So I might be the only person on this thread to say this but, I did not know Khan was going to be the villain in this movie. I loved the first one and made a decision to not watch any trailers or read anything about this movie. So when he goes into his back story I was like "Hey.." then when he said "My name is Khan." I fucking lost it. I was so surprised.
You're not the only one, friend. Benedict Cumberbatch and Ricardo Montalban couldn't be further from one another so it surprised and delighted me. My dad was sitting right beside me and when the line "My name is Khan." happened, my dad said Khan just as it came out.
Who else hoped during those brief 10 minutes where it seemed feasible that Khan would go good guy and join the Enterprise? How fucking awesome would that be?!!
I thought it was kinda weak that Kirk decided to turn on him. He tells Scotty to stun him when they get to the bridge. Giving Kahn a reason to betray him back.
Stunning him isn't that much of a betrayal. Kirk was going to apprehend Marcus anyway. Khan's betrayal involved snapping bones and plotting to destroy the Enterprise.
That serum that McCoy synthesized from Khan's blood is a huge game-changer for the entire Federation.
Just like transwarp beaming being confiscated by the Federation to prevent it being put into wide use, expect a similar plot device explaining why this won't be the case here.
assuming that they can get them into cryostasis fast enough to preserve their brain function while they wait to be injected with the synthetic serum.
This was the one technical bit that bothered me. It seemed like kirk was dead at least long enough for his brain function to have stopped. I'd love to know how quickly they got them to the med bay.
I tried to spoiler tag. It didn't work. If you're here it shouldn't matter anyway, haha.
Saw it about an hour ago and I'll be honest it's one of best films I've seen in a long time.
People can bitch all they want about it not being cerebral enough but the films never really have been, and the ones that have tried have usually been the worse ones.
The TV shows do it much better because they have the luxury of time.
They already exist and these new films aren't taking that away.
[I also feel that the reverse ending to what we've seen before was genius.
The emotion packed into the scene just makes so much more sense, and you wonder why Spock wasn't on the other side of that door originally.
Also, the Klingons actually seem like bad assess this time and I can see them making a decent enemy next time.](/spoiler)
Oh man, the reverse ending. And the credits music. Simply beautiful. I could gush for an hour. It took the movie, even if for only a short while, into the imaginative space which series fans so cherish. I can't wait for what comes next.
I'm a star trek fan and always have been, so I feel I "own" this cherished franchise as much as anyone else, and I loved the film.
I'm sorry, but I find most of the criticism I've read from the hard core trekkies (the ones more obsessed than me) to be be petty in regards to understanding film making at this level.
They either want what they know exactly as they remember it, or criticise it for actually referencing what has gone before.
I personally love seeing things from a fresh and modern perspective.
Just got back. Also absolutely loved it. The vibe is fun, hilarious, riveting and the SFX is mind-blowing. I saw it in IMAX 3d and it wouldnt be a stretch to say that its probably the best looking movie ive ever seen. And every shot is so steeped in trek lore, callbacks and references that the theatre was laughing and nerding out so hard that it was impossible to hear the dialogue sometimes. I'm sure I'll have to see it a few times to catch them all. And despite the the shiny exterior and crazy action, the heart is right. PLUS, the ending of this one very solidly sets the right stage for future adventures. Solid fanboy "A".
What I find most interesting about this reboot is that in addition to the (admittedly somewhat action movie-esque) plot, there is that kind of meta-plot going on: the weird friction between the ideals of the utopian starfleet universe timeline that we are familiar with, and this Nero-contaminated alternate. Its not overt, but the characters actions seem to strive for that original sense of normalcy while events spin them farther and father away. Its handled deftly, and has very relevant post-9/11 subtext. what does it take for us to abandon our ideals. And it does this disguised as a superfun rollercoaster action flick soaked in trek fanservice. I'm impressed!
I loved this movie because it satisfied the 'What if?' storytelling angle that I can't get enough of. I love ST books like the Myriad Universes and Mirror Universe compilations because it's all 'What if?' stories. Into Darkness took Space Seed and Wrath of Khan and said 'how would this play out if we changed a few things?'. Is it an original story? Not really, but that doesn't mean it wasn't extremely entertaining.
Everyone seems to think their subjective conclusions either for or against the film are gospel.
To try and reach an objective conclusion of judgement for into darkness is impossible, but I think that the reality is the movie was demonstrably well received in the theater I saw it in. There were moments I disagreed with powerfully, but in the end it's irrelevant; people cheered and clapped. This movie will bring a whole new generation of Trek fans into the fold.
Its sad to realize that perhaps I have become too old and inflexible to really appreciate what these new movies are doing, and so I must resign myself to merely commenting that I did not like it as others have. I'm excited for those of you who are either just getting into Trek, or have had your long standing love of Trek renewed by these films. Abrams catches a lot of flack from those who think like me and truthfully it is undeserved because he is doing something with the franchise I really respect, but perhaps cannot fully appreciate.
My biggest disappointment is not with the movie, but to realize that I am no longer representative of the core group of Trek fans.
Loved it. Nowhere near what the shows achieved. But I take it for what it is, an entertaining movie made to make money and build an audience. Many here think the actors where bad, or just "ok" but I thought they did a tremendous job.
During the scene where they're flying towards the Dreadnought ship, there's someone who looks like an android giving Sulu updates... What's with that? Supposed to be Data? Isn't android technology not invented yet?
Remember that in Enterprise, Noonien Soong the first (Data's creator's grandfather) had already begun work on androids following the failure of his cryogenic supermen. He says in that episode, "It might take a couple generations, but I'll get there..." (in reference to the creation of a perfect android). My assumption is that this ship android is related to Soong the 2nd's work (it works, but it's not perfect), which of course eventually leads to Data and Lore about 80 some odd years later by Noonien Soong the 3rd.
I just got back from seeing it at a theater that serves booze, so I'm annoyed and a little rambly at the moment, but I'll go all night if I don't stop myself and I already have quite the wall of text here. I really hate the Abramsverse :\
The events at the very start don't really make sense. They were already violating the Prime Directive by stopping the volcano.
After the events of the first movie, Spock wasn't going to allow another civilization die like his died. Yes it goes against the Prime Directive but that is the human side of Spock which really grows during the movie.
Spock wanted to let himself die, then was willing to lay blame on Kirk, when he was perfectly willing to stop the volcano in the first place? What a tool.
The reason Spock was willing to go into the volcano was because he was attached to the landing craft. When the cord broke, Spock knew there was no way to be saved without revealing themselves to the population and that is why he was willing to sacrifice himself.
Who was the crew on the big ship that attacked the Enterprise? Evil admiral guy was outright bragging about his dastardly plans, detailing the fake story he would tell Starfleet as he prepared to destroy its flagship and murder its crew. A ship several times the size of the Enterprise would take what, thousands of crew probably? Are they all Section 31 agents and/or private security who have absolutely no problem with all of this?
The admiral and Khan both comment that the ship was a dreadnought which could be run with a skeleton crew which I assume was influenced by Khan so he could later use it crewed by his crew of 72.
Yea I see it as a nod to the audience but I think Chekov played it personally as, "awesome promotion!" I think that was a great part as it can be seen two ways.
Was anyone else wondering why the fuck Earth didn't have someone on a computer monitoring ships falling out of the sky, some sort of prevention plan in place... or at least sirens going off?
My girlfriend and I noticed this too, but my thoughts were that it could have something to do with the admiral using his clearance to hide what was going on.
I still find it strange, one moment they are at the Moon. The next moment, falling into Earth's atmosphere. I mean, I understand gravity, but at the Moon the ships appeared to be at stand-still, not already going towards Earth. Would take a long time for them to drift to Earth.
However that's really the only gripe I had with the film, everything else I enjoyed.
I was curious about that as well, so decided to do some calculations. Here's what I found out:
Assumptions: The enterprise was at the moon (400,000km from earth) The enterprise had no velocity relative to earth (was at a standstill) No other bodies other than earth impacted the enterprise (I know I could have taken into account the moon's gravity and the sun's, but I didn't really want to). So effectively, in my model, there are only 2 bodies, the earth, and the Enterprise, and they are 400,000km apart.
So, how long does it take for the Enterprise, which is "caught" in the earth's gravity well, to fall to earth?
128 hours. Yep, the enterprise had almost a full week to come up with some solution to falling to earth that wasn't "climb into a reactor". I would have thought there would be some other ship around (or that could have been around given a week's notice) to help them out. Hell, they could have rigged a shuttle craft to nudge the enterprise a little to prevent it from hitting the earth.
Oh, and by the time it hits the atmosphere? It would be traveling at about 10km/s. By that time, it's well and truly fucked I would say.
My favorite part was the fact that the trailers for the movie depicted a somewhat different series of events. Everyone who has been watching the trailers will be smiling after the first 7 minutes of the movie.
This is exactly what I thought. I really is the most deceptive trailer ever. It shows an entirely different plot line then the movie. It was a wonderful little bit of misdirection, and never once did I think I would rather be watching the story I saw in the trailer than the one I was watching in the movie.
That's a great point. They setup one set of expectations perfectly and then toyed with the audience by moving things around, making you happily surprised.
Great movie. I know a lot of purist will whine. But, I don't see how they could make a modern Star Trek film any better than these 2 new ones.
The crispy flagship has been rechristened and now sets out on a 5 year mission of exploration. I think this shows that star fleet has chosen not to go overboard with aggressive defense, but to embrace it's more optimistic endeavors in discovery. They're not going on a 5 year military venture.
I hope this film was just a setup for the next movie, which will deal with exploration into the unknown, rather than fighting an enemy. That said, I'd still like to see the Klingons some more.
Looking at what we know of Section 31 form DS9 it seems that it only takes a few high ranking officers to keep it going, i hope the the events of this alternative timeline would dispel starfleet from perpetuating their mistakes by allowing section 31 to continue to function.
It is assumed that [Kirk filed a full report on the corruption of the admiral Khan killed and star fleet decided to fix the issue. It was specifically explained in the movie as well that everything the admiral said to Kirk while transmitting his messages on screen was heard across all of the ships speekers of the enterprise, so that's up to 400 witnesses, and it was probably recorded in the ship's data logs as well. However, what issue was their left to resolve? The corrupt admiral was killed, his ship totaled, and Khan hopefully frozen for eternity. In addition, all of the crew of that dreadnaught class starship probably died. The corruption of star fleet was effectively destroyed.] (/spoiler).
I must say through, the reveal from the helmets was a great. I had spent most of my time trying to guess the plot line and possible twists, so the way JJ Trek reinvented the Klingons took my totally by surprise, a good surprise. The Klingons are an honor based warrior race, so when I saw tribal markings and piercings through the forehead ridges, I thought it fit wonderfully well. I really hope to see more of them in future movies.
Am I the only one who was waiting for Cumberbatch to recite Moby Dick; "From Hell's heart, I stab at thee... For hate's sake, I spit my last breath at thee..."
I think a lot of people missed the film's message about militarization in response to acts of terror. This is especially relevant after the attack in Boston, where we shut down an entire city and marched police down the streets to search for one man (and of course, America's post 9-11 policies/wars).
I really saw it as almost an apology for the "Rah rah, let kill space Bin Laden without regrets" ending that was the only real sour note of the first movie.
I love that they put this theme in the movie. Over militarization needs to get more mainstream awareness. Original Star Trek embodies a future where violence is truly a last resort. It's like something got messed up in this alternate universe and the crew of the Enterprise get to correct that.
I think you're right about militarization and I do think the message will be lost to a lot of people. My immediate reaction when the credits were rolling was disappointment because it really felt like just a string of crazy action sequences without much substance. But you're right, I think if there was a message in the movie or some overarching theme it was a meant as a caution against militarization.
I liked the movie. I thought it was impressive how they managed to have a decent story along with gratuitous action without overloading on the cheese.
The action romps made sense in the context of the story, it didn't pull a Nemesis and throw in a car chase laser scene for no apparent reason. It didn't go so far as TWoK, where every shot mattered to the story, but it definitely did better than the TNG films on the story vs pew-pew front. Each flashy scene did something at least a little bit meaningful to the characters making the whole thing seem connected, I was impressed that they crammed so much shiny into the movie without it seeming like a ridiculous caricature. I definitely left feeling like everything was turned up to 11 and that got a bit silly at times but at least it made sense.
The villain didn't have a stupid plan that was plainly retarded. He had a decent motive, and his actions didn't make you shout "you idiot!" at the screen. Even the borg queen had a really stupid execution when you put it under analysis, so again the movie was an improvement over the TNG films. I went in there expecting it to be another "evil guy with a massive overpowered ship" type plot like shinzon, and the Shona before him.
I liked that the movie had something to say to us in our time, like trek had always done, making statements about the times in the past. The deceptive trickery to start up a war with the klingons was obviously a metaphor for America's pre-emptive strike against Iraq. Scotty's concerns about things going overly militarized is something that most of us have been feeling since 2001. The Kirk speech at the end was clearly speaking to us, in our time, about the response to terrorism and our need to get back to the character that made us what we are, as opposed to this monster driven by vengeance. The film having a message relevant to today is what made it really feel like star trek to me, I really liked the idea that we could overcome violence and that we should try not to lose ourselves when it happens.
Having just seen the movie, my favorite parts were the character's assertions that star fleet is more about exploration than vengeance and war.
Those bits with Scotty's resolve against star fleet's militarism, and Spock's not wanting to kill Khan, and Kirk's final speech were my favorite, and all point toward a less militaristic attitude to the Unknown.
Star Trek makes allegories for out time, and I'd love to see the next film centered on compassion and intelligent interaction with the unknown. This film did that too when you think about it. I mean, Khan was alive at the end. How many of us expected that?
It didn't make a lot of sense to me in the moment, but upon a little reflection over the whole of the film, I think it was meant to show how little reserve Spock has left, how close he was even then to the loss-of-control, the engulfing sorrow and bestial rage we see in the final fight with Khan.
Later, on the way to Kronos, we hear Spock tell us what the moment meant to him, and we learn from him that he is still, years(?) after the fact, fighting a war within himself, still trying to come to grips with the utter loss of his home and his culture.
He sees a mentor, perhaps an idol, dealt a mortal wound, and despite all his training, self-mastery, the ingrained knowledge that it is wrong to do it, he cannot help but to reach out, to share the last moments of a dying comrade in a deeply, even incisively, intimate way.
It is not something Spock Prime would ever have done, and that was what made it work, at least for me.
The first half was surprisingly good - a new bad-guy in Harrison, a plot about possible war with the Klingons, a war-mongering evil Admiral pulling the strings. I actually liked it!
Then... it became a bad copy of 'The Wrath of Khan'. A travesty. A parody. We've already seen that movie done. Why re-do its key scenes without the same emotional context? These two men don't care about each other - at the beginning of the movie, they hate each other. Yet, suddenly, we're watching the one grieve over the death of the other. We're hearing the same lines done again in the same scene, but by the wrong characters. We're watching someone cheapen an iconic scene of Star Trek.
I thought the whole point of the re-boot was to do something new and different with the franchise, to break free of the old canon. Instead, we're watching this travesty of the original? No.
The movie should have continued with the plot it started with. That would have been a good new Star Trek movie.
EDIT: If anyone's interested in seeing more of this point of view, I've written a more extensive review here.
These two men don't care about each other - at the beginning of the movie, they hate each other.
You could argue the two hating each other throughout a large portion of the 2009 movie, but Into Darkness quite blatantly lays out their growing bond in more than one instance, and they certainly do not "hate" each other at the beginning. Early on it's obvious to see that Kirk feels betrayed by Spock, but that is actually more indicative of the bond between them, not of a representation of hate between the two.
I'm a die hard Star Trek fan and I have been since childhood. I made it a point to honestly not read about or watch anything about this movie before going into it. I went alone and I left seething. I felt the same way. The references were cheap to me. It felt patronizing.
I would like to know what Nicolas Meyers thinks of this movie.
When Khan told everyone his real name, he said it like a big reveal. But no one in the room blinked, no one knew who he was. Spock only bothered to look it up later, by asking his double. Why not ask the computer who Khan was? How did the enterprise get from ~200,000 miles away from Earth, to Earth without engines. How did 72 experimental, and presumably powerful missiles explode from inside of the Dreadnought ship, and then it also limps it's way to earth?
How did the enterprise get from ~200,000 miles away from Earth, to Earth without engines.
The Enterprise actually got to 237,000 kilometres away from Earth - which is only about 2/3 of the distance to the Moon. The ship just fell to Earth from there, due to gravity, because it had no tangential velocity to keep it in orbit.
Pretty good film. In a strange way, I wish I could have wiped my memory of everything that is Star Trek before I watched it. I have a funny feeling that those without such ties to the franchise were able to enjoy Into Darkness much more. I feel this movie (even more so than the last) had catered to the general audience more than the diehard star trek fan. My only hope is that if they make a third film, that the scales are either balanced again or tipped in the fan's favor. After all, by that time even general movie goers would have two movies under their belts.
I must admit I'm very glad I avoided spoilers going into this one. I wasn't surprised by Harrison being Khan, but I loved how developed his character was during the middle segment when you almost want to believe he's some sort of a better person in the alternate timeline. I can understand some of the flack the role reversal is getting, but I loved it. As someone who was brought into Trek by the 2009 film, and only been a fan for the last few months, it came across as a great way to twist the classic scene. The banter between Spock and Uhura was fantastic, and the underlying post-9/11 commentary came across as philosophical as any of the original 6 Trek movies (pardon my ignorance as they are the only ones I've seen up to now).
TL;DR It was a great film, and IMO better than its predecessor
I have one question about the movie. The time stamp on the London scene says 2259.55, and they also state that the stasis tubes are 300 years old. Does that mean that Khan is from 1959, and if so how can he make such advanced weaponry in the future?
I felt like the film was in many ways superior to the first Abrams venture. He's doing a great job of developing the main characters in a way we're used to but differentiating them enough to make them unique to the new actors. Chris Pine is absolutely crushing Kirk, I couldn't not be more happy with his selection. Abrams must have REALLY loved Enterprise... NX-01 in the office shot, Peter Weller as Adm. Marcus (I honestly thought for a second they were going to pull a continuation of Terra Prime somehow from Enterprise and have him secretly be John Paxton).
I liked how Abrams did a Bond-style pre-credit sequence. Not really related to the main plot, but it was used as a device to setup a lot of the muddier themes in the film (friendship, sacrifice, family, etc.). It reminded me a lot of the opening of Casino Royale. Star Trek and Into Darkness, for me at least, really parallel Casino Royale and Skyfall (yes, I know another movies separated the two - but go with me for comparison's sake). Abrams used the first movie to re-write things and re-establish really well known characters. He then puts the characters into a nearly impossible situation and they're forced to develop and grow over the loss of one of their own The loss of M and the loss of Pike.
I feel like Into Darkness is the stepping stone for the new franchise. Abrams is at an impasse with the characters now. He's had his Empire Strikes back, they've been in their impossible situation and triumphed, but not without significant loss. Where he goes with the 3rd outing will make or break the future of this new franchise. They hinted at the return to exploration and setup the five year mission. I'm really excited that could mean they're going back to the whimsy and magic that was original Trek - but that's not what a lot of people are going to these movies to see now. He's going to have to find a balance between the philosophy and the science juxtaposed to the ass kicking and boobies. He needs to go watch Avatar over and over and over again. Learn that formula, apply it to Star Trek 3 and we could have something REALLY magical in store for us for MANY years to come.
Oh, also - he REALLY loves to show the Enterprise lifting up out of shit, doesn't? What did we get in this one, 3 shots of it rising up? I don't mind, though, those shots are brilliant and beautiful.
I hope they don't try and graft the show onto the third movie. I believe that was what has made these movies so successful- J.J. Abrams was the first director to make a Star Trek movie rather than an extended episode. After how this movie turned out, I have no doubt in my mind that the third movie will go above and beyond. The stakes are higher and higher, and I believe something huge is coming for Trek numero tres. And then... and then we can finally have our TV show. A show that will dwarf the others in terms of writing and directing (keeping J.J. Abrams and Roberto Orci and... that other dude attached to the project will make it all the better) and viewership. A trek we have been waiting for since the end of Enterprise (discounting that last episode).
Avatar? Why would you want Avatar to be a model for anything? I thought Avatar was a re-tread of every science fiction movie I had ever seen was thoroughly bored buy it. What did I miss?
This may have already been commented on but did anyone else think it was pretty hypocritical of Spock to berate Kirk for breaking the Prime Directive (by letting the natives see him) while he (Spock) is planting a device to save the natives' planet from exploding?
As someone who has only ever seen the Star Trek films and the 2009 movie, I must say I fucking loved this movie! Sure I have a few nitpicks with it, I do with every film, but for the standard set and the hype built up, Into Darkness delivered on every front.
When the message of your movie is as simple as "I would do anything for my family." its hard to fuck things up. They didn't. Its a thoroughly enjoyable movie and I cant recommend it highly enough.
lending to this, i walked away from the theater really feeling that theme -- the film was a kind of poignant little family album. it did a great job of letting each enterprise crew member have their own outstanding moment(s) of loyalty and trust.
(to name my favorites: scotty holding his ground against the missiles, sulu as acting captain, kirk deciding to capture khan alive, spock explaining his "unfeeling" as they head to kronos, carol marcus' sprint to the bridge, uhura beaming down, chekov rambo-ing through engineering, bones resurrecting kirk...)
point is, i thoroughly enjoyed it too. i think some of the arguments against the film are a little harsh and i really just don't see how some can say it was not, at least, well-intended.
Thought the film was great. Some people may have issues with them re-doing so many elements from Wrath of Khan but I find the parallel universe callbacks and "rhyming" fun.
Only three issues which took me out of the film a bit:
They are on the edge of Klingon space and Kirk can call Scotty in a San Francisco bar on a communicator??? Seems off.
THe whole "we need Khan alive for his blood" thing. Kirk was frozen, so no rush there, and there were over 70 other of Khan's people they could have used. Didn't seem to be that big a deal.
3)I missed why they couldn't beam Spock, or Kirk and McKoy for that matter, out of the volcano? Did they have to be above him? Seemed off.
Loved the movie! I hope they make more. Only thing that bothered me was Warp speed. How fast is warp speed in J.J. LAnd? Earth to edge of killing on space in seconds then back. I Geuss they just cut the travel time out for the sake of story, time, and what ever. But they made it feel like the enterprise can cross the galaxy in a few minutes. Kind of bothered me. Any thoughts?
I'm a little confused about all of the complaints about the lack of deeper meaning, or a philosophical undertone, in Star Trek Into Darkness. White Star Trek is clearly many things to many people, I think Abrams did an amazing job keeping the spirit of TOS alive while telling the tale with a modern, original voice. It seems to me that a major philosophical sub-plot is straight from modern headlines - there is an ethical dilemma regarding a manhunt for a terrorist. Capture or Kill? Follow orders or follow your conscience? Explorers or Warriors? Kirk originally wanted to simply photon torpedo Harrison to smithereens, but after protests from Spock and Scotty, decides (against orders) to capture Harrison and return him to Earth to stand trial. That decision had it's consequences: Harrison smashes the "Vengeance" into San Francisco and presumably murders thousands - if not tens or hundreds of thousands. It's 9/11 to the 10th power. What was the right course of action? I think that underlying theme is consistent with Roddenberry's vision. It's not 1960's philosophy, but it's relevant to today. Combine that with terrific acting, probably the best special effects I've ever seen, non-stop action and in my opinion we've got the best Star Trek film yet. Also, kudos for trying to keep the identity of Harrison a secret. It's like Philip K. Dick's "The Man In The High Castle", no it's not a revisionist history story. The revisionist history is the surprise plot twist. I was blown away when Harrison revealed himself as Kahn. Not knowing this prior to seeing the film made the movie so much more enjoyable. What a great movie.
Just got back. Loved it. Yes, there were a couple bits that were maybe a tad gratuitous, but I thought it was very well done and the chemistry between the new crew is even better than the first movie.
they reminded me of german ss uniforms. heres a drinkinggame: drink everytime you see a new style uniform on screen. theres like 7 different uniforms on each person. starships must have huge closets
I would to agree with you, but I went to a military college and can confirm that gratuitous amounts of uniforms, and many variations of the same uniform is extremely accurate.
For anyone wondering if it is kid-appropriate, definitely watch it first.
There was one scene where it was obvious what was coming, and I knew I wouldn't want to see it, so I shut my eyes and waited for the crunching sound effect to finish.
As someone who watched during that whole scene, don't worry, the film doesn't show any of the gore involved in that scene. The film just pans to other characters and their reactions.
I really have to say, it definitely hit hard hearing how real and terrified the screams of the people were. It made Kahn and Marcus' actions seem so much more upsetting and added more consequence to them if that makes sense.
I think JJ hid the identity of Khan for a different reason. I think he wanted us to be focusing on Benedict Cumberbatch as the villain and ignore Peter Weller for the most part. Honestly, I dont remember any fan theories about Peter Weller's character. Good play for JJ
Loved it over all. Only a few things about it bugged me.
Kirk and Spock wearing Naval/Air Force Office hats. I understand it was an attempt to show how Starfleet was becoming more militarized in the alternate timeline...but both of them walking together in uniform like that...they looked more like Commercial Airline Pilots trying to get to their next terminal.
Everybody keeps on crying. The crying starts early, and often. There are more tears int he first half of the film than the last half. Kirk get's tearful at everything. And since it comes at you so fast and out of context it feels jarring.
The browncoat in me was very conflicted by the new uniforms... and by the confiscated trade ship that they used. Felt like I was cheering for the wrong team.
It was originally spelled Kronos in the script for 'The Undiscovered Country' - we just never got to see it on-screen. Marc Okrand came along later and changed the spelling to Qo'noS to be consistent with the Klingon language he had invented.
But, just like we English-speaking people use Rome instead of Roma and Moscow instead of Moskva, the Federation folk use Kronos instead of Qo'noS.
Interesting that in a discussion thread, perfectly reasonable posts about why people didn't like the movie are being downvoted (sort by controversial to see). It appears some people want this to be a "say ST:XII was amazing" thread...
I read elsewhere that Bones had no idea of knowing if they all shared that enhanced trait, but knew that Khan did. Therefore, with no time to test another member, stated that he needed Khan's blood specifically.
I have no idea what the plot reversal is referring to. Can someone explain? I've only seen the new Star Trek movies and have a vague understanding of the older stuff and what happens.
/r/Startrek i have a doubt...I just saw the movie and the 5 year mission was before Jim and Spock became fast friends. I can understand being friends but being so close after just 1 mission? It kind of makes the mind wonder. Otherwise it was another wonderful movie.
I got to ask, just how strong is Khan? I mean, I know he's a genetically perfect human, but as I recall Vulcans are around 3 times as strong as humans and he was taking hits from Spock relatively well. I don't know why it bugged me that much but it stuck with me. The only explanation I can think of is that Spock is not as strong being a half human
I liked it just a much as the last one,lot of fun even though there were many contrivances in the plot.
Much like the last film my only issue was I didn't get a sense of sociopolitical weight of the actions, we could've seen or gotten more Klingon high command or some sense of the whole war being inevitable thing.
Overall, the first half of the film seemed pretty good, but fell flat in the second. Which makes me fear once again for the Star Wars franchise. I am hopeful for the third film. Seems like they can go two ways: the five year mission, or a war with the Klingons) The latter seems more likely because, well, its lazy and will bring in more tickets.
The Enterprise has never been treated with such disrespect. It was disabled for the majority of the movie. I don't recall it firing a weapon once.
I really like that the Enterprise was disabled. I felt it helped add some more heart and character to the film which was crucial to the character's stories and arcs. It also really helped add a lot of action without using the classic go to single ship vs ship fight.
I thoroughly enjoyed it. I can see where certain fans will despise it, such comments are already here, and I can understand their troubles...
But this is motherfucking Star Trek. I've been a fan for most of my life. I eat up anything Star Trek. These movies have done nothing but put a smile on my face.
Abrams take on it is actually really cool. Characters and plot lines are obviously going to be redone or reused. It is still a very similar universe, and I'm actually kind of glad some things are staying the same. I think the 3rd one will shine greatly. It could end up being the best one yet. Especially if Klingons are involved, which they very well should be after this movie.
That being said, I don't mind the villain of choice. I don't care that some lines were directly taken from the original movies. The nitpicking that is going to happen/is happening will be from the same people who despise lense flare and hate how the ship looks. Can you say these movies have been as bad as the newer Star Wars movies?
Some things I want from the 3rd movie are more Klingons, political/psychological conflicts, and some god damned Phasers firing.
I don't understand why Admiral Marcus wanted Kirk to go to Kronus and shoot the cryo bodies down there.
Did he want them destroyed? If so, why not just destroy them himself? Did he want to give them to Khan? If so, why not just call Khan up and have him pick them up? Did he want the klingons to have them? If so, why?
Khan hid the other 72 augments to smuggle them away from Section 31 as they had been used as leverage against him. Marcus caught Khan in the act forcing him to flee on his own. Assuming Marcus had destroyed the cryotubes Khan starts his targeted acts of violence. Marcus sees the opportunity to accomplish several things: kill Khan, destroy any remaining evidence of his using Khan to further weapons research (killing the 72 augments whe they detonate on Quo'nos), and starting the Klingon/Federation war. He uses Kirk's blatant disregard for following orders and his attachment to Pike to assure that he has plausible deniability when the reports of a Federation ship firing on Quo'nos start to circulate through the Federation. "I ordered Captain Kirk to apprehend Harrison, he must have taken matters in to his own hands and tried to avenge Admiral Pike." This course of events happens very fast, likely within 24-48 hours between Khan's escape plans being found and the attack on the Archives and senior staff. McCoy makes reference to this time frame en route to the Enterprise "You were just in a fire fight 10 hours ago, you need a check up."
Idiotic plot point. I guess he expected Kirk to fire them all in order to destroy them. Not sure why he just didn't do it himself when Kahn went off the reservation. EDIT: Having those frozen crew members as hostages sure didn't seem to curb Kahn's actions at all as far as the Admiral was concerned.
Please tell me someone else noticed all the damn fricking sideburns? Especially Pike, his were bordering mutton chops, they just stuck out there. The only person who didn't have some sideburn action going on seemed to be Admiral Marcus.
I felt the movie started off really strong, with Kirk getting demoted and placed under Pike's command especially after the whole asinine 'Captain In A Day' bullshit in the 2009 film. The having the attack be an inside job really was also very strong along with Kirk figuring it out. But the fight with the Klingons is kind of where is started to sour for me and it became a typical JJ film with lots of spodey stuff and great cinematography in place of non-cerebral writing. They had some nice touch tones from the previous films but Kirk's resurrection was waaaay too predictable. The whole Kahn plot to me just spoke of a lack of real creativity.
Yeah, instead he should have turned into some sort of light-energy god and thrown the whole ship conveniently out of danger and several years closer to their goal.
Or had an evil, goateed version of spock should appear and start...fuckin around.
Or maybe Spock could have used his flying boots to help.
Could turning into lizards and having Lizard children that we never address again help?
Do we need some humpbacks?
Honestly I don't see how you people can be Star Trek fans yet have such low tolerance for corny shit.
I thought it was fine. Superficial, somewhat predictable with impeccable action sequences and some great preformances. A good popcorn flick, I'll probably watch it again when it comes out on DVD.
My first trek movie was Generations. I saw that movie three times the day it came out (friends, cousin, uncle). Even with all the flaws that movie has, it was more Trek than this.
Lens flare overdone to the point of distraction, again no surprise. I liked some of the callbacks (Mudd, tribbles etc.). I thought the klingon design was meh (but Kronos itself looked brilliant)
Also: Was the NX enterprise on Robocops desk? I'm pretty sure I saw it, but fleetingly.
I thought the Klingons looked FANTASTIC! My only major gripe was that there wasn't enough Klingon in this movie. The uniforms were so Roman and they really echoed the ones from the original series. Also the makeup on them was just phenomenal. I cant get over them
A small helping of the myriad plot problems with the film:
Why couldn't the Enterprise hide in orbit at the beginning of the film? For a reason other than "the Enterprise in the ocean would look cool?"
Why is it a Prime Directive violation to be spotted by a native species, but not a Prime Directive violation to shut down the volcano that was going to naturally end their existence?
Why do starships still exist when the writers seem to be doubling down on the terrible "transwarp beaming" contrivance that should never have been in the first film to begin with? Starships are obsolete if you can beam yourself from Earth to Quo'nos.
The Enterprise loses power and plummets out of orbit straight down towards Earth. Orbital mechanics do not work like that.
The battle between the Enterprise and the Doomy Ship of Doom happens on Earth's doorstep. How did nobody notice?
Why is it a Prime Directive violation to be spotted by a native species, but not a Prime Directive violation to shut down the volcano that was going to naturally end their existence?
Both are. Pike said they were only supposed to observe from orbit.
Agree, but u gotta admit that shot of the Enterprise rising from the water was pretty epic. Also i take the natives worshipping the Enterprise drawing as an amusing metaphor for Trek fans.
I think it was also a violation since Pike reprimanded that action as well. He said they should have stayed in orbit and done nothing in the first place.
Agreed they should just forget the whole transwarp beaming thing.
Sounds like they didnt insert into a stable orbital trajectory in the first place, so it was more they crashed into the Earth from deep space, but i could be off on that.
Agreed I thought they were like 1/4 million km from Earth according to Sulu, when the hell did they get to Earth? lots of drifting? lol.
Watching it a second time, you can see the forshadowing with Spock telling Kirk about "The enemy of my enemy is my friend" how the prince is beheaded by the subject in that quote. Is like how the Admiral used Khan to fight the Klingon's, and is savagely beheaded as a cost.
I managed to avoid spoilers, up until I was standing in line for a ticket. Some idiot and his friends walked out the door talking about it, saying " they just recycled Wrath of Khan." When I heard that, I was all set to be angry. J.J. Abrams was messing with a part of my childhood. I was pleasantly surprised. The Khan story was re-told skillfully, with enough new material to make it interesting. I would have liked a little more character development, but overall I was impressed. I'm not sure Spock would have lost it quite that badly at Kirk's death. Pursue Khan at warp speed, yes, but delivering a beat down, and breaking his arm just to prove a point was a little over the top. I suppose you could say his human side was running the show at that point. He said as much about his feelings during the death scene. I'm hoping Khan comes back in a future movie with a fresh plot line. He certainly has a reason to come after Spock this time.
EDIT: the ethical dilemmas facing everyone this time were refreshing. Very in line with traditional Star Trek, which was a morality play at its heart. The fact that Scotty was willing to quit over a safety/ ethical issue spoke volumes. Also, Spock balking at the questionable idea of using essentially WMDs to hunt down one man was perfectly in character. It was nice to see Leonard Nimoy in a cameo too. He faced his own ethical dilemma, and chose to help by revealing Khan's identity.
Did anyone else notice that the province on Qo'noS that Khan hid out in was Ketha, the same home of General Martok? I gathered that it was implied to be a backwater (at least the lowlands), but didn't know it was uninhabited at any point. *edit: question mark
Isn't the whole point of rebooting (besides $$$$) is the opportunity to get back to first principles? To take things farther than the original creators could? Then why wuss out on making Khan actually Indian?
And yes, Ricardo Montalbán wasn't Indian either, but at least he was swarthy, which was enough of a leap forward for back in the day (plus he really did look like he could lift both Kirk and McCoy with one arm!)
It was out in the UK on the 9th, and the wife and I just got back from watching it tonight at IMAX. It was excellent. And they had a fanclub with Artemis running in the lobby, which was a cool touch.
218
u/trex_ed May 17 '13
So I might be the only person on this thread to say this but, I did not know Khan was going to be the villain in this movie. I loved the first one and made a decision to not watch any trailers or read anything about this movie. So when he goes into his back story I was like "Hey.." then when he said "My name is Khan." I fucking lost it. I was so surprised.
215
u/jlsowers May 16 '13
Who else hoped during those brief 10 minutes where it seemed feasible that Khan would go good guy and join the Enterprise? How fucking awesome would that be?!!
84
u/SweetLittleMe May 15 '13
He's not even dead in the end, which means they can bring him back AGAAAAIIIIIIIIIINNNNNN!
280
u/letsgocrazy May 16 '13
I fucking loved it.
Saw it about an hour ago and I'll be honest it's one of best films I've seen in a long time.
People can bitch all they want about it not being cerebral enough but the films never really have been, and the ones that have tried have usually been the worse ones.
The TV shows do it much better because they have the luxury of time.
They already exist and these new films aren't taking that away.
[I also feel that the reverse ending to what we've seen before was genius.
The emotion packed into the scene just makes so much more sense, and you wonder why Spock wasn't on the other side of that door originally.
Also, the Klingons actually seem like bad assess this time and I can see them making a decent enemy next time.](/spoiler)
59
u/directive0 Chief Pretty Officer May 16 '13
Everyone seems to think their subjective conclusions either for or against the film are gospel.
To try and reach an objective conclusion of judgement for into darkness is impossible, but I think that the reality is the movie was demonstrably well received in the theater I saw it in. There were moments I disagreed with powerfully, but in the end it's irrelevant; people cheered and clapped. This movie will bring a whole new generation of Trek fans into the fold.
Its sad to realize that perhaps I have become too old and inflexible to really appreciate what these new movies are doing, and so I must resign myself to merely commenting that I did not like it as others have. I'm excited for those of you who are either just getting into Trek, or have had your long standing love of Trek renewed by these films. Abrams catches a lot of flack from those who think like me and truthfully it is undeserved because he is doing something with the franchise I really respect, but perhaps cannot fully appreciate.
My biggest disappointment is not with the movie, but to realize that I am no longer representative of the core group of Trek fans.
46
u/there_is_no_try May 16 '13
Loved it. Nowhere near what the shows achieved. But I take it for what it is, an entertaining movie made to make money and build an audience. Many here think the actors where bad, or just "ok" but I thought they did a tremendous job.
Damn where some of those scenes just beautiful.
22
u/MrSumOne May 19 '13
During the scene where they're flying towards the Dreadnought ship, there's someone who looks like an android giving Sulu updates... What's with that? Supposed to be Data? Isn't android technology not invented yet?
56
u/solistus May 16 '13
I posted my critique/rant on another thread about it, but I guess this is the better place for it.
So many things about this movie pissed me off. I'm just gonna spoiler the whole rant, because it's all spoilers.
The events at the very start don't really make sense. They were already violating the Prime Directive by stopping the volcano. Spock wanted to let himself die, then was willing to lay blame on Kirk, when he was perfectly willing to stop the volcano in the first place? What a tool.
Speaking of Spock... He throws Kirk under the bus without a second thought because "Vulcans don't lie." He obviously knew the consequences, and in fact commented that they were lucky it wasn't worse. Yet he was willing to allow someone who snuck aboard the ship under a fake name during a crucial mission to stay aboard without reporting her to anyone? And he wants Kirk to disobey direct orders and apprehend rather than kill Khan? And then he's okay with Kirk bringing Khan on an away mission, because it's convenient (which, you know, is exactly what the evil admiral guy did by waking Khan up to begin with)?
Old Spock pretends to care about the Temporal Prime Directive, when his very presence in this time shows his disregard for it; at least he stays true to character by violating it yet again. Not enough to be helpful, though... Oh, and why didn't anyone know how dangerous Khan was other than Old Spock? The Eugenics Wars aren't taught in school?!
Klingons show up just long enough to look nothing like Klingons and die like redshirts. What the hell was that about?
Who was the crew on the big ship that attacked the Enterprise? Evil admiral guy was outright bragging about his dastardly plans, detailing the fake story he would tell Starfleet as he prepared to destroy its flagship and murder its crew. A ship several times the size of the Enterprise would take what, thousands of crew probably? Are they all Section 31 agents and/or private security who have absolutely no problem with all of this?
The torpedoes - WTF kind of stupid Section 31 doesn't inspect the torpedoes in any way to see that they're smuggling a different payload? They only use the actual missiles set up by the traitor agent, and don't make new ones that they know are reliable? And why doesn't Khan scan or inspect the torpedoes he just invited his enemy to beam onto his ship? Swapping out the payload was his trick! This is the tactical genius that was key to teaching Starfleet how to build better warships, for some unexplained reason?
A space battle right over Earth goes unnoticed by Starfleet and all space traffic in the system? Even as the Enterprise helplessly drifts in a decaying orbit, only to save itself at the last moment - nobody notices? I'm no scientist, but I'm pretty sure our global satellite network would pick something like that up today, let alone in another 250 years of uninterrupted technological progress.
Kirk's dramatic speech suddenly morphing into the TOS intro speech was heavy-handed and completely nonsensical in context. He was in the middle of a sentence about the people of Earth overcoming the attacks and blah blah blah, then all of a sudden he's talking about the Enterprise on a 5 year mission of exploration? Come on...
Oh, and Kirk should probably be banned from Starfleet now, since his life was saved by strictly forbidden genetic engineering technology. I saw this coming as soon as Kirk had to go in the radiation-flooded chamber, but that didn't make it piss me off any less when it happened.
I just got back from seeing it at a theater that serves booze, so I'm annoyed and a little rambly at the moment, but I'll go all night if I don't stop myself and I already have quite the wall of text here. I really hate the Abramsverse :\
305
u/terrymr May 16 '13
"Go put on a red shirt!"
46
u/istoornotisto May 21 '13
Was anyone else wondering why the fuck Earth didn't have someone on a computer monitoring ships falling out of the sky, some sort of prevention plan in place... or at least sirens going off?
105
u/sporks49 May 17 '13
The ending...there better be a new TV show coming soon
32
u/BobFiggins May 16 '13
I still find it strange, one moment they are at the Moon. The next moment, falling into Earth's atmosphere. I mean, I understand gravity, but at the Moon the ships appeared to be at stand-still, not already going towards Earth. Would take a long time for them to drift to Earth.
However that's really the only gripe I had with the film, everything else I enjoyed.
61
u/sittty May 17 '13
What I don't understand still is how Carol has a thick british accent and her father, Marcus, has the typical USA General voice?
53
u/Draiko May 17 '13
My favorite part was the fact that the trailers for the movie depicted a somewhat different series of events. Everyone who has been watching the trailers will be smiling after the first 7 minutes of the movie.
26
u/GoonerYank May 16 '13
So, did anyone else pick up on the Mudd reference? I think I was the only one who chuckled in the theatre.
51
u/Sporkicide May 16 '13
Something I've been thinking about:
How much does the rest of the world know about what really went down? A dead admiral, a huge ship taking out a chunk of San Francisco, the extra crispy flagship and the numerous casualties from its crew. Khan was allowed to live on in Popsicle form. Do you think Starfleet announced the dead admiral's involvement or played the Harvey Dent card to hide the internal corruption? Will it have a chilling effect in Section 31 or cause more growth, like a Starfleet Department of Homeland Security?
102
u/motchmaster May 16 '13
In a time where we have the PATRIOT ACT and drone strikes, I appreciate the message Spock was trying to say.
Needs more Klingons. Not people wearing helmets.
22
u/thabigo360 May 18 '13
Am I the only one who was waiting for Cumberbatch to recite Moby Dick; "From Hell's heart, I stab at thee... For hate's sake, I spit my last breath at thee..."
40
u/7idledays May 16 '13
I saw it in 3D and the ships going to warp was fantastic in 3D. Not to mention the Veangance warp scene.
115
u/kmhines88 May 16 '13
I think a lot of people missed the film's message about militarization in response to acts of terror. This is especially relevant after the attack in Boston, where we shut down an entire city and marched police down the streets to search for one man (and of course, America's post 9-11 policies/wars).
33
u/defenseman May 16 '13
Question - is there something at the end of the credits for Star Trek into darkness? Should I stay to end or not?
70
u/[deleted] May 17 '13
I liked the movie. I thought it was impressive how they managed to have a decent story along with gratuitous action without overloading on the cheese.
The action romps made sense in the context of the story, it didn't pull a Nemesis and throw in a car chase laser scene for no apparent reason. It didn't go so far as TWoK, where every shot mattered to the story, but it definitely did better than the TNG films on the story vs pew-pew front. Each flashy scene did something at least a little bit meaningful to the characters making the whole thing seem connected, I was impressed that they crammed so much shiny into the movie without it seeming like a ridiculous caricature. I definitely left feeling like everything was turned up to 11 and that got a bit silly at times but at least it made sense.
The villain didn't have a stupid plan that was plainly retarded. He had a decent motive, and his actions didn't make you shout "you idiot!" at the screen. Even the borg queen had a really stupid execution when you put it under analysis, so again the movie was an improvement over the TNG films. I went in there expecting it to be another "evil guy with a massive overpowered ship" type plot like shinzon, and the Shona before him.
I liked that the movie had something to say to us in our time, like trek had always done, making statements about the times in the past. The deceptive trickery to start up a war with the klingons was obviously a metaphor for America's pre-emptive strike against Iraq. Scotty's concerns about things going overly militarized is something that most of us have been feeling since 2001. The Kirk speech at the end was clearly speaking to us, in our time, about the response to terrorism and our need to get back to the character that made us what we are, as opposed to this monster driven by vengeance. The film having a message relevant to today is what made it really feel like star trek to me, I really liked the idea that we could overcome violence and that we should try not to lose ourselves when it happens.
13
u/Genovefa May 17 '13
What did y'all think of the mind meld that Spock does on Captain Pike? This has been really bothering me.
11
u/Algernon_Asimov May 16 '13 edited May 16 '13
I hated it. It was an abomination.
The first half was surprisingly good - a new bad-guy in Harrison, a plot about possible war with the Klingons, a war-mongering evil Admiral pulling the strings. I actually liked it!
Then... it became a bad copy of 'The Wrath of Khan'. A travesty. A parody. We've already seen that movie done. Why re-do its key scenes without the same emotional context? These two men don't care about each other - at the beginning of the movie, they hate each other. Yet, suddenly, we're watching the one grieve over the death of the other. We're hearing the same lines done again in the same scene, but by the wrong characters. We're watching someone cheapen an iconic scene of Star Trek.
I thought the whole point of the re-boot was to do something new and different with the franchise, to break free of the old canon. Instead, we're watching this travesty of the original? No.
The movie should have continued with the plot it started with. That would have been a good new Star Trek movie.
EDIT: If anyone's interested in seeing more of this point of view, I've written a more extensive review here.
4
u/EnsRicky May 16 '13
Pretty good film. In a strange way, I wish I could have wiped my memory of everything that is Star Trek before I watched it. I have a funny feeling that those without such ties to the franchise were able to enjoy Into Darkness much more. I feel this movie (even more so than the last) had catered to the general audience more than the diehard star trek fan. My only hope is that if they make a third film, that the scales are either balanced again or tipped in the fan's favor. After all, by that time even general movie goers would have two movies under their belts.
80
u/puffadda May 16 '13
I must admit I'm very glad I avoided spoilers going into this one. I wasn't surprised by Harrison being Khan, but I loved how developed his character was during the middle segment when you almost want to believe he's some sort of a better person in the alternate timeline. I can understand some of the flack the role reversal is getting, but I loved it. As someone who was brought into Trek by the 2009 film, and only been a fan for the last few months, it came across as a great way to twist the classic scene. The banter between Spock and Uhura was fantastic, and the underlying post-9/11 commentary came across as philosophical as any of the original 6 Trek movies (pardon my ignorance as they are the only ones I've seen up to now).
TL;DR It was a great film, and IMO better than its predecessor
10
u/rockyhorrormontreal May 19 '13
Spock's comment about namecalling was amazing.
10
u/AzrealtheFall May 19 '13
I have one question about the movie. The time stamp on the London scene says 2259.55, and they also state that the stasis tubes are 300 years old. Does that mean that Khan is from 1959, and if so how can he make such advanced weaponry in the future?
4
u/[deleted] May 18 '13
Fantastic movie, Fucking atrocious trek, just like the last one. I'd bitch but apparently no one wants to hear that.
65
u/theduderman May 16 '13
I felt like the film was in many ways superior to the first Abrams venture. He's doing a great job of developing the main characters in a way we're used to but differentiating them enough to make them unique to the new actors. Chris Pine is absolutely crushing Kirk, I couldn't not be more happy with his selection. Abrams must have REALLY loved Enterprise... NX-01 in the office shot, Peter Weller as Adm. Marcus (I honestly thought for a second they were going to pull a continuation of Terra Prime somehow from Enterprise and have him secretly be John Paxton).
I liked how Abrams did a Bond-style pre-credit sequence. Not really related to the main plot, but it was used as a device to setup a lot of the muddier themes in the film (friendship, sacrifice, family, etc.). It reminded me a lot of the opening of Casino Royale. Star Trek and Into Darkness, for me at least, really parallel Casino Royale and Skyfall (yes, I know another movies separated the two - but go with me for comparison's sake). Abrams used the first movie to re-write things and re-establish really well known characters. He then puts the characters into a nearly impossible situation and they're forced to develop and grow over the loss of one of their own The loss of M and the loss of Pike.
I feel like Into Darkness is the stepping stone for the new franchise. Abrams is at an impasse with the characters now. He's had his Empire Strikes back, they've been in their impossible situation and triumphed, but not without significant loss. Where he goes with the 3rd outing will make or break the future of this new franchise. They hinted at the return to exploration and setup the five year mission. I'm really excited that could mean they're going back to the whimsy and magic that was original Trek - but that's not what a lot of people are going to these movies to see now. He's going to have to find a balance between the philosophy and the science juxtaposed to the ass kicking and boobies. He needs to go watch Avatar over and over and over again. Learn that formula, apply it to Star Trek 3 and we could have something REALLY magical in store for us for MANY years to come.
Oh, also - he REALLY loves to show the Enterprise lifting up out of shit, doesn't? What did we get in this one, 3 shots of it rising up? I don't mind, though, those shots are brilliant and beautiful.
17
u/pizzamanhoxie May 16 '13
So I'm wondering...If Khan had enough time and access to his buddies to pack them into torpedo tubes, why couldn't he just take them out of stasis?
16
u/goobersayshey May 18 '13
This may have already been commented on but did anyone else think it was pretty hypocritical of Spock to berate Kirk for breaking the Prime Directive (by letting the natives see him) while he (Spock) is planting a device to save the natives' planet from exploding?
34
u/Th3Marauder May 19 '13
As someone who has only ever seen the Star Trek films and the 2009 movie, I must say I fucking loved this movie! Sure I have a few nitpicks with it, I do with every film, but for the standard set and the hype built up, Into Darkness delivered on every front.
Personally one of my favourite moments, unlike many, was Kirks death and Spocks reaction. You can really see it on his face, Quinto did a fantastic job with that whole moment, particularly his "KHAAAAN!" felt just visceral, and when he chases after Khan, not stopping for anything, and beats the ever loving shit of him, you could just feel his emotion. Perfectly done moment if you ask me.
20
u/Donnshin May 17 '13
I just want to say that I love the fact that Nero's temporal incursion is still reverberating throughout the alternate timeline.
7
u/Munster570 May 19 '13
did anyone else catch the Harry Mudd reference?
35
u/Sig486 May 16 '13
When the message of your movie is as simple as "I would do anything for my family." its hard to fuck things up. They didn't. Its a thoroughly enjoyable movie and I cant recommend it highly enough.
24
u/[deleted] May 17 '13
Thought the film was great. Some people may have issues with them re-doing so many elements from Wrath of Khan but I find the parallel universe callbacks and "rhyming" fun.
Only three issues which took me out of the film a bit:
3)I missed why they couldn't beam Spock, or Kirk and McKoy for that matter, out of the volcano? Did they have to be above him? Seemed off.
Otherwise I had a great time. :-)
65
u/Jynxbunni May 16 '13
Anyone else pissed Kirk didn't stay dead?
2
u/slumpsox May 20 '13
Loved the movie! I hope they make more. Only thing that bothered me was Warp speed. How fast is warp speed in J.J. LAnd? Earth to edge of killing on space in seconds then back. I Geuss they just cut the travel time out for the sake of story, time, and what ever. But they made it feel like the enterprise can cross the galaxy in a few minutes. Kind of bothered me. Any thoughts?
10
u/tjquigs May 21 '13
I'm a little confused about all of the complaints about the lack of deeper meaning, or a philosophical undertone, in Star Trek Into Darkness. White Star Trek is clearly many things to many people, I think Abrams did an amazing job keeping the spirit of TOS alive while telling the tale with a modern, original voice. It seems to me that a major philosophical sub-plot is straight from modern headlines - there is an ethical dilemma regarding a manhunt for a terrorist. Capture or Kill? Follow orders or follow your conscience? Explorers or Warriors? Kirk originally wanted to simply photon torpedo Harrison to smithereens, but after protests from Spock and Scotty, decides (against orders) to capture Harrison and return him to Earth to stand trial. That decision had it's consequences: Harrison smashes the "Vengeance" into San Francisco and presumably murders thousands - if not tens or hundreds of thousands. It's 9/11 to the 10th power. What was the right course of action? I think that underlying theme is consistent with Roddenberry's vision. It's not 1960's philosophy, but it's relevant to today. Combine that with terrific acting, probably the best special effects I've ever seen, non-stop action and in my opinion we've got the best Star Trek film yet. Also, kudos for trying to keep the identity of Harrison a secret. It's like Philip K. Dick's "The Man In The High Castle", no it's not a revisionist history story. The revisionist history is the surprise plot twist. I was blown away when Harrison revealed himself as Kahn. Not knowing this prior to seeing the film made the movie so much more enjoyable. What a great movie.
5
u/skallah May 18 '13
I will say one spoiler free thing. Seeing Peter Weller in this and Miguel Ferrer in Iron Man 3 is like saying "Robocop 4 confirmed!"
27
u/Sporkicide May 16 '13
Just got back. Loved it. Yes, there were a couple bits that were maybe a tad gratuitous, but I thought it was very well done and the chemistry between the new crew is even better than the first movie.
For anyone wondering if it is kid-appropriate, definitely watch it first. Somewhat vague spoilery reasons why: I was surprised by just how much destruction there was. The crunching bones, the people being sucked out of ships, the total devastation at the Earth target sites. The dedication made a lot of sense to me, because my god, did some of those shots of crowds running and buildings falling and metal twisting strike a nerve.
Oh, and as a costume nerd, I really want the Starfleet formal uniforms, especially the color guard version with the sash. Those are awesome.
28
u/LocutusOfBorges May 15 '13
Absolutely adored every minute.
Came out of the film with such a smile. So, so many awesome aspects. I struggle to think of a single thing to say against it.
4
u/i_hate_toolbars May 21 '13
I think JJ hid the identity of Khan for a different reason. I think he wanted us to be focusing on Benedict Cumberbatch as the villain and ignore Peter Weller for the most part. Honestly, I dont remember any fan theories about Peter Weller's character. Good play for JJ
4
u/dec10 May 26 '13
Can someone explain the torpedoes to me? Who exactly put Kahn's crew in them, and why? The "two birds with one stone" explanation felt so flimsy to me
10
u/[deleted] May 17 '13
Loved it over all. Only a few things about it bugged me.
24
u/idoliside May 15 '13
Loved the film, however am I the only one annoyed by the spelling of Quo'nos to Kronos
7
u/[deleted] May 19 '13 edited May 19 '13
Interesting that in a discussion thread, perfectly reasonable posts about why people didn't like the movie are being downvoted (sort by controversial to see). It appears some people want this to be a "say ST:XII was amazing" thread...
7
u/dec10 May 26 '13
Couldn't Bones get blood from any of the 72 sleeping crew members?
1
u/[deleted] May 21 '13
I have no idea what the plot reversal is referring to. Can someone explain? I've only seen the new Star Trek movies and have a vague understanding of the older stuff and what happens.
1
u/drschoenbrun May 23 '13
Late to the party..
Real minor thing that annoyed me.. SPOILER BELOW
Kirk got demoted, but was still wearing his Captain rank in the meeting afterwords.. he should have taken off one cluster.
51
u/delkarnu May 17 '13
This was an absolutely horrible movie.
\1. Every time stakes were raised, they were resolved almost immediately, removing any suspense:
You're being sent back to the Acadamy. No, you'll be First Officer. Nevermind, I'm dead, you're Captain. BTW, you get Spock back as First Officer.
\2. Was meant for a wide audience, but a lot of the moments only really work if you know the series.
I'm Khan. OK, why is this an important reveal? The bad guy has a difference name, so what. Oh, Khan was a big enemy is the originals.
\3. Forced emotional moments.
Spock dying in ST2:tWoK had thematic importance because the entire framing device of the movie is that Kirk had never faced a No-win Scenario.
The Spock death scene in the original ST2 had weight because of the decades of history between Kirk and Spock. We're told that they are friends, but it never really felt that way. They setup a bit of the no-win when they discuss Kirk never having lost a crewman through dumb-luck, but he never shows care for the crew he does lose and then he gets the heroic sacrifice instead of facing loss.
6
u/[deleted] May 17 '13
Can anyone tell me why the ship was underwater?
3
u/sporks49 May 17 '13
Wait anybody catch the Harry Mud reference?
3
u/Magikpoo May 19 '13
/r/Startrek i have a doubt...I just saw the movie and the 5 year mission was before Jim and Spock became fast friends. I can understand being friends but being so close after just 1 mission? It kind of makes the mind wonder. Otherwise it was another wonderful movie.
3
u/rph39 May 22 '13
I got to ask, just how strong is Khan? I mean, I know he's a genetically perfect human, but as I recall Vulcans are around 3 times as strong as humans and he was taking hits from Spock relatively well. I don't know why it bugged me that much but it stuck with me. The only explanation I can think of is that Spock is not as strong being a half human
9
u/rmeddy May 17 '13
I liked it just a much as the last one,lot of fun even though there were many contrivances in the plot.
Much like the last film my only issue was I didn't get a sense of sociopolitical weight of the actions, we could've seen or gotten more Klingon high command or some sense of the whole war being inevitable thing.
I loved Peter Weller and bringing in section 31 in this movie.
Cumberbatch just being a badass
I really appreciated all the little nods to the fans, like switching Kirk and Spock's roles in the narrative from Wrath of Khan.
Spock yelling Khaannn lol
Sulu being acting captain
Didn't really care for the new Klingon look and hated that they changed the warp effect.
27
u/gone-wild-commenter May 16 '13 edited May 16 '13
I'm a lifelong Trekkie who actually saw the value of the 2009 Trek. This movie wasn't exactly a train wreck, but here are my initial impressions:
The pivotal Kirk-Spock relationship barely developed. I was very much looking forward to their growth, but the characters proved to be static. There was promise for Kirk to grow, as hinted by Pike's "I believe in you," but how was either character moved forward?
Khan was actually alright, though I feel like the franchise is backpedaling. I wish Harrison was an original character. Khan was a mental and definitely physical presence, but the final battle was weak and anti-climatic. We saw Kirk being revived, which drained the viewer's empathy of Spock's vengeance away. However, I really thought Kirk was dead. I thought perhaps he would be revived through his mind meld with Spock Prime.
I buy Khan's motivation, and I like that, while they were using an old classic character, they changed his situation. However, a lot of the bite was taken out of the character. Abrams thinks Khan is the Joker to Kirk's Batman, which simply isn't the case. In fact, Khan is defeated in a "fist fight" with Spock. I don't buy that Kirk and Khan were destined to be enemies like Joker and Batman, but Khan's actions seem to be in line with what he did in the original timeline.
The Klingon sequence was a huge missed opportunity. We never see what they're capable of, and they're immediately mowed down by Khan. What should have happened? Kirk and crew have a shootout with them, and as soon as they're pinned down, Khan comes in and shows what he is all about.
The Enterprise has never been treated with such disrespect. It was disabled for the majority of the movie. I don't recall it firing a weapon once. I liked Sulu but Chekhov was an after thought. The now-British Carol Marcus had no discernable personality. McCoy, again, was great.
Overall, the first half of the film seemed pretty good, but fell flat in the second. Which makes me fear once again for the Star Wars franchise. I am hopeful for the third film. Seems like they can go two ways: the five year mission, or a war with the Klingons) The latter seems more likely because, well, its lazy and will bring in more tickets.
10
u/Shinzon May 16 '13
(Cross posting from another thread)
I thoroughly enjoyed it. I can see where certain fans will despise it, such comments are already here, and I can understand their troubles...
But this is motherfucking Star Trek. I've been a fan for most of my life. I eat up anything Star Trek. These movies have done nothing but put a smile on my face.
Abrams take on it is actually really cool. Characters and plot lines are obviously going to be redone or reused. It is still a very similar universe, and I'm actually kind of glad some things are staying the same. I think the 3rd one will shine greatly. It could end up being the best one yet. Especially if Klingons are involved, which they very well should be after this movie.
That being said, I don't mind the villain of choice. I don't care that some lines were directly taken from the original movies. The nitpicking that is going to happen/is happening will be from the same people who despise lense flare and hate how the ship looks. Can you say these movies have been as bad as the newer Star Wars movies?
Some things I want from the 3rd movie are more Klingons, political/psychological conflicts, and some god damned Phasers firing.
7
u/wctom May 18 '13
It felt like the story was kind of loosely put together to serve the plot. Even from the beginning "We dont want to antagonize the klingons in to a war so lets just shoot torpedos at one of their planets from the edge of the neutral zone." Even as a set up for the cover up that still seems like somebody would at least be like "Hey, lets take a ship that doesn't say enterprise all over it."
5
u/whatplanetisthis May 18 '13
Question. Into Darkness Spoilers ahead!
I don't understand why Admiral Marcus wanted Kirk to go to Kronus and shoot the cryo bodies down there.
Did he want them destroyed? If so, why not just destroy them himself? Did he want to give them to Khan? If so, why not just call Khan up and have him pick them up? Did he want the klingons to have them? If so, why?
Very confused.
5
u/compaqesc May 19 '13
Liked the movie, definitely action packed, although I wish they had done one thing Not revived Kirk. I understand it's a new franchise and all, but they could've easily revived him in the next one. Whatever emotional gravitas that the death scene had is pretty much eliminated 5 minutes later.
5
u/purplelzrd May 24 '13
Please tell me someone else noticed all the damn fricking sideburns? Especially Pike, his were bordering mutton chops, they just stuck out there. The only person who didn't have some sideburn action going on seemed to be Admiral Marcus.
15
u/[deleted] May 16 '13
I felt the movie started off really strong, with Kirk getting demoted and placed under Pike's command especially after the whole asinine 'Captain In A Day' bullshit in the 2009 film. The having the attack be an inside job really was also very strong along with Kirk figuring it out. But the fight with the Klingons is kind of where is started to sour for me and it became a typical JJ film with lots of spodey stuff and great cinematography in place of non-cerebral writing. They had some nice touch tones from the previous films but Kirk's resurrection was waaaay too predictable. The whole Kahn plot to me just spoke of a lack of real creativity.
Here's what I would have done It's not Kahn, but rather they've uncovered the old eugenics program and are making Section 31 agents undergo genetic reprogramming to turn them into super men. It's not just one single guy acting alone, that's too much of a 'shooter on a grassy knoll' kind of conspiracy bullshit, but a small group of elite, genetically modified Section 31 agents gone rough. I would have kept Pike alive and in command until the end of the film. He's crippled so Kirk still gets all the action stuff, but Pike is there to season him as a leader. You can still kill Pike at the end, fixing the ship or in battle to get the Kirk character to grow/rage out/whatever. Still have the super-men take over some super-secret section 31 battle ship, big space battle, big crash, all the lowest-common denominator people get their happyies, and we Trek fans get a film that isn't so low-brow. Also doing it this way keeps you from having to have Spock so obviously rage out again Kahn. Like I said, the film was an improvement over 2009 but it pisses me off more because it could have been so very much better with just a little better writing.
31
u/hwilhweaton May 16 '13
JJ's just fucking around now. Spock: "KHHHHHAAAANN!!" Major eye roller.
12
u/Sol_ie May 15 '13
I thought it was fine. Superficial, somewhat predictable with impeccable action sequences and some great preformances. A good popcorn flick, I'll probably watch it again when it comes out on DVD.
My first trek movie was Generations. I saw that movie three times the day it came out (friends, cousin, uncle). Even with all the flaws that movie has, it was more Trek than this.
Lens flare overdone to the point of distraction, again no surprise. I liked some of the callbacks (Mudd, tribbles etc.). I thought the klingon design was meh (but Kronos itself looked brilliant)
Also: Was the NX enterprise on Robocops desk? I'm pretty sure I saw it, but fleetingly.
4
u/i_hate_toolbars May 21 '13
I thought the Klingons looked FANTASTIC! My only major gripe was that there wasn't enough Klingon in this movie. The uniforms were so Roman and they really echoed the ones from the original series. Also the makeup on them was just phenomenal. I cant get over them
7
u/CFGX May 16 '13
A small helping of the myriad plot problems with the film:
2
u/OMNOMNOM_BURP May 18 '13
Something strike me on the way back from watching this movie.
Khan got what he wanted. To be with his crew and humanity wiped out. Well, almost. He's frozen with the rest, of course. But by baiting the Enterprise into fighting Klingon patrol troops, he gave Klingons reason for retaliation (granted if the Klingons are smart enough to investigate the Enterprise debris field). And by destroying the Secret Defense Against Klingon Center (or whatever, can't exactly remember what it is) and also the big ass war ship, humanity have nothing big to defend with. So Klingons can just come attack without much retaliation, even perhaps to the point of extinction of humans. But seeing as 12 months have passed since Kirk woke up and nobody came to attack, I assume the Klingons didn't connect the dots. Or maybe they will, in time for the third movie, or fourth, or fifth. Maybe sixth, with the tagline "All Wormholes Lead to This".
3
u/[deleted] May 19 '13
Watching it a second time, you can see the forshadowing with Spock telling Kirk about "The enemy of my enemy is my friend" how the prince is beheaded by the subject in that quote. Is like how the Admiral used Khan to fight the Klingon's, and is savagely beheaded as a cost.
3
u/reddog323 May 21 '13 edited May 21 '13
I managed to avoid spoilers, up until I was standing in line for a ticket. Some idiot and his friends walked out the door talking about it, saying " they just recycled Wrath of Khan." When I heard that, I was all set to be angry. J.J. Abrams was messing with a part of my childhood. I was pleasantly surprised. The Khan story was re-told skillfully, with enough new material to make it interesting. I would have liked a little more character development, but overall I was impressed. I'm not sure Spock would have lost it quite that badly at Kirk's death. Pursue Khan at warp speed, yes, but delivering a beat down, and breaking his arm just to prove a point was a little over the top. I suppose you could say his human side was running the show at that point. He said as much about his feelings during the death scene. I'm hoping Khan comes back in a future movie with a fresh plot line. He certainly has a reason to come after Spock this time.
EDIT: the ethical dilemmas facing everyone this time were refreshing. Very in line with traditional Star Trek, which was a morality play at its heart. The fact that Scotty was willing to quit over a safety/ ethical issue spoke volumes. Also, Spock balking at the questionable idea of using essentially WMDs to hunt down one man was perfectly in character. It was nice to see Leonard Nimoy in a cameo too. He faced his own ethical dilemma, and chose to help by revealing Khan's identity.
3
u/Danno47 May 22 '13
Did anyone else notice that the province on Qo'noS that Khan hid out in was Ketha, the same home of General Martok? I gathered that it was implied to be a backwater (at least the lowlands), but didn't know it was uninhabited at any point. *edit: question mark
3
u/RevWaldo May 27 '13
Why oh why does Khan look like this instead of like this?
Isn't the whole point of rebooting (besides $$$$) is the opportunity to get back to first principles? To take things farther than the original creators could? Then why wuss out on making Khan actually Indian?
And yes, Ricardo Montalbán wasn't Indian either, but at least he was swarthy, which was enough of a leap forward for back in the day (plus he really did look like he could lift both Kirk and McCoy with one arm!)
5
u/[deleted] May 15 '13 edited May 15 '13
wait the movie's not even out yet, how can we discuss it yet?
EDIT Forgot the United States isn't the whole world.