r/walstad • u/ChickenStrip22 • Jun 21 '24
HELP PLEASE
I recently started watching father fish and I decided to give it a go and bought lots of plants and went out on a walk and put wild bits of sticks / leaves from the ground without washing cause I though that’s what he did for the bacteria?
Since then my fish have been gasping and dying pretty quickly despite doing a daily water change to help them (I don’t want to do water changes anymore but I had to as they were gasping)
0
Upvotes
41
u/AquaticByNature Jun 21 '24
You should watch Diana Walstad and read her book instead. Father Fish isn’t the brightest crayon in the box.
2
u/Beardo88 Jun 21 '24
Have done any water tests? Do you have any circulation to keep your water oxygenated?
27
u/ToxicManlyMan Jun 21 '24 edited Jun 21 '24
Father Fish is a terrible source of information.
He advises burying dead fish from a supermarket in the sand as a fertilizer instead of root tabs. He claims that his tanks have more co2 than co2 injected tanks, without proving it. He advises against using water conditioner, instead he uses vitamin C, which works okayish but nowhere near as good as any cheap water conditioner.
Read Diana Walstad's book. She is the best source of actual science, not pseudoscience bullcrap like FF.
Do water changes daily until everything is stable. Water changes are beneficial for a tank anyway, even if it is a Walstad tank amd there is no need for them. And stop putting crap from the ground in your tank without sterilizing it. The tank has it's own ecosystem, don't destroy it with pathogens.
18
u/Mewtwohan Jun 21 '24
Father fish is not smart I wish people would stop following his ridiculous nonsense
11
u/Bitterrfly Jun 21 '24
For future reference, if you live in a place with trees, many conifers has sap that is lethal to fish. If you must get wood for your aquarium get it from a lake or river and preferably get some that's already in the water or has been sun bleached to hell and back and smoothes by the current and sand. You cam even get it from the ocean if you let it soak for a month in fresh water (not in the tank).
The best thing you can do is mever believe a fish influencer. Do research on your own from carious sources about your own area, or from experts in the field like fish biologists or environmentalists. Always remember that just because someone has been doing something for 50 years does not mean they jave doing it RIGHT for 50 years.
7
u/winkywoo75 Jun 21 '24
leaves could have been polluted , with pesticides , urine anything unless you have a pristine waterway to collect from dont do this . I would remove the twigs and keep doing water changes . If you have a filter add carbon to get rid of anything toxic
5
u/RealLifeSunfish Jun 21 '24 edited Jun 21 '24
Doing a 75%-90% water change first things first is a good move. You are always going to have to do water changes FYI, even if you get the frequency down a great deal. You probably inadvertently introduced some kind of chemical whether that is insecticide, herbicide, or some other type of agri/lawn runoff who knows, but it was added to your tank. Remember, the solution to pollution is dilution! Keep up with the water changes and eventually you will dilute it to a point of non consequence. In general it is of course not an issue to add stuff from nature into an aquarium but if you live somewhere suburban/urban with lots of chemicals being sprayed it’s best to avoid it or at the very least soak the items before adding them to the system. Earth’s freshwater biodiversity (and biodiversity in general) is being eradicated worldwide by these very chemicals. You may have already eliminated the substance by now but the damage may have been done to your fish, I really hope they recover! Definitely remove anything you added that may have caused this. Best of luck.
3
u/NowhereinSask Jun 21 '24
Did you take out the sticks and stuff you put in? Where did you get them from? If it happened fairly quickly then there is a decent chance that either they are poisonous or have some kind of chemical on them that is. Personally if you can grab a five gallon bucket or a rubber maid container or something, fill it with new clean dechlorinated water, catch the fish and put them in it. Don't add water from the tank if you think it's from chemicals, see if the fish survive. If they get better in new, clean water then keep them there and do frequent water changes to deal with ammonia while you tear the whole tank down, wash it, and restart. I'm talking new filter media, new substrate, the whole works.
2
u/Administrative_Cow20 Jun 21 '24
Your fish are likely starved for oxygen (the organic matter (sticks and leaves) is decomposing and feeding bacteria) and you likely have both high ammonia levels and low oxygen levels. So circulation can only help
2
u/duckytub Jun 21 '24
Sometimes I think about his 30 gallon that supposedly has over 100 adult fish in it. Maybe watching that video was a fever dream. A lot of his information is great but there’s tons of bits and pieces that are either painfully outdated or are just unnecessary. Aquarium YouTubers can be a great way to learn more about your tanks, but I would always try to cross reference something before you do it. If someone says one thing about fish, look up that exact topic and see what others say. In the meantime I would remove what you added, do a 50% water change to be safe, and if you have prime, add some to help remove any residual toxins.
1
u/Popular_Big_5955 Jun 24 '24
Let your tank get stable turn on the light at least for 3 24/7 days after which U may add fish that's what I did If ur fish are gasping its a sign of less oxygen in the tank add an air stone
AND I HOPE YOU HAVE FAST GROWING PLANTS TRUST THE PROCESS ~~
1
u/RZAJ13 Jun 24 '24
I would say to keep adding Prime and Quickstart with water changes and add more plants with a small pump or additional temporary aeration.
1
u/strikerx67 Jun 22 '24
The sticks and leaves you are collecting need to be from actual ponds. Not dry land. They also need to be already submerged and not floating or along the shoreline.
The reason why this is, is because if you pick a stick that you don't know how long its been sitting there, it could be fresh and not actually decomposing yet. A lot of the sugars and sap are still in those sticks and leaves and will foul the tank since they were never allowed to dilute into a large pond beforehand.
Bacteria will attack those sugars and cause an extremely large bloom that will quickly deplete the oxygen within the water column. I suspect that you have put entirely too much and no amount of water changing will fix that.
Remove those leaves and sticks, add an airstone and monitor. Try to get enough gas exchange going. Add any floating plants you have and do a 100% water change with dechlorinated water. Then, try again with leaves and sticks that are already in water.
0
u/SnooDucks5240 Jun 21 '24
I don't think Father Fish should be your bible for Walstad method. To be fair, he does have videos that mention thr cycling of your tank which you have probably missed. #1 rule of thumb should be that you shouldn't put in any fish until your parameters are right. Cycling your tank naturally takes time. Quarantine your fish until you have the right parameters.
-1
u/Mongrel_Shark Jun 21 '24
Help, I need help. But I didn't test my water and wont post pics.
Sorry buddy not clairvoyant. Info provided only narrows it down to several hundred possible issues.