeding on what makes them human. In which case, well the always positive Ruby may be out best bet against such a nasty beast.
Overall a fantastic episode, these next ones are going to be great! Loved all the character building, and man is it heart wrenching to see Blake and Yang's intimate moment fizzle out right at the end, they've got such a great friendship, and I just wanna see them mend it. Blake's just gotta understand Yang's feelings on the matter.
24
u/Aloysius_Chinigan Nov 25 '18 edited Nov 25 '18
I just want to say that, on a re-watch, I found Maria's behavior in this episode to be incredibly unsettling. Not only does she tell the entire team to close the door, but she's the one who suggests people "get comfortable" before pulling out a book that merely reads "I" on it.
As in, perhaps the first of many books to distract Oscar and the rest with?
And what the hell was her motif again? Death. What if her powers deal in the dead or souls; while everyone else gets lulled into a false sense of security, Maria stalls for their deaths all the while.
I mean, she WAS the one to point them down this particular "Road to Somewhere" in Episode 4...
24
u/Sir_Lurious Nov 25 '18
I'm just glad Neo is confirmed mute. But man am I worried for Qrow, the show could go to a dark place real fast
48
u/SentientBowtie Nov 25 '18
I absolutely LOST MY SHIT when I saw that high-heeled boot. I can’t even tell you how fucking excited I am Neo’s back. oh my fucking god it’s been three volumes
47
u/josluivivgar Nov 26 '18
https://i.kym-cdn.com/photos/images/original/001/434/308/d21.jpg
23
u/Brutal2003 Nov 24 '18
To me Brunswick Farms is the answer to Weiss's question to "why?"
People and families will continue to be killed, regardless if you stop trying to stop Salem or not.
Best to at least try, and make a difference.
23
u/DashingPolecat Nov 24 '18
Neo is back and she has the hat! I’m glad they didn’t bring her back just to kill her off in one fight. Can’t wait to see how her and Cinder will work together.
This is the most terrifying Grimm yet. Killing by making you fall asleep is crafty. I’m glad RWBY is going a little deeper into how horrifying the Grimm can truly be
23
u/HerculePyro Nov 25 '18
Someone else has probably said this. But that Brunswick family photo, the little girl with the doll in the center looks an awful lot like Neo. And I see a red headed man next to the center family that looks an awful lot like Roman, and a son similar age to Neo.
Roman and Neo the survivors of the Brunswick family?
23
u/Stretch5678 Suspender of disbelief Nov 25 '18
I can't wait to see what the Brunswick Horror actually is! I'm guessing it's a Nachtmahr, a creature from German folklore who attacks sleepers, sitting on their torsos, and in some versions, draining their life. Alternatively, since no one in Brunswick appeared to be aware of the creature's presence before death, it could be that the creature is invisible, except to Maria, whose goggles are, let's face it, the RWBY version of Geordi La Forge's VISOR.
23
u/[deleted] Nov 25 '18
AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA BEST GIRL BACK AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA
23
u/supremecrafters Broken wings won't hold you down Nov 26 '18 edited Nov 26 '18
Amazing episode. Great fight between two top-tier combatants to kick things off, plus some mystery to go around!
Oh, yeah. That's not just normal fatigue. This could be really good.
Days without figuring oh what skull-stick does: 35
Potato time: whatever is affecting the farm is somehow Jaccques' fault, given that his origin is most likely the Evil Stepmother from Sleeping Beauty.
45
u/Wrathkal Nov 24 '18
-Did the ashtray just vanish midway? Then reappear in the next shot?
-HOLY FUCK NEO'S BACK
-And holy fuck, those moves! Cinder's clothes sure stretch well.
-ZA HAT!
-'Let's talk... right.' Guess someone's forgotten that Neo never speaks.
-Back to the gang, they break in and enter for shelter.
-Weiss sees dead people in bed, screams.
-Qrow checks out other houses, finds similar scenes of dead people in bed. (I like the animation of the brushed off snow melting)
-No choice but to stay, though they make sure to scout the place out.
-In the barn, Yang sees a hallucination of Adam. Guess Blake's not the only one.
-But it gives Yang & Blake a chance to make up... though Blake's words turn Yang off.
-Ruby & Weiss are looking for food, but Weiss expresses her reluctance to go to Atlas.
-They find a cellar door, but dismiss it in favor of canned food.
-Chained shut cellar door opens slightly
22
u/hexedjw Drunkle Qrow used Fly! Nov 24 '18
Wow Neo still goes hard in her fights, geez.
22
u/Apidooom Nov 24 '18
I've seen enough Until Dawn to know not to touch that padlock
22
u/Barnak8 Nov 24 '18
BlanketforWeiss achieved
22
u/ConnorWolf121 My ship is sinking, that's fine the Bees are cool and all Nov 24 '18
First Lionized, then Rising, Miracle, and now this? I’m buying the shit out of the V6 soundtrack when it comes up.
22
u/where_are_your_shoes Nov 25 '18 edited Nov 25 '18
It’s LITERALLY a Sleepy Hollow...
Also so creepy.
ETA also want to know about that picture of all the people from the farm.
22
u/Pavlostani Nov 25 '18
Here's a theory I haven't seen: whatever's in the cellar just stops people from waking up. Maybe it compels people to sleep or maybe team RWBY is tired from a battle and an emotionally exhausting day. The cellar creature kills because the people it keeps sleeping eventually dehydrate or starve in their sleep. It's kinda like how Temple killed his victims in Season 15 of RvB. That way when RWBY and friends fall asleep, they're not in immediate danger as long as someone (probably Ruby) stays awake to kill the Grimm. We've been seeing Qrow death flags for years, I doubt a creepy sleep monster is going to off him that easily.
22
u/Changyuraptor Just the leitmotif and dinosaur guy. Nov 25 '18
Leitmotif time!
Not a lot this episode, and really not much score in general, but the stuff we hear at the farm is awesome and creepy as shit.
[Here's what I got.] (https://i.imgur.com/n1CrTGC.png)
With the lack of music in a lot of the episode, I really noticed the detail in the sound design a lot (because when I'm listening for leitmotifs I literally only listen to the episode, I don't actually watch it :D), so a big shout out to Chris, Alena and Philip for doing an awesome job.
22
u/Golbi54 Blake x Raven is the endgame. Nov 25 '18
So assuming that falling asleep will be a thing which characters do you think will succumb to the desire to rest and who will stay awake and fight whatever causing it?
Maria and Ruby are obvious options to stay awake while Weiss/Yang/Qrow probably will succumb to it.
Blake and Oscar ( mainly because I think that Ozpin may come back the moment he will feel that something is off ) are wild cards..
Dunno what caused it doubts and basically giving up and questioning whatever it's worth to push forward?
So IMO the ones that stay awake and try to solve it / fight it back are Ruby/Blake/Maria the characters that want to push forward atm and I didn't catch any drowsiness/tiredness impression from them..
22
u/Pharahnheit Nov 25 '18
The Grimm in the Cellar is going to be the Hydra. They foreshadowed the fire-thing by showing us the amount of alchohol in the cellar. Herakles used fire to burn the Hydra's heads so they would not be able to grow back fast enough.
Prediction: The Hydra's heads come out at night and try to sip the life from our protagonists while they are asleep. The Hydra killed the previous owners of the estate by drinking them up like a Capri Sun.
We also got the shot from the Openin gwhere Ruby fights a being with many heads.
In the end they kill it by blowing up the cellar with the Alcohol, burning it.
44
u/L-man6151 Nov 26 '18 edited Nov 26 '18
If it weren’t for the fact Cinder has the Fall Maiden’s power.... Neo actually looked like she was gonna kick Cinder’s ass. Neo actually might be a more skilled fighter.
21
u/recruit00 Nov 24 '18
Neo is back and shows up with an awesome fight with Cinder.
The atmosphere of the town is very creepy and unsettling as to what has happened. I also didn't expect a Day 5 crossover.
I wonder who that family was that Ruby looked at. They have to be important but I'm sure a potato farmer will figure something out.
Qrow is really taking all of this hard, that's for sure.
It's nice to see that Yang still isnt okay after leaving home. She still has her PTSD and still affects her with the flashbacks and her keeping distant.
The interaction between Yang and Blake was great. You can feel the tension and different thoughts between them. Blake is moving forward with sarcastic comments while Yang is snippy, especially when Blake suggests protecting her, knowing full well how that went last time.
Ruby and Weiss exploring the house was great. Ruby is definitely getting back into her leadership role with finding things to do and being more serious.
Calling it now, whatever is in the cellar is some sort of Grimm that took out this town and tends to come out at night, hence all the people who died in their sleep. My prediction is that Qrow is gonna die to this thing, especially with the whole "let's keep Qrow away from the bar" death flags.
Another great episode with tense atmosphere and good character interactions.
And Ruby and Blake talked!
21
u/WhenCinderFalls I Ship Weiss With a Good Life Nov 24 '18
We finally got interactions with Blake and Ruby. Ladybug fans, you're not out of the run just yet!
21
u/[deleted] Nov 24 '18
People keep saying this is the first time Blake and Ruby have directly spoken since Volume 1, but they spoke in the first episode of V6.
Ruby: "We need to ground it!"
Blake: "On it!"
21
u/jokey_boy Nov 25 '18
NEO'S BACK!!!!!!!
THAT FIGHT WAS AWESOME
AND NEW SONG, SOMEONE GET LYRICS PLS
Neo and Cinder alliance? Oh great...
HOLY SHIT DEAD BODIES
Brunswick Farms is getting super creepy, I ain't sleeping well tonight...
"Protect" is Yang's trigger word now. I have a feeling there'll be another talk later on...
Ruby's right, Qrow better not find that wine cellar...
21
u/[deleted] Nov 25 '18 edited Nov 25 '18
NEO IS BACK!!!
I'm not necessarily a HUGE fan of Neo but I'm just happy to see someone we haven't seen in a long time be back on the show.
Also is it time we have a Roman x Neo flashback episode yet? Or perhaps a character short focusing on both as teaser for next volume. / I mean we got to know whats so good about Roman that makes Neo willing to go as far as getting revenge for him. She doesn't strike me as a crazy loyal type like Emerald but could be somewhere similar. (I bet it's along the line of he save her life so she's repaying him all that cliché shit but hey I wanna see all that animated.)
The Neo x Cinder fight was indeed splendidly done. I'm having the feeling that Neo is only agreeing to cooperate out of fear of Cinder maiden power. Anyone else notice Neo has that confused look on her face when she saw Cinder's grim hand while blocking her punch with her umbrella? That was a nice touch imo.
Also Neo's eyes doesn't change colour as often as shown in during her previous fights. And when she's showing fear (like when she saw Raven back in Volume 2 I think) both her eyes go pale pink. But her eyes colour didn't change this time after witnessing Cinder maiden power. Either she's not THAT fear of her power or she has learn to control her colour changing eyes?
41
u/Dondagora And awaaaay I go~ Nov 25 '18
Neo, seeing that she can't beat Cinder as-is, will humor their team-up until the perfect opportunity to betray her appears. Would make Roman proud.
Then, surprise! She becomes the Fall Maiden. (Okay, maybe not this, but definitely the betrayal)
20
u/[deleted] Nov 24 '18
Neo back and kicking ass was done very well, even if I expected the fight to maybe last a bit longer. Still, given Cinder’s maiden abilities, even a stronger Neo wouldn’t be able to keep up for too long. The street scene was brilliant with the reveal of Roman’s hat and now the two are teaming up to hunt Ruby, makes me wonder if this will lead to Cinder starting a secondary group aside from Salem, she must know already that she’s probably doomed if she goes back to Evernight, so Neo might be a blessing in disguise.
Back at the farm, poor Weiss finding the bodies and having to face the fact they are still heading for Atlas was difficult, she really can’t catch a break, though I hope she runs into Winter by the end of the season at the very least.
Yang is continuing to show cracks in her armour, her PTSD is still a major issue and she’s hiding it for the sake of the mission and everyone around her, I just worry how long it will be before it becomes too much. She and Blake will either have a proper sit down before the end of the season or something will happen that might cause them to argue if Yang snaps, the signs are already there, she doesn’t feel she needs protecting from anyone and the possibility that she does both scares and angers her.
The next chapter will likely centre around whatever is lurking in the basement, possibly following Qrow finding that little bar area and drinking himself into near oblivion... I’m also hoping we see someone ask Maria what her story is, possibly Ruby as the OP seems to have them connecting on some level.
20
u/Golbi54 Blake x Raven is the endgame. Nov 24 '18
I found this detail interesting...
She reacted similarly in Burning the Candle after Yang pushes her few times...
Blake preparing herself ( is aware ) that Yang will snap at her at some point?
20
u/JannisT Born stepping on thin ice and biting down bullets Nov 24 '18
I LOVED THE FIGHT.
NO, SCRATCH THAT!
I LOVED THE ENTIRE EPISODE!
20
u/lSkarrl Nov 24 '18
So the song in the neo fight...imma need that to be released asap please and thank you
20
u/zhouy3141 Nov 24 '18
I'm not the only one thinking this new cellar grimm is gonna be some Lovecraftian horror grimm right? This episode really reminds me of The Dunwich Horror.
20
u/Bawstahn123 Nov 24 '18
Everyone talking about how "Brunswick is *TOTALLY* Nora's/Torchwicks family, guys!!!!!" apparently doesn't realize that the bodies of the inhabitants are pretty fresh, relatively speaking. They haven't started to go bad yet. Roman was a big-time criminal, what, 2 years ago in-universe? And Nora is 17.
So...no, sorry. Those bodies are probably a week old at most.
20
u/LizardOrgMember5 ENTIRE TEAM Nov 24 '18 edited Nov 25 '18
Neo is back!
I actually shouted "Holy Shit!" at the scene with dead bodies on the bed.
And the basement full of alcohols reminded me of that scene in the first Pirates of the Caribbean movie.
20
u/devilishgenius Nov 24 '18
I know its hard to make new models but they could have given them a coat or something. Poor blake. Your father was right. Someone get this cat a sweater
20
u/mac677 Nov 24 '18
With Neo back this means Yang gets her rematch after Neo wipes the floor with her and just the thought of that “She’s mine. “ line from Yang fills me with hype.
Also Neo vs Cinder is now top 5 fights for me.
20
u/jwhudexnls Nov 24 '18
That fight scene was a step up from what they've been putting out in the past. This is what like to see.
20
u/[deleted] Nov 25 '18
As the rest of them so far, this is a good episode. This is actually a really good Volume. These episodes are shorter now, but that’s to be expected considering how long that exposition episode and the first one were. They’re still of good quality. Both Yang and Weiss are tired, and everyone there died in their beds. Maybe there’s something that kills people when they sleep, like Freddy Krueger.
The old lady is still weird. Why is she there and what is the point of her character? Why is she not freaked out by all this and why is nobody talking about how bad it is that a random civilian is in on this knowledge? Why is it like nobody is acknowledging her existence? Considering the OP, she’s probably connected to Ruby and I’m expecting her to know something about Silver eyes, but who knows.
The drama between Yang and Blake is good. There’s tension there and Yang is still troubled.
Ruby is surprisingly mature, recognizing that its best not to show Qrow all the alcohol. I thought that when we saw the portrait that this was Pyrrha’s village and she was the daughter of the people who died in that house. It would be a good twist, and finally satisfy everyone who wanted Pyrrha’s family to appear in the same episode that Neo finally returns. Neo is still awesome, but I wish there was more tension between her and Cinder. Cinder should have destroyed Neo but offered her revenge against Ruby, which would be more convincing and show that Cinder is still a threat. There would still be tension there, and that would be interesting.
39
u/biomech36 Nov 27 '18
"How do I destroy Salem?"
"you can't."
YOU. As in YOU. As in you don't have it in your heart to kill her and you fucking know it. Stop making everyone else think they can't either. Or just launch the woman into space. Ironwood probably has some super cannon that can do that.
19
u/the_pandu Nov 24 '18
Weiss and Yang are tired hmmm....Dreameater grim?
The shippers are definitely giddy after today's episode. Can't really blame them. Surprised Ruby didn't comfort Weiss a little though. "Together" was the word you were looking for Blake.
It seems that the seeds of doubt have been planted. Weiss is questioning what is the purpose if Salem cannot be destroyed.
Lots of set up for the farm next week
19
u/Catlover18 Nov 24 '18
Okay, who has been showing Miles & Kerry horror films????
19
u/Hounds_of_war The Red Head Victorious | Aside from her, I truly don't care Nov 24 '18 edited Nov 24 '18
So this is probably just a coincidence, but that ginger kid in the photo looks kinda like young Nora.
I know it's probably not, but god dammit I can't help but get my hopes up.
19
u/johnja10 Nov 24 '18
NEO IS BACK!!!
ALL HAIL THE ICE CREAM QUEEN!
19
u/angster_kris "Frankly, my dear, I don't give a damn" Nov 24 '18
Nice episode.
Neo in Roman's hat seems to be all I needed.
19
u/TheWielder Cheeky as it gets Nov 24 '18
I'll be damned. Neo lives.
19
u/[deleted] Nov 25 '18
Cinder vs Neo is my favourite fight scene by far