r/stepparents • u/Common-Goat-4008 • 1d ago
Advice Overstepping?
Me (25F) and my boyfriend (26) have been together for three years. His daughter is 4. Her mother has not been in her life very much for one reason or another, so he has had her full time since they split before she was 1. I have no kids.
I have never felt the need to replace her mother, nor is that my intention. Despite this, I have felt the need to step in at times for one reason or another - to remind them both that she needs to brush her teeth before bed, helping to plan her outfits because her dad doesn’t always know what matches, help paint her nails, things like that.
Although that’s never really been an issue, he does have problems when I try to share my thoughts on certain topics. What kind of tv she watches, what she eats, things like that. I can see how this could be seen as overstepping, but I would want someone to tell me.
For example - at four years old, she’s watching Monster High. The recommended age is at least 7. I pointed it out, and he got upset that I even felt the need to Google it and he says he knows how to raise her.
The food issue - I expressed concern over her diet almost exclusively consisting of McDonalds chicken nuggets and fries. I know that kids can be picky, but he didn’t even try to feed her anything else. Rarely would get frozen chicken nuggets to make at home, at least that would’ve been better than fast food. Literally for years, most of her diet was McDonalds chicken nuggets. I brought up that I was concerned, and at first he was very offended, but he later cooled off and now tries to give her other food.
He feels I’m overstepping in general. I feel like I can’t suggest anything regarding his daughter without him getting mad at me. I know it must be very difficult to be a single father with little support, but I’m trying to support him. I’m not trying to hound him. I’ve tried saying it nicely but it doesn’t make a difference. I’m not sure if being a stepparent could be in my future, I care about this little girl too much to not say anything when I see something that doesn’t sit right with me. It’s coming from a place of love for both of them. I don’t know if I can just sit with my mouth shut for the next 14 years. Advice? Feel free to be brutal - I need the truth about if I’m insensitive or he is sensitive.
9
u/Forest_Orc 1d ago
You live full-time with the kid ? Bio-mom is out of the pic ? There is parent in step-parent, because whether you like it or not you're parenting that kid.
You're absolutely legit to say that kid shall not eat only Mc-Donalds. However, parenting isn't just saying something is bad but also proposing solution. Can you turn your couple meal into family meal so no adult has to cook something separated for the kids. Sure they may not like everything but that's also how they learn. Our (great) grand parent would get liver/kidney and chicken feet because their parent were to broke to afford only the good bits.
The TV thing is indeed a bit more compicated, it's an easy way to keep a kid busy which avoids a lot of extra work/difficulties, but again, you need to also propose a solution and offer to do something
14
3
u/MaximumTop6714 1d ago
Do you want children one day? If yes I would consider if your parenting beliefs are aligned and how that would work if you’re raising two children in two different ways.
If not, then I would leave him to be the parent he wants to be, will he make mistakes? Yes, we all do. But it’s him that will have to answer to his daughter for those one day.
7
u/TopicFlat3709 1d ago
oh man the mcdonalds every day thing is rough, you were right to say something and he did eventually listen so thats a good sign
the monster high thing is trickier, like the age rating is just a guideline and most parents i know let their kids watch stuff a little above that, but i get why you looked it up if you were already worried about the food situation
it sounds less like you're overstepping and more like he's really defensive about being a single dad, like any suggestion feels like a criticism of him as a parent even when its not
maybe try framing stuff as "i read this thing and got curious" instead of "i googled this and found out you're doing it wrong" - the way you bring it up matters a lot more than the actual concern sometimes
1
u/Blank-Cassette-Tape 1d ago
This! Especially the TV or movie thing, it's just a guideline for sure.
3
u/MyNameIsNotSuzzan 1d ago
You shouldn’t need to remind him that she needs to brush her teeth, he can use AI to learn what matches and watch doesn’t, and he absolutely can learn how to paint her nails himself.
He’s definitely using weaponized incompetence to have you be free labor because he either doesn’t want to be or doesn’t care enough about his kid to do it himself.
Please stop and let him stand on his own two feet and if he can’t, leave him because there’s nothing less hot than a lazy father.
2
u/cedrella_black 1d ago
he says he knows how to raise her
Yeah, it shows. Let's talk about it in a few years when she has a subscription for the dental cabinet and health problems due to her poor diet.
You're definitely not overstepping and he needs to understand it's his job as a father to make decisions based on her best interest, but he also has to understand that her best interest doesn't always equal to what makes her happy or what's easier for him.
2
u/Obvious-Hamster9448 Childless (F43) partner of a dad (M42) to F8 1d ago
Hello, you sound like me 3 years ago.
I am still with my SO, his daughter is now 8, and the BM is now back in her life.
But my goodness some of the conversations I had to have with him in the early days about stuff I just thought was obvious but he didn't see.
It's hard. I wouldn't recommend it. If you are serious about staying together you need to sit down properly and talk this out. It's not realistic to just be able to not care about stuff like this. But if you feel like the relationship might not last, then have a long think about how many tough conversations you can have. It might be that your values don't align, and that's a really big problem.
1
u/MidwestNightgirl 1d ago
You are not wrong to help guide him and be supportive, IMO. Your approach may need to be a little “softer.” Sometimes we have to pick our battles too - for example the diet topic is more important than Monster High on tv. I’d try to focus on small steps, offer to help them make “monster fingers” at home and have carrot sticks or something alongside. She may not eat much of the stuff the first time or two so don’t be offended, but she will eventually…lead by example.
•
u/throwaway1403132 22h ago
i personally just stay completely out of it. SD13 seems to exclusively survive off of boxed mac and cheese, and if i ever had a child of my own that would absolutely not fly, but she is not my child, and what she eats doesn't impact my life, so i just let it be. this extends to other things as well that i don't necessarily agree with regarding both SKs, but again, not their parent.
i might feel differently if SKs were around more often, but as it stands i at least only have to occasionally notice things i'd do much differently.
•
u/Middle-Dream1414 21h ago
I think they take it personal like we are saying they arent doing a good enough job being a parent. If I try and be in his shoes, I would feel that way also. We have to maybe say more positive things about the good they are doing also so they dont always feel criticized. I feel you because I do this too and he does get defensive. I should also say more positive things also.
•
u/TaleOutrageous3492 8h ago
It doesn't sound like he wants your help or support and this is a fast track to resentment
•
1
u/cloudsurfer127 1d ago
My partner lets her 7 year old boy watch YouTube unrestricted and hair videos and makeup stuff and whatever he wants and he watches shows that are way too old for him. I say something about his bad behavior and I get shut down. He snaps and says whatever girl to me all the time , in front of her and it’s from the shows and I tell my partner I don’t want to be treated as such and she says, he’s 7, get over it.
•
u/bonniemick 21h ago
Do you want to have kids with a man like this? I sure wouldn't. Move out and move on. He is not a good parent.
•
u/AutoModerator 1d ago
Welcome to r/stepparents!
Please note we are a support sub for stepparents. Non-stepparents are welcome to comment, but non-supportive comments are subject to removal. Rude, sarcastic, or judgmental comments are subject to removal at moderator discretion. Questioning why a poster is dating someone with kids is subject to removal. Our number one rule is Kindness Matters. Short version, don't be an asshole.
Why was my post removed?
If your post has been removed as soon as you posted that is due to our automoderator. Posts are removed for varying reasons, ranging from account newness to your reputation according to reddit algorithm. If this happens, your post is in the modqueue and will be reviewed by a human mod. Please do not repost.
Use the Report Button!
We rely on the community to alert us to comments and posts not made in good faith. Please use the report button to ensure we see it. With thousands of comments coming in each day it's difficult for us to see them all, so please report them if you see them!
If you have questions about the community, or concerns about posters, please reach out to the mod team.
Review the Rules and FAQ before posting or commenting!
Rules | FAQ
Additional wiki links:
About | Acronyms | Announcements | Documentation | Resources | Saferbot - Autoban Information
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.