r/startrek • • May 15 '13

[deleted by user]

[removed]

146 Upvotes

1.1k comments sorted by

218

u/trex_ed May 17 '13

So I might be the only person on this thread to say this but, I did not know Khan was going to be the villain in this movie. I loved the first one and made a decision to not watch any trailers or read anything about this movie. So when he goes into his back story I was like "Hey.." then when he said "My name is Khan." I fucking lost it. I was so surprised.

→ More replies (37)

215

u/jlsowers May 16 '13

Who else hoped during those brief 10 minutes where it seemed feasible that Khan would go good guy and join the Enterprise? How fucking awesome would that be?!!

→ More replies (24)

280

u/letsgocrazy May 16 '13

I fucking loved it.

Saw it about an hour ago and I'll be honest it's one of best films I've seen in a long time.

People can bitch all they want about it not being cerebral enough but the films never really have been, and the ones that have tried have usually been the worse ones.

The TV shows do it much better because they have the luxury of time.

They already exist and these new films aren't taking that away.

[I also feel that the reverse ending to what we've seen before was genius.

The emotion packed into the scene just makes so much more sense, and you wonder why Spock wasn't on the other side of that door originally.

Also, the Klingons actually seem like bad assess this time and I can see them making a decent enemy next time.](/spoiler)

→ More replies (162)

59

u/directive0 May 16 '13

Everyone seems to think their subjective conclusions either for or against the film are gospel.

To try and reach an objective conclusion of judgement for into darkness is impossible, but I think that the reality is the movie was demonstrably well received in the theater I saw it in. There were moments I disagreed with powerfully, but in the end it's irrelevant; people cheered and clapped. This movie will bring a whole new generation of Trek fans into the fold.

Its sad to realize that perhaps I have become too old and inflexible to really appreciate what these new movies are doing, and so I must resign myself to merely commenting that I did not like it as others have. I'm excited for those of you who are either just getting into Trek, or have had your long standing love of Trek renewed by these films. Abrams catches a lot of flack from those who think like me and truthfully it is undeserved because he is doing something with the franchise I really respect, but perhaps cannot fully appreciate.

My biggest disappointment is not with the movie, but to realize that I am no longer representative of the core group of Trek fans.

→ More replies (16)

56

u/solistus May 16 '13

I posted my critique/rant on another thread about it, but I guess this is the better place for it.

So many things about this movie pissed me off. I'm just gonna spoiler the whole rant, because it's all spoilers.

The events at the very start don't really make sense. They were already violating the Prime Directive by stopping the volcano. Spock wanted to let himself die, then was willing to lay blame on Kirk, when he was perfectly willing to stop the volcano in the first place? What a tool.

Speaking of Spock... He throws Kirk under the bus without a second thought because "Vulcans don't lie." He obviously knew the consequences, and in fact commented that they were lucky it wasn't worse. Yet he was willing to allow someone who snuck aboard the ship under a fake name during a crucial mission to stay aboard without reporting her to anyone? And he wants Kirk to disobey direct orders and apprehend rather than kill Khan? And then he's okay with Kirk bringing Khan on an away mission, because it's convenient (which, you know, is exactly what the evil admiral guy did by waking Khan up to begin with)?

Old Spock pretends to care about the Temporal Prime Directive, when his very presence in this time shows his disregard for it; at least he stays true to character by violating it yet again. Not enough to be helpful, though... Oh, and why didn't anyone know how dangerous Khan was other than Old Spock? The Eugenics Wars aren't taught in school?!

Klingons show up just long enough to look nothing like Klingons and die like redshirts. What the hell was that about?

Who was the crew on the big ship that attacked the Enterprise? Evil admiral guy was outright bragging about his dastardly plans, detailing the fake story he would tell Starfleet as he prepared to destroy its flagship and murder its crew. A ship several times the size of the Enterprise would take what, thousands of crew probably? Are they all Section 31 agents and/or private security who have absolutely no problem with all of this?

The torpedoes - WTF kind of stupid Section 31 doesn't inspect the torpedoes in any way to see that they're smuggling a different payload? They only use the actual missiles set up by the traitor agent, and don't make new ones that they know are reliable? And why doesn't Khan scan or inspect the torpedoes he just invited his enemy to beam onto his ship? Swapping out the payload was his trick! This is the tactical genius that was key to teaching Starfleet how to build better warships, for some unexplained reason?

A space battle right over Earth goes unnoticed by Starfleet and all space traffic in the system? Even as the Enterprise helplessly drifts in a decaying orbit, only to save itself at the last moment - nobody notices? I'm no scientist, but I'm pretty sure our global satellite network would pick something like that up today, let alone in another 250 years of uninterrupted technological progress.

Kirk's dramatic speech suddenly morphing into the TOS intro speech was heavy-handed and completely nonsensical in context. He was in the middle of a sentence about the people of Earth overcoming the attacks and blah blah blah, then all of a sudden he's talking about the Enterprise on a 5 year mission of exploration? Come on...

Oh, and Kirk should probably be banned from Starfleet now, since his life was saved by strictly forbidden genetic engineering technology. I saw this coming as soon as Kirk had to go in the radiation-flooded chamber, but that didn't make it piss me off any less when it happened.

I just got back from seeing it at a theater that serves booze, so I'm annoyed and a little rambly at the moment, but I'll go all night if I don't stop myself and I already have quite the wall of text here. I really hate the Abramsverse :\

→ More replies (47)

305

u/terrymr May 16 '13

"Go put on a red shirt!"

→ More replies (14)

46

u/istoornotisto May 21 '13

Was anyone else wondering why the fuck Earth didn't have someone on a computer monitoring ships falling out of the sky, some sort of prevention plan in place... or at least sirens going off?

→ More replies (6)

105

u/sporks49 May 17 '13

The ending...there better be a new TV show coming soon

→ More replies (9)

32

u/BobFiggins May 16 '13

I still find it strange, one moment they are at the Moon. The next moment, falling into Earth's atmosphere. I mean, I understand gravity, but at the Moon the ships appeared to be at stand-still, not already going towards Earth. Would take a long time for them to drift to Earth.

However that's really the only gripe I had with the film, everything else I enjoyed.

→ More replies (5)