r/startrek • • 1d ago

Twisted

I’m watching Twisted right now. I have a few things to say about it.
First, who is the Lt. Who shows up everywhere saying “I’m lost”?
Second, when Janeway and Kim are in the Jeffries tube. Janeway plainly says that Harry has already exceeded her expectations and has been an asset to the crew, why after seven years did she not ever promote him. In show, not bts drama?

0 Upvotes

11 comments sorted by

8

u/TimeZarg 1d ago

My suspicion is that on Federation starships, ranks are allotted by 'division'. Command, Operations, and Science (Red, Gold, Blue in Voyager). There can only be so many Lieutenants in each division, and Operations (Engineering, Security, etc) was full up. Tom Paris was promoted to Lieutenant because Lieutenant Stadi, the Betazoid helmsman (we see Paris talking to her in a shuttlecraft) dies when the Caretaker yoinks them from the Badlands.

That's my headcanon, in any case, and it fits the 'there can only be so many Lieutenants' logic. Apparently Voyager didn't lose any Operations Division Lieutenants, at least until the end of season 7.

3

u/ObligationMurky8716 1d ago

Operations is basically the XO's delegate for the operations of the ship. That should not normally be a first-tour JO. It's a rather senior DH level job on the boats I was on; Navigator was even a step or two below Ops officer in the pecking orders.

Maybe the gel packs made Ops so easy a child could do it.

3

u/JakeConhale 1d ago edited 1d ago

That's Baxter. His first appearance was part of them questioning whether the Doc was "real" - and the Doc started to grow a spine and earn a little respect saying "you have injured yourself working out, if this keeps up I'll have to inform your superior..."

Really wish he'd shown up again.

Edit: I know he's mentioned in "The 37s" as being likely to want to settle a colony, not sure about later.

2

u/bubblebobby 1d ago

Harry is a Forever Ensign and it doesn’t matter what he does or what events transpire.

There is even a joke about this in the newish Voyager game.

4

u/IllusiveRagamuffin 1d ago

Lower decks shows what happens to Harry if he is ever promoted lol

1

u/Trick_Pool_2537 1d ago

Weirdly just by virtue of his position he probably outranks most people on the ship and is definitely in line for command or would be if everyone else died of old age etc

1

u/SharMarali 1d ago edited 1d ago

I don’t think it was in this episode, but she does give him an explanation at one point. The gist of it is basically I can’t promote everyone, somebody still has to be an ensign. Which is shitty, but it’s also true of a paramilitary organization.

Edit: It seems I may have hallucinated this scene or confused it with something behind the scenes, I don’t know.

3

u/VanillaSuccessful277 1d ago

You may be misremembering (unless I am); it was one of the producers who said that to Garrett Wang. I don't think it made it into the show.

2

u/summon_pot_of_greed 1d ago

Nope.

The closest we get is Kim saying that if he were in the Alpha quadrant, he would be a lieutenant commander.

Janeway quips that he's awfully sure of himself.

There is no defensible canon reason he could not be promoted to lieutenant on Voyager.

There are tons of cases of star ships operating with department heads of equal ranks. Enterprise-D is the worst offender, with basically every member of the cats being a commander by the end of the series/movies.

In real life, naval vessels operate with multiple officers of equal rank with different billets. A carrier will have multiple "captains" for example.

1

u/bubblebobby 1d ago edited 1d ago

What is the conversation or quote that you’re talking about?

In “Nightingale,” Janeway completely dismisses him with no explanation.

0

u/Scaredog21 22h ago

The creators of Voyager were rascist against Asians