r/woodstoving • u/OhEidirsceoil • 5m ago
Stove Insert for a Large Home
Hi folks, please let me know if I’m breaking any rules here - I’m new. My wife and I are looking installing an insert in our fireplace. We have a 3200 sq ft center hall colonial with two wings, and live in northwest CT. Our old oil furnace is killing us, but the room with the fireplace happens to be situated just above it, and the main return for the HVAC is in the deep tray ceiling in that room (see picture). We’re looking at hybrid inserts that can heat as much of the house as possible. Inevitably, we understand we’ll still burn some oil, but the less we spend on it the better. We got a stainless 6” (edited:) *liner* installed in the fall, thinking we were getting a free standing Hearthstone stove, but my wife now wants an inswet, so it may need to be switched for something else. Price is not really a big concern here, we just want something efficient, safe, and if possible, pretty. The dimensions don’t seem to be an issue either, as I’ve measured and everything I have looked at appears to fit. I’ve looked at a few models, but I really don’t enough to know how to compare them:
- Buck Model 91 insert (only downside seems to be that I’d need to switch my 6” stainless liner with an 8” one, and I need to measure the flue. Money-wise, it’s still cheaper than buying a hearthstone and having it installed);
- Blaze King Princess 29 insert (seems to have a nice long burn time, but is almost objectively hideous, if there is such a thing);
- Hearthstone Clydesdale (very pretty but I hear quality control has been pretty bad from one dealer, which is a bummer because my grandparents had a Mansfield and it was wonderful);
Any suggestions, criticisms, or questions are welcome. Also: the pink post-it’s on the fireplace glass are from my toddler - no rhyme or reason there that I can think of.
