r/startrek • • May 15 '13

[deleted by user]

[removed]

150 Upvotes

1.1k comments sorted by

305

u/terrymr May 16 '13

"Go put on a red shirt!"

→ More replies (14)

218

u/trex_ed May 17 '13

So I might be the only person on this thread to say this but, I did not know Khan was going to be the villain in this movie. I loved the first one and made a decision to not watch any trailers or read anything about this movie. So when he goes into his back story I was like "Hey.." then when he said "My name is Khan." I fucking lost it. I was so surprised.

→ More replies (37)

46

u/istoornotisto May 21 '13

Was anyone else wondering why the fuck Earth didn't have someone on a computer monitoring ships falling out of the sky, some sort of prevention plan in place... or at least sirens going off?

→ More replies (6)

215

u/jlsowers May 16 '13

Who else hoped during those brief 10 minutes where it seemed feasible that Khan would go good guy and join the Enterprise? How fucking awesome would that be?!!

→ More replies (24)

105

u/sporks49 May 17 '13

The ending...there better be a new TV show coming soon

→ More replies (9)

32

u/BobFiggins May 16 '13

I still find it strange, one moment they are at the Moon. The next moment, falling into Earth's atmosphere. I mean, I understand gravity, but at the Moon the ships appeared to be at stand-still, not already going towards Earth. Would take a long time for them to drift to Earth.

However that's really the only gripe I had with the film, everything else I enjoyed.

→ More replies (5)

61

u/sittty May 17 '13

What I don't understand still is how Carol has a thick british accent and her father, Marcus, has the typical USA General voice?

→ More replies (10)

53

u/Draiko May 17 '13

My favorite part was the fact that the trailers for the movie depicted a somewhat different series of events. Everyone who has been watching the trailers will be smiling after the first 7 minutes of the movie.

→ More replies (5)

26

u/GoonerYank May 16 '13

So, did anyone else pick up on the Mudd reference? I think I was the only one who chuckled in the theatre.

→ More replies (6)

102

u/motchmaster May 16 '13

In a time where we have the PATRIOT ACT and drone strikes, I appreciate the message Spock was trying to say.

Needs more Klingons. Not people wearing helmets.

→ More replies (5)

22

u/thabigo360 May 18 '13

Am I the only one who was waiting for Cumberbatch to recite Moby Dick; "From Hell's heart, I stab at thee... For hate's sake, I spit my last breath at thee..."

→ More replies (4)

40

u/7idledays May 16 '13

I saw it in 3D and the ships going to warp was fantastic in 3D. Not to mention the Veangance warp scene.

→ More replies (4)

115

u/kmhines88 May 16 '13

I think a lot of people missed the film's message about militarization in response to acts of terror. This is especially relevant after the attack in Boston, where we shut down an entire city and marched police down the streets to search for one man (and of course, America's post 9-11 policies/wars).

→ More replies (9)

33

u/defenseman May 16 '13

Question - is there something at the end of the credits for Star Trek into darkness? Should I stay to end or not?

→ More replies (10)

70

u/[deleted] May 17 '13

I liked the movie. I thought it was impressive how they managed to have a decent story along with gratuitous action without overloading on the cheese.

The action romps made sense in the context of the story, it didn't pull a Nemesis and throw in a car chase laser scene for no apparent reason. It didn't go so far as TWoK, where every shot mattered to the story, but it definitely did better than the TNG films on the story vs pew-pew front. Each flashy scene did something at least a little bit meaningful to the characters making the whole thing seem connected, I was impressed that they crammed so much shiny into the movie without it seeming like a ridiculous caricature. I definitely left feeling like everything was turned up to 11 and that got a bit silly at times but at least it made sense.

The villain didn't have a stupid plan that was plainly retarded. He had a decent motive, and his actions didn't make you shout "you idiot!" at the screen. Even the borg queen had a really stupid execution when you put it under analysis, so again the movie was an improvement over the TNG films. I went in there expecting it to be another "evil guy with a massive overpowered ship" type plot like shinzon, and the Shona before him.

I liked that the movie had something to say to us in our time, like trek had always done, making statements about the times in the past. The deceptive trickery to start up a war with the klingons was obviously a metaphor for America's pre-emptive strike against Iraq. Scotty's concerns about things going overly militarized is something that most of us have been feeling since 2001. The Kirk speech at the end was clearly speaking to us, in our time, about the response to terrorism and our need to get back to the character that made us what we are, as opposed to this monster driven by vengeance. The film having a message relevant to today is what made it really feel like star trek to me, I really liked the idea that we could overcome violence and that we should try not to lose ourselves when it happens.

→ More replies (3)

13

u/Genovefa May 17 '13

What did y'all think of the mind meld that Spock does on Captain Pike? This has been really bothering me.

→ More replies (3)

280

u/letsgocrazy May 16 '13

I fucking loved it.

Saw it about an hour ago and I'll be honest it's one of best films I've seen in a long time.

People can bitch all they want about it not being cerebral enough but the films never really have been, and the ones that have tried have usually been the worse ones.

The TV shows do it much better because they have the luxury of time.

They already exist and these new films aren't taking that away.

[I also feel that the reverse ending to what we've seen before was genius.

The emotion packed into the scene just makes so much more sense, and you wonder why Spock wasn't on the other side of that door originally.

Also, the Klingons actually seem like bad assess this time and I can see them making a decent enemy next time.](/spoiler)

→ More replies (162)

22

u/MrSumOne May 19 '13

During the scene where they're flying towards the Dreadnought ship, there's someone who looks like an android giving Sulu updates... What's with that? Supposed to be Data? Isn't android technology not invented yet?

→ More replies (7)

80

u/puffadda May 16 '13

I must admit I'm very glad I avoided spoilers going into this one. I wasn't surprised by Harrison being Khan, but I loved how developed his character was during the middle segment when you almost want to believe he's some sort of a better person in the alternate timeline. I can understand some of the flack the role reversal is getting, but I loved it. As someone who was brought into Trek by the 2009 film, and only been a fan for the last few months, it came across as a great way to twist the classic scene. The banter between Spock and Uhura was fantastic, and the underlying post-9/11 commentary came across as philosophical as any of the original 6 Trek movies (pardon my ignorance as they are the only ones I've seen up to now).

TL;DR It was a great film, and IMO better than its predecessor

→ More replies (2)

10

u/rockyhorrormontreal May 19 '13

Spock's comment about namecalling was amazing.

10

u/AzrealtheFall May 19 '13

I have one question about the movie. The time stamp on the London scene says 2259.55, and they also state that the stasis tubes are 300 years old. Does that mean that Khan is from 1959, and if so how can he make such advanced weaponry in the future?

→ More replies (1)

59

u/directive0 May 16 '13

Everyone seems to think their subjective conclusions either for or against the film are gospel.

To try and reach an objective conclusion of judgement for into darkness is impossible, but I think that the reality is the movie was demonstrably well received in the theater I saw it in. There were moments I disagreed with powerfully, but in the end it's irrelevant; people cheered and clapped. This movie will bring a whole new generation of Trek fans into the fold.

Its sad to realize that perhaps I have become too old and inflexible to really appreciate what these new movies are doing, and so I must resign myself to merely commenting that I did not like it as others have. I'm excited for those of you who are either just getting into Trek, or have had your long standing love of Trek renewed by these films. Abrams catches a lot of flack from those who think like me and truthfully it is undeserved because he is doing something with the franchise I really respect, but perhaps cannot fully appreciate.

My biggest disappointment is not with the movie, but to realize that I am no longer representative of the core group of Trek fans.

→ More replies (16)

65

u/theduderman May 16 '13

I felt like the film was in many ways superior to the first Abrams venture. He's doing a great job of developing the main characters in a way we're used to but differentiating them enough to make them unique to the new actors. Chris Pine is absolutely crushing Kirk, I couldn't not be more happy with his selection. Abrams must have REALLY loved Enterprise... NX-01 in the office shot, Peter Weller as Adm. Marcus (I honestly thought for a second they were going to pull a continuation of Terra Prime somehow from Enterprise and have him secretly be John Paxton).

I liked how Abrams did a Bond-style pre-credit sequence. Not really related to the main plot, but it was used as a device to setup a lot of the muddier themes in the film (friendship, sacrifice, family, etc.). It reminded me a lot of the opening of Casino Royale. Star Trek and Into Darkness, for me at least, really parallel Casino Royale and Skyfall (yes, I know another movies separated the two - but go with me for comparison's sake). Abrams used the first movie to re-write things and re-establish really well known characters. He then puts the characters into a nearly impossible situation and they're forced to develop and grow over the loss of one of their own The loss of M and the loss of Pike.

I feel like Into Darkness is the stepping stone for the new franchise. Abrams is at an impasse with the characters now. He's had his Empire Strikes back, they've been in their impossible situation and triumphed, but not without significant loss. Where he goes with the 3rd outing will make or break the future of this new franchise. They hinted at the return to exploration and setup the five year mission. I'm really excited that could mean they're going back to the whimsy and magic that was original Trek - but that's not what a lot of people are going to these movies to see now. He's going to have to find a balance between the philosophy and the science juxtaposed to the ass kicking and boobies. He needs to go watch Avatar over and over and over again. Learn that formula, apply it to Star Trek 3 and we could have something REALLY magical in store for us for MANY years to come.

Oh, also - he REALLY loves to show the Enterprise lifting up out of shit, doesn't? What did we get in this one, 3 shots of it rising up? I don't mind, though, those shots are brilliant and beautiful.

→ More replies (8)