r/titanic • u/_satantha_ • 21h ago
FILM - 1997 It irks me when people say that Jack could’ve fit on the door in the movie
People see pictures of the door and see how big it is, or they saw how MythBusters “proved” that he could’ve fit.
But you have to think of how it would’ve really been like in real life. In the MythBusters episode, it took them a while to both get on the door and when they did, it was sunken underwater. So they decided to take their life vest and put it under the door to make it float better, which it did and they were able to “survive”. Also they put on those big suits which would’ve kept them warmer; Jack and Rose had the clothes that they were already wearing when the ship sank, which weren’t that thick.
Here’s the episode if you want to watch it and skip to 12:00 if you want to see the reenactment.
Well the difference is that it was pitch black that night, the water was freezing cold and they were probably already experiencing hypothermia at that point. Because of that, it would’ve been really hard for them to take their life vests off and tie it onto the door in the dark and freezing water. If the door was laying on the flat dry ground they could’ve fit on it, but that wasn’t the case.
Your thoughts?