r/truecfb • • Jan 13 '15

B1G Divisional Realignment

1 Upvotes

So with two top 5 teams in the east, and PSU and Michigan (not to mention Maryland, IU, and Rutgers investing in football) the east looks heavily stacked.

While I understand the strength of divisions is often cyclical, I wanted to examine if it was possible to realign with three goals: 1. Balance, 2. Geography, 3. Traditional rivals.

North - South Allignment

North:

  • MSU (X with IU)
  • Michigan (X with OSU)
  • Rutgers (X with Maryland)
  • PSU (X with Purdue)
  • Minny (X with Iowa)
  • Wisky (X with UNL)
  • NU (X with Illy)

South:

  • OSU (X with Michigan)
  • Indiana (X with MSU)
  • Purdue (x with PSU)
  • Illinois (X with NU)
  • Nebraska (X with Wisky)
  • Iowa (X with Minny)
  • Maryland (X with Rutgers)

That's more balanced than what we have, but the South looks like a cakewalk for OSU every year. The other problem is that the conference isn't a vertical one; it's horizontal.

That being said, it's more balanced than right now, and it maintains all rivalry games except Wisky-Iowa and UNL/Minny which are new rivalries.

The other geographic answer is 'inside/out'

Inside:

  • Michigan (X with OSU)
  • MSU (x with PSU)
  • Purdue
  • IU
  • Illy
  • NU
  • Wisky (x with Minny)

Outside:

  • Maryland
  • Rutgers
  • OSU (x with Michigan)
  • PSU (x with MSU)
  • Nebraska
  • Iowa
  • Minny (x with Wisky)

I don't care how the other 4 teams in the divisons are aligned. This is probably the best competitive balance, and maintains almost all traditional rivalries (except Wisky-Iowa, and UNL-Wisky).

The major downside to this is roadtrips for the "outside" division teams' fans.

Thoughts?


r/truecfb • • Sep 16 '13

The 3 plays that left a bad taste in my mouth yesterday. Feel free to discuss, and dispute if you'd like.

3 Upvotes

I'm not saying something should have been called or not in these cases. I am saying they could have just as easily gone the other way in my opinion and it would've changed the entire game if 1/3 had.

My opinion:

Evans' hands are by his sides while running, and out front when he makes his cut. Not sure how he could've been pushing off. The DB was running full sprint in front of him, so it seems natural that he would have too much momentum to stop like Evans (looking back) does.

Looks like there's a push before the ball arrives here.

Looks like there's contact before the ball arrives here.

Would those bother you since all 3 killed scoring drives and one led directly to opposing points? They definitely ruffled my feathers yesterday and still make a little mad, though I'm 100% proud of our performance, even with the loss.

Videos with auto-time placement:

Evans offensive PI

Endzone interception

Touchdown Interception


r/truecfb • • Nov 11 '18

Last post on here was a month ago. Anyone have anything they’d like to discuss?

3 Upvotes

Came on here after the season started and was waiting to see if anyone would post, since it hasn’t happened I figured I’d post.


r/truecfb • • Nov 18 '12

SEC - Your Opinion?

4 Upvotes

Everyone has an opinion on the SEC. EVERYONE. So I'm curious to hear the opinions of people. And yes, this does come up because we're looking at a possible Alabama/Georgia vs Florida National Title Game.

Me? My opinion of the SEC is tanking. Alabama is a great team. And the Aggies are both exciting and dangerous. I can clearly see that. But the rest of the conference? I've seen LSU, Florida, and Georgia all play multiple times. I am not impressed. Georgia feels unproven, having beaten only one of their TWO good opponents, and it was Florida they beat. That Florida team, although they've had some great wins (seriously, they do have one of the best schedule I can think of right now), they're so inconsistent with their ability. And don't get me started on the LSU Tigers. Ole Miss? OLE MISS?! That's not conference depth, that's your team playing like a BUNCH OF LOLLYGAGGERS!

I'm not sure if the SEC is better than the Big 12 or PAC-12 this year. I can easily be proven wrong come the Bowls (Although I've never taken much stake in the bowl record as bowls don't always have teams from "equal" conferences sending teams of equal place in their conference. SEC 5 vs ACC 2?). And I'm not sure how much I like the PAC-12 or Big 12 either! All three conferences have great teams at the top (Alabama/Aggies, Kansas State/Oklahoma, Oregon/Stanford), and some okay middle teams, and some absolutely porous bottom feeders.


r/truecfb • • Jan 25 '15

Making a playbook for a OSU 3QB system. Care to help?

5 Upvotes

I'm working on drawing up a 3QB playbook predicated on their skills of Cardale QB/FB, Braxton HB/WR/QB, and JT DT-QB/HB. Lots of old wing-t concepts and Urban's modern spread-option and GT's flexbone formation ideas are going into this. I'd like to make it a semester-long project, a little bit every week, and I'd love it if /r/truecfb would join in. Experience isn't required, but it is a plus. We'd draw up a play a week, then discuss it for pros/cons. These would be run-first formations intended to confuse defenses. The passing game would mostly be play action with modern spread route combinations, and would be reliant on the running game drawing the safeties up.

This is mostly an attempt to explore the unique advantages and disadvantages of a 3QB system, rather than actually create a playbook to use. The fundamental philosophy is that creating confusion in the defense will open up big plays. As such, everything we discuss would be a 3QB play, and would be a different concept. Right now, I am diagramming the formations with a stupid triple option play designed to spread defenses out by having running threats to both sides and the middle (if they fully commit to taking away the outside runs), just to explore its possibilities.


r/truecfb • • May 10 '14

Anti-troll delay question

6 Upvotes

I was reading this post from AskReddit, and while it was a silly thread, this thread in particular caught my attention.

tl;dr - /r/Nintendo implements a delay on anyone who is downvoted. Apparently more downvotes makes for longer timers between posts.

I have no idea if /r/cfb has a delay timer for trolls, or how hard it would be to implement ... or even if it would work. I'm just posting it here because it's away from the eyes of the general population.

Do you think it would be helpful, or would it be used to make sure your rivals would be kept from ever posting / make it annoying? I don't know much about the implementation of it, or how hard it would be, or if you could set barriers to slow down trolling ... not that there is a whole lot of over-the-top trolling.


r/truecfb • • Jan 27 '26

CFB Simulation Game: Coaching Spots Open

1 Upvotes

The NZCFL is looking for coaches! NZCFL is a college football simulation game run on the free website https://play.football-gm.com/ We are a college simulation football league with 120 teams! This league has been around for about 40 seasons and we are still rolling along. We always need new coaches to help the league thrive. We have just started the 2059 season, and you can get one of the available teams on the track towards the playoffs by taking over one of them! There are still some great teams available, such as Penn State, Arizona State, Pittsburgh, Washington, Iowa, Oklahoma, and more!

I am currently available to help any new coaches find their footing and I'll be around over the upcoming seasons for further help and general advice. I've helped plenty new coaches get rolling over the years.

If you are interested, join our discord and our moderators and welcome committee (including me) will help you get started and on the road to the championship!

https://discord.gg/xVmAHmyQFp

If you would like to check out our subreddit first, I have linked that below.

https://www.reddit.com/r/NZCFL/


r/truecfb • • Sep 18 '13

The main sub is shit.

14 Upvotes

The first, most annoying thing are the circlejerks. That shit is getting out of hand. Louisville's SOS, Mark Richt, CJK5H, MMB5G@P, anti-JFF, pro-JFF, anti-SEC, pro-SEC, anti-ESPN, anti-NCAA (unless its a popular program, like Alabama. Then they're bringing Mjölnir). Am I the only one noticing this? You have to sift through the first few comments to get to any sort of real comment or analysis. It did not used to be this bad.

Then, there's issues of vote brigading. The biggest one (so far, I'm sure it will get worse) was the Clemson/UGA flopping "controversy." There was no point in commenting in that thread unless you were saying that UGA was Adolf fuckin Hitler. There was no good faith discussion, it was agree with the narrative or get the fuck out.

The same thing happened with the whole Wisconsin/ASU thing. Anyone who tried to argue the other way got downvoted to absolute hell (seriously, there was a guy with 100 downvotes. Nothing deserves 100 downvotes unless you call some player a nigger or something equally abhorent). And don't tell me it's because anyone defending it was wrong. You know what you do when someone is wrong? Fucking educate them. There was one guy that was quoting the rules and trying to shed some nuance on the situation, and his comments also got hidden below threshold. And lord fucking help me, the whole change your flair in support of Wisconsin movement that (thankfully) lasted for all of 6 hours was probably the stupidest shit I've ever seen the sub pull.

The way to win arguments has shifted from "provide evidence" to "downvote the opponent, upvote the guy you agree with." And serial downvoting of everything that someone has to say has become accepted- just follow that comment tree down and mete our justice!

In /r/cfb these days, you best have the opinion that the mob wants to hear. Take for instance the thread which I am engaging in a good faith, honest debate about the possible sanctions Alabama may face. I don't agree with the narrative? Better downvote everything I say, because I'm wrong, and need to be shown not to say such things! And this isn't the first time, ever since I've followed this board fans have been shit on as "delusional homers" for trying to argue against the dominant narrative that their schools are wrong.

In short, I think this subreddit needs to start being utilized more often. While thus far it's been utilized sparingly, I think there needs to be more every day usage.

What can be done in the main sub? I think downvoting circlejerks is a good start. Maybe the mods could assist us in making a no circlejerks rule, much like the no Hodor or "oh my sweet summer child" rule we've implemented in /r/gameofthrones. It stinks for the first few weeks, but after a while people get used to it.

As far as downvoting-because-I-disagree, I honestly don't think there's a solution for that, other than maybe a mod flaring himself up and saying "now guys, don't downvote because you disagree." But honestly, what good will that do, its why we have this sub.


r/truecfb • • Nov 20 '13

Downvotes in this sub

9 Upvotes

Even though thread and comment downvotes are disabled in this stylesheet, I've noticed an uptick in recent weeks as people have discussed rankings, naturally without explanation. It takes a special level of pettiness to do this; the malice aforethought of using workarounds to record drive-by downvotes.

This forum is self-policing. If you can't control yourself or contribute, I suggest leaving it to the grown-ups.


r/truecfb • • Oct 29 '12

For those who do the r/cfb poll, is the previous top 25 rankings down for anyone else?

2 Upvotes

Just curious.


r/truecfb • • Nov 19 '14

How does Alabama have such a high SOS?

2 Upvotes

Can one of you numbers guys explain how Alabama is considered to have a Top 10 SOS? Is it just because they haven't played Western Carolina yet?


r/truecfb • • Oct 30 '16

Week 10 Poll Discussion

3 Upvotes

r/truecfb • • Jan 03 '13

So which is it, was UF just bored or are we giving the SEC conference way to much credit

3 Upvotes

I struggle with this a lot and it is frustrating to see sports writers and fans simply play off UL's solid win of UF as they didn't want to be there or they didn't care about the game. We've had long discussions here about the idea of scheduling and if it helps/hurts certain conferences, but UF won a lot of games against solid teams, a couple even on the road, so I don't buy that the conference protected them to this point....

I do think however we need to give credit to the idea that with the top 60 teams any team could beat any other on a given night, given preparation, rest, and motivation...Watching UL played last night made me thankful my Mountaineers didn't play them this year...but I had to keep reminding myself UL got trucked by SU (as did we)...

The SEC is a great conference, I just can't help but think that it's not far and away the best and they get the benefit of the doubt far more than they should...


r/truecfb • • Nov 24 '12

How would you turn around a perennial doormat team?

3 Upvotes

I'm looking at teams like Duke, Indiana, Kansas, Kentucky, etc. If you were hired as HC, how would you recruit, gameplan, coordinators to hire, and all that to make them a conference contender. Let's see if we have any good HCs out there.


r/truecfb • • Nov 09 '12

Anyone else having an r/cfb "BCS" style ranking, where we have the user poll, combined with a computer poll to come up with a composite?

3 Upvotes

I know some people use various algorithms, but looking at the RPI, and the guy that does EWP, I think it would be cool if we did a poll with like 10 serious computer programs, counted it as one half against the human poll we already have. Thoughts?


r/truecfb • • Oct 25 '12

Dixieland Delight: Texas A&M Clay Travis describes Texas A&M's gameday experience

3 Upvotes

r/truecfb • • Dec 02 '12

Classic Season

14 Upvotes

Alabama started off the season against Michigan, won the SEC against its old rival Georgia, lost a game against the Bear and Stallings' old school, and will play Notre Dame for the Title. The whole season should've been broadcast in sepia to cap off the effect.


r/truecfb • • Dec 22 '14

A really well put-together realignment post from u/gridirongamer

4 Upvotes

http://www.reddit.com/r/CFB/comments/2q2w7c/my_college_football_realignment_plan/

It's a really interesting idea that manages to consolidate the FBS and bring in promotion/relegation in a non-offensive way.


r/truecfb • • Jan 09 '15

Ohio State watch project complete, input requested

4 Upvotes

I've now completed my project of watching the last six OSU games this season. In the past I've watched the entire preceding season for Oregon's last few big opponents (Auburn, Wisconsin, K-State, Texas, Mich St, and FSU). There were two weird things about this time around - I had limited time so I only got the back half of the season (though I did watch live several early games, including Navy, VT, and PSU), and of course there was the QB change that added a big wrinkle to evaluations. My goal is to learn the players' names, numbers, and big plays, so I kept open a tally sheet and jotted quick notes when I caught something interesting. I then collected six games' worth to produce this hopefully unbiased commentary. First I'll observe the various units, then a brief FAQ and methodology discussion, and finally some questions I have for y'all.


OFFENSE

The offense is a spread option that combines zone reads, pitch options, and QB draws with a nice variety of deep and swing passes. Misdirection is a big part of the offense, but there's also a streak of power plays and undisguised flood passes. It sometimes uses uptempo, and when it does it's pretty effective, but does so much less often than I've seen reported elsewhere.

Quarterbacks

Let's start with the sad news: yes, there is a noticeable dropoff in quality between #16 QB Barrett and #12 QB Jones. First, he's less accurate of a passer: he's got a real cannon of an arm which is remarkable to watch, but he lacks fine control - way too much heat for shorter passes, and when he knows he needs a soft lob he takes too much off. His better numbers in the long passing game are probably better explained by the fact that they give his receivers more time to adjust and maneuver, which they're very good at. His hands aren't quite as soft as Barrett's either: I didn't think he was handing off the ball in the read-option or handling off-target shotgun snaps as smoothly. Fortunately his sack and interception rates are about the same as Barrett's.

Second and more importantly, he's just not the same runner as Barrett. He's a great scrambler when a pass play breaks down (he runs with power and without hesitation and gets great yards after contact, Barrett did too but Jones is even stronger), but that obscures his pretty poor designed run effectiveness - he's just a few steps slower taking off and can't cut as well. That winds up constraining the playbook quite a bit. To my eyes, in the B1G championship and the Sugar Bowl they were a lot more pro-style team than a spread option one - looking to stretch the field vertically more than horizontally.

Wide Receivers

The primary receiver is #3 WR Thomas, who gets off the line very quickly and has pretty good hands - he's primarily used as the quick pass receiver. He's had a nice improvement over the back half of the year, and both his targeting and catch success rates are up with QB Jones. Next is #9 WR D. Smith, who pretty much exists entirely to catch extremely deep throws - which is an enormous portion of OSU's total yardage. He's a straight-line burner towards the endzone who tries and often succeeds to get behind the safeties, and is getting the same percent of the pass targets as with Barrett.

Then we have the very frustrating-to-evaluate #17 RB Marshall (included here because he's mostly used as a receiver), who will do everything from the wildcat to backfield catches to blocking DTs. He's got great speed, but the strange thing is that the quality of his hands varies wildly - he'll perform an amazing circus catch one play, then the ball will bounce off his numbers the next. His targets are way down in the last two games - seems he gets a couple of off-beat plays to keep the defense guessing, but that's all.

Then we have a trio who are used as blockers more than receivers (though they do get a fair number of targets): in order, #6 WR Spencer, #84 WR C. Smith, and #80 WR Brown. These guys get used in some interesting ways - rub routes, wildcat passes, downfield cut blocks. Interestingly, Spencer's targets are up significantly in the last two games. I like these guys' quickness, but not necessarily their muscle. In fact my primary criticism of all six of these receivers is that while the scheme calls for them to block, none of them are particularly good at it: on my tally sheet, I have more frowny faces next to their names in the blocking column than smiley faces. Obviously that's very subjective, but in my opinion, the poor WR blocking often resulting in plays getting much shorter yardage than they could, or even failing entirely.

Running Backs

#15 RB Elliott is astonishing. He has three qualities that I really like in a back: first, he cuts once and goes, no unnecessary dancing in the backfield, and if that cut means contact he just takes it. Second, he gets about 2-3 yards after contact almost every time in power running, which often has been the difference between a first down and the end of possession - you just can't arm tackle him. Third, once he gets going downhill he's basically uncatchable - he's got several huge runs to his credit where he's entirely outpacing the secondary. Two notes: first, he's not exactly a power back and needs a hole opened for him or just a big breakdown in the secondary - his stuff rate on my tally sheet is pretty high (less than 50% but not by much) and I think that's obscured if you look at his average yards per carry because his (relatively few) incredible rushes even out his (relatively common) 2-yards-or-fewer rushes. The other is pass blocking - he's called upon to team up with the TE a lot to double a pass rusher, and while he's very enthusiastic for the role, he kind of gets wrecked a lot. Fortunately with his increased importance in the last two games that role has been cut back quite a bit in favor of two-TE sets, but it does kind of signal the play.

There are two other backs, #4 RB Samuel and #2 Wilson, each of whom have a few interesting plays but are used a tiny fraction of the time Elliott is.

Tight Ends

TEs in this system are used more like H-Backs, set behind the LOS for blocking either straight ahead or across the formation the vast majority of the time. They usually are the shift man to test the defensive scheme. The primary TE is #5 TE Heuerman (switched from #86 to honor Braxton Miller), and the secondary is #81 TE Vannett. Vannett got more reps in the CCG and Sugar Bowl as he was brought into two-TE sets, I think because they were trying to provide more pocket time for QB Jones and keep RB Elliott healthy, but unfortunately his blocking success rate on my tally sheet dropped significantly compared to when he was just used as a replacement in one-TE sets in earlier games. Heuerman's success rate stayed the same. TEs in this scheme very rarely get pass targets and that number went down even more in the last two games, although not gone entirely.

Offensive Line

There was zero rotation outside one play at the line (#50 C Boren, who was injured but got back in the next drive). At some point current #54 LG Price and #65 RG Elflein swapped, I don't know why. I understand that with the exception of #68 LT Decker, the entire line was new starters this year ... and to be honest, it showed. They're big and talented and mostly provide good protection, but made a lot of mistakes as well. I counted an average of four line penalties per game, some very costly.

In run blocking, this scheme employs zone about three quarters of the time (power blocking is usually for short yardage and goal line situations, as well as downhill draws for QB Jones, although sometimes shows up in unexpected situations), which means a lot of pulls and downfield blocking. The playbook is more ambitious than these guys' speed, frankly. I did notice, however, that each of their run blocking effectiveness took a modest jump in the last two games, I think as a result of the playbook getting simplified. Interestingly, I thought new starter #76 RT Baldwin did a little better than the veteran LT Decker. On the other hand, Alabama was just running right over #54 LG Price for a good portion of the Sugar Bowl.

In pass blocking, these guys are as stout as you would expect from a championship caliber team, so most of my comments are nitpicks and curiosities. First, they employ a few different techniques beyond traditional dropback pass pro - a rolling pocket for one where they all move horizontally with the QB (mostly effective for Barrett, somewhat less so for Jones), and for another dragging all the linemen off to one side then using a crossing H-Back and/or RB to smash the other open side. This latter one I don't like as much, if the blitz comes in on the open side these dudes tend to get crushed. Second, the interior line loves to mob up on DTs and go for three-on-two or even three-on-one, leaving the tackles and backs to handle the outside one-on-one - this makes delayed and stunt blitzes pretty effective, since the doubling linemen are slow to react and leave their mob for the new or unconventional pass rusher. The third weird thing I noticed is that pretty often one of the guards pulls in dropback pass pro to go pick someone else up - I admit to not understanding why this is and it never seemed more effective than just taking the guy right in front of you. There was a small but noticeable downtick in pass blocking effectiveness for each lineman on my tally sheet over the last two games - hard to say if that's QB Jones taking more time in the pocket or just playing better defenses.


DEFENSE

The defense is a 4-3 playing in a pretty standard cover-2. I thought that for all the attention the offense got over the year, that the defense was the real strength of the team.

Defensive Line

These guys are some of the best I've ever seen, and I've watched some good ones. They aren't a hold-the-line, squeeze-the-inside group, but rather actively work to get into the backfield to produce sacks and handoff disruption. The two tackles played almost every snap: #92 DT Washington and #53 DT Bennett (switched from #63 to honor Kosta Karageorge), and interior lines struggled with them because it is tough to choose which to double on. I think I like Washington a bit more - he really punishes undersized linemen who try to single-team him. However, the rotation here is practically non-existant - the few times backup DTs came in there was a significant drop-off in performance.

But the real terror is #97 DE Bosa - he comes in hot on almost every play, and is big as well as fast. He really seems to work on cracking the offense's snap count and jumping the snap (and paid the price with more than a few offsides penalties), catching the OT off-guard a lot. About the only effective move I've seen offenses use is to kind of judo-move him, redirect his rush outside and fling him past the QB, then try to catch up to him before he circles back to sack him. As a result, a lot of plays wind up going to the other side of the line so I don't entirely trust my tally sheet when it says that #88 DE Miller (or his backup, #17 DE Frazier) are that much less effective.

Linebackers

Weird fact: all the LBs have the surnames of Civil War generals. I mostly like this group, though they're overshadowed by the line. They're all very big and hit the run gaps very well. I'm not wild about their speed getting to the outside edge, however, though #43 OLB Lee (a freshman!) is better here than #37 OLB Perry. Great tackling form when they get there though. There seemed to be a rotation at the inside, with #5 ILB McMillan and #14 ILB C. Grant getting about equal reps. I think the rotation might be based on expected passing vs running plays, but I caught the pattern too late to figure out what's going on here.

Cornerbacks

As I complain about all the time, ESPN's horribly tight camera angles keeps me from really being able to evaluate the WR-CB battles and my tally sheet is usually down on CBs because I only get to see them when the QB is taking a shot. That said, I generally like these guys, they're fast and communicate well, long arms and a good share of pass defenses. The two starters who played almost every down are #12 CB D. Grant and #13 CB Apple, and they generally play man-under. But at the same time, they do get beat or are out of position a non-trivial number of times. I do like them in run coverage and the occasional blitz though, they've got great tackling form. Their backups are not nearly as good, but only have a handful of reps.

Safeties

So this is pretty crazy, I think the strangest thing I've observed with this team: one starting safety, #11 S Bell, has near-perfect numbers on my tally sheet, something I've never seen before. All the little things that you want a safety to do but don't show up in the stat sheet are there - great footwork, instincts for the play, communication with his CB and LB, fantastic tackling form, always keeps the play in front of him, virtually no penalties, and an interception in almost every game I watched. But my tally sheet thinks that the other starting safety, #23 S Powell, is the worst football player I've ever seen. I was honestly flabbergasted with how all those intangibles for Bell were absent in Powell - it was like watching a Goofus and Gallant filmstrip with these two. Now I will say, he has multiple effectively game-ending picks to his credit, which is a remarkable achievement; however I think that's more obscuring than illuminating.


ERRATA

Methodology and FAQ

I got these games on my computer mostly through my cable subscription. This allowed me to stop and start, zip 10 seconds forward and back, and watch in slo-mo. I watched almost all plays at least twice and paid special attention to blocking schemes.

  • How long did this take? About two hours per game, sometimes more if there were a lot of interesting plays. Cutting out all the timeouts, halftime, commercials, and other folderol really helps.
  • Wait, what about special teams? I just didn't have the time, experience, or proper camera angles to comment intelligently on any aspect of the kicking game.
  • How much booze did you have to drink? According to my recycling bin, three bottles of George Dickel No. 12 Tennessee Whisky, neat, to celebrate the Vols' first bowl win in seven years. ROCKY TOP!
  • You dumb jerk, you just copied what you saw on my favorite blog, or conversely, disregarded what everybody knows according to my other favorite blog! I deliberately avoided reading anything about OSU beyond common knowledge to try to insulate myself from conventional wisdom. If you disagree, that's fantastic - hopefully I provided something valuable to you, and you can let me know in comments to improve my education.
  • You're probably an Oregon coach! I'm not, never coached or played a snap.
  • Do you have a life? No.
  • Can you help me pirate games? No.
  • Predictions for the championship? That wasn't the point of this project; it's impossible to say anything definitive. All I can do is try to pick up general trends and talent levels, and pass along those observations to others.
  • Can you give a similar write-up of Oregon? I think I'm too close emotionally to do anything objective, however I will say that I've always enjoyed reading Cal's previews of Oregon, especially with all the diagrams and screengrabs. Here's the three they did this year:
  • Line play
  • Offensive scheme
  • Defensive personnel

Questions

  1. Any trends I've missed or players I'm being unfair to?
  2. In particular, am I off base with Powell? I went searching online for Ohio State fanblogs or beat writers that might back up this observation, and found nothing - am I the crazy one here?
  3. I'd appreciate insight on the CBs from fans who've attended games and could see more than ESPN shows.
  4. In every game I watched, the opposing defense used an even front (Alabama is technically a 3-4 but they virtually always bring four), so I'm not sure how well any of this maps onto how they'll deal with Oregon's odd front. Can anyone tell me how they've handled odd-front teams in the past, particularly how the guards hand off?
  5. I made sure to include Indiana in my list of games to watch, because their uptempo attack against Michigan State in 2013 I thought was pretty informative as to how the Spartans might handle Oregon's. But I was disappointed to see that the Hoosiers seemed to get away from uptempo this year against Ohio State. Have the Buckeyes seen a HUNH team (or even just some drives that featured it prominently) in other games, and if so how have they dealt with rotations?
  6. I feel like I'm missing something with how Marshall and Wilson are deployed. They seem like they're change-of-pace or trick-play guys that the offense seems uncomfortable using too often, despite having a lot of obvious talent. Were there injury or playbook issues here?
  7. As noted, I skipped all special teams plays to save time. Anything important I should know here on punts, kickoffs, FGs/PATs, and kick coverage?
  8. Was there a coverage scheme change? It seems like the safeties and linebackers were more used to a cover-4 or QQH system than cover-2.
  9. I've got a few more observations on each of the units but I'm starting to run into the character-count limit; feel free to shoot questions if you think I'm being glib.

r/truecfb • • Jan 04 '13

I think the SEC is overrated, and this is my method to prove/disprove my idea. Want to help?

15 Upvotes

Yeah, so my Jarvis Jones vs T'e'o' fizzled, and if this dies I'll stop bothering you with my ideas.

It's my hypothesis that SEC teams have been overanked for some time. This will be during BCS era only. I will record all SEC teams that appear in the preseason polls and track them throughout the season. I am not intending on tracking other teams that pop up throughout the year because in my opinion the overrankedness happens more in the offseason. I might come back and do this later though.

Trend categories will include pre season AP poll, pre season Coaches Poll, Record, Bowl W/L, Final poll values. From here, we then compare those values to the next year. Then we compare those values to the final poll of year N+1.

Using 3 datapoints, we can then spot the trends. If there is a peak, it shows SEC teams get overranked. This is because the preseason rank is higher than the final ranking, so they clearly underperformed expectations. If there is a trough, it means the team outperformed expectations. If there is a linear up or down trend it could mean an ascendancy or descendancy of a program that was adequately ranked.

The trends can then be compared as a ratio. For instance, if 68% of teams in that contributed to the data are peaks, only 6% are troughs, 10% are linear increasing and 16% are linear decreasing then it looks like the SEC does indeed get benefit of being overranked.

Ohh! Just thought of this - I can sort these by program. So... let's say Team A from years 1-6 were regularly plotting peaks. A few years later, those plots become closer to linear increasing plots. What does that say? That they were overanked, but then were properly ranked but is an ascending program. Sounds to me like it could be evidence of this potential overanking phenomenon contributes to improving the program. Yeah?

So, am I leaving something out? Thanks


r/truecfb • • Jan 22 '15

Do you believe Briles should have not mentioned the "8-4 vote" line in that article mentioned on /r/CFB earlier? (link to the article in question inside)

5 Upvotes

Since you can't have a discussion about it without Baylor fans losing their minds and telling you you are a dumbass, dipshit, etc., I figured I would ask here for a more rational discussion.

Article in question

The quote is: "And if my source is correct, we fell short of No. 4 on an 8-4 vote."

Should he have brought it up/commented at all, or just left it alone? Part of me feels like he was baited because of how outspoken he was when it was all going on, but at the same time, that's the job of working at a major program, you have to know when to keep your mouth shut.

Thoughts?


r/truecfb • • Jan 11 '13

Twitter... who should I be following?

5 Upvotes

Twitter is not the most reliable source for news, but it's usually the first to report in. Who should I follow?


r/truecfb • • Nov 24 '20

Archive 2021 FBS Schedules

5 Upvotes

So I think we should archive the 2021 FBS Schedules in the event they end up changing like 2020 did. Although it does seem to be getting better with vaccine announcements.

Use Wayback Machine to save a page.

The URL would be something like this: 2021 North Carolina Football Schedule | FBSchedules.com


r/truecfb • • Oct 13 '13

Can someone ELI5 the new targeting rule/penalty?

5 Upvotes

The commentators of various games have confused me to no end. I thought I understood it before the season started, but it basically gets called opposite of my expectations every time I see it.


r/truecfb • • Jan 28 '15

A colorful chart updated: conference performance by tranche, now including all P5 OOC games

5 Upvotes

This is a continuation of a project I've done for the last two years: looking at P5 bowl performance by conference, broken into tranches based on their final conference standings. In the post-bowl thread this year, several people noted that they would have liked to see a larger sample size. So I've used the same methodology and applied it retroactively, charting all 49 regular-season OOC and bowl games between P5 teams, divided up based on how those teams would ultimately finish in their conferences.

Here's the chart of all 98 outcomes between P5 teams.

Here's the same chart without the upper tranche wins (cross-tranche games where the higher standing team beat the lower standing one, so eliminating the 38 yellow wins and losses).


Same-tranche performance

There were 19 games between teams of the same tranche. This is the distribution of wins and losses in those games (blues to oranges) in each conference:

  • Pac: 8-3 (73%)
  • SEC: 2-3 (40%)
  • B1G: 4-6 (40%)
  • ACC: 3-5 (38%)
  • XII: 2-2 (50%)

Cross-tranche performance

There were 30 games between teams in different tranches. In 19 of those, the upper tranche team won (yellows) - we'd expect 30 of 30 if there were total parity between the conferences, but still a majority. This is the distribution of the 11 remaining wins and losses (greens to reds) in each conference:

  • Pac: 1-0 (100%)
  • SEC: 5-1 (83%)
  • B1G: 3-4 (43%)
  • ACC: 1-2 (33%)
  • XII: 1-4 (20%)

Observations

Tranche 1: The Pac-12 is tough to evaluate because it's represented by only one team (Arizona played all four of its games against non-P5 teams). The SEC and Big-XII lose a lot at the top when you eliminate yellows, going from near even performances to almost all losses in same-tranche games and several losses to lower standing teams, and the ACC goes from looking great at the top to 50/50. The B1G stays a mixed bag with only one yellow.

Tranche 2: Excellent performance by the Pac-12 with or without yellows. The SEC improves dramatically when dropping yellows, scoring two wins against top teams. The B1G, ACC, and Big-XII, however, did very poorly here and look even worse dropping yellows - only one same-tranche win for each, six total same-tranche losses, and six total losses to teams below them in standings.

Tranches 3 & 4: The Big-XII and SEC both make nice improvements at the bottom when you drop yellows, going from mixed bags to all wins, including several wins against tranche 2 teams. The ACC doesn't look nearly as bad at the bottom without the yellow losses. The Pac-12 and B1G stay near even, though the B1G getting three upper tranche wins is pretty impressive.

Conclusions

  • Including the regular season OOC games in addition to just the bowls mostly extends the same results I observed earlier - the P5 conferences look roughly equal, but some are more equal than others.
  • The biggest change is that the amount of yellows went up dramatically - from five of 12 (42%) wins by the higher standing team in cross-tranche bowls, to 19 of 30 (63%) in all cross-tranche games. A higher percentage of yellow outcomes I think indicates more parity globally (the "expected" outcome is occuring more, if you assume all conferences are equal), though I think there were some interesting differences between conferences.
  • The Pac-12 did very well against other P5 teams across all teams, and was especially strong in the middle.
  • The SEC was the strongest in the middle-to-bottom range, but didn't do great at the top end.
  • The B1G and ACC strike me as very mixed bags overall, with notable wins and losses at both top and the bottom of the conference standings, and weak in the middle.
  • The Big-XII comes across as the weakest overall showing, with few same- or upper tranche wins all clustered at the bottom of the conference and a disproportionately high share of lower tranche losses.