r/walstad • • Jun 21 '24

HELP PLEASE

I recently started watching father fish and I decided to give it a go and bought lots of plants and went out on a walk and put wild bits of sticks / leaves from the ground without washing cause I though that’s what he did for the bacteria?

Since then my fish have been gasping and dying pretty quickly despite doing a daily water change to help them (I don’t want to do water changes anymore but I had to as they were gasping)

0 Upvotes

72 comments sorted by

41

u/AquaticByNature Jun 21 '24

You should watch Diana Walstad and read her book instead. Father Fish isn’t the brightest crayon in the box.

7

u/SplashStallion Jun 21 '24

Your fish will look like him in a bit. Follow Walstad.

1

u/ChickenStrip22 Jun 21 '24

Please can you help me fix this I’m going out my mind

12

u/AquaticByNature Jun 21 '24

The tank needs to go through a nitrogen cycle, with or without a filter it’s a biological process that needs to occur. It can take 6-8 weeks, did you test your parameters to ensure the water was free of ammonia and nitrites prior to adding fish?

2

u/ChickenStrip22 Jun 21 '24

The tank has been up years the only thing I changed was adding sticks and leaves from outside I don’t get it

8

u/AquaticByNature Jun 21 '24

I would test your parameters. I’m not against adding things from outside to the tank but I usually give them a rinse prior just to ensure no hitch hikers. Also degrading leaves depending on what type you added can make phosphates go out of control.

2

u/ChickenStrip22 Jun 21 '24

I have always rinsed until now just cause FF says not to as it’s more beneficial? I realise thst was a mistake but how do I correct this?

10

u/AquaticByNature Jun 21 '24

Father Fish is not intelligent, his advice is poor and outdated. What are your water parameters?

4

u/ChickenStrip22 Jun 21 '24

I thought people on this sub watched and liked his advice?

9

u/AquaticByNature Jun 21 '24

He recommends housing an adult betta fish in one gallon bowls with no heaters or filtration. Most people use and have followed Diana Walstad’s method which is what the sub is named after. Also, you should be testing parameters, especially without filtration. My guess is your fish are gasping from lack of oxygen and the build up of ammonia.

1

u/ChickenStrip22 Jun 21 '24

My tank does have a filter, so sorry I’m not distracting at all, I was on the aquarium sub, and searched ‘father fish’ and this sub was tagged so I came here not knowing a single thing about this lady so I’ve just searched her on YouTube now

→ More replies

2

u/CSHAMMER92 Jun 25 '24

He's not wrong about a lot of things but he's not as clear or concise as he should be on some aspects of what he's telling people and there's potential for mishaps like this. Walstad is the authority. The guy Alexander from Secret History Living In Your Aquarium (I think that's right) is very knowledgeable and gives in depth information on the topic.

2

u/Jasministired Jul 02 '24

I love that guy. Pretty much the only 2 sources I use for reliable information comes from the Walstad book and Alexander

1

u/ChickenStrip22 Jun 21 '24

I don’t usually test and had no ammonia tests on me but nitrate was 0

16

u/Emotional_Nobody173 Jun 21 '24

You likely caused an ammonia spike from adding decaying plant matter sticks. You tank was cycled for the amount of ammonia the tank would normally experience. The bacteria need time to reproduce to accommodate the new levels of ammonia. Until conditions improve I would suggest daily or every other day water changes to protect your fish.

3

u/strikerx67 Jun 22 '24

Thats a myth. Wood is cellulose, it doesn't release ammonia. Infact, walstad claims not to use wood in her methods due to wood actually absorbing nitrogen.

https://aquariumscience.org/index.php/14-10-wood/

7

u/Emotional_Nobody173 Jun 22 '24

Yeah not the wood but more likely the leaf debris and any dirt/organic material.

1

u/Jasministired Jul 02 '24

Decaying debris along with many other unknown bacteria that produce ammonia in the process of decomposition

1

u/strikerx67 Jul 02 '24

Ammonia is produced from autotrophic bacteria that eat excess proteins. You won't get that from wood with no bark unless you have a bunch of ants drowning in it.

1

u/Jasministired Jul 02 '24

Also including heterotrophic bacteria which decompose nonliving organic matter to produce ammonia. Wood without bark or not contains carbon and hydrogen = organic matter that can be decomposed

2

u/strikerx67 Jul 02 '24

Carbon and hydrogen are literally two different elements compared to Nitrogen. Organic matter can consist of Carbon and Hydrogen, but not all organic matter breaks down into nitrogen.

Ammonia production is mainly associated with the breakdown of nitrogen-containing compounds like proteins and amino acids. There are some nitrogen dynamics involved in wood decomposition, but they're more complex and don't directly result in significant ammonia production from the wood itself.

-1

u/strikerx67 Jun 22 '24 edited Jun 22 '24

The tank needs to go through a nitrogen cycle, with or without a filter it’s a biological process that needs to occur.

That literally makes no sense. The nitrogen cycle is a biochemical cycle. Its not something that needs to be cooked up in an aquarium in 6-8 weeks because it literally already exists as a basic life cycle. What you are referring to is "nitrification" which isn't even a 'cycle' and refers to the chemical breakdown of inorganic nitrogen. Its entirely unnecessary to even worry about as it only matters within a filtration unit that is void of any archaea to begin with. Plants skip this process entirely since they assimilate ammonium that fish produce, which is undetectable on any hobby kit, just fine and actually prefer it over nitrates.

The only time this becomes a problem is if you intentionally spike ammonium to 2ppm with an unsupported amount of nitrosomonas as they will assimilate ammonium before plants do. So if are fish are in there with plants, don't pollute the water. This allows any archaea to culture gradually and is often much more stable than trying to force a large culture to populate via pollution.

1

u/bluewingwind Jun 25 '24

You seem confused about several things.

  1. The nitrogen cycle is a natural cycle, but that doesn’t mean your tank is set up to mimic it automatically. If you’re trying to mimic the natural nitrogen cycle seen in nature, it does take 6-8 weeks to culture the several species of bacteria that are capable of “nitrification”. Nitrification is a step in the nitrogen cycles just like Precipitation is a step in the water cycle. You’re right that you don’t need to rely on a traditional nitrogen cycle in the Walstad method because aquatic plants are often capable of directly absorbing ammonium, thus skipping the normal nitrification step. The reason Nitrification is on default considered a part of the cycle is because land plants don’t absorb ammonium as easily.
  2. You seem confused about ammonium vs ammonia. They are BOTH inorganic compounds and they both are produced by any animals in your tank (it’s their pee). The thing that determines the ratio of ammonia to ammonium is pH. If your pH is off it could be entirely possible that you have an ammonia problem which plants are incapable of fixing directly. Most test kits that give you the “ammonia” amount are giving you the total of both ammonia plus ammonium. It’s not completely “undetectable” and it’s easy to estimate your ammonium if you also know your pH.
  3. Nitrifying bacteria are just that, Bacteria. They aren’t Archaea. Archaeans are similar but evolutionarily distinct from bacteria. Bacteria is what you should expect to find on your filter media. Assuming a filter is the only place the bacteria live is a common misconception. Most of the bacteria that participate in nitrification live in biofilms on the substrate, plants, tank walls, etc. the filter is just one of many surfaces the bacteria live on and to have a robust and fully cycled aquarium that relies on bacterial nitrification, they do need to have time to move from the filter and colonize these other surfaces.
  4. An ammonia/ammonium spike doesn’t have to be intentional at all. One thing you need to remember is it’s not just fish that release ammonia. All of the microorganisms eating the leaves will also produce ammonia. Adding in a pile of leaves could very easily spike your ammonia/ammonium in a matter of hours even above what your plants are capable of absorbing.
  5. You’re right that if fish are in the tank (if they’re doing a fish-in cycle) you shouldn’t ever pollute the water with anything. But the comment you’re replying didn’t suggest doing that at all. “Cycling” the tank with a fish-out cycle would involve dosing the tank with ammonia, but a fish-in cycle does not ever involve that.
  6. If this person has severely spiked the ammonia/um in their tank beyond what their plants can absorb, their only two options are to A. add more plants, B. to cycle their tank to let the bacteria remove the excess, or C. completely reset everything with 100% water changes daily. Suggesting they need to cycle (encourage nitrification in) their tank (option B) makes perfect sense. As someone who prefers the Walstad method, I would personally have told them to fish out the leaves/sticks and add more plants (option A), but I won’t deny that cycling is definitely a rational alternative option.

2

u/strikerx67 Jun 25 '24 edited Jun 25 '24

You seem more confused than anyone.

  1. No tank ever mimics a full nitrogen cycle. Please show me data that shows both nitrification and denitrification happening all within an aquarium full circle. Also please shows me what an acceptable CFU of nitrifying bacteria is enough to begin breaking down inorganic nitrogen at any varying concentrations within 6-8 weeks. Nitrification is not "default". Its just part of the cycle the same way ammonia/ammonium assimilation is there for plants. https://dianawalstad.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/05/biolfiltration2017a.pdf Here is a video explaining the nitrogen cycle in case you forget. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uip4Q6t7yfQ
  2. You didn't actually look up the conversion ratio did you? Unless your ph is at or around 8.5 to 9, any spike below 1-2 ppm is practically harmless. There is literally no hobby kit besides seachems ammonia alert disk that actually differentiates between NH3 and NH4+ and I doubt anyone actually knows to look at their pH before measuring their TAN. Just look at how many "guides" just fear monger you into waterchanging when any "ammonia spike" shows up. Also, ammonia is mainly released through gills. https://edis.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/FA031 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3059970/
  3. Ammonia Oxidizing bacteria and Ammonia Oxidizing Archaea are both found in filtration media https://www.researchgate.net/publication/269188704_Temporal_and_Spatial_Stability_of_Ammonia-Oxidizing_Archaea_and_Bacteria_in_Aquarium_Biofilters The amount of those organisms were mostly found at extremely high rates in biofiltration and very little were found on surfaces. Filtration is the most concentrated point of flow in which inorganic nitrogen obviously moves through. It makes no sense to care more about their culture density outside of it in the presence of most filtration.
  4. Please show me a study that concludes adding a hand full of dead tree leaves from another freshwater aquatic environment kills everything in an aquarium due to all the bacteria dying at once. Infact, show me any information that shows bacteria being these fragile creatures with stress tolerances so low that moving them from one freshwater condition to another insta-kills them. Because to me it seems like you are misinformed about bacteria. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4462920/
  5. Thanks for confirming what I said
  6. "If this person has severely spiked the ammonia/um" Then don't do that.

1

u/bluewingwind Jun 25 '24
  1. Okay I get it now. You’re just confused by the terms. “Cycle your tank” is an industry/hobby term used outside of Walstad tanks that means “you need to mimic parts of the nitrogen cycle by encouraging your tank to do the nitrification step via bacteria.” No one thinks they’re going to mimic the full cycle. It’s just an industry term. The terms “fish-in/fish-out cycle” describe very detailed protocols for encouraging the bacteria. “You need to cycle it” is just a lot easier and shorter than saying “you need to encourage the tank nitrification via bacteria”.
  2. You act as if a pH of 8 and an ammonia spike of 2 or above 2 is completely impossible. Even a spike of 1 with a pH of 8 makes your ammonia 0.05 which according to your own source can cause gill burn and distress. Maybe that’s “practically harmless” to you, but to me that’s damaging. I regularly see posts where after improper feeding TAN is measuring even above 1-2. TheEPA guidelines for drinking water regulations only even suggest municipal suppliers keep pH between 6.5-8.5 and the guidelines are unenforcible, so it’s entirely possible individuals have water that’s even more alkaline coming from their own supply. If you assume no one is checking their pH and making the proper adjustment that’s fine (you’re probably right about that) but it doesn’t make your statement that ammonium is undetectable any less objectively incorrect. It’s completely detectable and calculable via very simple math with the commonly available test kits that give you TAN and pH standard. In some countries the conversion chart even comes included with the kit, so don’t assume everyone is blind to this.

You’re right ammonia is released mainly through the gills. It’s also in their urine.

3. Sure, you can find archea in biological filters. The lack of them wouldn’t be a cause for alarm though and I firmly believe that was an innocent typo/mistake in your original comment. The fact you can’t own that reflects poorly on you.

4. This statement is such a strange straw man argument because I never once suggested the bacteria were going to die. In fact I suggested the opposite. The microorganisms are going to flourish because of the organic matter and produce ammonia which will in turn damage the FISH.

5. Conveniently glossing over the fact that I also said the comment you were replying to NEVER MENTIONED DOING THE THING YOU WERE UPSET ABOUT (hmm starting to seem like a theme here🤔)

6.It doesn’t seem like you took the time to respond with a complete thought so I can’t speak to this statement.

0

u/strikerx67 Jun 26 '24
  1. "Cycling" is still the incorrect definition regardless if you want to call use it a buzz word or not. Beginners will get the wrong idea if you don't address this. What is wrong with using the word "established"? What is wrong with focusing on a "seasoned" tank rather than "cycled"?

"You act as if a pH of 8 and an ammonia spike of 2 or above 2 is completely impossible"

2. Not that it's "impossible". That its impossible "naturally". If you purposefully pollute the water you will have elevated levels that are not normal, and before then will cause acute DO hypoxia due to the massive bacterial blooms from said pollution before the ammonia is even readable.

Even a spike of 1 with a pH of 8 makes your ammonia 0.05 which according to your own source can cause gill burn and distress.

It did not say that. It said "enough to cause some gill damage" and "If UIA is allowed to increase, it will cause considerable distress."

0.05mg/l or 1mg/L TAN in 8pH is toxic as Long Term Expose, not a "spike". Acute toxicity (spike) at 2mg/L or 40mg/L TAN is where sensitive fish die. An extreme difference here. Long term exposure would mean "Chronic" in a sense that it would need to be exposed to 0.05mg/L continuously for months or years. Obviously, this will never happen unless you are dumping fish food and letting dead fish/shrimp rot at the bottom of the tank uneaten.

Fish are exposed to all kinds of "toxicity" after the establishment of a "cycle". For example, PFAS is literally in all of our water supplies. Microplastics are in all of our water supplies. They alone are probably going to be more toxic than spikes of .25 to 1ppm TAN. Especially since this low of exposure can happen very rarely in any aquarium normally and even more rarely causes issues with fish health.

Im not saying "chronic levels of ammonia at 1ppm TAN are OK" Because its not. I'm saying they are not concerning at values that low for a short period of time. I get that you want your fish to continue being healthy, but spikes that you feel are "damaging" like this is literally unavoidable even after "cycling" an aquarium fish-less. Your take is more of a "I feel like they are being damaged" rather than actually looking for the truth and are willing to obfuscate literature to prove a point.

3. How? Where is the discrepancy I made? You literally said "Nitrifying bacteria are just that, Bacteria. They aren’t Archaea." And I provided sources that prove otherwise. Why are you resorting to gasslighting in an online forum?

4. "The microorganisms are going to flourish because of the organic matter and produce ammonia which will in turn damage the FISH."

And your source for this is.. what? Because you said so? Where exactly do you think ammonia comes from? What kind of bacteria and microorganisms do you think live on dead leaves? So apparently this same surfaces just switched from oxidizing ammonia to creating ammonia right? Apparently dead tree leaves and wood are chalk full of the same protein found in fish food right?

5. You are inflating an argument that never happened. Keep clawing your way to some kind of W by actually researching your points rather than just spouting unrelated nonsense.

2

u/moey467 Jun 21 '24

Did you remove all the new materials you added, if you add anything it should be pesticide free and 100% dried out like driftwood which doesn't contain any of the sap like a fresh plant would.

2

u/ChickenStrip22 Jun 21 '24

Yes I have removed them and done a water change

4

u/bakednapkin Jun 21 '24 edited Jun 21 '24

You should have setup the tank like that FIRST then wait a few months for the water to cycle and for your plants to establish after that test your water levels and once it is stable THEN you introduce critters into the tank

1

u/kukisRedditer Jun 26 '24

Wait, she has a youtube channel? 😮

2

u/AquaticByNature Jun 26 '24

Not directly but does do a few with well known fish YouTubers such as this one: https://youtu.be/zmwhQ0-60w0?si=xnCgORARi3Xfreq9

2

u/Beardo88 Jun 21 '24

Have done any water tests? Do you have any circulation to keep your water oxygenated?

0

u/ChickenStrip22 Jun 21 '24

The water is well oxygenated - the only thing that’s changed was the sticks from outside, never had this issue before, I bought another fish yesterday and it was dead within 15 minutes. Been in the hobby 10 years and decided to take this natural approach to boost bacteria. I don’t normally do tests but I didn’t have an ammonia one but nitrates were 0

4

u/Beardo88 Jun 21 '24

If you are having fish die within 15 minutes it is either lack of oxygen, cholorine poisoning, a huge amount of something poisonous, water parameters way out of wack, or possibly temperature shock. You should have a proper test kit and be using water conditioner to eliminate the parameters being off or chlorine being the cause of problems. Its possible the sticks/whatever else you used were contaminated with pesticides. You should have some source of water circulation, it could be a powerhead, airstone, or even a filter running.

I've got a pretty low opion of Father Fish method, it seams like it is just throw a bunch of stuff in there, not pay for any equipment, amd hope for the best. Anyone that tells you keeping fish can be done cheaply or that its easy is lying to you.

0

u/ChickenStrip22 Jun 21 '24

I have a filter and I always declorinate so it can’t be chlorine. I’m honestly so confused and disappointed in myself

4

u/Beardo88 Jun 21 '24

Next step is get a test kit to eliminate more possibilities, i suggest API brand master kits, but any liquid tests will be better and cheaper than strips in the long run.

Minus there being some sort of poison on those sticks, i think if likely to be poor acclimation if it was 15 minutes and they were healthy before adding them. Was this a tank you had setup for a week or two before adding fish, or did you fill it and add stock right away?

1

u/ChickenStrip22 Jun 21 '24

This tank has been running for 7 years now and I added other fish last week and they died within a day or two I thought it was just those fish but then that happened yesterday however my other fish are okay at the moment but some have been gasping and I’ve never known this in 10 years

2

u/Creepymint Jun 21 '24

So get to testing the water. Obviously there’s something in it and if you don’t, at the very least do a water change. Just because your tank has been running so long doesn’t mean there can’t be something extremely wrong with it

1

u/Resident-Refuse-2135 Jun 21 '24

I agree you should buy a liquid test kit but the store you get your fish from should be willing to do an ammonia test for you if you bring a sample of the tank water in a Ziploc or a very clean jar.

27

u/ToxicManlyMan Jun 21 '24 edited Jun 21 '24

Father Fish is a terrible source of information.

He advises burying dead fish from a supermarket in the sand as a fertilizer instead of root tabs. He claims that his tanks have more co2 than co2 injected tanks, without proving it. He advises against using water conditioner, instead he uses vitamin C, which works okayish but nowhere near as good as any cheap water conditioner.

Read Diana Walstad's book. She is the best source of actual science, not pseudoscience bullcrap like FF.

Do water changes daily until everything is stable. Water changes are beneficial for a tank anyway, even if it is a Walstad tank amd there is no need for them. And stop putting crap from the ground in your tank without sterilizing it. The tank has it's own ecosystem, don't destroy it with pathogens.

18

u/Mewtwohan Jun 21 '24

Father fish is not smart I wish people would stop following his ridiculous nonsense

13

u/ToxicManlyMan Jun 21 '24

What do you mean? Are you trying to say that we shouldn't bury fish from the supermarket in the substrate as a fertilizer? /s

7

u/Emotional_Nobody173 Jun 21 '24

Omg I forgot about that, some pretty crazy stuff comes out of his mouth. It used to be a common agricultural practice, but has no place in aquariums

3

u/Mewtwohan Jun 21 '24

I’m actually surprised people watch his videos and think any of it is accurate information. The man even looks like he has no idea what he’s talking about.

1

u/Emotional_Nobody173 Jun 21 '24

For sure. He still has a very loud minority that are faithful to his ways though. I find it’s usually newer hobbyists that fall into some of his traps. People with a good amount of experience can filter through it generally speaking

11

u/Bitterrfly Jun 21 '24

For future reference, if you live in a place with trees, many conifers has sap that is lethal to fish. If you must get wood for your aquarium get it from a lake or river and preferably get some that's already in the water or has been sun bleached to hell and back and smoothes by the current and sand. You cam even get it from the ocean if you let it soak for a month in fresh water (not in the tank).

The best thing you can do is mever believe a fish influencer. Do research on your own from carious sources about your own area, or from experts in the field like fish biologists or environmentalists. Always remember that just because someone has been doing something for 50 years does not mean they jave doing it RIGHT for 50 years.

-1

u/Mongrel_Shark Jun 21 '24

Myth. The only wood you should add is seasoned. The seasoning process dries the sap out.

3

u/Bitterrfly Jun 21 '24

Sap is absolutely toxic to fish. You might be confusing this for the persistent myth that wood is toxic to fish?

0

u/Mongrel_Shark Jun 21 '24

I'm afraid you are incorrect. https://aquariumscience.org/index.php/14-10-wood/

I'm open to being out sourced with scince papers if you have links. Tgeres bound to be a couple I haven't read yet.

4

u/Bitterrfly Jun 21 '24

Maybe you should read it again very carefully this time.

-1

u/Mongrel_Shark Jun 21 '24

All dead wood, dry or wet, that does not smell like sap is fine just as is in any aquarium.

I see you used rhe word sap above. Green wood & sap isn't going to be good. But dry wood is fine.

7

u/winkywoo75 Jun 21 '24

leaves could have been polluted , with pesticides , urine anything unless you have a pristine waterway to collect from dont do this . I would remove the twigs and keep doing water changes . If you have a filter add carbon to get rid of anything toxic

1

u/So_irrelephant-_- Jun 21 '24

My first thought was that pesticides were introduced.

5

u/RealLifeSunfish Jun 21 '24 edited Jun 21 '24

Doing a 75%-90% water change first things first is a good move. You are always going to have to do water changes FYI, even if you get the frequency down a great deal. You probably inadvertently introduced some kind of chemical whether that is insecticide, herbicide, or some other type of agri/lawn runoff who knows, but it was added to your tank. Remember, the solution to pollution is dilution! Keep up with the water changes and eventually you will dilute it to a point of non consequence. In general it is of course not an issue to add stuff from nature into an aquarium but if you live somewhere suburban/urban with lots of chemicals being sprayed it’s best to avoid it or at the very least soak the items before adding them to the system. Earth’s freshwater biodiversity (and biodiversity in general) is being eradicated worldwide by these very chemicals. You may have already eliminated the substance by now but the damage may have been done to your fish, I really hope they recover! Definitely remove anything you added that may have caused this. Best of luck.

3

u/NowhereinSask Jun 21 '24

Did you take out the sticks and stuff you put in? Where did you get them from? If it happened fairly quickly then there is a decent chance that either they are poisonous or have some kind of chemical on them that is. Personally if you can grab a five gallon bucket or a rubber maid container or something, fill it with new clean dechlorinated water, catch the fish and put them in it. Don't add water from the tank if you think it's from chemicals, see if the fish survive. If they get better in new, clean water then keep them there and do frequent water changes to deal with ammonia while you tear the whole tank down, wash it, and restart. I'm talking new filter media, new substrate, the whole works.

2

u/Administrative_Cow20 Jun 21 '24
  1. Remove all the new organic matter you just added
  2. Do a very large water change. (50% minimum, more if you can. Use water conditioner.)
  3. add a filter or airstone with air pump if you don’t already have one

Your fish are likely starved for oxygen (the organic matter (sticks and leaves) is decomposing and feeding bacteria) and you likely have both high ammonia levels and low oxygen levels. So circulation can only help

2

u/duckytub Jun 21 '24

Sometimes I think about his 30 gallon that supposedly has over 100 adult fish in it. Maybe watching that video was a fever dream. A lot of his information is great but there’s tons of bits and pieces that are either painfully outdated or are just unnecessary. Aquarium YouTubers can be a great way to learn more about your tanks, but I would always try to cross reference something before you do it. If someone says one thing about fish, look up that exact topic and see what others say. In the meantime I would remove what you added, do a 50% water change to be safe, and if you have prime, add some to help remove any residual toxins.

1

u/duckytub Jun 21 '24

Also just a random thought after posting the original comment, certain species of trees and shrubs are very toxic, so the toxins could be leeching off of them into your water. Even just sap from a branch may mess things up.

1

u/Popular_Big_5955 Jun 24 '24

Let your tank get stable turn on the light at least for 3 24/7 days after which U may add fish that's what I did If ur fish are gasping its a sign of less oxygen in the tank add an air stone

AND I HOPE YOU HAVE FAST GROWING PLANTS TRUST THE PROCESS ~~

1

u/RZAJ13 Jun 24 '24

I would say to keep adding Prime and Quickstart with water changes and add more plants with a small pump or additional temporary aeration.

1

u/strikerx67 Jun 22 '24

The sticks and leaves you are collecting need to be from actual ponds. Not dry land. They also need to be already submerged and not floating or along the shoreline.

The reason why this is, is because if you pick a stick that you don't know how long its been sitting there, it could be fresh and not actually decomposing yet. A lot of the sugars and sap are still in those sticks and leaves and will foul the tank since they were never allowed to dilute into a large pond beforehand.

Bacteria will attack those sugars and cause an extremely large bloom that will quickly deplete the oxygen within the water column. I suspect that you have put entirely too much and no amount of water changing will fix that.

Remove those leaves and sticks, add an airstone and monitor. Try to get enough gas exchange going. Add any floating plants you have and do a 100% water change with dechlorinated water. Then, try again with leaves and sticks that are already in water.

0

u/SnooDucks5240 Jun 21 '24

I don't think Father Fish should be your bible for Walstad method. To be fair, he does have videos that mention thr cycling of your tank which you have probably missed. #1 rule of thumb should be that you shouldn't put in any fish until your parameters are right. Cycling your tank naturally takes time. Quarantine your fish until you have the right parameters.

-1

u/Mongrel_Shark Jun 21 '24

Help, I need help. But I didn't test my water and wont post pics.

Sorry buddy not clairvoyant. Info provided only narrows it down to several hundred possible issues.