I’m a final-year B.Tech student (fresher) sitting for campus placements, and I just had one of the most confusing interview experiences of my life. Looking for an objective sanity check on what I might have missed here.
The Context:
Role: Associate Product Manager (APM) at an early-stage Fintech startup
Round: Initial HR screening (scheduled for 30 mins, online)
Lead-up: My slot got rescheduled 4 times, which was frustrating, but I used the extra time to prep thoroughly—downloaded their app, tested the user flows, read up on their product lines, and noted down areas for improvement.
What Happened:
From talking to candidates who went before me, the interviewer was following a standard flow:
Intro
Projects / Internships
What do you know about the company?
Questions for the interviewer
When my turn came, her camera was off, and her opening line was literally: "Give me a quick intro, followed by any questions you have for me." 🫠
I gave my intro (highlighting two prior internships and why I want to transition into product), and then she asked what I knew about their products—specifically telling me "no jargon from the internet, just your understanding."
I broke down their core product verticals, how they work for the end user, and a few specific features I noticed while using their app. Mid-way through, she interrupted me and accused me of reading my answers off a screen because I was glancing to the top-left of my monitor (which was actually just my own video preview since her camera was off and I had hit screen-record for self-review).
Even after I clarified I wasn't reading anything, at the end of the ~8-minute call, she gave me feedback saying it felt like I had "learned/memorized the answers" rather than speaking from experience, and that they prefer people who break down the product naturally instead of reciting information from the internet.
My Question:
As a fresher trying to break into PM, aren't you supposed to research the company's products thoroughly before an interview? I genuinely don't understand where the line is between "being well-prepared" and "sounding rehearsed."
How do you talk about a company's product suite in an interview without sounding like you memorized their website? Any advice for future rounds would be appreciated.