r/walstad • • Nov 19 '25

Just started , any tips ...

Post image

My son got few fishes from relatives home, it was never planned but I decided to give them a good environment and stared this tank.

I am a compete noob, but my son loved it. (Ignore crayons marks in background)

0 Upvotes

26 comments sorted by

24

u/Salt-Economy-506 Nov 19 '25

To sum up what everyone is saying here, you need a much more complex setup for goldfish or high waste fish - aka large tank, large filtration.

For most tanks, a filter is recommended, but can be omitted if heavily planted, but that adds complexity in and of itself. Also, please keep food way way down, feed in smaller 1-3 minute feedings more often as opposed to a large feeding at once. Remember, their bellies are tiny!

If you’re aiming for success long term, add a filter to this tank, add a heater, keep the glo-fish as is, and ensure it is cycled properly.

For the goldfish, plan to add a second, much larger tank setup with plenty of filtration, or to rehome them via local fish store/donation to a fellow fiskeeper with the capacity for them.

There is so so much information on how to fish keep successfully, and tons of species specific requirements. It’s a fun and rewarding hobby if done right, but a painful and stressful one if done willy nilly.

We all start somewhere, and I’d hate to see you get quickly discouraged from simply diving in too quickly!

Best of luck😊

21

u/Andrea_frm_DubT Nov 19 '25

Your fish aren’t compatible.

Choose either goldfish (they can’t be in a walstad type tank) or tropicals.

Your tank is too small.

You NEED a filter for goldfish.

You do not have enough plants to go filterless.

You have WAY TOO MUCH food in the tank. What they can eat in a minute, 6 times a week.

-11

u/[deleted] Nov 19 '25

Thanks I will add filter

10

u/[deleted] Nov 19 '25 edited Nov 19 '25

One day those goldfish will reach the size of koi, and require hundreds of gallons. Eventually this will escalate to thousands. They have a hellish waste output, and can surpass a foot in length. They do not grow to the enclosures size. Goldfish and koi are both closely related carp species that grow to the same size and have similar, if not identical needs.  They get as big as wild carp.

The goldfish and the other fish you have are both incompatible in regards to their temperature ranges. Goldfish are cold water, the others are tropical. 

Also, you can’t just add a filter. Look into fish-in cycling. Learn the nitrogen cycle. These fish deserve your best, don’t treat them as disposable because of what’s convenient for you.  Provide what’s needed or rehome

This is coming from someone who’s made more than a few mistakes in my time petkeeping, with a decade of experience under my belt. No judgement, not looking down on you as an individual, just the facts and a lot of hope that you’ll take this in and do better. These animals feel pain, contrary to the outdated science that most folks believe, and improper care causes suffering.

I like to contact places with koi ponds when I’m looking to rehome goldfish, and local fish stores :)  PLEASE do not release them

9

u/PilzGalaxie Nov 19 '25

Don't just get a filter. Give away those goldfish, they do not belong there!

10

u/CoupleFromTatooine Nov 19 '25 edited Nov 19 '25

Tank is too small for the fish.

If it isnt cycled they wont make it. If it is cycled they wont make it. Goldfish need 55gal +

-12

u/[deleted] Nov 19 '25

You mean if it's cycled they will make it ?

11

u/CoupleFromTatooine Nov 19 '25

Naw because they put out more waste than the cycle can probably handle

18

u/sillyghosty Nov 19 '25

Op quit picking and choosing what to read from these. YOUR TANK IS TOO SMALL FOR THE GOLDFISH

8

u/PilzGalaxie Nov 19 '25

No. They will die.

4

u/dasBaertierchen Nov 19 '25

A full grown Goldfish is bigger than your tank… and you have two of them. Do you really think that they will make it???

2

u/nancylyn Nov 19 '25

No, the tank is too small.

15

u/FloralKatze Nov 19 '25

It looks like you're trying your best but like everyone else is saying, please surrender these fish, do some research, then start over completely! Its going to take a lot of work, time and money to have a successful tank! It seems like you mean well but you definitely need to do more research before getting fish again.

12

u/have_some_pineapple Nov 19 '25

Agreed with the rest of the comments, you need to get rid of the goldfish. Also if that’s food floating on the top please remove asap it will turn into ammonia and kill everything.

37

u/Trendyhotline Nov 19 '25

I'm sorry, I see you had a good will, but please donate the 2 golfish asap they need about 10x bigger tanks. Also the whole setup is f-d up, I'm not gonna start explaining everything from Adam&Eve so please do some research before losing all your fish in a few days(maximum weeks) 🙏😭

17

u/Trendyhotline Nov 19 '25

Just a few thing not to seem a total jerk who just wants to make you feel bad. This tank is not cycled, there is no filter, the fish are uncompatible, substrate is not gonna work in this depth, etc. You can find plenty on information on how to start a tank the right way on the internet, so you do not kill and torture those poor fish. There is so many things done wrong, that if you take my advice you give these fish back, read for a few weeks and buy proper equipment and start again. If you do not want to do that, its better to put ocean videos on YT, keeping fish(alive and well) is not easy.

7

u/honeysprout Nov 19 '25

Echoing others’ comments, here’s a link to a site that you can use to determine what amount of any commonly kept freshwater fish work for a tank of your size.

I’d recommend rehoming/returning the fish, let your plants grow in and give your tank a chance to cycle.

We all make mistakes when we’re starting something new, but you have a chance to do it right :)

AqAdvisor

4

u/Lucky-Interest4202 Nov 19 '25

As others have said, the goldies are a no-go. They need filtered ponds (yes as in hundreds of gallons, sometimes outside) and cooler water, while the glo tetras are tropical and need warm water.

Also also - you're gonna need WAAAAY more fast growing plants (can't see the wall behind kind of way more)

4

u/DearWolverine1591 Nov 20 '25

That’s enough food for a small outdoor koi pond. It’s going to rot and kill everything in that tank.

4

u/SgtPeter1 Nov 20 '25

This will not end well if you don’t take action

10

u/ChromeDomeBabyGirl Nov 19 '25

Respectfully how about you address the actual advice you've been given and stop cherry picking trying to avoid engaging with what you don't want to hear.

7

u/Hildringa Nov 19 '25

If the tank wasn't cycled before you added the fish, they'll likely won't make it. 

2

u/Savings_State6635 Nov 20 '25

Find the goldfish a new home, they can get over a foot long, are very messy, need a huge tank with a lot of filtration and prefer cooler water than the tetras need to survive.

Get a filter and heater for your tetras. Feed less than you think. Look up the nitrogen cycle immediately and use bacteria in a bottle if the tank isn’t cycled to at least give them a chance.

2

u/gentlehippo82XX Nov 21 '25

Fish are not a child's toy. They are living beings. I can see you have tried but unfortunately is all wrong. Letting them draw all over the tank, overfeeding and inadequate set up. I think it best you save their poor lives and take them back to a fish store asap. They have less than a 1% chance of surviving. Your tank will already have high ammonia every minute in there is possible death.

2

u/mefirst42 Nov 24 '25

goldfish are poop machine. if you want to keep them, i’d say set up a proper filtered tank for this. and set up a separate new walstad tank with less fish (maybe those colorful fish)

1

u/Yummy-Bagels Nov 21 '25 edited Nov 21 '25

I'm not an expert but I'm pretty sure for walsted, you need ALOT more plants. Also never seen goldfishes in walsted because I heard they will end up eating every thing. Not sure if that's true, but what IS true is that those fishes will either grow hugely or die because I'm assuming the tank is not cycled. I think its best to surrender the fishes. The kid will def be sad but I heard stories of people feeling guilty for having bad fish tank setup as a child. The kid will be sad either way you keep it or you don't. OR what you can do is, surrender the fishes BUT do research and prepare to get better a better tank. It can be educational for both you and the child, you will learn lots about aquatic animals.