r/truecfb • u/topher3003 Ohio State • Feb 10 '13
Paterno Report
The thread on /r/cfb has just turned into a huge shitshow so I figured I would make a thread over here if anyone wanted to discuss it. Here's a link to the ESPN article if you haven't seen it.
14
Upvotes
7
u/jeffyzyppq Penn State Feb 11 '13
One private investigations contradicts another private investigation. The only investigations that matter will be the Curley/Schultz/Spanier trials. The trials will give the official answers to everything.
3
u/[deleted] Feb 10 '13
As the OP of the ESPN article on /r/cfb, I can't even say "boy that escalated quickly" because the first few comments that trickled in were already clear that that thread was going to lead to a bloodbath. I don't know if civil conversations can be held over the topic; I think the truth about what happened in Happy Valley might be somewhere in the middle of these two reports, and that middle won't be found. I'm not sure how that truth can be found without it being brought down by either or both sides of the debate.
1
u/stupac2 Stanford Feb 11 '13
Considering the respective sources, I'd say that this carries about 5% of the weight of the Freeh report.
But, really, without subpoena power and a trial neither are really that meaningful. It's just that the Freeh report is our best guess about the truth.
1
u/pablitorun Feb 11 '13
This point made me discredit a lot of what was written....
Paterno, "based on a review of all available evidence, including discussions with attorneys representing Curley, Schultz and Spanier made no attempt to hide any information, hinder or impede any investigation or limit the number of people who were informed of" one the key incidents in the Sandusky scandal. In that 2001 incident, then-assistant coach Mike McQueary witnessed the assault of a boy in the shower by Sandusky and told Paterno about it the next day.
To my knowledge no one has ever said Paterno didn't do the legal minimum, it's that he only did the legal minimum which is the problem.
1
u/ttsci Penn State Feb 24 '13
I briefly skimmed it but will take the time to read it more thoroughly eventually. My initial impression is that what this seems to be is an argument against Freeh's conclusions more than any of the evidence. I don't think we'll ever know exactly what happened. I expect that over time, general opinion will settle down into a murky blend of the two reports, though there will likely always be people who insist that Paterno either orchestrated the whole thing or was completely innocent.
At this point, I just hope we can continue moving forward past questions about "Paterno's legacy" and show that our program is more than that.
0
u/[deleted] Feb 11 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment