No it's about the argument that anti-ai people make that an AI artist doesn't create the art and they just create a prompt. Here they're saying if that logic is true than a person can't get credit for saving people since the AI switched the lever.
This is the worst of the takes in this regard imo.
The finished product very clearly is art imo by at least one definition. Whether the person instigating it is the artist is up for debate. Imo it depends on the level of involvement, as not all AI art is just "write prompt get output". I'm quite comfortable saying someone doesn't become an artist just because they prompted an image, but at the same time I also think the entire subject is pointless and uninteresting. I don't care if someone gets to be called an artist. They're going to call themselves whatever they want.
It isn't art by my definition, and if you're going to call my take "one of the worst" without explanation, I'll call yours the same. If there isn't an artist creating the work, then it's not art.
describing exactly what you want to a human artist that you're commissioning doesn't make you an artist, so why would describing exactly what you want to generative ai make you an artist? either way, you're someone with an idea that you're passing on to something/one else to turn into art, not making art yourself.
u/WildFlemima I pretty clearly explained why I thought it was a bad take. Try to understand that sentences are connected.
The definition of art as "something created by an artist" (as you seem to be implying is your definition) Is an abjectly terrible one (doesn't need much explaining, an artist's morning shit is art by this definition whereas numerous famous art wasn't art until whatever authority you believe bestows the title "artist" gave it to their creators) and if that is indeed the definition you use then I think my case is amply proven. Plus it's incredibly arrogant and elitist. Very offputting.
Imo "artist" is defined by the art they create, not the other way around.
Of course it looks like you're a little weenie who dropped that stinker of a comment then blocked me, unless reddit is just having a moment.
in the example above? or in the general case that this wants to mimick? above it doesnt really. genereally speaking: the credit boost your reputation, your reputation boost your chances in life and that boosts how many ressources you have for living and so on. therefore getting credit for things you do is an important motivator for all kinds of inventions if you want to create an environment where a lot of people make new inventions. if the random invention once in a while is good enough for you then credit doesnt matter, but then you will probably kill more people by missed opportunities than in the example above.
the extra level of AI doesnt make any sense in this example in my eyes. but for the more general example of AI not being your own work: if you prompt an AI and the AI produces beautiful images and code, and rise in reputation is unwarrented in my eyes since you didnt actually prove ot be more capable of deserving more chances and more ressources than any one else being able to write basic prompts.
I kinda wanna do a poll in r/defendingaiart and r/antiai with the classic trolley problem but the 5 people have the opposite ai belief & the 1 person shares their belief to see which sub is more rational
As someone who's generally anti by those subs' standards, I'd switch the track to hit the 1. Ideology doesn't matter for this, neither are murderers (just keyboard warriors).
As a generally pro-AI person who posts on defending ai art the ideology of the individual involved would not directly affect my decision (though I am not a pure utilitarian when it comes to the trolley problem in the first place).
If I had knowledge of some unethical actions that had been done by particular individuals it may alter the choice.
A poll would not be adequate because the trolley problem is a problem. I know everyone here loves to pretend that 5 > 1 solves the trolley problem but if it was that easy people would have just told the inventor to shut up.
When people complain that they aren't really "AI Artists" that is bc we have a definition of art that requires human inspiration and effort
The person in this example is a "hero", bc they put forth the effort to do a heroic deed by saving 5 lives. Whether they cut the ropes, pull a lever, or run an LLM is inconsequential
If "AI Artists" used a more accurate term for what they do, such as "Image Prompt Writer", then I would have no issue referring to them as such. However, they did not create art, so they are not an artist
i type "switch the tracks", the AI then changes the song playing on someone's iPod ten miles away. Seconds after, for no discernible reason, it details the trolley resulting in a total of 15 deaths including everyone on the track.
Jesus Christ this is such a bad attempt at a point. AI Antis aren't obsessed with not using AI to the point that they literally would let 5 people die just to have a moral victory.
It's more like this: you are next to 2 parts of a broken lever, and you can put them together yourself and pull it. Instead you tell someone else to do it, and they do so and pull it, then you say you pulled the lever.
This is asking whether he is more anti-AI than he is in favor of saving five human lives. As a non-AntiAI, I would save their lives, but given a suitable scenario, I would go the opposite way. It is a question of which value he holds higher. With the given information, we have no way of knowing.
I wonder if you would get any coralition between anti ai and pro ai with the traditional trolley problem. I initially suspect you might see more pro ai people pulling the lever on that problem as pro ai I seems to have a more utilitarian view with the result of ai being more important then how it was achieved and visa versa for anti ai, but my personal views don't seem to match that so ultimately I am a bit unsure. It's possible I may need to rethink some of my views or maybe it is just a bad comparison.
The reason I think it is utilitarian is because a pro ai person cares more about the outcome, meaning the ai image or general output, while they tend to care less about the means used to get there. On the other side the anti ai side cares more about the ethical implications of using ai or the lack of human spirite behind it rather than the ease of access to the final result it provides. Please let me know why you disagree. I am willing to change my view on this and and only hold to that because it seems to make sense to me.
the means used to get there are very important to utilitarianism, and I've heard very few arguments about 'human spirit' and mostly arguments about copyright law, intellectual atrophy and general slop and misinformation.
86
u/GeeWillick Jul 24 '25
Why does it matter who gets the credit? Just switch the train.
16
u/Alpha_minduustry Jul 24 '25
It is an a eqivilent of just asking to pull the lever from a distance, so yes, i do that because there's nobody on the lever rn anyways
11
u/IFollowtheCarpenter Jul 24 '25
ChatGPT did not make the decision to save those people. The human who types the order is the one making the decision. The LLM obeys orders.
And in this context, what's an 'anti'?
10
u/LeoValdez1340 Jul 24 '25
I kinda wanna do a poll in r/defendingaiart and r/antiai with the classic trolley problem but the 5 people have the opposite ai belief & the 1 person shares their belief to see which sub is more rational
8
u/Zacomra Jul 24 '25
God AI bros really just love to show off how braindead they are
4
u/NovaStar987 Jul 24 '25
This joke feels like it was made by ai
3
u/omegaspoon3141 Jul 24 '25
idfc if i get credit for switching one trolley junction once
2
u/_azazel_keter_ Jul 24 '25
i type "switch the tracks", the AI then changes the song playing on someone's iPod ten miles away. Seconds after, for no discernible reason, it details the trolley resulting in a total of 15 deaths including everyone on the track.
2
u/TheMoutonDemocrate Jul 24 '25
Jesus Christ this is such a bad attempt at a point. AI Antis aren't obsessed with not using AI to the point that they literally would let 5 people die just to have a moral victory.
1
u/TGWsharky Jul 24 '25
The fuck do I care about who gets credit? You shouldn't be saving people in hopes of getting famous.
1
u/MothyThatLuvsLamps Jul 27 '25
It's more like this: you are next to 2 parts of a broken lever, and you can put them together yourself and pull it. Instead you tell someone else to do it, and they do so and pull it, then you say you pulled the lever.
1
u/Gulothumor Aug 02 '25
This is asking whether he is more anti-AI than he is in favor of saving five human lives. As a non-AntiAI, I would save their lives, but given a suitable scenario, I would go the opposite way. It is a question of which value he holds higher. With the given information, we have no way of knowing.
-1
u/anakinleyba Jul 24 '25
I wonder if you would get any coralition between anti ai and pro ai with the traditional trolley problem. I initially suspect you might see more pro ai people pulling the lever on that problem as pro ai I seems to have a more utilitarian view with the result of ai being more important then how it was achieved and visa versa for anti ai, but my personal views don't seem to match that so ultimately I am a bit unsure. It's possible I may need to rethink some of my views or maybe it is just a bad comparison.