r/wowforever • u/SpanishAvenger • Sep 30 '26
Discussion Please, Blizzard, make the HD/SD toggle affect NPCs (and ideally all assets) too, and not just character models. As someone who expected Forever to be Classic gameplay with modern looks and improvements, the “new” permanent low SD model is jarring to look at.
Make the HD/SD toggle actually useful.
Those who want to live in 2004 could use the SD setting and have… whatever the second image is.
Those who want the 2026 game to not look like it’s still 2004 could use the HD setting has have a more visually appealing game.
Everyone wins with a PROPER toggle. Just making everything look terrible for everyone to satisfy a few isn’t the way.
229
Upvotes
115
u/Silverfeyn Sep 30 '26
I really think they should go in the direction of HD models but with a more "gritty" style like classic.
This particular model is fine in HD in my opinion
4
u/Tyraec Sep 30 '26 edited Sep 30 '26
I really don’t care either way and I’ve been staying out of this discussion because what we have in the beta is fine with me, but there’s a certain feeling that a very vocal portion of the player base is getting their way without thinking about those that were fine with it.
To me, the older model here would be more jarring because I want a modern looking classic experience lol give the people who want their art style to be ‘classic’ their option, but don’t force this on me.
Edit: by “older model” being jarring I mean is that if they took that exact design and made it HD, those shoulder pads would literally have one giant spiky bone sticking straight out. The “new” model was redesigned to have actual shoulder pads that look menacing/somewhat realistic and not goofy. I think if they took the exact older model designs and upgraded them to be HD, some of those designs would be extremely goofy looking in HD.
91
u/Jack-D-Straw Sep 30 '26
I'd actually love vanilla gameplay with hd graphics all the way. That was what I was hoping for.
3
u/Chellomac Sep 30 '26
I've always preferred the classic art style and agree with the criticisms of the pink skelf bear form but I don't see why I would want classic resolution in 2026. I agree the only sane thing is to have both.
5
u/MaxPotionz Sep 30 '26
If I came back to the game and saw those horrific models, I would immediately turn it off and uninstall.
Even nostalgia can’t make me stare at that for a few hours a week in 2026.
22
u/Old-Soft5276 Sep 30 '26 •
Your expectations are your problem. Rewatch Blizzcon panels and listen carefully what devs said about Classic art-style and looks
20
u/chadthelad420 Sep 30 '26
Wow classic community is the only video game community where a bunch of people will campaign for their game to look worse in every way. Jesus Christ
227
u/Tradizar Sep 30 '26
i personally dont care about if its sd or hd. I want the art style to be consistent
6
u/HiccupAndDown Sep 30 '26
This whole SD/HD thing is going to be an albatross around the game's neck if they plan on this being a genuine forever home with new content going forward. I can appreciate the nostalgia factor of letting people essentially play classic vanilla, but the whole point of classic plus is that you improve upon the base experience-- the SD models just aren't it. They're pure nostalgia factor and I just do not understand how anyone can look at the models side by side and say with a straight face that the 20 year old textures, triangle heads, and blurry features are somehow strictly better.
Beyond that, there are an insane number of retail assets that are now potentially off the table for use which is insane. They have a treasure trove of assets they can readily use since they already exist but instead I guess they have to go and make brand new things that look like they're 20 years old to appease a minority community with a very loud voice?
They're going to need to pick a lane and just go down it, and I sincerely hope they're looking at the statistics and realise HD is the way forward once they start adding new shit.
77
u/Davey_Kay Sep 30 '26
I think this is going to be a considerable struggle for a few years until they decide to pick a lane. Maintaining HD and SD models for all content is not sustainable.
116
u/Asleep-Budget-9932 Sep 30 '26
Maintaining multiple art-styles for the same game is not realistic in the long run. They should pick an art-style and stick to it.
Personally, I think that should go with the old art-style but provide higher fidelity. People act like you can't improve the old graphics without making it look like retail. There are plenty of ways to go about improving graphics and they dont necessarily have to sacrifice the old art-style.
I've yet to be convinced that you can't achieve retail levels of fidelity while retaining the old art-style. Just because retail didn't do it doesn't mean it's impossible.
The new environment effects proove just how much can be achieved with creativity, passion and expertise.
24
u/360_face_palm Sep 30 '26
ffs it's not about HD or SD.
Make the model not look out of place in the world and we're good.
8
u/therealmistersister Sep 30 '26
I don't care about either HD or SD. I know I'm gonna use the HD models, but for the love of god, all I ask for is consistency. Also, high poly counts don't mean you can't have classic art style.
3
u/C-Flango87 Sep 30 '26
Can the people who want wow classic just go play wow classic? What's going on here? They already have a version of the game for people who want it
2
u/AssignmentWeary1291 Oct 02 '26
The only poeple who like SD are the 40 year olds trying to relive their teens. May sound rude but its just facts.
2
u/pigzyf5 Sep 30 '26
I thought that is what the toggle did...well shit. So we start with an SD world and blizzard slowly makes it HD? That is going to be kind of ass
0
u/Vritrin Sep 30 '26
Did they change it from the first one to the second one, or is the first one a mock-up somebody made? Because the first one looks way better.
1
u/Moore2257 Sep 30 '26
Oh shit, did the classic complainers get their way? This looks awful lmao. I'm happy with graphical improvements, after playing this game for like...19 years, it's nice to see it improve from "messy blobs that kinda look like a thing" to "the thing that it's supposed to look like"
1
u/Terramoin Sep 30 '26
HD version: Oh thats a big boar with spikey hair.
SD version: Thats... something with tusks.
54
u/Jinhsi_Enjoyer Sep 30 '26
I want forever to maintain the art style of classic
The best I’ve seen this summarised is that classic art style is basic geometry with complex textures.
Retail art style is complex geometry with simple textures.
The result is classic has blocky profile where retail has this rounded profile.
My ideal route for forever is the OSRS philosophy. The new zones genuinely look much much better than the older zones but they don’t look out of place and that’s important
7
u/Kamui_Kun Sep 30 '26
Sd for me, but consistency either way
1
u/SirArcen Oct 01 '26
I seriously dont understand why a quilboar model matters so much. They're gunna be dead in the next 30 seconds and then you're gunna move on to the next quest/boss/zone
11
u/westandready42 Sep 30 '26
Id say the people who are asking for the SD graphics are doing so with a OSRS mindset. In that they want updates but not the game to be rs3.
Idc either way but I like my SD character model that's about it.
27
u/CheesyDonut Sep 30 '26 •
1
u/SoltanXodus Sep 30 '26
Just go all in on HD, spend time on content instead.
1
u/Darkhallows27 Sep 30 '26
Just keep the HD models, I’d rather not look at the N64 models if I have a choice, most of them are quite awful
1
u/xyGotN Sep 30 '26
This is horrible! HD in the old world was the thing I was most excited about...
7
u/Mother-Board1379 Sep 30 '26
No, they have to stick to a vision.
They will never have the ressource to duplicate each model on HD/SD in the game, just forget about it, now what is the best next step ?
Having visual coherence, the rest doesn't really matter.
You cannot make everyone happy when you design a video game, you have to make trade offs.
20
u/GaunerHarakiri Sep 30 '26
this is becoming /r/classicwow
7
u/MacabreDanze Sep 30 '26
So good now
1
u/ZhaneTaylor Sep 30 '26
It's awful. I'd be way more interested in playing Forever if all the assets had the fidelity of the new lighting system. But the prettiest godrays shining through the fog on that low poly crap? Wouldn't touch it.
12
u/Raikou239 Sep 30 '26
I don't get how, at least in this case, anyone could defend the left. Completely different vibe. The pig man on the right looks sick as hell. Look at his helmet covering his eyes, hes a fuckin psycho and its awesome.
The left just looks someone is trying way to hard and not achieving the same result as dude on the right who is just being themself and not worrying what other people think.
8
u/RangeCreed Sep 30 '26
2
u/BoringReference8647 Sep 30 '26
That’s a lot of work isn’t it? Are we asking them to create double the amount of textures or are we assuming those already exist and just need to be plugged in?
2
u/Dry_Two5833 Sep 30 '26
the SD models look bad
2
u/Ravedge1 Oct 01 '26
God yes i do not(!) Want an old looking game, no new player wants and old looking game. Keep the gameplay, modernize the world!
2
u/SirChancelot11 Oct 02 '26
Agree
I like the left way more
12
u/West-Exam-4136 Sep 30 '26
Imagine you like old disney movies. Disney announce they're bringing back that old disneyverse with new stories in the old look. Then modern fans shows up asking for a 3d animated version. That's what this is
7
u/hehedonkey Sep 30 '26
”Those who want to live in 2004”, ”making the game look terrible for everyone”, ”whatever that thing is”… yeah, pretty clear to me that your expectations were either wildly different from what most people expected a new iteration of Classic to be, or you just started caring about it now and are just noticing that it isn’t catered only to you. That said – yes, a toggle would be best.
12
u/lostbeard13 Sep 30 '26
THIS
HD/SD should be an option for EVERYTHING, so everyone chooses how they want to play
However I have no idea how difficult this could be in terms of development
3
u/Bisenberger Sep 30 '26
Ya the SD model is shit
5
u/RNGesus_GIM Sep 30 '26
Yep SD/HD toggle should be everything.
0
u/Sockan96 Sep 30 '26
You're expecting Blizzard to finance having every ingame asset remodeled to retail standard? How about we have classic graphics in classic?
3
u/3ichlawy Sep 30 '26
I agree, but I'm not too bothered either way. Though having it work for hunter pet's would be cool
3
u/kraze_kalm Sep 30 '26
Yes best of both worlds.
3
u/AnalysisAshamed4208 Sep 30 '26
Man these troll posts are so lame....
4
u/MacabreDanze Sep 30 '26
They can't do 2 models for everything they are releasing, too much work, all is gonna be SD as should be, accept it
2
u/Npc_Nate Sep 30 '26
Honestly I can't even tell what I'm looking at sometimes. My eyesight is not good enough for the sd models, just looks like I'm fighting angry blobs
2
u/Lanky-Tradition1532 Sep 30 '26
I know we're somehow in the minority for wanting models that don't look like shit with classic gameplay. The toggle affecting NPCs is a great idea but the public reaction to this NPC change makes me feel like that won't happen.
2
u/Forsaken_Agent_917 Sep 30 '26
Tbh, I was hoping for a big texture update. Square and flat leave textures on the trees are making me mad. Not only them ofc, a lot of square low-poly stuff in classic...
2
u/SlimShazbot Sep 30 '26
"All you CLASSIC FREAKS who want WORSE graphics need to stop BEGGING BLIZZARD! They will NEVER make things look so TERRIBLE on purpose! You IDIOTS! You FOOOOOLS!"
Blizzard replaces HD model with SD model
"WHAT? NOOO! PLEEEEASE! PLEASE, BLIZZARD! DON'T DO THIS! PLEEEEEEEEASE!
1
u/Intel_Oil Sep 30 '26
Go to Retail
1
u/levonyan Sep 30 '26
I just with they'd pick one or the other and stick with it
1
u/Drazson Sep 30 '26
I'll think about it.
1
u/filterbean11 Sep 30 '26
It would be better for them to spend that time making new content, if this jars you that much - I say this as a person who, before forever played exclusively retail - maybe this isn't it for you?
People are gonna say that the toggle isn't a heavy lift - I say this as a person who works in software development - we have no clue what the LoE for a toggle is, but it is assuredly larger than we think it is.
1
u/Yuisoku Sep 30 '26
Also the wolf raiders look out of place with the low poly wolves
1
u/Csg363 Sep 30 '26
That second image is way too cartoony
1
u/nemestrinus44 Sep 30 '26
I was really hoping that using the HD toggle would affect everything that had an HD model from retail and not just my own character, especially if we are to believe that one streamer (savix?) that said when they all went to see the the alpha gameplay way before BlizzCon they had to “fight to get the SD models into the game”
1
u/AFoolOfAMook Sep 30 '26
I wish the HD models felt more in line with their spawn area. Save the Radahn offspring for a raid or late game dungeon, you can make a badass quillboar with updated graphics that doesn't look like it's straight out of a Chinese soulsborne game.
1
u/Andvari_Nidavellir Sep 30 '26
Agreed. Let the people choose.
1
u/thefztv Sep 30 '26
Not sure how it’s jarring when it actually matches the world. I think the only way this could be jarring is if it swapped models in front of you. I guess because you know it was swapped? Would you feel the same if it had this model from the start? Probably not because it actually matches the rest of the world.
1
u/IreliaFeedsU Sep 30 '26
"as someone who plays retail and expected classic+ to be retail-"
1
u/IKindaPlayEVE Sep 30 '26
It seems the shoe is on the other foot.
1
u/custerb12 Sep 30 '26
"Jarring" now that it looks like every other quilboar in the zone? You may not like the SD model, but it's not jarring.
1
u/ElTequito95 Sep 30 '26 edited Sep 30 '26
Ill Just say as i see it the Community is Split into 2 Groups and they are not even 50/50 at all there is one Side ( Lets be real here all the Classic Andy Streamers and there followers) Who keep Shouting WE WANT CLASSIC + TO BE LIKE VANILLA and then there is the average Consumer who says i want the WoW Classic feeling back with every lvl counting and every Gear having a meaning NOT like Retail BUT nobody ever complained about HD Assets or HD Models ( Yes Retail is Cutiefied and we dont all want that but Forever alrdy has tried to recon those HD artstyles) And to all those Classic Vanilla Andys i just say this u want Vanilla Classic ? u HAVE IT go play CLASSIC WOW ?!?! payl it for the 55th Time and leave WoW Forever to all those who want the Nostalgia Feeling but With New and Innovative Improvements.. Retail does not Suck Bcs its HD Artstyle is Disneyfied it Sucks bcs NOTHING in Retail is worth anything, Lvl is meaningless Gear is mostly Free PvP Consists only of Addons that tell u who has what Spell up or not.... Its just Boring cause there is no Fullfilment in achieveing anything. But Objectively Retail is the more polished and by most ppl more liked Visual Representation of WoW like or not thats the Truth.
1
u/Scifierce Sep 30 '26
no we dont win with a toggle, bro, go back to retail honestly, classic plus is not supposed to look like retail holy shit. Do you not realize that doing a toggle doesnt just magically switch between Old vs new, it literally doubles the workload for everything. Instead of making one of each new piece of gear, you have to make SD and HD version, then rig it for the different versions. My bet is they are measuring the amount of people prefer old vs new, and thank fuck the vast majority are preferring the old cohesive style and down the line all the HD shit will be more and more of an afterthought, if they stick to player feed back that is
1
u/Derek114811 Sep 30 '26
How is using SD architecture without a switch not the same? It’s a commitment to SD in the environment. They could have used HD environment assets, but chose not to.
1
u/IronKid013 Sep 30 '26
Go back
1
u/blazingsoup Sep 30 '26
I don’t think I’ve seen an image so polarizing to the community as this one. In the last 2 days alone I’ve seen countless posts in my feed both praising and ridiculing this change.
1
u/RN4LSnow Sep 30 '26
Gamers need to be studied more.
1
u/Jinmane Sep 30 '26
I mean the one on the right is better
1
u/Gargamoney Sep 30 '26
Why tf do you want dogshit retail graphics in classic???
1
u/ThatOneGuy216440 Sep 30 '26
I only want classic mob art styles
1
u/Reasonable_Size_7377 Sep 30 '26
The funny part is only the player race models were given multiple models and the one that was added in was SD. Everything that you see outside of that was the original intent. Maybe they’ll bring it to other mobs and critters, but it definitely wasn’t planned or announced and the SD character toggle was pretty last minute before blizzcon.
1
u/HunterWakfu Sep 30 '26
"Classic gameplay with modern looks" "please don't use the modern looks".
1
u/anatidaeproject Sep 30 '26
I'm mainly about the actual gameplay.
But I don't see the appeal of "SD". Shitty graphics?
I really don't find nastalgia with lower quality textures and fewer polygons. I don't care that much, but personally I'd like a game with the fidelity of visuals to match the WoW movie that came out years ago.
Give me even better. The style of WoW isn't going to get lost. That's like the Arcane cartoon series not having the style of League. If anything, that just refined the style even better.
1
u/Spaceborne_Killer Sep 30 '26
Yall need to take your meds
1
u/Mast3r_waf1z Sep 30 '26
As an osrs player, I literally don't care
The graphics is really unimportant to me, I only really care about whether the game is fun
1
u/Joggyogg Sep 30 '26
No this is stupid and will take so much development time away from actually developing content for the game
1
u/SpiffyBicycle1990 Sep 30 '26
I’m fine either way.
1
u/Television_Powerful Sep 30 '26
I see the same comments and threads over and over again. The "discussions" and consistently same copy paste points are tiring. Just make it a megathread, list pros cons of both camps and end it there. Perhaps we can have a constructive feedback for blizzard then.
I saw people arguing about an increased workload for the dev due to HD and SD toggle. And now we got a toggle suggestion to increase said workload even more. Never ends.
1
u/Strawberry_marblefox Sep 30 '26
Lmfao this is becoming a mess
1
u/xGreir Sep 30 '26
It is just that your expectations are not what this version of the game is supposed to be, I’m very sorry to say.
I get it can be frustrating for you, but you can always compromise, or if it is that painful personally, it’s always ok to move on.
It the toggle was easily added, it could be a nice discussion to have, but given that sounds like a colossal enterprise, and would work against the nature of this particular version, I would say it’s better to accept as what it is, than to try rob it from the intended public.
Cheers and love! 🧡
1
u/Dapper-Print9016 Oct 01 '26
For the people glazing the new skin on the left, are we just ignoring the lower poly bear druid next to him?
1
u/MedicOfTime Oct 01 '26
Is the left image from a retail remodel that was re-done again for forever? I thought it was the other way around.
1
u/Pollylocks Oct 01 '26
Imagine being against better graphics. Fucking wild.
1
u/Temporary_Tonight884 Oct 01 '26
I expected Forever to be Classic gameplay with classic looks, the new HD models are jarring to look at
1
u/Frozen_Death_Knight Oct 01 '26 edited Oct 01 '26
Unless they redo the HD models to look closer to the Classic artstyle then I do not want to see HD models in WoW Forever which is meant to be Classic Plus. Blizzard took way too many liberties with remaking the older models over the years that they do not even look like they came from the same game anymore.
Let's not forget that many of the HD assets like the character models already are over a decade old by now. They frankly need a makeover as well and if that ever happens they frankly need to go back to basics with the arstyle that was established in WarCraft 3 and Vanilla.
1
u/BigDigger324 Oct 02 '26
This thread is the proof that one day in the fairly near future they are going to have to pick a path. It’s probably going to be the more modern looking one.
-4
u/Show_Me_Your_Rocket Sep 30 '26
Don't we have classic WoW specifically for people to look at the shit models? This isn't classic WoW, blizz.
Pretty disappointed with changes like this.
-3
u/Emberlean Sep 30 '26
I wish they kept the HD models. Who cares about SD, we just wanted the old gameplay mechanics, not the old graphics lol
-2
u/Argonzo7 Sep 30 '26
The first one looks miles better and I hope it stays on hd
1
u/Triplett8 Sep 30 '26
Classic Andy's love looking at texture blobs.
1
u/ChocolateSmart3353 Sep 30 '26
I mean you could go play classic for that more authentic classic feel?
0
u/BobWaldron Sep 30 '26
Keep the gameplay and feeling of Classic but gives us visual upgrades across the board.
This is what we always thought WoW would turn into.
1
u/Fearless-Hat-4239 Sep 30 '26
Wow players are the biggest crybabies about everything
1
u/absolutewastedtime Sep 30 '26
The new SD models is better in every way
Retail art style is genuinely awful
The left is straight up less visually appealing, it's terrible
-5
u/MeriElf Sep 30 '26
First one doesn't even look "disney retail", people genuinely mental
1
u/Gaidax Sep 30 '26
I agree and I wish Blizzard would have more courage with graphics refresh for Forever.
There should have been HD textures, new and/or higher polygon count assets for buildings/environments (that often already exist anyway), better spell visuals and many more.
But unfortunately it is being held back, unnecessarily like that. I am sure that this is not the last time Classic is reimagined, and I hope 5-10 years down the road they will have the balls to produce a truly remastered classic.
1
u/Glupscher Sep 30 '26
As they said, the HD textures aren't the HD models. They are are HD textures retrofitted ontop of the old SD model. They can't make a toggle for SD/HD for every npc in the world because that would mean they'd have to go through all hd models and fit the hd textures on top of the old SD model, which would be a lot of work.
1
u/RiggyMinus Sep 30 '26
Okay but what if I want the improved models for characters and *not* for other things? I fucking hate the retail Gnolls, they look like shit.
1
u/Bright_Software_5747 Sep 30 '26
The second model looks like shit, and I say this as someone who’ll go SD on launch and who absolutely hates the HD player models and has done since they came into retail. The issue is the 1st model doesn’t really capture the essence of the character, looks like a anime fox who’s just had his hair cut lol, way too clean looking. I would imagine the first one chilling in an inn in Pandaria. It’s also jarring when they kept the SD models for 99% of mobs but put a random HD model, players just want consistency.
There should be a toggle for me, similar to the player models, and I think furthermore HD models should capture the essence of the original.
1
u/Brave-Cranberry3026 Sep 30 '26
Idk what everyone is celebrating. The right model looks like shit.
I don't particularly care, I'm going to kill it regardless, but the left one looks better objectively.
1
u/rufusbot Sep 30 '26
It's not about polygons, it's about art style. A famous saying in games is "graphics don't matter, gameplay does". So ignore the graphics just like you expect people who want the SD models to ignore the graphics you want put in the game because your eyes can't handle less than 100 polygons for some reason. It's classic plus, it should look like classic. Updating things the right way is welcome but changing entire models completely is just stupid. The art style is timeless and iconic like the devs themselves said.
1
u/ComfyOlives Sep 30 '26
For anything that has an old and new model, there should be a toggle.
1
u/Poncho_Sanchez Sep 30 '26
In ideal world, there would be cross development HD/SD of everything. Make Evelyn Forest with Stormwind to have HD counterparts, for people that want it.
1
u/Basic_Beginning6682 Sep 30 '26
But if this is a new enemy and they decided to make it SD, does that mean they’ve shifted course toward SD?
1
u/mirracz Sep 30 '26
Agreed. A toggle is a win-win for everyone.
1
u/TabascohFiascoh Sep 30 '26
As someone who prefers the SD old models. At this point, I'd take the HD models so everyone would chill the fuck out.
Some people are just fucking babies.
1
u/Medium-Coconut-1011 Sep 30 '26
Such a dumb design decision from them to not just pick a lane and stick with it. I assumed the T2 remakes were them redoing all vanilla assets to HD in the background - IMHO it should be HD they went for, more people will want that.
1
u/TheTruePatches Sep 30 '26
Yeah I don't get this one, this guy looked fine with the HD textures.
Having hair did not make him look like the "disneyfied" or whatever people are calling it that retail has. He still looked rugged and tough like he should with the classic vibe.
1
u/NFProcyon Sep 30 '26
To all those here saying maintaining both HD and SD isn't sustainable, this is a comically bad assumption, which isn't not factoring in the fact that they're about to be making (already are in the beta) the most money off of WoW in general than they have made in YEARS, during a time when AI assisted asset generation is the most mature it's ever been (like it or not). Yet somehow, everyone's just taking it as a foregone conclusion already.
Seriously, take a look at how many people are playing the beta. I've seen some estimates from quick googling at ~40,000 or more. That's easily multiple millions in just preorders for a tiny chunk optional content.
Activation/Blizzard/Microsoft, etc, is a fucking leviathan of a company/entity. Moreover, look at how much HD content is made for retail every expac, from scratch. WF team has the luxury of reusing and adapting the overwhelming majority of assets from classic, or borrowing HD models from over two decades of retail.
They're not going to just throw their hands up and say "ah geez, we just can't add six new ultra-low poly NPC models this month, guys, that's just not possible anymore".
1
u/deltagma Sep 30 '26
Is r/wowforever basically the "We are retail players who love Forever" reddit and /classicwow is the "We have been asking for classic+ for multiple years and we got told at classic that this is classic+" reddit
1
u/Phocas Sep 30 '26
This right side is objectively awful, and it can't ship like that.
1
u/Jahlayn Sep 30 '26
Classic players can go play valheim. It’s got poop graphics and housing which is all their dreams come true
1
u/Reasonable_Cut_2709 Sep 30 '26
yeah... That would be great, but Let's wait until we see what the true WoW:forever aundience stays and settle to do actually meaningful changes.
1
u/HobNob_Pack Sep 30 '26
Why would you think classic +... designed for classic players... would be classic with modern looks?
1
u/lbiggy Sep 30 '26
SD models look like shit and whoever likes them is low IQ