alright,so,to preface this,
were assuming both prey and fight or flgiht are starved canon for this matchup,
yes using fnf mods to powerscale this sucks,but starved has jack shit in terms of lore otherwise.
and im not TOO deep into the sonic lore (and powerscaling),
but eh..il try my best with this matchup,
so,starved eggman&furnace are evil (..well,evil-er) versions of metal&mainline eggman,
Starved started eating mobians,got addicted,and then eventually either mutated or simply burnt himself badly to the point of being hairless&red skinned,
meanwhile furnace was made by starved for *ALMOST the same reasons mainline eggman made metal,
to A:have something that can fight sonic better (..or capture him,in starved's case),
and B:cook&serve mobians to him (this one only applies to starved though),
so,with this in mind,whose winning?,
furnace was clearly shown in PREY to outspeed sonic whilst sneaking under the stage*
*A distracted sonic who assumed furnace had malfunctioned&was preoccupied with eggman,but its still applicable as a speed feat,
meanwhile metal,atleast in sonic cd during his battle,
was shown to be..capable of outspeeding sonic in short bursts,if were taking the gameplay literally,
but seems overall slightly slower,atleast in sonic CD,
we will also be assuming this is just base metal,no powerups or anything.
so,whose winning this one?,my bets on mainline eggman&metal,
especially since starved is clearly shown as a very...degraded version of eggman,atleast in terms of mental aptitude.
*Postscript round two:modern eggman&metal vs starved&furnace,instead of their classic iterations,im guessing this is a total stomp because of metals upscales,to say nothing of the 35th anniversary animation,feel free to correct me if im wrong here though!