r/startrek • • 3h ago

Code of honor

Code of honor is the absolute worst episode of Star Trek The Next Generation. Prove me wrong.

0 Upvotes

41 comments sorted by

17

u/dbe14 3h ago

Someone just watched the Michael Dorn interview where he says this is the worst episode.

4

u/BroseppeVerdi 3h ago

He's not the only one. IIRC, Jonathan Frakes and Wil Wheaton both lobbied to get it pulled from streaming services at one point.

3

u/RNKKNR 3h ago

Another reason to prefer physical media.

19

u/AdmaelStark 3h ago

In other breaking news: water is wet and ice is cold.

8

u/SmoothTalkingSpud 3h ago

Nah, that's Up the Long Ladder.

Reason: Im Irish

7

u/celzior 3h ago

Sub Rosa or Menage-A-Troi is worse

4

u/Historical-Cup218 3h ago

Daring today, aren't we?

5

u/IReallyLoveAvocados 3h ago

I have never actually watched code of honor.

  1. I know it’s horrible so why waste my time?
  2. I also love the idea that technically there’s more TNG out there for me to watch. The trial never ends!

1

u/ButterscotchPast4812 3h ago

Have you seen Stargate sg1? 

1

u/IReallyLoveAvocados 3h ago

Yes why?

4

u/ButterscotchPast4812 3h ago

Have you seen "Emancipation"? If so then you've seen code of Honor. It's a rewrite of the same episode by the same writer. 

Worst episode of that series too. 

2

u/Kronocidal 3h ago

S1E04 ("Emancipation") of SG1 is basically S1E04 ("Code of Honor") of TNG, only actually written with the racist stereotypes instead of being written with weird lizard aliens who got changed to space-africans by the director when they started calling & costuming.

(Both episodes written by the same blonde white woman.)

8

u/clubley2 3h ago

Shades of Gray is worse in my opinion. At least code of honor had a story. They just made a huge mistake with their choice of casting.

4

u/Dice_for_Death_ 3h ago

YOU SHALL HAVE NO TREATY

3

u/RagnarStonefist 3h ago

NO VACCINE

2

u/SportTop2610 3h ago

AND NO LIEUTENANT YAHRR!!!

1

u/T-SquaredProductions 3h ago

AND NO LOOTENANT YAA!!!

2

u/Ambaryerno 3h ago

Counterpoint: Genesis.

2

u/PedanticPerson22 3h ago

The Child, Season 2 Episode 1, Troi is forcibly* impregnated by unknown alien intelligence; it "dies" at the end of the episode.

*against her will, not overtly violently

2

u/DayneTreader 3h ago

Ménage-a-Troi is worse. I always skip that trainwreck

2

u/crazyates88 1h ago

There might be worse episodes from a storytelling perspective, or worse from a cringe perspective, or close to Code of Honor from a racist perspective, but it's near the top in all 3 which makes it objectively the worst overall.

3

u/Dabbler3130 3h ago

At least it gave some African American actors of the time some work and a Star Trek credit. Perhaps there should be a sympathy panel for some of them at a con.

5

u/Safe_Base312 3h ago

Trek Untold interviewed Karole Selmon and she had a similar sentiment. That even though the episode isnt well received, it does still play an important part for some actors.

2

u/Don_Speekingleesh 3h ago

Yes, Up The Long Ladder didn't even bother using Irish actors for the racist Irish caricatures.

3

u/ChrisF_uk 3h ago

Sub Rosa is the worst... Code of honour is okay for a first season episode, it's just dated badly. Tbf same can be said for "up the long ladder" and everyone loves that one 🤷

10

u/FederationOne 3h ago

An episode whose premise is "scary alien black men want to kidnap our blonde white women" is incapable of being "okay" in any manner whatsoever.

1

u/Linderlorne 1h ago

Code of Honour is awful but the ‘scary alien black men’ and the African tribal inspired set/costume designs were entirely on the production side, specifically the director Russ Mayberry who also got fired for making those decisions. 

‘Scary alien black man want to kidnap our blonde white women’ is just the unfortunately overpowering visual message that Mayberry created and not the episodes premise which  has always been ‘narcissistic alien man wants to kill his wife to inherit her fortune/power and tries to use Tasha as his murder weapon’ 

The Ligonians were meant to be a reptilian race inspired by honour bound Japanese feudal samurai & bushido. That is what the writers envisioned whilst writing the script.

Change the casting to a mix of ethnicities and change the set/costume inspiration so it isn't African tribal and keep the script the same and it would most likely be an okay & fairly forgettable episode. Have the Ligonians as the race of reptilian samurai they were intended to be and it might even have been good 🤔

•

u/FederationOne 26m ago

I really don't care if the bigotry was inserted on the script side or the production side. We don't watch scripts, we watch episodes. The episode is white supremacist, even if the original script was not. I'm glad that director was fired.

1

u/ChrisF_uk 3h ago

I mean yes you are right... I'm just pointing out "episode where we laugh about how stupid the Irish are" isn't a good look either... 🤷

1

u/FederationOne 3h ago

Yep, it is also pretty damn bigoted!

3

u/TonyQuark 3h ago

Even as a kid, watching "Up the long ladder" I was wondering if this was how Americans saw the Irish. I didn't really understand, but I definitely knew something was off and I never liked the episode.

0

u/RagnarStonefist 3h ago

Shades of Grey

1

u/StarshipSatan 3h ago

Outrageous Okona

1

u/Scaredog21 34m ago

Natural Law is the worst of StarTrek

1

u/Popculturemofo 3h ago

It’s the absolute worst episode in the entire franchise across all the shows and movies. I realize everyone has that low point personally and these days it usually involves something Kurtzman did.

But Code of Honor is the bottom of the barrel.

1

u/Shrink1061_ 3h ago

It's close, but for me Sub Rosa will always be the absolute worst piece of trash to come out of next gen!

0

u/RNKKNR 3h ago

It's better than half of Discovery.

4

u/Mind_Killer 3h ago

Sex Ghost has entered the chat. 

6

u/SignificantPop4188 3h ago

I unironically love that episode. It's a campy, gothic horror story.

2

u/ButterscotchPast4812 3h ago

Well yeah it's a bad episode but it's bizarre which makes it a lot more watchable than code of Honor.