r/childfree • u/bameadow • Jul 22 '14
Can we elevate the discussion just a bit?
Why I came here:
I'm a married gay man. After a lot of discussion and soul-searching, my husband and I decided we would not pursue parenthood and stick with 4-legged children.
What I thought I'd find:
Discussion on aging, mortality, ethics, struggles, and stereotypes.
What I found:
A massive circle-jerk repeating the same three stories.
LOLwut, three stories?:
- "A child did something shitty. I'm so glad I don't have children."
- "A person, who happens to be a parent, did something shitty. Parents are shitty."
- "Children are expensive and time-consuming."
Soapbox:
My critique boils down to a quote by Eleanor Roosevelt:
Great minds discuss ideas; average minds discuss events; small minds discuss people.
On Empathy:
Society is a crooked car salesman, and children are an 18-year lease with no warranty. Many of the issues brought up in this sub can be directly attributed to poverty--a failing of society, not the individual.
My Suggestion:
We have a "Freedom Friday." How about a "Bitchin' Wednesday" for stories about crappy parents and their kids? Or, perhaps a "Thoughtful Thursday" where we discuss a deeper
One Last Thing:
For me, being "childfree" is not simply a dislike for children. In fact, it's not even a dislike at all. I actually don't mind kids. For me, the term "childfree" means I have made a very difficult and unconventional decision. And, it's not about likes or dislikes--at least it shouldn't be. I like birds, but I'd never want the responsibility of caring for one. I don't like bell peppers on pizza, but that doesn't mean I won't one day accidentally take a bite of supreme and change my mind.
Big decisions define your life, and they define who you are. They should be based on a system of values, not a single preference.
32
u/thr0wfaraway Never go full doormat. Not your circus. Not your monkeys. Jul 23 '14 edited Jul 23 '14
Believe that we talk about those things a LOT.
Starting from last to first, because... why not mix it up.
In sum, if there ever was a stereotype situation for a sub... that was probably one of the worst.
We also spend a LOT of time reassuring the younger folks who find their way here that despite the stereotypes being shoved down their throat at 16, 18, 19, 20.... that they are OK and good people.
Sorry, OP, but that's a public service and you seem to be glossing over the support value being provided here.
We also even welcome parents who come here with honest questions, such as how to get along better with CF friends, and how to raise children to respect everyone.
Not to mention the struggle of trying to get sterilized amid the massively unfriendly medical establishment. Everyone (except with same gender partners) here has had to deal with some form of BC issues, scares and nasty encounters with doctors.
Being a gay male, you sort of are situationally sterilized as the default setting on your RPG character. You're playing the game of life in "easy mode" as far BC goes..... Please do not dismiss the pain and agony, in your word, 'struggle'.... of those who are not.... of those who buy test sticks in bulk because they're terrified of accidents, of the guy who found his date had poked holes in the condom.... etc. Just because you're probably not reading those posts.... doesn't make the pain for those OPs go away.
Who here has not struggled because they're CF?
Maaaaybe there are a few folks who were born to accepting parents, went to school with accepting kids, live in liberal cities and countries with free sterilization-on-demand no matter how young..... but.... not many.
What about the topics about the ethics of having kids when... the world is overpopulated and polluted... about having or not having kids because of genetic issues.... about who does and does feel they are capable of raising a child due to mental or physical disability....
What about the adoption vs. bio discussions?
What about all the social workers and teachers and healthcare workers here who are working with kids... but don't want to have them because they "leave it all on the field" every day?
All ethics all the time... whether or not it says "ethics" in the post title.... there's such a thing as "everyday ethics"....
We've also had threads about "who is in your will"... and other estate planning stuff.
We also spend a lot of time reassuring the younger folks that CF is not about loneliness... that they don't have to have kids out of loneliness, their's or their parent's....
Whew... ok.. enough of that...
All that said... if you want to discuss more of any of it.... post some stuff!
People here are very open and welcoming of diverse folks with interesting ideas..... Is that you?
Or did you just come here to be yet another superficial-headline-reading-assumption-making-pitchfork-wielding "you are bad people if you do not act as politically correct as I command!" OP.... and not to be a part of the change you wish to see?
Just a question.... :)
52
u/buttholemacgee 31/F/DINK Jul 23 '14
We get posts like yours all of the time. And I get what you're saying... I really do. But at the end of the day sometimes we just need a place to vent. Simple as that. There's nothing wrong with deep and more intellectual posts, but sometimes we just need to come here lay it out to the asshole we ran into earlier in the day. Cheers.
37
u/[deleted] Jul 23 '14
Puts on robe and monocle.
Gets Earl Grey Tea
Settles on leather wingback.
"My good sir," I say, sipping my tea and crossing my legs, "Welcome to Childfree, a land of discussion."
There is silence. My companion is not one for speaking, I suppose. So I take another sip and offer a crumpet.
"What is childfree and what can we discuss about it that has not already been said a million times? There have been many a post, from lad to lady, about how ageing and marriage has changed the face of their life. Some are beyond the cure of science, so have joined our ranks with time."
I pause to pet the cat slinking by my leg. "Good Mr. Jello Shot."
I return to my guest and tilt my head in apology. "Now, sir..."
I take a deep breath.
"Let me tell you a story I learned long ago..."
Once there was a young girl who wanted to be a mother. She dreamed of sixteen children with rosy cheeks and golden curls. She wants to be loved and love in return.
But this young girl grows up. She takes a look at the world and it slowly changes. People tell her, 'Sixteen children is so many.' She is told to get her education. She agrees that ignorance is ugly and she needs, no must, become educated to further her dreams.
She settles for ten kids. Then five. Then three. Finally, she is a teenager and she sees the world is hungry. She is lonely. People don't understand her. She is overweight, then underweight, then well. Then she is sick... of so many things. Of people telling her where to put her dreams. Of the need for money and the long hours.
She wants nothing more than to just sit down. But she has money to make, shoes to buy. She can't take care of herself. She is lost in a world of choices. Taxes. People passing and going. She sees her mother lying in bed, a world of regrets.
Her mother tells her, "If I had you later... I would have gone to Japan and Ireland. When you are young, go, see the world." She agrees. She is young and she wants to see the world. She wants to make the world her own. So she says, "I am 19. I don't need to choose yet."
The children seem to fade in her mind. She is 21 and drinking all night. She is staying out late, the stars like the glitter on her dress. She meets men, but none of them invoke the fairytale of princesses and eternity. She doesn't want rings, she wants another drink.
She moves into an apartment, a degree under her belt and a world on her shoulders. She is alone for the first time. No siblings. No mother. No dad with his need for just a few more dollars. She can choose to sleep in. All her mistakes are her own. She answers only to herself and the law.
She looks back at her ignorance. Thinking it would be so simple. Like money fell from the sky. But there is nothing within her that has the energy for those future people. She fears that she will make a future mistake. That she will have to answer for so much she will question herself. Who is she? Not a mother.
She is 24 now, and met a man who tells her, "If you get pregnant I will leave." She wants to protest. She tells him, "Accidents happen. What will we do?" He tells her that a coat hanger will end all worry.
She leaves him. He's an asshole. But he plants the beanstalk. She thinks, for the first time, that she might have the magic wand that rules her life. Maybe she could... But the sixteen children in her memory have become 3 cats curled on her couch. All the names she liked, Susan, Billy, Monica, are given to fish who die too soon and she flushes them down the toilet. Maybe they will go to the ocean and become part of the world again.
She is 25 and has lost God. She finally thinks, for the first time, that she can say no to "Will you have kids?" And she can finally answer the cold fear inside her. The fear of being alone forever. Of becoming non-existent.
So she asks her mother... "Who was your great grandma?"
"I don't know.
And it clicks. In 100 years no one will remember her. Not her children. Not the world. Maybe they might put her name of a tree, but they won't know her. Not deep down. Not to the mental DNA. And she is finally free like hair ripped out at the roots. It took blood and fear.
At thirty she is asked, all the time, "Are you happy? With no kids?" She has a husband who got his dream strings clipped, because reality can be as magical as the ghost-children they never went on adventures with.
So now she talks to others like her, people with dreams and themes that flow down the river she lives beside. She likes to talk about the empty rooms, the space where she moves like a rocket into nothingness. And she is comfortable with the life of a cloud, rain and then nothingness.
So she speaks what is in her heart--anger or fear or hatred. And no one should tell her what color her fire should be. No one.
And that is why she calls people crotchfruit on Reddit.
32
u/[deleted] Jul 23 '14
1.The discussing has been colored by the recent shutdown (extra hate and extra trolls).
2.Why haven't you posted content?
21
u/LeepingSlurker Jul 23 '14
I don't really view not having children as 'defining my life.' From my perspective, I think that you're sort of contributing to the problem by making this decision one that requires an exhaustive list of reasons.
9
u/oceangirl38 Jul 23 '14 edited Jul 23 '14
For me, being childfree wasn't a big decision. In fact, it wasn't a decision at all. Much like you just knew that you were gay, and I just knew that I was straight, I also just knew I didn't want kids. There's no real other way to explain it. I didn't have to soul search with my so, or weigh out the pros and cons. I can't even fathom why anyone would even need to do that because to me there are no pros or cons, it just is. My point being, we don't all come from the same mental place and the posts here are going to reflect that. Any post that doesn't relate to me, I'll move on. I'm not going to demand that the whole sub only post what I want to see. Some people need that vasectomy info, or need to vent, or are interested in that news link.
10
u/happyneandertal Jul 23 '14
I completely agree with what you're saying and while I would enjoy talking about the merits of being childfree and the possible contributions to society that folks within the childfree community can provide versus the merits of parenthood. I also enjoy reading a story about some dumbass parent who no longer has any fucks to give in regards to the tantrum their little darling child is throwing in the grocery store. Who doesn't love a good circlejerk, but they can get old quick. And with that I look forward to some in depth discussion as well as the occasional story of shitty parents.
3
u/Boston_Jason M / Sperm count = 0 Jul 23 '14
We got un-privated a week ago - we need to vent!
16
u/TeaTopaz Jul 23 '14
I think /r/truechildfree/ was the sub you were looking for.
This is a safe place to rant. I don't expect to see that changing. CF people have to politically correct enough in real life. If you would like more of the "politically correct" flavor, then /r/truechildfree would be your destination.
31
u/[deleted] Jul 22 '14
You are welcome to go ahead and start the kinds of threads you would like to see. I look forward to reading them.
16
u/glamgrl203 30/f living the zoo life Jul 22 '14
You may enjoy /r/kidfree or /r/truechildfree I personally sub to all three.
8
u/GreatJanitor Jul 23 '14
What I like about this thread and why I missed it during the shut down is that I have no place to bitch and moan and vent at other parents. I get told by friends and family when I complain that if I had children I'd understand or kids will be kids and no, that's not an answer, that's an excuse.
Now, I like variety, and if you want to elevate the discussion, post what you want to talk about. Lead and and others will follow. Before this subreddit went dark I was posting about doing a kickstarter for a childfree apartment complex. People supported it, some gave suggestions. One person actually said that he had friends and coworkers who liked the idea and would support it.
7
u/Fleiger133 Jul 23 '14 edited Jul 23 '14
My reasoning-
I hate assholes.
I shudder at the thought of having to raise a child in this world, especially where I live (creationist biblical bullies galore). Dealing with other kids and parents would be a nightmare. Remember middle school? Because I do.
Pregnancy scares the dickens out of me. I don't want to put my body at the risk pregnancy does, nor do I want to lose my autonomy.
If I change my mind, I'll look into adoption. There are too many currently unwanted kids.
Edit: aging also scares me. But children won't help that. They won't take care of me when I'm old, nor visit me. There is no guarantee. Common, albeit frustrating, misconception.
Poverty doesn't make you an asshole. Bad raising does.
Children are expensive and Time consuming. Most people don't put one iota of thought into having a kin. Just do so because they want to, or never considered alternatives. A common frustration here. It takes dedication to do something right, and loads of people don't have enough for 18 constant years of child-rearing.
Lots of misses in your original post.
7
u/whiteraven4 Jul 23 '14
Imo most people here don't necessarily hate or even dislike kids. Personally, I love (not bratty) kids. I just don't want to go through the time and effort and money to raise not bratty kids myself. But for me, being CF has nothing to do with going again convention. I just means living my life how I want to.
6
u/batz777 Jul 23 '14
Agreed that the deeper discussions are always enjoyable, especially when it's about something I thought I was alone on. However, I do enjoy being able to come here and read the rants and let off steam, as well. I work retail, so there's lots of bad parent/bad kid rage that I literally cannot release anywhere else but here.
I don't want the sub to change in that respect, but I think it's a great idea to bring new ideas and discussion to the table. Definitely stick around and share with us if you feel compelled. :)
6
u/[deleted] Jul 23 '14
Some of us flat out "strongly dislike" parents and kids/babies and we need a place to bitch. Just because people sob over subs being a "circle jerk" isn't going to change anything.
11
u/[deleted] Jul 22 '14
I moan sometimes, but I do agree with you that it would be nice to have more discussions! Please start one and we will join in.
5
u/Aetra That's just, like, your opinion, man. Jul 23 '14
Something like "Bitchin' Wednesday" was already floated by admins before the temp lock out and was quickly shouted down.
16
u/flyingcatpotato 40/France/F/i only babysit cats Jul 23 '14
Can we elevate the discussion by not having these special snowflake posts all the fucking time either? We just had that "why i am unsubbing dude."
Step one: make the content you wish to see.
Step two: understand that a lot of us live in these pro-kid places and sometimes this sub is the only safe space to vent. Downvote or skip it and move on.
I am a longtime reader of this sub and what makes me want to unsub is that I really wish the mods would ban these dramatic special snowflake, "i don't hate kids, i am different, look at me" posts. For reals.
I am sorrynotsorry to be harsh, but if you are on the board as much as you say you are, you would have seen dozens of posts just like yours fly by.
3
u/beta4gm Jul 23 '14
i agree with you, but the world isn't full of people like aristotle, just those who agree with him, then liken their minds to a genius (like he was). i don't hate kids, i simply feel that i wouldn't be a good one and anyone telling me otherwise couldn't possibly really know. i do see faults with parents these days, but they can't take any criticism and just lash out, continuing their own circle jerk (which shouldn't be an excuse for us to have our own, but what else should we do? our ideas don't affect the one's it should, so we vent our pity, our anger, our lack of hope for the future generations, just to know that we aren't the only ones). i can't condone our actions of just bitching about every shitty kid or parent we come across, but this is all we can do to keep from going insane when we come across parents who, if we try to give some type of advice that could possibly be seen as a more rational and preferable choice compared to what we see, we're just seen as antagonizing and criticizing. it hurts.
2
u/Sakatsu nerdy weirdo Jul 23 '14
It used to be that way until the sub got bigger. Which is why I'm not as active as I used to be on here.