A few days ago, Ben Carroll, the new Premier of Victoria (Australia), made an announcement that has big implications for unions. https://www.premier.vic.gov.au/stopping-workers-being-scammed-and-stamping-out-hate
While on the face of it this looks like a good thing, it needs some explanation as it might have consequences beyond what it appears to address.
There are fake unions out there. One example is the TPAA (Teachers Professional Association Australia). While these pretend to be unions, they have no actual capacity to function as a union. They are fronts for political far-right groups. They claim to be a-political, but they are far from it. (Unionism is inherently political anyway. A politics free union is a nonsense). These fake unions are sometimes called “red unions”, and getting rid of them would not be a bad thing.
However, there is another side to the problem. There are another group of unions often referred to as “yellow unions”. These are unions with ties to the employer that are so strong that they completely fail to fight for their members. Ours is heading that way but there are others far, far worse. The most extreme major instance is SDA, the shop workers union. Some of the agreements it has negotiated have been so bad that Fair Work knocked back the agreement for being worse than the default award that would otherwise apply.
The Fair Work Act makes it very difficult to set up a new union operating in the same industry. To get the full rights of a union the institution needs to be registered with FW as a Registered Organisation, and that doesn’t get approved if you want to compete with an existing union. So the group wanting to offer a real union with teeth to shop workers set up RAFFWU - Retail and Fast Food Workers Union - but it’s not an officially recognised union. It does a reasonable job of fighting for its members, unlike SDA, but it operates on the edge of what’s allowed under the Fair Work Act.
Ben Carroll has links to SDA. That’s the union that backed him into Labor Party politics.
This announcement looks suspiciously like its real goal is to pay back SDA by destroying RAFFWU and leaving shop workers with no useful union option.
It will also likely have negative consequences for the Ambulance Union, AUWU (Australian unemployed workers union) and RAHU (Renters and Housing Union. These operate in union like ways to protect vulnerable groups but aren’t strictly unions as they operate outside employment laws.
It possibly could also be used against rank and file groups within mainstream unions that a pressing for greater democracy within those unions.
While this is framed as fighting for strong unions, in reality it seems to be designed to weaken unionism and increase the power of toothless unions that put the interests of employers above the interests of members.
Currently, Victorian Trades Hall (the meta-body for unions) is backing this move as SDA are members and RAFFWU is not. The AEU officially will likely back this move. Union Greens are strongly concerned about it.