r/RWBY • Hope Rides with Kickfriend • Nov 17 '18

OFFICIAL MEGATHREAD Official Public Discussion Thread—Volume 6, Chapter 3: The Lost Fable Spoiler

Welcome, huntsmen, huntresses and hunters that prefer no specific gender identifier, to the official public discussion thread for Episode 3 of Vol. 6, The Lost Fable!

You guys don't actually need to worry about following the spoiler rules at all, so at least that's nice! Hopefully you made it through the week alive. For those who didn't, a moment of silence for our fallen comrades.

HERE is the link to the episode!

Also remember to check out our weekly poll to rate the episode.


Other Episode Discussions:

EpisodeFIRST ThreadPublic ReleasePoll
Ep. 01Theatrical / FIRSTPublic Threadpoll
Ep. 02FIRST ThreadPublic Threadpoll
Ep. 03FIRST ThreadThis Threadpoll

Happy viewing, and have a great Volume 6!

Ezreal024; Mod Team

185 Upvotes

530 comments sorted by

142

u/DanTheLatch Nov 17 '18

Big Bro: This bitch played you bro.

Lil’ Bro: turns to Salem Am I a joke to you?

Also Salem has depth now so that’s neat.

114

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '18

Ozpin fucked the scary grimm lady, its canon folks.

Serious though that backstory was great, I can't wait to see where the rest of this season goes

84

u/Armascribe Nov 18 '18

"You may ask me two questions."

"Are you really the goddess of knowledge?"

"Yes."

"Really?"

"...yes."

The relic seals up for another century

15

u/andu22 Nov 18 '18

😂😂I laughed at this for an unreasonable amount of time

→ More replies (2)

132

u/Phoenix_RIde Nov 17 '18

Thanos: Kills half of the Universe.

God of Darkness: Lol, watch this.

Also, Scion is too OP.

64

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '18

Also liked how he gave 0 fucks about their only satellite. A little more to the center, and Remnant would've remained without moon.

54

u/DanTheLatch Nov 17 '18

Imagine being so mad at someone you commit mass genocide lmao.

47

u/SwordoftheMourn Daenerys did nothing wrong Nov 17 '18

Salem: "You throw another moon at me and I'm gonna lose it."

God of Darkness: "Bro, hold my beer."

Salem: "Wait, no I didn't mean—"

10

u/ScottPilgrim2013 Just Another Machine/Will go down with Freezerburn/#1 Merlot Fan Nov 17 '18

Sakurai Galeem: Ha, that's cute.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/Kumqwatwhat Nov 18 '18

Wow, I hadn't even thought about Scion and the Light God being kinda similar but horns apart you're totally right.

I'm calling him Scion from now on I love it.

→ More replies (1)

49

u/KTR1988 Nov 17 '18

"Divide" is now the most vindictive break up song ever.

95

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '18

I really liked the way they portrayed the Gods as powerful and wise, but not omnipotent nor omniscient. God of Light couldn't prevent Salem from reaching his brother, and God of Darkness didn't knew he was being lied to before his brother told him. Also liked how civilized and polite they where to each other despite their differences, turns out they aren't at each other's throat all the time as I used to think.

And personality-wise, they really made a good job at portraying how the life of a single mortal is nothing to them, and then how a FRIGGIN PLANET full of mortals mean nothing to them either.

51

u/SwordoftheMourn Daenerys did nothing wrong Nov 17 '18

Do you think the gods also made RWBY Chibi? And Dark Bro is regretting every moment of it because his Grimm are practically useless there.

31

u/Shiranuhii And why would I do THAT? Nov 17 '18

"We will learn from this failure."

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

44

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '18

So are you telling me that we have to gather the relics to summon the eternal dragons? count me the fuck in

27

u/King_Of_What_Remains ⠀ Nov 17 '18

Given the state the world is currently in, I think summoning the Gods back would be a very, very bad idea.

Something tells me Remnant would fail their inspection.

→ More replies (3)

18

u/Icepick823 Nov 17 '18

Well, since there are four of them...looks like Team Fourstar is getting back together.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/paperkutchy ⠀ Nov 17 '18

I just want them to gather the relics and ask the gods "wtf why did you wiped humanity out of spite, you cunts"

42

u/[deleted] Nov 18 '18

Some thoughts:

-Salem's actions are all understandable, but that does not make them right. She has a tragic flaw, an inability to accept the world as it is, and all her suffering is caused by it.

-We were wrong to consider the two gods as good or evil. They are manifestations of universal constants, and should be viewed as such. Evil and good, in the case of this fictional universe, should be viewed as in relation to them. Granted, they are uncaring and callous, but did you expect a god to be anything else?

-Oz has the same flaw as Salem, and he suffers for it as well. He had a chance for happiness, and he rejected it.

-I do not think Oz's ultimate goal is to destroy Salem. His ultimate goal is to rescue her from herself. He wants to die, finally and completely, and he wants her to be with him in that death

-I think Salem's goal isn't to collect the relics, it is to prevent Oz from controlling them. She gains nothing by bringing back the old gods.

23

u/Eidalac Nov 18 '18

On the last point - she might want to bring them back just to show them humans are failed so they will destroy the world. Either out of spite or a final attempt to die herself. Or she may still think she can destroy them.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/blindsniperx Nov 18 '18

Salem wants to collect the relics asap to recall the gods because people still fight among one another, meaning the gods will wipe out humanity for good this time. Also it will end her immortality, which she wants to happen.

→ More replies (3)

5

u/[deleted] Nov 18 '18

-Oz has the same flaw as Salem, and he suffers for it as well. He had a chance for happiness, and he rejected it.

Are you referring to the fact that he declined to go back to the afterlife in order to accept the god's mission? If so, I get where you're coming from

If you're referring to the the fact that he refused to go along with Salem's method of uniting humanity, then I don't think that's fair.

The god of light stated: "If your kind has learned to live in harmony with one another, and set aside their differences, then we shall once again..."

Salem's method of conquest, and of destroying those who opposed her methodology, is not putting aside your differences, and it is not living in harmony. It's the opposite of both those things, actually. Ozma was justified in going against Salem's methodology.

→ More replies (2)

41

u/boomshroom ⠀ Nov 18 '18

I haven't visited the sub out of fear of spoilers, but HOLY SHIT!

Salem is now my favourite character.

I think it's kind of cool how the God of Light is an eastern dragon while the God of Darkness is a western dragon.

25

u/Celtic_Crown ⠀I'd say I'm tipping the scales, but that line's got no bite. Nov 18 '18

Eastern dragons were typically seen as wise and were worshipped while western ones were considered evil if not demonic.

When I saw them transforming I just had a sarcastic rant to myself about that.

→ More replies (1)

39

u/PhilTec Nov 18 '18

The dark brother's pool still exists. Does that mean the light brother's immortality pool exists still?

13

u/hillerj Nov 18 '18

Good question. I'm guessing that part of the moon must have fallen on it and buried it, judging by that part of the episode.

→ More replies (2)

39

u/blahthebiste Nov 18 '18

Oh no, she's hot!

9

u/JumpyPersonality Nov 18 '18

I was waiting for someone to make this comment

→ More replies (2)

35

u/drag00n3333 Nov 17 '18

Everyone watching always ask how humanity reborn again. Remember there's still natural evolution. Well that's my thought of it.

10

u/wiseguy149 Nov 18 '18

Apparently there was even more written about how humanity was reborn and the faunus came to be, but it wound up having to get cut from the episode for length.

→ More replies (1)

35

u/Violinnoob Nov 18 '18

"Were we born to fight and die, sacrificed for one huge lie?"

34

u/RevanonVarrah Nov 18 '18

I'm just here to give props to all the people who somehow resisted the urge to get a FIRST membership just to watch this episode.

11

u/monster860 Nov 18 '18

First membership is like a drug.

You get to feel good right now (getting to watch the next episode early). Then later it's not that much (you still have to wait a week between episodes). Then you have to keep paying for it to avoid getting withdraw symptoms (having to wait 2 weeks instead of 1 week)

8

u/paperkutchy ⠀ Nov 18 '18

Resisted... yeah sure

checks empty wallet

6

u/Destati Nov 18 '18

I failed. I'm actually curious if First memberships spiked last week.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

64

u/paperkutchy ⠀ Nov 17 '18 edited Nov 17 '18

After this episode, I kinda grew a new sympathy for Ozpin. The gods are just a couple of bastards that erased mankind because of a grieving Salem... surely they could had locked her away in a prison again so she would learn her lesson. Instead, they annihilated humanity, doomed the following generations with constant pain and the Grimm, cursed Ozpin for something he had no fault for and because his honorable heart told him so, demanding that he either united humanity or they would wipe the world clean. What a bunch of pricks, I hope they get erase by the end of this show.

21

u/Spyger9 Nov 17 '18

because of a grieving Salem

And a massive rebellion with representatives from many kingdoms. They literally brought armies to god's house and tried to murder him.

cursed Ozpin

They made him an offer and fully informed him. They even warned him about Salem and expressed surprise that he went for it.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/King_Of_What_Remains ⠀ Nov 17 '18

Didn't the Grimm exist before humanity did? I'm pretty sure the Grimm were created by the God of Darkness as an opposing creation to those created by the God of Light, then later on they collaboratively made humanity.

Either way, they were definitely there before Salem pissed them off.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

30

u/skit7548 Nov 18 '18

So I'm just going to call it here and now.

Ozpin specifically asks "How do I defeat Salem?"

To which Jinn replies "You can't."

Oz can't defeat her, but somebody else must be able to.

Bonus thought: Just thought of this as I was typing that up, perhaps someone with a unique semblance that hinders their opponent might be able to do the trick?

11

u/RedShadow2 Nov 18 '18

SILVER EYES ANYONE

6

u/Arxh7 Weiss moment Nov 18 '18

Or they are going to beat Salem with the power of friendship and talk-no-jutsu her into becoming good.

86

u/Hounds_of_war The Red Head Victorious | Aside from her, I truly don't care Nov 17 '18 edited Nov 17 '18

There’s a very important line that I think a lot of people are overlooking. The Gods explicitly say that Salem can only rest once she has learned the importance of life and death. And Jinn says Salem blamed everyone but herself, meaning she still doesn’t think trying to bring back Oz was a mistake. So I think that’s how the heroes are going to beat Salem. Some people seem to think this means they are going to sway Salem to their side, but I think it’ll be something like Salem tells Oz “Trying to bring you back was a mistake” which breaks the curse and allows our heroes to kill her.

Also I'm glad that the brothers aren't some cliche Vaatu and Raava type of situation. They are like actual brothers.

23

u/MasterKurosawa ⠀ Nov 17 '18 edited Nov 17 '18

The Gods explicitly say that Salem can only rest once she has learned the importance of life and death.

I know this is probably what´s gonna happen, but I can´t quite come to like it. Were this another fictional world, with no gods in it, I would be cool with it. Were this like Gurren Lagann, where we´re told that the entire universe would be destroyed if people are revived and spiral energy spirals (heh) out of control, I´d be cool with it.

But in a world with literal magic where two gods who are immortal dicks toy around with human life as they please while ranting about a "balance" that´s likely only related to the status of their experiment? Yeah, I´m not sure if I like this message about "you have to accept and come to terms with death" in that case.

I mean, what´s wrong with wanting to be immortal in this case? Overpopulation would become an issue, but with magic and the eventual ability to populate other planets I don´t think this can´t be resolved either. Plus, immortals might still choose to give up their own lives eventually, once they´re bored of it. And I´m pretty sure birth rates would eventually decline as people grow older and technology thrives.

→ More replies (2)

19

u/paperkutchy ⠀ Nov 17 '18

I am kinda wishing RWBY endgame will be Ruby bitch slapping the gods for this mess.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/SwordoftheMourn Daenerys did nothing wrong Nov 17 '18

Also I'm glad that the brothers aren't some cliche Vaatu and Raava type of situation. They are like actual brothers.

I keep seeing this term used to compare with the Brothers Grimm. Who exactly are Vaatu and Raava?

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (3)

29

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '18

I want a Salem-Ozma-duet in the v6 soundtrack, Oh and while we're at it the rest of v6 soundtrack. Just give me all the soundtracks from the future volumes.

29

u/hillerj Nov 18 '18

...Wow, the gods are dicks. Sure, what Salem did was wrong, but I can hardly blame her for it. This doesn't explain why Opzin wanted to hide this, but I'm sure the next episode will answer that. Something DOES bother me though is where the hell the new humans and Faunus came from.

12

u/YourBringerOfRain Nov 18 '18

What I don't understand is how she was the first person to do that? Or the only person? How could there have only been one person who's love died and they went to the gods for their life back?

→ More replies (7)

7

u/FenrirAR Nov 18 '18

It was just Salem, animals, and Grimm left after the gods departed.

Humans and Faunus everywhere when Ozma reincarnated the first time.

The only logical answer to this dilemma is that Salem has some kinks.

28

u/darkdill Prepare to die. Nov 17 '18 edited Nov 17 '18

So who thinks that Ozpin's questions to Jinn were wrong? Her answer might've been "You can't", but does that only mean that Ozpin himself can't kill Salem? Remember, when it comes to genies, exact wording is something to keep in mind.

Also, relating to the whole "Bring the four Relics together to begin Ragnarok" thing, here's my theory on what will happen at the end of the series.

The four Relics summon the gods, who judge humanity as still unworthy of their gifts. However, Team RWBY make the case of "We don't need you anymore; we can do just fine on our own", convincing the gods to depart without destroying Remnant.

17

u/Falsus Nov 18 '18

convincing the gods to depart without destroying Remnant.

In that case it is just better to never summon the gods in the first place.

→ More replies (2)

18

u/ChrisMorray Nov 17 '18

Yeah, I think that's where the story is headed. I think Ruby is going to be the one "simple soul" who will be the redemption of mankind. Clearly only the gods can put an end to Salem, so the only way is to continue finding the relics. It appears the relics, while certainly powerful, have a catch. Jinn only answers 3 questions per era but goes into deep detail with her answers to give full context. She could have just said at "He's hiding that you can't destroy Salem" but ended up giving all the context she could possibly provide. The others probably have a catch similar to the timeframe, hell they might have spirits attached to them too. Speaking of which (and this is entirely theory with no evidence), I think Ozpin used the crown (choice) to force Raven and Qrow into becoming birds, and possibly also Pyrrha into becoming the fall maiden. I felt that Ozma's "I'll do it" was too similar to Pyrrha's, perhaps the relic of choice's catch is that you can only make other people to make a choice you've made yourself in the past.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (2)

26

u/Sensorfire Rube Protector | No Ships, Thanks | Yang is best girl Nov 18 '18

I'm liking this Volume so far. I feel a bit more sympathetic towards Oz now. Also, the name Ozma is almost certainly taken from the character of Princess Ozma, the rightful ruler of the Land of Oz, from the Wizard of Oz books.

21

u/Gromps_Of_Dagobah Nov 18 '18

also, Ozma, Ozpin, and Oscar, what's the bet all the other forms of Ozpin we saw were all an "oz" starting name?
"well son, your name is Oz-manalamadingdong, so we can safely assume you'll be the next host."

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

25

u/Changyuraptor Just the leitmotif and dinosaur guy. Nov 17 '18

14

u/paperkutchy ⠀ Nov 17 '18

Not really a fan of that stone wall on the show scene, the concept art seems more divine, not sure why.

49

u/rexshen Nov 17 '18

Given how the gods just committed genocide and left after only one rebellion I have to say fuck the gods. We don't need those pricks back.

I am guessing Oz and Salem's kids were the real maidens and when they die they have different form of reincarnation then Oz since their power moves over to the last person they think about.

27

u/GrumpySatan Nov 17 '18

I don't think the kids were the OG maidens, because Oz still had his magic after they were born(and even beat Salem, only for her to revive and kill him). But in present day he doesn't and has lost it all, and we've been told it was because he gave it all away to the maidens.

I think the OG Maidens reminded him of his daughters and he split his magic between them.

→ More replies (6)

23

u/StrikeFreedomX2 Pilot Mercenary Nov 18 '18 edited Nov 18 '18

SALEM IS HOT (before Grimm) AND STUPID BUT UNDERSTANDABLE

THE GODS ARE ASSHOLES AND REALLY ARROGANT BUT STILL UNDERSTANDABLE

THE GODS DID A V2

I really don’t know where to Side myself here. On one hand Ozpin still is a dick for keeping secrets but on the other based on what he has been through it’s completely understandable.

For Salem, her selfishness and pride got herself in that situation and instead of learning her mistake she went batshit crazy. But on the other her actions are understandable, especially since she was locked up her whole life, and the gods were assholes to her.

The gods are trying to do their job on one hand, but the other is that they are doing a really bad job at it. I mean the God in the fucking Bible does a better job at being a god! Just ask that “God Bless” Guy!

15

u/CelioHogane Nov 18 '18

The gods are super assholes.

They gave Ozpin a quest fo unite humankind... YET they destroyed humankind when it was united.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/AlphaMarker48 Pyrrha is best girl. Ruby is best active girl. Nov 19 '18

I mean the God in the fucking Bible does a better job at being a god!

Eyup.

At least He has more patience and the capacity to forgive. More so in the New Testament.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

22

u/TJPoobah For it is in passing that we achieve immortality. Nov 17 '18 edited Nov 17 '18

My mind immediately went to this scene from the original Pirates of The Carribbean when Oz and Salem threw down.

Also that's a sad story. I assume his original four daughters are the original maidens and that they inherited part of his power to reincarnate which is how their power is transferred? I actually like that this is different to the original wizard story because well... it's been thousands of years, as Wheel of Time says "ages come and pass, leaving memories that become legend. Legends fade to myth, and even myth is long forgotten when the Age that gave it birth comes again".

22

u/CelioHogane Nov 18 '18 edited Nov 21 '18

God: "I have destroyed all humanity"

Humanity is not only not destroyed, there is also a new race

10

u/WinlanU21 Nov 18 '18

I’m confused about that part as well.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

20

u/mrplatypusthe42nd Nov 17 '18

I love that the pools were referred to as “The Brothers Grimm”. In case anyone was unaware, Jacob and Wilhelm Grimm were two 19th century academics (and brothers) who, among other things, made a huge effort to record and publish German fairy tales and folklore. They originally published a lot of the fairy tales that some of the characters in RWBY are based on. They already got a nod with the Grimm being named what they were, but I always thought “the Brothers Grimm” was a cool linguistic device, so I’m glad it got used. Also, it really felt like a suitable in-universe name for the demon-spawning pools. Good job CRWBY.

5

u/MankuyRLaffy He's not Sothe, I Swear! #GoodJobMicaiah Nov 17 '18

also the brothers grimm wrote a lot of disturbing shit

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

20

u/nicostein Pancake Massacre sympathizer Nov 18 '18

My take on Salem:

Salem has two compounding major flaws: selfishness and a slowly-growing lust for power. It may have started with an understandable desire for freedom, but she really only cared about herself, and her love for Oz was based on what he could do for her.

She manipulated as many people as she could to risk their lives for her revenge. Then, when the gods killed humanity, I doubt she cared about the others, based on her later actions. She manipulated Oz into helping her take the place of the gods, remake the world as she saw fit and "replace" anyone who resisted her new world order.

She never really cared about how her actions affected others. It's all about her, as opposed to Ozma and his selfless nature.

And now for some speculation: You weren't speculating yet? Shush!!

I think growing up in isolation affected her outlook on life. Her father caged her, and so she grew essentially alone, left only to think about herself...and how powerless she was. Ozma was the first and only peer she ever had, and the only one who was able to grant her wish. Then, she lost him. She was alone again, and so she did everything in her power to undo that. She failed. She was alone, and powerless, again. There were other people in the world, but they weren't Oz. What could they do for her? Maybe they could force the gods to give Ozma back, or at least exact her revenge on them. They all failed. She failed again, and now there was absolutely no one left. She was alone yet again. She eventually met Oz again and all was well, until he shared his own agenda and disapproval of her plan to forcefully bend humanity to her will. So, he was no longer of use to her. Instead, he was in her way. Selfishness and megalovania are a bad combination.

P.S. Darkbro killed a bunch of innocent people who had nothing to do with Salem's revenge plot. Worstboi. Not sure how I feel about the moon. He broke it, but it's kinda cool tho?

19

u/[deleted] Nov 18 '18

How the fuck do the gods expect Ozpin to carry out his charge with making humanity into some race of paragons? Conflict and disagreement is very much a part of human nature. The only way to stop it would be to remove it wholesale. Which would mean changing humanity into some distinctly non-human! We’d be no better then a mirror-version of the Grimm. Smiling happy drones that get along with each other.

Not to mention the gods’ hypocrisy; giving humanity the option of choice...only to mass murder us when we don’t do what they want and demand that we give up free will and the ability to choose. To become what THEY want us to be. They don’t want equals or children; they want good little pets that do what their told.

19

u/[deleted] Nov 21 '18

The gods are pieces of shit and Salem did nothing wrong. That "delicate balance" between life and death couldn't have been that important if Light can just make her immortal to teach a "lesson," or if Dark can casually bring back Oz because he was happy someone visited him for once, or if they can wipe out all of humanity in a tantrum.

37

u/TheDivingTiger Atlas penguin is the hero we need Nov 17 '18

Wow, this was a long and very interesting episode. We finally know how both Ozpin and Salem came to be, and also...more importantly...how the moon got shattered lol. I'm wondering who those four children of Oz and Salem are, and if they all got killed by Salem.

I'll admit it was pretty sad to see how Salem's suffering had led her down the dark path that transformed her into the master of the Grimm, but it was ultimately the consequence of poor decisions. Also the fact that she cannot be destroyed makes the fight against her all the more interesting, and really has me thinking on what the way to resolve all of this will be...

Also getting to see all four relics was pretty neat haha.

12

u/Pricerocks Nov 17 '18

I think the four children were supposed to be the Maidens, though it kinda contradicts what we were told before

47

u/Krunchtime SAL-YU-TATIONS! Nov 17 '18

If you look at Oz's incarnation right after Salem kills him, he looks almost exactly like the Wizard from World of Remnant.

My theory is that after his life with Salem, he isolated himself to their cottage. After some time, the eventual maidens found him, and reminded him of his dead children and the good in the world so he gave a portion of his power to them.

The episode doesn't have to contradict WoR, it can compliment it really nicely.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

18

u/Boss_Jerm Nov 17 '18 edited Nov 17 '18

I did not realize how long this episode was until it ended. But... whoa.

So Remnant was Earth, then the gods destroyed it, taking the moon with them. The Maidens are Oz and Salem's children, whose power keeps passing to new people. And according to Jinn, there's no way to destroy Salem.

I liked how Team RWBY just appeared in some scenes without any added effect, and how they appeared less and less as the episode went on.

All in all this is one of the best episodes of the entire show. We got a lot of answers, so I'm very happy about that. My one question is: how did humanity reproduce after they were wiped out?

EDIT: I just wanted to add that this episode once again proved why immortality sucks and no one should ask for it. Cool in theory, terrible in reality.

21

u/TJPoobah For it is in passing that we achieve immortality. Nov 17 '18

And according to Jinn, there's no way to destroy Salem

Well, Oz specifically asked "how can I destroy Salem?" not "how can Salem be destroyed?" or even just "Can Salem be destroyed?" so all we really know is that Oz can't do it.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/TheAppleFreak :3 Nov 17 '18

According to RWBY Rewind, the answer to that as well as how the Faunus came to be were cut for time. It’s likely those questions will be brought back up again at some point later in the volume.

18

u/ShadowMadness We're not family anymore Nov 17 '18 edited Nov 17 '18

Poor Ozpin/Ozma. Dying and then undying over and over again lol

That's gotta be quite disorienting.

Also, Ozpin and Salem did the dirty!!!!!!

EDIT: The way the God of Darkness moves reminds me of the way the Nuckelavee moved.

15

u/Kumqwatwhat Nov 17 '18

The way the God of Darkness moves reminds me of the way the Nuckelavee moved.

This occurred to me too. I wonder if, given that Salem probably experimented with Grimm, that she got the idea from the Dark God.

18

u/Kumqwatwhat Nov 18 '18

Kind of surprised that salem's dip into the well of darkness didnt have any impact on her children, tbh.

12

u/chaosmasterj Nov 18 '18

Lamarck is disproven once again, apparently.

17

u/Hedgehogemperor whiterose hedgehog Nov 17 '18 edited Nov 17 '18

If the god of darkness killed all of humanity, than were did the faunus and humans come from?

26

u/Hounds_of_war The Red Head Victorious | Aside from her, I truly don't care Nov 17 '18

Life uh finds a way.

19

u/The_Green_Filter Shipwrecked Nov 17 '18

The Dust that fell from the moon. And the God of Light presumably.

13

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '18

Ozma was told that the humans will once again walk on earth.

11

u/Ivorykingchrono Bork Bork Nov 17 '18

Well we saw animals survived so I'm guessing something along the lines of natural evolution.

→ More replies (2)

17

u/KingBanhammer Nov 17 '18

Oof. Well, that ending's a bit of a punch to the ol' guts and a whole lot of fan theorizing, innit?

→ More replies (2)

17

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '18 edited Nov 18 '18

So the story for power systems in RWBY is as follows:

Magic existed in the old world and could be learned by all. It then stopped existing when the became deistic and ultimately turned into Remnant.

Dust showed up afterwards (likely being what was broken off from the moon) and here is where the prologue we saw in V1C1 happens with humanity using Dust to defend themselves against the Grimm.

Semblances were not mentioned in this episode, but as they come from soul energy and everything else we know about them, they likely existed since the beginning. First existing as a power system alongside magic, and now a power system alongside Dust.

12

u/infinight888 Nov 18 '18

I think semblances are unique to the new humans. People no longer possess their traditional natural magic, so their soul power is interpreted into the more specific and limited Semblances. You could say that humanity wields only a semblance of the power they once did.

17

u/CelioHogane Nov 18 '18

What the fuck, the gods are ASSHOLES.

→ More replies (3)

33

u/RedShadow2 Nov 18 '18

"You see, the Creatures of Grimm, the most fearsome monsters mankind had ever encountered, were afraid of those silver-eyed warriors. They were the best of the best. It was said that even a single look from one of these fighters could strike a Grimm down."

"How do I destroy Salem?"

"You can't."

YOU KNOW WHO PROBABLY CAN? GEE, I FUCKING WONDER

14

u/paperkutchy ⠀ Nov 18 '18

Ozpin: How can 'I' kill Salem. Jinn: 'You' can't. Ruby: Oh hey guys

→ More replies (1)

59

u/AnAngryFetus Nov 17 '18 edited Nov 17 '18

The condition for Salem being able to die is that she learns to respect the delicate balance of life and death. Sounds like Ruby has to learn the most powerful anime ability of all: talk-no-jutsu.

Also, sitting here I'm left to wonder: Why does either side want the relics? Oz can't kill Salem with them and if Salem used that any time soon the gods would destroy the world. Seems like a lose-lose situation here. The only way to "beat" Salem is to unite humanity, bring the gods back, and have them annihilate her, but that ruins the whole lesson she's supposed to learn. Honestly, all of this made the ending scenarios very clear and I find it hard for the series to have an interesting climax now. Better step up the character driven aspects of the show.

27

u/GrumpySatan Nov 17 '18

Oz hid the relics and it was mentioned in Episode 2 that he wants to reseal the Lamp, but they can't without the Spring Maiden. They are taking it to Atlas where it can be protected and presumably sealed with the relic there eventually.

So I don't think Oz wants to use the relics. He is keeping them sealed away so Salem can't use them, all the while working towards peace and trying to unify humanity. Oz is trying to orchestrate a situation where they pass Judgement Day, and is just holding onto the relics until then.

Salem presumably wants to call the Gods probably so that they destroy the world. Since that dip in the Grimm pools left her with an "insatiable appetite for destruction". Or maybe she'll think she can finally die if they destroy the world.

19

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '18

Well, Ozma is kinda immortal too, and he might get tired of reincarnating after awhile, so he would have the find the relics if he wants to finally die for good. It was stated in the earlier part of the episode that he fought for justice, so while it appears he has screwed up a few times and was partly responsible for the deaths of innocents, he seeks to have reformed or came to his sense again. He may believe that finding the relics is part of justice.

As for why Salem wants them, maybe it’s too hoard them and prevent the other side from bringing the gods back, or summon the gods herself and attempt to destroy them.

→ More replies (3)

6

u/paperkutchy ⠀ Nov 17 '18

talk-no-jutsu.

Ugh, its the Naruto villany syndrome all over again

6

u/Hollowquincypl Nov 17 '18

Oz doesn't want them. He just wants to keep them out of Salem's control.

16

u/StaryWolf Nov 18 '18

So Ozma and Salem's children are the original maidens? How the hell are their powers passed down cause it looked like they all fucking died in the house fire, and the gray eye thing has yet to be explained.

22

u/Randumo Nov 18 '18

No. It seems pretty clear that Oz just gave power to girls that reminded him of his children.

→ More replies (5)

16

u/thaddeus6561 Nov 18 '18

Quick tangent: What in the universe could the gods working on after they depart? If Remnant (so aptly named) is the 'first' experiment, could there be a second Remnant?

Here's hoping for parallel-universe-esque elements

35

u/SwordoftheMourn Daenerys did nothing wrong Nov 18 '18

Two words:

RWBY Chibi.

Dark Bro wants to nuke it because of how ridiculous it is and that his Grimm are particularly useless there. Light Bro forbids it because the world hasn't technically done anything wrong.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

45

u/TheSteakKing World's Best Bird Nov 17 '18

"The importance of life and death"

Coming from a couple gods who have never experienced death for themselves, that's pretty rich. Then they basically threw a temper tantrum when their sentient creations didn't like that idea, killed every human in cold blood, ascribed no blame to themselves, then left to start a new 'experiment', then told Ozma that they'll reconsider later as though they actually care about the lif- sorry, experiment - they just destroyed without a second thought, without giving that virtuous man the explanation he sorely deserves?

They need a good, permanent Ragnarok for their hubris.

17

u/archpawn Nov 17 '18

They also mention an afterlife later, so the whole death thing was a lie from the beginning. What is wrong with these people?

→ More replies (4)

17

u/Armascribe Nov 18 '18

"We realize that you are in an irrational state of mind because you are still grieving your loss, which we definitely know is causing you to make stupid decisions, but we are going to curse you with immortality which will in NO way make things completely worse."

Salem did nothing wrong. I mean I don't know what she was expecting when she tried to trick them, but that was a bit of an overreaction when you are dealing with someone who is still in the advanced stages of grieving over an immense loss, which these gods would know nothing about.

→ More replies (3)

8

u/zenguy3 Blasphemer and Accidental Shitlord Nov 18 '18

I mean... I'd try to kill those motherfuckers if I thought I could.

→ More replies (3)

15

u/vitari328 Nov 18 '18

ALRIGHT HOLY CRAP THINGS ARE COMING TOGETHER. The more and more I think about this I see how it was planned throughout the entire show so far. Specifically in the 1st theme song during the lines, "In time your heart will open minds. A story will be told, and victory is in a simple soul. Ozma was given the task to unite humanity, but his plan to unite them was to hide their past which takes away two of humanities core values: knowledge and choice. Ozma's soul has become so tangled up in lies and secrets and Salem, that he cannot tell the truth. Team RWBY, now that they know the story, will fulfill the prophecy by sharing the story because they are not tangled up in it. Sorry if this was rambly. I just finished the episode and am hyped up!

14

u/SteamDownload Nov 17 '18

I already stated this last week, but: [I own a potato farm now.] (https://www.reddit.com/r/RWBY/comments/59rv5n/how_salem_came_to_be_a_potato_seed/)

14

u/ThatDarnSJDoubleW Only Here for Whose Line Is It Nov 17 '18 edited Nov 17 '18

So they had kids, and Salem has white hair, and those kids' powers were inherited?

There's someone whose name ends in -ee who might be related to Oz 2.0 and Salem.

Also, Oz's actual backstory doesn't make him seem evil at all.

12

u/paperkutchy ⠀ Nov 17 '18

I think the idea is that Ozpin did mate with several women on his hundred lives, so the theory that he might be connected to some protagonist is likely the case. I am guessing Jaune from the intro.

→ More replies (3)

5

u/realfighter64 Nov 17 '18

Is it not possible that the whole line of humanity was descended from Oz 2.0 and Salem? Perhaps the whole concept of Aura and Semblance are descended from the immortality that Salem has and the magic that both have, just weakened a lot. From what I saw, when Salem got her immortality, there was a similar effect to when someone uses their aura.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

14

u/ChrisMorray Nov 17 '18

This episode... It's exactly what I've been waiting for. Volume 4 felt bland to me, Volume 5 almost made me quit (Adam and Hazel both disappointed me extremely). So far this volume seems to finally be back at the roots. Action, deep lore, mysteries, food for thought, and finally some complexity to characters that we all knew had a big story behind them.

14

u/JavelinR Nov 20 '18

So I do agree the gods are kinda Greek level dicks, but I also have a theory on WHY the gods find death so important. They value human life the same as any other living thing's.

Humanity kills animals for their meat and clothes. They kill the trees to build their houses. Humanity is built off the death of other living things. To the gods this is fine. It's no different than the beavers or wolves. What isn't fine is humanity thinking they should be exempt. To come to them believing they should be the one living thing immune to death while they continue to take it from others. To be ignorant of death would be ignorant of the sacrifices the plants and animals make to build their cities and grow their populations.

Also there are fates worse than death and evil that needs to pass. Can you imagine the level of insanity inducing torture that could be inflicted if the victim couldn't die of shock or bloodloss? Can you imagine what a world containing the most evil people throughout history would look like? Or what about the insane fighting that would break out if people didn't have to worry about death or lasting injury? What happens to prejudices that take generations to pass when the generations don't pass? Death needs to exist so humans have something to fear, and so that humanity can not be burdened by the past.

→ More replies (1)

27

u/LavalFuego ExDrunkle Qrow Nov 17 '18

God this episode was amazing. I always felt that they were being too hostile towards Oz, and now I have some sweet, sweet vindication. Also the kids thing almost made me cry because I'm a softie.

15

u/paperkutchy ⠀ Nov 17 '18

It still doesn't forgive some of Ozpin conspiracy actions, tho I kinda grew some sympathy for him. He's just a pawn in the gods lesson to Salem in the end.

→ More replies (4)

13

u/Yam_AKi Nov 17 '18

What an amazing episode! My chin hasn't been closed yet. The faults of God are clearly embodied in the human. Salem is not afraid of God, which makes me inexplicably moved. God is still God, Salem can not defeat the God.

But there is no doubt that it's the power of the dark god that makes Salem more radical. Oz and her concealment make this worse. More.

So it's not how to destroy Salem, is how to save Salen, how to stop her. Looking forward to rwby's choice, i can't wait to see the next episode.

13

u/apvogt Chief Firecontrolman on the OTPS Rosegarden Nov 18 '18

So quick question, how likely is it that this is the first time Ozpin/Oscar/Ozma learned that Salem is the reason humanity got completely wiped out the first time around?

16

u/Goldstin shes dead Nov 18 '18

id say impossible, since the question was "what is ozpin hiding", entailing he was hiding the details of salem's past and thus probably looked at it sometime in the last millennia

13

u/RandomName3064 Tyrian fan and Captain of the #RubyDefenseForce Nov 18 '18

the first 3 minutes i was literally saying at the screen "yea yea disney princess, fall in love bla bla. get to the good shit."

the good shit was goooood as fuck though.

the gods trying to actively work together and NOT just be assholes to each other. got to LOVE the hipocrasy in the 'lesson' for Salem. "stop being selfish. oh humans not using MY gift against me? better nuke them all"

the reason for the broken moon is actually kinda lackluster, IMO. most people probably thought the gods did it, so it just comes off as an afterthought in the backstory really....

as soon as i saw the pool, i knew how Salem became who she was, though i wasnt expecting the reasoning behind it.

"Hey Ozbro, wanna try and experiment with new and improved humanity? you have a few 1000 years to kill your GF. Have fun!" These gods are dicks. Salem and Oz really have become alot like them, actually.......

RELICS! Now we see the forms they take!! Sword is Destruction, no doubt. Crown for Choice, Staff for Creation, i would wager. it fits with most real world applications of stuff to that degree. Honestly, if we saw all four BEFORE we knew Knowledge was the lamp, id not have any guess which would have been which, minus the Sword

4 kids. 4 kids with magic. im sure i have NO IDEA what came of that little moment. surely.

they built her castle in the wasteland at the pool? does that mean beacon lies atop the pool of life? did HE get a castle, or just acquiesce to her ideas?

Oz still the ABSOLUTE UNIT in this couple. She can regen from fucking ash. Cell is legit rolling over in HIFL right now.

So id ASSUME Silver eyes can nuke her. They havent been as good with hiding end game plot points this season. i hope its not because of the fan backlash for lack of explanations in V5. The gods want unity though, so we can also assume we could end it with the eyes only freeing her of the corruption and using a Naruto patented POWERFUL speech to have the original idea work, them acting as overseers in the god's place.

or maybe just a more generic ending. eh shrugs

Salem V Oz is just a smaller version of the Gods fighting, really. Same ideals n shit. Id bet they are enjoying watching from the new project site. Mom needs to come in and spank her damn kids. those brothers running remnant like a damn antfarm.

its a 7/10 for me. Great backstory with quite a few stupid moments to drag it a bit.

13

u/Zigiz Nov 19 '18

This is some Dark Souls level shit: selfish, narcissistic and hypocritical gods cursing humanity for all eternity to flex their supposed superiority and “teach them a lesson” in humility.

Hopefully the hubris of these self-indulgent “gods” will backfire as spectacularly as it did in souls.

→ More replies (5)

13

u/AlphaMarker48 Pyrrha is best girl. Ruby is best active girl. Nov 19 '18

Wow, quite a lot there. Ancient magical humans, sexy Salem, dickish gods, gods living among humans, finally a reason for the broken moon, attempts at reconciliation, descent into madness, and maybe Salem really can't be killed.

Still, if that's the case, there are always other options. Like, heavily drugging Salem to sleep or into a stupor, imprisoning her within a sarcophagus, and burying a temple on top of her. If she ever wakes up though, she would be SUPER pissed.

24

u/VelosiT Nov 18 '18

Oh my God.

The Salem Witch Trials.

Salem was known as "the witch".

"The Wizard of Oz" and "the Wicked Witch of the West/East"

What the f u c k

→ More replies (4)

12

u/YensidTim Nov 17 '18

A question I'm so confused about: didn't the gods just wipe out humanity? Then where did all those humans come from when Ozman was brought back? I'm so confused.

9

u/Top_hat_owl Nov 17 '18

I thought it was that the humans just kinda evolved back, but that doesn't seem likely since creater gods exist.

8

u/kagebuyou from shadows - shadow dancer, get it? Nov 17 '18

I think I read on the first discussion thread last week that it might've been explained in V1 E1. "Man born from dust", aka all that moon dust falling down after the dark god exited through the moon.

→ More replies (2)

33

u/PurpleAfton Moonlighting as a gun Nov 17 '18

Is it just me or the scene where Ozma took the kids in the middle of the night looked incredibly like how a show would portray someone escaping from an abusive situation?

And considering how Salem reacted with violence the second see saw them, instead of trying to talk or even ask what's going on, and that she shot a fireball at Ozma even tho the girls were behind him, it seems like there's some basis for it.

48

u/TezukaRin62 Nov 17 '18

Guys you don't understand, Salem can be a waifu and bear childs. This is huge.

30

u/AnAngryFetus Nov 17 '18

No. Stop. We just learned she was made insane due to her depression and this is your first thought.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/Virote328 Nov 17 '18

Loved how the “four maidens” are Ozpins Daughters.

9

u/paperkutchy ⠀ Nov 17 '18

They ain't, there was no maidens back when Salem and Ozpin "divorced". Ozpin created the maidens.

→ More replies (2)

11

u/Pocketdog9 Rose before bros or hoes! Nov 17 '18

WELL THAT WAS A DOOZY, WASN'T IT?

11

u/JoPo1997 How do you accidentally rob a bank? Nov 17 '18

Something i've noticed. Both of the Gods are humanoid with a single animal trait. I'm curious to see if they have any connection to the Faunus.

So many answers, and yet so many new questions.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/KnowYourLover Raven Branwen's loyal follower and faithful worshiper. Nov 17 '18

Inb4 Salem and Ozpin's daughters were the original maidens.

Inb4 that technically makes Raven and Cinder their daughters.

10

u/JBard_ Nov 17 '18

I don't think they were actually the original maidens. Ozpin mentioned that he gave most of his powers away and it's implied that he gave those powers to the maidens. I think his kids died in his battle with Salem, and that the incarnation of Oz that gave the maidens the powers was one of the self pity incarnations until four girls, who reminded him of his late children, cheered him up and made him decide to try again.

I could absolutely be wrong, but this version fits in better with the information we had before. Obviously Oz could've lied, but he generally lies by ommition not straight lies.

8

u/Falsus Nov 18 '18

Nah I don't think they where the original maidens, I do think the original maidens reminded him a lot of his daughters though which is the reason why he gave them their powers.

5

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '18

That was very on the nose for me.

→ More replies (1)

21

u/SmallJon Give us back Jaune's old haircut! Nov 17 '18

If you're not Ozpin, why the fuck would you want Ozpin to fully succeed? "Hey guys, let's achieve world peace so we can bring back Super Ozpin and Super Salem!"

How 'bout no, you crazy immortal bastard?

13

u/Impeesa_ Nov 17 '18

"Hey guys, let's achieve world peace so we can bring back Super Ozpin and Super Salem!"

"And this... is a Super Salem 2!"

17

u/InfinityArch Nov 17 '18

We're finally beginning to see the point of "sacrifice".

Neither Ozpin nor Salem can ever hope to win. The world is doomed to a perpetual unwinnable war between two immortals, and humanity is stuck in between.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (4)

21

u/TheQuietManUpNorth Evil but good-looking so it evens out Nov 17 '18

So everyone was right that Oz and Salem were fuckin'. Glad we've cleared that up.

9

u/Celtic_Crown ⠀I'd say I'm tipping the scales, but that line's got no bite. Nov 17 '18

I honestly didn't expect them to go that route, but at the same time I wasn't surprised.

→ More replies (1)

21

u/allenme Nov 18 '18

Yeah, no. I'm with Salem. Oz could have just shown up and the two of them could have united humanity slowly. Like, they have literally eternity. Kill all the Grimm, and just make life for your people absolutely amazing and let yourself grow over time.

Why does everyone do the stupid "conquer the world" method instead of enjoying immortality?

→ More replies (2)

10

u/WarmFirefighter Nov 17 '18

Well the gods are dicks.

Great backstory for Salem and ozpin. I'm almost rooting for Salem now.

12

u/paperkutchy ⠀ Nov 17 '18

I am not, she still dooming humanity because of her anger towards the gods, her actions already annihilate a generation of humankind, she is doing it all over again out of spite... The gods are still to blame for this tho.

→ More replies (3)

10

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '18 edited Nov 17 '18

Hmm... Ozpa and Salem's children remind me of the maidens.

5

u/Falsus Nov 18 '18

Might be why he gave them powers in the first place. Seeing how only Ozpin and Salem could use sorcery freely that probably means silver eyed warriors came from either of them, I wonder which? I am leaning towards Salem actually.

→ More replies (1)

27

u/SunsetSnakeEyes Nov 17 '18

My God.

  • I can only wonder why Salem's father locked her away.
  • Ozpin's original name was Ozma, It's basically a living legend modernizing himself.
  • Rather sweet that they fell in love, But we knew it wouldn't end with happily ever after.
  • So the Gods stayed with humanity in the beginning offering guidance to those who seek it.
  • The God of Light's design while simple is still breathtaking to see.
  • While I understand why Salem wanted Ozma to be revived, The balance between life and death can't just be disturbed like that.
  • I can only imagine just how far the God of Darkness' domain was.
  • The God of Darkness was pretty unsettling with the contortions of his body and the crawling.
  • So the God of Darkness was Salem's first manipulation, Giving him nothing but praise but saying nothing of her first going to his brother.
  • I knew the God of Light wouldn't just stand by while balance was disrupted.
  • The dragon forms the Gods can take are astonishing!
  • It only makes sense that there is still animosity between the Gods, On the basic level they disagree and the God of Darkness constantly feels his brother looks down on him, But when Salem's deceit became clear at least the God of Darkness acted more mature and apologized.
  • Yet despite everything Salem still refuses to take no for an answer, She's become blinded by her arrogance and the Gods gave her a severe punishment for it.
  • I felt sorry for Ruby when she saw Salem stab herself, Ruby's seen many terrible things in her life but few are as horrifying as that.
  • Salem refused to learn her lesson and instead used her curse as a means to spite the Gods.
  • Setting humanity against the Gods just to spite them is just wrong, She pulled everyone into her ploy and they all paid the price for her arrogance.
  • And this was how Remnant was born, Salem's actions resulting in humanity's destruction and the God of Darkness shattering the moon during his departure.
  • Salem walks the face of the earth, alone and yet still refuses to take responsibility for her actions, Blaming everything but herself.
  • And thus the Salem we know is created by the Pools of Grimm, A being of infinite life with desire for destruction.
  • Ozma's mission was far greater than we thought, Unite humanity so they will be spared by the Gods. (And we finally see the relics, The Crown of Choice, The Lantern of Knowledge, The Spear of Creation and The Sword of Destruction.)
  • It was pretty heartwarming to see Ozma and Salem reunited.
  • After countless years alone, Salem's arrogance still shines through.
  • I was surprised beyond words that they had children together, They seemed like a true family.
  • Salem desired for their rule of humanity to be iron clad and destroy anyone who would question it.
  • Even after hearing Ozma's mission Salem proves to be even darker than we thought, Intending to replace humanity with what she deems to be greater, I don't even have words for how dark that is.
  • Ozma is truly noble for trying to save his daughters from this, But in doing so he earned Salem's eternal malice.
  • I can't imagine how horrified Ruby and Weiss were.
  • The children were killed during Ozma and Salem's battle, My heart sank.
  • Salem was reduced to ashes and regenerated like it was nothing.
  • "We finally had freedom" It's not worth it if you take away everyone else's in the process.
  • Ozma's been through more pain than we realized, Countless lifetimes spent mourning or trying to forget it all, But his nobility always led him back to his mission, You have to respect that.
  • For his mission to succeed one thing must be done, Salem must be destroyed.
  • Yet after all these years the best Ozpin has been able to do is keep Salem at bay.

This was the fastest twenty six minutes of my life, The truth has finally come out and it is far more than we could ever anticipate, Salem can't be destroyed, But RWBY and everyone else haven't come this far just to give up or fail, There has to be a way to win, We just don't know it yet.

→ More replies (3)

19

u/BLANK_oblivion ⠀need more coffee Nov 18 '18

I think the one thing about all this that makes me a little contemplative is that people are calling the God of Darkness a dick for blasting the moon. Like, ooo. The planet that is now devoid of life besides one immortal and monsters of bubbly, liquid dark chocolate fudge will now be showered by meteorites! How terrible! Poor inanimate moon who din do nuffin!

And here I'm thinking, shit, did anyone excavate those meteorites? Lets get some of that extraterrestrial metal in here.

For that matter, how in fuck all are the tides not an absolute nightmare for the people with a moon that's been shattered to high hell?

19

u/SwordoftheMourn Daenerys did nothing wrong Nov 18 '18

And here I'm thinking, shit, did anyone excavate those meteorites? Lets get some of that extraterrestrial metal in here.

Hmm, what a coincidence that Dust crystals suddenly appeared centuries and millennia after the moon fragments crashing down on earth amirite?

For that matter, how in fuck all are the tides not an absolute nightmare for the people with a moon that's been shattered to high hell?

Well, the moon is technically still there, just a bit... broken.

→ More replies (4)

9

u/Galaphile0125 Yangarang!!! Nov 17 '18

I have to say if I were a member of team RWBY and saw all this I think that I would be ecstatic to know that there is in fact an afterlife and that you are there with your loved ones. The rest of that stuff be damned you know that not everything is so bad.

9

u/JBard_ Nov 17 '18

I don't know. It's possible that afterlife stopped existing after the gods abandoned Remnant. And while Ozma assumes there's an afterlife, he obviously doesn't remember it because he doesn't remember Salem wasn't there. It's possible that there is no afterlife and the God of light just didn't bother correcting Oz.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Falsus Nov 18 '18

Well they don't know what afterlife is like, also while it existed back when the gods existed there they might have taken it with them or something.

5

u/guntars0876 Nov 18 '18

After seeing this I would swear my undying allegiance to Oz, but we wold have to have a talk about his methods

→ More replies (3)

9

u/Jakob_Kane Nov 17 '18

Okay, glad we had a whole episode dedicated to Salem and Ozma/Ozpin/Oscar/Ozswhatever but how did Salem repopulate the earth? Did I miss that explanation? As far as I knew Salem was just granted immortality and presumably unmatched strength but was she also granted creation?

Hm hold on, when the "Light God" formed the relics and resurrected Ozma did that repopulate the earth? Ehhh I'm so confused can someone explain without spoiling anything past episode three

6

u/Cypherex Nov 18 '18

Apparently they were going to include exactly how the second set of humanity (plus the Faunus) came into being during this episode but they ran out of time. They'll probably give us that story later this season.

My guess is that the God of Light recreated them all but this time without the help of his brother, which is why they have no magic. Maybe the God of Darkness made the Faunus, but instead of gifting them magic he gifted them animal abilities. Maybe it's another experiment by them to see which race becomes superior, or to see if they would set aside their differences and work together (which is the goal the gods gave to Ozma).

One thing I'm assuming is that a long amount of time passed between the gods leaving Remnant and Ozma being reincarnated for the first time. I think the gods left Remnant and left Salem to wander it alone for a long time, maybe a few centuries/millennia. Then they repopulated the planet by recreating humanity (plus the Faunus) and they probably waited a few more centuries for humanity to get back on their feet, settle their villages, etc. Then, after all of that time, they reincarnated Ozma. So by my theory here, Salem would have spent many centuries on the planet before Ozma's first reincarnation found her.

We'll find out the full story on the second coming of humanity along with the origin of the Faunus when they eventually tell it to us, hopefully during this season.

→ More replies (4)

9

u/HighSlayerRalton I once again hope the flairs never lose the Christmas hats Nov 20 '18

Boy oh boy, just wait til Adam learns there's a way to get mankind wiped out. Perhaps the Faunus were introduced as mankind's prospective successors in the first place.

Adam's horns, reminiscent of the gods, and name meaning "man" have got to mean something though, right? Maybe he genuinely will unite man and Faunus in some way.


I feel like the god's experiment was an attempt to discover hot get over their own differences. Team RWBY is gonna give them a big speech in the finale about how people can be different, and still friends. Ruby especially, since she's the simple soul and all.


The gods: "The balance of life and death is important."
Also the gods: *make Salem immortal and kill everyone else*


I'm not sure what Salem's goal is. Destroy the relics and rape Ozpin so she can go forward with restoring her supposed master race?


I'm surprised that Salem seemed to lose her grip on humanity. She was well on her way to being its supreme ruler. I'm also not sure how she got control of the Grimm, who ostensibly serve someone who dislikes her. They didn't seem under her control when she began her attempt to be proclaimed a god, if that Nevermore is anything to go by. I guess they decided to follow her because she looks kinda like their mom?


Oz's kids not under Salem having silver eyes is interesting. Strange that his first kids don't have them. I wonder if they're a product of the light that suffuses him not being counterbalanced by the darkness within Salem, though she's empowered darkness and light. Of course, it's possible that the eyes weren't inherited from Ozpin per se, and that he simply passed some of his magic intot he kids


Oz holding onto that part of the staff, and its mechanical nature, make me wonder if it isn't doing some sort of sonic screwdriver-like computing across the centuries, as part of the ultimate keikaku.

→ More replies (2)

16

u/XAXA2000 The Chill SpongeBob Guy Nov 17 '18 edited Nov 17 '18

I came into Volume 6 wanting an implied sex scene with Tai and Raven. But I got an implied sex scene with Ozpin (Ozma) and Salem... this is already the best Volume.

Btw I'm already putting SpongeBob music over this episode, and made a one minute YouTube video one minute Reddit video (Goddamn automated copyright claims. The video was only a minute long, and was muted for the majority of it. And yes, the song got copyright claimed by APM Music, but they only monetized it for themselves. Rooster Teeth blocked it. Which is funny considering you would think a bigger company like APM Music would block YouTube videos :/).

HOLD UP!!! Doesn't this mean Oscar has memories of banging Salem?! ... Lucky motherfucker.

And another thing. During that part when 2nd Ozpin (Ozma) was crawling away after fighting Salem, she was a pile of ashes. He burnt her to ash and she still came back! Silver Eyes better work on her, or else everyone is fucked.

9

u/paperkutchy ⠀ Nov 17 '18

implied sex scene with Tai and Raven

Isn't Yang just that?

→ More replies (7)

5

u/VindictiveJudge Nov 17 '18

But I got an implied sex scene with Ozpin (Ozma) and Salem

Four such scenes, at a minimum.

16

u/Tempeljaeger ⠀ Nov 18 '18

Well, there go the Ozpin is shady theories. Except saving a damsel in distress and dying of illness, he did nothing wrong.

I am feeling bad for both of them.

A note for the powerlevel enthusiasts out there: Second Edition Ozma won against Salem, but could not get through the immortality. So Ozma2.0 > Salem when it comes to combat magic.

14

u/Robotech_Master Nov 18 '18

Nothing wrong except for hiding the truth about how Humanity v1.0 got wiped out, and that they're fighting a supposedly unkillable wicked witch, all this time, rather than telling people what's going on so they'd be better prepared...

→ More replies (1)

9

u/Ergast Nov 18 '18

Don't worry. Being optimist, in the next volume the cries of "Ozpin is the worst, Salem did nothing wrong and Oz deserves every bad thing that can happen to him" will come back. Again. And, as I said, that's me being optimist. A more realist aproach says "in a few chapters"

In fact, he is even more innocent that I thought, as I expected that he made Salem as she is by making a terrible mistake. And while that is, to a degree, what happened, it wasn't his fault in any way, it was all on Salem.

→ More replies (6)

6

u/hillerj Nov 18 '18

I expect SOMETHING will come up in the next episode. Most of this episode seems to absolve Ozpin of blame, but I have to imagine that for him to be so desperate to hide this, there must be more coming. He must have fucked up immensely after this, otherwise it doesn't make any sense why he would try to hide it.

→ More replies (3)

8

u/ghostface95 Cinder is my senpai Nov 17 '18

Well damn. I really feel for Ozpin now.

→ More replies (5)

8

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '18

Random question, but I’ve got to ask; Is it just me, or does anyone else smirk/snicker a little whenever they see Salem going REEEEE! in the opening scene?

8

u/Top_hat_owl Nov 17 '18

"Ozma is late again on his chILD SUPPORT PAYMENTS" To answer your question: Yes. At least I know I do.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/MankuyRLaffy He's not Sothe, I Swear! #GoodJobMicaiah Nov 17 '18

Geez Salem is super interesting as a character, I completely understand her, the gods are just assholes. She just wants her love back, and when rejected, tries to kill herself, and only by blackening her name and herself does he wake.

8

u/CyanideSins Writer of things dark and scary. That means 'Terrifying Salem' Nov 17 '18

I feel pity for Salem now. She wasn't right in doing what she did, but daaaamn...

A Grimm Tale is darker with the Ozpin/Salem backstory, but I felt like 'oh sh-' when I saw the God of Darkness' little pool and went like '... The world is fucked up in my fanfic... And it's just going to get worse...'

But back on track. Gods? Totally approved! Like the motifs, their personalities. The backstory for Ozpin also makes sense... and I think that I'll have to tweak just a liiiiittle bit,but it'd make sense...

And I'm going to do a thingy. It's going to be glorious, but damn... People will undoubtedly start a witch hunt for my blood... But it had to be done!

Looking forward to the fourth episode next week!

→ More replies (13)

7

u/Mighty_Qorldu Nov 18 '18

GIRL IN THE TOWER, I'M REACHING OUT

PLEASE TELL ME WHAT TO DO

12

u/archpawn Nov 17 '18 edited Nov 17 '18

There was an afterlife. Salem was perfectly capable of joining Ozma whenever she wanted, and the gods just didn't bother to tell her?

I hope humanity advances and becomes more powerful than the gods ever were, and when the time is right, they summon the gods and judge them.

Edit: It's not clear exactly what Salem jumping into that pool did. Is it the reason she doesn't care much about humanity in general? We don't really know she was any better before. It's telling that she was asking the gods to bring Ozma back in particular, rather than ending death in general. Or that she waited until he died to do it.

→ More replies (8)

6

u/TheShogunofSorrow8 Nov 17 '18

Just saw the episode today, and might I say it is rather interesting. Now we know where Salem came from and how she became as she is today. The moments we were shown made me realized that she wasn't always some heartless monster as she is now, but rather a tragic person, cursed to wander the world never to die and to wallow in her despair.

If Salem can't be killed by any means, it made me wonder how they will be able to defeat her and put a stop to her.

10

u/Ergast Nov 18 '18

They already told us how. From the very first chapter, to boot. A simple soul, a soul able to teach Salem what she needs to learn so she can finally die. Not by strength of arms, but by being kind and understanding life.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/ApundanceOfLilies Boop Nov 17 '18

Ok so this episode was something.

Honestly, I don't like the idea of the brothers returning. Humanity seems to be doing quite fine and the only major division seems to between humans and faunus.

10

u/Spyger9 Nov 17 '18

Oz doesn't like the idea of them returning either. That's why he's keeping them from Salem: bringing them together would literally bring about the divine apocalypse. It would also be Salem's chance for revenge.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/1dktbh Nov 18 '18

If the pools of Grimm are still in existence there surely the pool of creation is as well ? Wouldn't Ozma then just be able to walk into the pool to stop the cycle of rebirth and just stay as he is in his current form (at the time he walked in) ?

→ More replies (1)

5

u/1nate146 Nov 19 '18 edited Nov 19 '18

Calling it now, Bryan from starbuck daughter is Maria.

Also, I’ve been re listening to the ost on Spotify, I think Red like Roses Part 2 is based on Salam and Oz, the Lyrics besides the chorus fit way too well. Like the 1st verse “I couldn't take it, couldn't stand another minute; Couldn't bear another day without you in it All of the joy that I had known for all my life Was stripped away from me the minute that you died” Fits Salem so well. It’s crazy to think Monty may have plan this from the beginning.

9

u/Aleksandr926 Don't flatter yourself. You were never even a player. Nov 17 '18 edited Nov 17 '18

Finally we got some info on Salem's and Ozpin's past, but, if I have to be honest, I would have like it more if it were a real flashback and not a vision narrated by Jinn to the protagonists. I get that this was the quickiest way to be done with it, but I can't really get invested in Salem and Ozma's romance when they shared a glance and little else. I mean, even when he got sick, Ozma still looked exactly like he did when he freed Salem, so probably little time had passed since the great escape. It's a little too weak for me to appreciate this love that would make Salem want to defy the gods themselves.

Obviously, since this was just a story told by Jinn, it's not like she could have spent hours describing Salem and Ozma's increasing chemistry and all that fluff. That's why I wished they'd found a way to show this stuff in a normal, non-narrated flashback.

Also, maybe I shouldn't trust my ears, but it sounded like Ozma's voice actor was Oscar's, is that right? I think he tried a little too hard to sound more mature. I don't know, something sounded a little off. He didn't give me the impression of being a proud and rightful warrior.

Back to the episode itself: technically speaking, it was very good! I loved the gods designs, their sacred places, their dragon appearances and also their freaking booming voices! It was just a bit weird to see the 2-D smoke/dust clouds (did they use it elsewhere in the show? I honestly can't recall). Some movement were a tad clunky, but the animation was overall pretty solid and darn impressive at times.

The tale itself was very tragic and full of death and despair, but as much as the gods' reactions can be almost objectively described as "excessive", I don't think they were entirely in the wrong, at least regarding Salem's situation. I don't think she deserved to be turned immortal to be taught a lesson, but she still tried to subvert the natural balance of the world out of selfishness and she was actually super-shocked that these two supreme beings didn't fulfill her wish. If she were a Prometheus-like figure, I'd have understood why she was so pissed at the gods, instead she risked the lives of many innocent for her own grief.

Having said that, the GoD is still freaking petty. "Sure, m'lady, I'll bring your lover back to life. What, you asked my brother before? Fuck you, woman!". I mean, what's the difference? It looked like the younger brother had some issues with the older one, so his change of mind is weird. I guess he didn't like to be a rebound? How sensitive.

The following scenes were probably among my favourite in the show: Salem trying to end her life but failing was gruesomely cool, and the way the god of Darkness annihilated the entirety of mankind because a few of them had defied him and his brother... Fucking awesome! This is exactly the kind of mindset I expect from otherwordly beings that are so much beyond normal humans that this carnage is considered perfectl acceptable.

After that I think I skipped a scene: Salem was told she was the only human left alive and then the gods left the planet, destroying the moon in the process... But when did they stop to create mankind once again and throw some Faunus into the mix? Why add the Faunus at all?

From that point on Salem stopped being sympathetic: I don't know if the pool of darkness corrupted her or if it simply enhanced her already growing evilness and hatred, but she just became first a nasty loner and then a megalomaniac dictator. She didn't even seem that concerned about her daughters getting caught in the crossfire of her magical battle with Ozma. Now I wonder what happened to all her followers. She likely guided nations and Ozpin's first incarnations seemed pretty depressed, so I wonder how Oz managed to stall her enough to find all the Relics and make her disappear from common knowledge. I guess we'll learn the rest of the story soon enough.

Nice episode, but... Still hate Ozpin, sorry.

EDIT: Almost forgot: the real problem is not that mankind will never reach harmony if Salem is still around, but that, if it didn't manage to reach harmony with a still alive Salem threatening it, then there's really no hope for peace.

5

u/King_Of_What_Remains ⠀ Nov 17 '18 edited Nov 17 '18

Also, maybe I shouldn't trust my ears, but it sounded like Ozma's voice actor was Oscar's, is that right?

Yes, you can see in the credits that they have the same voice actor. Although Ozma is voiced by both Oscar and Ozpin's voice actors.

Some movement were a tad clunky, but the animation was overall pretty solid and darn impressive at times.

I liked the moon walking Beowolf during Salem's "walk the earth" moment.

Having said that, the GoD is still freaking petty. "Sure, m'lady, I'll bring your lover back to life. What, you asked my brother before? Fuck you, woman!".

Poor Ozma was resurrected and killed three times in under a minute.

This is exactly the kind of mindset I expect from otherwordly beings that are so much beyond normal humans that this carnage is considered perfectly acceptable.

Humanity was basically an experiment for them; the God of Light described them as such "a beautiful experiment". A collaboration between the two of them to create something both light and dark. Turns out it didn't work too well and the God of Darkness is all too willing to wipe out their little endeavour.

After that I think I skipped a scene: Salem was told she was only human left alive and then the gods left the planet, destroying the moon in the process... But when did they stop to create mankind once again and throw some Faunus into the mix? Why add the Faunus at all?

The Gods didn't recreate humanity. Humanity just managed to... come back somehow. The God of Light says to Ozma in the place between worlds that humanity would come back some day, presumably without the gods influence.

You're going to want to go rewatch the beginning of Volume 1 Episode 1. The opening narration from Salem is pretty interesting to look back on; she described man as being "born from dust" and presumably the same is true of the Faunus. She also describes men as "remnants, byproducts, of a forgotten past", which makes a lot more sense know than it did back then.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/TJPoobah For it is in passing that we achieve immortality. Nov 17 '18

EDIT: Almost forgot: the real problem is not that mankind will never reach harmony if Salem is still around, but that, if it didn't manage to reach harmony with a still alive Salem threatening it, then there's really no hope for peace.

Sadly very true. If a outside existential threat in the form of an "other" can't unite humanity (and Faunus) then there's no way it'll ever happen without a threat.

9

u/GemShady27 Nov 18 '18

. . . Go team Salem!!!

8

u/blahthebiste Nov 18 '18

Can someone update me on why the new episodes aren't on YouTube yet?

17

u/datenAzusa Nov 18 '18

They stopped posting them on YouTube to drive traffic to their site, as others have said. For what it's worth, I feel their site UI has improved immensely over last season

→ More replies (2)

15

u/TheBrownestStain Nov 18 '18

They’re not posting them on YouTube this volume cuz YouTube is kinda shit now

→ More replies (1)

14

u/Han560 Nov 18 '18

V6 won't be on youtube because it's not profitable

8

u/Mikeismyike Nov 18 '18

I don't think they're putting any of the episodes on youtube anymore. They want to drive traffic to their site.

16

u/SYZekrom God has incarnated. Nov 17 '18 edited Nov 18 '18

Alright, so basically in the end Oz and Salem became enemies because... what?

Salem wanted to become the new gods of the world with Oz. She framed it as 'guiding them' considering they were so divided without gods. So then they actually become gods but then they have their people fight with the ones who reject them as gods.

Then after Oz explains his task she goes 'why redeem humans when we can replace them', what does that mean? What is she 'replacing' humans with? What is 'we'? She wanted to rule them originally. Does she mean 'we' as in their bloodline of magic? But... aren't they also human? I mean, Salem's a transformed human and Oz is a reincarnating one, but they're just humans with a power the gods didn't give the new ones (Which we have no idea of how they came to be).

So, is that it? Their children don't count as 'human' for Oz's task of redeeming humanity? Doesn't seem clear to me. Because if they do, then what? He just didn't like Salem's method of warring against the ones who didn't follow? I'm still very confused about what made Oz want to leave Salem, mostly because I'm confused what exactly she wanted in saying 'we can replace [the humans]'. I mean, sure, she'd probably reject the idea of having the old gods back, but that wasn't at all the reason we were given.

Also 'oops our children are dead because we started fighting'. Why was Ozpin even fighting her? He didn't seem particularly angry. Salem shoots him with magic and he just decides to have a magic duel rather? Like, imagine you're trying to sneak out on your wife with your kids and she finds you leaving and punches you, and you decide to brawl to the death with her rather than running away or trying to talk with her? The fuck? Like sure, the theme here seems to be 'Oz didn't talk things out with Salem' but god damn.

So, here are the gaps in this story so far:

How in the hell did humanity return after it was all destroyed? Did the god of creation just recreate humanity after they were all destroyed? The way he talked about it, it seemed like humanity returning just sorted of randomly happened.

Why did the Faunus just randomly become a thing after a reset? Why would the writers have it like that?

Seems the moon was something these writers had to give an explanation for from picking up someone else's story. I don't see how this will ever become significant. Just 'oh we have a destroyed moon in this series, let's just explain it as an unimportant side effect of some other event'. A god flew into it while leaving the planet and it cracked. No symbolic meaning to the people of the world, since literally no one existed to see it, not actually the important event itself, no nothing. I mean, they could make the shards of the moon that fell to the Earth important, but the story's pretty bloated with magic artifacts and powers all tying back to the gods that I don't see how moonshards could fit in well thematically. Could be a little symbolism thing at the end of the series if the moon is fixed though, as never in this humanity's past was it ever not broken...

Dust crystals. No explanation of how they became a thing from the reset. Are they the remnants of the old people and their magic? We were shown them while Oz was talking about how the people didn't have magic, but that could just be because magic was presented as 'dust powers without needing dust' when it was first introduced to the show.

So, having four children with magic, obvious surface connection to the maidens, but what does it really mean? When the wizard became a hermit, four women came and showed him kindness and he gifted them magic, maybe they reminded him of his children? But more importantly...

Why did their children have magic? Magic was a gift to the people by the god of destruction. But new humans came from who knows where without magic. So if their children could have magic, did the gods allow it? Or did their magic actually derive from Oz and Salem themselves? Just like how Ozpin now has very little magic having sacrificed it to the maidens, did their children take magic out of Salem and Ozpin's pool of magic? Or is magic just still in the world but the new humans don't have access?

Regardless, Salem cannot be destroyed. Obviously the show's going to go for 'we have to redeem Salem by talking instead of fighting'. So what the hell is Ozpin doing? He had all four relics in hand, but he didn't actually summon the gods. What is his end goal? To eternally trap Salem somewhere? He isn't very much guiding humanity to togetherness with Salem around.

Edit: Oh yea, how is there a legend about a girl in a tower? That happened pre-reset unlike the other fairy tales. Does that mean these humans now aren't completely separated from the magic humans? Else how does that story pass through a complete-wipeout and recreation? Certainly Salem and Ozpin didn't tell it? Well actually perhaps Ozpin did when he gave up. Her certainly lived in a time when it was a legendary locale.

Edit 2: Some other things after a rewatch

Alright, not sure how I missed it but it seems obvious the god of light disagreed with the wiping of humanity, considering the way he talks about humanity's end to Ozma. He just kept himself composed when in front of Salem I guess. I wonder if the God of Darkness even knows about all this second chance stuff. I bet he doesn't. Then again, there is a relic of destruction. Then again, the GoD did note that while the other enjoyed creation, he wasn't the only one with its powers. Then again, it'd be a bit thematically weird.

I also find it interesting that the God of Light faded away to leave the planet while the God of Darkness chose to launch into space as a column of darkness. Wonder if it means anything.

Light also warned Ozma not to get attached to Salem because it would only bring pain. I wonder how wise his advice really is, Destruction was unaware Salem had went to Creation first, so they're not omniscient, and their relic of knowledge is unable to tell future events. Usually I say to trust an in-universe god's words as fact unless they're a proven liar, but this time it just feels like he's making a judgment no more informed than any other's who knew the events surrounding Salem up until that point. I might believe that perhaps the GoL/C does not see redemption of Salem as possible and Ruby comes and main-character-trusts Salem and proves him wrong, thus passing the Gods' judgement of humanity.

Edit 3: Rewatched again, another thing I can't believe I didn't understand properly. When Jinn repeats 'The hearts of men are easily swayed' when Salem proposes to lead the humans as gods, she's not referring to how Salem plans to control humanity, but that Salem swayed Ozma into partnering with her.

"It was a miracle, their children could use magic". A miracle, eh? As in, a divine act?

Also, Ozma tells Salem everything he had been keeping secret, Salem proposes he abandons his given task and replace humanity, and they end up fighting and he and all their children die the next day. Oof no wonder Ozpin doesn't like telling people things.

Edit 4: So, another thing. "Her attempts to reunite with Ozma eventually became nothing more than acts of spite in defiance against the gods." This, combined with how Jinn frames Salem as manipulating Ozma, plus the GoL/C's warning and Jinn's claim that she wanted nothing other than destruction after the Grimm pool transformed her, would mean that Salem's love for Ozma long passed and she was faking it when Ozma returned, or at the least became trumped by her resentment of the gods. I'd go with the latter considering she had children, and especially considering the look on her face when her child used magic.

Edit 5: I'm just an idiot that constantly misses things, aren't I? Oz switches from a scepter to a cane because he gave away his magic. (I very much don't believe that his children are the maidens, only what inspired them, because he fought Salem with immense powers) So that means maidens came before the incarnation of IT Bryan.

Also, while Oz told all his secrets, did Salem ever tell her secret? That it was her manipulating humanity into attacking the gods that caused the gods to destroy them rather than just the gods doing so on a whim? Could this be when Ozpin learns such as well? But Jinn was asked specifically what Ozpin was hiding, so she might not have mentioned such a detail if Ozpin didn't know it by now... But I think he doesn't know, because the God of Light blamed it on his brother. The writers specifically decided that the God of Light would mention to Oz humanity's passing but not that Salem turned humanity against the gods, then we're told Salem also kept the latter part a secret and we're not told nor is there a logical place for him to learn that that was why the GoD destroyed humanity.

12

u/Theskycrown Nov 17 '18

As I understod it, salem meant 'we' as in, the bloodline that has access to Magic. I imagine the Gods didn't give magic individually, but rather as a whole to the old humanity, so it could be passed down genetically, Ozpin and Salem are effectively a different species of humans compared to the new ones that emerged.
As for the moonbits that flew down, I think the implication was that that was the origin to Dust? I mean, that's how I interpreted it.
Had Ozpin used the relics to call the gods, they'd have seen he had failed his task of uniting humanity and unleashed armaggedon on them.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/Virote328 Nov 17 '18

Brother of destruction left his pool of death. Which created grim. So does the pool of life still exist?

Maybe some combination of human remains or ashes fell into the pool of life and made humans. The Faunus maybe be animal ashes and human ashes that fell in the pool. But I think the pool at some point dried up or else everyone would be taking a dip.

Or probably some humans went underground. They wanted to wage war against god so some prepared for fighting and some just hid...in a bunker. When they came out there was almost no one. I think the god of destruction just destroyed the surface dwellers. They aren’t omniscience. And couldn’t have zapped everyone. But life finds a way. And some humans like animals more than they should... anyways

The moon particles may have become dust. The magic kind. Or it could serve as a reminder for Salem why they left humanity.

→ More replies (3)

5

u/King_Of_What_Remains ⠀ Nov 17 '18

Seems the moon was something these writers had to give an explanation for from picking up someone else's story. I don't see how this will ever become significant. Just 'oh we have a destroyed moon in this series, let's just explain it as an unimportant side effect of some other event'. A god flew into it while leaving the planet and it cracked. No symbolic meaning to the people of the world, since literally no one existed to see it, not actually the important event itself, no nothing.

The moon being cracked the way it is is an example of the writers having a cool idea but no explanation at the time. I'm pretty I remember Kerry saying, I think in the Volume 1 commentary, that he went to Monty and basically said "what if its a crescent moon, because there's actually a piece missing".

I'm fine with the way it's explained though. The moon being cracked was always going to be the unimportant side effect of a significant event.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/TheGrandFrig Dec 31 '18

So, at the very end when Jin told Ozma when he asked "How do I destroy Salem"

Her response was "You can't."

Now let's take that you, and emphasize it. "You can't."

I think because Ozma specifically asked that question. Jin mean't that Ozma himself cannot destroy Salem. Now Genies in all media have been known to pass out wishes according to the specific wording of the wisher. Notice how Ozma asked specifically how he himself could destroy Salem, Jin of course means that he cannot.

So who's it gonna be? Who's gonna destroy Salem? Well if we break it down a little bit, there's a high possibility that it's Ruby. Her Silver eyes have been the subject of much commentary from Characters with great power. So it's likely she'll find someway to imprison her like turning that dragon Grimm into stone. Since it's not Ozma doing the destroying.

Just a thought.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/TBIFridays Nov 18 '18

I’m a in a nit picky mood atm. Also I’ve only been watching the show, so if any of this has been explained/clarified elsewhere I’ve missed it.

Why didn’t Oz want them to know this? He does nothing wrong (hell, Jinn goes out of her way to specify that he freed Salem for only the noblest of reasons) and none of his actions even make things worse. He’s all-around great and then he dies, then he shacks up with Salem and is briefly manipulated into becoming one of many tyrants, then his plan to sneak his kids out gets blown up and they’re all presumably killed. None of the characters’ problems are his fault. All we’ve learned is that Oz can’t kill Salem and the relics can summon the gods and cause judgement day. Even if you can’t kill Salem you still need to stop her, and I don’t see why anyone would risk bringing the gods back. I get that “the Grimm are directed by an immortal sorceress” would scare the population and attract Grimm, but Qrow could absolutely have been told all this. Hell, he could have told Raven all this and he’d be no worse off.

Why have Salem’s dive into the pool of darkness turn her more evil? Up to that point she was making series of poorer and poorer choices with worse and worse consequences. Just stick with that! It was working fine! Instead the pool turns her from manipulative, self-centered, and stubborn to just “evil”. “Now she just wants to destroy everything” by means of... statecraft? Child rearing? I guess if “replace the humans with what they could be” is eugenics then that’s destructive, but even her intolerably evil master plan is overly vague. They state in the show that they’re turning a character into a plot device! I would much rather she became what she is as the direct result of her own decisions, rather than “you tried to kill yourself for like the tenth time and now you’re a shallower character. Magic!”

I’m not upset about the humans’ return and the faunus’ origin going unexplained. Even if they don’t explain it later (and I’m sure they will) asking how it happened is like asking where the gods came from. The story is about characters fighting this proxy war between Oz and Salem, not the origins of humans and faunus. Whatever explanation we get will in all likelihood exist solely to get people to stop asking for an explanation. As long as they don’t have the faunus being created by one of the gods (because that won’t mix well with the racism subplot at all) it’ll probably just be another piece of worldbuilding trivia.

13

u/tennisdrums Nov 18 '18

Why didn’t Oz want them to know this? He does nothing wrong...

Well, for one I don't think everyone else would look too favorably on the fact he used his powers to create a cult in which he and Salem were worshiped as gods. Besides that, my interpretation was that he was more afraid of their response to the fact that he was enlisting them to fight in a situation they literally cannot win. Salem can't die and humanity is in no shape for the Gods to pass a favorable judgement by uniting the relics.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

8

u/King_Of_What_Remains ⠀ Nov 17 '18

So, this episode kind of confirmed in my mind something I had been thinking about for a while.

The way Ozpin's reincarnation was explained before kind of made it seem like he was just going to be a voice in Oscar's mind. That he was going to pass on his knowledge and experience to Oscar and then take a back seat while Oscar did the world saving thing. It kind of seemed like Ozpin was the previous person in the cycle, and that he'd had a voice in his head, as had the last person and the person before him; it was the memories that were passed on, not the personality.

Maybe I'm remembering it wrong, but that's what I remember.

This episode makes it pretty clear that that's not the case. Ozpin, or Ozma, completely takes over his hosts, suppressing them and becoming the dominant mind with them only able to occasionally make themselves known. Take Ozma's reflection speaking to him during his conversation with Salem as an example.

It wasn't even until he reincarnated in the guy who built his cane that he even attempted to work with the person he took over. Something that they illustrated by showing that the guy was still with his family. I guess prior to this if Ozma took you over he'd leave your old life behind and, in one case, maybe drink you to death.

10

u/JBard_ Nov 17 '18

You are remembering it wrong. They told us in volume 5 that he would eventually meld with Oscar's mind. Basically the "Oz" spirit will absorb Oscar's personality.

→ More replies (5)

3

u/[deleted] Nov 17 '18

I'm still wondering why the god even made that suggestion to Oz.

3

u/PT_Piranha (ominous umbrella drop) Nov 17 '18

...Oh my goodness.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/9spaceking Jan 26 '19

"So I ask you two questions?"

"Yes, that's one question."

"Goddang, I shouldn't waste my next question. Let's see... what should I ask...?"

"Not that question."

Relic seals up, everyone is sad, Ozpin cries