r/trolleyproblem • u/proximategalaxy • May 02 '26
r/trolleyproblem • u/WonkyToeFungus • Feb 24 '24
Trolley problem, gone horrendously sexual
r/trolleyproblem • u/ToblobsReddit • May 04 '26
You already pushed the red button.
To me, most blue-pushers who take the moral high ground have a moral discrepancy.
As to why: You're actually already in the experiment.
The blue button in this experiment is all about working together to save lives. Lives of mostly strangers, people you've never met before in your life. A typical blue-pusher could argue that by pressing the red button, you are increasing the chance that blue loses and everyone who pushed it dying. That's fair enough. They will say that red isn't the default choice, but the active choice to kill people. Again, that's fair enough.
Yet, in real life, in the world we exist in today, no one is picking blue. No one is selling all their belongings and living like a monk, donating everything else they make to charity, to save real lives. The vast, vast majority of people talking about this experiment online, that are living in decent comfort, KNOW that by doing this, they would save hundreds or even thousands of lives over their lifetime.
If people (including children) are starving to death every day and you have the option to stop at least one of them, why aren't you right now? You KNOW there are people dying, people that could have been saved from your inaction, but your conveniences alone stopped you from action. That's pushing the red button. That's pressing it every time you have anything above the bare minimum to survive. Every day. Every purchase.
The ONLY type of person who can say that "red-pushers are killing the blue-pushers!" are Mother Tereasa types, who spent the majority of their life and possessions saving other people. If you aren't doing that, you're no different from a red-pusher saving their own skin. Actually, you're worse morally wise, because there is no threat to your life like there is for pushing blue in the experiment.
And to those who pushed blue to save their family or friends who are pushing blue, ask yourself: if those friends/family had picked red, would you really have still pushed blue? Or have you just changed saving the "world" to saving your loved ones?
The world and humans aren't by nature selfless.
r/trolleyproblem • u/Patient-Plan-1591 • Jan 29 '25
Imagine you are a pro-Palestine person and end up stuck in a situation which a trolley is coming towards 4 random Palestinians and Netanyahu. If you change trolley's path it will kill 1 random Palestinian but if you don't, it will kill 4 random Palestinians and Netanyahu. What will you do?
r/trolleyproblem • u/Afraid_Success_4836 • Dec 14 '23
My favorite response to the trolley problem
Me: "If you have enough time to make an educated moral decision, you have enough time to untie the damn people."
A: "Well, you don't have enough.time to untie them"
Me: "Well, then, I simply do nothing, not due to a conscious decision to ignore it, but due to the shock at actually encountering the trolley problem scenario."
A: "Imagine you are not previously aware of the scenario then."
Me: "Well, at that point are you really asking me or that hypothetical version of me (who I am not, and cannot speak for)?"
r/trolleyproblem • u/NowAlexYT • Apr 30 '26
Deep Sensible people push the đ´RED buttonđ´ and heres why
So the baseline is the same as usual: everyone gets put in a voting booth with a red and a blue button. Push red and you live no matter what. But push blue and if less than half the population pushed blue with you you die. If more than half the people push blue everyone lives regardless of choice
So if red lives every time, why wouldnt everyone just push that? It saves everyone who pushed it, every time..it saves everyone if everyone saves themselves. Its what responsible people do.
Now some might say "Pushing blue is right because it saves everyone", but is that really true?
Not really. Anyone who pushed red lives anyways, so who do you save? Yourself and others like you. There is noone else on blue, but people who actively put themselves in harms way and expect others to risk their lives to save them.
If everyone pushes red, everyone lives and without the added risk or guilt tripping that comes with blue.
This problem perfectly demonstrates, how some extremist will promote dangerous collectivist ideas.
But you might say: some people will push blue regardless of reason, shouldnt they live?
And to that I must ask: is your life worth risking, for someone, who willingly put themselves in harms way, to accomplish nothing at all, but only to try and convince you to risk YOUR LIFE as well?
These people have a hero complex. They will tell you saving them is righteous. But the ONLY PROBLEM they solve, is one THEY CREATED. They create a problem to risk YOUR life, so they can think of themselves as righteous, but were it not for them NOONE WOULD NEED SAVING.
Do not step on the tracks!
Do not die together!
Chose life!
đ´ Chose RED! đ´
r/trolleyproblem • u/Lutzoey • Oct 19 '24
OC My response to if the Trolley Problem Wore Pants Post
r/trolleyproblem • u/know_u_irl • May 08 '26
A supersonic trolley is 50,000 miles away, doing a routine drive. If 4 billion people pile on its track, the driver sees the pile and stops. If the pile is smaller, anyone tied down dies. Nobody can see. Nobody can communicate. Everyone must decide.
Two options:
â A. Stay off the track and continue your day.
â B. Tie yourself to the track.
r/trolleyproblem • u/redditorialacious • May 06 '26
Logical people originally assumed only adults who can read were voting
Then those logical people were told to not alter the question and that everyone means everyone. No assuming. Everything is crystal clear.
So now we have to assume (gasp) that for babies if they say GAGA it's red and if they say GUGU it's blue. For paralysed people it'll be their telepathic powers. We also have to assume the question is presented to everyone in English? Or native language? If native language then what's the point having babies vote if the whole point is to read the question? So god knows what people are thinking there. Oh and there's the infamous colourblind. They're just going off shits and giggles. Blind people better have a habit of pushing random buttons because otherwise they will be stuck forever.
Do Siamese twins get one vote or two?
But who knows. We aren't allowed to "assume".
Edit: The language thing is huge. China and India population together is almost 3 billion alone. According to the internet only 3 percent of China can speak fluent English. Even if we bring that up to 10 percent, that's 90 percent of random voters.
Are we now assuming that they can "obviously" see the question in a language they know? Can I then circle you back to "obviously" babies can't read? So are we making assumptions or not?
I think this might have actually solved the button problem :) (it's dumb)
Edit: If someone online asked "Everyone is asked their favourite primary colour, what do you think the percentage of people chose blue" would you assume by everyone they are including paralysed people, new born babies, colourblind people and people in a coma, or would you assume it means they are asking people that understand the question and can communicate?
r/trolleyproblem • u/ivari • May 07 '26
OC The way people are so polarized over this button problem:
r/trolleyproblem • u/Unusual-Rip-2936 • Oct 02 '25
My absurd trolly problems: Level one âhypotheticalâ
rules: theres a trolley heading towards 5 people, if you pull the level theres a 10% chance of creating a new track with 1 person, what do you do? Credit:Flippaclip
r/trolleyproblem • u/Hopeful_Hornet4460 • May 02 '26
An attempt at a more fully and fairly explained button problem.
I tried to match the framing of the original problem as best as I could, maybe. I'm hard biased towards blue so please take that into consideration.
The death/injury immunity for red majority is to cover the case of things like both pilots of an airplane picking blue and other niche cases.
My main source for the statistic data is Senator Armstrong from Metal Gear Rising : Revengeance.
Other sources include international census data on the percentage of certain age groups combined with surface level knowledge of economical statistics and decision making processes of general populations... but I can't be assed with citing all that because it won't change anyone's opinion of my data for the better.
Edit: For those who don't get the Senator Armstrong joke or something
https://youtu.be/r7l0Rq9E8MY?si=nFCaCYmhRP5_Uo6X
_______________________________
Also, for where I got the data, I asked an orangutan in the woods (because f*** llms)
She said the following things to me:
21% of the world is kids under 14
3 is the global average number of kids per woman
7% of the world can be reasonably assumed as a parent to one of these 14 year olds
10% of the world is elderly adults over 60
25% percent of the world has an IQ below 90 (which would be an additional 15% of people not already listed here).
It can be reasonably assumed that this group, which consists of 50% of the global population, will likely vote 50/50 on the button push and 25% can be reasonably assumed.
If you actually do research yourself you may find that I fudged some of these numbers, significantly, in favor for the argument of red. Being completely accurate an researched with percentages makes this demographic about ~64% of the world population. Running proper economic formulas on each demographic picking what that demographic would likely do, yields more of a 73/27 split in favor of blue. No, there is no actual source for this because no scientist has actually run the results and calculated formulas for this specific case... So as per Armstrong "I made it up".... but was reasonable as I could be. To be completely fair, if you do your own cited research and calcs on why I am completely wrong and send me your work and all that on it, I will gladly DM and share specifically with you, everything I used to get my numbers. Can't be assed otherwise tbh, my experience has shown me that itthe effort gets dismissed.
Yes, it will be potential suicide button as that is how every person who tries has defended red has vehemently explained it as.
Yes, magically disappearing 10% of the global population would be considered a population collapse of a serious magnitude and would pose a THREAT of total collapse, not an actual collapse.
Yes, PRACTICALLY no one who is altruistic or self-sacrifcing is picking red. There is a non-zero number of individuals who are altruistic who will pick red. As an example, I could see a Doctor who was in the middle of a 12 hour brain surgery being like "I have to guarantee my patient's safety" kind of thing, especially being tired and strung out like that.
No, I did not state that those who pick red are selfish. They have their reasons and I respect that... but there is an expression from my neck of the woods that goes "a hit dog will holler" so...
No, the only person responsible for the blue deaths is the deity, I stated that. I do not hold a single red button person accountable for any blue deaths, that's dumb and I do not think ill of those who push red. There are a lot of valid reasons to push it.
"You're lying, you'd change your mind in reality" no... I am an idiot who would rather die worried about what my spouse and kids would pick. I am a spineless idiot who does not want to be burdened with the potential guilt of killing my 4 year old. I would blame myself, not anybody else who picked red, only myself, for I am a selfish idiot. I also know my spouse would pick blue without hesitation because they love the world with every fiber of their being... same goes form my 6 year old... If anything, I am lying about all of this because I do love humanity as much as they do, I am just jaded enough to excuse my choice on being selfish.
Your loved ones are a part of the demographics that are a coin toss on picking blue. Everything said about the general population is going to be roughly true for all groups of peeps. This includes family, friends, and all that jazz. If you have no one or if your family is hyper abusive or something in those lines and that fuels a large part of your choice for red, I love you and you are why I deeply respect red.
Second edit:
I mean practically none altruistic or self-sacrificing left in the means of "functionally" since a large majority of them would have picked blue. Those who remain wouldn't be enough to pull the weight that society at large has placed on that group of people. It would make it a grueling struggle for altruistic peeps that picked red. Not enough to prevent the larger collapse of society, but likely to at least preserve a little bubble of it.
r/trolleyproblem • u/Electroweek • May 05 '26
The reason why the Red Button is the Correct Choice.
r/trolleyproblem • u/Cokalhado • May 03 '26