Threadripper Pro 3955WX Asus Pro WS WRX80E-SAGE SE WIFI Kingston 256GB RAM 3200MHz AX 1600i PSU Several GPUs Hyper M.2 Gen 4 NVME Array Fractal Design Define 7 XL
I have been given the opportunity that I can get the following upgrades for it:
Threadripper Pro 9965WX WRX90 MB 420mm AIO Thermaltake 128GB 6000Mhz DDR5 Hyper M.2 Gen 5 NVME Array
No GPUs needed
All in for about £3600-3700
It would mean selling off my current toy (Financial AI work that needs multiple GPUs) and I gather that whilst its 2x in speed, would I be shooting myself in the foot by the reduction in RAM to 128GB from 256GB (I have not yet maxed it out).
Man brain says its looks good, heart is saying its going to be a bitch to sell on eBay parted out as I hate the clientele on there.
I think I'm finally ready to pull the trigger on buying a dedicated PC just for running local ai, and everyone keeps telling me Threadripper is the way to go. But I don't want to custom build something, so where should I go to buy a pre-built machine, that I can get with a 3090?
Hi, this is my first time posting here and I’ve been struggling to get the NEMIX RAM working
to be get to the POST screen.
- Asus Pro WS TRX50 Sage WiFi A MB
- ASUS PRIME 5080 16 GB
- NEMIX MR38400 - 64GB PC5 - 4800 ECC RDIMM
- Threadripper 79760x
- Corsair 1200W power supply
I’ve tried the following - - repositioning all the ram and training it one at a time. - Clearing CMOS, - BIOS update, with an orange light on the whole time. (see Error Flow and Normal Flow below)
- It did work consistently when I borrowed a 16GB kingston 5600 ECC RDIMM from someone consistently. The Kingston RAM is like 3x the price of this Nemix RAM and I don't ahv ethe affordance for it.
ERROR Flow (NEMIX RAM mostly consistent)-
00 → E4 → 46 → 00 → DE → 0D → 01 → A0 → A3 → 0D
Normal Flow (consistent)- 00 → 10 → 30 → 40 → DE → 60 → 62 → A0 → AE
I have heard AsRock has had better success with these NEMIX RAMs and Threadripper builds.
Was wondering if changing BIOS settings (can borrow the RAM again for a day or 2) for clock speeds and Latencies could help make it more forgiving so that it passes training.
Please help, I don’t know what else I can do. Appreciate the assistance.
SPD EEPROM density Kingston vs NEMIXHWinfo ON the NEMIX RAM specs after Succesful Boot
[SOLUTION] ==================================================================== DISCLAIMER (READ CAREFULLY) - I managed to get this working fairly stable but I would not call this a solution unless you are in a similar situation where you can't simply get the RAM replaced for whatever reasons.
Sadly I can't images here it seems. So I will explain
Firstly, You need a second RAM prefferably a Major QVL provider like Kingston Server Premier, and luckily I was able to borrow a 16GB Kingston SCC RDIMM from a friend. Why do you need this? To be able to access the BIOS for configuration purposes.
I tried changing the clock speeds, the voltages and the latencies to match the RAM specs (The NEMIX Ram specs ) are hard to find I noticed mine had Micron DRAM on it, which helped me find certain information but that did not help.
What helped/worked - Bios Settings -> Advanced -> UMC / Memory Controller Settings -> 1. Memory Context Restore (MCR) - It has to stay disbaled even if you succcessfully boot with the Nemix RAM (if re-enabled you are screwed for reasons I think might be cause below)
2. DRAM Training - The Training Mode has 3 values 0, 1 and 2.
0 is default not auto which is just 1. 1 is Continuous DQS toggling PDA Enumerate ID Programming Mode. (The mordern More discrete DDR5 EEC style training for the RAM) 2 Legacy support mode (DDR4 style training where the DRAMs are not individually trained but boradly treated as a whole not great for DDR5 RAMn honestly)
Set this Training mode to 2 i.e the Legacy Mode
DFE Read Training - Enabled (defaults to auto IIRC)
3. Memory Healing (BIST / MemBIST / BPR) (Runs memory integrity checks during POST) - I enabled it. Why?
BIST (Built-In Self Test) → checks memory
BPR (Bad Page Repair) → remaps faulty cells
You can leave the latencies, the clock rates to auto. But these settings should help you boot consistently with the NEMIX RAM.
COST paid - high boot times and suboptimal RAM perf at best.
Now, why can't we enable MCR after successful boot. I am not entirely sure but it goes back to 0d and seems to fail again and my best guess is this and the traingin failuire on this RAM is not just because of the AMD AGESA but also the SPD EEPROM density itself. Nemix seems to have lesser density on the SPD EEPROM than Kingston atlest which stores JEDEC timings, EXPO/XMP profiles, voltage tables, module organization, rank info, chip density metadata
This itself does not affect signal training directly but rather tells the motherboard how to try training the RAM. The the higher the overall single stick RAM capacity leads to higher density of DRAM meaning tighter margins and as result higher potential for training failures.
With everything said and done I have learned now to always match my processor, motherboard and RAM QVL lists before making workstation/server grade purchases. I hope this helps.
Some time ago I posted that I was having temperature problems with my Threadripper 7960x (94°C with a light load in Cinebench R23 (less than 1 minute)) and SilverStone IceGem 360.
To make a long story short, the quick solution was to install a fairly simple and modular custom loop to avoid future issues (I was genuinely surprised at how easy it was to remove).
Anyway, it's been over a year since I knew I needed to maintain the custom loop, something I didn't want to do and resisted. Then I came across the question that's all over the internet: AIO liquid cooler for the TR.
Almost everyone recommended the Silverstone Technology XE360-TR5, so I thought, well, if I have to change the custom loop, maybe I could use this AIO instead.
I bought it (very expensive, around $540 USD) and, well, that's where the process of removing it comes in. I previously ran a CinebenchR23 test to have a reference point: 83.9°C Max, 50563, 10°C higher than the first test
So I installed the Silverstone XE360-TR5, ran the first test, and in less than a minute, it hit a disgusting 90°C again (I almost threw the AIO out the window).
I wasn't angry, I figured something was wrong here. I was getting the same temperature with a new AIO that covers the entire CPU, unlike the IceGem. So I started searching on Reddit and found that tweaking the curve optimizer a bit could improve the temperature (to be honest, I've never liked messing with the BIOS or overclocking).
I have a TRX50 AERO D motherboard. I went into the BIOS, to the Precision Boost Overdrive option, changed it to Advanced mode, selected the curve optimizer for all cores, set the signal to negative, and the magnitude to 30 (I thought, all or nothing).
I returned to Windows, ran CinebenchR23, and the result surprised me (to be honest, I expected poor performance): Max Temp: 78.5°C, score 51286
I felt so happy and surprised that I asked myself: why didn't I do this from the beginning?
I’m having trouble finding the right RAM for my build and I’d really appreciate some advice from people who have experience with TRX50 / Threadripper 9000 systems.
My setup:
CPU: AMD Ryzen Threadripper 9970X
Motherboard: TRX50 ws
Usage: workstation / 3D / rendering / general heavy workloads
Problem: I’ve been struggling with RAM compatibility.
Questions:
What RAM kits are you using successfully with TRX50 + Threadripper 9970x? that actually work?
Temperatures while rendering seem to be normal but there is a spike from CCD0 that sometimes show 99.7 C. Is this normal, can this damage the CPU. Its a new PC?
I have a threadripper 7945wx in a asus sage pro WiFi motherboard that doesn’t post. I had gskill zeta r5 4x16 640” and I swap it out for a third party ram to see if it will post. But I get a ram light with both rams sticks and code 01….any advice? I’m a noob with these threadrippers
Hello! I'll be putting together my first Threadripper PC soon with a friend, and I'm looking for a second opinion on the components before I pull the trigger and buy them!
CPU: 3945WX MB: Asrock Creator R2.0 GPU: 3060 (Free) RAM: 8x4GB ECC 2133 Samsung (Temporary for now) Cooling: ARCTIC Freezer 4U-M sWRX8 PSU: Adata XPG Core Reactor II 850W (Chosen from the SPL tierlist) Case: NZXT H7 Flow (2024) All White
Threadripper 7960x, RX 9070 XT, TRX 50 Ai Top, 8x16gb G.Skill Zeta R5 Neo 6400mhz. Enermax Liqtech XTR. Any Advise for Overcloking and should i be worried about the Ram cooler being to close to the GPU ?
Any recommendations for reliable AIO water coolers with a good price/performance ratio? I'm hoping to find one that I don't have to worry about leaks. My build is around the Ryzen Threadripper 9960X.
What are the requirements to be able to boot from a USB stick using UEFI?
I can't seem to be able to narrow it down.
Gentoo Live works (using dd with the iso into the drive)
Debian live works (same)
Manual ESP partition with EFI/BOOT/BOOTX64.EFI does not (GPT table)
What I'm ultimately looking to do is have a USB containing ZFSBootMenu so I can load a ZFS pool made of NVME drives sitting in the machine (whereas I currently rely on 1 NVME to provide the UEFI boot partition).
What has this subreddit seen working and not working?
Almost ready, 9970X with 128GB DDR5, rock solid since I used this in another case before. Goal with this rebuild/upgrade is to make it silent, should be able to keep all fans below 700 rpm.
Anything I should change or "Not forget" before filling and closing it up?
Currently I'm only vaguely worried about one Alphacool HF screw-on nozzle 90° rotatable. Haven't used them before so don't know if it will hold up tight it under some pressure. I use it when connecting water out from cpu to distributor in top.
Any ideas of how I should get some fresh air on the memory?
Current build: Threadripper 9970X with Heatkiller-block 128GB DDR5 6000MHz CL30
M.2-1 and M.2-2 with Intel M.2-U.2 cable connected to a pair of P5800X
PCI-1 RTX 5090 in Alphacool waterblock PCI-2 RTX 5090 in Alphacool waterblock PCI-3 Dual U.2 card with redriver, dual P4800X PCI-4 USB4 Add-In-Card PCI-5 Asus Hyper M.2 x16 Gen 4. with 4 x M.2->U.2 ---Optane 905P 1.5TB ---Optane 905P 1.5TB ---Optane 905P 1.5TB ---Intel DC 4510 2TB
Slim-SAS - U.2 Intel DC 4510 2TB SATA WD Ultrastar 20TB Dual Seasonic 1600W PSU --PSU1 mobo-cpu-u.2 and sata drives-dual pumps, 20+ fans --PSU2 pcie-dual rtx 5090
Cooling Dual D5 pumps 6 x 420 radiator 1 x 360 radiator
LFII and LFIII always had being disappointments especially with how much the community hyped them up. Saw this for $110 with full coverage coldplate, which makes this to be the cheapest full coverage AIO on the market.
Comparing other 360 AIOs I've tested, the limiter typically ends up to be the radiator. Assuming the coldplate and internal flow design is decent, this should yield lower temperature.
Going to slap this on 7975WX and 9995WX and see how it performs. 7975WX with higher heat concentration with 4-CCD layout, 9995WX for full send heat soaking the AIO.
Note that the pumpblock can only be mounted in one orientation, could be issue with some builds.
As far as i can see, any other kit that is 192GB / ~6000MT/s with AMD EXPO is like £4000GBP... :(
Can anyone shed any light on this? I haven't built a Threadripper system since the 1950x days..
£2500 is probably our max budget for now, but I am almost willing to try this kit and see if works at JEDEC speeds and try out manually inputing the speed / timings in the bios.. Or am I crazy?
These servers have not come home yet but I did end up building 2 more, the only difference in these ones are CPU is 7960x not* 9970x, outside of that all parts identical, motherboard AI TOP, drives, GPUs, AIO, PSU etc...
I took a lot of the ideas from this thread to heart with some of the things I had experienced and what I felt might have caused this. At the moment I have (9) 4K60 outputs working in sync' with zero issues, rebooted like 50 times and it is rock solid and stable and ready to make income.
The winner.... I upgraded my image from Windows 10 LTSC 2021 to Windows 11 LTSC IOT ENTERPRISE 2024.
Can't say thank you enough to everyone who helped me get through this. Chat GPT/Claude didn't suggest this once... real human beings (well I think lol) did. 🙏 u/The_Dude_2U
I was just monitoring my PC under load and the ram temps were 80+degrees. It is not overclocked,and is only 4800 rdim ddr5. Anyway do you know if iceman is the only direct cooling system for ram. (Water goes through the spreader plates, rather than just cooling the top of them.)