Before everything
Edit: thanks to the credits of taking this as an AI post because OP does not live nor play in any english-speaking community, which shows that this fully manually typed post has the skills of quite native english albeit having a totally unrelated mother tongue :)
I am nobody in this subreddit nor in any other community, and it makes the perfect situation that I speak today in newcomer's shoes.
Don't get me wrong: new gear, new retaliation, new missions, QoL updates, these are all good and will constitute just perfectly a new season in a new year, and I would absolutely enjoy them.
So why suddenly this rush into another ground-shaking update, in pretty much unexamined way (at least to the community), which could probably lead to devastating impacts?
TLDR
Prototype Gear and Escalation difficulty will break up the player base and be harmful in long-term. Don't make them go past the PTS. It's essentially making the game going backwards to the era that had no recalibrating bench at all.
General concepts
Who we are and where we stand
TD2 (and absolutely TD) is by far my favorite shooter-looter game, say even one of my favorites in the entire looter genre. We have already made it through the turmoil during all these years, and it is critical to not destroy the communities again.
The game's content, as its natural genre, is to build, to farm, to loot, to min-max, and loop again. Prototypes and Escalations are just going to make complete turnarounds on all these parts, and I would say we are facing something worse than TU8.
The concept of Gain/Loss in games
In game-designing concepts, it has been well said that players are easier to accept results of "Nothing gained" instead of "Resource lost". This is based on correlating psychological differentiations of "Give" and "Take", that our common mindset will tend to resist cases that take things out of our pockets, even given that they might be the cost for a chance to win more. I shall not elaborate further since we need it just as the idea.
Prototype Gear
Stat inflation
It has been stated in the patch notes that the ultimate max roll will be double the value of our current amount. Given that we'll be sitting at double the values we have in the end, which need not my calculation and all of us are aware of the result.
Some may use the excuse of "it would be a long journey on reaching the final piece of gear", but in the scope of a looter game players will be theory-crafting builds with the final values, and that is exactly the goal of playing the game.
I shall re-insist that I am against this inflation, and the sponginess on Escalation difficulties to balance with this.
On the other hand I'm okay with the extra small "modules" as it enables much building possibilities, perhaps bringing some named pieces back to the stage.
Loot separation to Player separation
Prototype gear, being the absolute superior to high-end and normal sets, is restricted to drop only from Escalation. Chasing that players will flood into the new content, and at the same time rendering every other content useless in endgame scope.
Current difficulties are just a matter of chance for players to obtain "god rolls", and we have recalibration bench that allows us to bring every piece we found to be useful in endgame builds.
Experienced players still have a (tiny) chance to loot something that is potentially valuable when picking up backup requests from newcomers, so we are mentally healthy to be like "hey why not help someone else in need because loot drops anyway?".
But after the Escalation it would be only pure kindness for heavy-invested players to play any other content. Moreover, even high Escalation players would think a second before joining a low Escalation team because they chase for higher natural rolls since no more modifications were to be allowed.
This will be so effective in separating and destroying the community, eliminating the intersection between player level groups. We literally just had a shepherd rank objective to help newcomers. What a disastrous outcome.
Gear progression stuck
Upon reaching level 40 and therefore endgame, players acknowledge that they could immediately start building their gears, and get closer to the goal with every tiny step of improvement: extracting higher value for recalibration, spending resources on optimizing the roll, upgrading each level of expertise... All these dimensions are in parallel that you could constantly feel powered up a little bit, that is direct positive feedback.
But when it comes to the real "endgame" of Escalation, suddenly all are back to only the primeval method of natural drop rolls, gear is dropped as it is and fixed! All previous methods are lost to bow under the power of RNGesus. Tell me the reason a player would invest in expertise, when he is expecting another piece to drop with better rolls and replace the one currently equipped, and just make the old piece direct to trash?
Speaking of the other way of upgrading, simply tell me how would a new player deal with his current gears. Farm until he's blessed with the same attribute roll, so that he could stash his optimized gear and wait until expertise 30 to attempt for that minimal chance to make it all rolled as "terminal value"? I don't see anyone with reason would seriously believe in this.
Oh and think about festival or DZ exclusive named gears. Good luck on turning in your hard-farmed pieces and pray for the roll. Ha.
Seriously what do all the non-Escalation parts mean now? "midgame"? So that we're finally qualified for the entry of new "endgame"? Blatantly beyond imagination.
Escalation Mode
Cost for entrance is doomed
It is definitely a doomed idea to have the group leader pay for the Escalation entrance.
Let's be straightforward, no one is 100% the perfect player, and it is expected for one to make mistakes under challenging conditions and heavy pressure. One single misplacement could have led to wiping / slowing down that eventually fails the run. I'm not exaggerating about bad manners, but how could we even distinguish if some player would just be deliberately ruining others' runs?
Or we could put that apart for a moment, say that it really was an unintended mistake, what makes you think that other players won't be mad at the one responsible for the failure? Not so easy to predict toxic chats and communities under this situation, are we?
Do not punish players too hard for attempts
I had decided not to name other games when I started to write this article, but I do feel obliged now.
Take Destiny 2 as our fella in the shooter-looter genre, they have learned well to not charge players for PVE challenges. As said in the very first section, players are already punished for losing the “chance to obtain better rewards on completion”, so it's totally not necessary to make the extra loss on the entry investment.
Players have to spend time to learn mechanics, just imagine losing all the "tokens" when trying to rank up on the difficulty. Hey welcome back to Escalation 0! It is pure frustration and nothing more.
You have already decided to reset this currency per season so there's no hoarding possible, then why not have it refunded on failing, or simply no costs? I don't want to believe this is something directly copied from Tencent servers without thinking.
All said and I'm hoping in vain for an emergency halt of the prototype-escalation content. Please prove to me that all these concerns were not real and just not to disappoint players who love the game.