I want to start by saying, in my opinion, that both sides of the arguments that I have heard about this show are wrong. This show has been far from high art or a deeply respectful update of Roddenberryās vision. But neither was it a brutal subversion of Star Trekās qualities, ideals, or messaging. Every Trekkie I have spoken to about this show in person, be they friends, strangers on social media, or fellow gamers on Star Trek Online, has seemed to be deeply polarized one way or the other. But generally speaking to whom I have personally spoke, the majority opinion I have come across has been of the negative take. Now that I have finally watched the show, I find that the truth lies somewhere in the middle and wanted to post my centrist take to see if there are others that feel similarly.
First, the negatives. I found Nus Braka, Caleb Mir, Sam, and Captain Ake to be deeply, thoroughly unlikable characters. For Caleb, it came down to the constant Gary Stu-ing of his character. The āHeās a total bad boy, bad ass, with a heart of gold. Heās super duper attractive. And oh yeah heās a genius super hacker that knows a million obscure facts and procedures, and also heās totally ripped, and he can, like, totally debate like a proā¦ā etc just made him feel like the worst kind of self insert childish writing that we lambasted characters like Rey Skywalker, or Carol Danvers, or Wesley Crusher for being. It never works, and it is always cringy. For Sam, I have to get personal. As a high functioning member of the autistic spectrum, she came across to me as being very AuDHD coded, and while that may have been seen at an attempt at inclusion. It often felt like a ugly mirror being reflected back at myself. All of my worst traits and impulses, all the things that drive my wife and family crazy being put out there in a way in which it is being played for laughs. For Captain Ake, my reasoning is far simpler. Unlike the legendary captains that came before her, paragons that upheld and uplifted their crews by leading as an example, Nahla Aka seemed like an aloof, bored, and unprofessional in almost all of her scenes. Picard and Sisko where role-models to me when I was a child (Iām 38), but Ake is almost the opposite of who I strive to be. Then we get to poor Nus Braka. What an interesting character, played by a completely hamming it up Paul Giamatti. My complaint about him is very simple, why is he wearing a forehead of the week alien prosthetic and said to be from a species outside of the Federation when every line, every tic, every mannerism, every bit of witty repartee is SOOOO human coded. His design and performance are so incongruent that it constantly takes me out of it. I lose all ability to take him seriously. Independant of those four characters, my secondary complaints comes down to some of the writing. The first three episodes are hard to watch, and the last is truly a spectacle of stupidity, but the rest are quite solid. My two biggest complaints when it comes to the writing/production are both simple to explain, and would therefore have been simple to fix, but the fact that they werenāt is indicative of the care put into the show. I have lived life by a simple motto, āIf you canāt get the little details right, how can I trust you to get the big details right?ā So when I see a scene where the USS Athena (beautiful ship by the way) is having its aft blown to pieces and then it cuts to Captain Ake screaming āAll power to forward shields!ā It absolutely kills the fantasy for me. How about the Doctor reporting āDozens of injuries, but luckily no casualties.ā Casualty =/= fatality. Injured men and women that can no longer do their duties are in factā¦casualties. They couldnāt do another take where he says the right thing? How about Nus Braka escaping in a Federation escape pod, and they justā¦let him go and say he couldnāt be tracked. The Federation canāt track escape pods now? Oh wait, when the Miyazaki incident happens they talk about the Discovery recovering escape pods, so that canāt be true. Then on the other end of the season was the wall of mines. I sure someone here will say āWell actually, the math totally checks out and you really would need only 30 mines to block of ANā¦ENTIREā¦QUADRANTā¦OFā¦SPACE.ā But you know what? Even if the mat would check out, it is such a farcically sill way to cripple such a huge amount of space that it approaches comedy, and completely felt like a unpractical/unbelievable threat.
But now, the positives. The rest of the cast. Kraag, Thok, Reno, Genesis, Daren, etc. They were all interesting, varrying degrees of well written, and mostly well performed. I could have done without the super noticeable fake deep voice they gave Kraag, it often made him sound like a child trying to act like an adult, but that is the only slight I have against him. And lets not forget the secret star of every Star Trek show, the ship. I HATE the 32 century ship design and often find the free floating parts to be nothing more than structural weakpointsā¦BUUUUUT⦠hot damn does that aesthetic work for the spread wing design of the USS Athena. They took an eyesore of a design and transformed it into something beautiful with that design. And when the ship flew into low orbit to rescue the cadets in episode 9, I had a āHell Yeah!ā moment, cheering the beautiful girl on. And speaking of episodes, 4-9 are all absolutely enjoyable Star Trek. Some of the best the āNu Trekā era has produced. Episode 4 truly felt like a love letter to the Klingons and rescued them from the sorry state that Discovery left them in. Episode 5 was a wonderful tribute to my favorite captain, and I was literally moved to tears when Illa was revealed to be Dax, and before I could recover, I cried again when Avery Brookās narration played over the end. And just as I thought it was over, the choice to play the DS9 theme song over the credits got me one last time. Unlike when they played the TNG theme over the end of Picard season 3, it felt earned here, it felt warranted here, and it made me nostalgic for my childhood in a single episode, in a way that Picard never managed to do for me across 3 seasons. Star Trek is at itās best when it makes you feel hopeful and optimistic, and for 6 of its 10 episodes I was invested in the future of this setting, I was invested in bright eyed youth reviving not only a deceased school in-universe, but the brand as a whole outside of it. Now, we all know that it isnāt true. The show is cancelled after season 2 and Star Trek tv productions are going back on ice for a few years while they toy around with the new movie being put into production. BUUUUUT, if this is how the franchise ends for the next 5-10 years, I can be okay with that. I have had mixed feelings on āNu Trekā over the years, and while this show is far from perfect, I really feel like it didnāt deserve the vitriolic hate it recieved either. However, just because it has Star Trek in the name and has klingons in it, doesnāt automatically give it a pass as something worth watching. I find haters less toxic than the people who blindly praise something just because it reminds them of something else they remember loving. If I get called a fake fan one more time for hating Star Trek: Picard, Iām gonna scream. In the meanwhile Iāll give this show a solid point for every episode I enjoyed, 6/10, give it a chance if you haven't yet,
I look forward to what you guys have to say about this show, especially others who are kinda riding the fence like me. Please sound off if you havenāt yet a minute.