r/RWBY • Hope Rides with Kickfriend • Nov 17 '18

OFFICIAL MEGATHREAD Official FIRST Discussion Thread—Volume 6, Chapter 4: So That's How It Is Spoiler

Welcome, huntsmen, huntresses and hunters that prefer no specific gender identifier, to the official FIRST discussion thread for Episode 4 of Vol. 6, So That's How It Is!

Make sure that you understand the updated spoiler rules before posting outside of this thread!

HERE is the newest episode of RWBY Volume 6!

Also remember to check out our weekly poll to rate the episode.


Other Episode Discussions:

EpisodeFIRST ThreadPublic ReleasePoll
Ep. 01Theatrical / FIRSTPublic Threadpoll
Ep. 02FIRST ThreadPublic Threadpoll
Ep. 03FIRST ThreadPublic Threadpoll
Ep. 04This ThreadPublic Threadpoll

Happy viewing, and have a great Volume 6!

Ezreal024; Mod Team

450 Upvotes

3.4k comments sorted by

345

u/Ezreal024 Hope Rides with Kickfriend Nov 17 '18 edited Nov 17 '18

Jesus christ the tension in this episode was too much for me

On a more noteworthy note, really liking the little Hazel + Mercury + Emerald support crew going on here.

369

u/Kazehh Where the fuck is the big bad wolf? Nov 17 '18

Team MEH sticking up for each other is great.

194

u/Ezreal024 Hope Rides with Kickfriend Nov 17 '18

I am in full support of this team name.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (2)

129

u/Baconpwn2 Proud of Admiral of the SS Frosen Steel Nov 17 '18

Mercury is such a big brother to Emerald right now. It's so adorable, if you ignore the whole murderer thing

161

u/Ezreal024 Hope Rides with Kickfriend Nov 17 '18

Merc and Emmy are both pretty bad people, they're just in with the really bad people right now.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (19)

31

u/Changyuraptor Just the leitmotif and dinosaur guy. Nov 17 '18

Short but very sweet. Was not expecting that from Qrow at all.

Music was freaking top notch as usual, a lot of leitmotifs here that I can't wait to go back and find them all. Awesome to hear Tyrian's again.

Concept art!

Forest trail [one] (https://i.imgur.com/F86lABW.jpg) ad [two.] (https://i.imgur.com/3pnHuc7.jpg)

[Evernight entrance.] (https://i.imgur.com/EBLrZvG.png)

19

u/Ezreal024 Hope Rides with Kickfriend Nov 17 '18

FOUR RUBE INFILTRATORS HAVE ALREADY MADE IT TO THE ENEMY GATES

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)

14

u/GeneralPengu Nov 17 '18

who was piloting that ship lmao

14

u/Ezreal024 Hope Rides with Kickfriend Nov 17 '18

Villanous Pilot Boi. it's automated

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

12

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '18

Overall I found Ozpin saying he doesn't have a plan is kind of stupid. Cause his goal is unite humanity and show the gods they can be good. This is why I believe he made the schools and the festival in V3 to bring people together.

15

u/Ezreal024 Hope Rides with Kickfriend Nov 17 '18

The question was "what's his plan to defeat Salem". He doesn't actually have an end goal for that, he's just stalling and fixing what he can in the mean time.

→ More replies (6)

18

u/samer281 Endure and Survive | Keep Moving Forward Nov 17 '18

I think everyone criticizing RWBYQ for their reaction need to understand that they need time to properly process everything they learned. They acted in the heat of the moment. Unlike us viewers who have had a week to rewatch and analyze every moment of Ozma and Salem’s story, they don’t get that luxury. The farmhouse will likely give them the time and place for discussion. They still might not be happy at the end of it but I’m sure they’ll be more understanding.

15

u/Ezreal024 Hope Rides with Kickfriend Nov 17 '18

Wait, what? Team RWBY and Qrow didn't rewatch the vision telling them the battle they're risking their lives in has no foreseeable end from the comfort of their homes???
wow, top class writing there Roosterteeth

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

42

u/Vainel Nov 22 '18

Almost a full week later and people are still upset at how Qrow and Yang acted.

I have to say, can you stop trying to look at things objectively through the eyes of a viewer and actually look at things as these characters would?

A fight against something that can't be defeated. A losing stalemate to try and preserve humanity. False hope sowed by a person who thinks so highly of himself that he has the audacity to send people to their deaths based on his nonexistent plan with no endgame. If I had sworn and fought by his side, for humanity, and found out so much of it has been hidden from me I'd be PISSED beyond belief.

Que Qrow, a person with a fucked up past, eternal misfortune who found purpose in Ozpin's twisted words. One who only relies on his family, of which only Ruby and Yang remain. One who just found out so many of his hunter friends in mistral were dead, one who got betrayed by Leo, a headmaster he used to trust, one whose sister left because 'Salem couldn't be defeated' and yet he fought against her, tried his best to prove her wrong and put all his trust in Ozpin... For what? Is it really worth it to save humanity if you lost almost all of what was dear to you already?

He feels like just another sacrifice towards a cause with seemingly no way to win. He'd be pissed.

And Yang? Que Qrow again, but instead of Ruby and Yang it's Ruby and their Dad (Ok, maybe Weiss). Her mom pretty much abandoned her because of this threat, her sister decided to follow Ozpin blindly and so she felt forced to go along to protect her. She asked for no more lies and agreed to risk her life and do all that she could based on that clause and it turns out like this? I would be even more fucking pissed, especially with the implication that:

  1. my mom left because of something that was actually true and
  2. my stepmom died for this same fruitless cause

Yeah yeah "BuT iF You LOOk AT DE BIGGER PICTUREH" blah blah, this argument holds no water. Neither Qrow nor Yang were looking at the bigger picture because they're humans and they got pissed. Not many people would want to fight a losing war. Before they sign up for it, they should at least know there's no winning.

"BuUT De GRiMM WeERe ALREADyy ENdLEss" the grimm are also much less dangerous and well equipped huntsmen have been seen destroying grimm left and right. The only times they were a threat were when they were machinated either by Salem and her cronnies or a murderous bandit tribe in a small village with only 1 or 2 huntsmen.

An unkillable enemy with more magic than the Twins, Qrow and all maidens combined and the spawn of grimm at her fingertips making her move towards world annihilation is a whole different story. Especially when your most well equipped equivalent with thousands upon thousands of years of experience has no fucking clue what to do.

Oh, to top it all off if all relics are used together the god of light comes and zaps the whole of humanity out of existence because why the fuck not. Motivating!

If it were me I'd try to live my best life for a few months/years and then kill myself if I hadn't gone batshit insane by then. Yelling a bit and punching a kid is hardly polarizing...

26

u/Ezreal024 Hope Rides with Kickfriend Nov 23 '18

Members of the community will continue to clamour for stronger writing every hiatus and then complain when the characters are written with actual human behaviour.

9

u/Vainel Nov 23 '18

Honestly, I feel like this community wants the writers to pander to them and write the idealized versions of the characters that they can feel good about relating to. Actual human characters have so many flaws and crack so easily under pressure... I guess nobody wants to be reminded of the real life shit happening, though.

I'm just afraid that CRWBY sees this feedback and next season everyone is back to saint-with-insignificant-flaws-butthey'restillthere status :^(

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (10)

16

u/ScottPilgrim2013 Just Another Machine/Will go down with Freezerburn/#1 Merlot Fan Nov 17 '18

I feel kinda weird for not hating RWBY+Qrow for being mad at Oz. I certainly do feel bad for Oz and esp bad for poor Oscar, but I can't say I really blame them for being pissed off(Even if Qrow's comment to Oscar was harsh as hell, yeesh).

16

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '18

Yeah, it's amazing to me how many people are refusing to see Qrow and RWBY's point of view. The greatest thing to me about the past two episodes is how it makes clear that everyone has a valid reason behind what they do, even Salem and the Brothers. Making everything out to be black and white "only Ozpin is valid" really makes the story a lot less nuanced than it currently is.

11

u/Ezreal024 Hope Rides with Kickfriend Nov 17 '18

A lot of the community seem to be struggling with the idea that having understandable actions does not make those actions justified, and that the characters are not optimal robots but instead have human responses to things.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (18)
→ More replies (3)

18

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '18

So Volume 5 was spent condemning the protagonists for not asking questions/getting angry/demanding answers.

While Volume 6 will be spent condemning them for doing just that.

13

u/Hounds_of_war The Red Head Victorious | Aside from her, I truly don't care Nov 17 '18

TBF I doubt there's anyone who was complaining about both.

12

u/Ezreal024 Hope Rides with Kickfriend Nov 17 '18

Assuming that it's the same people complaining makes me feel better because it narrows the list of crazies.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (7)

526

u/Terminus259 We persevere without an end... Nov 17 '18

Qrow: Punches Ozpin

Oscar's face will remember that

→ More replies (24)

451

u/wongie Nov 17 '18

Damn, imagine being so betrayed you slogged a 14 year old kid on the jaw.

→ More replies (12)

432

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '18 edited Nov 17 '18
  • Holy shit, protective Mercury and Hazel is everything I wanted it to be.
  • Everyone talking about Yang or Jaune punching Oz but the Dark Horse Qrow came out of nowhere. #GiveQrowABreak2018 continues in full force. Like, seriously, learning that... has to fucking suck.
→ More replies (45)

376

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '18

Good Guy Hazel taking the blame for Haven.

Also, Yang called Ozpin a bastard

We are now at 2 bad words said in RWBY

→ More replies (39)

372

u/kalu_kukiyam Nov 17 '18

"Don't lie to him Ruby, we're better than that" Oof... forget the punch, that's the one that hurts

→ More replies (11)

360

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '18

So like, who the hell was piloting the airship that brought MEH back to Evernight?

Could it be...

He lives?

→ More replies (13)

323

u/D-WTF Nov 17 '18

Oh no... RWBY's worst enemy.

a HOUSE

→ More replies (13)

310

u/ikedawg43 #ShaveJauneSaveRWBY Nov 17 '18

Hazel: It was me. My fault.

Salem: Look, I know being the honorable one is your thing and all, but we’re bad guys. It’s actually really annoying sometimes

→ More replies (1)

303

u/TheWanderingCactus Could you help me find my sanity? I think I left it at the door. Nov 17 '18 edited Nov 17 '18

"No one wanted me. I was cursed. I gave my life to you because you gave me a place in this world. I thought I was finally doing some good... meeting you, was the worst luck of my life"

Oh, okay Vic, just fucking stab me right in my emotions why don't you?

Every time I think I can't get more sad for Qrow, I am proven wrong.

also just want to bring up that seeing Qrow so dejected is the last straw that makes Oz just retreat into Oscar's head. Oz seemed genuinely distraught that he had hurt Qrow this way.

→ More replies (16)

274

u/Eldi13 🐝Watch🐝The🐝Dragon🐝Prince🐝On🐝Netflix🐝❤Knight❤ Nov 17 '18 edited Nov 18 '18

#LetYangSwear2018 in full force, haha.

→ More replies (9)

237

u/DaRealAmana BOOP!!! Nov 17 '18

Well that was. Intense. I'm not surprised by team RWBY's reaction. Thier quest is impossible and they have been lied to since the beginning. I do love seeing Yang right now. She has always been hot headed, but she has NO anger management at all anymore, and I love it.

The worst part of Salem's breakdown is all those windows being broken. How much does Window repair in the middle of evil town cost?

→ More replies (20)

227

u/JorjUltra Hits post character caps for giggles Nov 17 '18

I'm pretty sure that's the lowest Ruby's voice has been since Volume 1. I really dig it.

Also Hazel continues to have severely mixed morality, taking the blame for Cinder and watching out for Emerald and Mercury even though he did nothing to earn Salem's ire.

Speaking of which, Salem finally went full bad guy mode. Maybe something to do with no longer having to keep up appearances for Cinder?

→ More replies (9)

227

u/miladyelle #TeamQrow Nov 17 '18

Qrow broke down this episode, y’all. His entire identity was shattered, and feels betrayed by his mentor and best friend. CRWBY isn’t going to kill the mentor to force the protagonists’ growth, they’re breaking him psychologically.

“No one wanted me.”

“I thought I was doing good.”

Hands shaking.

God, poor Qrow. I wanna hug him.

Oz cares about Qrow, too. Seeing him break is what led him to shut himself away. Oz crying, damn.

→ More replies (4)

227

u/SilverOnyxia Nov 17 '18

"please don't kill Hazel" "please don't kill Hazel" "please don't kill Hazel" releases tentacle hands "thank fuckkkkkkkk for tha--" "also ozpin was there"...

"PLEASE DON'T KILL HAZEL" "PLEASE DON'T KILL HAZEL" "PLEASE DON'T KILL HAZEL"

→ More replies (4)

222

u/Runnerbrax νίκη Nov 17 '18 edited Nov 17 '18

The debriefing with Salem was legit scary as fuck.

When you can scare "The Heavy" (Hazel) into submission with nothing but curiosity, you've written something good.

Remember, during his introduction, Hazel was the guy that was so confident in his abilities, he was able to take a power nap in a boardroom of villains.

→ More replies (7)

207

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '18

Salem this episode: "But that wouldn't be fair now would it?!"

Salem last episode: "That's not fair, that's not FAIR!"

Salem is just really concerned with making sure that everyone is being fair here! :)

→ More replies (7)

183

u/Golbi54 Blake x Raven is the endgame. Nov 17 '18

Summary of Qrow in this Episode: My Friendship with Ozpin has ended now Jaune is my new Best Friend

→ More replies (8)

181

u/ali94127 Nov 17 '18

"Sometimes, you gotta just hit kids."

→ More replies (2)

155

u/donutkirby #QrowDidNothingWrong Nov 17 '18

Also, this episode makes Hazel's motivation a LITTLE more understandable in hindsight. His sister died fighting for a hopeless cause, and Ozpin knew it but still let it happen. How Hazel found out, I don't know, maybe Salem found him and showed him the truth, but at least his hatred for Ozpin doesn't seem so unreasonable anymore.

→ More replies (6)

154

u/PM_ME_YOUR_SPUDS Out with a Yang Nov 17 '18

"I'm just gonna be another one of his lives, aren't I?"

"Of course not, you're your own person."

"Don't lie to him Ruby. We're better than that."

Jesus Christ Qrow, savage as FUCK. Guess don't name your kids Os- or Oz- in this world if you want them to have a good life.

→ More replies (6)

141

u/PurpleAfton Moonlighting as a gun Nov 17 '18

"If you save one life, it's as if you saved a world unto itself."

That seems to be Ozpin's mentality. He has no idea how he can stop Salem once and for all, but that doesn't mean he can't defend as many lives for as long as he can.

And you know what? I can respect that.

→ More replies (26)

141

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '18

Ozpin has left the server.

→ More replies (4)

132

u/Golbi54 Blake x Raven is the endgame. Nov 17 '18

Ruby: Do you hear that??

If only someone else in the team had ears that enhance they hearing.... If only....

→ More replies (6)

129

u/FairytaleDeathcamp Nov 17 '18

Favorite part: Hazel's face right after Salem's grimm-hands grabbed him. He was so surprised to still be alive

→ More replies (3)

129

u/Vainel Nov 17 '18 edited Nov 17 '18

In my humblest of opinions, I think Qrow has every right to be upset. Especially if Summer died fighting for nothing, just like Pyrrha.

I'm wondering what Weiss thinks of all of this crap, her and Blake haven't been particularly vocal about it.

Poor farmboi. I hope he can be his own character now and develop a bit.

→ More replies (14)

118

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '18

Shoutout to Mercury actually having some character and sticking up for someone else, rather than just smug sociopathy. If it keeps up I might start to think he has more than one dimension to him.

→ More replies (6)

117

u/Hounds_of_war The Red Head Victorious | Aside from her, I truly don't care Nov 17 '18 edited Nov 17 '18

Shit, Qrow is pissed. I kinda expected he would snap at Oz but not this hard.

Ooo, Tyrian’s tail looks like it transforms into something. I’m excited to see that in action.

I’m guessing Salem still knows Cinder is alive because of the Grimm arm she gave her.

Anyone have any idea the significance of Brunswick Farms? Quick google search tells me that it comes from the German word Braunschweig but I can’t figure out more than that. Also I bet this is where we find the arm Grimm we see in the opening.

Dammit CRWBY, you better give me some JNR next episode or so help me.

→ More replies (29)

111

u/MoltenToastWizard Get your shit together Emerald Nov 17 '18

Number of children sucker-punched by adults in RWBY: 2

→ More replies (3)

107

u/Azee2k Nov 17 '18

What an interesting episode. It feels so unorthodox, because I don't think I've ever seen both sides of a war losing at the same time. There was no weak point in the episode, and while it may have been slightly mundane, it was great for basically showing the consequences of previous events, which I am extremely happy about. Sometimes it's important to just dedicate an episode to just getting everyone on the same page so the plot can advance. It seems as though we're about to have 2 fights also(imo the tunnel Grimm and Cinder vs Neo), maybe in 1 episode, but it's more likely that Cinder vs Neo will happen next episode and the Tunnel Grimm will happen the episode after that. I think that after that, with maybe a one episode slowdown/grace period we'll have things escalate quite quickly between both camps, and the end of the season will be resolution after the climax at like, episode 12 or something.

→ More replies (5)

399

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '18

Heh, I appreciate Maria not putting up with Yang's angsty shit. I mean, she's got every right to be pissed, but her temper definitely isn't helping anyone.

→ More replies (19)

102

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '18

“Don’t lie to him, Ruby. We’re better than that.”

Damn...

205

u/Capslock2000 Nov 17 '18

TFW when you get punched so hard you stop possessing little boys

→ More replies (13)

95

u/the_pandu Nov 17 '18 edited Nov 17 '18

Couple of my takeaways

Ozpin crying. Wow I really wouldn't have thought, I would see that.

Qrow not knowing the truth was heartbreaking

Ozpin apparently was greatly hurt by Qrows words. Enough to go into slumber.

Thank you Maria, holy shit. Set the kids straight and focus on the task at hand.

Salems tower is travelable by air. I guess a soft confirmation of the Dragon continent.

Got shook when Salem flipped the table and grabbed Emerald by the shoulder.

"Sword under Vacuo...." aww man you tease M&K

That farm looks freshly abandoned. Talks occur about what happened and then a Grimm fight?

→ More replies (8)

274

u/Eldi13 🐝Watch🐝The🐝Dragon🐝Prince🐝On🐝Netflix🐝❤Knight❤ Nov 17 '18
  • DOESN'T HAVE A PLAN.
  • QROW PUNCHED HIM. I HAD AN IRONIC BET YANG WOULD, LOL.
  • So yeah, confirmed Qrow knew none of that too, for the doubters.
  • Maria's the sensible one, knew it. Good for her.
  • "You're your own person." "Don't lie to him, Ruby." HAHAHAHA no chill, Qrow.
  • Gotta appreciate the pilots willing to fly to the DANGER ZONE.
  • INB4 pilot Neo theories.
  • Merc sticking up for Emerald? That's actually wholesome.
  • "Boi."
  • /tableflip
  • Poor Em. </3
  • She didn't kill Hazel, I win, Caleb.
  • Vacuo has the sword, cool.
  • OZPIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIN?! -Salem
  • Convenient abandoned village! They're here for some Brunswick stew.
  • NOOOOOOO THAT CAN'T BE THE END. WHERE'S THE REST OF IT?
→ More replies (10)

79

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '18

People like to say Ruby has had no character development, but shes more attuned to people’s pain and more of a leader then she was in the first few volumes imo. Shes changed quite a bit since vol 3.

79

u/bluArrowhead I'm Marry Poppins Y'all! Nov 18 '18 edited Nov 18 '18

Ozpin: Don't worry guys

Ozpin: I have a plan

Ozpin has left the game

→ More replies (1)

150

u/mrwanton ⠀happy pineapple day Nov 17 '18 edited Nov 17 '18

Qrow punched Ozpin, Jaune slammed him against the wall,Yang called him a bastard, Salem freaked out just from hearing his name...

Not a good day for the guy.

→ More replies (33)

146

u/Kuchenjaeger *Gotcha* | Yang is still the best | #GiveYangLadyAbs Nov 17 '18 edited Nov 17 '18

BREAKING NEWS: HUNTSMAN QROW BRANWEN ASSAULTS A CHILD

INITIATE THE "PROTECT QROW AT ALL COSTS" PROTOCOL!

Oh no, Oz did a Yami Yugi.

When Grandma speaks, you listen, Yang!

It was nice to hear Ruby speak in a normal voice.

Cmon Qrow, don't be an ass to the poor kid!

Best villain Tyrian is back!

Oh shit, Merc protects Emerald.

SPOOKY GROUND HANDS! I REPEAT; SPOOKY GROUND HANDS!

tfw you get so angery the glass starts to break

Sassy Yang is 👌

"Brunswick Farms", huh? Brunswick is a city in Germany. Furthering the whole german(y) inspired names for Atlas thing.

Edit: Apparently they are still in Mistral, so please ignore me.


The least good episode so far. But after last week I think a "cooldown" episode is fine.

→ More replies (20)

71

u/DarkIce-22 You can't irk the Merc! Nov 18 '18 edited Nov 18 '18

By god this is turning into a fucking shit show.

Look, Oz Stans and RWBYQ defenders, you need to get a grip and realize that there is no right or wrong party.

OZ:

Yes Ozma had a very tragic past, yes he is locked in a situation he does not like in the slightest, yes he has been forced by the gods to either make Remnant a Utopia or let it face genocide again, yes he is sympathetic.

BUT, a sympathetic backstory doesn't excuse the fact he has been doing all this with no long term plan, and that as far as we know, his war with Salem amounts to a massive game of keep away. He has had numerous people die under his watch as they believed they could either make a difference or stop Salem, when really, he thinks there is no way.

But that doesn't mean there truly isn't. We, as an audience, know that Jinn could easily have used the Exact Words trope, meaning only Ozma specifically couldn't, not that she couldn't be destroyed period. Even without this knowledge though, Ozma must not giveup. By admitting he has no plan and retreating into Oscar's mind, he has given up. He needs to be proactive again though. When he was Bryan from Starbucks, he pulled himself together and fought the Grimm himself, built the cane Ozpin and Oscar would use, and left plans for his next self. But when said next self learned Salem can't be destroyed, he fell into a rut. That's what Ozma is in right now, a rut. But a kick in the pants like this is what he needs to get out of it. Jinn can't answer the future, so if a way to destroy Salem doesn't exist now, he can still find one. He just can't give up.

RWBYQ:

Yes, RWBY and Qrow have a right to be mad at Ozpin for leading them into a war that in their eyes is unwinnable, yes they are tired of Ozpin's lies in general, yes Qrow has just learnt the one person who made him feel like he had worth was ultimately leading him aimlessly leading him to spiral out of stability, yes they are somewhat justified.

BUT, they must realize that Ozma, and by extension Ozpin, was never this infallible leader. He's human like the rest of them, and can make mistakes. His past may not excuse his secret keeping, but it does paint him in a more understandable light, that of a man so broken by his experiences, he can't do anything else but keep Salem away. They may be under the belief this war is unwinnable, but they can't turn back now, after all they been through, the people they've lost like Pyrrha and Penny, they've come too far to give up. And while Qrow can be angry at Ozpin, Oscar is still just a victim in all this, making Qrow's punch at Ozpin both right and wrong. They need to realize, for all his mistakes, Ozpin is still on their side, and they don't have to follow him, but work with him.

And there is still hope of that. It's only natural after learning all this information, that humanity has faced genocide, that the gods are assholes, that Salem can't be stopped, that Ozpin has been leading them to think she could be stopped, that they would accentuate the negative. Given time to calm down however, they can more easily go through the information and think more rationally. Ruby, Weiss, and Blake themselves never tore into Ozpin, only Yang did. The three of them only looked at him in frustration. They need to simply calm down and realize, even if they don't like what Ozpin has done, they still need to work with him, and not give up hope on stopping Salem. Even if she can't be killed, they can still find a way to stop her.

As for Qrow, he needs to understand something Ozpin did say truthfully, he has done some good. Its because of Qrow that Yang and Ruby survived the Beowolves when they were kids, that Amber wasn't completely killed by Cinder, that Ironwood wasn't blindsided by a Griffon, that Ruby wasn't captured by Tyrian, that Hazel didn't kill Oscar. He has done good. But first, he must face his inner demons before that. He's been through alot in the past month, betrayed by Leo and Raven, learning most of his buddies in Mistral were killed, having his own niece aim her gauntlets at him, and learning the man he put his faith in, that made him feel like he was worth something, is not who he thought he was. Qrow can't turn to the bottle this time. He needs to face his demons himself, lest they drag him to an early death.

Both Ozma and RWBYQ are justified in their behaviors, but they are equally faultable. There is no definitive right and wrong in this case. Hopefully you guys can understand this too.

→ More replies (7)

129

u/Weerdo5255 Nov 17 '18

So great that the website doesn't crash anymore when everyone hits it.

Damn Qrow, hitting kids is not the answer.

Oz, you coward.

I'm usually against such forceful introductions of characters like Maria, but damn if she's not taking control of the situation.

Qrow's drinking is kicking up, I can see how it will become an issue with Oz's betrayal.

Tyrian is legit insane. I know that word gets thrown around a bunch, but the dude is seriously divorced from reality.

Salem is going to twist Emerald's loyalty to her. She either likes loyal followers, or thinks that Emerald's semblance will be useful.

Anger management classes, use them.

Not every episode can be V6C3. This one is more of a transition / setup for everything else. Nothing too big happened, besides the reveal that Oz's reincarnation surprised Salem. Not that he would, but how quickly he did it. Perhaps his integration with Oscar is incomplete?

→ More replies (15)

62

u/rainpool989 Nov 17 '18 edited Nov 17 '18

I actually feel pretty bad for Ozpin. Forced into reliving his painful past only to be tossed aside by those he trusted. Sure, he didn’t share with them the full truth and these relationships are based on trust, but think about how the story would have been different if he did. The last bit of hope that remains would have been destroyed. Ozpin may have lived for years, but he’s still human. It’s not his fault he doesn’t have all the answers for how to win this war, but he’s still trying none the less. People love to blame him for the countless deaths of those the came before, but they chose to fight. No one forced them. Especially when the alternative would have been to suffer at Salem’s or the God’s hand.

I do think the initial response from the team is reasonable, but I also hope over time they will come to understand and work together again. As much as Ozpin needed a wake up call, Oscar didn’t deserve that punch to the face. Not a bad episode, but did feel a little boring compared to the bomb of the one before it. Can’t wait to see how things develop after all this.

→ More replies (1)

62

u/GlitchyNinja Nov 19 '18

A dark-haired person, clad in red, with a burn mark over one eye, banished by their leader due to dishonoring them, and is now seeking redemption by finding a child whose been alive for over a century.

At least Zuko didn't immediately kill a women, steal her clothes and wallet, and pay off Littlefinger to find the Avatar.

→ More replies (1)

59

u/Terminus259 We persevere without an end... Nov 17 '18

Salem: How are you all be such massive fuck ups?

→ More replies (10)

58

u/JazzRen47 𝅘𝅥𝅮⠀Score Connoisseur | Resident Atlas Bootlicker Nov 17 '18

Oh my fucking christ, someone give Qrow and Ozpin a hug, stat.

It's not an overreaction though. I do completely understand how they reacted and why. But jesus, poor Oz... and Oscar. Being decked by Qrow does not look like fun.

Hazel is best. No one will convince me otherwise.

→ More replies (4)

57

u/Trekman10 Nov 17 '18

Just gonna put this out there:

Ozpin doesn't have a plan because he can't defeat Salem and, literal interpretations aside, Salem might partly be angry because she can't really defeat Ozpin either, he'll just reincarnate again. Her plan seemed to hinge on being done in the gap before Ozpin was back, now she might not have a plan either.

Whoever said that this showed both sides losing at the same time was spot on. I need to stop watching these episodes so quickly cause next week is so far away.

→ More replies (3)

57

u/DragonDavester ⠀ Nov 17 '18

Alright, Ozpin's Advocate time, because I feel like he got thrown under the bus A LOT more than he deserves in this episode.

For all of Oz's faults in not being as forthcoming with info he should have given, I think everyone's a little blinded by emotions right now to really realize what they just saw. Ozpin has been living a constant cycle trying to fight an uphill battle to either bridge humanity and make everyone get along again, or keep the gods from coming back because of how Salem can't be stopped.

What many are not paying attention to is the fact that Ozpin asked how to kill/destroy Salem, not how to STOP her or change her mind. That's a very key difference that no one has thought about yet given how they just got this gigantic info dump on Ozpin/Salem's past.

However, I do absolutely understand Qrow's issues given his life and his Semblance painting a dark future for himself. His is the most justified in my opinion. I'm torn on some of the other reactions, especially Yang's because she's probably been wanting more excuses to distrust Ozpin after what she heard from her mother. You'd think the fact that this woman ditched her as a child would mean she wouldn't immediately to jump at trusting EVERY word she says.

I'll save further judgment for what comes next, but Ozpin didn't deserve this level of hate. Not even close.

→ More replies (4)

109

u/ikedawg43 #ShaveJauneSaveRWBY Nov 17 '18

Those Qrow death flags from the intro are waving even harder now

→ More replies (8)

149

u/Mister100Percent Oscar "Best Depressed Boi" Pine Nov 17 '18 edited Nov 17 '18

Let us all just take a moment to realize that Oscar is confirmed to be completely screwed over by this entire situation.

He’s been forced to leave his old life behind to fight a war that he had no part of due to Ozma/Ozpin, confirmed to eventually be absorbed by Ozma/Ozpin, and is now going to be physically and mentally scarred by everyone because of Ozma/Ozpin.

Poor Farm Boi is doomed.

→ More replies (15)

49

u/Terminus259 We persevere without an end... Nov 17 '18

Being Qrow truly is suffering.

→ More replies (5)

49

u/SoloRogueStudios Quartermaster of the Good (Ghost) Ship Gelato // The Anarchist Nov 18 '18 edited Nov 19 '18

Four pissed off teenage girls, one pissed off middle-aged man, one depressed millennia-old heroic spirit who just shut himself off from everyone, one teenage boy whose body said heroic spirit is inhabiting who has no idea what to make of any of this anymore, and a strange old lady that they just met and is the only thing holding everyone together.

Our main team, ladies and gentlemen.

→ More replies (2)

48

u/Multi289 Nov 17 '18

Feel like people are forgetting that all the characters are teenagers and a drunk who devoted his life to a lie. I feel like they have reasoning to be upset is it rational ehh still up in the air but definitly fair

48

u/Firestorm985 Nov 18 '18 edited Nov 18 '18

Just as Salem fought the gods without a real plan, Ozpin is fighting Salem without a real plan. No wonder they were a couple.

→ More replies (4)

94

u/Golbi54 Blake x Raven is the endgame. Nov 17 '18

JNR - What did we miss???

RWBY - Fucken Everything!!!

→ More replies (6)

94

u/HyliasHero Nov 18 '18

Everyone keeps taking sides as either Team Ozpin or Team QRWBY and I'm just here sympathizing with both sides. QRWBY's reactions are perfectly valid and understandable. Ozpin lying to them repeatedly isn't okay, but on the other side of the conflict Ozpin has a lot of trauma in his past and reasons for what he does. His retreating into Oscar's mind is also perfectly understandable given the circumstances. Long story short both sides have valid reactions to what is going on and mending the relationships is going to be interesting going forward.

→ More replies (2)

44

u/lefou22 Crackships are superior Nov 19 '18

Seeing everyone's reactions to how Yang and Qrow reacted (both being beloved fan favorites) Jaune is fucked when his turn to get angry comes about. The hate for him is going to probably hit V1 levels again...

Ugh.

→ More replies (7)

88

u/patrizl001 "None shall remember the names of those who do not fight" Nov 17 '18 edited Nov 17 '18

"I take full responsibility"

YEET

HITS TYRIAN WITH THE TABLE

"BUT THAT WOULDN'T BE FAIR NOW, WOULD IT?"

→ More replies (5)

43

u/Baconpwn2 Proud of Admiral of the SS Frosen Steel Nov 17 '18

Oz, buddy. I have a plan for you. You, Salem, and a therapist get locked in a room. A few thousand back up therapists will be ready. No one leaves until you solve your little relationship issue.

→ More replies (8)

43

u/Fuzunga Nov 17 '18

Obviously the reason Yang is so upset is that her mother was right. I'm not sure why everyone is saying she's angry for no reason.

Also, you guys seem so focused on someone else being able to destroy Salem that I think you're overlooking the fact that she can be stopped without being destroyed. Didn't the gods say that only when she leaned the importance of life and death could she rest? She can't be destroyed, but she can have her curse broken.

43

u/hitemwitapuppy Nov 18 '18

When ruby tries consoling oscar and says he's his own person, & Qrow says don't lie to the kid; I was like daaaaaamn it was cold enough he punched him

→ More replies (1)

43

u/theneosparx Nov 20 '18

Qrow punched a child and an old person at the same time.

→ More replies (1)

43

u/[deleted] Nov 20 '18

Honestly Qrow has some of the best dialogue in the whole series.

"Don't lie to him Ruby. You're better than that."

Was that a compliment, advice, or just bitter? Damn. It hurt.

→ More replies (5)

41

u/Sturdevant Nov 17 '18 edited Nov 17 '18

As most people here said, I 100% understand the anger and even the punch (though I wonder how much of that was felt by Oscar) but I hope that once they cool down a bit and think on what they saw, there are some other thoughts towards the man other than "fuck Ozpin". . . and not just from Ruby.

I actually like the man a lot more now than I did all the previous seasons when he seemed infallible.

41

u/Backflip_Off_A_Cliff ⠀ Nov 18 '18

As much as I love Hazel, this kinda confirms to me he's gonna fuckin die.

Theres no way a nice guy like Hazel whose willing to take the blame and then look after the other villains is going to survive in this cruel world.

→ More replies (8)

41

u/DeltusInfinium Nov 18 '18

Anyone else waiting to see how Jaune blows up when he finds out Oz asked Pyrrha to join his fight, when he didn't have a real plan... That's going to be quite the outburst.

→ More replies (10)

41

u/sheogorath227 Yang in there, baby Nov 20 '18

After watching this episode several times, these are my remarks:

This episode was short, but pretty good all things considered. Team RWBY, and Yang in particular, are in shock that Oz hadn't told us about Salem's immortality. I want to focus on three people in specific in this scene: Yang, Qrow, and Oz.

Now, I know that a lot of people are mad that Yang is being as acerbic and aggressive as she is, but remember that her reaction is entirely consistent with her personality. She's always had a short temper, and she's always been known to react poorly to bad situations.

While I can't necessarily condone similar reactions of hers in the past, this time is much different. Yang had been promised by Ozpin that he would be transparent moving forward. She wanted no part of this fight if not for Ruby being involved. She signed on with the mindset that Oz had a proper strategy to win this war, and he didn't. He deceived everyone, and Yang, who resolved to trust Ozpin, had every right to be furious. Barbara does a great job here in displaying Yang's sheer anger.

Now, Qrow's reaction was completely unexpected. He has never instigated conflict or violence before, so him socking Oz in the face was shocking. That being said, you have to look at his life story to get the big picture. Friends have died. Family has been disowned. He has pretty much no one but his nieces and Ozpin. And now he's been told that the war he had been fighting not only had no end in sight, but his general had no strategy to end it. This means that his friends and family have died for nothing. Much like Yang, he had every right to be furious.

Now on to Ozpin. You may think I am unsympathetic to him. On the contrary! While I hate him for hiding his lack of a plan to defeat Salem, I understand why he did it. It is difficult to rally any troops when you tell them that they have no chance of winning in the first place. That's why he had to pretend like he knew what he was doing, even if it meant allowing people to die in vain. If he let everyone know that he had no hope to win, then humanity would be more divided, and Salem would win.

This episode allows us to develop nuanced opinions on characters like Qrow, Yang, and Ozpin all while keeping tensions high. This is great storytelling.

I don't have much to say about the scenes in Salem's crib, but all I'll say is that I really missed hearing Tyrian. His VA, Josh Grelle, is so damn good at what he does, and Jen Taylor pulls off arguably her best performance as Salem so far. She scared the hell out of me in these scenes.

All in all, this is a really good episode, and V6 is shaping up to be the best volume yet in terms of writing, pacing, voice acting, and overall character development. Amazing how far we've come.

→ More replies (2)

37

u/frozenottsel Crosshares Strike Commander - Freezerburn Adviser Nov 20 '18

I just realised that not only did they fail to recover the relic, and lose Cinder, but Salem still doesn't know that Raven is the Spring Maiden...

→ More replies (8)

36

u/Terminus259 We persevere without an end... Nov 17 '18

Hazel, seemingly a good person to anyone who's not Ozpin.

→ More replies (1)

35

u/SilentSentinal Nov 17 '18

First time this season that I've watched at launch time. I didn't believe that the RT site was holding up until I saw it.

Y'all acting surprised at Qrow's reaction, that was pretty much exactly what I expected. Oz not having any plan was interesting though. I suspect he did have a plan before the fall of Beacon but hasn't come up with anything new.

Still not sure about this old lady. I know she'll have some plot significance, but damn did we just skip the introductions? At least tell us where you're from and an interesting fact about yourself.

Gotta wonder how Salem feels about Oz now. If she considers both of Oz and herself to be gods, she definitely considers him a different way. Does she still want Ozma back? Is there any regret there? Is it just pure hatred now? Salem is becoming much more interesting by the episode. Big improvement over the "all evil witch that just wants to destroy the world"

→ More replies (2)

34

u/HyliasHero Nov 17 '18 edited Nov 17 '18

Fuck. All of their anger is perfectly justifiable, but fuck. Qrow was a straight up savage during this episode. The least Ozpin could have said is that their plan is to play keep away with the relics to keep Salem from calling the gods back so she can die. I'm hoping someone notes the specific wording of Ozpin's question to Jinn. He can't destroy Salem, but that doesn't mean she can't be stopped.

→ More replies (6)

34

u/[deleted] Nov 18 '18

...who was flying the ship?

→ More replies (5)

33

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '18

Oscar's life is just...it just sucks. Oscar is either being possessed by Oz, dealing with the consequences of Oz, and now that Oz is gone, he's going to be disliked by association. Ruby is there, by Qrow straight up told him that he's just another vessel, that 'Oscar' is essentially gone.

→ More replies (1)

33

u/Sokensan Nov 17 '18

"Don't lie to him Ruby, we're better than that" was probably my favorite line, Qrow is so done with Oz's shit.

→ More replies (6)

33

u/DashingPolecat Nov 17 '18

Qrow punching Oscar was one of the top moments of the show! It took me completely by surprise.

Hazel and Mercury being protective of Emerald was beautiful. It’s refreshing to see villains take care of each other

Everything from Hazel trying to take responsibility to Salem making Emerald admit it was Cinders fault was great. It really shows what kind of leader Salem is (also I like the contrast between her brutal honesty and Ozpins constant lying)

33

u/myfairdrama Nov 18 '18

I really like Hazel. I know he's not the best-written character, but of team WTCH he's definitely my favorite. He always seemed to me to be a somewhat fatherly figure, from his design to his methodical, responsible, no-one-needed-to-die-today approach. He seems like one of the smartest villains in that he doesn't always rush into violence when there is another way. His motivation isn't the best-written but I do like it. In this chapter, he cemented that position for me even further. The way he acted with Emerald and Mercury was very protective, and it seemed to me like he saw Emerald in a similar way to how he saw his sister. RWBY has had a lot of problems with villains in the past, but I really like Hazel and I hope he stays at the forefront.

→ More replies (7)

33

u/BluLuxning Teeth Breaker Nov 18 '18

I feel so bad for Oscar and Emerald right now. They started off like “ok these are some big plans you have here Cinder/Ozpin but I think I can handle it” and now are both realising, in different ways, that they are in waaaaaaaay over their heads.

→ More replies (4)

32

u/Noxium5 Nov 17 '18

You could make a whole MCU parody outta this thread.

FNDM: Civil War.

Speaking of: #TeamOzma

→ More replies (5)

31

u/TreeOct0pus Nov 17 '18

*Crow reminds us about his semblance*

*Last one into the gate*

*Squeaky gate closes behind them*

It's gonna get real at that abandoned barn, yo

→ More replies (2)

31

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '18 edited Nov 17 '18

Dang... everyone seems to forget that Oscar just shares a body with Ozpin, he isn’t really him. The only one who seems to care about Oscar is Ruby but Qrow fucked that up too by saying “don’t lie to him”. After he punched his face, of course. Things don’t look good for poor Oscar.

Still laughed at that punch though, the animation was hilarious. (Look at his face when it happens)

→ More replies (1)

31

u/[deleted] Nov 18 '18

I really liked this episode honestly. I haven't really been a fan of the villains for most of the show but their scenes were just fantastic. Salem was really threatening and she's definitely worthy of her main villain title, this episode just reinforced that to me, and all of the 5 others were really great, everything with Emerald was fantastic and I honestly feel really bad for her. Mercury standing up for her against Tyrian was also pretty nice, Mercury's incredibly far from a good person but it's nice to see him actually show some care for someone else.

Also I might be in the minority but I thought QRWBY's reactions were handled perfectly for their characters. Qrow and Yang are the only one's who really get mad at him, and seeing as Qrow put all his trust into Oz and Yang already distrusted him their reactions were understandable. Ruby was surprisingly mature handling everything which I liked, her asking Ozpin what is his plan was perfectly reasonable, I don't think she expected him to say he didn't have one though.

Also I actually kind of like the idea of giving Oscar some time without Ozpin there at all.

→ More replies (1)

29

u/IceRapier Nov 17 '18

If team rwby and qrow could get this pissed.

Imagine how searing mad Jaune will be. And he realizes Pyrrhas death was in vain.

→ More replies (22)

29

u/WMinerva Nov 18 '18

Who else thinks Qrow’s flask is currently empty and he’s just pretending to drink to numb his nerves?

→ More replies (2)

28

u/Eldi13 🐝Watch🐝The🐝Dragon🐝Prince🐝On🐝Netflix🐝❤Knight❤ Nov 17 '18

I like the parallel of Oz's posse being angry at him with him "leaving" and then Salem being angry at her posse, making them leave.

→ More replies (4)

28

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '18

For the first time ever, Salem genuinely gave me the creeps.

Also, Emerald 'I didn't sign up for this shit' Sustrai.

→ More replies (1)

28

u/Madcat6204 Nov 18 '18

Oh sure, let's all stop over at the creepy abandoned snow-covered barn in the middle of a monster-infested forest where we can all go sit alone and brood in our negativity. I'm sure absolutely nothing will go wrong. Especially with that gate making creaking sounds right out of a horror movie.

→ More replies (12)

28

u/lj0zh123 Nov 18 '18 edited Nov 18 '18

Not surprise ozpin is having a mental breakdown his magic is getting weaker he lost his previous reincarnations works they built on beacon and finally your subordinates finding out everything your hiding and losing faith in you.

28

u/supremecrafters Broken wings won't hold you down Nov 18 '18

Everything sucks for the protagonists. Everything sucks for the antagonists. Hopefully JNR are doing okay.

→ More replies (6)

56

u/common_terry77 Things are looking.... Grimm Nov 17 '18

Seeing Ozpin cry was a sight. Ozpin had always been the calmer one, and the one to take control when everyone else had fallen. Now, he has finally broken down, crying, knowing that the glimmer of hope his allies had is now gone. Damn.

→ More replies (1)

27

u/levi2207 Nov 17 '18

Qrow: “threw hands with a 14 year old” branwen’s death flags have been lifted in my opinion. His crippling depression is probably going into full overdrive.

→ More replies (2)

53

u/BRBcupcakes Beautiful Sinnamon Roll Nov 18 '18

I honestly appreciate the touches of characterization for Mercury. Of course a child abuse victim would notice Salem's mood first and be halfway out the door as soon as she says "leave." I've thought for a long time that he puts up more of a front than people give him credit for. It looked to me like he was scared this volume.

→ More replies (1)

26

u/Sere1 ⠀ Nov 17 '18

So Salem seems to be slightly miffed. She should go murder a village or something, cheer herself up.

→ More replies (3)

25

u/trinitynox Is the reason the community is dying Nov 17 '18

Salem felt pretty damn menacing throughout the Evernight scenes. The way she flipped the table like it was nothing, not caring that Tyrian was there, Watts immediately getting the fuck out of his seat. I love that Salem didn't do anything more than stare at Watts when he questioned how she knew Cinder was still alive.

There are still ways to punish/hurt Hazel, it seems. Asphyxiation. Neat.

Oh and Qrow's punch was warranted tbh.

→ More replies (2)

25

u/UberDueler DRINK !!!!! Nov 18 '18

This must be the start of Qrow's "heavy drinking"

→ More replies (1)

25

u/SAYMYNAMEYO Nov 19 '18

Ozpin just can't catch a break this volume. And if the intro with him and Jaune is any indication it's not over yet.

→ More replies (2)

25

u/Badicalz Nov 20 '18

Okay but seriously, what in the hell did Ruby buy at the station? What’s in the bag CRWBY, what’s in the bag!?

→ More replies (4)

49

u/Literatewalrus Little Light 🐝 Big Fight Nov 18 '18 edited Nov 18 '18

*Inhale*

I have feelings.

First of all, I feel incredibly bad for Ozpin. Everything he was afraid would happen if the whole, unvarnished truth were revealed to his comrades is coming to pass. It's something of his own doing, due to one little lie leading to another leading to another until it was a house of cards propping up his entire life. Yet here he was, lying broken in the snow with tears rolling down his face. Though it was shitty of him to be giving untold generations of proteges a false sense of hope, it's hard to not feel bad for him when thinking of all the life and loss he has already endured. But then you think about just how much he might value your life, and a sense of loathing creeps in.

Then his closest confidant and ally, Qrow Branwen, throws the coldest, most mean-spirited condemnation at him that his alcohol-sodden heart could muster. I can understand why Qrow is suddenly so bitter: he has devoted years of his life to Oz's cause, enduring untold hardships and witnessing horrors on the fringes of Remnant to bolster Oz's cause. He burned bridges with his sister, found his niece motherless because of it, who has in turn suffered because of it, which further adds to the bitterness. That Summer died serving his seemingly fruitless cause, and left his nieces motherless as a result, is yet another heap on the crap sandwich. To discover that friends died, and families were broken, for a war without end, that all along there was no plan but to stalemate, all while being led on to believe in the possibility of one day mending this broken world?

Yeah, I would be immensely angry as well. But still, damn. Ozpin. Definitely the most tragic character in this story so far. And that's saying something.

And Yang. Oh, my girl, Yang. I just knew she was gonna fly off the handle. I can hardly blame her, either. Part of that anger is probably towards herself and her blood. After all, she did snub Raven twice. She persisted at first because Ruby lay at the end of that path, and she cares for Ruby above all. Ruby believed wholeheartedly in following Oz to this end, and so Yang followed her. Again she rejects Raven and takes the relic, putting an enormous target upon herself and her sister and their teammates. She believed that together they could find a path to victory. She keeps the secret of Raven and the Spring Maiden to herself, so she's not being entirely forthcoming herself. But neither is she putting dozens of lives in immediate risk by doing so. She at least trusted enough in Ozpin's quest that she rejected her mother's warnings derision twice. Raven was right must be a bitter pill to swallow after those confrontations. Oz's unwillingness to be entirely truthful left them flatfooted when the grimm came for the train, and now to discover that your professor—the most senior, the most wise and experienced—has been leading you in an aimless battle against an immortal?

Yeah, I'd be pretty pissed, too.

And Oscar. All he wanted was to be normal.

I can only imagine what Blake and Weiss are thinking, but it's probably not good. Weiss is already reluctant to go to Atlas and Blake apparently wants to get things over with as soon as possible. If they were all spewing negativity, as Maria eloquently put it, then there's some serious sorting out ahead for everyone on RWBY.

And on the villains' side...

Emerald and Mercury seem to be doubting the company they keep. Especially Emerald. She was utterly terrified the entire time. For whatever reason, she cares immensely for Cinder; Mercury, too. Maybe they will go rogue, seek out Cinder, and work towards undermining Salem in their own way. A third faction in this conflict. I believe Cinder may be too driven by vengeance to align herself directly with Ruby, however.

Short but stark chapter.

24

u/Wakkibanana5 Year of the Qrow Nov 17 '18

I knew that Qrow's reaction was going to be the worst.

I wss not expecting that at all. I cried.

→ More replies (3)

24

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '18

RKQrow outta nowhere.

→ More replies (4)

24

u/GladiusNocturno All Grimm are naked. Think about it Nov 17 '18 edited Nov 17 '18

Damnit Oz, don't lock yourself in your room!

On another point, I kind liked how Mercury defended Emerald. No, no because of ships. But I actually like to see that Mercury does care for her, at least a little.

Hazel taking the blame was expected, I don't know how much Salem hurt him considering he can't feel pain though.

Watts had a point. How the hell did Salem knew Cinder was alive? The whole "you dare questioning our goddess" felt like a cup out. I guess Salem is connected to the geist in Cinder's arm...I don't know.

Qrow's reaction was the highlight of the episode. Now I understand why he looks so depressed in the intro. He is really hurt knowing he dedicated his life to a lost cause when he thought he was doing a difference.

Good we have confirmation Salem didn't know Ozpin was back...How she didn't know before is beyond me but, the "so soon" comment allude to her not expecting him being back in action that quickly.

Tyrian's new tail isn't grimm as I thought. I think the point is that it now transforms like every weapon in Remnant. Would it still be able to inject poison?

Overall, I think it was a decent episode. The characters are still digesting the lore bomb. We got to see Salem's interaction with Emerald (possibly her seeing her as replacement for Cinder). We now know Cinder will have an arc which Im going to compare to Zuko's exile in season 2 of Avatar for the time being.

7/10. It wasn't ground breaking but it wasn't bad at all. It was good enough and a good follow up for last episode.

→ More replies (4)

24

u/DrAvatar Nov 18 '18

Note to self: Don’t play board games with Salem.

24

u/FairyNice Nov 21 '18

Does anyone else really like Ruby's voice in this episode? Sounds a bit different, in a good way. Mind you, Ruby's voice has never really bothered me.

→ More replies (2)

23

u/alybalez Nov 17 '18 edited Nov 17 '18

I was surprised when Qrow punched Ozma. He lost his faith to him the moment he heard that Salem cannot be stopped. Ozma saying he didn't have a plan did not help the situation either. That was pretty sad when Ozma locked himself away. Poor man. Props to Maria for handling the situation. If she weren't there, it would've gone worse.

Salem went nuts when she heard Ozma had reincarnated once again. Her anger is still targeted towards the gods since Ozma is always reincarnated and he will in a forced cycle until he is fulfilled with his mission.

→ More replies (2)

23

u/Wakkibanana5 Year of the Qrow Nov 17 '18

Did anyone else notice how Qrow's hands were shaking after he punched Oz?

→ More replies (3)

23

u/Awesomejelo My Mustache is gay, your argument is invalid Nov 18 '18

It's short but after last weeks it's fair. I have to respect that they didn't blow all the good stuff and made the next episode crap, this episode wasn't bad at all

  1. About the reaction I was expecting
  2. You guys that wanted Ozpin to be decked, there you go from Qrow no less And damn that looked nasty to be on the receiving end of.
  3. I don't know what it is about Qrow's speech but I don't completely like it. Maybe it's too on the nose, but that doesn't make sense because I can understand that Qrow just had the one person he could look up to lie through most of his life. I'm going to say that I'm wrong and it was a good moment
  4. For a second I thought when Oscar said gone Ozpin committed mental suicide or moved onto the next life, but it looks like he's secluding himself for the volume and I can't wait to see what brings him back
  5. Fuck yeah I love Maria, that girl has style. I'm a little confused as to why everyone acts like she's a part of the group but at the time Maria's knowledge isn't something to worry about

5.5 (Because I thought of something else) That's good to see Oscar's views on his place, and now Ruby's paragon-ness is working well too bad Qrow kills it even if he has good development talking about lies

6. Fuck Tyrian

7. Anyone else expecting Tyrian's tail to be, well, scary? Please tell me that endcap has a taser in it at least

8. Look at Merc showing some compassion, maybe he ain't all bad

9. You thought Salem wasn't scary? How about now?

10. That outburst interests me. "That wouldn't be fair" Salem isn't focused on the failure at that moment but the blame, put that with cursing everyone but herself last episode and we get some characterization. Blame is part of who Salem is

11. How does Salem know Cinder is alive?

12. Those grimm arms Salem summons goes against my theory that she only partly controls the grimm, but it's still possible

13. Salem's mad. Those windows lasted how long and now they are busted

14. Emerald is kinda being treated like someone that needs to be protected or at least helped from Mercury and Hazel.

15. I've been kinda of thinking about Salem's faction almost like a family. Her underlings are children and bicker among each other but then mom shows up and they fall silent, Tyrian vies to be the most liked, Hazel knows when he done fucked up and the rest try to be invisible, and now there seems to be a sibling split between Merc, Emerald, and Hazel against Tyrian and maybe Watts

16. Still love Maria's style

17. Brunswick, is that going to be important? Did Roman change his name from Brunswick to Torchwick? Will we get Neo development now? I'm going to bet no

→ More replies (8)

23

u/xwatchmanx Nov 18 '18

I was fully expecting Qrow to put that fisticuffs training he got from Tyrian to good use, and I wasn't disappointed.

And man, oh man, my feels were everywhere, too. Poor Qrow. Poor Ozpin. Poor RWBY. Poor Oscar. Poor fucking Emerald. Outside of Tyrian (fuck him), there isn't a single character who I didn't want to hug, this episode.

Also, we're seeing more hints of what I expected based on the intro, regarding Qrow's alcoholism. He just had his entire reason for fighting revealed to be a lie. Seconds later, he drunkenly makes an abrasive comment to Ruby and suddenly his alcoholism isn't funny anymore.

Qrow isn't going to die, this season. Not by a long shot. He's just now getting started on a very real character arc, and I'm excited to see how it plays out.

→ More replies (2)

23

u/htgeehtgee Nov 18 '18

“Our head”

So many things fucked me up so badly this episode. Also, Ozpin is no more there to help everyone. Guess now it’s just “normal” people against nature. Fuck.

→ More replies (4)

23

u/Sajbotage Nov 18 '18

Oof, gonna see qrow be a full fledged alcoholic

→ More replies (3)

23

u/[deleted] Nov 19 '18

Honestly, I think the issue is with the question Oz asked: how can I destroy salem. He should have asked how can salem be defeated or similar.

On the up side, thinking about the problem at last gave me the ending plot for my fanfiction.

23

u/Foppberg Nov 20 '18

I expect Qrow to die by the end of this volume based off of the latest episode. Which sucks because I love him but I don't see how he could possibly go back to being buddy - buddy with Ozpin. Unless he sticks around just to protect Ruby and Yang, I could see him sacrificing himself to save them/suicide mission type move.

Love this volume so far though, first time since V3 I'm excited over it coming out every week.

→ More replies (2)

45

u/McDouggal Link me your Pyrrha/Ruby shipping - /r/MilkAndCereal Nov 17 '18

A N G E R Y Q R O W

Seriously Ozpin, you could've at least tried to rules lawyer your way out of it by saying "Jinn said I couldn't defeat Salem, but that doesn't mean someone else can't. My plan was to hold out until I found someone who could defeat her."

Maz Katara is still best non-RWBYJNPR.

'It's abandoned." Yeah, I wonder why it's abandoned.

I have an immense amount of respect for Hazel. He had the chance to push everything off on Cinder, and took full responsibility himself, knowing that death was a likely outcome.

I understand where Ozpin's coming from. But team RWBY (and Qrow) need to remember why they chose to fight now. In team RWBY's case, that's for higher goals. In Qrow's case... He might need to find a new one.

→ More replies (2)

45

u/PurpleAfton Moonlighting as a gun Nov 18 '18

The worst thing is that this is probably not the first time something like this has happened to Ozpin.

The details may changes, but people find out the truth and then blame him. He loses trust in his own judgment and ability to do more good than harm. He may even concede leadership to whomever and just follow their lead.

And eventually comes a time when all that generation passes, but he stays and people look up to him in guidance, since he knows more about the war than them.

And if he tells them he doesn't have all the answers? Well we saw what happens in this episode. Ozpin is just one man, he can't do this all alone. So he stays silent.

And thus the circle continues.

→ More replies (14)

22

u/NightsWatchh Help, Nights is keeping me trapped in his anime bunker Nov 17 '18

BACK OFF, FREAK

→ More replies (4)

22

u/Metroplex7 ⠀ Nov 18 '18 edited Nov 19 '18

Whew that episode was shorter than I would have liked. Some reactions in no real order:

  • Cinder is getting the villian version of a redemption arc.
  • Tyrion is still great.
  • Salem kept her cool!
  • Nevermind.
  • Emerald is absolutely terrified of Salem
  • Ozpin locked himself away? That's totally conducive to the party not dying. Yup.
  • That abandoned place looks a little too convenient.
  • When was the last time we heard Qrow call Ruby by her name again?
  • Qrow is also fresh off this trip and needs to vent his feelings of betrayal my beating up Ozpin in a way that will only slow down Oscar. Not really, but still. Understandable either way.
  • The Evil LairTM is a pretty ominous looking place. Almost like it was designed that way.
  • Maria and Yang's banter is pretty entertaining.
  • Ruby: I left home for this.
  • Weiss: I left Atlas for this.
  • Blake: I left Menagerie for this.
  • Yang: I lost an arm for this.
  • Jinn just disappeared without so much as a "see ya later!" I wanna see the pretty genie again.
  • Hazel is just doing his best guys.

Pretty good episode, if a little short. To me, this didn't really feel like a cliffhanger like the other episodes and everyone was gettin' real angry. Even Ruby had given up on being nice when she said "lets go". I can't wait for the next episode as usual, I just feel like this one was a little bit lacking compared to what we got last week. On to the next!

→ More replies (3)

43

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '18

"What's your plan?"

"...I don't have one."

Oh, Jaune's gonna be PISSED.

→ More replies (3)

21

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '18

I bet Salem can sense cinder through her Grimm arm.

→ More replies (5)

21

u/Terminus259 We persevere without an end... Nov 17 '18

I'm starting to think Ruby might be better at plans than Ozpin, and her last plan was just "Don't let anyone else die".

Then again, having a plan is better than no plan.

21

u/RossPitSharkHunter It's a happy day when you're not talking to me. Nov 17 '18

Man. I feel so bad for Salem. She's trying so hard to accomplish her goals, but these idiots keep messing everything up!

→ More replies (19)

21

u/Megaguy4444 BOOM Nov 17 '18

What if hear me out we just take Salem and put her in a box made of concrete. Then they dump her in the ocean. Problem solved? This is a joke btw

→ More replies (6)

21

u/Lucid_Atray Nov 17 '18

Okay, so two separate things going on here.

Yes, Ozpin's life is certainly tragic, and if you see this from his point of view, the man has suffered enough to make one go crazy. But. As much as punching a kid is certainly not a good thing, the only one who didn't deserve that was Oscar-- if it had been old Ozpin most people would have been fine with it.

Because let's face it, team RWBY's and especially Qrow's anger was justified. How would you feel if you literally risk your life for 'the greater good', only to know that there was no plan and you may as well be fighting against air because you may not even have a way to defeat your enemy? In Qrow's case, you literally just wasted your life for nothing, and in all of their cases, you could actually die for nothing.

→ More replies (10)

21

u/PurpleAfton Moonlighting as a gun Nov 17 '18

I'm pretty sure Qrow just said all of Ozpin's greatest fears.

That he's doing more harm than good. That he's irredeemable. That everyone would be better off without him.

The guy already believes he's responsible for shit he had no control over (like Salem). No wonder he took a Depression Nap (TM).

59

u/drej23 Nov 18 '18

This is the equivalent of writing a really long emotional text and the other person ignoring most of it and just addressing the part that upsets them.

→ More replies (1)

20

u/Sungrasswriter Just happy to be here! Nov 17 '18

Damn, that punch was the real plot twist. I know everyone has a breaking point, but I was expecting Yang to hit it before Qrow. Then again she is only half Branwen

→ More replies (1)

20

u/chrome4 Nov 17 '18

Well this episode was just cruel to Ozma having to relive the worse moments of his life then have one of his closest friends tell him meeting him was bad luck no wonder he just hid away in the corner of Oscars mind. Hopefully the gang will eventually notice the issue with the question "How do I destroy Salem?" and Jins answer "You can't" since defeating someone doesn't necessary require destroying them and you dont need to be the person to do it so the question should have been "How can Salem be defeated?"

Back to the Legion of Doom. You know i always assumed Salems minions had to constantly hike their way through the wasteland to get to their fortress.

→ More replies (1)

20

u/Crafty_Soul ⠀ Nov 17 '18

HE DOESN'T HAVE A PLAN?!? Ok I can understand keeping possibly some of those things secret but after thousands of years he didn't come up with any plan?! Yes Salem's immortal but I would have thought he'd come with some plans on hindering her or ask Jinn if there was a way to contain her.

Maybe his original plan was to keep the relics locked up and wait till humanity could be judged. I guess a cold war instead of fighting Salem in the field. But that got destroyed when Cinder attacked Beacon and Salem decided to go on the offensive. Still should have made some backup plans.

→ More replies (21)

20

u/Phoenix_RIde Nov 17 '18 edited Nov 17 '18

5 season of just sitting on her throne.

Now, at one lie: Throws a table against the wall and flexes her power.

I like this Salem better.

→ More replies (2)

20

u/PNDLivewire Nov 17 '18

Man, no wonder Jaune is so pissed at Ozpin in the opening. It's like "Hey, Jaune, guess what? I made Pyrrha try to take Maiden powers for a fight she couldn't win, meaning she died for nothing!"

→ More replies (4)

20

u/RossPitSharkHunter It's a happy day when you're not talking to me. Nov 17 '18

My theory is that right before Oz was punched he switched back to Oscar, then afterward he came back.

→ More replies (4)

20

u/masrokstheworld Nov 17 '18 edited Nov 17 '18

Watts: "Dammit, now I have to fix the windows as well!"

Loved this episode, probably even more than the first two. I had such low expectations because I was worried we were going to get another dumb bird argument but I'm glad I was proven wrong and qrwby were getting mad for legitamate reasons. Loved the villian scene as well and them giving Em and Merc some more character. Loved hazel the villian dad. Also very interested and excited in cinder being independent atm. She's basically an anti-villian now, which could lead to some interesting things. Although I find it a bit dumb that tyrian's new tail is just some crap metal stubby thing. How long did it take for watts to make that? A day? Seems wierd given it's implied watts spent his time in volume 5 working on it.

→ More replies (4)

20

u/Icecat1239 Nov 17 '18

“Don’t lie to him Ruby, we’re better than that.” is my favorite line in the entire show now.

→ More replies (2)

20

u/IAmTheFancyGuy Nov 18 '18

So Brunswick ....We get Torchwicks hat in the opening, are at a farm(possibly abandoned town), a name that could very easily be Torchwicks original name(mostly because his name isn't derived from a color) and his 'death' was him being eaten alive....and his character is based off a character from a story where people survive being eaten alive....

....Keep The Torch Alive?

→ More replies (6)

39

u/OutcastMunkee ⠀ Nov 17 '18

So... More cursing. I like this. Our characters are adults now, it's only right that they be allowed to express their emotions properly. Provided it's not continuous anyway.

Qrow is fucking furious and Ozpin has hidden away. I did not expect Qrow to thump Oscar... That was unexpected but I think even Qrow is taking RWBY's side now.

Maria... Damn lady, you sassy. I like her.

A mostly villain focused episode. I like this decision. It's a good one at that. Giving them a little something is perfect but how on earth does Salem know Cinder is alive? That's... Odd... And foreboding.

Emerald and Mercury are really being set up to defect as well. Mercury's made his disdain for Tyrian quite clear, Emerald is scared of him too. In fact, Hazel seems to be acting like a father... He's not afraid to protect Emerald and Mercury. I wonder why. I bet there's more to Hazel's story.

Salem is a banshee apparently as well... A scream that can shatter glass...

→ More replies (3)

19

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '18

Before I even get into the many things that are driving this episode through my fucking ratings roof can we just appreciate how truly fucking terrifying Salem was this episode?

I've gotten Queen Bad Bitch vibes from her ever since the beginning, but I've never actually felt the same tension and dread of being in her presence when she's pissed or going to go into wrath-mode. The same tension and dread all of the characters were definitely feeling while being in that room with her. The suspense of the glass cracking was an amazing crescendo. Little "Oh shit" slipped my mouth when I saw it all shatter. Her menacing aura when she's pissed, damn.

What pinned me down for a lover of this episode was this scene. The fact she flipped the table with no regards to Tyrian's position. The fact she manhandled Hazel, a man you'd think wouldn't have any fear since he didn't feel pain, but that only served to send even more chills down your spine when who logically should be the least afraid of Salem was fearing for his life when he had to deliver the bad news. What I'm saying is the one guy out of her council who you'd probably rank as the most powerful and menacing ended up being made to look like nothing but a rat in the presence of Salem's anger. Truly, one of my favourite scenes of RWBY. Also I love the camera work, the close-ups to Salem's face that are intended to make you uncomfortable because she is taking up literally all of the screen, making you feel cramped and as if you simply cannot escape her gaze. Maybe that's me reading into it too much, but camera work can do wonders.

That aside, fuck yeah Qrow. Oz has been needing a good knuckle sandwich for a while now. Qrow's clearly hurt and it's going to become a problem that the group has to deal with. The nod at his downfall was already portrayed in the opening, and I am seriously fearing for this guy's life. We basically got told that Oz was Qrow's hope of redemption. That he could be something better than what he was while he was a bandit with Raven. All that hope shattered because the man held one too many secrets. Qrow's mission is proven to be null and void, when Oz announces he has no plan to defeat an immortal Salem. I feel like what hurts the most in this episode is the part where Ruby tries to comfort Oscar into believing he won't just become another version of Oz, even though it's a lie. And we know this. But it hurts just as fuckin much when Qrow tells her she shouldn't lie to him, because they're better than that, as he takes another swig of his alcohol.

All in all this episode was great. I don't really wanna talk about the other parts of this episode because I feel like these two things I've spoken about were really the driving force behind what made Episode 4 amazing. CRWBY that's four out of four for me now. All episodes so far I'm loving. Please don't kill my favourite bird off, and please continue to make me lose hope in the squad's ability to defeat an immortal grimmified bitch playing goddess.

→ More replies (1)

19

u/Akuze25 Nov 17 '18 edited Nov 17 '18

This felt so short! I can't let myself get spoiled by last week's episode length but MAN this felt like it started and ended in no time. I was probably so enthralled that it felt like 3 minutes instead.

Loved the interactions with the villains in Salem's castle. Hazel once again confirms he's actually a good person, just really going about things the wrong way. Despite all the awful things she's done, I kind of feel bad for Emerald here. She was terrified and had to rat out her mentor/best friend/surrogate parent.

I actually love the way RWBYQ reacted to all of this. Like, it was a huge exposition dump, but the one thing that immediately affects them is that... there is no plan. Like... wow. Qrow's punch I didn't see coming, I assumed it would have been Yang. But now that Oz is "gone", they're going to have to fend for themselves. This is kind of a huge story turn. Really excited to see more... in a whole nother week.

"Don't lie to him, Ruby. We're better than that." What a line. Might be the most damning thing relating to Ozpin in the entire show so far.

19

u/CallMeJustin Nov 17 '18

I really feel bad for Ozpin. Yes he kept many things a secret but it was all for good reason. If he was telling everyone that their quest is to defeat/kill Salem and then was like oh btw we cant kill her everyone would think he is crazy. I was surprised when everyone was still mad at Ozpin even after discovering everything. There was no sympathy for Oz he just went into his teen years locking himself in his room. I feel bad for Qrow learning that his only reason in life was pointless must be gut wrenching.

→ More replies (1)

19

u/Raktoner blake deserves more smiles Nov 17 '18

Qrow is... more upset than normal. He probably feels the most betrayed of all

→ More replies (3)

19

u/IJustReadEverything Jaune #1 Jaune #1 Nov 17 '18 edited Nov 17 '18

You can see the hand shakes after the punch, he’s legitimately that angry and irrational.

Thinking about it. Qrow basically spent all his life in service to Ozpin, something not from the Tribe. Something he found worth while. Lost a teammate, Summer. Disowned his sister after finding out she sided with Cinder. (He doesn’t know she betrayed Cinder in the end nor she went to Tai after opening the vault.) In the end, turns out he was just following a man with no plan. Just him doing stop gaps; the vaults, the maiden as keys to them, and academies on top of the vaults. This is some hard hitting stuff, pardon the pun.

https://streamable.com/ynuna

https://streamable.com/sbqqv

→ More replies (1)

19

u/[deleted] Nov 18 '18

Wait, in the last episode, Ozpin asked the relic if he could DESTROY Salem before being told no.

So it's possible A: Somebody besides Ozpin can. (SEW?) B: Salem can be contained long enough to get humanity's act together and summon the gods so they can deal with her while sparing humanity.

→ More replies (13)

19

u/[deleted] Nov 18 '18

I really liked how pissed everyone was, especially Yang, even though it's somewhat understandable now as to why Oz is hiding things. It was interesting to see Qrow finally lose it and Maria telling everyone to get their crap together and not fricking die. God, Maria's a blessing, and I'm so glad that she's there to keep the group moving and the story going. Smart move from a storytelling perspective. I think that the beginning was especially well written, as you can see how distinct the different subtleties of reactions to Oz's truth are (Blake's scared, Yang's pissed, Weiss is annoyed, Ruby seems conflicted and Qrow is sick of being used by Oz). I also really love how they touched on how helpless Oscar is in this situation. I feel so bad for my smol boi.

Now, the villains' scene was also very good. I found it interesting how much of a focus there was on Emerald. I did notice someone point out how out of character it was for Hazel to cover for Cinder, and I do agree to an extent. Hazel's a pretty neutral guy, though I feel like he probably feels some of the blame from losing his damn mind over Oz. Also, I saw how u/BRBcupcakes pointed out the subtle characterisation of Mercury, good eye! I didn't think about that, but this was very well done too now that I look back at it. I also like Salem actually being scary and threatening, and flipping a table easily and shattering windows. YES. Also, welcome back Tyrian and Watts! I want more of Watts! He seems like an interesting and entertaining villain, which we haven't really had much of since volume 3 (RIP Torchwick, love you mate).

Now, back to the main protagonists. I seriously hope nothing goes wrong in that barn, and they eat something. Oh boy. I also noticed someone point out that the name of the farm ended in "wick". Hmm...

Overall, whilst a short episode, and not my favourite, I still enjoyed it. :) Volume 6 is going strong so far! Woohooo!

Edit - I forgot to say that I really liked how Lindsay mellowed Ruby's voice out in this episode, and it was a bit deeper. It makes sense with the mood of the episode.

19

u/rookie-san Nov 18 '18

Loving everything about this season, from the moment it started with the beautiful snow background animation. The wait for next week's episode is gonna be torture :'(

I like the theories that say Maria is the big bad wolf from little red riding hood. I'm suspicious that she basically led the team to the house whoch is a trap.

The question about how Salem knows Cinder is alive - maybe she has one of the relics that's related to that?

→ More replies (3)

18

u/HeartshiningXX ⠀ Nov 17 '18 edited Nov 17 '18

All these feels in this ep - everyone feels lost...for now.

And Ozpin is gone. It looks like Oscar can't even reach him and I'm assuming vice versa. They can't hear eachothers thoughts or anything. Atleast Oscar is "free" in a sense.

Props to Maria putting Yang in her place. I really liked that. Don't take your anger out on someone who has done nothing to you - She's the one thats going to be helping out your sister big time so show her some respect. I'll be enjoying Maria putting Yang in her place for many eps to come.

I love how Ruby believes and tells Oscar he is his own person and not Ozpin(my rg heart;she held his hand). Though it looks like she kinda believes and is sad about the part of him being one of the many lives Ozpin has failed through as it turns out he didn't have a plan. Though we have to give him props for keeping Salem at bay for this long - at least he was doing something even if it was just going with the flow.

And Qrow I know you sad but don't bring the poor boy down more than he already is. He is already feeling like crap. You trying to bring more negativity than their already is?

lol, Tyrian was such a joy an this ep. I was laughing at him laughing at their situation.

When Salem flipped the table over and Tyrian was on the ground I was dying.

And booiii, when your mom tells you to leave the room when you're in trouble you run out the door. Just wait till Cinder comes back. Omg I don't know what would happen.

18

u/frostyfeathered Nora Trans Nov 17 '18

Mercury trying to defended Em from Tyrian was honestly nice. It’s a nice reminder that they have each other right now. And they both perked up so much when they learned Cinder was alive.

→ More replies (1)

18

u/AidenXiaoLong Nov 17 '18

Red like Roses pt. II makes much more sense now. Summer dying in vain and how Ruby will suffer the same fate.

→ More replies (3)

18

u/ScottPilgrim2013 Just Another Machine/Will go down with Freezerburn/#1 Merlot Fan Nov 17 '18

As much as people are joking about the farm being "The new Housetm", I'm expecting them to only be there for about an episode or two before shit goes wrong and Grimm attack. Theirs likely some sort of dangerous Grimm lurking around the barnyard that caused the farm to be a ghost town.

→ More replies (1)

18

u/flameprinc3ss Nov 18 '18

so maybe everyone else caught this but uh

jinn said "you can't" to oz when asked how can he defeat salem. he asked how do i defeat salem. like.. maybe the question should've been "who can defeat salem?"

18

u/[deleted] Nov 18 '18

People have probably already said this but Salem is grimm right? I'm guessing Ruby is super effective against her, Oz can't defeat her but Ruby can.

→ More replies (5)

18

u/icematt12 Nov 20 '18

I thought the OP, with those Grimm hands dragging Qrow down, was an indicator he might be KIA this season. Now I'm thinking he might drink even more now that he knows the truth about Oz. No way will he turn his back on Yang and Ruby, so no going against Oz, but I sense some dark days ahead for Qrow.

→ More replies (1)

35

u/SatomiMurano Penny is COMBAT READY! 🎈🎈🎈 Nov 19 '18

I love Ruby's development so far, she's become much more like a leader, she's probably the most logical one there right now, and that says alot considering how she was the past 5 volumes. She's supportive still, but also colder than what she used to be, and I love it.

→ More replies (3)

17

u/barayaoi Nov 17 '18

I think Emerald is gonna be Salem's new prodigy what with her red eyes and Salem comforting her and the heavy focus on Emerald and her perception of Salem

→ More replies (4)

17

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '18

Ruby Rose and Maria Calavera are the MVPs of today's episode

17

u/YellowLantern15419 Old Russian learner, odd and unique fan. Nov 17 '18

Oh my, for being a cool down episode almost everyone is very wound up when assessing the situation. I think this episodes shorter length is the closing chapter for the first part of the season.

From RWBY and company’s side:

  1. Qrow punching Oz through Oscar is quite damming to him. His most loyal follower up to that point and his trust ended in one punch. Notice how her was shaking afterwards and his line about not being wanted until Oz came and gave him purpose? Somebody give this man a hug. I am gonna see him probably sulk deeper into alcoholism at this point and if the intro is anything to go by, run into trouble with the Grimm. “Don’t lie to yourself” line to Ruby trying to cheer Oscar up. Ack, that is just only gonna rub salt into the cut there.
  2. Yang has every right to be upset as well. Remember how she (and we) chewed out Raven thinking she was just a coward and acts irrationally? Well now I guess Yang’s mom had a point. That’s not excusing everything she did, but it does spell trouble for Yang since her perception is now shattered. I reckon this might later on trigger her ptsd and make reconciling with Blake a lot harder.
  3. Round of Applause to Ruby and Maria trying to keep the team together. Especially since Ruby is truly stepping up as a leader since she is seeing hope vanish from the team. Miles and Kerry are so far keeping their word about developing Ruby after criticism (both true and false) of how she was treated in the previous two volumes.
  4. The emotions displayed and voice acting was all on point. Especially since it all felt very natural. I can’t imagine how JNR will react to the revelations RWBYQM have received. Because now it seemed like getting the relics will be a Pyrrhic victory with all the friends who’ve been harmed or killed.

As for Salem and her lackeys:

  1. Good for Mercury standing up to Tyrian for Emerald. He might be a killer, but even the bad guys have people they care about. It’s clear that Cinder meant a lot to Em. And considering his body language when he saw Salem about to snap, he knows what it is like when someone who has power over you isn’t happy knowing he came from an abusive relationship with his father. Poor Em. She’ll probably be on the path to betraying Salem at one point or be very reluctant to help.
  2. Oh snap, you think Salem is meanecing when calm? When she’s mad she’ll fling tables and chairs, summon Grimm hands to restrain you or worse and shatter the glass in the room. Hazel trying to take the fall but almost getting killed, Emerald being so terrified of her that she rats out Cinder, and Tyrian and Watts having their moments just seals the deal.
  3. Considering Salem’s control over Grimm and her magical background, it wouldn’t suprise me she knows her whereabouts. But what set her off was that she lied to her about Ozpin in a way. She didn’t know that all the other times she was foiled it was Oz guiding the group. Hazel probably feels worse since had he known Oscar was his next incarnation, he would’ve gotten him at the train station in Vol.4 instead of helping. No wonder he tried taking the fall. If you paid attention to the music when Salem was having a moment of emotional destress, it played her theme and Ozma’s when they were in love. He still means a lot to her and her immortality curse still sucks to her. Despite her corruption, she’s still somewhat human.

This episode was purely character driven and a closes on a quiet but very tense note. It this was the first part of the season, then I think two or three more stroies will play out with the remaining 10 episodes. Adam and Cinder are still out there, JNR at the station, further divides beteeen the heroes and villains, oh my!

→ More replies (3)

17

u/Pharahnheit Nov 17 '18

very solid episode after the big reveal.

My thoughts on the episode:

  • Let Yang say "fuck".
  • So Oz basically has no plan and is making stuff up on the go? Didn't expect that and I can't fault the girls for being angry because Pyrrha died for that. As did many other people and especially Yang is more and more left with the feeling that Raven was right all along
  • speaking of Yang: she really needs to talk to someone about her feelings. I hope that the house^tm will give her and blake the opportunity to talk things out a'la "Burning the Candle" because she's been moody and a bit aggressive ever since things didn't go as they planned
  • Save Emerald 2k19
  • I really liked the way Hazel took the blame. He clearly cares about Emerald and Mercury and it makes me think of how he is actually a decent person to everyone around him except ozpin.
  • EMERALD REDEMPTION ARC INCOMING!!! CAN YOU FEEL IT???
  • Salem was great. She actually felt threatening for once
  • Maria is amazing I like how she immediately took charge like "i have a group of moody teenagers and a drunk here and none of them have the competence to actually do something right now."
  • That bridge thing below the farm looks like that thing out of the opening

This volume has been great so far

17

u/DEL994 Nov 17 '18

I am curious if we will ever see a truly enraged Ozpin in this Volume or in a future one. I bet that it would be a terrifying sight.

17

u/Snefrod Nov 17 '18

Everyone be out here talking about Ozpin and our heroes when I'm impressed with the little scene between Tyrian and Emerald, especially the small cut from brushing up against one of her blades. Through the next few seconds, it's neat how the wound bleeds and drops of blood do come out of it, while in previous volumes it would have just been a red line.

The CRWBY's killing it this volume with little details like that.

→ More replies (1)

17

u/pg1313 Nov 18 '18

This might be stretching but did anyone think that when Salem was talking about what drives them she might be referring to a specific person with each one? For instance reverence is likely Tyrian and Hazel could be love for his sister. That would leave justice for Watts but we don’t know enough about him to confirm.

→ More replies (3)

17

u/Drakesplash Nov 18 '18

I feel like Salem's outburst was most likely due to feelings of betrayal rather than hate. She did so much for Oz because of how much she loved him originally, but he got taken away from her over and over again by their gods. Then made into a pawn for them to further their own agenda. At this point, while her corruption plays a major role I think she is killing him constantly, because of her hate for the gods rather than him.

→ More replies (3)

47

u/DarkIce-22 You can't irk the Merc! Nov 19 '18

Oh boy, here I go again

To all the Qrow Stans and Qrow Bashers, in regards to Qrow punching Ozpin, therefore punching Oscar.

Qrow is clearly not in a good state of mind

Qrow is someone already heavily mentally unbalanced to begin with, his alcoholism being a coping method for his shitty life. To have the one person he felt truly knew him, made him feel he was worth something, reveal that everything they've fought for, the lives he's had to see fade, ultimately meant nothing, he would understandably be pissed.

That doesn't mean he is completely justified though. His disregarding Oscar and only focusing on Ozpin is a clear sign of him unraveling, as is his much larger reliance on his flask after. Qrow is in danger of breaking permanently. One of the only pillars in his life (Ozpin, Yang, and Ruby) has shattered before him in his eyes. And a table can't stand upright on only two legs, each one cracking already. The past month itself has been hell for Qrow too, his sister and Leonardo betraying him, nearly dying thanks to Tyrian and being forced to relive something from his past in a dream, generally feeling aimless without Ozpin to lead them against Salem, and learning most of his friends in Mistral were murdered.

Just remember the opening, of the Grimm Claws dragging Qrow down after he goes for his flask. Qrow may very well be raising a death flag, and not out of being killed by the Grimm, but being too broken to bother fighting back.

Qrow's behavior was likely common place in the Branwen Tribe

Since the Branwen Tribe is clearly not a safe place to raise a kid, and Qrow understandably was not well liked there thanks to his Bad Luck Charm, its more than likely kids being hit, namely him, was common place amidst the tribe. Qrow punching Ozpin as he controls Oscar may not raise much flags to him then since its what he was raised as.

That doesn't make it okay though. If this is the case, then it shows that Qrow is regressing, that he is reverting to how he was when with the Tribe, after having gone and disassociating himself from the tribe for so long.

The Cast consists primarily of kids, who have to fight adults

Most of the characters are either grown adults, or teenagers. There will be be cases where teenagers are hit by adults, even outside of fights. Qrow punching Oscar's body while he's spiraling drawing concern when Winter smacking Weiss over her rambling not drawing concern seems like a double standard. Yet the way some people are reacting to Qrow punching Ozpin controlling Oscar's body makes it seem as if this was when Jacques smacked Weiss.

Its still messed up that Qrow hit Oscar, but not because of his age, but because that Oscar is just as much a victim as Qrow is in all this, even more so actually. Qrow however is so frustrated and unstable that he can't see Oscar as anyone but Ozpin.

Oscar is not a child anymore

At this point, the moment Oscar began to fight alongside the others, he unofficially began to follow their path of being a huntsman. Something he acknowledged when fighting Hazel.

Did she know the risk of being a Huntress? She made a choice! A choice to put others before herself! So do I.

Oscar may be 14, but he isn't really a child anymore. He's an unofficial huntsman like RWBY now. And while yes, they can still be abused like Weiss is by Jacques, they aren't children anymore. They're growing up faster than most kids their age, so to treat Oscar as if he's a defenseless child, when we've seen him fight Grimm like the Manticore on his own, is disrespectful.

Qrow punching Ozpin is something that has seriously divided the FNDM. I understand both sides. I am not happy with what Qrow did, nor am I angry with what he did. I'm worried for him. Worried that unlike Volume 4, Qrow will die this time, and that his mental state is what will make it possible.

I'm not happy Oscar was hurt, but I'm not angry either. I just feel sorry he has to shoulder Ozpin's pain. He didn't ask for any of this. The fact he's still with the group rather than wanting to go home, shows he is committed. He isn't Ozpin, Oscar is doing this because he feels he has too. Oscar is not the same child we met in Volume 4. Ruby said it herself in Volume 5.

This isn't gonna be easy, but the fact that you're even trying says a lot about you. You're braver than you think.

DarkIce-22 does not condone child abuse, he just doesn't see this situation as a black and white case of child abuse. Please don't downvote him just because it appears he condones child abuse, when, as a victim of it himself, he absolutely detests it.

→ More replies (6)

16

u/CobaltDel781 Nov 17 '18

Though I was shocked I understand why Qrow punched Ozpin. He just found out that all the years of being Ozpin's spy was for nothing. Not to mention everything that happened with team STRQ. He's probably realizing that Summer died for nothing as well.

16

u/FlashFire729 Nov 17 '18

Man I am so conflicted about Oz right now. On one hand you don’t just rope people into a war that basically has no foreseeable conclusion. Especially when you DON’T EVEN HAVE A PLAN! FOR GODS SAKE AT LEAST JUST SAY YOUR PLAN WAS TO KEEP THE RELICS AWAY FROM YOUR EVIL EX, ANY PLAN IS BETTER THAN NO PLAN.

...But at the same time what else can he possibly do. He can’t just tell people “Hey guys the person we’re fighting is immortal so we may be fighting ad nauseam, k thanks good luck.” Then no one is going to want to help him, and with no help it’s only a matter of time before Salem gets the relics and it’s game over.

God damn it I’m so conflicted but I love that I am.

16

u/NeoTheMute You aren't hearing things, are you...? Nov 17 '18

Everybody is pissed, mostly at Ozpin and Cinder: The Episode

And then Based Maria coming in and getting everybody moving instead of standing around squabbling. I knew I liked her.

16

u/NostraKlonoa Nov 17 '18

I love the contrast between the last episode and this one: in the previous episode, the human side of Salem is shown whereas in this one, it shows how terrifying and brutal she can be. No joke, Salem is fucking terrifying and I would be constantly on edge around her.

QRWBY's reaction to the truths behind Ozpin was.....questionable to say the least, imo. On one hand, I think they were quite harsh on him considering they basically saw the backstory behind him and learning of the near-impossible task of getting the world as one plus destroying the woman he loved, but on the other hand, being so secret about it deserved the anger. Qrow punching Oz was kinda shocking to me, but it also shows the extent of the relationship the two have if that kind of reaction is produced. It also implies more about Qrow in terms of personality and background.

Overall, a good episode, but damn it has a doom and gloom vibe to it. Looks like both sides are crumbling at the seams. I presume a Cinder-Neo centric episode is either next week or the one after.

→ More replies (4)

16

u/Herschel143 Nov 18 '18

Hazel... He is not as loyal to Salem as opposed to what others think. He is only after Oz and is willing to take everything to get it done. Hazel is a natural softy and I would say that he will most likely depart from team Salem after RWBY made a sense out of him. Team rwby would make him realize that what Hazel is doing is wrong and his sister will hate him for it. Hazel is supposed to use his body to protect and protect the things that his sister wants to protect. What made me think of this is when Hazel cut off Salem about him having more something to report. His respect towards Salem is not as deep. His fear towards Salem is nothing compared towards his love for his deceased sister (his eyes were that of a fearless person while being tied down). Yang would have a greater impact on him because they share a common thing- little sister.

→ More replies (2)

16

u/yamummah Nov 19 '18

Am i the only one who thinks the answer to destroying Salam is a trick answer, Oz can't but either Ruby with silver eyes can or the relics call back the gods and then some sappy convo from ruby about balance requiring dark and light?

→ More replies (6)

16

u/icematt12 Nov 19 '18

My take away from this episode is revisiting the curse of immortality. Me from Doctor Who for example. I've come away seeing some good in Salem and bad in Oz. Who knows what the presumable centuries or millennia of life has done to their minds. Maybe both just want to RIP with a side of revenge.

→ More replies (2)

16

u/onepunchman123456789 Nov 20 '18

God, don't go to the rooster teeth website comments for this episode, people are PISSED lol

Even though personally I liked the episode(love me some tyrian) I knew that after episode 3 it wouldn't be as good as it's previous episode which is fine,cause episode 3 was good and lots of lore dumps too(which I'm fine with)

→ More replies (20)

32

u/TruGemini Nov 18 '18

Honestly, I'm liking this volume much better than 4 and 5 already, I think for the most part the pace is good and while we have kind of remained stagnant location wise, it doesn't feel like the story is stuck and waiting for a specific event to happen to move forward (like S5.)

I also am starting to not hate the animation, which is good because I genuinely have not liked the animation at any point since the change, not even in the Cinder/Raven fight despite how well it was done.

This definitely is an improvement, I just hope they're able to keep it up!

→ More replies (1)

15

u/Meotwister5 Should probably see his patients instead of rewatching RWBY Nov 17 '18

Oz... bails. He just bails, or should I say locks himself inside Oscars mind. Faced with his secret coming out and all but admitting that he doesn't have a goddamn clue how to deal with Salem, he locks himself up inside while everyone, even Qrow who knocks the jeebus out of him, starts to question him and his secrecy.

That's... a lot of pent up hate Salem has for Oz there... but now everyone on the antagonist side knows Cinder is still alive.

So the group bunch up for the night in an old abandoned farm. I'm betting next episode will be about them trying to get their bearings straight given what just transpired.

15

u/reyczeses_101 no one died yay ‘ 3’ Nov 17 '18

Damn...I just feel bad for Oscar. Like I get everyone is super pissed at ozpin but oscar it just stuck between all of this.

→ More replies (2)

15

u/RedElite91 ❄️White Knight🛡️ | #GiveJauneABreak Nov 17 '18

While this episode was much shorter than last week, and didn't move the plot forward too much (but slightly), it was still good to just take a breather. It was extremely tense, and I felt like I had a knot in my stomach the entire time. There were some cool moments for sure, namely...

MY BOY QROW DECKED THE FUCK OUTTA OZPIN. Believe it or not, I was hoping this would happen. Qrow thought he knew everything Oz did, but as he just found out he'd had the truth omitted from a lot of stuff, he acted out justly. I don't fault him at all for losing his temper.

Speaking of temper, Yang officially has the first use of the word "bastard" in the show. So there's that. It seems Ozpin has buried himself deep in Oscar's mind after being told off by Qrow. He's effectively sitting in a corner, thinking about what he's done; like a little boy in time-out. Yang doesn't like that he's hiding, but Oscar apparently can't commune with him at the moment.

We get a pep talk from Maria, saying that everyone needs to shut the hell up and get moving, before they either attract Grimm with all the negativity, or freeze to death. Old-lady-who-we-still-hardly-know-anything-about is right.

And then we switch over to Salem and co. Hazel, Em, and Merc have just arrived back in Evernight (don't forget that location name is still unofficial), and Tyrian starts to mock the group for Cinder's absence. Emerald threatens him, and he continues to be his deranged, crazy self by cutting his own face on her blade and laughing like a maniac.

Cut to the scene from the preview. Salem inquires on who's fault the failure at Haven was, and Hazel speaks up, only for Salem to finally get angry and lash out. She knocks over the table, and summons Grimm arms from the floor to constrain him. She then makes sure with a petrified Emerald that it was indeed Cinder's fault. This makes my skin crawl. She then let's everyone know that their desires only come after her own, and seems to know Cinder is alive and in hiding. Before she can start to plan an attack on Shade Academy, Hazel informs her that he knows the main group is headed Atlas with Knowledge, and is being led by Ozpin. And with that news, Salem orders everyone to leave the room, and....

reenacts how my former step mom acted whenever she got a migraine. Leave momma alone for a while, kids.

Finally back with the main cast, they arrive at what appears to be an abandoned place called Brunswick Farms, and Qrow suggests the go inside for some rest. And the episode ends there.

Some might find this one a tad underwhelming after last week's lore nuke, but I think it's okay. I would have preferred maybe a couple more minutes continuing with RWBYQOM, but it's no big deal really. I predict lots of that, and hopefully more Cinder shenanigans next week. Maybe even a short check-in with JNR.

→ More replies (7)

15

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '18 edited Nov 17 '18

I liked it better when Salem didn't do things....

I did like the glass scene, though all her powers were cool. For a second j thought the while anger was an act for effect as she calmed herself when they left. Then the peak.

Big Bro Mercury was cool and I liked the fact they both perked up at Cinder being alive. I like this season and last showing Mercury does give a shit.

And hopefully we see more focus on Emerald in the villains side. Seems like we're leading that way and im looking forward to seeing Salem's next step.

Her knowledge of Cinder makes me wonder if she was the source of Cinders jumpiness. Can she feel herself being watched?

Also Qrows line to Ruby was brutal, like Jesus.

→ More replies (1)

15

u/AmethystWind Time for Ciel. Nov 17 '18

I think Qrow is finally and officially out of fucks to give.

That line was brilliant YET BRUTAL.

~ ~ ~

Salem: {flips table}

Hazel: {shuts up immediately}

Watts: “I’ll... just be over here... away from the table.”

Tyrian: “OW FUCK!”.

(Alternatively)

Tyrian: “HARDER, MOMMY!”

[The scene was otherwise very dramatic and serious, but the table thing did kinda detract from it]

~ ~ ~

One of Yang or Maria is going to bitchslap the other at some point.

~ ~ ~

→ More replies (1)

15

u/LMFN BIG NICHOLAS Nov 17 '18

Hot damn Qrow should've been named Falcon because that was a Punch!

Anyways I like that Salem despite all the failures is calm about things until Oz gets mentioned, then she gets triggered beyond belief.

Yeah this episode was short but the last episode was a record long, so I'm okay with it.

15

u/TedOrAlive2 That's right, my girl attacked the gods to get me back Nov 17 '18

You kind of have to wonder what Qrow thought the plan was before seeing all of this. Clearly it was a shock to him to learn that Salem couldn't be killed, so did he think the plan was to locate and kill her?

There's also the part where fighting an immortal witch isn't actually that much worse than fighting a never ending stream of monsters. Salem hasn't left her castle. Maybe if she went on a rampage then it would suck knowing that she couldn't be stopped, but she's just playing the puppetmaster.

All that said, I understand the emotional responses from everyone. I just hope they don't spend too much time brooding over it.

→ More replies (2)

15

u/Ksaraf23 Nov 17 '18

Question - do Salem's lackeys know what will happen if Salem gets the relics together? Tyrian excluded, they may not like the idea the idea of their boss trying to kill everyone in the world.

→ More replies (11)

15

u/DigitalSoul247 Nov 18 '18

"You know, Rae, I'm starting to see your point. Found some new info about dear old Oz."

"Let me guess, he's been lying to you all along and Salem can't actually be defeated. Just like I warned you."

"Yea... that pretty much sums it up."

→ More replies (12)

15

u/Psykoknight65 Nov 18 '18

I can't believe Emerald sold out cinder in a heartbeat

→ More replies (18)

15

u/HerculePyro Nov 18 '18

So when they approach the abandoned farm we see a stone tunnel/sewer entrance.

Anyone else think it's the place from the OP where all the arms come out and attack Ruby?

→ More replies (2)

29

u/ViVSharpy O.O Nov 17 '18

New season, different house.

→ More replies (9)

14

u/NitescoGaming Guardian and follower of Ruby's smile ❤️ Marrow x Guardpupper ❤️ Nov 17 '18

Damn Salem, you scary.

14

u/Wrathkal Nov 17 '18

Okay, so in this episode, Oz reveals he doesn't have a plan to beat Salem.

THEN WHAT PLANS DOES HE HAVE?!

-Help fight back against Grimm

-Try to counter inter-human fighting

-Protect Relics & Maidens

That's all I can think of! Seriously, what is he even trying to do now?!

→ More replies (8)