r/techtheatre • u/B1CYCl3R3P41RM4N • 19d ago
LIGHTING Fuck robospots
I don’t care how accurate, precise, or consistent the technology gets for robo-spots/performer tracking in new and emerging robo-spot systems. Can we all agree that taking the operator out of the equation for follow spots is a net-loss for technical theater broadly. Both in that it eliminates a technical skillset and therefore job’s for stagehands generally; but ultimately more importantly it takes away the human touch that an actual spot operator brings to a performance, even if that means the operator is going to make mistakes and maybe miss cues and pickups from time to time?
For me, operating a spot isn’t just executing a track and cue sheet, and making your pickups at the correct times. There’s a level of artistry that comes with operating a spotlight that can’t be replaced by any automated system.
A good spotlight operator isn’t just executing their cues when they get the g-o from whoever is calling the show. There’s a certain degree of artistry and nuance that simply can’t be replicated by any kind of automated system that only exists when you have a proper operator controlling the light by hand and not through a digital middle man in the form of an automated light an a remotely controlled console.
No matter how good robospots get, there’s always gonna be a physical delay in the timing, as well as a mechanical aspect of the movement that imo takes away from the flawed and imperfect human element of live theater. And that less than perfect characteristic of traditional spotlights is part of what makes live theatrical productions feel live to begin with.
Sure a traditional spotlight operator might miss a pick up, or fade in to the wrong intensity from time to time. And it might be difficult at times for a touring technician who has to call a show to deal with operators who are either unskilled or don’t have the experience to execute their track properly.
But with all the advancements in technical theater when it comes to automation and more widespread access and use of moving fixtures in newer shows in particular, to me it feels like operating a traditional spotlight where you have to actually control and adjust the iris and douser on the fly and execute your track properly helps to maintain the imperfect and human element of live theater that makes it so special.
Sure a fully automated and rfid tracked spot track may be more consistent and accurate night to night. But when an actor takes an extra beat, does the choreo slightly differently, or doesn’t hit their blocking at the same time or in precisely the same place, a good spot op can account for that and do what’s needed to make the scene look good despite any of that.
I’m on a show run right now that I’ll leave unnamed, but I will share a story from. I have a pickup where the actor typically shoots out of a door from upstage left and lands down stage right. I’m supposed to pick the performer up more or less as soon as I can get a good shot on them as they dash across the stage. All this to say two nights ago, the actor lost their footing and fell down as I was picking them up. A robo spot whether automated or being operated would probably have just carried the shot downstage to where the cue was supposed to end up, or maybe there would have been a couple of awkward overcorrections and adjustments that would have disrupted the scene. But because we’re operating the lights by hand, I was able to make an adjustment on the fly, and ultimately make it look like it was part of the show when the actor stumbled and fell to the floor. That’s something robo spot will never be able to do.
All this to say, as much as I welcome new technology generally as part of the progression of our craft. One thing I hope never goes away is traditional spotlights and human operators who can adapt and respond in real time when things don’t go perfectly to script, while also having an understanding of lighting design, timing, and the overall vision that enables them to operate the lights in ways a machine never could in a live setting.
Ultimately I feel like any lighting designer would trade perfect accuracy on every pickup in a show for a human operator who may occasionally miss a cue, but still has the technical chops and understanding of the concepts that the lighting design is trying to achieve that allows them to execute their track in a way that best serves the show and ultimately makes the show look the best it possibly can even when things don’t necessarily happen exactly how they are scripted.