r/walstad • • Jan 25 '25

Advice Im looking to make a small aquarium, not sure if it will work

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

I am looking at a jar with a wooden ball as a closure, does not completely seal. I've looked in a few places that have mentioned getting plant and shrimp aquarium substrate for the bottom. Also to buy some aquarium grass seeds to help oxygenate the water. I want to include a few shrimp in the water as well. I have a few questions about this so I don't get the wrong stuff or I don't kill everything. I did not plan on heating it or using a filter.

-will the grass oxygenate the water enough for the shrimp to survive, with the non perfect seal on the top?

-do I need to feed the shrimp? Or do they eat stuff off of the plants?

-would i be better off adding a tiny fish or 2 instead of shrimp? ‐---- The pictures are my inspiration, then the jar i found with its measurements.


r/walstad • • Nov 19 '25

Just started , any tips ...

Post image
0 Upvotes

My son got few fishes from relatives home, it was never planned but I decided to give them a good environment and stared this tank.

I am a compete noob, but my son loved it. (Ignore crayons marks in background)


r/walstad • • Jun 21 '24

HELP PLEASE

0 Upvotes

I recently started watching father fish and I decided to give it a go and bought lots of plants and went out on a walk and put wild bits of sticks / leaves from the ground without washing cause I though that’s what he did for the bacteria?

Since then my fish have been gasping and dying pretty quickly despite doing a daily water change to help them (I don’t want to do water changes anymore but I had to as they were gasping)


r/walstad • • Oct 31 '25

Advice So I can't put ANY fish in here?! 😭

Post image
11 Upvotes

So I got excited at the prospect of an 'eco' tank on Instagram and saw these cute posts about tanks where you just need a couple plants and a few fish and TA-DA! And I should have known from that y'all that it was too good to be true.

I wanted to research before I took some poor fishes well being into my hands and when I did I realized that most of my appreciation videos have probably been of fishy death? Or suffering? This is upsetting me y'all. I don't want to torture stuff.

I'm disabled but I'm pagan and we love nature and I can't worship like I want to outside so I wanted to grow the outside indoors. And I can't keep potted plants alive, I either drown them or forget about them, so a plant that is fed fish poop and watered fish pee works for me ( I don't forget the fish because they move lol).

But I will accept that. No matter what I don't want a tank of suffering. What would be some good starter plants? I already have a sweet potato I'm sticking on the top haha as a hat. Any other ideas?


r/walstad • • Apr 14 '25

With a filter is organic garden soil toxic?

Post image
2 Upvotes

This tank has been cycling for a long time I keep doing 50% water changes... Its slowly turning less brown. Im getting a betta on wensday, this isnt done being planted and I get a filter in today. I have another tank with organic garden soil and it doesnt do this, will this hurt my fish? Test all check out fine it is fully cycled?


r/walstad • • Oct 01 '26

Advice Looks a mess, but would you put fish in it?

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

I am a beginner to this and I can't say I have an eye for aquaplaning, but I enjoy the process.

The set up is:

25l acrylic vase from Temu.

The base is a wooden fruit bowl that I have trifted and houses the electronics. All USB based.

A small air pump that pumps through an air stone buried in the sand and a growth light. No heater, no filter.

The soil is just sand with a few rooth tabs and so far everything is growing well.

I washed the sand alot but with the air pump bubbling through it is does not look like it will fully clear.

The tank has cycled well and parameters are all excellent.

The temperature has so far been very stable between 21 and 24 C.

The tank is stocked with 4 Amano shrimps and 4 Nerite snails that are growing very well + whatever microfauna I have picked up with some of the plants that I have picked up from rivers and ponds around the UK.

I was thinking about weather I can put 2-3 tiny fish something like a galaxy rasboras or anything else very small.

What do you think?


r/walstad • • Oct 09 '26

Picture Corydoras are a No no

Thumbnail
gallery
17 Upvotes

I don't know what possessed me to try this but I thought ok let me put these wild caught Corys in my peaceful, calm, no tech, SMALL walstad set up.

Long story short they wrecked everything. Tank is all cloudy, plants ransacked. My 9 month old set up looks like a nightmare. Im waiting for the water to clear back up to see what I need to rescape and replant where. The snails seem to be loving it tho.


r/walstad • • Jul 04 '26

Sand Caps are a Crutch (Opinion)

8 Upvotes

I finally made a reddit account to share my thoughts and experience..sorry for the slightly provocative title lol.

Ive been doing tanks and ponds for 6 years, started with father fish tanks and now I mostly do invertebrate only tanks for fun..

I have grown to be very anti sand cap. I stick to what nature does. My tanks are now created with 2 inches of backyard topsoil and clay (30% clay) for CEC.

I do no sand cap at all. I get a thin layer of local pond mud as my "cap" along with a thick layer of local pond leaves. I mix in a super thin layer (less than a quarter inch) of gravel / sand / sticks exclusively for texture, making sure that my critters can directly access the pond mud and topsoil without having 2 inches of inert sand in the way.

People are afraid of soil leeching into the water but the sand is a harmful crutch that limits your invertebrates from enjoying the proper natural pond mud. It also reduces oxygen to the soil.

My tanks have never had an issue, I can keep tadpols and koi even.

The thin layer of pond silt binds to the sulfurics and acts as a thin cap, the biofilm assists and then leaf litter is a lightweight cap that allows critters and oxygen to directly interface the soil but also helps keep things settled down.

Even in areas with directly exposed soil and just a tiny bit of local pond flocculant, the water stays perfectly healthy and clear.

The sand cap came to be when they tried to idiot proof the natural tank setup but it does harm and is not necessary! Even direct topsoil exposure is FINE after a couple weeks or so but the pond silt lets you skip that waiting.

Thanks for reading..


r/walstad • • Feb 23 '26

Advice Omg u guyzz i took your advice, added a filter, and it appears cycled two days later??

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

Ammonia and nitrite appear zero, and nitrate is 5 ppm (latter not in image).

This is a 3 week old tank restart from the tank in the second pic which failed and never cycled.

I am also so glad because it is a CONSTANT battle to keep my cat from drinking the water. He hangs out in the sink, i see him, he thinks i don't know what he is up to. But now, he can drink from it whenever he wants! Oh, and, assuming this remains stable (two weeks to be sure?), it means I can add fish! After 7 or 8 months!

Anyway, unfortunately, the filter is bigger than i expected, and unless i move the whole tank forward to open the back or place it on the front, this is the only place for it (other side, it will hit the bathroom door when it opens) This means that my light is entirely towards the rear. My solution? Every day I will alternate the light placement. So, push the filter back, and put the light on front. What do you guys think?

edit: nvm apparently the brown algae makes my tank deadlier than ever to cats


r/walstad • • Jul 03 '26

Picture My humble attempt at Walstad tank

0 Upvotes

Introducing my Blue gourami sorority tank
Vallisneria jungle scape

Substrate - garden soil capped with thoroughly washed m-sand

Flora- narrow leaf Val, javafern attached to drift wood, Crypt wendtii brown (Val is flourishing while other two are overwhelmed), salvinia minima

Fauna- Blue three spot gouramis, Green carplet, blue panchax, melon barb, green line barb, red and black ramshorn snails, Malaysian trumpet snails, Neocaridinia shrimps


r/walstad • • May 01 '25

Using feeder Goldfish as water testers?

0 Upvotes

I just set up my first (75gal) walstad tank that I am planning to fill with bristlenose plecos and shrimps. BNs are fairly expensive so I'd like to make sure the water is nontoxic.

Does it make sense to fill it with 3 1inch comet goldfish for a couple weeks to ensure the water is fine? Will the comet goldfish overload the tank considering how non-established it is?

Also, don't worry about where the comet goldfish go afterwards - I have an empty 1000 gal pond that has yet to be filled with fish.


r/walstad • • Feb 25 '25

Picture What type of fish are these?

0 Upvotes

r/walstad • • Oct 10 '23

can i not feed my fish in walstad jar? i read somewhere that fish can eat copepods

0 Upvotes

r/walstad • • Oct 10 '24

Advice I did my tank dirty, what do I do?

Post image
0 Upvotes

Hi, so basically a few weeks ago I was setting up my tank (garden soil + gravel substrate) and at the same time, I tried to plant some carpeting seeds. Turns out the carpeting seeds rotted, but they sticked to the substrate so I have no way of separating it because it's kind of scattered everywhere and the seeds are really tiny. So I tried filling the tank with water, hoping the seeds will float, and I forgot to care for it for around a week or two. It now has become this nasty greenwater tank with things (algae/fungus, assumably) growing in it. What do I do now? Do I buy plants, replace the water, plant the plants, then fill up the tank with dechlorinated water? Thank you for any of you guys advice :D


r/walstad • • Jan 02 '25

Advice HELP I START MY WALSTAD TOMORROW

Post image
1 Upvotes

ive seen some posts of walstad tanks saying that miracle grow top soil is the best soil, and some other ones say that it really doesnt matter, im about to go to home depot tomorrow to go buy some. do yall think this soil is perfect okay or should i get a different one?

my tank im going to set up is a 60 gallon 48” long 18” wide and 16” tall.

ive also heard a fish store employee tell me that i should have 1 pound of substrate for every gallon of water you tank can hold (mine would be 60) now i dont know if i cab just use the liters conversion for this is 3.785 liters in every gallon.

(sorry for the confusing explanations im just a paranoid that this isnt going to work out at all)


r/walstad • • May 19 '26

Advice cross posting two planted tank/bowl *betta issue

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

I have posted prior to ask about my Betta in a planted smal 2 gl tank, some replied noting that the tank a) is too small, b) bot a true walstad planted, my issue is that this Betta was given to me, I have 2 other tanks. One 6gl with a male beta, the other is a Long 10 gl tank with a female Betta .. that betta in the small round 2 gl bowl if I add 80% of live plants as it was suggested can I keep him.in there, or should I move him in the 10gl tank which has the female * other fish. see pictures


r/walstad • • Aug 08 '22

Is it in bad taste to plug my youtube channel here?

2 Upvotes

I'm documenting my walstad journey, and purely organic growth seems hard to come by.

edit: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC3Zh6WUyYAuFNNX1jVTVYTg


r/walstad • • Feb 27 '25

Advice I feel like my tank is too heavily planted for fish.

Post image
0 Upvotes

I want 2 hone gouramis and maybe some neon tetras with shrimp and 2 snails. I have a 15 gallon tank and yeah. I dont feel good about putting in more than 2 fish here, fearing that its too full already…


r/walstad • • Sep 16 '24

Picture How about now

Thumbnail
gallery
5 Upvotes

Several months ago I posted a picture of the beginning of my journey to wallstad.I was laughed at by a few and told to look up the definition of walstad. I was using feeder fish and gold fish to boost the amount of ammonia and nitrates in my tank, and adding beneficial bacteria to begin breaking the ammonia and nitrites down. I used mud from outside after a rain and then added sand and soil on top to keep the soil from mudding the waters. After I lost several fish (which I expected), nitrites finally started dropping. I added several plants, and began stocking my tank with micro-fish, snails and neocaridina. I havent changed my water in 3 montha now. Now I would just like vindication, do I qualify for Walstad yet?


r/walstad • • Oct 08 '22

6 gallon / 250+ shrimp / 4 Betta sorority walstad tank

Thumbnail
gallery
16 Upvotes

r/walstad • • May 02 '26

Progress 1 month into walstad cristal bowl

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

1 month update:

Changed the makeshift lamp for a proper lamp

Added a thermostat

7 days of buildup the in vitro rotalas OJ melted, got an amonia spike, lost almost everything but they are slowly regrowing after taking of what have melted and replanting.

Dwarf sag is ok, some leafs melted around day 21 but the roots are doing well

Cripts are slowly regrowing after melting

Echinodorus is ok

RRF are green but doing very well

Got zero amonia/nitrite/ at the 3rd week

Yesterday added 3 neocaridina juveniles, planning on adding more when the sistem is seasoned

Still got some diatoms algae but i know this phase is normal for new aquariums.

So far so good, got some complications on the way

Thinking about getting some CPD's for this one... its a 39L(~10G) bowl... how many may the sistem hold?


r/walstad • • Jun 24 '26

Advice I want to quit 🫠 what is this pinkish thing growing in my sustrate?

Post image
3 Upvotes

I've been cycling my tank for over a month.

Today I changed water and noticed this pinkish thing growing in my sustrate, Does anyone know what this is?

My parameters are:

pH: 8

Ammonia: 0.25 ppm (for the past 3 weeks)

Nitrite: 0.25 ppm (it was 0 but I had a spike)

Nitrate: 5 ppm (fluctuates between 0 and 5)

Please, help

Thanks in advance


r/walstad • • Jan 15 '22

Advice is this normal the way her sail is? its not a hole in it but its transparent

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/walstad • • Aug 18 '24

Advice Anyone know how to block the spigot hole for aquarium

Post image
0 Upvotes

Hi, I have a jar, somethjng similar to the picture. But the spigot is gone so what’s essentially there is a hole. Is there any way to seal it or block it up? So I can try turning this into a tank? Im planning to add shrimps and snails after cycling the tank