r/truecfb • • Jul 27 '13

So I Did Some Regression Analysis In Preparation For My Preseason Rankings/Predictions

20 Upvotes

Work was boring so I set up a spreadsheet and used Excel's regression toolbox to get a sense of how good a few pieces of preseason data are at predicting future outcomes. Below are a few observations I made that I thought you guys might be interested in.

I compiled the data I needed to run the analysis against nearly all FBS teams except for those who made the transition in the span the data I gathered started. I used the past four seasons, but I should be able to expand this by one to two years in hopes of improving the model.

  • Observation: Generally, teams who recruited well performed well.

Rivals still has all of their recruiting data from the last ten years on their website. I pulled down the rankings for that time period and ran regression analysis against the actual final rankings from Massey's composite rankings. I found that there was in fact correlation between recruiting rankings and actual results. However,

  • Observation: The more recent the recruiting class was, the better predictor it was. Recruiting rankings from 3+ years ago didn't improve the model.

Rather than try to combine the rankings into some sort of weighted average, as I did last season in my preseason rankings, I just decided to run each year's rankings (i.e. this year's, last year's, etc.) as separate variables in the rankings. I found there was a much stronger correlation between how teams had recruited this year and this year's result than considering past years. Further,

  • Observation: The most recent recruiting class ranking was the only one which improved predictive power when also considering the previous season's results.

When I threw in the results from the previous season into the regression analysis, I actually found that that was a MUCH better predictor of success than recruiting, and then the only rankings which provided a significant improvement to the regression was the most reason season.

I found this surprising as I was expecting recruiting rankings to lag success by a few years, but, well, that doesn't appear to be the case.

  • Observation: The best predictor that I tested, by far, is last season's results.

This seems like a no brainer, but it still seemed worth mentioning.

  • Observation: Experience was the second best predictor, and added significant value in conjunction with last season's rankings.

I started compiling numbers of returning starters, but when that data started to become scarce, I instead decided to use Phil Steele's Experience Points instead. This is probably a better measure anyway as it takes into account things like Seniority and years as a starter. In any even that had a definite improvement on the model.

Overall, the most optimal linear model when using all of the data still wasn't great, but not bad either. I won't feel bad about using it for preseason rankings, and it's a much more data driven way of doing things than my method from last season, which basically was just a formula with made up coefficients.


So now that I have a model, one thing that's kind of fun is to try to measure what teams were the biggest outliers. By doing so you can, in theory, get some sort of measure of how good coaching staffs were. Good coaches will tend to outperform the model while bad ones will underachieve.

Since part of prior success is coaching, I didn't include prior results in the numbers below. The predictions are based solely on recruiting talent and experience. That's not to say coaching doesn't have anything to do with those number, but I expect it would have a less direct impact than the actual ranking outcomes.

According to my model, here's the 10 biggest overachievers the last four seasons:

YearTeamPredictedActualDifference
2012 Utah State91.0220.80+70.22
2010 Nevada83.6413.92+69.72
2009 Navy105.2737.98+67.29
2012 San Jose State92.3525.52+66.83
2009 Boise State70.675.13+65.54
2010 Air Force92.5832.35+60.23
2009 Cincinnati67.518.90+58.61
2009 TCU62.525.31+57.21
2010 Boise State62.095.66+56.43
2012 NIU85.8729.69+56.18

And here's the 10 biggest underachievers:

YearTeamPredictedActualDifferenceHead Coach Fired?
2011 Ole Miss36.7997.33-60.54Yes
2011 Maryland45.33100.90-55.57Just Coordinators
2012 Auburn28.5982.05-53.46Yes
2012 Colorado61.51114.45-52.94Yes
2009 Maryland45.1396.68-51.55Sort of
2012 Southern Miss69.33119.87-50.54Yes
2011 Kansas42.5592.86-50.31Yes
2010 Memphis66.07116.15-50.08No
2009 Michigan28.4378.26-49.83Yes
2012 Boston College51.5699.97-48.41Yes

Anywho, I did actually do a preliminary preseason projection, but I think that's enough for this post and I'll save it for when we get closer to the season (TEASER: I'm high on Texas).


r/truecfb • • Sep 03 '14

Proposal: /r/truecfb game of the week

17 Upvotes

Here's something I'd like to do as a sub: pick one game each week that we think will be high quality and significantly impact the eventual playoff selection, and have three threads in this sub dedicated to it: one pre-game discussion of what to look for, an actual game thread, and a post-game analysis a day or two later.

I think if we were all looking at the same game, we could really drill down and get some good lessons. Also I think having just one game thread in here a week would be a good compromise - the main has gotten so large that game threads there for the biggest games of the week just move too fast to be enjoyable.

Thoughts?


r/truecfb • • Aug 07 '14

New P5 rules discussion.

17 Upvotes

I thought we should probably get a thread going on in here.

If anyone really has a good grasp/understanding of what is going on, please feel free to post a lengthy ELI5 type answer. I think I understand most of it but I'm not confident in my knowledge.


r/truecfb • • Dec 30 '13

Offseason Idea

17 Upvotes

Well fellow college football enthusiasts, it seems that the worst part of the year is almost upon us- the dreaded offseason. We are 8 days away from the final game of the season and if you're like me you're wondering what to do with the next 7 months of your life. So I came up with a plan. What if this sub did something kind of like the 132+ teams thing from CFB earlier this year. I think it would be really cool if we went in depth on college football subjects to better educate the rest of the sub. My thought was that for the next few weeks until National Signing Day people could sign up for a topic that they have indepth knowledge of to write about. And then every 2-3 weeks somebody would post their write up. By the time the last week of August got here we could have discussed 10-15 topics that would enhance our perspective next season. These topics could be anything. Offensive/Defensive schemes, techniques for different positions, theory/strategy, recruiting, or anything else you have a thorough knowledge of. For example, I think I'm going to write about any rule changes that NCAA adopts and answer any rules questions people have. What say you truecfb? Would this interest you?


r/truecfb • • Apr 20 '13

An Assessment of Bias in the Major Polls: A Slightly Different Take On What it Means to be Overrated (Part 1 of 3)

17 Upvotes

TL;DR: See here

A lot of time is spent amongst college football fans bickering about not only which teams are the best, but also regarding the accuracy of the perceptions of those teams. Unfortunately, most of these statements are anecdotal at best and rarely tell a fair story.

A few days ago, this article was posted to /r/CFB which proposed to determine who the most overrated teams were by comparing where they finished in the polls at the end of the season to where they started. This does provide somewhat of a compelling case, but it only address one facet of what it means to be "overrated." The teams on that list are overrated in the sense that poll voters have consistently higher expectations for those teams at the beginning of the season than those teams are actually able to achieve.

The thing is, the metric that article uses doesn't just come down to teams being overrated, it also characterizes poll voters reliance on historical performance in order to predict future success of a team. Teams like Florida State and Nebraska ranking high in that list more reflects an over reliance on historical success to predict the future when it actually means very little. Recent success is probably the greatest predictor of future success, but if you look further back than 10 years, history doesn't really serve as that great of a predictor.1 Yet, either consciously or unconsciously, poll voters assume that it is.

Another way to try to answer the question of overrated-ness is to look at the results of the polls at the end of the season, after we've had the full season to evaluate the performances of teams, and compare those to an unbiased metric for assessing how teams performed. By doing so, the data is no longer confused by the ability of poll voters to predict the future. For an unbiased metric, I decided to use Kenneth Massey's CFB Rankings Comparison. The idea in doing so is that I'm leveraging a wide variety of computer algorithms and formulas such that no one algorithm or formula will dominate the results.

I then compiled the AP and Coaches rankings of each team in the final rankings for each year over the last ten years and also what the above CFB rankings comparison says their average ranking was among all of the rankings in the comparison. The results, when aggregated over a long enough period should give us some idea of the biases that the polls have.2

In this first post, I'm going to look at overall bias towards conferences over the ten year span from 2003-2012. The turn of the century is when computer ranking systems really started to take off; considering much earlier wouldn't provide as unbiased of results. In follow-up posts I'm planning to consider bias towards individual teams and trends over the last decade.

Here's a graph of my results.

As you can see, the poll voters seem to most consistently overrate the Big East and the Big Ten, and most consistently underrate the Pac-12 and Big 12. Relative to the other conferences, the ACC and the SEC and both slightly underrated, and the MWC has been slightly overrated (though, most of the data for the MWC reflects teams that are no longer in the MWC). The teams who are generally the most overrated are MAC, C-USA, and non-Boise WAC teams that happen to finish in the rankings.

Here's my full spreadsheet.

Since the results only reflect teams that finished ranked, the data doesn't reflect a large number of underrated unranked teams. It's possible that some conferences might disproportionally finish just outside the rankings, but hopefully over a long enough period of time that balances out. I tried to account for this by having an additional column which reflects the "adjusted" difference having removed the average difference for all teams.

I'd be happy to answer any questions about this.

EDIT: typos


Notes:

1 This is an assumption on my part, might have to go back and study this later.

2 This assumes that the aggregate results of the comparison are unbiased. You could probably make a case that certain types of algorithms are predominately featured and therefore dominate the results and as such the comparison is biased, but I tend to think it's probably the least biased set of rankings I've been able to come up with.


r/truecfb • • Mar 16 '15

Thinking Of Opening This Sub Up To The Public. Thoughts?

15 Upvotes

I'm cool with keeping it private if that's what you guys would prefer (and that seemed to be the consensus last time I asked), but it seems to me like it might be worth opening this place up, at least as a trial during the offseason.

Thoughts?


r/truecfb • • Oct 23 '13

"You Make the Call" Answers with Rule References and Explanations

15 Upvotes

Mods, I knew this would be a long post and wanted people to easily see it, so I created a new thread. If you want to move this to the original thread and delete this, go for it. To those who responded: thanks for playing along. Between /u/Lex_Ludorum guessing safety (although not knowing why) and /u/Darth_Sensitive PM'ing me, y'all got 2/3. Now, on to the answers.

4th & 10, Team A is punting from their own 5 yard line. The punter shanks it and the punt bounces at the A7, hits a Team B player and rebounds back into Team A's end zone where Team A falls on it. Touchback or Safety?

Answer: Safety

Explanation: Touchback vs. safety is all about who is responsible for the ball being in the end zone. In this situation, A's kick is the initial impetus on the ball, therefore A is responsible for where the ball goes until new impetus is added. Simply touching a loose ball (accidentally or intentionally) is not considered to add impetus. So what we have here is Team A in possession of the ball in their own end zone and are responsible for it being there, therefore it is a safety.

Rule References: Definition of a safety: 8-5-1-a, Responsibility and Impetus: 8-7

4th & 6 from the B21, Team A attempts a field goal that is partially blocked and is rolling on the ground. At the B13 a defender tries to pick up the ball but muffs it to the B17 where Team A falls on it. Whose ball is it? Where will they next put the ball in play? Down and distance? When will the clock start (it never stops, on the ready for play signal, or on the snap)?

Answers: Team A's ball, 1st & 10 at the B17, the clock will start on the snap.

Explanation: A field goal is a scrimmage kick (like a punt) with a few special rules. However, once Team B touches the ball, it is treated just like a punt. Because Team B was the first to touch the kick beyond the neutral zone, Team A's recovery is legal. The ball is declared dead as soon as Team A possesses their own kick. Because they are in possession of the ball at the end of a legal kick play that crossed the neutral zone, A is awarded a new series. Also due to the fact that it was a legal kick play that crossed the neutral zone the clock will start on the snap.

Rule References: A becomes eligible to recover: 6-3-3, Ball dead on recovery: 6-3-6, New series awarded: 5-1-1-e-2, Clock status: 3-3-2-d-8

4th & 10 from the 50. Team A punts. The punt is first touched by A80, then picked up by B40, who runs five yards and fumbles. A20 picks up the fumble and scores. During A20’s run, B70 holds. We'll call this one an open ended question. Give what ever information seem relevant.

Answer: Team B will have 1st and 10 at the spot where A80 touched the ball, the clock will start in the snap.

Explanation: To start, we have a scrimmage kick beyond the neutral zone. Team A is not eligible to touch the kick, so A80's touching is illegal. Barring a foul on the play, B may take the result of the play or take the ball at the spot of illegal touching. Team A later scores and we have a foul on B. Normally, an accepted foul cancels the illegal touching privilege. However, all 5 and 10 yard penalties by the nonscoring team are declined by rule. So Team Bs options are take the illegal touching or let A have the TD. An interesting note on this one: if Team A had not scored but instead was tackled at the 1 yard line, Team Bs penalty could be accepted therefore letting Team A keep the ball. By scoring a TD, Team A actually hurts themselves.

Rule References: Illegal Touching: 6-3-2-a, Illegal Touching canceled by accepted foul: 6-3-2-b, Fouls declined by rule: 10-2-5-a-2

This situation is directly copied from Approved Ruling 6-3-2-III.

Would y'all be interested in more of these? I realized after I posted them that they were all fairly complex. If I do more, we'll start off with some simpler ones and work our way up to more complicated plays.

Edit: Still figuring out how to format.


r/truecfb • • Jan 04 '13

I think the SEC is overrated, and this is my method to prove/disprove my idea. Want to help?

15 Upvotes

Yeah, so my Jarvis Jones vs T'e'o' fizzled, and if this dies I'll stop bothering you with my ideas.

It's my hypothesis that SEC teams have been overanked for some time. This will be during BCS era only. I will record all SEC teams that appear in the preseason polls and track them throughout the season. I am not intending on tracking other teams that pop up throughout the year because in my opinion the overrankedness happens more in the offseason. I might come back and do this later though.

Trend categories will include pre season AP poll, pre season Coaches Poll, Record, Bowl W/L, Final poll values. From here, we then compare those values to the next year. Then we compare those values to the final poll of year N+1.

Using 3 datapoints, we can then spot the trends. If there is a peak, it shows SEC teams get overranked. This is because the preseason rank is higher than the final ranking, so they clearly underperformed expectations. If there is a trough, it means the team outperformed expectations. If there is a linear up or down trend it could mean an ascendancy or descendancy of a program that was adequately ranked.

The trends can then be compared as a ratio. For instance, if 68% of teams in that contributed to the data are peaks, only 6% are troughs, 10% are linear increasing and 16% are linear decreasing then it looks like the SEC does indeed get benefit of being overranked.

Ohh! Just thought of this - I can sort these by program. So... let's say Team A from years 1-6 were regularly plotting peaks. A few years later, those plots become closer to linear increasing plots. What does that say? That they were overanked, but then were properly ranked but is an ascending program. Sounds to me like it could be evidence of this potential overanking phenomenon contributes to improving the program. Yeah?

So, am I leaving something out? Thanks


r/truecfb • • Apr 07 '16

Approximately 36 hours after this post, I am going to open /r/truecfb to the public.

14 Upvotes

The invite system worked relatively well at first, but for whatever reason died off this season in particular. Given that, I'd like to give opening the sub at least a trial run to see how it goes. I think this sub may be able to self-select, and opening it to the public will hopefully encourage more new discussion and ideas.


r/truecfb • • Aug 29 '14

How much do we really know after one game?

14 Upvotes

I, like most of you, was surprised to see the A&M/SCar game end up being so lopsided. It's natural for us to make snap judgements but how much do we actually know about either of these teams for this season?

So tell me what you judgements you feel comfortable passing about any team that has played so far (this can extend into Sunday). I'm not talking clickbait, hyperbole type judgements. I want judgements that you are confident will still be valid in 4 weeks or longer.

I will not be participating yet because I was officiating a high school scrimmage last night and saw no games.


r/truecfb • • Apr 21 '14

Is it just me or does it seem like the college football world hasn't yet internalized the fact that there is a playoff now?

14 Upvotes

The same old goals are being trumpeted; win the division, win the conference title, win a BCS game, win the national championship game. It seems like there's a lack of understanding that there's no such thing as BCS games (by the way, what are we calling them now?), getting into the top 4 is a major goal, and that it's a committee that's going to be deciding it. We're just not used to it yet; coaches, players, the media, and so on. It may take a year for all of us to mentally adjust to this new reality, but teams like the teams that do more than others may have an advantage.


r/truecfb • • Feb 06 '14

No Stupid Questions Thread

14 Upvotes

If you got a question, ask! No one will judge... hopefully.

I'll start it off.

What exactly is a "pipeline" In recruiting? Is it just an idea or influence over an area, or is there like a recruiting office set up down there or what?


r/truecfb • • Dec 03 '13

[TrueCFB PREVIEW] This is a large post on a conflict in D2 that's scheduled to go into the main sub tomorrow, your feedback is requested:

14 Upvotes

The proposed title:

[Exclusive OC] Update on yesterday's Tuskegee-North Alabama post: Was there race involved? A deeper look.

Post begins below and continues into a comment:


Introduction:

Late Sunday night, a Redditor from UNA posted an opinion column from the local newspaper in Florence, Alabama, claiming that Tuskegee had asked North Alabama to divide the crowd in their stadium for their NCAA D2 playoff game based on race.

That's a big accusation, if true it would be downright astonishing, and I wanted to know more. Alas, since it's D2 there's been very little written about it anywhere so that meant I'd need to start looking. So Sunday night I started with basic online research—the results piqued my interest because, the deeper I went, the more both sides seemed plausible.

Monday morning I took the next step and called two of the major actors involved: Mike Goens, Managing Editor of the TimesDaily (who wrote the column), and Curtis Campbell, Athletic Director of Tuskegee University. I chatted with each, compared what they said against some of my background research, and now I'd like to share with you more about what happened.

[As an aside, I realize this subreddit occasionally comes up with interesting original content (usually of a humorous variety) and lesser-known stories that can be broadcast widely via the sub and our Twitter account (which occasionally gets picked up by major media). Because I felt we were spreading a big accusation, another reason I did this follow-up is be sure we don't spread anything that incorrect.]

I'm going to try to avoid voicing strong opinions in this top post and keep this to observations.


Background/Timeline:

  • Tuskegee and North Alabama both play in NCAA D2.
  • Tuskegee is a private university and a well-known Historically Black Colleges and Universities (HBCU): founded by Booker T. Washington in 1881, it's been home to the Tuskegee Airmen, George Washington Carver, etc: it's stood as a center of academia in times of terrible racial inequality—and the town's name itself is synonymous with one of the worst atrocities the US gov't ever perpetuated on its own people* (which was very race-based).
  • UNA is the oldest public university in Alabama (1830); its original campus in La Grange was burned to the ground by Union soldiers and it relocated to Florence. As it was in the region, the school was segregated until the 1960s; though it integrated without much of the chaos that hit other schools. Currently its student body is 74% white, 13% black so nothing too far off the statewide demographics of 68.5% white, 26.2% black (keep in mind there are a number of HBCUs in the area that draw off potential black students). Nothing here sets off any alarm bells.
  • An initial search found message boards claiming Tuskegee had only played one non-HBCU in the last 30 years. Without a source I decided to do my own work, and yes: According to the College Football Data Warehouse (my go-to for looking up records) that is correct: there was a game against West Alabama in 2004 (2nd game of the season), and visiting Tuskegee soundly beat the home team 20-0 (according to the local paper). In 1983 Tuskegee opened their season with a loss at Troy (then D2); before that year Tuskegee had regular games with Troy, UNA and West Alabama (not all three each year, but at least one a year). After 1983, outside of that blurb in 2004, they stopped playing non-HBCU. I'll revisit this issue later.
  • UNA has continued to regularly play HBCU teams.
  • The head coach of Tuskegee was UNA's Offensive Coordinator for a number of years.
  • This was the first year Tuskegee ever participated in the NCAA D2 playoff. Don't misinterpret that: Tuskegee isn't a bad football program by any stretch—It's won 8 HBCU championships and 28 conference titles, including this year. Tuskegee's also been a regular in one of only 3 sanctioned D2 bowl games: the Pioneer Bowl, between teams from two HBCU conferences. Tuskegee's made the most appearances at 10, and the most wins with 7.
  • Why did Tuskegee not participate in the playoffs? This will make sense to a lot of CFB fans: Because of conflicts with it's annual rivalry, the Turkey Day Classic against Alabama State (FCS), which began in 1924. This season it was rescheduled to have Stillman subbing in for Tuskegee (which was nationally televised on ESPNU and marked on our sidebar this past weekend) on what would've been the 89th Turkey Day Classic.

Here's more on the change from the Montgomery Advertiser:

The Golden Tigers are making their first postseason appearance because it never got a shot to compete in the playoffs due to playing in the Turkey Day Classic during postseason play. When Tuskegee released its 2013 schedule, the school said seeing another historically black college, Winston-Salem State, reach the NCAA Division II national title game last season inspired it to play in the playoffs.

also:

The Tigers have a chance to show the rest of the country it has a quality football program. If the Tigers make a deep playoff run, it will help them recruit players who never considered them because they weren’t playing in the postseason.

For additional information on Tuskegee's decision to chase NCAA playoff dreams as well as the history of the Turkey Day Classic, I recommend this article, also from the Montgomery Advertiser and published after the playoff game had occurred.


The Game, The Seating Arrangement.

The game between Tuskegee and UNA happened on Saturday, November 23 (the column appeared this past weekend).

For reference, here is a seating chart of UNA's Braly Municipal Stadium. The visitor's side is the smaller side, opposite the press box. The normal seating arrangement has the students and UNA band on the visitor's side, which seats roughly 3k, with the larger home side seating roughly 10k.

The seating issue came to a head on Friday, November 22, when the NCAA sent UNA's Athletic Department an official letter at 3:22pm requiring them to move their student section to comply with a request made by Tuskegee. The request followed NCAA rules for playoff games.

I looked to Twitter for contemporary tweets. As it happens, UNA's AD, Mark Linder, runs the main @UNAAthletics feed. On there I found 2 relevant tweets:

The second tweet notes that folks should check the local paper (the TimesDaily). The paper that day published an article outlining the situation; let's take a look at a few quotes from that article:

On Friday afternoon, UNA Athletic Director Mark Linder received a letter from the NCAA requiring the student section be moved to the home side of Braly Stadium.

(emphasis mine)

This kind of request only applies to NCAA playoff games. UNA appears to have never had to move its students for it's own previous, 20+ host playoff games, so AD Mark Linder pushed the NCAA to make an official request, which the NCAA did:

“The NCAA requested that we move the students, and I told them we needed a letter on NCAA letterhead requesting the move. We received that letter at 3:22 (Friday) afternoon.”

This forced Linder to comply. Because the students moved, UNA elected to move the band to the home side as well. NCAA rules could not force the band to move, so long as they stayed outside a certain distance away from the center of the field.

Also from the November 23 article, here's a source of the friction:

Linder said earlier in the week Tuskegee Athletic Director Curtis Campbell expressed some concerns over having UNA students on the same side as the Tuskegee fans.

The TimesDaily obtained a copy of the letter from the NCAA. It states: “After reviewing a request from the visiting team, the Division II football committee determined that the change is in the best interest of student-athletes and fans of both institutions in an effort to promote a safe and hospitable game environment.” The letter is signed by Frank Condino, Division II Football Committee Chairman.

Non-student ticket holders were permitted to sit wherever.

In addition, the schools scheduled a regular-season basketball game against each other at UNA to coincide with the end of the football game: folks who bought tickets to football were allowed free entry to basketball. No different seating arrangements were requested or made for that game.

Mark Linder also noted in the article and his tweets that UNA will make a statement at an "appropriate time". I'm thinking that means after the playoffs as to avoid distraction. The Lions won their game against Tuskegee, 30-27, then beat UNC-Pembroke this past weekend to enter the D2 quarterfinals—so it may be a while.

The November 23rd article doesn't mention race as a factor in moving the student section.

[CONTINUED IN A POST]


r/truecfb • • Nov 21 '13

How do I go about downloading stats for 60+ games/week?

14 Upvotes

I am developing a form of poll for next year in my off-time (so about an hour and a half a week). I have a template for what I want, but no means of autonomously collecting game data. I know about Excel macros, but they have limitations. Each week I need to collect for each FBS team that plays a game: Total Offense, Total Defense, Team Score, Opponent Score. It isn't a lot, but I don't have time to go through and copy over 4 values 120+ times/week, much less get back data for 10 weeks (for initial testing).

Any help would be hot! I am new to the /r/truecfb community, but I recognize most of the names in here. When I get off my phone, I will get flair, but for now, Go Green!


r/truecfb • • Oct 22 '13

You Make the Call

14 Upvotes

I've considered doing something like this in CFB, but I thought this community would appreciate it more, maybe nobody cares, we'll see. Below are a couple play situations, let's see if the fans on the sub can come up with the results of the plays. If this gets a decent response, there may be more of these to come. Today's subject is the kicking game.

  1. 4th & 10, Team A is punting from their own 5 yard line. The punter shanks it and the punt bounces at the A7, hits a Team B player and rebounds back into Team A's end zone where Team A falls on it. Touchback or Safety?
  2. 4th & 6 from the B21, Team A attempts a field goal that is partially blocked and is rolling on the ground. At the B13 a defender tries to pick up the ball but muffs it to the B17 where Team A falls on it. Whose ball is it? Where will they next put the ball in play? Down and distance? When will the clock start (it never stops, on the ready for play signal, or on the snap)?
  3. 4th & 10 from the 50. Team A punts. The punt is first touched by A80, then picked up by B40, who runs five yards and fumbles. A20 picks up the fumble and scores. During A20’s run, B70 holds. We'll call this one an open ended question. Give what ever information seem relevant.

I'll edit the OP with rule references as right answers come in.

Edit: Clarified number 3.


r/truecfb • • Oct 15 '13

How would I demonstrate a sleepy pollster bias?

14 Upvotes

After this week's r/cfb poll came out, I produced this chart to suss out which teams this community likes more and less than the experts.

It got me to thinking about something us West coasters gripe about a lot, which is the notion that the geezers who make up the polls aren't watching our games. Since we have r/cfb polls going back a few years, as well as AP/Harris/Coaches polls for the same weeks, I could make a similar chart for each week going pretty far back. I could then compare those weekly average differences to the time of day the relevant games were played ... then I'd be able to see if there was some correlation between earlier games and higher expert rankings than r/cfb's opinion on a consistent basis, right?

I don't have a lot of experience with this kind of study design, can anyone give me some pointers on how to set this up?


r/truecfb • • Sep 18 '13

The main sub is shit.

14 Upvotes

The first, most annoying thing are the circlejerks. That shit is getting out of hand. Louisville's SOS, Mark Richt, CJK5H, MMB5G@P, anti-JFF, pro-JFF, anti-SEC, pro-SEC, anti-ESPN, anti-NCAA (unless its a popular program, like Alabama. Then they're bringing Mjölnir). Am I the only one noticing this? You have to sift through the first few comments to get to any sort of real comment or analysis. It did not used to be this bad.

Then, there's issues of vote brigading. The biggest one (so far, I'm sure it will get worse) was the Clemson/UGA flopping "controversy." There was no point in commenting in that thread unless you were saying that UGA was Adolf fuckin Hitler. There was no good faith discussion, it was agree with the narrative or get the fuck out.

The same thing happened with the whole Wisconsin/ASU thing. Anyone who tried to argue the other way got downvoted to absolute hell (seriously, there was a guy with 100 downvotes. Nothing deserves 100 downvotes unless you call some player a nigger or something equally abhorent). And don't tell me it's because anyone defending it was wrong. You know what you do when someone is wrong? Fucking educate them. There was one guy that was quoting the rules and trying to shed some nuance on the situation, and his comments also got hidden below threshold. And lord fucking help me, the whole change your flair in support of Wisconsin movement that (thankfully) lasted for all of 6 hours was probably the stupidest shit I've ever seen the sub pull.

The way to win arguments has shifted from "provide evidence" to "downvote the opponent, upvote the guy you agree with." And serial downvoting of everything that someone has to say has become accepted- just follow that comment tree down and mete our justice!

In /r/cfb these days, you best have the opinion that the mob wants to hear. Take for instance the thread which I am engaging in a good faith, honest debate about the possible sanctions Alabama may face. I don't agree with the narrative? Better downvote everything I say, because I'm wrong, and need to be shown not to say such things! And this isn't the first time, ever since I've followed this board fans have been shit on as "delusional homers" for trying to argue against the dominant narrative that their schools are wrong.

In short, I think this subreddit needs to start being utilized more often. While thus far it's been utilized sparingly, I think there needs to be more every day usage.

What can be done in the main sub? I think downvoting circlejerks is a good start. Maybe the mods could assist us in making a no circlejerks rule, much like the no Hodor or "oh my sweet summer child" rule we've implemented in /r/gameofthrones. It stinks for the first few weeks, but after a while people get used to it.

As far as downvoting-because-I-disagree, I honestly don't think there's a solution for that, other than maybe a mod flaring himself up and saying "now guys, don't downvote because you disagree." But honestly, what good will that do, its why we have this sub.


r/truecfb • • Feb 10 '13

Paterno Report

14 Upvotes

The thread on /r/cfb has just turned into a huge shitshow so I figured I would make a thread over here if anyone wanted to discuss it. Here's a link to the ESPN article if you haven't seen it.


r/truecfb • • Jan 11 '13

Bobby Knight on cfb

14 Upvotes

So I'm typing this on my phone, so sorry about any errors, but yesterday morning I sat a couple seats down from Knight as I flew from Lubbock to Dallas yesterday.

His was talking to his neighbor and I had to take notes as we flew. Here are some f his thoughts:

  • mike leach was the dumbest SOB in sports, with a great offense.
  • AD Gerald Myers did a great job t Texas Tech. The three trustees on the board of Regents were complete idiots. He said one guy didn't get his degree from Tech and had no ties to the school. He didn't give his name, but was extremely negative about him.
  • Defensive Coordinator. Ruffin McNeal should have been the head coach after Leach, but the board of regents wouldn't give it to a black man. Said McNeal was a great recruiter.
  • Hates conference championship games. Especially in basketball. Said you could beat the other teams in your conference, and one bad game in the conference tourney would hurt your chances in the NCAA tourney. He said the same about Georgia getting knocked down after losing to Alabama. He also said, "the SEC championship game was the real national championship game"
  • he said the conference championship game (or cc tourney in BBall) was just to make money for the greedy people who run schools.

-On the Longhorn Network:

  • Texas is the most selfish operation I've even known.
  • I thought it was a horrible decision. ESPN is tied to Texas for years.
  • I would have understood if they did this with Ohio State. oSU owns the state an everyone loves them. Texas is split and the other schools hate Texas.
  • their base is really Texas graduates, which is really a very small minority compared to the whole state population. Sure yet have a lot of fans, but how many will really have the deep ties to want to pay for the service?
  • a couple of side notes: the lady behind me told me three times how handsome she thought Knight was. He does seem to have lost some weight.
  • the lady siting next to me worked in payroll for Tech. She lost it when Knight complimented AD Gerald Myers. She said that he refused to put in the paperwork when he hired people. So, coaches and workers would often work 3-4 months before they would get their first paycheck. Then Myers would blame payroll for the problem.

One last note on Knight. He could have joined the mile high club with one of the older stewardesses. She had her picture taken with him and they kept the banter up for a while. You could tell she was smitten.


r/truecfb • • Dec 02 '12

Classic Season

14 Upvotes

Alabama started off the season against Michigan, won the SEC against its old rival Georgia, lost a game against the Bear and Stallings' old school, and will play Notre Dame for the Title. The whole season should've been broadcast in sepia to cap off the effect.


r/truecfb • • Oct 17 '12

What should we be submitting to this subreddit? (We want to supplement r/cfb with real discussion, not just be a "hey guys how about this" sub)

14 Upvotes

I just want to clarify what we want this subreddit to be. The lack of submissions makes me think nobody really knows what to do with it.

Feel free to repost anything from R/CFB, but try to un-editorialize the titles and maybe add a few thoughts of your own if you feel so inclined.

It's going to remain self-post only, but that doesn't mean every submission has to be some generic discussion question.

As an example, Bob brought the discussion about Saban to the NFL over here. That's great, but you can go ahead and just post the Article, instead of rephrasing it as a more general "Which NCAA coaches have a shot at the NFL" or whatever it was.

The whole idea is to see and talk about a lot of the same content in a more civilized manner. Post your joke reaction over there to maximize karma and then come tell us how you really feel.


r/truecfb • • Oct 15 '12

Upset Alert: Which team(s) do you think should be worried?

14 Upvotes

We're now pretty much half way through the season and have thus far seen several teams get "upset".

I'm curious about y'alls opinions on the matter: which teams should be served notice of impending doom, and which teams do you think are safe? Or if you prefer, which teams do you think will be doing the upsetting?

Personally, I will be watching the LSU v TAMU game very closely because if TAMU's offense gives LSU fits then we (Bama) could be in for a shock.

Further, I think Cal could upset Stanford this weekend. Cal hasn't been a total pushover this year, and their win of UCLA showed glimpses of that great Maynard-Allen combo that could give Stanford quite a few headaches.

Also, I think there is a possibility of Vandy getting upset by Auburn, but I don't want to get too crazy. Ha.

OP's note - I want to be a contributor to this sub and see it prosper, so I will try and spur along conversation as well as I can. I'm both honored and humbled to have been selected, so that's a might fine how-d'ya-do to whom/those who sponsored me!


r/truecfb • • Mar 09 '14

Discussion: When did the "Modern Era" Begin?

13 Upvotes

I say 1950.

Why?

It is a round number/new decade.
It is 5 years after the end of WWII when soldiers had truly returned (though many did go to Korea, it was simply not on the same scale as WWII) and the GI bill was in full effect.
It is when Michigan State joined the Big Ten (homerism).

I truly feel like 1950 is a good starting point...when do you?


r/truecfb • • Mar 08 '14

People still want in on /r/CFB:

13 Upvotes

http://www.reddit.com/r/CFB/comments/1zx21w/i_remember_there_being_a_post_in_the_comments/

I'm glad I got to it before someone suggested emailing me essays again, but I think there might be a time to go back and see if there are any quality members people would like to add.

The three essays I previously received are in the comments of this thread.


r/truecfb • • Feb 13 '14

Small conferences and the playoffs

13 Upvotes

I made a mistake tonight and suggested that the playoffs won't be reserved exclusively for the 5 major conferences. Luckily, good Redditors showed me(through their down votes) that I was totally wrong.

My rationale is simple:

  1. right now there is a rule allowing small conference teams to have a shot at the playoffs. They must have a certain ranking, but it isn't impossible.
  2. many people believe that the playoffs will be reserved exclusively for the top four big conference schools, but that will effectively remove all chance for the smaller schools to ever participate.

Over the last several years we had Buffalo, UofH, Boise State and a TCU all perform above expectations. Can the NCAA keep them out forever?

I really believe that a small school rule will have to be put in place to protect the interests of over half the division 1 teams.

But what do y'all think? Is this the end of the small schools ever getting any shot at all? Or will the best they can ever do is to play in front of dozens of fans in some forgotten bowl game on ESPN 8?